They didn't even get his personality right, Newton was not a smiling gregarious type. He was a solemn, serious person who could be actually quite ruthless.
@@thegaurdianchild5571 Absolutely no one insinuated there aren't other options. Stop acting like a needlessly confrontational teenager on the Internet.
@@AJadedLizard - I'm gonna assume that this wasn't an overreaction out of nowhere, and that the "(edited)" next to the original comment means that person said something uncouth.
@@Raggedy-Man I think you misunderstand, people are complaining that they didn't get more of him, they love wilfred, they do not like the writing choices, that's what people are complaining about
Sydney Newman wanted the show to be historically accurate to teach kids interesting ways to learn about the past. So, there. Shat all over his legacy as well.
As an Indian it makes me cringe. Sir Issac newton is one the greatest minds of humanity. Instead of focusing on colour and gender identity of the scientist, look at his contributions.
the saddest thing is that they will never look up at an actually indian or X non white european caucasian whose did some cultural or tecnological accomplishment and the fact they simply race swap other historical figure like isaac newton is kinda of racist.
Herr was also an elite level (on a daily basis) trench runner/message carrier for like 18 months straight on the Western Front.. Unbelievably hardcore.
They might, but it'd have to be an alternate history version, where a black woman goes back, takes his place, and turns out to be the greatest and most benevolent ruler who ever lived (all while clapping back at every white man who appears on screen, of course)
They keep wasting elderly actors. First we lost Carrie Fisher without reuniting the OG trio now we lost wilfrid before he could say anything meaningful to 14.
Good for Bernard Cribbins. The man who was also the "First male companion" when they tried to take Doctor Who and the Daleks to the US. Because there's nothing meaningful about "14" or David Tennant or Russell Davies.
Here's the thing... the creators say race-changing historical figures like this is to make little kids feel included. But what a rude awakening they'll have when they learn the truth. Why not create new diverse characters if that's what they want, have them have their own story. All it does is confuse kids all the more. It's going to be a mess.
Also seems (a) confusing for kids, how can racism be a problem when the UK has been diverse since Roman times or something; and (b) insulting, why not find out and adapt unique stories from different heritages and cultures?
I stopped watching Dr. Who 10 years ago. I didn’t realize it was THIS BAD 💀 but that’s to be expected when you hire progressive activists instead of writers to tell a story
Nah you gotta at least see Capaldis greatest hits as 12th, in a sense his finale got a really good series closer. Like it could have been a good ending to the show. Peep it, the show died after that lmaoo
I had my fill when Malcolm Tucker took over the role and the woke BS kicked into high gear. I was starting to get sick of it when the woke mind virus kept seeping in during David Tenant's FIRST run, but it wasn't overwhelming.
@@brandonbaka1375 Capaldi's run was not good; Clara got really annoying towards the end, the 12th doctor is really annoying with his "remembering to be nice" trash, and the black female lesbian with a dude's name is basically the beginning of intersectional who
There’s one good takeaway from all this: The intensifying agitprop means the enemy is desperate and that victory is at hand. After our victory, we can burn all the propaganda material and assume stewardship of our favorite characters.
Even if the war-grade philosophy or model worked here, what would this "attack" MEAN? Who would they possibly bring on board to their side with this nonsense?
*Coming soon, the made-for-Netflix documentary of British PM Rishi Sunak, "History is a whitewash," starring Brie Larson as Prime Minister Rishi Sunak.*
or simply he dont know but is wise enought to use the almighty biggest library of the human civilization's knowledge to fact check his stuff aka google N wikipedia and other sources.
@@the_bane_of_all_anti_furry Wikipedia says he studied Modern History at Oxford (which is why I said he really knows the subject). plus he's got good memory to hold these facts, so he made a comedy character & got rich/rewarded for it. Anyways, back to the irony stuff (see top)...
I totally agree with your comments. To think that the 50th anniversary of Doctor Who and the trailer to that programme was lauded world wide. Doctor Who ended with Peter Capaldi.
It's also silly because most men know when another man is good looking. That doesn't make them gay it just makes them a realist. To be fair, Bernard Cribbens could only do those lines and couldn't continue. He did have further lines written but he couldn't do them.
5:00 Think this was because Wilf died (as you said), not sure how important of a role he would have played had he been alive to shoot more scenes but at least we saw him for one last time. Wilf was the best part of the 3 episodes tbh.
Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute.
From what I've seen, even Tennant just looks exasperated and done. Apparently he's pretty into the nonsense himself, but it looks like even he realizes it's going to be what kills the show again.
Was never a Doctor Who fan but I remember Tom Baker being the Doctor during my childhood years from reading Starlog magazines in the late 1970's and early 80's.
they majorly missed an opportunity to have a call-back to a Capaldi episode and have the ship be the ship from world enough and time since the world enough and time ship was about to enter a black hole and likely then enter the void, matching the setting of the wild blue yonder ship and both ships look almost identical. the plot could have been something the doctor and donna have to destroy a ship full of dormant evolved cybermen before it escapes the void to get to earth while they're being hunted by a hyper advanced cyberman. Would've been a great way of actually tying the story into the rest of the dr who universe and a good inclusion of a classic villain for the anniversary
Actually, the reason why the Doctor was a couple days in the future when he returned at the end of the episode, is because I actually don’t know why. I mean, we learn in the giggle that the Toymaker is back, and that the world is shitting itself more than usual, but it’s never said or shown that the Toymaker is the one fucking with the Tardis. A possible counter argument of the Tardis taking the Doctor where he needs to go not where he want to go isn’t valid either, considering that it would make more sense for the Tardis to take the Doctor to the time before the situation got really bad.
I quit Doctor Who around 11 years ago during the Matt Smith era, I've tried to get back into it but never made it far, this has sealed it, can't believe the stuff I've been hearing about this show now, I thought people were exaggerating but it's literally just a propaganda series at this point, it's basically a parody of itself.
Your comment about Wilf’s inclusion being so nothing, I think that might have been all they were able to shoot with poor Cribbins before he passed away.
At least you highlighted NOTICEABLY that the Intellectual dishonesty and trolling of the License Payer goes ALL THE WAY back to the Moffat + Piers Wenger axis and notably Capaldi's complicity in reading crap out for money(!) - which is surprising as someone who also writes and directs would maybe have have shown the same integrity that Eccleston did with the Production Team (which is why I started to go off nu Who very gradually at that point). As for the bit at the end - mixed feelings as the Cribbins thing couldn't be helped: he OFFICIALLY was supposed to do another scene and was a little infirm when they were doing what they could at the time; it's also established lore that the TARDIS is unreliable so the fact that it couldn't go back to a fixed point isn't a contradiction with with older material?
To be fair to the Wilfred cameo, I think all of the reminiscing and catching up would have been done in the Giggle. Bernard Cribbins’ death prevented that, so they were stuck with the choice of whether to remove Wilfred from the specials entirely or give the fans the moment of seeing him again. Personally I’m glad they did the second option. The lack of a proper catch up is one of the few flaws that BBC and Disney are faultless for.
We know from RTD's treatment of Davros that mere juxtaposition of two issues, such as (1) being evil and (2) being in a wheelchair, is enough for a Message. Thus, making Newton (1) too stupid to know the Latin _gravitas_ and (2) Indian is also his Message.
Doctor who's White Jesus criticism is also silly for a man considered to be reflective and dynamic minded. Do these people know every ethnic region paint their dieties to their regionals peoples and it wasn't only Europeans?
1:10 it's probably just because that actor was in another show written by davies and is probably a good friend of his, plus he's a comedy actor and this scene is meant to be comedic
Now I'll devil's advocate with Horrible Histories by saying it's not quite blackwashing history but rather shining a spotlight on historical figures that not many people may have heard about.
The 50th anniversary was a good ending to the entire franchise, and if you are a fan of only the classical era of Doctor Who then the Seventh Doctor and Ace "walking into the sunset" moment implying that the adventure continues right after the show is no longer on screen is also the perfect ending to the franchise. The Doctor had a good run, let him rest.
>The 50th anniversary was a good ending to the entire franchise It really wasn't. Apart from the instant introduction of a whole new Doctor out of nowhere... I remember the scene where Tennant and Smith are bouncing around like stupid idiots who ought to be bounced into space asking what the "round things" in the walls are for and the other says he doesn't know. And Tennant, who claims he was a fan of the Fifth Doctor's era and married the daughter of the guy who played the Fifth Doctor, where we saw very clearly what the "round things" were for, allowed these stupid lines to be spoken on screen. And I just want Moffat and Tennant and Smith and Davies and the show ended. It doesn't matter that I've been watching and reading since 1978, there's nothing good left here. Now it's nothing but lies and horrors.
Stop acting like the TV show is the only aspect of the franchise that matters. The audio adventures are still going strong and are typically better than the TV show, even when it was good. Support a GOOD aspect of the franchise for a change.
@@thegaurdianchild5571 Everything that happens in the show branches out into the other media. Other than a bare passing reference, the other media don't impact on the show (there's one exception: when Steven Moffat stole from the books of the 90s and 2000s for, say, the "Human Nature" episode). The way the show goes - currently, into hell - affects how everything else goes.
...Which is why the most recent audios are still receiving overwhelming praise from fans who've given up on the show. Honestly, have you listened to the most recent releases of the Eleventh Doctor Chronicles? Or Christopher Eccelston's Ninth Doctor adventures(Yes, it's really him)? Some of them are better than any of their actual tv episodes. The audios have a much larger variety of writers, most of whom are actual fans who care about the franchise instead of the corporates who run the tv show. Also, wtf do you mean Human Nature/Family of Blood is the only example!? Dalek was an adaptation of a popular audio story, The Haunting of Villa Diodati was a loose adaptation of TWO popular audio stories, THE STAR BEAST WAS MARKETED AS AN ADAPTATION OF A POPULAR COMIC STORY FOR CRYING OUT LOUD! Anyway, the audios will likely continue on even if the show gets cancelled because that's what happened before and it worked out.
It is rebel flesh, without support cast, interaction with the enviroment, stake, end moral of the story. Some ugly wierd shit happens in a less than convincing CG enviroment untill the whole crap is get blown up. No fighting. No conflict. No clever plan. It just 2 copy trying to scare the protagonists for knowledge without hurting them. It was as scary and atmoshperic as a Garfield Halloween special. It was almost mid tier to me, except the mavity "joke" made it a little bit worse. Btw, Newton dint invent the word gravity
In all the clips I've seen of Tennants new episodes, his performance sucks. How can he lose his acting ability? Or more likely the script made it impossible to be good
About the only time they ever got the race swap thing right, is when they had Tony Curran _correctly_ portray Vincent van Gogh as Glaswegian, contrary to what the history books would have you believe, the legendary artist wasn't Dutch at all & in fact grew up on port Glasgow in Scotland.
Wait! Old Who. Tom Baker era. Pirate Planet. The Doctor claims he hide in the tree and dropped apples on Newton's head and then went and shared dinner with him. The Doctor has ALREADY MET NEWTON! Fk this show.
1:35 It wasn't quite that moment that killed the show for me but that entire season with Capaldi was like that non stop. It was so high off it's own gas. There's a reason me and other people weren't willing to give Whitaker a chance and the bad writing is my reason way before I ever heard her name. The show was just dead. Imagine the doctor being a racist.
Hey i know your whole thing is hating on stuff for views, which is fine, but you do know the actor died right? He filmed a grand total of one scene. It's not like they really had a choice there.
Oh for gods sake is this really the best you can come up with? It sucked because Isaac Newton was played by a black actor and the doctor had a throwaway line about a man being hot? Come on now give us some real meat as to why the episode was bad other than the woke elements, and btw the 14th doctor and the 10th doctor are two different doctors so if the 14th is a bit gay it’s cos he’s a different character
3:18 While he's certainly more into the ladies when portrayed by Tennant, Christopher Eccleston's Doctor definitely swung both ways at the very least. I think he mentions it once in passing but he also accepts a kiss goodbye from Captain Jack Harkness (also bi) in his finale. Easy to forget since it was written in 2005 and wasn't pandering nonsense like modern day "representation" but the Doctor at least _was_ bi-sexual in the initial revival series from 2005.
Was that kiss from Jack supposed to turn The Doctor on, or was he just not bothered by it because his version of the Doctor saw himself as above sexual desire? I don’t think accepting the kiss means that he’s bi. I took it as The Doctor knows this guy is a slut and shrugged it off as an odd custom that Jack practices.
i hate that modern media is changing history now. replacing every white historical figure with a different race. Had Issac newton been any other race they wouldn't have race swapped. Even in broadway they made King Richard the third a black trans woman. and on Netflix they made Celopatra black. its so frustrating and offensive to geology and history.
Oddly enpugh, English Isaac Newton turns Indian, but John Logie Baird in the Giggle was still white Scottish. His assistant, however, was race-swapped. This is RTD's racist white Celtic agenda.
I think the bait and switch reality we are trapped into must be destroyed ! I truly hate this brining back characters that have a beautiful history of heart and being used to make us bleed out and be filled by the gray liquids of a dead modernity ! It Is Time For A Full Scale Rebellion.
I’m indifferent about the race swap but RTD is a total hypocrite for many reasons, he doesn’t believe straight actors should play gay characters and “cis” actors definitely shouldn’t be playing trans
Except he made Tenant Doctor's bicurious, so he can claim rectroactive representation credit. Like JK Rowling for Dumbledore. And Yasmin Finney who played Rose isn't non bineary. But consisntency dosen't matter to this people. Just the fact that is in it, and to provoke men. Witch somehow fine, bc there are more bad men than women so when they are doing the thing that claimed to be shitty is fine or something. I donno.
Whenever they race swap people, how come it’s always with a black or Indian actor? How come it’s never someone who’s Asian? Seems a little racist to me….🤣
They didn't even get his personality right, Newton was not a smiling gregarious type. He was a solemn, serious person who could be actually quite ruthless.
If you want to experience that portrayal of Issac Newton in a Doctor Who story, just listen to Circular Time: Summer.
@@thegaurdianchild5571 Absolutely no one insinuated there aren't other options. Stop acting like a needlessly confrontational teenager on the Internet.
@@reharl4953 What the fuck? Dude, calm down.
@@reharl4953 Stop acting like a twat, there wad no need for your outburst, grow up child
@@AJadedLizard - I'm gonna assume that this wasn't an overreaction out of nowhere, and that the "(edited)" next to the original comment means that person said something uncouth.
Just because the actor that played Wilfred is dead doesn't mean they won't replace him with an elderly Samoan.
Woman, elderly Samoan woman. 😅
@@Raggedy-Man I think you misunderstand, people are complaining that they didn't get more of him, they love wilfred, they do not like the writing choices, that's what people are complaining about
@@Valen-mh9fh Elderly Samoan trans, apparently they're somehow both and better and neither or something.
@@AstralLaVistait was a joke, like they'll bring the character back as a handicapped black tranz male.
Funny asf. 😂😂
To quote the 2nd Doctor "People spend all their time making nice things and then other people come along and break them!“.
Sydney Newman wanted the show to be historically accurate to teach kids interesting ways to learn about the past. So, there. Shat all over his legacy as well.
...He also didn't want any "bug-eyed monsters" in the show, so they kind of already disregarded his legacy since the beginning...
@@thegaurdianchild5571 But he was still alive when he accepted the "bug eyed monster". The rule was to keep historicals as accurate as possible.
As an Indian it makes me cringe. Sir Issac newton is one the greatest minds of humanity. Instead of focusing on colour and gender identity of the scientist, look at his contributions.
the saddest thing is that they will never look up at an actually indian or X non white european caucasian whose did some cultural or tecnological accomplishment and the fact they simply race swap other historical figure like isaac newton is kinda of racist.
@@the_bane_of_all_anti_furryIt is ironically funny and insultingly patronising at the same time.
@@the_bane_of_all_anti_furrythere actually is a lot of Indian people that did some great things
@@the_bane_of_all_anti_furrywhen your so against racism you decide to go the other route
newton was just a freem@s0n, like buzz aldrin
I WANT A BLACK ANNE FRANK!
... nah, black Hitler would be more apt.
It's going to be Lizzo
She’d have to hide in the back of the attic
Played by Westley Snipes.
Black Girl Magic!
They sure will not cast the Austrian Painter anything but white.
So true!
Herr was also an elite level (on a daily basis) trench runner/message carrier for like 18 months straight on the Western Front.. Unbelievably hardcore.
They're currently casting for a white Robert Mugabe.
Herr is German for Mister@@Veldtian1
They might, but it'd have to be an alternate history version, where a black woman goes back, takes his place, and turns out to be the greatest and most benevolent ruler who ever lived (all while clapping back at every white man who appears on screen, of course)
They keep wasting elderly actors.
First we lost Carrie Fisher without reuniting the OG trio
now we lost wilfrid before he could say anything meaningful to 14.
Good for Bernard Cribbins. The man who was also the "First male companion" when they tried to take Doctor Who and the Daleks to the US.
Because there's nothing meaningful about "14" or David Tennant or Russell Davies.
@@troffle
William Russel was the first male companion.
Cribbins was in the Peter Cushing Who flicks too. That's a double waste right there.
At this point, any disappointment you feel when watching modern TV is your own fault. It's been absolute bollocks for at least a decade now.
Yup. Paradigm Shift started in 2013, after the Mayan apocalypse date. Muh gaymergate was in 2014 🤔
Watch better shows
@@smd1876 No. I stopped watching TV once I was smart enough to recognise all the programming & social engineering. I guess you're not there yet.
@@josephsalmonte4995 I haven't watched TV in years, dear.
I said watch better shows...
For awhile there it was ambiguous bollocks...
Newton looks... Different 👀
Why does he look like Obama with flowing locks?! BBC earnin that acronym.
No shit Sherlock
Here's the thing... the creators say race-changing historical figures like this is to make little kids feel included. But what a rude awakening they'll have when they learn the truth. Why not create new diverse characters if that's what they want, have them have their own story. All it does is confuse kids all the more. It's going to be a mess.
cause they want to speed up the genocide
Or not. UK is a White country. These other people are owed nothing. They can create their own media if they want representation.
Also seems (a) confusing for kids, how can racism be a problem when the UK has been diverse since Roman times or something; and (b) insulting, why not find out and adapt unique stories from different heritages and cultures?
It's a humiliation ritual. It's meant to shit on British culture and rob them of any identity
They can’t. They’re pure evil, and as Tolkien once said ( correct me if I get the quote wrong): “Evil cannot create, only destroy.”
If you want a Newton lookalike, cast Brian May.
I thought that too when I saw that portrait 😂
I stopped watching Dr. Who 10 years ago. I didn’t realize it was THIS BAD 💀 but that’s to be expected when you hire progressive activists instead of writers to tell a story
GREAT 👌 @REAPER DOCTOR WHO REVIEW 👌 IS HOT 🔥 GARBAGE 🗑
Nah you gotta at least see Capaldis greatest hits as 12th, in a sense his finale got a really good series closer. Like it could have been a good ending to the show. Peep it, the show died after that lmaoo
I had my fill when Malcolm Tucker took over the role and the woke BS kicked into high gear. I was starting to get sick of it when the woke mind virus kept seeping in during David Tenant's FIRST run, but it wasn't overwhelming.
@@brandonbaka1375 Capaldi's run was not good; Clara got really annoying towards the end, the 12th doctor is really annoying with his "remembering to be nice" trash, and the black female lesbian with a dude's name is basically the beginning of intersectional who
@@timewarpdrive77 that's why I said greatest hits. Don't act like Heaven Sent wasn't one of Who's finest
There’s one good takeaway from all this: The intensifying agitprop means the enemy is desperate and that victory is at hand. After our victory, we can burn all the propaganda material and assume stewardship of our favorite characters.
No. If somehow we get rid of all this crap, we need to have records of it so we never forget how truly awful it all was and never do it again.
@@DanimationYTagreed
Even if the war-grade philosophy or model worked here, what would this "attack" MEAN? Who would they possibly bring on board to their side with this nonsense?
??
*Coming soon, the made-for-Netflix documentary of British PM Rishi Sunak, "History is a whitewash," starring Brie Larson as Prime Minister Rishi Sunak.*
Coloured characters don't get switched out, yet...
They would never allow a straight white woman to play an Indian man. You would need to get a black transgender disabled vegan lesbian.
Reaper is legit my favorite new content creator of 2023 and overall right up there with Mauler, Drinker, Nerdrotic & the rest of the cronies.
Check out despot of atrim and dvd vandoomcock
21st century black face
BBC: "Let's f*ck history up!"
I find it ironic that the funny British man knows more about history than all the writers of doctor Who
Wait till you see Al Murray the Pub Landlord... He's also a funny British man who KNOWS history...
or simply he dont know but is wise enought to use the almighty biggest library of the human civilization's knowledge to fact check his stuff aka google N wikipedia and other sources.
@@the_bane_of_all_anti_furry Wikipedia says he studied Modern History at Oxford (which is why I said he really knows the subject). plus he's got good memory to hold these facts, so he made a comedy character & got rich/rewarded for it.
Anyways, back to the irony stuff (see top)...
The BBC know history they just don't care
Knowing and caring are a bit different. I'd be willing to bet several of them know, but none of them care.
Reaper doesn't hold back!!! 💪💪💪👌😆
the people fighting in the episode was just the representation of the reaction to these 😂😂
I totally agree with your comments. To think that the 50th anniversary of Doctor Who and the trailer to that programme was lauded world wide. Doctor Who ended with Peter Capaldi.
Just listen to the audios. They're still good.
It's also silly because most men know when another man is good looking. That doesn't make them gay it just makes them a realist. To be fair, Bernard Cribbens could only do those lines and couldn't continue. He did have further lines written but he couldn't do them.
' You don't getting punched, you getting stabbed in London '😂😂😂😂😂
I’m not even a Dr Who fan but this shit is just sad
I'm pretty sure this doctor takes the magic screwdriver from behind
Sir Isaac Newton looks like Weird Al.
Weee wuzz physicians and saars
😂😂😂
N shiet boi
Cumskins race swap characters & other cumskins cry like a bitch about it. Go save your kids from grooming gangs & jack off to your sisters OF.
"The writers were practically water-boarding you with it."
Aaaand that's a like within the first minute of the video. Reaper is funny as fuck.
5:00 Think this was because Wilf died (as you said), not sure how important of a role he would have played had he been alive to shoot more scenes but at least we saw him for one last time.
Wilf was the best part of the 3 episodes tbh.
2:22
This make me laugh more than it should have. Never change lol
Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute.
From what I've seen, even Tennant just looks exasperated and done. Apparently he's pretty into the nonsense himself, but it looks like even he realizes it's going to be what kills the show again.
Can't wait for their new episode where they meet the English-Arab poet and play-write of Hamlet, Macbeth and others, Al-Shaykh Zubair!
The painting of Newton looks like Jeremy Vine.
Not sure which specific british action Reaper has but it suits obscenities really well
Same as mine, Liverpool Scouse accent 😊
Dr Who is so bloody awful now. In my childhood Tom Bakers Dr Who was unmissable TV
Was never a Doctor Who fan but I remember Tom Baker being the Doctor during my childhood years from reading Starlog magazines in the late 1970's and early 80's.
Just listen to the audios. They're still good.
Never seen Who, but I see Reaper ever sense I found him,-) 👍
they majorly missed an opportunity to have a call-back to a Capaldi episode and have the ship be the ship from world enough and time since the world enough and time ship was about to enter a black hole and likely then enter the void, matching the setting of the wild blue yonder ship and both ships look almost identical. the plot could have been something the doctor and donna have to destroy a ship full of dormant evolved cybermen before it escapes the void to get to earth while they're being hunted by a hyper advanced cyberman. Would've been a great way of actually tying the story into the rest of the dr who universe and a good inclusion of a classic villain for the anniversary
Actually, the reason why the Doctor was a couple days in the future when he returned at the end of the episode, is because I actually don’t know why.
I mean, we learn in the giggle that the Toymaker is back, and that the world is shitting itself more than usual, but it’s never said or shown that the Toymaker is the one fucking with the Tardis.
A possible counter argument of the Tardis taking the Doctor where he needs to go not where he want to go isn’t valid either, considering that it would make more sense for the Tardis to take the Doctor to the time before the situation got really bad.
Yeah way to further reinforce the stereotypes of Indians as mathematical geniuses/prodigy
They wanted Wilfred, like they wasted all the potential of Dr. Who
Thats a great point, we should boycott the episode where Agatha Christie fights a damn wasp
I quit Doctor Who around 11 years ago during the Matt Smith era, I've tried to get back into it but never made it far, this has sealed it, can't believe the stuff I've been hearing about this show now, I thought people were exaggerating but it's literally just a propaganda series at this point, it's basically a parody of itself.
Your comment about Wilf’s inclusion being so nothing, I think that might have been all they were able to shoot with poor Cribbins before he passed away.
At least you highlighted NOTICEABLY that the Intellectual dishonesty and trolling of the License Payer goes ALL THE WAY back to the Moffat + Piers Wenger axis and notably Capaldi's complicity in reading crap out for money(!) - which is surprising as someone who also writes and directs would maybe have have shown the same integrity that Eccleston did with the Production Team (which is why I started to go off nu Who very gradually at that point). As for the bit at the end - mixed feelings as the Cribbins thing couldn't be helped: he OFFICIALLY was supposed to do another scene and was a little infirm when they were doing what they could at the time; it's also established lore that the TARDIS is unreliable so the fact that it couldn't go back to a fixed point isn't a contradiction with with older material?
Doctor Who, once a fun adventure now an offensive lecture. Good work BBC!
Just listen to the audios. They're still good.
Reaper nails it again.
Am surprised the tree didn’t collapse into its own footprint, due to structural failure caused by fire.
7:20 woulda loved it if randy old Isaac Newton had been gobbling a male chicken under that tree
PUTACHICKINITANDMAKEHERGAY
Lmfao they actually race-swapped Isaac Newton hoooooly
To be fair to the Wilfred cameo, I think all of the reminiscing and catching up would have been done in the Giggle. Bernard Cribbins’ death prevented that, so they were stuck with the choice of whether to remove Wilfred from the specials entirely or give the fans the moment of seeing him again. Personally I’m glad they did the second option. The lack of a proper catch up is one of the few flaws that BBC and Disney are faultless for.
We know from RTD's treatment of Davros that mere juxtaposition of two issues, such as (1) being evil and (2) being in a wheelchair, is enough for a Message.
Thus, making Newton (1) too stupid to know the Latin _gravitas_ and (2) Indian is also his Message.
Yep
Doctor who's White Jesus criticism is also silly for a man considered to be reflective and dynamic minded.
Do these people know every ethnic region paint their dieties to their regionals peoples and it wasn't only Europeans?
It's only a "bad" thing with white people do it.
Double standards.
2:19 Right, well I completely lost my shit there. 😆
You forgot Christopher Ecclestons kiss with John Barrowman
1:10 it's probably just because that actor was in another show written by davies and is probably a good friend of his, plus he's a comedy actor and this scene is meant to be comedic
Now I'll devil's advocate with Horrible Histories by saying it's not quite blackwashing history but rather shining a spotlight on historical figures that not many people may have heard about.
The 50th anniversary was a good ending to the entire franchise, and if you are a fan of only the classical era of Doctor Who then the Seventh Doctor and Ace "walking into the sunset" moment implying that the adventure continues right after the show is no longer on screen is also the perfect ending to the franchise.
The Doctor had a good run, let him rest.
>The 50th anniversary was a good ending to the entire franchise
It really wasn't. Apart from the instant introduction of a whole new Doctor out of nowhere... I remember the scene where Tennant and Smith are bouncing around like stupid idiots who ought to be bounced into space asking what the "round things" in the walls are for and the other says he doesn't know.
And Tennant, who claims he was a fan of the Fifth Doctor's era and married the daughter of the guy who played the Fifth Doctor, where we saw very clearly what the "round things" were for, allowed these stupid lines to be spoken on screen.
And I just want Moffat and Tennant and Smith and Davies and the show ended. It doesn't matter that I've been watching and reading since 1978, there's nothing good left here. Now it's nothing but lies and horrors.
@@troffle Well, then like I said the original classic Doctor Who ending is a perfect ending.
Stop acting like the TV show is the only aspect of the franchise that matters. The audio adventures are still going strong and are typically better than the TV show, even when it was good. Support a GOOD aspect of the franchise for a change.
@@thegaurdianchild5571 Everything that happens in the show branches out into the other media. Other than a bare passing reference, the other media don't impact on the show (there's one exception: when Steven Moffat stole from the books of the 90s and 2000s for, say, the "Human Nature" episode).
The way the show goes - currently, into hell - affects how everything else goes.
...Which is why the most recent audios are still receiving overwhelming praise from fans who've given up on the show. Honestly, have you listened to the most recent releases of the Eleventh Doctor Chronicles? Or Christopher Eccelston's Ninth Doctor adventures(Yes, it's really him)? Some of them are better than any of their actual tv episodes. The audios have a much larger variety of writers, most of whom are actual fans who care about the franchise instead of the corporates who run the tv show.
Also, wtf do you mean Human Nature/Family of Blood is the only example!? Dalek was an adaptation of a popular audio story, The Haunting of Villa Diodati was a loose adaptation of TWO popular audio stories, THE STAR BEAST WAS MARKETED AS AN ADAPTATION OF A POPULAR COMIC STORY FOR CRYING OUT LOUD! Anyway, the audios will likely continue on even if the show gets cancelled because that's what happened before and it worked out.
It is rebel flesh, without support cast, interaction with the enviroment, stake, end moral of the story.
Some ugly wierd shit happens in a less than convincing CG enviroment untill the whole crap is get blown up.
No fighting. No conflict. No clever plan.
It just 2 copy trying to scare the protagonists for knowledge without hurting them.
It was as scary and atmoshperic as a Garfield Halloween special.
It was almost mid tier to me, except the mavity "joke" made it a little bit worse.
Btw, Newton dint invent the word gravity
When real-Donna caught and beat up fake-Donna all I could think was "WhEn WhHhHoMeN dO iT ToXiC MaScUlInItY iS aOk!"
In all the clips I've seen of Tennants new episodes, his performance sucks. How can he lose his acting ability? Or more likely the script made it impossible to be good
The dr.who loves bbc now.
Why do they never blackwash the guys from WW2??🤔
About the only time they ever got the race swap thing right, is when they had Tony Curran _correctly_ portray Vincent van Gogh as Glaswegian, contrary to what the history books would have you believe, the legendary artist wasn't Dutch at all & in fact grew up on port Glasgow in Scotland.
The worst thing is, I'm so gullible I actually had to Google VVG to make sure that wasn't true.
Less cannon than Pakistani dalik
Kill your television is a great neds atomic dustbin song I took to heart
I LOVE YOU REAPER! And I am NOT gay!!
Do a review on Turning Red.
Also you sound more tired tired than usual.
Wilf was meant to be in the third one. That's when Cribbins died.
Wait! Old Who. Tom Baker era. Pirate Planet. The Doctor claims he hide in the tree and dropped apples on Newton's head and then went and shared dinner with him.
The Doctor has ALREADY MET NEWTON!
Fk this show.
Yup, and he explained gravity to him over dinner.
And people wonder why we gatekeep leftists out of warhammer 40k so hard. This, this is why.
The brown Issac Newton got me
I'm glad I've never been a big Doctor Who fan and that I dropped out after season 9 before it went super woke
1:35 It wasn't quite that moment that killed the show for me but that entire season with Capaldi was like that non stop. It was so high off it's own gas. There's a reason me and other people weren't willing to give Whitaker a chance and the bad writing is my reason way before I ever heard her name. The show was just dead. Imagine the doctor being a racist.
NEW FAVOURITE CHANNEL
Hey i know your whole thing is hating on stuff for views, which is fine, but you do know the actor died right? He filmed a grand total of one scene. It's not like they really had a choice there.
i mean it's the year 2024 and the fact that the bbc hasn't rebranded itself is proof enough that they love their acronym name thoroughly 🤣
Reaper is Awsome haha 3:02 , 3:13 call BBC out for the BS
Seriously? Sir Isaac Newton???
There was a more accurate portrayal of Newton in the Epic Rap Battle he was in- where he was played by Weird Al...
Oh for gods sake is this really the best you can come up with? It sucked because Isaac Newton was played by a black actor and the doctor had a throwaway line about a man being hot? Come on now give us some real meat as to why the episode was bad other than the woke elements, and btw the 14th doctor and the 10th doctor are two different doctors so if the 14th is a bit gay it’s cos he’s a different character
No, he's the same character; The Doctor. That's the character.
Dr Who ripped my face off and sold it for drinking money. But very cheap.
2:35 that greenscreen
Isaac Newton! :O You cant let them Reaper! This a war of annihilation! Please! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
3:18 While he's certainly more into the ladies when portrayed by Tennant, Christopher Eccleston's Doctor definitely swung both ways at the very least. I think he mentions it once in passing but he also accepts a kiss goodbye from Captain Jack Harkness (also bi) in his finale. Easy to forget since it was written in 2005 and wasn't pandering nonsense like modern day "representation" but the Doctor at least _was_ bi-sexual in the initial revival series from 2005.
Was that kiss from Jack supposed to turn The Doctor on, or was he just not bothered by it because his version of the Doctor saw himself as above sexual desire? I don’t think accepting the kiss means that he’s bi. I took it as The Doctor knows this guy is a slut and shrugged it off as an odd custom that Jack practices.
Hilarious! Thanks for the laughs.
It's Dr. Who .... but that woman has as much airtime as he does.
the bbc made the doctor like bbc
Reaper is the UFC Baddy of RUclips, Sheeesshhhh
i hate that modern media is changing history now. replacing every white historical figure with a different race. Had Issac newton been any other race they wouldn't have race swapped. Even in broadway they made King Richard the third a black trans woman. and on Netflix they made Celopatra black. its so frustrating and offensive to geology and history.
Oddly enpugh, English Isaac Newton turns Indian, but John Logie Baird in the Giggle was still white Scottish. His assistant, however, was race-swapped. This is RTD's racist white Celtic agenda.
‘Doctor who wild blue yonder’ is a confusing sentence 😄
Doctor who is soooooo bad it’s almost unbelievable. It’s hell to watch.
04:58 he died so he couldn't film the rest of his scenes...
I think the bait and switch reality we are trapped into must be destroyed !
I truly hate this brining back characters that have a beautiful history of heart and being used to make us bleed out and be filled by the gray liquids of a dead modernity !
It Is Time For A Full Scale Rebellion.
I don't care what they tell you in school, Isaac Newton was black.
Sherman: I have a hard time believing that!
Mr. Peabody: THANK YOU!
Should've used that ole badass Clarence Bodiker alot fuckin more l😁✌️🍻🤣
I’m indifferent about the race swap but RTD is a total hypocrite for many reasons, he doesn’t believe straight actors should play gay characters and “cis” actors definitely shouldn’t be playing trans
Except he made Tenant Doctor's bicurious, so he can claim rectroactive representation credit. Like JK Rowling for Dumbledore.
And Yasmin Finney who played Rose isn't non bineary.
But consisntency dosen't matter to this people.
Just the fact that is in it, and to provoke men. Witch somehow fine, bc there are more bad men than women so when they are doing the thing that claimed to be shitty is fine or something. I donno.
@@katokianimation Well, no one is non-binary, that isn't a thing, so no problem there.
Whenever they race swap people, how come it’s always with a black or Indian actor? How come it’s never someone who’s Asian? Seems a little racist to me….🤣
Indians are Asians, super intelligent murican.
Hi Reaper
AY UP REAPER