I absolutely love your method. I have made it a bit more simple after I didn’t notice any difference in just mixing the flour and water overnight vs. mixing all the ingredients and putting them in the fridge overnight. I take it out in the morning and let it rest for 1 to 2 hours, then start my stretch and folds every 30 minutes until I get a nice window pane. Then I do the bulk ferment, and the rest is as usual. My starter lives in the fridge, and I only feed it when I get low. This makes an amazing 100 whole grain loaf. I mill my own wheat. Delicious. Thank you!
This is such a fantastic 100% wholewheat sourdough loaf. I have watched quite a few RUclips videos about 100% wholewheat loaves and I think yours has the best rise and best crumb. Well done!
I've been searching for the best whole wheat sourdough on youtube for a long time now and this is BY FAR the winner on a whole new scale. Amazing, you have really truly perfected it. We're lucky you've shared it with us! Thank you so much :)
Very impressed! You definitely know what you are doing. Btw, love the music, and appreciate the silence! One can teach without all the nonsense words! I saved this video, and will share with others. Thank you
After experimenting with different whole wheat sourdough recipes, I finally found the perfect one! I followed your instructions exactly, without any modifications, and it rose beautifully. Thank you for sharing such a fantastic recipe-it's truly the best! This will be my go-to recipe from now on.
Best whole wheat sourdough recipe. I wonder why RUclips didn't show me earlier. This will be my go to recipe now. A lot of support for your channel. It was a perfect video.
Love this recipe. it yields hands down the best bread I’ve ever tasted. I tweaked a few things for my kitchen but this is a great resource. it is a more challenging recipe as handling 90 percent hydration dough is more difficult but I think it’s worth it
I recently started baking with fresh milled wheat and have had a tough time getting any height from my loaves. Following your recipe has made a huge difference to the openness of the crumb! Thanks so much for sharing!
This is the best video I've seen on WW sourdough. I've been baking yeast and sourdough since 1970 but was wanting to perfect the techniques. Thank you. 💗
Luckily for me your video came up and I watched it. Excellent video! I am excited to make this bread. I am very familiar with high hydration and sourdough breads. Again I have to tell you what a fantastic video this is. I subscribed to see what else you do! To those just starting out with high hydration doughs, this is an excellent video for you to follow. Don’t be discouraged, try and try again. The quality of the bread is far above anything you can buy unless you live near an artisan bread shop. This bread is well worth your time and dedication.
Amazing technique, amazing bread Very impressive, the best 100% WW sourdough I've ever seen. Would you mind sharing the brand of whole wheat flour you use? I dont think mine could handle 90% hydration.
@@Pin-kitchenwhat brand of flour do you use? Do you have any secrets to get your starter so strong. I feel my issue with 100% whole wheat has something to do with my starter not being quite strong enough to handle it for some reason. It’s still a younger starter.
Your bread is amazing. Thank you for the great video. I tried my first batch and it came out ok, but didnt seem to rise in the oven like yours. I had the bubbles which made me happy but definitely smaller. Do you know what could be the problem please? Could it be shaping / not having a good banneton which leads it to be flatter?
Hello. Thank you for the comments. In this case It can be many reasons. I'm glad that you've tried to lower hydration. You did the right thing because every type of flour has its own hydration. A good shaping could make the difference too. And I don't think having a good banneton is necessary. I've done it in bowls and baskets, and they were just as nice. Also it could be the proofing. Over proofed dough doesn't rise much when baking and has many smaller holes. Thank you for trying my recipe. 😊
@@jesusislord6955 I will be preparing my first try tonight as recipe calls for, then I will go from there. Thank you for the tip. 🙏🏻 King of kings and Lord of lords.🙏🏻
This is very challenging to do for someone with little experience. I am on my second attempt at this recipe. First one was OK, I would give it 6/10 in that it yielded nice tasting and edible bread but it was not close to the grade produced here. There are a lot of nuances such as flour type, shaping and folding , proofing and bulk fermenting for the right amount of time and baking with steam as well as temperature. Not for the faint of heart.
Hello, yes you're right. Specially with wholewheat, so tricky to work with. Need a lot of practice. I would say it's NOT bad for the first to be 6/10 😊 My first first attempt was failed. I hope your second one was even better 😊
I think I only managed 6.10 as I am already a half competent baker. 2nd attempt was better but still lacked oven spring. I suspect its in the shaping...will retry with boul shape as I am much better at that shape as opposed to batards. . @@Pin-kitchen
You'll want to use a whole wheat flour that is high in protein, ie. Gluten. If not you won't be able to get a good rise from it, even with proper technique.
Lovely Whole Wheat SD video and probably the best one I have watched so far. Also a lovely-looking loaf when cut. Why do you autolyse it overnight before adding the starter? I am still really new to baking breads and Sourdoughs. This video is a must make. Thank you.
Hi, thank you so much for your wonderful videos. I wanted to ask if it is possible to replace the sourdough with dry yeast? If so, how many grams of yeast should I add to the dough?
awesome info..want to know if we autolyse overnight for 38-39 degree celcius in India..is it fine?..Plus what kind of whole wheat flour is used here, can you elaborate on this..
My problem is that I don't have such a large benchtop to stretch it out like that @7:00! I will definitely try this next time I have the time to do this over the weekend. Been searching for a 100% wholewheat sourdough recipe for a long time, and most of them are at best 50% wholewheat mixed with white flour. Hey Pin, I think main point is to give the initial dough plenty of time to hydrate and soften the wholewheat. Can I skip the stretching out part and do more rounds of stretch and fold or coil folds?
gorgeous bread and presentation! Thank you for sharing this! BTW, any suggestions for getting a more sour taste, besides adding more starter and/or longer fermentation?
Hello, thank you for your comment. Here are a few more ways for extra tangy taste, - Keep your bread basic, flour water and sat. Don't use honey. - Let the starter starve a bit. You'll see your hungry starter develops some hooch. Keep that hooch. Stir it in and feed it. - Use less starter. - And sour salt (citric acid). No more than a teaspoon!
Great video! I had a few quick questions. Are the flour and water used to feed the starter overnight (i.e. The 1:2:2 ratio) accounted for in the recipe amounts, or is this extra? Also, is the starter amount noted in the recipe the amount of starter prior to feeding it overnight or after the addition of the 1:2:2 ratio? Thanks! 🙏
Question -- If you started the working process at 8 am in the morning, adding the hours would still land you at 1 pm in the afternoon when shaping is done. So what happened between then and proofing overnight in the refrigerator?
I am trying to make whole wheat sourdough but the flavor is acid. I will try to do this recipe to see if the flavor is different. What do you think is the reason for that flavor?
what a wonderful bread! how much protein contain your flour? i used 10 and 13 protein whole wheat but it's not rising that much. both of them was same. i think low gluten content, isn't it ?
I am wondering if it would work if the stretch and folds were spaced out longer apart? I often have 60 to 90 minute work calls during the day so doing the stretch and fold every 30 minutes would be challenging schedule wise. So if I did the stretch and folds 60 to 90 minutes apart do you thing that would work still as opposed to 30 minutes apart? Thanks, Bill
Can i use this recipe for sandwich bread? If not, are there any tips for making this recipe into a sandwich bread? I once tried making sourdough sandwich bread with 100% whole wheat flour, but the result was too sour and didn't rise because the gluten wasn't developed enough 😢
I have to ask a very important question, please answer. I like your recipes very much. Do you keep the bread at room temperature after you take it out of the refrigerator? Or do you shape it and put it directly in the oven. I kept it at room temperature for 3 hours after I took it out of the refrigerator. While shaping with a razor blade, my bread spread a lot and was out of shape.
Hello. I'm sorry to hear. It's tricky to work with whole grain. And every type of flour has its own hydration. I'd recommend making an experiment flour you're using with different hydration to see which is best for it. You can do around 50g of flour or more as you prefer with different hydration, for example like 78%, 80%, 85%.... Also different temperature, environment... make the difference..
My dough is currently on its first rest after salt and honey. It seems a lot more tough than yours but maybe mine is still pretty cold. Fingers crossed
My whole wheat fluor container 17% proteïne. Should I use a different amour of water? And my starter is 1:5:5. Can I use that? Or is that going to influence the rising tome?
Can you try this method with freshly milled flour, please. As I tried it, it wasn’t as high. As the perfect loaf book, the author mentions , aging the freshly milled four for a month before using.
I wouldn’t listen to that advice if you want the health benefits of freshly milled flour. The flour will start to oxidise as soon as it’s milled-you only have about 3 days before the natural oils in the wheat berry will start to spoil. Defeats the purpose of freshly milled if you leave it for a month IMO 🤷🏼♀️
I have tried whole wheat once and i was just terrified with the whole mess i created coz of how sticky it got even the next day...not sure if it was the proportions or my kneading technique...but somehow i lost the confidence...watched multiple videos after that and read a lot about it...but haven't had the guts to go back to it...i hv the starter in my refrigerator... But looking at your video...i feel i shud give it one more try...but will do it in smaller proportion this time... Can i do it in a smaller proportion say 300gm whole wheat flour...if yes...in what proportions do i use the other ingredients?
@nitingons Hello there. It's a challenge to work with wholewheat. It needs a lot of practice. I'm sure you will get there, slowly... Try this recipe: 300g wholewheat flour ( recommend 13%-14% protein) 60g wholewheat starter 270g water( try 250g first, then add slowly if needed more) 6g salt. If you're using a machine to mix, make sure to don't over mix. The dough will be sticky at first, It'll get smoother and elastic after a few coil folds. Thank you for the comment.
Maybe she wants to be the only one to be able to make this kind of wonderful bread. Keeping some of her secrets… I don’t know if it’s possible for anybody else because she uses an incredibly expensive flour from Italy. I’m surprised that anyone else trying this with regular flour is having success. This flour is $80 for 11 pounds. Which is quadruple the price that I pay for my already expensive organic whole wheat flour. Maybe you could share with us your secret about how you afford and where you get your special flour.
I have been baking 100% whole wheat sourdough bread for months but my bread doesn’t have beautiful oven spring and open crumbs like yours 😢. Are you using fresh milled whole wheat flour or store brought?
Hello there, I'm sorry that you're experiencing this. I'm using store bought flour. But I have some feedback from people that are using this recipe with fresh milled flour and they have similar results. However, it's really tricky to work with wholewheat. It requires some experience and knowledge. It may take many bakes to get a good one. Please don't give up. Also the clock is not important. You need to learn to read and feel the dough. It may sound complicated but trust me, You'll get there slowly. 💪🏻 It took me a while to finally be able to make beautiful breads. 😊
Thanks Pin. I’m using King Arthur 100% whole wheat flour. It said to have 13.8% gluten proteins which I don’t believe it does because my loafs would come out flat and dense. I recently added Vital Wheat Gluten to my recipe to include the protein to 13-14%. That made a huge difference where my doughs now have excellent windowpane, good rise, open crumbs, and crust. However, the breads still don’t have a good ovenspring no mater how tight I rolled and tucked the dough.
Yes you can. Please note that every batch of flour has its own hydration preference. With einkorn, I'd recommend to lower hydration just a bit. Maybe try 75% first. Then check and see if you're happy with the hydration, otherwise you can add a little more in the next bake. And cut back a bit the bulk rise to 40%-50%. Sometimes you need several bakes to get to your desire 😊
@@bobbyq4me You're welcome. I also forgot to mention the coil fold step. Do just stretch and fold instead. And long atoulyse is not so necessary too. You can do anywhere between 30min-2h( at room temperature).
Best whole wheat sourdough bread in you tube by far
Agreed
Looks great ❤
I absolutely love your method. I have made it a bit more simple after I didn’t notice any difference in just mixing the flour and water overnight vs. mixing all the ingredients and putting them in the fridge overnight. I take it out in the morning and let it rest for 1 to 2 hours, then start my stretch and folds every 30 minutes until I get a nice window pane. Then I do the bulk ferment, and the rest is as usual. My starter lives in the fridge, and I only feed it when I get low. This makes an amazing 100 whole grain loaf. I mill my own wheat. Delicious. Thank you!
This is such a fantastic 100% wholewheat sourdough loaf. I have watched quite a few RUclips videos about 100% wholewheat loaves and I think yours has the best rise and best crumb. Well done!
Thank you so much 🙏🏻😊
I can see why sourdough bread baking was popular during the pandemic.
😂😂
It's like child rearing while you go about your day
I've been searching for the best whole wheat sourdough on youtube for a long time now and this is BY FAR the winner on a whole new scale. Amazing, you have really truly perfected it. We're lucky you've shared it with us! Thank you so much :)
Agree 👍
This is insanely good. You're a talented baker.
Very impressed! You definitely know what you are doing. Btw, love the music, and appreciate the silence! One can teach without all the nonsense words! I saved this video, and will share with others. Thank you
After experimenting with different whole wheat sourdough recipes, I finally found the perfect one! I followed your instructions exactly, without any modifications, and it rose beautifully. Thank you for sharing such a fantastic recipe-it's truly the best! This will be my go-to recipe from now on.
Best whole wheat sourdough recipe. I wonder why RUclips didn't show me earlier. This will be my go to recipe now. A lot of support for your channel. It was a perfect video.
Love this recipe. it yields hands down the best bread I’ve ever tasted. I tweaked a few things for my kitchen but this is a great resource. it is a more challenging recipe as handling 90 percent hydration dough is more difficult but I think it’s worth it
Very informative and practical about showing the gluten structure
The lamination was key. Great work!!
Beautiful whole wheat loaf, excellent crumb!
Thank you ❤
Hello
I tried your protocol and it worked so so well. Thank you so much for sharing. Lots of good wishes from an Indian 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Hello, I'm so happy to hear that this recipe works for you. Thank you so much for your feedback 🙏🏼😊
Thank you for your feedback.. I was a bit nervous to attempt but feel more confident to risk it😆
How'd you make it...... mine always turns out flattish
@@PoojaG_PG namaskaram just follow the recipie and first bake it as loaf
@@minakshirinki9998 meaning use a loaf pan?
Thank you. The recipe was very helpful. My sourdough whole wheat bread has smaller holes. I will try increasing hydration.
I recently started baking with fresh milled wheat and have had a tough time getting any height from my loaves. Following your recipe has made a huge difference to the openness of the crumb! Thanks so much for sharing!
Beautiful bread. I bake with Sourdough starter for 10 1/2 years. Such good bread and so much healthier than the one from the store.
Yes, much healthier, much better. 😊😊
This is the best video I've seen on WW sourdough. I've been baking yeast and sourdough since 1970 but was wanting to perfect the techniques. Thank you. 💗
That looks AMAZING! I'm going to try this. Thank you for sharing and for the excellent step by step video.
Thank you very much 🙏🏼
This is SUCH a great recipe.
Amazing bread, thank you! Best of luck to you and your channel! 🌺
Those are some soft and giggly doughs! Beautiful outcome.
Amazing result.
As others have said - the best on RUclips.
Complex to make but very much worth the effort I’d say.
Thank you for sharing your skills.
Did you make this?
Luckily for me your video came up and I watched it. Excellent video! I am excited to make this bread. I am very familiar with high hydration and sourdough breads. Again I have to tell you what a fantastic video this is. I subscribed to see what else you do! To those just starting out with high hydration doughs, this is an excellent video for you to follow. Don’t be discouraged, try and try again. The quality of the bread is far above anything you can buy unless you live near an artisan bread shop. This bread is well worth your time and dedication.
Thank you for your kind comment. I appreciate it ❤️
VERY NICE , CONSIDERING THE HYDRATION YOU ARE USING , YOU HANDLE IT WELL.
Awesome! you have great understanding of how bread works 👍
Thank you very much 🙏🏼
Beautiful 100% whole wheat sourdough from Cambodia. Wonderful!
Perfectyl !!! Let us know can emmer flour be used in your recipe?
Wow! Thats some seriously beautiful bread
Beautiful!! ❤
Well done. 90 percent hydration…. Can’t wait to try.
Amazing technique, amazing bread Very impressive, the best 100% WW sourdough I've ever seen. Would you mind sharing the brand of whole wheat flour you use? I dont think mine could handle 90% hydration.
In another comment she wrote Caputo Integrale. In the US a more available flour that can take 90% hydration and more is Bob's Red Mill whole wheat.
This is the best wholewheat I’ve ever seen - but was it fresh ground or store bought ?
It's store bought flour. Thank you for the comment 😊
@@Pin-kitchenwhat brand of flour do you use? Do you have any secrets to get your starter so strong. I feel my issue with 100% whole wheat has something to do with my starter not being quite strong enough to handle it for some reason. It’s still a younger starter.
Your bread is amazing. Thank you for the great video. I tried my first batch and it came out ok, but didnt seem to rise in the oven like yours. I had the bubbles which made me happy but definitely smaller. Do you know what could be the problem please? Could it be shaping / not having a good banneton which leads it to be flatter?
Hi, I’m curious about this question too. I hope she replies.
@@justdi3347I done the hydration test as per this video and reduced mine to 85% and seems better. Will see how it goes
Hello. Thank you for the comments. In this case It can be many reasons. I'm glad that you've tried to lower hydration. You did the right thing because every type of flour has its own hydration. A good shaping could make the difference too. And I don't think having a good banneton is necessary. I've done it in bowls and baskets, and they were just as nice. Also it could be the proofing. Over proofed dough doesn't rise much when baking and has many smaller holes. Thank you for trying my recipe. 😊
@@jesusislord6955 I will be preparing my first try tonight as recipe calls for, then I will go from there. Thank you for the tip. 🙏🏻 King of kings and Lord of lords.🙏🏻
@@justdi3347 A good idea is to cut off a tiny bit of dough off and proof it separately and when it has roughly Doubled then u know its ready 😊
Amazing result !
This is very challenging to do for someone with little experience. I am on my second attempt at this recipe. First one was OK, I would give it 6/10 in that it yielded nice tasting and edible bread but it was not close to the grade produced here. There are a lot of nuances such as flour type, shaping and folding , proofing and bulk fermenting for the right amount of time and baking with steam as well as temperature. Not for the faint of heart.
Hello, yes you're right. Specially with wholewheat, so tricky to work with. Need a lot of practice. I would say it's NOT bad for the first to be 6/10 😊 My first first attempt was failed. I hope your second one was even better 😊
I think I only managed 6.10 as I am already a half competent baker. 2nd attempt was better but still lacked oven spring. I suspect its in the shaping...will retry with boul shape as I am much better at that shape as opposed to batards. . @@Pin-kitchen
Add the part about handling the dough itself. I doubt it's gonna be as easy as it looks 😂😂 her handling was so smooth and soft and quite neat
@richardwindsornomura
I have found that hard red wheat is a great grain to start with.
I like to use 1/3rd Kamut and the rest hard red wheat. ❤
You'll want to use a whole wheat flour that is high in protein, ie. Gluten. If not you won't be able to get a good rise from it, even with proper technique.
This video is excellent!
Thank you very much! ☺
This has been my go to recipe
wow amazing 😮😮😮
Lovely Whole Wheat SD video and probably the best one I have watched so far. Also a lovely-looking loaf when cut. Why do you autolyse it overnight before adding the starter? I am still really new to baking breads and Sourdoughs. This video is a must make. Thank you.
Hello, I found this cold long autolyse helps the wholewheat dough absorb water better. Thank you so much for your kind comment.
What a beautiful presentation. You are to be congratulated.
Thank you so much 🙏🏼
Perfect Crumb.
Thank you 🙏🏼
Thank you so much for sharing in great detail your "secret" recipe! As the comments that precede mine, you are appreciated.
Thank you very much 🙏🏼
فعلا افضل طريقه - شكرا جزيلا من مصر
Thank you very much 🙏🏻
Thanks, thit is exactly what I was looking for!
I'm glad to meet your needs 🥰
Beautiful loaves. Thank you for sharing.
Thank you 😊
Hi, thank you so much for your wonderful videos. I wanted to ask if it is possible to replace the sourdough with dry yeast? If so, how many grams of yeast should I add to the dough?
Amazing, but how much did you use of starter before feeding?
Waiting for your answer.
Thanks 😊 🙏🙏🙏
She has the recipe posted with all that info
thanks excellent video , I'll tray it soon. what is the banneton size you are using?
Looks great. If I want to mix 25% white flour, should I add the white flour the night before or together with the starter? Thanks
Hello, thank you for the comment. You can add in the night before. Or you can do the autolyse in the morning at room temperature for a few hours.
awesome info..want to know if we autolyse overnight for 38-39 degree celcius in India..is it fine?..Plus what kind of whole wheat flour is used here, can you elaborate on this..
Can this be done with fresh milled flour or other varieties like khorasan
My problem is that I don't have such a large benchtop to stretch it out like that @7:00! I will definitely try this next time I have the time to do this over the weekend. Been searching for a 100% wholewheat sourdough recipe for a long time, and most of them are at best 50% wholewheat mixed with white flour.
Hey Pin, I think main point is to give the initial dough plenty of time to hydrate and soften the wholewheat. Can I skip the stretching out part and do more rounds of stretch and fold or coil folds?
@@Zimzimhk Hello. Yes, you can skip the lamination part. And do more folds if the dough needs more. Thanks for the comment. ☺️
@@Pin-kitchen Thanks for responding! I'll certainly give this a try soon.
Hi can you explain about multi grain flour? Which grain did u use?
Thank you for sharing, great work. How about using stand mixer to knead/develop the dough? I'll be happy to hear your experience and guidance on that.
Hello, it will give the same results. It just need a little attention while using a stand mixer, you don't want to over mixing.
gorgeous bread and presentation! Thank you for sharing this!
BTW, any suggestions for getting a more sour taste, besides adding more starter and/or longer fermentation?
Hello, thank you for your comment. Here are a few more ways for extra tangy taste,
- Keep your bread basic, flour water and sat. Don't use honey.
- Let the starter starve a bit. You'll see your hungry starter develops some hooch. Keep that hooch. Stir it in and feed it.
- Use less starter.
- And sour salt (citric acid). No more than a teaspoon!
use a higher hydration starter. dryer gives more yeast,... wetter more acid producing bacteria which is what makes it sour
Beautiful video
Thank you very much 😊
I would love to try this. Is there a full printed recipe? I'm a novice so need the details 🙂
Hello, please click this PDF link
drive.google.com/file/d/1auLpvJfgIeF-67tDcd5v3XSNfIkrlS51/view?usp=drive_link
Thank you very much. I have done a perfect loaf without any changes to your recipe.
I'm so glad to hear. Thank you so much 🙏🏼
Did you bake at the oven temps? I normally bake 425F, but don't lower 300F. Thank you.
@@br4653you should not be afraid to bake at a higher temperature, I bake at 480 F first 25 min and after 450F, you get a better oven spring
Do you have a video of making starter as i am trying bake my first sourdough
Thanks for the video! Do I need to have a sourdough starter made with whole wheat? Or can I use my starter that is made with all purpose and rye?
All purpose starter is fine
Great video! I had a few quick questions. Are the flour and water used to feed the starter overnight (i.e. The 1:2:2 ratio) accounted for in the recipe amounts, or is this extra? Also, is the starter amount noted in the recipe the amount of starter prior to feeding it overnight or after the addition of the 1:2:2 ratio? Thanks! 🙏
No as that is not part of the recipe. 2nd question is after feeding
@@e30Birdy Thanks!
Question --
If you started the working process at 8 am in the morning, adding the hours would still land you at 1 pm in the afternoon when shaping is done. So what happened between then and proofing overnight in the refrigerator?
Any help! Can I just half the recipe to make 1 loaf
You can halve it, double it etc makes no difference
Thanks for your recipe. My family loves this bread 🎉🎉
What type of whole wheat flour are you using? Also what multigrain flour are you using?
I am trying to make whole wheat sourdough but the flavor is acid. I will try to do this recipe to see if the flavor is different. What do you think is the reason for that flavor?
What did you use for your multi grain flour?
Which kind of whole wheat flour do you use?
Can I use a mixture of whole wheat, rye and bread flour starter?
what a wonderful bread! how much protein contain your flour? i used 10 and 13 protein whole wheat but it's not rising that much. both of them was same. i think low gluten content, isn't it ?
Hello. Thank you so much. Mine is 13%. Or it could be the starter. A good and healthy starter makes a great loaf too.
@@Pin-kitchen thank you. I'm using my starter when double in size. It's doubling in 6-8 hours 1-5-5 ratio
@@Pin-kitchen I'm not familiar with multigrain flour, is it whole grain? Which brand do you use?
I am wondering if it would work if the stretch and folds were spaced out longer apart? I often have 60 to 90 minute work calls during the day so doing the stretch and fold every 30 minutes would be challenging schedule wise. So if I did the stretch and folds 60 to 90 minutes apart do you thing that would work still as opposed to 30 minutes apart? Thanks, Bill
Is this fresh milled or store bought whole wheat?
Can i use this recipe for sandwich bread? If not, are there any tips for making this recipe into a sandwich bread?
I once tried making sourdough sandwich bread with 100% whole wheat flour, but the result was too sour and didn't rise because the gluten wasn't developed enough 😢
What brand of flour did you use for this?
wonderful
I have to ask a very important question, please answer. I like your recipes very much. Do you keep the bread at room temperature after you take it out of the refrigerator? Or do you shape it and put it directly in the oven. I kept it at room temperature for 3 hours after I took it out of the refrigerator. While shaping with a razor blade, my bread spread a lot and was out of shape.
Hello. Yes, from the fridge and straight to the oven. It will not hold its shape if you rest the dough at room temperature.
Absolutely beautiful! Perfect teaching video. Thank you!!!
@@Pin-kitchen Curious what temperature your fridge is? Because you got quite a bit of rise while your loaf was refrigerated.
Amazing and look so easy but i still can’t get this perfection ... in the last stage everything is very liquid
Hello. I'm sorry to hear. It's tricky to work with whole grain. And every type of flour has its own hydration. I'd recommend making an experiment flour you're using with different hydration to see which is best for it. You can do around 50g of flour or more as you prefer with different hydration, for example like 78%, 80%, 85%.... Also different temperature, environment... make the difference..
Could you share what brand of whole wheat flour you use?
Hello, I use an Italian brand called "Caputo Integrale", naturally contains germ and bran. 13% protein.
Beautiful bread! Please, what brand is your flour?
Hello, I use an Italian brand name Caputo Integrale.
Please show how you make starter
Hello. Please click on the link for a video on how I make starter. Thank you 😊
ruclips.net/video/F459rLf8ZSU/видео.htmlsi=Y5DBqdBt8GtmkWg-
My dough is currently on its first rest after salt and honey. It seems a lot more tough than yours but maybe mine is still pretty cold. Fingers crossed
How did this come out for you?
@@br4653 no rise. I was having a hard time with my starter
Hi can you do a video on whole wheat bread with instant yeast
Hello there. Yes I will!
@@Pin-kitchen Can I get the video?
Great job. Thank you.
Thank you 🙏🏼
My whole wheat fluor container 17% proteïne. Should I use a different amour of water? And my starter is 1:5:5. Can I use that? Or is that going to influence the rising tome?
I’d like to know also!
How much starter grams you use for feeding ?
Hello. It's 35g starter + 70g flour + 70g water.
Can you try this method with freshly milled flour, please. As I tried it, it wasn’t as high. As the perfect loaf book, the author mentions , aging the freshly milled four for a month before using.
I will. I will look for some freshly milled flour and make some experiments!
I wouldn’t listen to that advice if you want the health benefits of freshly milled flour. The flour will start to oxidise as soon as it’s milled-you only have about 3 days before the natural oils in the wheat berry will start to spoil. Defeats the purpose of freshly milled if you leave it for a month IMO 🤷🏼♀️
When do you add walnut and cranberry ? Thank you.
Hello, you can add in when laminating the dough or when do the coil folds.
@@Pin-kitchen Thank you very much
Do u use 100% Wholewheat flour
I have tried whole wheat once and i was just terrified with the whole mess i created coz of how sticky it got even the next day...not sure if it was the proportions or my kneading technique...but somehow i lost the confidence...watched multiple videos after that and read a lot about it...but haven't had the guts to go back to it...i hv the starter in my refrigerator...
But looking at your video...i feel i shud give it one more try...but will do it in smaller proportion this time...
Can i do it in a smaller proportion say 300gm whole wheat flour...if yes...in what proportions do i use the other ingredients?
@nitingons Hello there. It's a challenge to work with wholewheat. It needs a lot of practice. I'm sure you will get there, slowly... Try this recipe:
300g wholewheat flour ( recommend 13%-14% protein)
60g wholewheat starter
270g water( try 250g first, then add slowly if needed more)
6g salt.
If you're using a machine to mix, make sure to don't over mix. The dough will be sticky at first, It'll get smoother and elastic after a few coil folds. Thank you for the comment.
@@Pin-kitchenThanks a lot for this...
Will give it a try😊
Maybe she wants to be the only one to be able to make this kind of wonderful bread. Keeping some of her secrets… I don’t know if it’s possible for anybody else because she uses an incredibly expensive flour from Italy. I’m surprised that anyone else trying this with regular flour is having success. This flour is $80 for 11 pounds. Which is quadruple the price that I pay for my already expensive organic whole wheat flour.
Maybe you could share with us your secret about how you afford and where you get your special flour.
Wooooow👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻
Can you tell us the protein content of the flour that you used?
Hello. It's 13% protein. 😊
How does this recipe work using whole spelt four?
Can you please give the exact measurements for the starter?
Hello. I did 35g of starter + 70g of flour + 70g of water.
Thank you!@@Pin-kitchen My loaves didn't rise as much as yours, but they are delicious!
Did you spray water on the counter or was it oil? During lamination.
Hello, It's water.
And after that too, while you were handling the dough?
Yes. Just water.
Alrighty!! Thanks a ton for responding ❤
I have been baking 100% whole wheat sourdough bread for months but my bread doesn’t have beautiful oven spring and open crumbs like yours 😢. Are you using fresh milled whole wheat flour or store brought?
Hello there, I'm sorry that you're experiencing this. I'm using store bought flour. But I have some feedback from people that are using this recipe with fresh milled flour and they have similar results. However, it's really tricky to work with wholewheat. It requires some experience and knowledge. It may take many bakes to get a good one. Please don't give up. Also the clock is not important. You need to learn to read and feel the dough. It may sound complicated but trust me, You'll get there slowly. 💪🏻 It took me a while to finally be able to make beautiful breads. 😊
Your starter may be the issue ? Do you think it is strong enough ?
@@julieeemg The issue is not with my starter as all of my loafs have good rise.
Hello. Following the comments... Maybe it's the shaping.
Thanks Pin. I’m using King Arthur 100% whole wheat flour. It said to have 13.8% gluten proteins which I don’t believe it does because my loafs would come out flat and dense. I recently added Vital Wheat Gluten to my recipe to include the protein to 13-14%. That made a huge
difference where my doughs now have excellent windowpane, good rise, open crumbs, and crust. However, the breads still don’t have a good ovenspring no mater how tight I rolled and tucked the dough.
Can I used fresh mill whole wheat einkorn berries?
Yes you can. Please note that every batch of flour has its own hydration preference. With einkorn, I'd recommend to lower hydration just a bit. Maybe try 75% first. Then check and see if you're happy with the hydration, otherwise you can add a little more in the next bake. And cut back a bit the bulk rise to 40%-50%. Sometimes you need several bakes to get to your desire 😊
@@Pin-kitchen thank you so much.
@@bobbyq4me You're welcome. I also forgot to mention the coil fold step. Do just stretch and fold instead. And long atoulyse is not so necessary too. You can do anywhere between 30min-2h( at room temperature).
@@Pin-kitchen thank you, so helpful. ❤️
Can I use white flour starter to bake this whole wheat sourdough?
Yes, you can. It'll be good! It just won't be 100% ww anymore.
내가 본 최고의 스프링 통밀빵
As opposed to 8am at night??