While at a family dinner in the epilogue, John asks Uncle when does he plan on leaving the ranch and Uncle tells them they’ll have to bury him there :/
If you get drunk and greet uncle he'll say "wow Marston now you're even more drunk than me" or something like that, but if you try to greet Abigail while drunk, she gets mad and ignores you. Nice detail tbh.
It's a video game. Unfortunately they don't have a difficulty setting option where you die after being shot a few times. But since you can't change the difficulty they want as many people to be able to play as possible. I wish there was a way to change it
In chapter 1, at the start of a mission, Lenny says that "when you (Micah) fall, there'll be a party" And at the end of the game, when Micah dies, the Marston wedding takes place
There’s one where Ross says to Jack, “Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can.” And that’s how the 1st game ended. Jack killed Ross while he was fishing.
The phrase "That's the way it is" is constantly repeated throughout the story, even until the song. The amount of small details and foreshadowing is insane.
In RDR1 when John has Dutch in gunpoint on the ledge of that mountain, Dutch says "hello John, we need to stop meeting like this." He's referring to when him and Dutch where on Mount Hagen with Micah in RDR2.
@@thefallingsun9542 it makes sense from a Canon standpoint but in the context of rdr1 coming out its kind of impossible because rdr2 hadn't been written yet
I just like to think Jack only became a gunslinger to avenge his father and Arthur Morgan. Then he became a writer himself, maybe even mentored by Mary Beth. So if anything, Arthur did save the Marstons in a way, not John nor Abigail though.
@@justinwright1745 About the only way that this idea isn't feasible is if Jack had a child with a J for their first initial, or married someone with that initial who took his last name. There's several different ways that whole thing could have gone
not really..it was a camp/fort between two parts of 1 mountain and there were stairs that lead up to a cave so his hideout wasnt really a cave the cave is just where he ran too
8:57 You can see Dutch’s sadness and regret in this scene. He feels genuine sadness towards Arthur, and he realizes what he has done to his sons and that Hosea was right all along.
ｏｎｉｍｕ＄ｈａ No that is years later, and he just got there right before John. When he comes out of the building, John asks “What are you doing here Dutch?” and to to which Dutch replies “Same reason you’re here.” Dutch was probably going to kill Micah at some point but he couldn’t with all of Micah’s companions. When John took care of them all Dutch was able to.
him saying same as you implies he was also looking for mica. but I don’t think he regrets his decisions but I do believe he feels he sided with the wrong person.
@@yuri_cobaia he doesn't team up with micah again in the dialogue dutch says "Same as you, I suppose." that when john asks him what he is doing then dutch shoot micah
Don't matter how you played Arthur's final 6 or so months of his life. They're all going to hell just based off of their own admissions of the life they've lead prior.
During camp dialouge Lenny and Hosea talk about how they eant to die and I think it’s Hosea says he wants to be burried with friends. Also they ask Arthur how he wants to die to which he responds (parafrasing) «oh, i don’t care about that. Just face me towards the sunset so i can think about all the good times that we had.»
Rdr2 needs a dlc where we play as uncle where did he go after Arthur’s death before meeting John and where he live and who he lived with and when he’s in trouble he tells the lawman he has lumbago and tells strangers that he has lumbago and play him as an outlaw but with lumbago
@@arthurmorgan6733 either way I can kinda understand Ross, he's fighting for a new frontier - but with Micah I have to respect Peter for bringing life to him.
@@Gamfluent no he doesn't, but I heard somewhere a while ago that if you go there as John and you've completed the game 100%, John says something. I'm not sure what he says
I just noticed in Chapter One Micah says that when he falls he wants no fuss and Lenny responds by saying that when he falls there's gonna be a party. This foreshadows John and Abigail's wedding party after John kills Micah.
He may be Human trash but you gotta admit, he's a great gunslinger. But too dependant on his weapons, as evidenced by Arthur and Micahs' Scuffle on the mountain.
The Womping Wampa I mean he clearly has a bond with those guns, afterall he slaughtered an entire town for them. But you’re right, in a fist brawl he couldn’t even “kill a dying man”.... except in low honor.
Jordan Dennis well he “couldn’t kill a dying man” except maybe that chest and backstab in the worst ending. Micah gets BTFO’d every fight except low honor and in both situations he needs a weapon too kill. You’re totally right.
he has a fast reaction speed but his accuracy is shit, remember in american venom when he missed a whole revolver of shots from no more than 8 feet from john
If u r running out during the jack party u tell uncle when jack is your age it will be the 20th century and then uncle says I'll outlive u all which is foreshadowing the 1st game he outlives almost everyone
Interestingly he was the first of the gang to start shooting during the ambush which means he most likely didn’t betray the gang till after Guama just like Milton said.
After completing the epilogue there is a random event at night by beechers hope where if you greet uncle. John will say that Charles and Sadie are leaving them but uncle will say that if johns burying him. He will have to bury him in beechers hope and he isn't leaving
i feel like the high honor ending where arthur looks at the sunrise is the canon ending. because in chapter 6 there are so many chances to rise your honor (charlotte, edith downes, hamish) and i've had more random honor encounters (may just be me). it would suit the story because arthur was trying to be a better man.
I remember playing the first game a while ago and seeing John marston die like that and I still have that game and play it that game was far a head of it’s time
Hopefully that all made sense my point being that someone snitching wasn’t what killed the gang simply the flow of time did. Because it’s easy to blame mica for all the gangs problems but most likely he didn’t betray them till he saw that it was over (so gauma). he didn’t rat the gang out before this because he still could still make money form them he’s selfish but not stupid.
I just realised that Micah's wretched soul is connected to fire: he sets Sadie's home ablaze at the very begining of the story and the low honor money ending takes place within a circle of fire, as if Micah and Arthur's souls were already condemned To an eternity of hell
Another unsettling, but rather interesting, one is in horseshoe overlook where they're threatening Kieran. I remember Bill saying something like 'he's gonna die, but he'll loose his balls first.' This foreshadows when Kieran is captured by Colm and they gouge his eyeballs out before killin him. Super subtle, yet nasty.
Everything that happened with Arthur at the end, the main bit that got me choked up was his voice. I got so used to hearing it strong that the weakness in it when he said "Dutch, he's a rat" shook me. Wheezing out the last words, trying to get his best friend who already betrayed him to see some sort of sense. That wheeze
Imagine if during the high honor scene of arthurs death he says something close to " thank you for being the father I never had Dutch, you and Hosea. "
Javier telling Hosea that John would look for him is probably my favourite, I played the second game first but I knew what the general story of the first was and when I heard Javier say that on my first playthrough I immediately knew it was a wink towards the first game
Anyone realize Micah instantly shot the sniper who killed Sean? Either it was Micah who ratted them out, or Micah actually cared for some of the the gang members.
When you complete the stranger mission, "No Good Deed" Dr Renaud gives Arthur the special remedy then throws in "It won't work on anything chronic". The layers of this game is amazing.
I’ve never seen anyone mention this. When Arthur and Dutch are on the cliff edge Dutch said “I got a plan, this is a good one”. The same thing he says in RDR1 to John when he’s on the cliff before he jumps. He also says “you’re fighting nature captain” and “you can’t fight gravity” then he jumps into the river. In RDR1 he says almost the same line “you can’t fight nature or gravity John”
After watching the scene where Arthur and Micah fall off the cliff again I’m startin to think that the fall really put Arthur through. You can hear how damn hard he’s trying to breathe. Obviously the man has been coughing up blood to this point because of the TB and he would’ve passed anyway, but I’m thinking that if he hadn’t taken that fall, he’d probably be able to find his way to John and say his proper goodbyes. I don’t know, it’s just a thought I had.
Also, I think a high honor Arthur might get to go to Heaven. After a stint in purgatory. He was a bad man for most of his life, but he did try to change and do the right thing at the end. I think God will respect that and give him a chance.
Sadly, I don't think so, all the lawmen who have a family he killed, I don't think if he helped John a murderer he would go to heaven. I respect Arthur and your opinion
@@IndoJordy in Red dead redemption there is a side mission were a man called Sam Odessa wants to go to California...well in GTA California does not exist,its called San Andreas. Here is your proof. Rockstar never said it because it was obvious. A lot of people still think the games are on the same universe. But....good video
6:18 what game is that? And when did Edith give leopold the debt? When I was playing I collected the debt by going to the downes house, not her coming to the camp.
I hate the low honour endings rockstar made it where if you are good you are rewarded with a good ending and low honour the make you realise that you did wrong and you shouldn't be rewarded
I think his loyalty was obvious from the being because he didn’t owe Dutch a thing if anything Dutch owed him he’s a self serving person that’s interested in his own survival over his fellow gang members he joined the gang because it was a tough one and he could make some money from it.
Never thought of the fact that Arthur has the exact same fate as Thomas Downes, both died after getting beaten up while being sick with tuberculosis
True
“It’s like poetry, they rhyme”
Not rly he died by getting shot in the head or stabbed multiple times really depends on your honor if their fates are the same
@@ceaselessdischarge1026 let's be honest though, that's the canon ending. No other makes sense
@@desmond931 well i agree the death on the top of the mountain is the true ending arthur doesn't deserve to be shot nor stabbed
While at a family dinner in the epilogue, John asks Uncle when does he plan on leaving the ranch and Uncle tells them they’ll have to bury him there :/
Thanks bud
Indo-J when Dutch dies is rdr1 he says “you can’t fight gravity” he also says that when Him and Arthur jumps off a cliff in chapter 6
he also sits at the place where he dies commonly at beechers hope :((
If you get drunk and greet uncle he'll say "wow Marston now you're even more drunk than me" or something like that, but if you try to greet Abigail while drunk, she gets mad and ignores you. Nice detail tbh.
Steve Jones last episode
Characters can get shot 1,000 times in game, but when a cut-scene comes they suddenly become mortal.
True
If only he drank some health cure
It's a video game. Unfortunately they don't have a difficulty setting option where you die after being shot a few times. But since you can't change the difficulty they want as many people to be able to play as possible. I wish there was a way to change it
Because your gameplay doesn't count.
Bold Counsel oh so you’d rather pay $100 for a game you can’t play if you die ONCE
In chapter 1, at the start of a mission, Lenny says that "when you (Micah) fall, there'll be a party"
And at the end of the game, when Micah dies, the Marston wedding takes place
True
That's a super reach
@@coreymyers3174 not really
you know something that still impresses me... john took over a hundred bullets and was still breathing... heck he was still standing....
It is, and rifle bullets 2
That's because John is a damn animal and not even a hail of gunfire was killing him until he was good and ready to die lmao
Like arthur said he is the luckiest man he ever met
@@Vicky-kk8hp I don't think that's luck...
@@reichtanglevictor1694 He survived everything that got thrown in his way
There’s one where Ross says to Jack,
“Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can.”
And that’s how the 1st game ended.
Jack killed Ross while he was fishing.
Duck hunting
I mean fishing is basically just hunting except with a fishing rod
Hunting 🦆🦆🦆🦆
he was duck hunting
@ ... nope... thats how RDR1 ended... the first one.
The phrase "That's the way it is" is constantly repeated throughout the story, even until the song. The amount of small details and foreshadowing is insane.
True that
Yeah man, I've never seen or heard so many foreshadowing moments in a game
"He's sick, he's dying, he's talking crazy!" two truths and a lie with Micah Bell.
Yup
Lel
“ *Yeah and your dead inside your dead* “
Always is a lie with Micah
But Micah didn’t really betray the gang though , Abigail did .
In RDR1 when John has Dutch in gunpoint on the ledge of that mountain, Dutch says "hello John, we need to stop meeting like this."
He's referring to when him and Dutch where on Mount Hagen with Micah in RDR2.
You think so ?
Indo-J almost definitely haha
@@IndoJordy yeah because snow....... gunpoint... on a mountain......
@@thefallingsun9542 it makes sense from a Canon standpoint but in the context of rdr1 coming out its kind of impossible because rdr2 hadn't been written yet
Evan Mendez-Perez I'm aware
I just like to think Jack only became a gunslinger to avenge his father and Arthur Morgan. Then he became a writer himself, maybe even mentored by Mary Beth.
So if anything, Arthur did save the Marstons in a way, not John nor Abigail though.
True
You saw the book.
@@justinwright1745 About the only way that this idea isn't feasible is if Jack had a child with a J for their first initial, or married someone with that initial who took his last name. There's several different ways that whole thing could have gone
He was only doing it for John Arthur already got avenged
(Gasps)Really?
2:16 and rdr 1 his hideout was literally a cave
True
Rafael Rios that’s why it’s foreshadowing
@@AJ-jd5je i was pointing put that that wasnt shown in the video
not really..it was a camp/fort between two parts of 1 mountain and there were stairs that lead up to a cave so his hideout wasnt really a cave the cave is just where he ran too
@@nysom3356 he sleeps and writes there also lots of books so yeah
8:57 You can see Dutch’s sadness and regret in this scene. He feels genuine sadness towards Arthur, and he realizes what he has done to his sons and that Hosea was right all along.
True
actually not, did you foget that he teams up with micah again
ｏｎｉｍｕ＄ｈａ No that is years later, and he just got there right before John. When he comes out of the building, John asks “What are you doing here Dutch?” and to to which Dutch replies “Same reason you’re here.” Dutch was probably going to kill Micah at some point but he couldn’t with all of Micah’s companions. When John took care of them all Dutch was able to.
him saying same as you implies he was also looking for mica. but I don’t think he regrets his decisions but I do believe he feels he sided with the wrong person.
@@yuri_cobaia he doesn't team up with micah again in the dialogue dutch says "Same as you, I suppose." that when john asks him what he is doing then dutch shoot micah
Pretty much whole game was foreshadowed
True
Uncle to Charles: "Someday, you'll warm up to me."
Charles and John go to rescue uncle as he's being burned to death
NOT THAT WARM NOT THAT WARM
Love how these are not just throw away references from the first game. After watching everything in RDR2 unfold their is so much meaning now to RDR1.
True that
These make me so sad. The things this game does to you.
True that Javier
@@ArthurMorganGaming Hello amigo
On hello there, Javier and Javier
@@IAmTheKnight26 Trelawny
I just wanted to stop by and say you really let yourself go in the previous game. I'm not insulting I was just informing you
6:18 who would have thought that book will be in Franklin's bookshelf after 100 years.
True 😂
99* at most
@@ClaytonTheCracker Actually, it depends on when Jack wrote it. If he wrote “Read Dead” at 35, then it wouldn’t be written till 1930.
@@suntzu6468 Well, Gta 5 and Red Dead Redemption aren't in the same universe. That book is just an easter egg.
Whenever John says you ain’t ever burying me I said are you sure about that then instantly I heard gun shots and knew that it was rdr1
Nice 👍
I'm going to be that guy but I don't think that was really for shadowing. But great video anyways
@@JakePridgeon It really was.
Passione Nera rdr2 is a prequel, so anything it hints towards has already occurred. Foreshadowing isn’t possible.
I’m in heaven with Lenny and John right now🤙🏼🎉
You are ?
Don't matter how you played Arthur's final 6 or so months of his life. They're all going to hell just based off of their own admissions of the life they've lead prior.
C. Morgan the gang only killed bad people who got in their way
you're with LENNNNNYYYYY?!?!?!
LENNYYYY?!!! WHERE ARE YA LENNY???!!
Not sure if this was covered but in Horseshoe Overlook, Lenny and Hosea sleep together, and also have graves next to eachother
Something like that is in part 2
Secret lovers? lol
Donovan Fox lol
During camp dialouge Lenny and Hosea talk about how they eant to die and I think it’s Hosea says he wants to be burried with friends. Also they ask Arthur how he wants to die to which he responds (parafrasing) «oh, i don’t care about that. Just face me towards the sunset so i can think about all the good times that we had.»
@@sebastianhall5573 that was included in one of the videos
Rdr2 needs a dlc where we play as uncle where did he go after Arthur’s death before meeting John and where he live and who he lived with and when he’s in trouble he tells the lawman he has lumbago and tells strangers that he has lumbago and play him as an outlaw but with lumbago
True that uncle
Who the hell would want to play as uncle
@@mendomaniac6733 maybe me,i want to try mr lumbago
@@mendomaniac6733 Me I want yo plsy as the legendary Lumbago Slinger!
Me
"I gave you all I had... I did." Those words shut Dutch down and probably broke him.
God iv neve rhated a character more than ross and micah
True
Crobatman I am the night Ross is not that bad in RDR2 but he’s horrible in RDR1
@@arthurmorgan6733 either way I can kinda understand Ross, he's fighting for a new frontier - but with Micah I have to respect Peter for bringing life to him.
You can go to Arthur’s final resting place early as Arthur. Just go to where the Ambarino sign is and then head up the hill right in front of it.
Thanks
@@Gamfluent no he doesn't, but I heard somewhere a while ago that if you go there as John and you've completed the game 100%, John says something. I'm not sure what he says
@@kiwibear2265 john said it "it's almost done my friend "
ruh you can even visit the same spot where arthur died I even stayed there for the sunrise and let the feels overwhelmed me.
As soon as you do the last thing to get 100% you are teleported straight to his grave and John says "Guess we're just about done, my friend."
I just noticed in Chapter One Micah says that when he falls he wants no fuss and Lenny responds by saying that when he falls there's gonna be a party. This foreshadows John and Abigail's wedding party after John kills Micah.
I heard about that
Micah’s arms are so fluent in the Rhodes fight, the way he swings his arms around almost like a thick rubber. Gorgeous.
Yup
He may be Human trash but you gotta admit, he's a great gunslinger. But too dependant on his weapons, as evidenced by Arthur and Micahs' Scuffle on the mountain.
The Womping Wampa I mean he clearly has a bond with those guns, afterall he slaughtered an entire town for them. But you’re right, in a fist brawl he couldn’t even “kill a dying man”.... except in low honor.
@@theOriginalRudeDude Even in low honor he had to use a gun. Nigga can't fight.
Jordan Dennis well he “couldn’t kill a dying man” except maybe that chest and backstab in the worst ending. Micah gets BTFO’d every fight except low honor and in both situations he needs a weapon too kill. You’re totally right.
John:gets shot 50 times
Also john:*special miracle tonic*
3:11 oh no don’t bring back the memories
At least you found Sean's moment.
Yup! Had a lot of people pointing me that out, thanks ❤️
I absolutely hate Micah, but I have to give it to him, dude was deadly af with those duel pistols
True that
Yep
He had a faster reaction time than bill, Shaun and Arthur in that scene.
he has a fast reaction speed but his accuracy is shit, remember in american venom when he missed a whole revolver of shots from no more than 8 feet from john
RDP he literally crossed both of his arms and shot two people when they got jumped by the grays
If u r running out during the jack party u tell uncle when jack is your age it will be the 20th century and then uncle says I'll outlive u all which is foreshadowing the 1st game he outlives almost everyone
I remember that one now, thanks for that ❤️ love how you all support and suggest me about more
Arthur Morgan has surpassed CJ in my book of best protagonists niko is second and John is 3rd
Man we have the same as 1 and 2, my third is tommy btw
Indo-J damn I forgot about Tommy, he was a very good one too
You think Niko is better than John? Alright, man...
Crip
Not if you’re black and from the hood
1:27 Micah got shot in Rhodes
Javier IF ONLY HE DIED REEEEE
I wish
I'm surprised he didn't fall and start crying
Paradox Messenger man, I’d fucking love to see that
Interestingly he was the first of the gang to start shooting during the ambush which means he most likely didn’t betray the gang till after Guama just like Milton said.
This game is beautiful. Nothing else to add.
True that
The lament revolver can be added
The hiding in a cave one shows that Dutch really lost his way
Yup
It's an honour that you responded to my comment
@@joelbarbeau6736 He never had a way, it was all a lie.
After completing the epilogue there is a random event at night by beechers hope where if you greet uncle. John will say that Charles and Sadie are leaving them but uncle will say that if johns burying him. He will have to bury him in beechers hope and he isn't leaving
Thanks for te heads up milton ❤️
@@IndoJordy dont thank milton! unless..... wait.... YOURE A RAT TOO! shame on you indo...
If I didn’t have then the skinner brothers would be dead and screaming
@@birdy1670 the lumbago is kicking in
Lumbago
How’s the lumbago uncle
Orange Dog sorry it was the lumbago
Uncle B you should've been grateful, they were trying to cure your lumbago
Abigail: how many times do i gotta bury you john marston
John: trust me you aint never-
*gets gunned down by edgar ross's men*
Yep
#FuckRoss
i feel like the high honor ending where arthur looks at the sunrise is the canon ending. because in chapter 6 there are so many chances to rise your honor (charlotte, edith downes, hamish) and i've had more random honor encounters (may just be me). it would suit the story because arthur was trying to be a better man.
I remember playing the first game a while ago and seeing John marston die like that and I still have that game and play it that game was far a head of it’s time
It was, I still love it
I seriously do think Javier was mostly genuine when John caught up to him, even Gabriel Sloyer thinks so.
Only if Arthur didn't save Micah..
True that
I put that mission off as long as I was able to.
@@MadaraUchiha-nr4zt Same.
Hopefully that all made sense my point being that someone snitching wasn’t what killed the gang simply the flow of time did.
Because it’s easy to blame mica for all the gangs problems but most likely he didn’t betray them till he saw that it was over (so gauma). he didn’t rat the gang out before this because he still could still make money form them he’s selfish but not stupid.
Only if Arthur weren't doing debt collecting....
I just realised that Micah's wretched soul is connected to fire: he sets Sadie's home ablaze at the very begining of the story and the low honor money ending takes place within a circle of fire, as if Micah and Arthur's souls were already condemned To an eternity of hell
Idk
What a well written thought out fleshed out story. Incredible work from Rockstar.
True that buddy
Another unsettling, but rather interesting, one is in horseshoe overlook where they're threatening Kieran. I remember Bill saying something like 'he's gonna die, but he'll loose his balls first.' This foreshadows when Kieran is captured by Colm and they gouge his eyeballs out before killin him. Super subtle, yet nasty.
1:27
You can actually see a bullet impact Micah's side.
True
Too bad it had no effect
Nah I think it missed him.
Too bad it didn't kill him.
*yay*
And the entire saga whould of had a happy ending if it was'nt for Edgar Ross
Yup
Actually if there were no Pinkerton agency
Voldemort actually if there was no Micah or Strauss if you think about it
Everything that happened with Arthur at the end, the main bit that got me choked up was his voice. I got so used to hearing it strong that the weakness in it when he said "Dutch, he's a rat" shook me. Wheezing out the last words, trying to get his best friend who already betrayed him to see some sort of sense. That wheeze
Wasn't Dutch in a cave in red dead redemption too
Yup
Yes, he was.. And his cave had no exit, nor him with an exit strategy
6:16 the way Jack looks at his father like "OK you know what maybe i will"😂
Yep 😂
"i expect you'll betray me in the end, arthur, your the type"
little did dutch know, it was the opposite.
I wonder if Charles came back to Beachers Hope to visit Jack and pay respects to John, Uncle, and Abigail
He does
Indo-J how do you know?
Imagine if during the high honor scene of arthurs death he says something close to " thank you for being the father I never had Dutch, you and Hosea. "
Sounds cool
Javier telling Hosea that John would look for him is probably my favourite, I played the second game first but I knew what the general story of the first was and when I heard Javier say that on my first playthrough I immediately knew it was a wink towards the first game
Anyone realize Micah instantly shot the sniper who killed Sean? Either it was Micah who ratted them out, or Micah actually cared for some of the the gang members.
"you aint never burying m-... *Gets annihilated*
Sadly
7:43 I broke my ps4 x button there
When you complete the stranger mission, "No Good Deed" Dr Renaud gives Arthur the special remedy then throws in "It won't work on anything chronic". The layers of this game is amazing.
7:01 if that would be a gameplay fall, we would be dead xD
Nope
6:21 Holy shit I never noticed that
👍
3:11 Ugh. The ugly truth HURTS
😮
When Arthur was dying I wanted Dutch to say something so bad. But at that moment Dutch really lost everything and everyone he had.
I'm still drunk
U are ?
@@IndoJordy yup
@@uncle1839 god dammit uncle!
*after all these years*
3:06 "Never"
6:23
So,Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto take place in the same universe,just in different timelines.
Yep
No
@@paulpartida4797 yep, the whole epsilon thing is there too, with the chelonians and the time tralever mission.
2:29 It also counts for RDR1 where Dutch hides out in Cochinay, a Native American reservation with a cave system that turned into Dutch’s hideout.
3:31 heavy breathing
😆
Indo-J when you kill someone who has a mic in RDO
You can all most hear the blood in his breath
John Marston: Never. You ain’t never burying me.
Edgar Ross: Allow me to introduced myself!
6:23 “Ghetto Booty”
I’ve never seen anyone mention this. When Arthur and Dutch are on the cliff edge Dutch said “I got a plan, this is a good one”. The same thing he says in RDR1 to John when he’s on the cliff before he jumps. He also says “you’re fighting nature captain” and “you can’t fight gravity” then he jumps into the river. In RDR1 he says almost the same line “you can’t fight nature or gravity John”
2:12 I remember replaying rdr2 and finding this and just searching for it in one of ur previous foreshadowing vids
Nice 👍
So you’re telling me you can find Jack Marstons books in GTA 5?!
Poor Sean
Poor boy
@@IndoJordy its boah
Colby Benoit
Honestly I wish Sean would’ve been alive longer.
Colby Benoit I loved that kid
The uncle and charles one is wholesome
I think Dutch realize at the end for the first time they;re way of life was coming to an end
Yup, I think the same
After watching the scene where Arthur and Micah fall off the cliff again I’m startin to think that the fall really put Arthur through. You can hear how damn hard he’s trying to breathe. Obviously the man has been coughing up blood to this point because of the TB and he would’ve passed anyway, but I’m thinking that if he hadn’t taken that fall, he’d probably be able to find his way to John and say his proper goodbyes. I don’t know, it’s just a thought I had.
3:06 Is it bad I kind of laughed at that. Just the timing.
Did you mention that in the epilogue Uncle always sits and rests in the exact same spot in the porch as where he dies.
When you give money to the blind beggar he foreshadows too
Thanks for the tip!
Sean getting killed still makes me jump. First time I saw that it shocked the hell outta me.
Also, I think a high honor Arthur might get to go to Heaven. After a stint in purgatory. He was a bad man for most of his life, but he did try to change and do the right thing at the end. I think God will respect that and give him a chance.
Repentance is everything
Redemption gives a second chance to anyone who's willing to accept it
Sadly, I don't think so, all the lawmen who have a family he killed, I don't think if he helped John a murderer he would go to heaven. I respect Arthur and your opinion
Arthur to sean after he hit his head on the train: "At least you ain't got a whole in it"
The Gray's: "You were saying?"
So...Micah called himself Arthurs friend then?
Even brother
Indo-J he was being sarcastic
Sons of Dutch makes us brothers! Didn’t sound sarcastic
You’ve got to give mica that at-least he never lied about who he was as a person.
@@timtim6373 Not if you take into consideration that he was giving the pinkertons information, lying about being loyal to dutch
Dutch felt so much pain and shame when he realized arthur really was trying to do good and he pretty much killed him
*Its high noo-*
Oh sorry wrong game
😮
John: You ain't never burying me!
*not even 5 seconds later*
John: gets shot up
GTA 5 is a different universe.
Dont use that book stuff,its just an easter egg.
When did rockstar ever said that gta is another universe? Please come with proof ?
Sounds legit
@@IndoJordy in Red dead redemption there is a side mission were a man called Sam Odessa wants to go to California...well in GTA California does not exist,its called San Andreas.
Here is your proof.
Rockstar never said it because it was obvious.
A lot of people still think the games are on the same universe.
But....good video
That Crazy Dude lmao a gangster from the hood starting a toothpaste business
@That Crazy Dude The book literally says red dead by J Marston. It is an Easter egg, but it confirms that he became a writer.
Sucks that every game under Rockstar's belt isn't in the same universe, but I still feel like that book in GTA V is more than just an Easter egg.
I got lumbago
U 2?
micah: playing Dutch van der linde gang
6:18 what game is that? And when did Edith give leopold the debt? When I was playing I collected the debt by going to the downes house, not her coming to the camp.
GTA 5
Same here, I had to go to the Downes Ranch. Maybe that was only a part of the debt, and you had to go collect the rest of it
I always thought it was really cool how immediately after Sean dies, Micah manages to kill 3 Grays right off.
Yep
6:44
Arthur- blue
Micah- red
Huh
😆
it's so sad that John died in a similar way to micah. Shot over and over and over and over again, all over the body.
By The Way Micah Bell was racist he said to Lenny that he shot a lot of cowards like him by cowards he meant he shot a lot of black people
David Fowler ok but why is that relevant
True, I made a video racist Micah
LENNY BOII
David Fowler lol racism wasn’t looked down on in that time haha
Zucc it was a bit considering it’s after the civil war and it’s still rude.
5:48 well not the way Javier imagined Johns intentions of finding him hm
I hate the low honour endings rockstar made it where if you are good you are rewarded with a good ending and low honour the make you realise that you did wrong and you shouldn't be rewarded
I like it though
The low honor ending reflects how you lived as Arthur by the gun and those that live by the sword die by the sword.
I just love the way micah shout black lung lol
😮
5:04 If you listen closely, someone else found this scene hilarious, like I did.
😆
@@ArthurMorganGaming u should
Micah is piece of shit but atleast he is honest on that one
Fuck off Micah
I think his loyalty was obvious from the being because he didn’t owe Dutch a thing if anything Dutch owed him he’s a self serving person that’s interested in his own survival over his fellow gang members he joined the gang because it was a tough one and he could make some money from it.
Never thought I’d see the day where three grown men act like toddlers, my life is now complete
😂