What Remains of Edith Finch: The Full Story: Live with Oxhorn - Scotch & Smoke Rings Episode 564

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
  • Subscribe!: oxhorn.it/youtu...
    Become a Member: / @oxhorn
    Support on Patreon: / oxhorn
    Get an Oxhorn T-shirt: oxhorn.it/oxhor...
    Join Ox's Discord Community: / discord
    My Twitch: / scotchandsmokerings
    Twitter: / oxhorn
    Facebook: / oxhornpage
    My Shirts: oxhorn.it/oxhor...
    My Fantasy Novel: www.cloranhasti...
    My Gaming Rig: pcpartpicker.c...
    My Editing/Streaming Rig: pcpartpicker.c...
    #Oxhorn #EdithFinch #S&SR

Комментарии • 76

  • @NeverLookBackOnce
    @NeverLookBackOnce 4 года назад +37

    Every man a tear to shed,
    For the living or for the dead.
    With stories penned, with tales told,
    It matters not if you're young or old.
    In the days past, in days to be,
    A end of a story we will see.
    So don't be sad, do not cry,
    For everything that is born must die.

  • @mistywolf312
    @mistywolf312 4 года назад +8

    Its a game that teaches you to remember the people you love and who loved you, wether they are alive or dead. It wsa awesome !

  • @smilinbandit4191
    @smilinbandit4191 4 года назад +12

    Just got done playing this. Its a top tier on my list.

    • @smilinbandit4191
      @smilinbandit4191 4 года назад +2

      Also the one the boat in the beginning is her son.

  • @ktbeaverhausen2211
    @ktbeaverhausen2211 4 года назад +6

    best story telling I’ve ever experienced and I couldn’t have imagined watching this stream anywhere else

  • @aussiebloke609
    @aussiebloke609 4 года назад +4

    There was a newspaper clipping on the wall @ 3:36:11 in the home classroom with the headline "Relief Efforts End In Disaster"...presumably that's when Sanjay died.

  • @pee-in-the-wind
    @pee-in-the-wind 4 года назад +9

    OX: That was really hard to turn off last night but i had to because of a early am meeting. But as soon as i could i picked it up where left off. Wow, what a game!

  • @averageyoutubeuser9995
    @averageyoutubeuser9995 4 года назад +3

    This is such an amazing game, it's my all time favourite indie game. This game pretty much got me hooked on indie games.

  • @tazersmurf4689
    @tazersmurf4689 4 года назад +6

    When I played this I somehow had missed Gregory's story. You missed out on Molly thinking about eating her fish. There's an achievement for knocking in all of the pool balls with the crutch. This game is so sad. Milton "escaped" he was part of an Easter egg for another unrelated game. There is no in game explanation for what really happened to him.
    Oh and there's also an achievement for knocking down all of the letters in the tub.

    • @JustKelso1993
      @JustKelso1993 2 года назад

      And an achievement for letting the sailor finish singing.

  • @MCWeeks
    @MCWeeks 2 года назад

    It’s been a while but I’m back here after I just played the game. Had no idea if you played this or not but it felt so… you. I immediately hit google and typed in “what remains of Edith finch oxhorn.” I knew somehow you’d find this game too! Your an amazing story teller and to see you get to sit back and what a game do what you do best was like watching two masters mellowly enjoying their craft. Keep it up man!

  • @andnee3
    @andnee3 4 года назад +6

    Great as usual ox

  • @Chaoticegamer
    @Chaoticegamer Год назад

    This game is absolutely amazing. I loved it but it def. Made me cry.

  • @RyanHolcombeRyan2Gamer
    @RyanHolcombeRyan2Gamer Год назад

    If you overthink things in this game you'll get confused never overthink it it always explains it at the end and most of it's simple

  • @cameronpatt466
    @cameronpatt466 4 года назад +1

    Accident prone family and they decide to build the rest of the house on stilts on top of the old one....brilliant

  • @jamesm6766
    @jamesm6766 4 года назад +1

    About the fusion core in the back conversation, I think what people forget that Army does movements in teams. So it would natural for soliders to assist each other with changing out cores.

  • @Waxson77
    @Waxson77 4 года назад

    Thank you for keeping the q&a alive ox

  • @timothy8428
    @timothy8428 3 года назад

    Oh I did the swing thing at school.
    Woke up at home with concussion.

  • @taylortot9527
    @taylortot9527 2 года назад

    I wish Ox would have played "Unfinished Swan" it's an amazing game about Milton and his life after he disappeared through his magic door.

  • @wairuaozula3060
    @wairuaozula3060 2 года назад +1

    I could listen to miltons theme forever. Did you play unfinished swan after this ?

  • @dondecaire6534
    @dondecaire6534 4 года назад

    That was the most depressing game I have ever seen and yet I could not stop watching it. The story was so bizarre yet connected and it was beautifully done. I cannot say I would ever play it, but it is unforgettable...

    • @beyondviolet
      @beyondviolet 2 года назад

      If I had the means I’d probably be the type of person to buy it just to support the creators

  • @littlebit8901
    @littlebit8901 4 года назад +1

    The best Scotch & Smoke Rings ever imo... damn you Ox

  • @DueRag
    @DueRag 4 года назад +1

    My heart... it burns...

    • @Prime_Logos
      @Prime_Logos 4 года назад +2

      they make pills for that

  • @dead_fox
    @dead_fox 4 года назад +11

    Oxhorn now that you played What Remains of
    Edith Finch, could you please re-consider Firewatch? It’s a wonderful game with an exceptional script and awesome narrative.
    I know you’re not interested because of the graphics, but please re consider, it’s quite similar to this!
    Hope he reads this

    • @goawayguzman7474
      @goawayguzman7474 4 года назад +3

      He kinda looks like the main character😂

    • @snowyowlrule4594
      @snowyowlrule4594 4 года назад +3

      I will say I loved watching Firewatch and it reminds me of this game. Only thing is the ending was not my cup of tea and the fate of Delilah’s arc was upsetting

    • @dead_fox
      @dead_fox 4 года назад +1

      • SnowyOwlRule459 •
      I see that people quite dislike that ending. I personally don’t, to me it kind of feels “real” in some way, like that’s what probably would happen in real life. We know Delilah runs away from her problems or decides to ignore them, for example doing that job in the first place, or drinking during the job, so while it was a surprise for me at first, when you think about it it kind of makes sense. But it would have been great to meet her ngl

    • @snowyowlrule4594
      @snowyowlrule4594 4 года назад +2

      Dead Fox I definitely wasn’t too upset with the ending and it is fitting, but I wanted to see her, you know? Just a tangible character, as I know many people wanted to. I still loved watching all the gameplay.

  • @Kattatonik7_yt
    @Kattatonik7_yt 4 года назад

    So glad to see you finally play this Oxhorn!😀
    After playing this I was led to play The Unfinished Swan, and from there Giant Sparrow became my second favorite dev!
    If you ever get time I recommend it but it isn't a streaming game imo. Its so poignant for such a short game and really gets its point across. It makes you gasp in wonder and awe but it is NOT as sad.

  • @curator3539
    @curator3539 4 года назад +1

    Hey Ox, I don't know if anyone has said it yet (it didn't look like it) but the story of Milton has been confirmed by a developer as being connected to the company's other game. Milton is the "king" not the protagonist from the other game. So I guess we're supposed to believe that there is a little something supernatural going on in this game.

  • @martinadrobne5550
    @martinadrobne5550 4 года назад +1

    I'd played this game before but I really enjoyed revisiting the story with you. Might I recommend you try Oxenfree? It's also a story driven game but you have to make decisions that will change how the story ends. Great video, as always.

  • @junglesairsoftblog6311
    @junglesairsoftblog6311 3 года назад

    Wow, so sad but so gripping I just couldn't stop watching, thank you Ox, I'm not sure I could have played to the end..

  • @jenmarie2030
    @jenmarie2030 4 года назад

    This game is so sad. I love the story and all the little puzzles. I thought you'd love this game. This is the game I would have recommended most.

  • @matthewmeakins6474
    @matthewmeakins6474 3 года назад

    Excellent, happy Halloween 🎃

  • @mithrandir3118
    @mithrandir3118 3 года назад

    Good stuff!

  • @xMotivationFix
    @xMotivationFix 4 года назад +7

    Life is strange would be a good game to do, it's amazing!

  • @Relaxedplaythroughs
    @Relaxedplaythroughs 4 года назад +1

    For next week maybe play Tales From the Borderlands. It will let you get used to the art style of the borderlands games. This should also be a good fit for scotch and smoke rings. Dark and funny with some bad dad jokes and has Patrick Warburton

  • @nicolaisidek
    @nicolaisidek 4 года назад

    So depressing but I enjoyed watching you immerse yourself in this

  • @Chibi-kittenplays
    @Chibi-kittenplays 4 года назад

    the music that plays when the baby scene is in the bathroom I suspect isn't mono since that is an OLD old classical music piece

  • @TheOrangeBrick22
    @TheOrangeBrick22 4 года назад +2

    It would be great if he played Mass Effect next week. Totally no gut-wrenching decisions near the beginning of that game

  • @caiocavalero
    @caiocavalero 4 года назад

    After watching this, maybe you should try Rime Ox, its also a touching story.

  • @xracingleague
    @xracingleague 4 года назад +1

    I really hate this kind of game. Makes my body chill. 😅😅😅. Great that you are the one who is playing it and not me Ox. Hahaha!

  • @juancarlosalonso5664
    @juancarlosalonso5664 4 года назад

    Really nice game, think it was free one month on psplus or I wouldn't even have looked at it, glad I played it.

  • @neillindgren8992
    @neillindgren8992 4 года назад

    Regarding playable ghouls and super mutants in Fallout 76, they could treat them somewhat like vampires and werewolves in Elder Scrolls online where instead of a separate race they are something you convert a preexisting character into, presumably using radiation to become a ghoul or using FEV you somehow find to become a super mutant. Speaking of ghouls and super mutants, I think it would be awesome if Fallout 5 took place near Chicago, where the Brotherhood of Steel is much more open-minded and supposedly accepts ghouls and mutants. Being able to play a Brotherhood of Steel ghoul or mutant would be a different new fallout experience, and having the local BoS being the good guys again would be nice.

  • @tgreaperzz1482
    @tgreaperzz1482 4 года назад

    Ox why don’t you go through the game options and turn off music, I am sure most games have the option of adjusting the volume of it

  • @nyotamwuaji6484
    @nyotamwuaji6484 2 года назад

    it was December, so the twig of holly was probably decoration?

  • @marshyspudder
    @marshyspudder 4 года назад

    Oxhorn, you should try out ori and the blind forest. It seems like it could suit you. It's not rpg or anything, it's a popular platformer.

  • @Pennsyltucky84
    @Pennsyltucky84 4 года назад

    I bet Dawn stopped feeling guilty about that deer!

  • @Prime_Logos
    @Prime_Logos 4 года назад

    As someone who has clinically diagnosed depression, and goes to therapy/medication. I uhh....Ill be back for a different game....lol Heres a up doot tho!

  • @Pennsyltucky84
    @Pennsyltucky84 4 года назад

    My mom really did swing a full circle as a kid... also broke her arm doing it.

    • @jamescolm1133
      @jamescolm1133 3 года назад +1

      Luckily her swing set wasn't near a cliff

    • @Pennsyltucky84
      @Pennsyltucky84 3 года назад

      @@jamescolm1133 lol, absolutely

  • @venombeetle7473
    @venombeetle7473 4 года назад +1

    Perhaps the hollyberries was the Christmas decor because they had a lot of Christmas lights outside

  • @mr.yeet_eats9609
    @mr.yeet_eats9609 4 года назад

    Probably not many people will see this. But, the part where he thought edie put the branch there, i thought to my self "assasasino". Edie out here being deadlier that Altair and ezio combined

  • @thatbobbi
    @thatbobbi 4 года назад

    Careful with all that Halloween 🎃 movie theme music (during the part where you're terrorizing the basement with the crutch in the comic book).

  • @HK1990Gaming
    @HK1990Gaming 4 года назад

    I'v never tried to use the mouse and keyboard function on my consoles. I would assume that remapping wouldn't be that hard if they allow button remapping options. like changing the jump button from a to b. I know some games don't allow that function at all and i would expect those games wouldn't work with them. Steam kind of does that already. I grew up using the controllers. Using the keyboard and mouse has been a challenge to get use to. Going from remembering 8 buttons to so many more also can be a challenge for me.
    I also thought about the power core. In my fan fiction I wrote They didnt reload. But adding that to the game would have been inconvenient and would have broke the combat up. but you brought this up as I wrote this lol.
    Pipboy=bag of holding.
    P.S. I am so behind in your content lol. basically having to play your videos on 2x speed to binge as much as i can. Wanted to leave a comment somewhere, your a huge influence in my initiative to become a content creator.

  • @aussiebloke609
    @aussiebloke609 4 года назад

    Ox, if your transmog hides your suspenders, do you still get the set bonus? :-D

  • @TheUnsuper
    @TheUnsuper 4 года назад

    is there a schedule for witcher 3 streams?

    • @canuck0822
      @canuck0822 4 года назад

      Mondays: Vampyre 10am Pacific
      Thursdays: Scotch and Smokerings 7pm Pacific
      Fridays: Witcher 3 10am Pacific

  • @2ndplaceagain648
    @2ndplaceagain648 4 года назад

    the girl sounds like veronica from new vegas

  • @RyanHolcombeRyan2Gamer
    @RyanHolcombeRyan2Gamer Год назад

    No she did not kill her daughter the Holly branches were already there for the holidays and the the mom sent her to room without dinner because she was being bad she probably locked the door cuz she didn't want her to get out cuz she was in big trouble

  • @r.e.barnes1168
    @r.e.barnes1168 3 года назад

    This video doesn’t work/play anymore

  • @PCGamingGoodies
    @PCGamingGoodies 4 года назад

    My favorite segment was Barbara's story told in comic book, first-person action format. Though tragic, it was energetic and humorous, whereas all the other segments were pretty moribund (not to mention, easy to predict what would happen). The isometric RPG segment was well done, but as soon as you saw the fish head chopper you knew what would happen. Regarding Molly's death (1:34:25), Ox said her parents might have tried to kill her with the poisonous fruit. But it seemed it was put there as decoration (Molly might have put it there herself). I think Molly's parents just sent her to bed without supper, not knowing the poisonous fruit was there. Overall, I loved the game, but it had too much of one thing for me. This story-game genre is still in its infancy, though. It started with Gone Home in 2013, and it's got better and better. Games like Edith Finch and Firewatch proved that story games can have interesting interaction too. This genre used to be so primitive that you just clicked through various unexciting visuals and interaction that didn't involve you with the story at all. Many people look down on this genre and call it "walking simulator." But this genre has the potential for breakthroughs in game design. Storytelling in games is still pretty low-level. Games can only tell *certain* kinds of stories, and can't handle *high-level* storytelling, such as that in classic movies like Pulp Fiction, Taxi Driver, Raging Bull, Mulholland Drive, Parasite, Roma, etc. Video games need to evolve much further to be able to reach that level. And what genre is best positioned to achieve that? It is the walking simulator genre, my friends. I'm closely watching this genre for this reason. And I'm glad Ox, whose primary interest is storytelling, is showing interest to games like this.

  • @maggieamoddio9050
    @maggieamoddio9050 4 года назад

    The real question is how are they writing how they died

    • @KungFuKendrick
      @KungFuKendrick 4 года назад +1

      I'm not even going to say anything

  • @AuroraAlchemy
    @AuroraAlchemy 4 года назад

    wait where's the end?!? it cut off before the library scene started!

    • @canuck0822
      @canuck0822 4 года назад

      @Aurora Alchemy RUclips has issues processing videos over 4 hours long. That is why Oxhorn tries to limits his streams to a 4 hour hard cap.
      Check back in a few hours, the full video should be finished then.

    • @AuroraAlchemy
      @AuroraAlchemy 4 года назад

      ​@@canuck0822 thanks :) I ended up finding an old 2017 playthrough of this game from another RUclipsr I occasionally watch that showed the ending. sucks that RUclips messes up long stream though. thanks for the heads up

    • @aussiebloke609
      @aussiebloke609 4 года назад

      @@canuck0822 Sadly, the end (when Edith is reading Edie's book in the library) is where it cuts off. Considering it's been at least 9 hours since your comment, I think by this point it's safe to say that yt has permanently truncated this video.

    • @Pennsyltucky84
      @Pennsyltucky84 3 года назад +1

      @@aussiebloke609 I watched this live and and came back to watch it again, it's full length now.

    • @aussiebloke609
      @aussiebloke609 3 года назад +1

      @@Pennsyltucky84 Thank you for the update - and what a tear-jerker it was. Glad I didn't miss this after all. Cheers!

  • @lathanchurch8352
    @lathanchurch8352 4 года назад

    Oooff deathloop is a playstation exclusive, which is fucking stupid because they are completely cutting off a large section of income and burning fans who would have bought it If they didn't have to wait

  • @aussiebloke609
    @aussiebloke609 4 года назад

    More of an interactive story than a game, as there's no player agency...but still a well-told story, nevertheless. :-)
    Shame youtube seems to have cut things short, just as what appears to be the final narrative starts.

  • @Leyanna69
    @Leyanna69 4 года назад

    Ox "why would she put Holly in her bedroom?!"
    No one points out the Diary entry is "December 1941"
    Christmas time......
    Still doesn't click after muting music saying "gonna get demonitised as it's a well known Christmas song" 🤣🤣