Pretty good though i have 4 reccomendations for improvement and a question - 1. Even keel should be when the bridge roof is at the water or starting to go under rather than at the other side. With a starboard list after even keel. 2. Based on my research, the lights failed in sections. Forward - 2;07:50 AM, Middle - During plunge (maybe in even keel), and Aft - as break happened, for me, when the decks start to crack. 3. 4th funnel should break off in descent as hardly anyone said it broke off when water reached it. 4. Forward tower looks abit too dislodged if it breaks off in descent. For me, it breaks off on surface 5 - 10 seconds after the stern settles when stern lists to starboard before port. Question: What is the port list before even keel out of interest? Great animation though, keep up te great work. Sorry for any offence, no offence meant. Just wanted to give a few recommendations for improvement. I also agree with the stern going under at 2:22 AM.
For me, If forward tower were to break off on the surface, it will end up in the Hypocenter, Towers were very heavy, it drops like a rock, so it's safe to assume it got flunged by the stern during the descent. The forward tower whether it broke off at the surface or at the descent it's still up to debate, but I choose the descent separation one
@@ship_builder 2:20 is an approximation. Watches show between 2:20 and 2:30. Survivors also testified Titanic remaining afloat for a while before sinking. (We know it broke at 2:17 as that was the time Californian saw (What was presumably) Titanic's lights go out) Some said it remained afloat for full five minutes. It might not be conventional, having Titanic sink after 2.20, but it does account for survivors who testified sinking shortly after 2.20. And also explain why some said it was horizontal for a bit and other saying it was vertical for a bit.
I myself believe that the list may have been part of the sinking, but a tilt to starboard seems more realistic to me than a tilt to port, since the ship struck the iceberg on its starboard side.
@@user-gu3es5ql3m The ship listed to the starboard first, when the water reaches the name plate, it listed to the port, until the bridge flooded where it got in an even keel and lost it's port list
Pretty good though i have 4 reccomendations for improvement and a question -
1. Even keel should be when the bridge roof is at the water or starting to go under rather than at the other side. With a starboard list after even keel.
2. Based on my research, the lights failed in sections. Forward - 2;07:50 AM, Middle - During plunge (maybe in even keel), and Aft - as break happened, for me, when the decks start to crack.
3. 4th funnel should break off in descent as hardly anyone said it broke off when water reached it.
4. Forward tower looks abit too dislodged if it breaks off in descent. For me, it breaks off on surface 5 - 10 seconds after the stern settles when stern lists to starboard before port.
Question: What is the port list before even keel out of interest?
Great animation though, keep up te great work. Sorry for any offence, no offence meant. Just wanted to give a few recommendations for improvement. I also agree with the stern going under at 2:22 AM.
For me, If forward tower were to break off on the surface, it will end up in the Hypocenter, Towers were very heavy, it drops like a rock, so it's safe to assume it got flunged by the stern during the descent. The forward tower whether it broke off at the surface or at the descent it's still up to debate, but I choose the descent separation one
@@Umi953 I'd agree with that, although I have the forward tower dislodge when the bow does in my theory.
the stern went down at 2:20 because in one of the interviews buddy had a watch and he was wearing it and it broke because it froze.
@@ship_builder 2:20 is an approximation. Watches show between 2:20 and 2:30. Survivors also testified Titanic remaining afloat for a while before sinking. (We know it broke at 2:17 as that was the time Californian saw (What was presumably) Titanic's lights go out) Some said it remained afloat for full five minutes. It might not be conventional, having Titanic sink after 2.20, but it does account for survivors who testified sinking shortly after 2.20. And also explain why some said it was horizontal for a bit and other saying it was vertical for a bit.
Nice, has a few inaccuracies but it's great
This animation is so good!! :)
I dont mean to criticize it but it looks very similar to honor and glory 2024 real time sinking
Yeah 😅, I've changed my theory a bit, the water will now reach the base of the third funnel, almost at the aft tower
All of the Titanic and maritime related stuff will be posted in this second channel youtube.com/@blackstarlinebyumi?si=CGjiaBZpjGHdRe04
Excelente simulation!
Song?
Songe D'Automne
@@Umi953 ty
this is uh....
why the list to port tho, sinking without a list looks more realistic to me
dawg this is a theory
I myself believe that the list may have been part of the sinking, but a tilt to starboard seems more realistic to me than a tilt to port, since the ship struck the iceberg on its starboard side.
@@user-gu3es5ql3m I agree
@@user-gu3es5ql3m The ship listed to the starboard first, when the water reaches the name plate, it listed to the port, until the bridge flooded where it got in an even keel and lost it's port list