Bhimsen Thapa: Heroic Leader or Selfish Dictator?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Bhimsen Thapa might be one of the most controversial yet powerful figure in the history of Nepal. He was the longest serving prime minister of Nepal. He was at the power when Nepal was going through its most critical moment, the war with British East India Company. For many, he is a national hero, a man who built the beloved Dharahara, the man who reformed Nepali bureaucracy. But there are those who criticize him for inhumane political massacre, Bhandarkhal Prava, elimination of his political rivals and consolidated power within his own family. This is the story of Bhimsen Thapa and Nepali politics at that time.
    From the books:
    भीमसेन थापा: उत्थान तथा पतन by Baburam Acharya
    जनरल भीमसेन थापा र तत्कालीन नेपाल by Chittaranjan Nepali
    Aitihasik Upanyas Bhimsen Thapa by Shree Krishna Shrestha
    Let's connect :
    If you are on Facebook: [ / dipesh.tripa.. .]
    If you are on Twitter: [ / nepalicomment ]
    If you are on Instagram: [ / dipesh.trip ]
    Research by: Rubina Subedi ( / rubina-subedi-284118234 )
    Edited and Animations by: Dungrey( / khadka__ajay )
    Thumbnail by :Rabi Kandel ( / proto_flex )

Комментарии • 752

  • @itsyourcomment
    @itsyourcomment Год назад +121

    Bhimsen Thapa, a beacon of courage and leadership in Gorkhali history! 🌟 His unwavering determination and fearless spirit inspire us all. 🏔️🇳🇵 #SaluteToBhimsenThapa

    • @ARick_499
      @ARick_499 Год назад

      Lauda ko birta muj sabai jagga harera muji ko birata

    • @AdulttBergg
      @AdulttBergg Год назад +2

      If this war wasn't happen then
      We should not underestimate british that they had take whole nation...

    • @sauravbastola893
      @sauravbastola893 Год назад +3

      How can you commend someone who caused the loss of many innocent lives? His actions seemed motivated by personal gain rather than the well-being of the country.

    • @itsyourcomment
      @itsyourcomment Год назад +1

      @@sauravbastola893 Bhimsen Thapa played a crucial role in Nepal's unification (Nepal Ekikaran) during the 18th century. As Prime Minister and military leader, his leadership and strategic decisions helped consolidate smaller kingdoms into a unified Nepal. Thapa's diplomatic skills and military campaigns significantly contributed to the expansion of the Gorkha kingdom, laying the foundation for modern Nepal's territorial integrity.

    • @ARick_499
      @ARick_499 Год назад

      @@itsyourcomment bahun lay sarpeko desh...blood mai kayar tah chalkapat...thagne.. frontline batlle ma jitna nasakne...kayar jasto pit piche chura hanne...currently Nepal ko conditions bahun baje hru lay loot tanatra machako cha

  • @MrBkas
    @MrBkas 8 месяцев назад +4

    वास्तवमा भिमसेन थापाले गर्दा नेपालले १/३ भुभाग गुमाउनु परेको हो।भिमसेन थापाले ब्रिटिससंग कुटनितिक सम्बन्ध कायम गर्न नसकेकाले अंग्रेजले आक्रमण गरेको हो।

  • @goingby
    @goingby Год назад +7

    Bhimsen Thapa is the first victim of foreign influence on Nepali politics. And unfortunately the streak still continues. True patriots after him have been outcasted, overthrown and murdered until today. What are the Nepali people doing to uproot this 200 years old sickness? 🤦🏻‍♂️

  • @Sheeekharrr
    @Sheeekharrr Год назад +453

    Omg you should be teacher in our school dai 😂

    • @TheNepaliComment
      @TheNepaliComment  Год назад +173

      I was poor at social in school hai tara. 😂

    • @dragonkaanxa
      @dragonkaanxa Год назад +32

      Script heraera padhnu ra paath padhera bujhera student laai bujhaaunu alag ho.

    • @Sheeekharrr
      @Sheeekharrr Год назад +16

      @dragonkaanxa
      Either i or you are lacking sense of humour

    • @dayghost379
      @dayghost379 Год назад +7

      ​@@SheeekharrrI'm guessing his is lacking more sense than you

    • @ujwalshrestha8432
      @ujwalshrestha8432 Год назад +5

      Dragon kanxa
      Bolna saknu pani thulo kura ho sab le sakxa vanni xaina

  • @dibaskhanal4043
    @dibaskhanal4043 Год назад +38

    I think Bahadur Shah is one of the most underrated warrior in Nepal history. Bro can you make video on Bahadur Shah

    • @creatorlight4346
      @creatorlight4346 Год назад +4

      I have heard he conquered all of Nepal in the west from gorkha. Eastern part was by his father Prithvi Narayan Shah.

    • @bhupendrasawad697
      @bhupendrasawad697 Год назад +1

      He has also dark sides like भीमसेन थापा😂

    • @shambhu3754
      @shambhu3754 3 месяца назад

      ​@@bhupendrasawad697Everyone has dark and good side.

  • @KapendraKathayat-qq8oi
    @KapendraKathayat-qq8oi 8 месяцев назад +3

    म तपाइको एक्दमै ठूलो समर्थक हु । हरेक भिडियोहरु नछुटाइ हेर्ने गर्छु । तपाइले बिषयबस्तु लाई धेरै अध्यान र खोज गर्नुहुन्छ तर यहाँ अलि पुगेन कि? भन्डारखाल पर्व बि.स १९०३ कार्तिक १२मा भएको हो र यो भन्दा पहिले नै कोत पर्व १९०३ असोज २ गते भैसकेको थियो । कोत पर्व र भन्डारखाल पर्व दुबैको योजनाकार जंग बहादुर राणा नै थिए ।

  • @CurrentIssuesDetailer
    @CurrentIssuesDetailer Год назад +57

    point to be noted always :-
    #नेपाल बनाउन पृथ्वीनारायण को भुमिका अनि
    #बिस्वशक्तिको पन्जाबाट नेपाल जोगाउन भिमसेन थापाको भुमिका बिर्सेउ भने नेपाली हु भन्ने कुरा बिर्सिदा भयो😢❤🇳🇵
    always respect those युगपुरुश🙏❤️

    • @d_reeves1133
      @d_reeves1133 Год назад

      ​@Arun_Yadav77788chup lag dhoti

    • @gi0993
      @gi0993 Год назад +2

      @Arun_Yadav77788 you are very dramatic person 😂😂 saying same thing again and again. Shame on you. Also what is this Greater Bihar ? You said China and North korea won't help us . Haha . North korea doesn't care about Nepal and they never helped us in anything. Also I don't think China will care about bihari territories . Nepal doesn't have any territory that belonged to Bihar .lol. You better try not say foolish thing about Nepal and Nepali.

  • @sureshasuresha6520
    @sureshasuresha6520 Год назад +4

    भीमसेन थापा - युद्द को कुनै ज्ञान नभएका, युरोप लम्पसाबाद, मूर्ख, जंगबहादुर भन्दा बढी ज्यानमारा, जसरी उनले अर्का लाई मारेर गिद्द लाई खुवाए, उनको पनि अन्त त्यसरी गिद्द को आहारा नै बन्यो उनको लास।

    • @naryanthapa460
      @naryanthapa460 Год назад

      मुर्ख अर्काको खालि आलोचना गर्छ।
      विवेकि परिस्थितिको गम्भीर अध्य्यन अन्वेषण अनि सामना गर्छ।
      त मुला इतिहास बुझेको भए बिश्वको सबै भन्दा बढी गुलाम भएको देश भारत अनि अर्को देश चीन जसमा british ले बुट बजारेको थियोे। अन्धो पटमुर्खहरु त्यतिका देश गुमाम हुदा नि नेपाललाई कसैको गुलाम हुन नदिनु भिमशेन थापाको तागत र बुद्धि कति थियो होला भनेर सहजै नजरअन्दाज गर्न सकिन्छ कि उनी को हुन भनेर ।

    • @sureshasuresha6520
      @sureshasuresha6520 Год назад

      @@naryanthapa460 bhimsen thapaa को मूर्ख्याइँ ले पृ ना शाह ले जितेको भूभाग इंडिया मा गयो, त्यसपछि भीमसेन डराए बेलायत संग, लम्पसार नीति अपनाए।
      २ वर्ष बालक देखि ८० बर्से वृद्ध सम्म को हत्या गरी सत्ता खाए, त्यत्तिको हिंसा त जङ्गे ले पनि गरेको थिएन।
      शाह निकट राष्ट्रबादी सब लाई सिध्याए, आफ्ना झोले, चम्चे संग सत्ता लिए। रन बहादुर लाई बौलाहा बनाई आफ्नै नाबालिक भतिजी ललित त्रिपुरा बिहे गरि उनै को औठा छाप प्रयोग गरी मोजमस्ती ले सत्ता चलाए।
      युद्द को कुनै अनुभव नभएका, लडाई नगरेका त्यसैले बेलायत संग को लडाई मा हार खाए, प्रशस्त भूभाग गुमाए।
      लास्ट मा आत्महत्या गर्न विवश भए, गिद्द को आहारा वने।

    • @ishantchhetri4917
      @ishantchhetri4917 Год назад +1

      ह्याट देश बचाएकै भीमसेनले हो

    • @naryanthapa460
      @naryanthapa460 Год назад

      @@sureshasuresha6520 मिथ्या कुरा गर्नुको कुनै तुक छैन। यदि त्यो परिस्थितिमा अझ देशको महाप्रजापति भए पनि हाल अझ नाजुक हुन्थ्यो। यद्यपि पृथ्वीनारायण शाहको पालामा british empire नेपालमा आको थिएन। यदि आको भए थाहा हुन्थ्यो कि.....उनले के गर्थे भनेर आधुनिक अनि शक्तिशाली फौजको अगाडि नेपाल जतो गरीबीले पिल्सिएको देश british empire सङ्ग डटेर लड्नु चानचुन कुरो थिएन। त्यो भारत र चीन लगायतका देशलाई british empire ले गुलाम बनाएको कुरा बाटै प्रष्ट थाहा हुन्छ। अतः कुनै देशलेनै राष्ट्रिय बिभुती मानेको व्याक्तीको reputation माथी धावा बोल्ने बकम्फुसे बकवास फोर्सो गफ दिएर काम छैन।यदि पटमुर्ख तत्वले भनेकै कुरा सहि हो भने प्रमाण लिएर आउ। बिना प्रामाण ह्या कसैको प्रतिष्ठा माथि औंला नउठाउ। नत्र यसको मुल्य महङ्गो पर्ला। we are waiting for your evidence. hearsay evidence is no evidence itself. So that We cannot believe in ..your hearsay evidence. because of i am a law student. ........plz uh should be prove of your argument.

  • @MR-lj1ks
    @MR-lj1ks Год назад +87

    The effort he puts into every video is so inspiring. I wonder if he manages to put English subtitles on every upcoming video, there is no doubt the audience will increase exponentially. This channel deserves larger family. Lots of love and support❤️

    • @princearyan1743
      @princearyan1743 Год назад +3

      Bro, yo comment ab dherai bhayo, baru research ko quality ma pani dhyan deu. Ek damai one sided, narrow angled, and stupidly and unintentionally manipulative content banairaheko chha aajkal. Sabai kuro baastabikta sanga sandharbhik chhaina.

    • @manojkhatri7259
      @manojkhatri7259 Год назад

      I have been suggesting using surtitles to him before he went viral.

  • @lumosmaxima8709
    @lumosmaxima8709 Год назад +42

    dedication to sharing valuable insights about Nepal's rich history is truly commendable and helps us connect with our roots in a meaningful way. Keep up the fantastic work! 🙌📚🇳🇵

  • @Kubotahonda5
    @Kubotahonda5 5 месяцев назад +1

    मानिसहरू भन्छन राजा हरूले 250 बर्ष सम्म शासन गरेर नेपाल लाई के बिकास गरे भनेर राजा हरूलाई गाली गलौज गर्छन, तर सत्य तथ्य मा भन्दा नेपाल को राजसँस्था 250 बर्ष भएपनि, प्रत्यक्ष राजा हरूको शासनकाल पृथ्वी नारायण शाह देखि gyanendra Shah सम्म जम्मा जम्मी 60 बर्ष पनि हुनसकेन, अरू सबै राजा हरू दरबार भित्र कठपुतली सरह जिबन बिताउन बाध्य भएका थिए भने 4 राजा हरूको त कलिलै उमेर मा नै मृत्यु भएको थियो । नेपाल को आधुनिक बिकास मा सबैभन्दा ठुलो योगदान दिने मा राजा महेन्द्र होईबक्सनछ , राजा महेन्द्र एक मामुली स्कुल र दरबार भित्र पढेका राजा यदि चतुर नभएको भए सायद आज हामी नेपालीहरु भारतिय हुनेथियौँ र नेपाल देश पनि भारत मा नै गाभिन्थ्यो र यीनै राजा ले नेपाल लाई सँयुक्त राष्ट्र संघको सदस्यता दिलाउनुभयो र नेपाल भन्ने देश लाई सँसार ले नेपाल लाई officially recognized गर्यो , यो नै नेपाल को पहिलो एेतिहासिक moment हो, नया एैन नियमहरू देखि नेपाल भर रहेका भारतीय सैनिक हरू को सिबिर हरू,पोष्ट हरू निकालिदिए , उत्तर मा चिन ले सिबिर हरू राखेको थियो त्यो पनि निकाल्न सफलता हासिल गरे, सन 1972 मा तिब्बत खम्पा हरू सँग लँडाइ लडेर मुस्ताङ ओलाङ्चुङगोला, कोराला आदि भुभाग जोगाउन सफल भए, राजमार्ग हरू, बिभिन्न कल कारखाना हरू,को निर्माण शुरु पनि यिनै राजा बाट भएको हो , यीनै राजा ले सकभर भारत लाई घुँडा टेकाएका थिए, सायद यहि कारणले राजा महेन्द्रको मृत्यु पनि mysterious नै छ । राजा बिरेन्द्र ले पनि नेपाल लाई almost peace nation zone को उपाधि दिलाउन ठुलो योगदान गरे तर भारत नै ठुलो बाधक बनिरह्यो, नेपाल मा जलविद्युत परियोजना बिदेशी लगानीकर्ता उत्साहित गर्नु मा राजा बिरेन्द्र को ठुलो योगदान पनि छ, नेपाल को बिदेशी कुटनीतिक एकदमै उत्तम उच्च थियो राजा बिरेन्द्र को पाला सम्म मा , सार्क सम्मेलन खडा गर्नु मा सबैभन्दा ठुलो भुमिका राजा बिरेन्द्र को हो र प्रथम सार्क शिखर सम्मेलन पनि काठमाडौं मा नै गराए , त्यो बेला 7 देश का राष्ट्रप्रमुख हरू र 50 देश का बिदेशी पर्यवछ्यकहरू नेपाल मा नै बोलाएर सम्मेलन गराउनु मामुली कुरा थिएन, सार्क राष्ट्र हरू को खेलकुद पनि पहिलो चोटि नेपाल मा नै गराए, भन्दा खेरी मानिसहरू बि पि राजमार्ग भन्छन तर सत्य तथ्य भने , राजा बिरेन्द्र र जापान को सम्राट हरू को एकदमै घनिष्ठ सम्बन्ध थियो अझै तत्कालीन जापनिज प्रधानमन्त्री हासिमोतो र राजा बिरेन्द्र को त असाध्यै घनिष्ठ सम्बन्ध थियो, हासिमोतो नेपाल भ्रमणको निमन्त्रणा आउदा राजा बिरेन्द्र बाट सिन्धुली राजमार्ग निर्माण गरिदिन अनुरोध गरिबक्सेको हो। राजा हरूको शासनकाल मा नेपाल गरिबी भएपनि जनता र देश को शान मान प्रतिष्ठा मर्यादा एकदमै गौरवमय पहिचान थियो, राजा बिरेन्द्र को पाला सम्म मा नेपाली हरू ले on arrival visa 53 देश मा पाउदथे including Germany, Macau, Hong Kong, UAE, Thailand, Ecuador, Peru , south Africa, etc, नेपाल कोpassport अहिले को भन्दा powerful थियो .त्यस समय शाही नेपाल वायुसेवा एकदमै लोकप्रिय भएको थियो, RNA ले सिधै काठमाडौं बाट London, Paris, Frankfurt सेवा गर्दथ्यो, राजा बिरेन्द्र को अनुरोध मा नै सन 1987 मा जापान सरकार को सहायता मा आधुनिक TIA बिमानस्थल को निर्माण शुरु भएको हो, जम्मा 50/60 बर्ष प्रत्यक्ष शासनकालमा राजा हरूले धेरै नैं महत्वपूर्ण भूमिकाहरू निर्वाह गरेका छन, तर नेता भनौदा हरु को लह लह मा लागेर थाह न थी यत्तिकै राजा हरू लाई नानाथरी का पोलहरू लान्छना लगाउछन् नेपाली हरू।

  • @weisaints2016
    @weisaints2016 5 месяцев назад +2

    Bas paxi thulo vayera Nepal ko history ko movie haru banauney ichhay cha ❤️

  • @ssadixzathapa
    @ssadixzathapa 5 месяцев назад +1

    As being one of the clans of Bhimsen Thapa, he did the whole justice for the National people being a patriotic leader.
    Long live Bhimsen Thapa ❤

  • @rishavpoudel3835
    @rishavpoudel3835 Год назад +17

    The Level on Quality in This content is Just Awesome. Thank you very much for this level of quality information. I have always been interested in the history of Nepal, our history is rich and beautiful filled with lots of plots and planning every little character in out history has played a vital role to make Nepal as it is of now. I hope other people also start investing time and bringing this level of quality content out . Hope to you a series of history of Nepal from Nepali Comment to! Thank you again!

  • @nepaliculturetrend
    @nepaliculturetrend Год назад +5

    Waiting dai lots of love
    I started following you from 50 subscriber. Keep it up hoping for 500 k subs

  • @unconscious1076
    @unconscious1076 Год назад +12

    The cold war between Kshatriya Nobel families of that time i.e Thapa Pande Basnyat and then Kuwar(later Rana) family deserve a video and even a high budget series on it's on
    There was so much murder betrayal and politics whose legacy last in Nepal still today in many ways

  • @ashimgurung7
    @ashimgurung7 Год назад +18

    FYI: There has been two Bhandarkhal Parva in Nepal one perpetrated by Bhimsen Thapa in 1806 AD as mentioned in the video and another one perpetrated by Queen Rajya Lakshmi Devi but worked on the favor of Jung Bahadur Rana in 1846 AD only a month after Kot Parva.

  • @umeshgurung8927
    @umeshgurung8927 Год назад +2

    यो video हेरेर भन्न सकिन्छ कि हाम्रो इतिहास को किताब पनि एकोहोरो र पक्षपात रूपमा लेखिएको रहेछ

  • @theyellowjacket
    @theyellowjacket Год назад +7

    Prithivi Narayan Shah, Bhimsen Thapa and Janga Bahadur Rana were men with powerful thoughts and great mind. Prithivi Narayan Shah was born in 1723 and died in 1775, Bhimsen was born in 1775 and died in 1839 and Jung Bahadur Rana was born in 1817 and died in 1877. Nepal had 3 terrifying leaders back to back.

  • @sanitatamang451
    @sanitatamang451 Год назад +4

    I didn’t know that JBR is descendant from his brother’s family. I am always intrigued by the life story of Junga Bahadur Rana.. would love to see more videoes of JBR . Thank you

  • @SandeshShresthaKazi
    @SandeshShresthaKazi Год назад +17

    Could you please make more videos in history of nepal like Sughauli Treaty, Life during Rana Rule

  • @binu2660
    @binu2660 Год назад +8

    Evil or not. These men had national interest in mind when they ruled the nation. Not like now, where national interest takes the backbench and chair of PM is all that matters.

    • @koopeigwer8072
      @koopeigwer8072 Год назад

      True jasto sukai corruption gareni boru nation interest ra peoples lai sochdiye ramro

  • @Sushant_kc9846
    @Sushant_kc9846 Год назад +3

    Nepal first channel to make such content

  • @sumangiri280
    @sumangiri280 Год назад +5

    Hi from MOON!
    On Chandrayan Left Door!
    Its cold here 🥶

  • @Nuam6
    @Nuam6 Год назад +49

    The name is enough to give goosebumps 'junga Bahadur Rana'🥶

  • @Sunlove108
    @Sunlove108 Год назад +4

    Hello dai i am your big fan ❤
    Lots of love from parbat 🥳

  • @the_kushal.kranti
    @the_kushal.kranti 5 месяцев назад +1

    गायक अरुण थापाको जीवन कथा उत्कृष्ट छ , उहाँको जीवन मा भिडियो बनाउनु पर्यो।

  • @mansinepali700
    @mansinepali700 7 месяцев назад +1

    I guess I will forever be confused about Bhimsen Thapa ! 🙂😅 But...One thing I must say...He was bold enough to do miracle !!!!

  • @gauravmagar6447
    @gauravmagar6447 Год назад +9

    Bhimsen Thapa was a great master mastermind, who can do anything for his country ❤❤

  • @EarthenNerd
    @EarthenNerd Год назад +29

    Wow that's awesome animation and storytelling
    Just loved It...❤

    • @TheNepaliComment
      @TheNepaliComment  Год назад +7

      Credits to our editing team. It really took long long time. There's so much of history we want to cover but we cant do it all at once.

    • @Schutzstaffel1234
      @Schutzstaffel1234 Год назад

      ​@@TheNepaliCommentmake a video about possibilities of nuclear energy in nepal

    • @SurajChaudhary-mb9nl
      @SurajChaudhary-mb9nl Год назад

      @@TheNepaliComment so we watch the video so easily

  • @Dhanuk3299
    @Dhanuk3299 7 месяцев назад +1

    भण्डारखाल पर्व त कोत पर्व पछि घटेको होइन र?

  • @gwkushaladhikari5575
    @gwkushaladhikari5575 Год назад +12

    Better than dhrub rathee
    👇👇👇👇

  • @czinthakuri
    @czinthakuri Год назад +1

    2:37 What RANA BAHADUR SHAH KASARI CHETTRI HORA BRO ??
    😂

    • @aayushbista2797
      @aayushbista2797 Год назад +1

      Raja haru royal chettri tw honi .

    • @pratik11-v7x
      @pratik11-v7x Год назад +1

      Aayo routey aafu lai Royal family vandai😆
      Royal family haru chhetri theya routey gaina

    • @czinthakuri
      @czinthakuri Год назад +1

      @@pratik11-v7x hasais Vai I don't mention it anywhere ki royal family hyan tyan, truth k ho tyo ta sabailai tha xa shah/shahi Thakuri ho ki chettri tyo tero Ghar ma vayeko mature person Lai sod Ani comment gar bachha

    • @khanal-to10
      @khanal-to10 Год назад

      ​@@pratik11-v7xhistory her dk paila 😂

    • @khanal-to10
      @khanal-to10 Год назад

      ​@@aayushbista2797o ho yo jimu feri

  • @Regmi.Sanjaya
    @Regmi.Sanjaya Год назад +1

    जे बिकीरहेको हुन्छ त्यही बेच्ने हुलमा The Nepali Comment ले आफै बजार बनाउँछ त्यहीँ कुरा मलाई औधी मन पर्छ , Content यत्तिको खोजमूलक हुनुपर्छ नुनवाला जस्तै content लाई चै ऐले प्राथमिकतामा राख्नुपर्छ जस्तो लाग्छ ।

  • @nikhilkhanal98
    @nikhilkhanal98 Год назад +102

    Remember that opinions on historical figures can vary, and perspectives on Bhimsen Thapa may differ among historians and scholars. It's valuable to delve deeper into the historical context and different viewpoints to form a comprehensive understanding of his impact on our Nepal's history.

    • @dishwasher69
      @dishwasher69 Год назад +14

      Chatgpt

    • @arsvlogs965
      @arsvlogs965 Год назад +3

      ​@@dishwasher69😂

    • @sangammainali5982
      @sangammainali5982 Год назад +4

      Itihas jitne ko hunxa.
      Harney ko najariya bata itihas padne ho bhane itihas nai paltinxa.

    • @colorblack8305
      @colorblack8305 Год назад

      Even then it sure shows how incompetent these Kings were. Getting their power stolen by a third party was a common theme in Nepal history. The pathetic part is, it was always so easy.
      Yet some retards want king back. nepal is still struggling due to the policies implemented during their era barely changed til to this day.

    • @bhupendrasawad697
      @bhupendrasawad697 Год назад

      ​@Arun_Yadav77788कति बौलाउँछौं भाई

  • @manojthapa7645
    @manojthapa7645 Год назад +1

    Waiting

  • @a2kaak490
    @a2kaak490 Год назад +3

    Imagine movie on this real story with good director and actor will be litt🔥

  • @justhere3565
    @justhere3565 Год назад +78

    Brave, opportunistic, evil, able leader, visionary - the man was a package of all these characteristics. I think this mixture was necessary to become a leader in times such as those when he was alive.
    Edit - and what happened to him was thoroughly deserved. He got what he gave. Just done reading Baburam Acharya’s The Bloodstained Throne: Struggles for Power in Nepal (1775-1914). Though the author tries to sanitise the Shahs and thus loses some objectivity, he has nonetheless done a commendable job in breaking down the gruesome Nepali history into manageable essays. What a hellhole it was back then. And it isn’t a lot better today.

    • @TheNepaliComment
      @TheNepaliComment  Год назад +30

      A grey character, I will say. But very important because his decisions still affects us today. Be it our map or sughauli treaty or the way for Rana rulers

    • @justhere3565
      @justhere3565 Год назад +8

      I agree - and more so, his was such a rise and such a tragic end that it easily rivals any Greek or Shakespearean tragedy. And of course, a deeper divide into the regional history, especially in geopolitical terms, will find his name inevitably highlighted. A character difficult to be pigeonholed.

    • @Countryballsnepal
      @Countryballsnepal Год назад +14

      @@TheNepaliCommentbut actually Bhimsen wanted a war with British as they were demanding but wal so even if he would give butwal and greater Nepal would exist, none knows; brits would again ask for something and maybe whole Nepal but Bhimsen Thapa’s resistance and confidence lead to survival of Nepal 🇳🇵

    • @Caurab
      @Caurab Год назад +3

      Yo characteristics tah Balen sanga ni milxa tah😅😅

    • @bpnk5237
      @bpnk5237 Год назад +3

      ​@@Countryballsnepalthat's not true, the war could have been stalled, nepal wasn't prepared for the war, we could have prepared if the war was moved a bit later.

  • @shisirsubedi777
    @shisirsubedi777 Год назад +7

    अब जङ्गबहादुर बाट continue दिन पर्छ है सर

    • @TheNepaliComment
      @TheNepaliComment  Год назад +3

      Plan chai tei ho, but kehi samaye chai lagcha

    • @shisirsubedi777
      @shisirsubedi777 Год назад +1

      @@TheNepaliComment ok sir .after this
      किन भड्किदैछ जातिय/ धार्मिक द्वन्द्व?
      yesko barema ni video banaunuhunxa vanni hope xa ❤️🤗

    • @samyogbasnyat6412
      @samyogbasnyat6412 Год назад

      नेपाल एकीकरण को series लेरौनुहोस् @@TheNepaliComment

    • @AnishKatwal-rs1cg
      @AnishKatwal-rs1cg Год назад

      ​@@shisirsubedi777jatiya dharma ta pasture country bata aako ho. For eg India Pakistan conflict British lea nai garaka hun

  • @sarthakgautam4352
    @sarthakgautam4352 Год назад +2

    The conversation of Two wifes at 2:15 was awesome!

  • @shy_yam
    @shy_yam Год назад +9

    I would have been much better in history if my teacher had taught this way.
    Superb work.

  • @irt00l
    @irt00l Год назад +3

    I want to know the untold history of nepal... All the history we were told is about bagmati region.. But what about kirat and limbuwan in east, sen rulers, baise-chaubise, sinja, kumaon and garwahl in the west

  • @shreejalthapa2007
    @shreejalthapa2007 Год назад +3

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @skk.782
    @skk.782 Год назад +16

    I didn't know much about his life except him being our first pm and a brave leader. Then got completely shocked after seeing all the hatred towards him on reddit just few days ago. Looks like i manifested this video😂

  • @mr.stillunknown
    @mr.stillunknown Год назад +2

    In today’s days we need one such brave courage and badass leader. Every changes need sweat and blood we will be ready for that. Sadhai yo neta harule garda kukur jhai bachnu vanda ek din sher jhai ladera marnu ramro. Hope we will found some revolutionary leader in coming years.

  • @samratsuwal8889
    @samratsuwal8889 Год назад +3

    Sindhupalchok lamosanghu ko magnesite industry ko bare ma ni banauna paryo bro

  • @magarrana4332
    @magarrana4332 Год назад +3

    I want a full detail video about Royal Massacre. Does anybody agree with me?

  • @RoshanMate-gr5yh
    @RoshanMate-gr5yh Год назад +6

    Jay Nepal 🇳🇵 hajurharuko yo mehent jasle hamlet lagayat Sampurna Nepali janta le Satya Kura ko chirfar garna paincha,yasko lagi hajur haru ko mehent Lai huge respect 🙏🇳🇵

  • @FragasmNepal
    @FragasmNepal Год назад +34

    Bhimsen Thapa, a man of courage and leadership in Gorkhali history! ❤

    • @rajrb593
      @rajrb593 Год назад +1

      And mudderer of 93 innocent people including 2 to 12 years old children...he was must evil person in Nepal history check 1806 bhndarkhal parba..other Thapa were brave and better

    • @UMANGPLAYS
      @UMANGPLAYS Год назад

      ​@@rajrb593faced himself a horrible ending tho, was half dead for weeks in river bank.

    • @comefindme8933
      @comefindme8933 Год назад

      ​@@rajrb593j garo thik garo prithvi, bhimsen, jung bahadur nah vako vaye nepal aile yesto hudena thiyo !!

    • @rajrb593
      @rajrb593 Год назад

      @@UMANGPLAYS he did same think to other people he beheaded 2 to 15 years old children too..en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1806_Bhandarkhal_massacre#:~:text=The%20Bhandarkhal%20massacre%20(Nepali%3A%20%E0%A4%AD%E0%A4%A3%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%A1%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%96%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%B2,was%20then%20Kaji%20Bhimsen%20Thapa check incident as well

  • @CurrentIssuesDetailer
    @CurrentIssuesDetailer Год назад

    thank you जँगे
    आफ्नो बाजेको योगदानमा मोज गरेउ✌️

  • @NuwakotInterests
    @NuwakotInterests Год назад +5

    Reminded me of “GENRAL BHIMSEN THAPA RA TATKALIN NEPAL” by Chitaranjan Nepali

  • @raichungpunmagar7984
    @raichungpunmagar7984 Год назад +10

    the diagram representation was so good, really helped to understand the complexation of politics, can't wait for another history video

  • @alfblue4734
    @alfblue4734 Год назад +2

    ALSO, Shah dynasty were not Chettri but Thakuri.

  • @MrPradipt07
    @MrPradipt07 4 месяца назад +1

    How about bhimsen, amar singh and bhakti thapa artifacts?

  • @siddharthaneupane3721
    @siddharthaneupane3721 Год назад +5

    I love this!!!! Thank you so much!!! The editing, story telling... its all awesome!! I'm so excited for PN Shah and Jaya Prakash Malla's (together or separate) story being told in this fashion!

  • @PasangDofy
    @PasangDofy Год назад +3

    never knew he was a dog water guy and here i thought he was innicent gedasin thapa

  • @caslook.kalliades
    @caslook.kalliades Год назад +8

    I read this in the book "The Bloodstained Throne" written by Baburam Acharya some years ago. Nice to see this on RUclips.

  • @Charvak-Atheist
    @Charvak-Atheist Год назад +3

    Why do you guys follow 'Vikram Sampath' calander insted of normal Callander ?
    Note :
    I am not criticizing you guys for following it.
    I am just curious to know the reason.
    Because I am not Nepali I am Indian, and I always get confused when I watch years mentioned in your channel. 😅
    (Yes, I can understand Nepali slightly, because its similar to Hindi)

    • @Hithere-qj1wj
      @Hithere-qj1wj Год назад

      Vikram Samvat(B.S.) was popular
      in South Asia.
      Previously, we used to follow Nepal samvat(N.S.)
      But Ranas replaced it and started using Vikram Samvat as an official calendar and the practice still goes on.

    • @kushalrijal9453
      @kushalrijal9453 Год назад +1

      How is Christian calendar a normal calendar?

  • @breeze8908
    @breeze8908 Год назад

    नेपालमा भन्डारखाल पर्व दुई चोटि भएको होर? जङ् बहादुरले घटाएको कोतपर्व पछि फेरि भन्डारखालमा भएको हत्याकान्ड चै भन्डारखाल पर्व होनि, रनबहादुर शाह को हत्या पछि भिमसेन थापाले मच्चाएको हत्याकान्डलाई भन्डारखाल पर्व भनिन्छ र?

  • @shishiradhikari6535
    @shishiradhikari6535 Год назад

    लास्ट लाइन कडा ,,जङ्गबहादुर को intro kada xa

  • @Getsetflynepal
    @Getsetflynepal Год назад +1

    ❤❤❤ nice explain valuable information

  • @BABA-G437
    @BABA-G437 Год назад +1

    साभारः जगदीश घिमिरेको उपन्यास सकस बाट ।।।

  • @sunilprajapati6377
    @sunilprajapati6377 Год назад +1

    Cracking video! Well done team! More of these history videos please!!!!!

  • @ishwaritamang7824
    @ishwaritamang7824 7 месяцев назад

    इलामको चियाबारी र चियाको इतिहासकाे विषयमा उजागर गरिदिनुस न जुन बिराटनगर जुट उद्याेग भन्दा पुरानाे हाे । तर लाेक सेवामा जुट मिल नै पुरानाे भनिने गरिएको छ ।

  • @ishwaritamang7824
    @ishwaritamang7824 7 месяцев назад

    इलामको चियाबारी र चियाको इतिहासकाे विषयमा उजागर गरिदिनुस न जुन बिराटनगर जुट उद्याेग भन्दा पुरानाे हाे । तर लाेक सेवामा जुट मिल नै पुरानाे भनिने गरिएको छ ।

  • @ishwaritamang7824
    @ishwaritamang7824 7 месяцев назад

    इलामको चियाबारी र चियाको इतिहासकाे विषयमा उजागर गरिदिनुस न जुन बिराटनगर जुट उद्याेग भन्दा पुरानाे हाे । तर लाेक सेवामा जुट मिल नै पुरानाे भनिने गरिएको छ ।

  • @BijjuMaharjan
    @BijjuMaharjan Год назад

    These videos make me more interested in our history. Plz keep them coming.

  • @kashsres1064
    @kashsres1064 Год назад +1

    Bhimshen Thapa namareko vaye, Rana Shasan Nepal ma kahile pani aaudaina thiyo hola.

  • @mrj6162
    @mrj6162 Год назад +4

    That's why Rana Bahadur Shah was known as Mad king of Nepal
    I wonder after the death of King Prithivi Narayan Shah ..Bahadur Shah should have been king instead of Pratap shah because Pratap shah was never active in the Unification campaign Bahadur Shah was the one who continue unification campaign even though he was the second son of Prithivi Narayan Shah

    • @binu2660
      @binu2660 Год назад +1

      Agreed. Bahadur Shah in my opinion should be held in equal status as his Great father.

    • @mrj6162
      @mrj6162 Год назад +1

      All shah kings after PN shah was never suited for the post of kings until Tribhuvan shah became the king of Nepal ....but For me King Mahendra was the best and perfect ruler for Nepal his reign was the time when Nepal was developed most and worst king of all time were Pratap Singh Shah, Rana Bahadur shah, Rajendra Bikram Shah and Gyanendra Shah

  • @jagatrawat77
    @jagatrawat77 Год назад +1

    Yastai video banaunu paryo dai
    Like Rana Bahadur Shah, Amar singh Thapa, Jung Bahadaur Rana etc❤

  • @ankitparajuli411
    @ankitparajuli411 Год назад +30

    21:41 seriously gave me goosebumps

  • @AadityaRegmi-fu4om
    @AadityaRegmi-fu4om 3 месяца назад +1

    Shadows soldiers, laid to rest standing tall. In freedom we live that's why they gave it all.

  • @jenishkun3385
    @jenishkun3385 Год назад +2

    Bhimsen thapa was heroic leader with selfishness 😅
    Your research is very nice brother keep it up you are very inspiring to me cuz I also like doing research but I had no idea about bhimsen thapa .thank you so much for your effort once again 🙏

  • @neeraj.ew_tube
    @neeraj.ew_tube Год назад +1

    brahamaputra nadi dekhi ganga nadi sammako nepal ko history ma vdo banaidinu paryo

  • @arigato4865
    @arigato4865 Год назад +1

    Make video On possibility of good earning in different government jobs in Nepal.

  • @koopeigwer8072
    @koopeigwer8072 Год назад +2

    Short story : After PN Shah death . Power struggle completely messed up Nepal which resulted Rana Regime .

  • @studentsdot3778
    @studentsdot3778 Год назад +1

    One video on Muni Bahadur Shakya who is a Nepali computer engineers.

  • @sameer2820
    @sameer2820 Год назад

    whooooaaaaa...... That endingggg

  • @jejisrai9130
    @jejisrai9130 Год назад +2

    Now waiting for Part 2: The rise of Junga Bahdaur Rana.

  • @DesunilSiR
    @DesunilSiR Год назад +1

    Bihnsen Thapa gau palika -Borlang vanni thau ho janma. Vako ❤️

  • @Riddlemethiseveryone
    @Riddlemethiseveryone Год назад +3

    By nach gaan the historians mean dance bar hai keta ho.

  • @Biiyannn111
    @Biiyannn111 Год назад +1

    Nepal ko history ma tw movie parts parts ma vanayo Ani world wide release gariyo vaney tw babal hunxa hola😅❤

  • @TheAugust15
    @TheAugust15 Год назад

    your voice always attaction my mind❤

  • @prateekghimire8869
    @prateekghimire8869 Год назад +2

    Make a video on unification campaign of Prithivi Narayan Shah.

  • @MichelThapa-r8w
    @MichelThapa-r8w Месяц назад

    गायक अरुण थापा को जीवन भिडियो बनाउन अनरोध गर्दछु🙏🙏🙏

  • @its_mrbibek
    @its_mrbibek Год назад

    this is the thing we need ❤

  • @TITAN1749
    @TITAN1749 11 месяцев назад +1

    Editor needs some raise

  • @shaagaa5661
    @shaagaa5661 Год назад +1

    @The Nepali Comments ko sabai vedio herisakya ❤

  • @binsonthapamagar3368
    @binsonthapamagar3368 Год назад +1

    This man sure knows when to create suspense

  • @samirtc2020
    @samirtc2020 Год назад +7

    Be proud of thapa ❤❤
    Samir thapa here✌️✌️

  • @NVAGamingOfficial
    @NVAGamingOfficial Год назад +4

    Now Lets Continue This History With Next Part ❤

  • @naryanthapa460
    @naryanthapa460 Год назад +10

    #Thapadynasty comes again.
    salute to #Bhimsenthapa
    Our#Grandfather

  • @chiranjeeviadhikari3533
    @chiranjeeviadhikari3533 Год назад +4

    Need a complete series on this history..... Your study and way of presentation is awesome keep going..

  • @princearyan1743
    @princearyan1743 Год назад +1

    Bro, here are two suggestions:
    Give the viewers a moment to breathe. Your hard work is admirable, but you sound like you're running a marathon. Take a moment to breathe and let us digest the facts.
    Don't be so decisive about the sequence of events and the intentions behind the events. And don't present your opinion as facts.

  • @चारआँखे
    @चारआँखे Год назад

    अब यो राजतन्त्र भनेकै यस्तै हो क्या हजुर !!
    एउटा व्यक्तिको ईच्छा अनुसार चल्न पर्ने, बाँच्न पर्ने र अन्तिममा अपमानित हुन पर्ने !!
    अनि आवेशमा आएर त्यस्ता घटनाहरु घट्न पुग्छ !!
    यसको दोषी सामन्तवाद एवं राजतन्त्र हो, एउटा व्यक्ति होइन !!

  • @चारआँखे
    @चारआँखे Год назад

    सँच्ची एउटा कुरा सोधिहाल्न मन लाग्यो !!
    त्रैलोक्य, पृथ्वी वीर विक्रम तथा महेन्द्रहरुको मृत्यु पनि अकस्मात भएको थियो नी !!
    बिरेन्द्र र दिपेन्द्रको कुरा त यसै पनि छँदैछ !!
    सबैले देख्ने गरि उनिहरु गोली खाएर मारिए !!
    यस्तो किन भएको होला `नेपाली कमेन्ट´..??

  • @surentamang9962
    @surentamang9962 Год назад

    भण्डारखाल पर्व also known as the बस्नेत पर्व was the massacre after the कोत पर्व of remaing भारदार (mostly Basnets)who were against jung bdr. so, I think you are mistaken.

  • @parassapkota1069
    @parassapkota1069 Год назад

    Gajjab xa haii dai
    Keep it up❤

  • @puspadahal8829
    @puspadahal8829 Год назад

    अहिले त ३ करोड नेपाली पशुपतिका बाँदर जस्ता छन्, २५० अगाडि जँगलमा पृथ्वीनारायण वा भिमसेन थिएन।
    नेपालको इतिहास उल्टो लेखिएको छ, जनतालाई मुर्ख बनाउन

  • @saliksatabhdi
    @saliksatabhdi Год назад +1

    Story Yei bata to be continue huna parne.....