The Art of War: Power Projection
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Explore the military strategy of power projection in this Art of War series installment. Learn how nations extend force far beyond their borders and why they invest immense resources to dominate distant territories.
→ Subscribe for new videos at least twice a week!
www.youtube.co...
Love content? Check out Simon's other RUclips Channels:
MegaProjects: / @megaprojects9649
SideProjects: / @sideprojects
Casual Criminalist: / @thecasualcriminalist
Today I Found Out: / todayifoundout
Highlight History: / @highlighthistory
XPLRD: / @xplrd
Brain Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
Places: / @places302
Astrographics: / @astrographics-ve4yq
Simon's Social Media:
Twitter: / simonwhistler
Instagram: / simonwhistler
Power projection is Simon taking over RUclips with 50 different channels and uploading quality videos in multiple different topics.
You made my day sir!
Yes, too true
I’ve even seen unofficial advertisements using clips from his videos, so the power projection is outside of YT as well.
@@dr.python His PP is so strong, he penetrated the YT 4th wall.
😂
Clicks on video
"You're a king."
Thanks Simon, I needed that😁
"Also, you just royally screwed up everything."
Yeah, sounds bout right.
The argentinians learnt of this the hard way, when the british came to retake their islands from half a world away.
Did they though? Yeah they won but they struggled to get there. I could be mistaken so don’t jump down my throat but didn’t one of the carriers have to turn around after leaving port? Leaving air power relying on one carrier. It wasn’t a carrier carrying 50+ jets I think they held 12-20. Again could remembering this wrong but I think bucks had to turn around too but again I could have that wrong. What I was wondering is why they didn’t use bases in the us? Don’t get me wrong they went down there and did their thing but I never understood why we didn’t help with that.
I mean, in the end they were successful, and that's the point. Relatively few nations can carry out a military conflict on a different ocean. Even a shadow of its former self, the Royal Navy had enough redundancy to win a decisive victory. "Two is one, one is none"
"Their" .... Half a world away....."their"
@@wilddingo0The harsh reality of the world is that it doesn’t matter if you’re right.
Whose islands 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tips to peacefully gain PP (Power projection):
- Keep longtime rivals: +5 per rival
- Embargo rivals: up to +10 per rival
- Insults rival: +5 or +10 for scornful insults
- Subsidize rival's enemies
Maintaining 50+ PP will grant a nation extra Administrative, Diplomatic and Military power.
😂😂
I see that eu4 reference.
i love keeping my PP up
Turnip2024
why do i feel the need to play stellaris again, after reading your commend :D
Other countries: “let’s burn the bridges”
Rome: “Let’s build more”
*Decebalus didn’t appreciate this move*
Roman engineer and willingness to build won them countless battles and sieges. turns out when your enemis can barely build towns and your army can build walls, forts and siege equipment on the fly within a couple week you can gain alot of flexibility
"To burn everyone else's"
The US has force projection capabilities of defending homeland and allies as well as fully operating two different theaters of war, there is not a single nation on earth able to even do part of this. China is trying but it's still way behind. Russia can't even properly enforce its will on a nation right on its doorstep. Iran uses lots of proxies because they severely lack any capabilities to deploy it's own forces for a sustained amount of time even in the region it claims is under its influence. All of our allies rely heavily on US military infrastructure to send their forces into coalition conflicts. They all have strictly defensive militaries if they even have one at all
Way behind? You can't surely believe that😂
@@KorpusV6Yes, they are way behind. War is won by logistics networks. Your troops can’t fight if you can’t keep them supplied. The USA has bases and supply chains all around the world. The U.S. can refuel its aircraft in the air, anywhere in the world they are needed. No one else can do that. They are the only true blue water navy. The Chinese have no submarines comparable to Americas. Their ships are sitting ducks. Their hypersonics are actually modified ballistic missiles. Because they have a predictable trajectory, the Patriot missile systems in Ukraine have already proven that this can be shot down. The B2 stealth and b21 raider bombers can fly over any country and can’t be shot down.
No one is even close.
Trump will pull the US out of NATO. America First right? Then watch things happen lol
lol Pro american bot comment. Bot name, bot response i've seen a million times. America really trying to desperately keep up this "We can still win any war!" facade when nobody in the nation outside of the extremely indoctrinated or stupid soldiers want more war when our nation is falling apart internally
@@KorpusV6 China doesn't ever have control of all the territory it claims. It literally cannot bring it's breakaway areas under it's governance. So yes, it's very far behind.
ik you may never see this Simon and team, but thank you for listening to your audience and stopping the use of ai art in your videos. it does not go unnoticed and your videos feel more authentic for it.
Can you give me an example?, because i have never noticed it
@@simongranger8127 Watch any video from a few months ago. Probably a third of some of his videos were AI art. Got really annoying. Especially when it was a serious topic and the picture just made you laugh.
@@Plaprad ok, i see what you mean
Here as soon as my boi posts
Always 👍
Stopped in the middle of what I was watching the second I saw
@@LacRagem same fr lol
I’m late fuck
@@jonathanbarnes215 all good just like comment sub and like the whole video give this man all the free traffic we can
One quote comes to mind:
“International order is not an evolution; it is an imposition. It is the domination of one vision over others - in this case, the domination of liberal principles of economics, domestic politics, and international relations over other, nonliberal principles…
𝙄𝙩 𝙬𝙞𝙡𝙡 𝙡𝙖𝙨𝙩 𝙤𝙣𝙡𝙮 𝙖𝙨 𝙡𝙤𝙣𝙜 𝙖𝙨 𝙩𝙝𝙤𝙨𝙚 𝙬𝙝𝙤 𝙞𝙢𝙥𝙤𝙨𝙚𝙙 𝙞𝙩 𝙧𝙚𝙩𝙖𝙞𝙣 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙘𝙖𝙥𝙖𝙘𝙞𝙩𝙮 𝙩𝙤 𝙙𝙚𝙛𝙚𝙣𝙙 𝙞𝙩.”
- Robert Kagan, The World America Made (2012)
and as america crumbles and it's foundations begins to wear away threatening to split the order it built on bodies and blood with a false smile and promises of freedom washes away like a oil slick down the river of time. thank god
Those things listed are exactly why it's called international order...
Otherwise it's just organised chaos.
It was absolutely an evolution in trade and global relationships.
Although he is right that it won't last unless you're capable of protecting it.
And Unfortunately we are seeing The US growing hesitant with it's overly restrained approach and lukewarm reactions towards countries that are attempting to completely undermine it's imposed World order such as Iran, China, Russia, and North Korea.
And the American people are growing complacent and Unaware with foolish movements and calls saying things like "it is not our war"
"It's a waste of tax money" in reaction to the US sending any sort of support to foreign fronts such as Israel in the Middle or Ukraine in europe.
"Most powerful is he who has himself in his own power"
- *Lucius Seneca*
Like nukes
Amazing how many people don't understand this. I get it they don't like war blah blah none of us do but while they sit there complaining about it they're doing so safe from war.
Literally the only thing keeping them from war is the fact they have or are backed by a military that can wipe the floor with any other military on the planet
As much as power projection is imprtant, not being affected by power projection is also important, this comes with good natural geographical protection + lucrative liquidity (resources) + securing trade (with alternative or neutral partners)
The countries that come in this club are
- India (natural naval protection)
- China (ample trading partners)
- Russia (enough resources)
- Canada (geographical isolation)
- Saudi Arabia (large support base & liquid assets)
You know Simon, you’re not allowed to quit. You’re not allowed to scale back or slow down. You only have your self to blame, you charismatic 😈, you.
Let him take a break, I don't want him falling ill. We need this National Treasure.
For those of you wondering why the US is so generous to Israel, think about how much money it takes to build and run an aircraft carrier that then must move to where you want it. They are amazing machines but having an ally as close as Israel is in one of the most volatile and economically pivotal locations on Earth is worth just an awful lot. The US has quite a lot of assets parked in Israel that are ready to go when someone in the region acts up.
This guy gets it!
Wake up babe, Simon dropped a new banger
getting old babe
😂
For anyone who wants a deeper understand of how power projection works/influence, read The Tragedy of Great Power Politics by John J Mearsheimer
Last time I was this early my girlfriend left me
😂😂😂
I'm on the contrary, the shortest I've lasted was 01:10
The clown of the court cannot help but to laugh and cry at his acts.
The last time you were this early Germany was already in Poland.
@@mattk7865 Buddy 😂😂😂
I say there's nothing more entertaining than listening to whatever Simon has in store for us today.
Simon : "A nation needs wealth to project power."
USA : "Hold my debt."
The line of suckers be deep.
Me thinks the "Nat'l debt" is actually a misnomer for the price of having to the world whine over the US "Keeping The Peace"!
lol. Sentiments of old Europe
We have temporally unstable wealth lol
Raise hell! Praise Dale!
😄😂😂
Слава Украйни!
"you're a king..."
Why would you lie to my face in the first 3 seconds! I already know I'm a mere peasant!! No need for gaslighting!!
Sometimes that Power of Projection" occurs just from eating too much chili, and drinking too much beer. Oops, and before ya know it, You're at war again with both England and France this time. "We'll teach you not to excuse yourself from the dinner table before projecting your Power! How dare you good sir! There are women present! " LOL
Why fighting for the first place when we can project the first place?
Ahhh, nice
On RUclips, Simon has the best power projection.
Simon......you are a non stop busy bee.....
There is this small country in the middle of East Africa called “Rwanda” I keep telling people that country is full of geniuses and military geniuses as well. The fact that they’ve been able to project their military forces all over Africa is nothing short of a miracle. Especially when just 30 years ago the country was completely destroyed.
Great country, we will be sending them a bunch of people this year.
Fantastic for everyone.
While I am aware of what happened 30 years ago in Rwanda and the fact the country is one of the most successful African countries I can't find any cases of military force projection aside from some operations against jihadists and the DRC which are nearby.
I heard that the reason they recovered so well is that afterwards everybody was essentially tired of murdering.
Everybody that had issues with everybody was basically dead.
Kind of like the purge lol
@@7stormy334 the whole "Visit Rwanda" thing you see at sport events around the world is an instance of soft power
That intro….
Screw online courses! Give me Simon Whistler ‘Choose Your Own Adventure’ 80’s books read like this!!!!!
having submarines on my mind thanks to Perun’s latest video… time to see if they get a mention!
also overseas military bases, can’t talk about power projection without talking about overseas bases… _cough_ USA
France and the UK still have power projection capabilities. They both have base around the world and aircraft carrier.
And France's intervention in Mali was a success in term of power projection (in terms of result, it is an other story).
I love this art of war series, I hope you put them all in a playlist soon!
Simon saying the word “ empire” is a power unto its self
Former British Colonist here and Simon saying 'Empire' with a standard accent is moving.
I learn more from watching you explain our world than I ever thought possible. It's so nice to have such a reliable, well-researched source of information that clarifies and explains things I learn elsewhere and put them into context better than reading it myself alone. Not to mention all the things I've learned from you that I would have never researched on my own. Thank you, very sincerely, for everything you do Simon! Cheers from Montana, USA!💯😎
i think the ukraine war has deminished the power projection of the usa a lot, think about the ukraine has been able to contain the russian fleet, now think about what iran could do to the USA carrier fleet down there...
just woke up and warographics uploaded a vid this day will be my lucky day
Look, it's Justin Trudeau! Oh, nevermind.. it's just Castro
Simon another fascinating topic, i would like to analyze for us how does combined armed maneuver works, indicating western doctrines Ops, i really appreciate your helpful and kind way for offering us such valuable knowledge, that i couldn't get from universities or military courses in my country, much appreciated professor simon.
It's called a......Rapid Response Force. Usually an Amphibious force.
Love how this quirky facts channel has grown, in to a professionally presented non slanted geopolitical news source 👏🏼love the content
Edit: aware of the historical see dive bios and true crime and top ten stuff too - same opinion on those too 👌🏽
Simon has the greatest power projection on RUclips.
Only 4.3k views in 25 minutes...
...this channel's dropping off
I am very glad you also enjoy deep diving into the art of war simon. I hope you have more art of war videos on the way, possibly a collaboration with the operations room for DEEEP dives into battle of what country or kingdom also used these tactics and how effective they were.
I cant wait till you talk about what happened recently in Iran about their President
I think it’ll be a relatively short video. Most sources do agree that it more than likely was an accident.
1:35 - Chapter 1 - The method
9:15 - Chapter 2 - The history
20:15 - Chapter 3 - The present day
That was a killer intro js
You are a master Simon, every video a masterpiece. Thank you.
I am too slow. Vid out 1min and only made 3rd comment
You can always nuke the moon just to show people you can.... Or piss on it.
Canada has to do better in the Arctic before we start getting pushed around.
Ah yes, the real reason why us Americans do no have free healthcare
Nothing is free.
I’ll be honest. Main reason I watch this channel is for the rare occasion that Simon says words like “mustache” and “aluminum”.
It was a clear explanation and realistically narration about power projection . Thanks for sharing
Power projection means future survivability..
And I thought power projection was the kind of thing movie theaters did
D’oh
Thought-provoking but you must be able to sustain that projection in the face of opposition. China and Russia I would argue can not, they can only project power regionally yes they do have bases but that is with the forbearance of others. If the West (US and allied nations) told both, "Your days in Africa are done" there is little either could do about it.
I'm so goddamn proud to be American 🇺🇸
I had a discussion with a friend a few decades ago about the sizes between the Roman and Mongolian empires. My friend asserted that Alexander's empire was larger while I stated that the Mongolian empire is bigger. Maybe I should send him a link to this video.
Honestly thought it was common knowledge that the Mongol empire was the 2nd biggest ever to Britain and it was the largest single territory with no sea in between territories.
Good job as always mates. One thing I would clarify though is when you were describing the difference between hard and soft power, soft power is always the implied application of hard power. That's why it's soft. There is no soft power if there is no implied hard power.
Hard power and chinchilla power
Signing in only 4 hours late but I'm here never the less. Lets Go Si
"yEr uH kInGg"
...
..uh..thanks...?
Simon’s content quality and upload consistency is so impressive 👌🏼
Honestly a brilliant strategy as well. Just keep spinning out new channels with new writers and cycle content across all of them, dominating the RUclips feed and generating consistent revenue. I see you, fact boi
His bald head which makes me come makes watching him even better!@Nick-gj6je
Countries capable of power projection:
1: USA
2:...🙄
Countries that could potentially power project:
1: Japan
2: UK
3: France
Tha tha tha THAT'S ALL FOLKS!!! 🤣
Everyone else is regional. At best.
Operation downfall, Macarthur wet dream. Would have been extremely stupid and costly, US and allied casualties would have been horrendous. If Oppenheimer had been unsuccessful war in 1946 would be extremely bloody, even with Air superiority guaranteed by the USN.
I would argue that you shouldn't start the historical account with Alexander the Grea but rather with the Assyrians - arguably the first "world empire" (although an argument can also be made for certain Egyptian dynasties doing power projection earlier).
The Assyrians were also followed by the Babylonians - that didn't last long - and the Persians. The Persians were very good at projecting power on all their borders, and in particular into Greece. In fact, you can interpret Alexander's campaign as an attempt - that was successful beyond expectations - to stop Persian power projection in the Aegean region.
It should also be said that the Macedonians were not very good with power projection. To much of their long term strategy was dependent on Alexander's charisma and military genius. The moment he died, the entire system fell apart and the armies sent to the East actually became a threat to the Macedonian homeland.
Why does it when you describe the evils of power projection in the beginning. It sounds like you're talking bout the United States I know you have to dumb it down for your audience to use an example. But there's many examples throughout history that you could've used subliminally
5:50 Hang on, Afghanistan allegedly hid Bin Laden, but what on earth did Iraq have to do with 9/11? I thought that war was about non existing WMD's?
The military industrial complex churns on and the billionaires who run it get ever more absurdly wealthy. Don't forget to spend at least 2% of your GDP on weapons!
your definition of power projection, when comparing it to the past(the vikings) is incorrect. The definition you are proposing is far too modern in comparison to a non-globalized world. As far as history knows, the vikings were arguably one of the best at power projection with the only debates being the roman and greek empires.
Man thank you so much for this video. I hate getting into arguments with people when they believe sensationalist media of possible "threats" of the Chinese, Russian, North Korean forces, etc. And I try to explain to them these countries cannot manage conflicts on their own borders let alone the massive logistical implications that a medium or larger scale conflict would mean for some of these nations. No one can maintain as much land forces, air forces and sea forces for as long as we can anywhere in the world. Not to mention the speed of even something as a partial mobilization would be ridiculous in the U.S.
There is an element of force projection regarding Ukraine as something of a proxy for NATO, at least post-invasion. NATO advisors did assist in warning Ukraine about Rissian movements prior to the first wave, aside from which setting aside advisors and training personnel to assist Ukraine indirectly on the warfront. I think that shipping will over arms and ammunition has assisted, albeit such an investment has always been limited to older vehicles and weapons that are deemed more or less unnecessary.
Beautiful story telling.
FACT BOY DOES IT AGAIN
In our polisci classes, we jokingly say that the American armed forces aren't a military; they're a logistics company that moonlights as an army.
Big shout out from sunny South Africa.
Love the work you do i watch all your channel i find it very educational entertaining.
I have to say this episode was brilliant.
The way you went about it and the intro i have to say was very well done.
21:16 I don’t think that is a fair attitude. Yes the U.S. can militarily dominate the world, but it does not oppress the world. We guarantee free trade and promote economic development across the world and only ask for peace in return. America is not perfect, but there has never been a more benevolent empire in history.
You see the world is a dangerous place, the only way for anyone to be safe is to make everyone dangerous
-Lucky Harith.
‘Murica speciality
Why did you glass over the nuclear bomb? The nuclear bonus dropped in Japan is the best hard power projection example that still stands the strongest to date and then the hydrogen bombs and the cold war era nuclear race is the perfect soft powrr projection to date18:40
We had ships whose only job was make ice-cream...
Guys, do you think power projection gets more difficult and expensive with distance?
I dont know if you'll see this or if you take requests, but do you think you could cover the war of the roses or the French wars of religion
"chaos" is the answer. the growing concern of damages and chaos is the direction all of humanity is going. when everyone gets the ability to shoot someone in the eye we have a world that figuring out who's to blame is hard to see and harder to get right!
It’s really crazy to think. US war economy alone is larger than most nation capabilities
Pakistan should probably help India or China cause they are not winning on their own terms
I would love to hear some words of the Vikings and their way of power projection, but still a great video 👍
Power projection is not a strategy, it is a capability. How you apply power projection is a strategy.
This is what I love about paratroopers. Anywhere in the world, 18 hours or less
Projecting power, hmm The Houthis send us more of your Reapers
This dude owns 100 channels at this point 😂. Impressive
Este es uno de los peores videos que eh visto sobre el tema, no menciona a ningun autor post moderno o clasico sobre el tema. Gente, agarren libros y lean.
Can you do a combind arms episode?
Early gang! The element of suprise doesn’t work on us.
US hard power: Dont mess with us
Rebels on the Red Sea: what hard power?
Again mesmerizing glare of teleprompter..
interesting assessment...
Damn that Russar employing hard pa all over the world...
yeah deterrence is cool and all apart from the fact it hasn't been working.
Suitable soundtrack: The rains of Castamere
"Tales of your misdeeds are told from Ireland to Cathay."
Jeopardy Answer: Who’s is the US of A?
Over exposure and to much speak. Enough.