Persona 3 FES & Portable Have Never Been This Good
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Go to strms.net/hell... and use code POGGVGJULY16 for my special HelloFresh discount and to support my channel! #ad
Persona 3 finally gets a full remaster in both its FES and Portable form
Downloads:
Aemulus mod manager: gamebanana.com...
Persona 3 FES HD: gamebanana.com...
Persona 3 FES Widescreen Fixes: gamebanana.com...
Persona 3 FES Widescreen Font Fix: gamebanana.com...
Persona 3 FES Cheats: forums.pcsx2.n... (download RAR and locate P3 FES)
Persona 3 Portable True HD: gamebanana.com...
Support GVG on Patreon!
/ gvgaming
Check out our merch!
the-official-g...
Follow GVG on Twitter:
• / gvgofficial
• / joncomms
• / bitnerd_
• / ashpaulsen
• / stevembowling
• / meruleaf_
• / evernightstudio
I'll say it: I'm pretty disappointed at how Atlus seems to be treating the P3 rerelease as an afterthought. Porting P3P with messy AI upscaling feels like the least possible effort they could put in. This was a great opportunity to do a "P3 Perfect" style release with the best of both games, finally bridging the gap, but instead it seems like they're doing it more out of obligation than any real interest.
Geez, a "Persona 3 Perfect" that merges both FES and Portable to be something more definitive was something I was thinking about when watching this video! A ground up remake of FES with stuff from Portable like the female protagonist would be something awesome!
It's because persona 3 is the least favorite game in the whole series. Atlus probably doesn't think 3 is going to sell well. That's not what I think but hopefully we can surprise them that persona has a fan base
@@austematicthatragic4352 Atlus/Sega are just quite dumb. I mean, look how they market their next game "Soul Hackers 2". There is nearly zero western marketing and the game will be out in 1 month + 1 week. They concentrate a lot on the Japanese marketing, but there is no Switch version lol.
@@TommyDeonauthsArchives and cutscenes from the anime and remade music
Yeah I wanted a portable fes combo
9:00 Other mods have deinterlaced and upscaled the pre-rendered cutscenes.
I'm probably asking for a ton but, I really hope they add the answer for the re-release.
If not, we'll probably have to keep our copies of FES. (or.. Mods for.. PC/ Mods For the ISOS.. *COUGH*)
I bought P3 FES on ps3 and have been playing it off and on lately, looks like I’m ditching that and doing this now
TrueHD Project Lead here. I'm glad you discouraged the Atlus-bashing, I've seen a lot of that since our trailer was released. I'm surprised at how well you communicated TrueHD's goals and intentions, very well-researched! Good video and good showcase, that was a fun watch!
I shake your hand with my bloody hand
ahhh, space patrol luluco enjoyer, based
I was going to like this, but the likes were at 420. i just cant bring myself to do it
You're cringe get a life
Thank you and the team so much for this!
Important to note: FES with player-controlled party members isn't magically Portable's gameplay; Portable backports mechanics from Persona 4, most notably the dizzy status, stunning a knocked-down enemy for a turn. In FES, hitting a knocked-down enemy makes it get back up.
There's also various changes to interfacing with your party members, but that's the biggest one.
I feel like it idavertently makes the game easier, which is the only unfortunate part
Yeah, this is very important to note. P3P's in a weird place, where I 100% prefer playing with manually controlled party members, but when you do, it becomes very clear the original game wasn't designed around it. Extra things like the Skill Cards can also make P3 as a whole seem easier than it really was originally.
There are many more important mechanics that Persona 3 portable differ from FES. Main character can no longer equip any weapon but is forced to use 1h swords or Naginatas depending on gender. Mitsuru gets rapiers to differentiate from MC. This obviously makes most good weapons, most notably ultimate weapons and some unique fused weapons, unusable by MC.
Once more also works differently with skills that hit all enemies. In Fes all party members or enemies have to be weak to attack to give once more, in P3P only 1 character is enough. For example if your party is hit by Maragidyne when you have Mitsuru (who is weak to agi) in it, in P3P enemy gets once more but in FES they will not get extra turn. Also getting up from knocked down status doesn't take a turn in P3P, making it harder to get stunlocked by enemies and stunlocking enemies by yourself.
I feel like all these changes have bigger effect than controllable party members. Then again, I never had a problem with the party members AI, like I used Mitsuru but she used Marin Karin like once during the entire game. You'll always want to scan enemy to upgrade your party AI even if scanning reveals no information. You also never want to have AI on the default Act Freely since that makes party use moves on random. Many players straight up refuse to interact with the AI system or don't take full advantage of it which annoys me to no end when these players bash the system they don't fully understand.
@@Newageretronoob
Correction: Act Freely does not lead to characters using moves at random. Each character has an affinity for different skill types and, if put on AF, they will default to those skills if they do not know the enemy's affinities eg. Junpei with usually use physical attacks, Ken/Koro will prioritise Hama/Mudo, Mitsuru will focus on ailments etc. They will readjust once the enemy is analysed but it's usually better to put them on Full Assault anyway because that's when they focus on their heavy-hitters, and after the scans, Knock Down, because PMs will mainly default to party-wide skills and, considering the aforementioned knockdown mechanics, this can be a waste of a turn.
It's so frustrating how often P3's combat is written off, it's a very nicely-designed system.
So wait the reason the AI version was bashed so hard was because people forgot the scan function and AI settings?
It feels bad that this was all done right before P3P was announced for PC where this could of been done a lot easier due to the magic of modding on PC.
The creator of the TrueHD mod for P3P has stated that they would port their mod to the PC version, if possible, as they are dissatisfied with Atlus' official upscale. None of the work is going to be wasted.
The Persona 3 FES mods have existed for a while before now, Aemulus even longer.
The brilliance now though is that playing modded 3 FES on a Steam Deck is an ideal way to play the game. The PS2 graphics with the HD texture pack look surprisingly good on that small screen.
The modder said the hardest game they modded is Persona 3 fes not Portable which is not on PC anyway so he didn't lost that much
hd mods for both games have existed for a long time now
I dream of one day being able to play the female protag in FES with the animated cutscenes and everything. maybe one day? :0
I bet it'll happen in 9-10 years
The female route is garbage as it is written for a male character still and doesn't take into account how women/girls are treated and addressed in Japan. It adds nothing. It's possibly the single worst addition to a Persona game ever.
@@FuzzyDlop ... Huh? Pretty much all the social links for the female protagonist are different. Characters DO interact with the female protagonist differently. What are you on about?
@@Omar_Al_Seddik The main story isn't well written for her though, which is a valid point imo
@@FuzzyDlop na how is that the worst addition to a persona game ever? your trolling or your high or something it is not even close to being the worst addition to the persona series
It’s pretty disappointing that Atlus didn’t capitalise on the fact P3P is no longer held back by the PSP, they could have tried to bring it in line with FES. At least Persona has a pretty dedicated modding community that will grow even more once P3-5 come to PC.
I do wonder if Atlus will ever remake Perosna 3 with all the good from each version. Like walking, The Answer, and anime cutscenes from FES and controlling party members and Female route in Portable into on version
I think they have that in mind, which this year's P-Sound hints at. I do think the rerelease of P3P is mainly to give the player an extra opinion, like if they don't want to play the remake, they can just play what Atlus thinks is the best way to play the original, much like how if you don't want to play Final Fantasy VII Remake and would rather play the original, it's available on the Switch and Steam. I think that's what Atlus' approach with this.
Don't forget skill cards from p3p and fusion spells from p3fes
I thought of maybe a remake that take the original main story with makoto yuki. Can take anime cutscenes from anime or something. Add some more stuff to the game
Also the title. Maybe called P3LIVE or P3 reboot
Controlling party members is awful in P3, it goes against the main theme of the game. It's no Persona 4 or 5. The female route is garbage as it is written for a male character still and doesn't take into account how women/girls are treated and addressed in Japan. It adds nothing. There's no good in P3Portable which is a fully garbage release.
@@FuzzyDlop The direct commands is actually optionable, as in you don't have to switch to it and just play the game as if it's FES, as you can do in EVERY Persona game since 3. Also, one interesting thing is the option to play as either a male or a female protagonist was actually an idea for the original game. So, the plot was written with that idea in mind. But, you don't have to play as the female protagonist and like it if you don't want to. There's aways the male protagonist in P3P, which is pretty much like FES.
Hmmm, not sure why we shouldn't ask more of Atlus? It's really disappointing to me that they're doing such a rush job with this port after all this time. The game and franchise deserve better. And anyway, I'm all for asking more of big companies.
We as individuals are free to demand better, but an outfit like GoodVibesGaming is obliged to make an effort stay in the good graces of the publishers of the games they cover. Jon might not have been so quick to sugarcoat it if he had been a solo RUclipsr (but we'll never know for sure.)
@@StevenUlyssesPerhero I don't understand how not sending the message that we shouldn't ask more of big companies is something that would put them in the bad graces of any company... it's like if every negative review from every outlet needed to end with "but we still think they did a swell job!" To be clear, this is a very different thing than condoning harassment.
@@timrattray companies can be pretty fickle. Even something as minor as suggesting they do better can put you in a bad perspective. They just won't tell you that you're on their list. It really depends on the company.
@@CRAgamer This pretty rarely happens. I used to work in the industry.
If P3 ever gets a definitive edition, I kinda hope they remake it in the style of Dancing in Moonlight for the presentation. They already have the models and a base idea for the look of the world... why not? Of course, they'd have to make some changes to the gameplay, which I'm cool with (even though I'm used to the faults of FES by now.)
P3 FES has no faults.
This is the way. Using Dancing's models it could be very easily achieve the look of P5 on that regard, but then the problem would be all the locations.
Even then, Atlus is very lazy sometimes so I have no hopes on anything official
@@FuzzyDlop It has a shitton of faults, what are you talking about xDD You can get softlocked for not knowing how high level you should be. I had to restart 15 hours in due to it. I had no way of beating the boss as i did the same thing i did in P4. Level up personas, make new personas, level up in general, level up social links, all in a balanced manner. Still was fucked.
You know, and when I got Dancing All Night, that's what I thought it was. A resource dump. An excuse to make alllll the resources ahead of time.
Junpei's "dance" wasn't even a dance, it was just his old aniamtions
I'm definitely checking out the FES HD mod when that comes out. However it's still somewhat of a bummer that P3 just seems cursed to have a lot of its core improvements locked behind two unique versions of the game, even as someone who does prefer Portable
...you did watch the video right?
@@LostSoulSilver They will never be able to port FEMC to FES (or it will take forever if so)
it's like 87% complete and you can currently download it it looks real nice!
I'm gonna lose it though when a group of people says "Fuck it, let's all mash FES and Portable together (irregardless if they keep Answer to only male protag and no FeMC ver), improve on it, and add the stuff that was only in Portable into FES."
All the stuff in Portable is garbage and would ruin the masterpiece P3 FES is. Althought it already did that just by existing. The female MC is garbage and written for a male MC. It adds nothing. Combat system in P3P is garbage too.
Fuzzy uh oh someone’s angy
@@FuzzyDlop sheesh talk about being childish, grow up will you?
The only thing that might be a problem is that the game might become too complex yet at the same time too easy?
Being able to use all types of weapons, having elemental weapons through weapon fusion and fusion spells, all of these mechanics mixed with skill cards controllable party members and other mechanics from portable might make the game overly easy due to the easy access to a lot of op items and abilities, i mean just with a random nihil weapon and a strength persona you can get a weapon that gives Auto-tarukaja, and the four main elemental ones give boost to their respective elements so you just need a 2° tier elemental increasing damage ring, and you 2 slot spaces you would use with an amp and an bossy skill being used for other things, and some fusion spells like Armageddon are pretty op, even Jack Bros is good.
And don't forget the fact there will have 3 physical attributes.
I vividly remember toiling on the P3P HD UI mod late nights after work, tracing the elements in vector to achieve the high res look. Eventually had to stop because of how time-consuming it was (and I needed sleep!). The emergence of AI upscaling was the boost the modding community absolutely needed, I am so glad at where things are now. Wishing the current modding team all the best.
If only they'd combine the p3p content, control of all the characters, and the FMC into Persona 3 Fes for a definitive version.
This was a fun watch, thanks for the showcase!
I'd love to see a P3 remake using the same UI as dancing in moon light.
Not just the UI. The whole assets. I want Thanatos out of the ps2 limitations.
thanatos was in p5/r
@@dniwetamp ah I didn't know that. I thought they only took Messiah/Orpheus for the dlc
We don't need a remake now. We need a persona 1 and 2 remake.
You can tell that Persona 5 had a bit of both the 3D exploration and more immersive aspects, but also the 1 button to teleport to places which is an upgrade to point and clicking from P3P imo. And that way they please everyone and i honestly prefer this moving forward.
Now i do wish they remade some of the old games like P1, P2 and P3 into something more like P5, but if they don't want to do that and they want to bring more Persona games or spin offs, i'm kinda ok with that too. Cuz' it just means we get Persona 6 faster.
It doesn't mean we'll get Persona 6 faster as Atlus doesn't have teams to make remasters or whatnot and they don't stop entire teams working on new games to remaster old ones. The only way they could remaster Nocturne was by taking two handful of SMT developers who were working on SMT 5 and making them "remaster" Nocturne when SMT 5 was close to being finished already. The result was a Nocturne remaster that wasn't a remaster at all. It's the cheapest and laziest thing ever sold at full price. But SMT 5 was never delayed and came out when it was supposed to.
Let us rejoice over finally getting Persona 3, 4 and 5 on Switch :)
Yorokobe
YES!!!
Ew
Meanwhile Persona 1, both parts of 2, the rhythm games, and the Q games are a bit stuck.
@@naliboi93 Does not matter if rhythm games are ported or not, but I wish Persona 1 and 2 was released with better gameplay 😕
What’s funny is that the only thing that was holding p3p from being a FES port is system limitations, otherwise it’s the same exact engine as P4G, hence why they likely ported p3p over p3f because it was a seemless port
It's not a remaster, they're too lazy and cheap to even remaster it. P4 is not a remaster either on PC.
Fuzzy by definition it is a remaster
I always wanted a definitive version of P3 with stuff with portable and fes combined. Because there's great things in both versions I prefer.
I will always prefer FES. Portable has nice additions sure, but the drawbacks it has are just a little to much for me. Not having a 3D over world is disappointing, and not having any cutscenes with 3D models can hurt some story beats and also gets boring to look at after a while. FES isn’t a perfect game either, far from it, but I feel it has less drawbacks in comparison. I know the big one is non controllable party members, and people will automatically pick Portable just for that alone, but I honestly think it’s an overblown issue. At least with my experience, my party members generally did what you would expect them to do. They might do something stupid every now and then but it rarely hurts gameplay for me. Plus the game is generally designed around it, so it’s not that big a deal.
Dude P3P sure has some Drawbacks but The Answer Gives FES So Many Drawback Points That I Don't Want To Talk About It
Honestly, I kinda like The Answer. Bold statement I know but it’s just fun to have more time with characters I love. Is it worse than The Journey? Yeah probably. It not having social links definitely hurts it and makes the game drag in a way The Journey doesn’t, and some story decisions are baffling, but overall I still like it and would call it a good and worthwhile addition. But I’m also the guy who way prefers vanilla Persona 4 and thinks Golden is just worse, so what I say probably doesn’t hold much water.
That persona 3 remake rumor better be real because persona 3 portable is indeed a sad rerelease with very little changes to the original, still gonna play it tho since I wanna get those achievements but when it gets a sale
Quite literally the only thing that prevents me from playing P3P is the fact you can’t walk around in the overworld. I would much rather wait for a PS5 remake of Persona 3 FES with all the story, and maybe any changes to “the answer”’s story if it matters with FeMC like how the original story changed
You aren't missing much
I am extremely disappointed with what Atlus has done and have been since the reveal, it’s cool that P5 and 4 are getting re-released but Persona 3 FES is my favourite piece of media of all time by miles, so to see that it’s getting ditched to the wayside in favour of a version I very much resent, I can’t help but feel angry, I did hear about how “porting FES is a nightmare” but that’s the thing, I don’t even ask for ports, I ask for ports OR good emulation, I would’ve absolutely bought something like what the FES HD overhaul project looks but as it stands, the public are generally gonna play what I very much consider a horrible version of the game and it’s just very heartbreaking for me, I’m happy for those that like this version but again, FES is my favourite piece of media of all time.
I agree. I played FES on my PS2 last year and it became one of my top 5 games of all time. Absolutely adored it. I honestly wish Atlus never made portable. It saddens me that this incredibly inferior version of the game is what’s being preserved and that new players will have to experience this wonderful title in such a terrible way.
Lol
jaire kambui your opinion isn’t fact dude some people like P3P
So glad to see these covered! P3 certainly has issues when it comes to which version to play but the mods/cheats for them are so great! Been really eager to play through the games again and on top of the new ports, these will improve it even more :)
That artwork was actually included in the artbook for the game. That's where they've pulled the high quality version from
It's really a shame that all atlus did for p3p was throw it into the world's messiest ai upscaler and call it a day. P3 is in this awkward spot where there aren't many great options visually, and the one chance we had for an official fix was treated more like an afterthought.
You seem to be pretty against saying anything negative towards Atlus concerning Xbox P3, which I kind of find silly.
They are selling you a product in exchange for money. If that product can't, at the bare minimum, _match_ the work of free patches and cheat-codes, why wouldn't that be worthy of criticism? It's not like they're struggling for time or money with this project. They probably have even more time and resources than most of these moders to work on an official release, however you seem very lenient on a company that's taking your money for something moders have put out, with twice the effort involved, for free.
Don't misunderstand, I love Atlus and the persona series. But not calling something out as lazy doesn't do the company any favors. Telling someone when they've done something wrong is the first step in fixing the issue. Lying to them and saying everything is hunky-dory because you love them and think it's nicer is counterproductive.
Should we tell him
I mean I've tried modding FES before and still couldn't get into it enough to continue after the first couple hours but I think I'll give it another shot after this video, thanks!
If you still can’t get into FES, play P3P as FeMC. It has some huge QOL improvements that make it much more fun to play IMO.
FES is a better game without being able to control your party. I will die on this hill.
Man at this point companies should create a special department to work closely along with fans like these. The final product would be so much better, and both parties would be happier. The company would end up making more money, and fans would get what they want.
Make a mod where we can pick what skills we want to inherit in Fes
12:00 - lemme guess, taken from one of the movies?
This stuff is incredible and while I vastly prefer P3P over the original/FES its great to see fantastic HD mods for FES.
P3P is garbage and by far the worst release in Atlus's history. It's an insult to Persona 3 and its fans. Everything about P3 FES is superior as that is the TRUE Persona 3. Portable is a much easier and casual version that ruins the essence and core theme of trust of Persona 3 by letting you control party members like every person incapable of playing a hardcore JRPG would want to. Clicking on stills like a straight up visual novel, instead of being immersed in japanese locations(which is the point of playing a Persona game) is awful and ridiculous. You didn't not play P3 with P3P. It's a garbage game that has nothing to do with it.
@@FuzzyDlop oh yeah sure, but I actually played P3FES, not P3. So that counts, right?
Oh yeah and I trusted Mitsuru not to break into her stupid Marin Karin fits, but each and every single time she did and never stopped frustrating the shit out of me. Much like the pre-P4 turn mechanics.
The "trust in AI" thing would've worked out great if it didn't make me feel like a cripple in the second half of the game where I would need to bend down to the whims of my AI partners and there's a good reason it became optional in P4 and P5. Because at some point it stops working right. I would much rather NOT waste time scanning each and every enemy I see and actually utilize my party members at their best I can manage.
Downloaded the HD mod for steamdeck and it's simply the best way to play the game. How atlus didn't do the work these awesome fans did is beyond comprehension. Thanks for the food work!
Dang that persona 3 fes ps2 case looks way cooler than the aegis one
I love persona 3 it was my introduction to this beautiful series
Well that sucks, I thought portable was just Fes with the female character addition. Damn I want Fes, not this crap.
Atlus needs to hire these people to work on getting Persona 3 FES out
Someone is working on a 3D overworld mod for P3P, and there are HD model mods too so that tartarus looks even better. I have a feeling in a couple of years the P3P mod scene will make it the definitive version of the game (hopefully someone mods in the answer too)
Mitsuru will always be my P3 waifu, and I will never apologize for it
Great character but literally all she does in battle is spam a spell that never works...
12:00 Holy- that looks so good!!
I just wish Atlus properly P3 for everyone to play, would be so good to be able to play the combination of both games. I mean they're totally can do it
The release of P3P on PC and Xbox was such a disappointment. I was hoping for a P3 remake myself.
isnt P3FES the definite one, as with the Answer, Aigis talks to Igor and Elizabeth and in P4 Arena with Aigis Story, Elizabeth and Aigis reference it. and in Elizabeth story, she mentioned Aigis as a Guest in the Velvet Room. which only happened in FES
Combination of Fes and Portable would have been amazing but sadly we didn't get that from Atlus
I'm not the modder, but thank you for covering this. I hope it gets more attention that it deserves and the mod got more support in the future.
I've only played the portable one since I prefer playing as female and can relate more when romancing male characters. Wish there were more femMCs in persona!
FYI the P3F Community Enhancement Pack is honestly the way to go when modding persona 3 FES. It’s a collection of mods all set up for you with a easy to follow wiki to help you through the install. Adds a bunch of quality of life features and more. Would recommend doing that instead
Thank you.
12:01 Ha, that's clever, I think they used the official art for that one. It's the first picture that comes up when googling "persona 3 dark hour art".
The only critic I have to this otherwise AMAZING video. is the level of downplay you've set
to discourage "atlus Bashing" it almost comes off like you are ok with the fact that we as a community
deserve an inferior and sub par product. As well we should feel bad for demanding a higher quality standard
all in the name of "lets not hate" A company's sole purpose is to sell you, the consumer, a product.
It's up to the consumer to use words and there wallets to show said company what we truly want in
terms of quality standard within said products. You stating "This is not to say, do better atlus" is so
aggravating because NOT saying that, is WHY we are getting a low effort, none definitive, AI upsampled
and half baked port of the handheld version of P3. Which many have already stated feels like it
was added out of an obligation. So atlus is able to "claim" to finally have all 3 games on other platforms.
The fact that a group of fans, as you yourself has shown. CAN DO BETTER, than a company with
100x the resources. illustrates that, in fact. "Atlus SHOULD DO BETTER" and its just sad that even
the project lead agrees with what is essentially "accepting mediocrity" within the products atlus creates.
Life is not progressed by silence and good intentions. Put in the work and the work speaks for itself.
Why buy P3P Portable if they are doing a shitty job? Stop buying this crap and maybe next time Atlus will put some effort in their remasters.
Modders have always carried these games imo. When Persona 4 Golden was released on PC modders went in right away and improved so much. Its gotten to the point where theres a huge community pack that is stupidly easy to install giving you the best Persona 4 experience. Im sure once 3 comes to the PC that modders will do what Atlus didnt care to do.
im about to play 4 any chance you can direct me to that mod pack? :)
P4G on PC is perfectly fine without any mods tbh
3 will always be my favourite. I recognise that 4 is objectively much better and improved in so many ways, but my personal opinion is 3. It was also an impulse buy. I was buying a PS Vita to replace my PSP, and I just happened to see this big chunky box in the corner of the bargain section at my local game store. I was collecting art books for games at the time, and I saw it was a special edition of P3P with the art book still included. It was only around $10 too. I picked it up not having any idea what Persona was as a franchise and having never seen it before. Took it home and played it on a whim, turned out to be a 2 month long obsession. Loved it. For me, P3P is the only version, as it's all I know.
All these negative comments about atlus I wonder how people feel now with the Reload release
I just want them to make Portable less of a Visual Novel and more like the other games. I don't care about The Answer. I just want to be able to walk around Pawlonia Mall and other locations in Portable. ;_;
Persona 3 Portable releases on Steam
Modders be like Let's P3FES this game
Actually there is a mod for fes that uses the movies to replace some cutscenes
thank you for giving me a reason to play p3fes on my pc now :D
i was gonna play it on a ps3 but i wanted the game to look nice while i enjoy it 💯
I'm definitely going to go the Fes route on my PC, the cheats/mods look amazing
i wish the official release was the FES version of the game, you really lose something by just selecting stuff with a cursor, it just defeats the purpose of the game, at least for me and i don't feel immersed (referring to the official ATLUS remaster here)
Never understood why Atlus didn't just make a Persona 3 ultimate or something that combined FES and Portable. Like it's such easy money
The number one mod I want for Fes is to be able to choose persona skill inheritance
Supporting that terrible upscale botch job is a terrible idea.
I still think P3FES is the best one, and exactly because you CANT control your party members without cheats.
I've cleared it 3 times on my hacked PS4pro, and anyone who thinks controlling your party is needed is hellishly wrong.
It really makes the atmosphere special. You kinda have allies and all, but in the end, the only one you can truly believe is yourself only.
The AI for party members was quite revolutionary too. At times they make really smart decisions. Though at times - really stupid ones.
But who's perfect, hey.
You can choose to make your party members AI controlled in P3P, so that argument is obsolete. Also, what about the other dozen extra features/additions/content that P3P brings? I played both games but I honestly don't understand why so many people prefer FES. It feels so primitive and raw. The 3D world didn't even look good.
@@Omar_Al_Seddik It has a far better atmosphere. "Content" matters a whole lot less than the music, tone, and presentation being noticeably changed for the worse, especially in the FeMC route (though both suffer). It's a downgrade of what was artistic perfection. Symbolism, writing, character dynamics, etc simply don't converge into what brilliance they do in FES, in Portable.
It's still a good game by virtue of being Persona 3, even a really great game, but it's not the best version of Persona 3.
@@Omar_Al_Seddik it felt different.
Zoomers wont understand, but how the game world feels is very important.
Yes, you can set the party members to AI control in P3P or P4. But those are different, you will not want to do so.
So it needs to be forced.
@@kurosan9712 _“You will not want to do so”_
… But you clearly stated in your original comment that you want your party members AI controlled?
Can you explain to me, a _“zoomer,”_ in simpler terms why FES _“feels different”?_ Is it nostalgia? Is it the 3D world? The answer?
In what way was the music a downgrade? I don’t get it. They added a few extra tracks without removing any, and they are all pretty damn good.
I have to ask… Did you guys even play and finish Portable?
@@Omar_Al_Seddik I did. Both male and female versions. I didnt even laugh at the sweet potato meme that was going around at the time, because I know japanese, and I knew it was a mistake.
I want, but when the game gives an option that's not good. Humans will always go for the easier option. Thus giving no options is the best.
As for music I dunno, I dont like Wiping All Out, I still prefer Mass Destruction over that crap. But I dont care about music much tbh.
I cant say why, but FES feels like a game, and Portable felt and still feels like a game from buttoned mobile phones of 00s, downgraded, even if somewhere the same. I never considered it as a serious game, even though I cleared it twice.
Maybe having no choice gives better synergy with your character, maybe something else. But I am still playing FES and doubt anything will make me want portable more than it.
Episode Aigis is also very important to me, as a finishing part of the story.
Like I have a friend who never even knew the protagonist "dies", at the end of P3, because he only played portable, where it's never said directly. That sucks, so shut your trap.
The inability to control party members in Persona 3 is the whole point of the game and one of the main themes(main one actually). There's nothing in P3 Portable that's more immersive...you have NO LOCATIONS, NO EXPLORATION, NOTHING. The combat system is garbage in P3P as it makes the whole game much easier and more casual. That's not Persona 3 as Persona 3 is one of the most hardcore games ever made. Stop promoting that shit because you prefer games to be easier and more casual.
Bruh it’s not Dark Souls chillax
Also WHAT
The whole party member control thing is wierd, the games difficulty was based on not having full control. If you just swap in the P4 party control system with P3s mechanics the game becomes too easy.
The biggest issue (which effects ally and enemy) is the knocked down system, with full player control you can manipulate the game so that the enemies are constantly getting up, since if your turn arrives when you're knocked down you waste it getting up.
You can still do this in p3fes, but I comes with the risk of having your party set to do nothing! Very good risk/reward balance design that goes out the window if you add party control
@@dez4668 exactly it's likely the reason why the dizzy status exists in p4. The whole get knocked down lose your turn is ripe for exploitation.
for those that don't understand why someone would prefer p3p and the 2d overworld exploration, its for time saving purposes. I only have so many hours a day to play games and every bit i can save helps me get further into a game.
late comment but P5 is 3D and you have the teleport option (best of both), Atlus just failed with 25th persona anniversary not announcing a remake of P3, pretty much as blizzard failed with diablo immortal announcement during blizzcon
Those people at Altus better not fuck it up. Like how rockstar games fucked up GTA: Definitive edition.
Doubt it
"But don't do that or I'll get you"
Damn, take my like 🤣
For me, the biggest things that keep either version from being definitive isn't even graphics or controllable party members.
Okay that's slightly a lie, controllable party members are a huge deal, but there's finer points that make the experiences different, most of which being stuff that makes portable a much more convenient and fulfilling gameplay experience. FES has jealousy mechanics that make it nearly impossible to clear all the social links in a single go to get Orpheus Telos.
Then there's the fact that Portable uses the refined battle mechanics of 4, which mostly changes the way knocking down enemies works. Then there's the police station being open at night, the game actually TELLING you what days your social links are available. Not to mention there's an entire bonus area where you can refight bosses for extra rewards. On top of ALL of that, it also features Skill Cards, which makes it much MUCH simpler to customize your Persona's skill set. (they're basically TMs). This means that you can hang on to Orpheus and make it useful. (Downright broken if you spam arcade stat buffs)
And yet, FES still has cool features like the protagonist being able to wield any kind of weapon, not just swords, which is important considering Slash, Strike, and Stab damage are separate, not just one big Phys stat, and for the characters it depends on what weapon they wield, and the fact that you have access to fusion spells in a much more organic format. Basically, the player can use special moves if they have two specific persona in their catalogue. In 3P, this is much more tedious, as they're basically relegated to really expensive items.
So Basically, even beyond stuff like the female protagonist and controllable party members, and cutscenes and all that, there's a shit ton to consider, and a massive dumpload of work that Atlus would have to do to make a truly definitive version of Persona 3.
That being said, if this new release finally gives you the ability to choose what skills your personas pass on during fusion, then it's the best version even if the rest of the game is untouched, idgaf.
I would argue those exact additions to portable (skill cards and stat buffing cards) are exactly what makes portable a joke. Not only can you use orpheus through the entire game, orpheus was pretty much the only persona I ever used for combat in the entire game in my last 100% femc run, in a vanilla new game, no ng+ benefits. This was not an intentional challenge of any sort, I did switch during certain fights where Orpheus' weakness was annoying or where I didn't have the spell I wanted on it yet, but the fact that the entire system of getting and using new personas as you go was trivialized by me just playing the game and not even intentionally trying to feels like an issue. Whats more, changes like the dizzy system fundamentally change how certain boss fights are meant to be done. Some early tartarus floor bosses are given movesets where the answer to the puzzle is simply to be patient and never actually let the boss attack at all (as getting up originally took a turn), but because dizzy cannot be stacked you now need an entirely different strategy to figure out how you're going to live through the fact the boss WILL get an attack at least every other turn. This raises the minimum level required to efficiently survive certain bosses, necessitating further early-game grinding. (I will note these changes to intended boss strategy are still not as awful as whatever the concept behind any given The Answer boss fight was.) All of these factors together on higher difficulties leads to an (occasionally) overly punishing/grindy early game that slopes down to nearly non-existant end game difficulty where (if you know how to abuse skill mutations) you might end up with an orpheus with access to every dyne spell, mind charge, null elec, and a magic stat of 99 (if not multiple maxed stats.) By the time I was able to fuse orpheus telos it was significantly weaker than the orpheus I had to use to make it.
All this to say it is still a fun and playable version of the game, it just feels... not as properly tuned as it could have been. I shouldn't have to buy cadenza as an item.
@@Namingway248 While I do agree with a majority of your points, specifically in regards to the game being more punishing in earlier segments, I will say that a lot of what makes Portable more easily breakable really only has an effect on the game at extremely optimal play. A lot of the quirks of 3 FES however make the game much more frustrating to your average player right off the bat. So while it lowered the skill ceiling, I feel like it also made it much easier for more people to get into on average. So again, it still will always come back to Portable and FES being a "Pick your poison" sort of thing. I don't think either version of 3 is optimal in every conceivable way.
Which leaves us with 3 needing a complete overhaul, which in and of itself is tricky when there's tons of other games under the megaten umbrella that could use the treatment more. 3 is in a really awkward spot.
Portable also has a ton of better menus which helps with the convenience factor. The quick travel within sections by pressing square, actually being able to check party member status and change their equipment outside of Tartarus, allowing you to view full skill effects of Personas without having to equip them, and the additional save points are things that don't get brought up as much but honestly do make a pretty big difference in the QoL. Some of the elements of menuing in FES are just so bad, I'm not 100% sure if this was changed in P3P because I haven't played that version in a while, but the fact that in FES the fusion menu, main Persona menu, and the combat Persona menu all use *different* buttons to view the same details of the Persona is just mind boggling. And what's worse, some of the buttons that view details in one menu will dismiss the Persona in another which can really fuck you over if you're not being careful and just quickly mashing through stuff.
But yet, from a presentation standpoint a lot of just simply important elements didn't make it over to P3P so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I really wish they had just made a definitive version. It would've been a lot of work, but P3, of all games, deserves it. And since Atlus still likes to revisit P3 as the sort of pseudo first game of the modern style of the series, it only makes sense to actually have a best version that people can play to understand characters that have appeared in a ton of Persona spinoffs since.
I'll buy p3p but I'll definitely wait for these mods cause they look so good
What if the female mc was actually a femboy mc?????
this is better than atlus doing it for years 💯
P3 needs a full remake. Not just a remaster, but P3P redone in the P5 engine. The FeMC deserves full cutscenes. She deserves her "per so na" awakening moment. And everyone playing deserves a Tartarus with sole actual thought put into it rather than the grinding misery that could fly fifteen years ago but is going to look like shit compared to the fantastic bespoke levels of P5.
I liked Tartarus better than P5's palaces. The puzzles were just wastes of time and nor fun in general, no one would ever shut up in them, and the whole process taking 4-5 days is just stupid. Not to mention the combat is mind numbingly easy, even on the hardest difficulties. In P3P you could do Tartarus at your own pace, no deadlines or anything like that. Also the combat was perfect in terms of difficulty. All of the floors being different every time you go also added some spice! P4's dungeons I feel were the best yet, the combat was still too easy though.
it's called 'Portable' for a reason...
but choosing that over FES for modern remaster is madness...
I think we know why they did portable
Shinjiro gang aproves the ad in the video
Sadly in 2023 this is still the best way to experience P3. Hoping for a P3 Remake soon
Good News: your wish is granted!!😊
Bad News: It's not going to feature the fem protag nor "The Answer" epilogue....😑
So it seems we got monkey paw'd if that's even a word....
Why do the narrators voices sound so familiar?
They probably did stuff for did you know gaming
Has there been any solid confirmation that the official P3P release is going to be a 1 to 1 remaster (ie made HD , but gameplay and mechanics staying the same?).
If not, I half wonder if Atlus's release will low key end up being a definitive edition with FES gameplay, controllable party members, cutscenes, fully explorable maps, but just labelling it as portable as it has the FeMC route included.
I hope, but I do not believe.
Not me beating FES for the first time 4 days ago. Thankfully I actually modded it using all of these and then some, so can vouch for the quality here. A word of warning though, I advise being careful with mods as I managed to somehow cause some of the anime cutscenes to not play, including the ending.
Is there a tutorial or anything you used to get all of this? It seems very overwhelming right now.
Did you play the answer? If the answer is no play the answer
Here's the controllable party cheat code
///Persona 3 FES
// Controllable party members (by TGE)
patch=1,EE,0029AFC8,word,00000000 // nop check for if battle unit is not mc -> ai
patch=1,EE,0020207C,word,00000000 // load proper unit id for battle menu skill list
patch=1,EE,0020208C,word,8F84B6FC
patch=1,EE,00202090,word,8C840254
patch=1,EE,00202094,word,8C840030
patch=1,EE,00202098,word,8C8400A4
patch=1,EE,0028DE14,word,2405001B // fix escape
patch=1,EE,0029692C,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0028AC5C,word,9683001A // disable persona menu for non-mc
patch=1,EE,0028AC60,word,3063FFBF
patch=1,EE,0028AC64,word,A683001A
patch=1,EE,0028AC68,word,96830018
patch=1,EE,0028AC6C,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0028AC70,word,081A6AF8
patch=1,EE,0028AC74,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069ABE0,word,8F82B6FC
patch=1,EE,0069ABE4,word,8C420148
patch=1,EE,0069ABE8,word,14540004
patch=1,EE,0069ABEC,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069ABF0,word,34630400
patch=1,EE,0069ABF4,word,A6830018
patch=1,EE,0069ABF8,word,34630400
patch=1,EE,0069ABFC,word,080A2B1D
patch=1,EE,0069AC00,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,001FF518,word,8E300254 // fix skill requirements
patch=1,EE,001FF51C,word,8E100030
patch=1,EE,001FF520,word,8E1000A4
patch=1,EE,001FF524,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,001FF528,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,001FF52C,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,002D8210,word,00000000 // fix items
patch=1,EE,002D8220,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,002D8224,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,002D823C,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,002A3914,word,081A6B01 // fix boss battle camera
patch=1,EE,0069AC04,word,1240000B
patch=1,EE,0069AC08,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069AC0C,word,8E420030
patch=1,EE,0069AC10,word,844700A2
patch=1,EE,0069AC14,word,20030001
patch=1,EE,0069AC18,word,14E00006
patch=1,EE,0069AC1C,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069AC20,word,844200A4
patch=1,EE,0069AC24,word,10430003
patch=1,EE,0069AC28,word,00001021
patch=1,EE,0069AC2C,word,080A8E47
patch=1,EE,0069AC30,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069AC34,word,0C0BE210
patch=1,EE,0069AC38,word,00000000
patch=1,EE,0069AC3C,word,080A8E47
patch=1,EE,0069AC40,word,00000000
Copy and paste all of this into a new text document, and name it "94A82AAA_controlparty.pnach (You may need to change it from a txt file to a pnach file, but be sure to do this
I think FES is the best version, Portable is an inferior version, it's not the true experience, it's like when a big console title got a Gameboy version that wasn't the real game because of limitations.
I'm very disappointed. They could have ported FES adding full control of the party to make the ultimate definitive version.
hey look, p3fes, my favorite game ♥️
Edit: THEY ANNOUNCED A PERSONA 3 REMAKE LETS GOOOOOOO
Video starts at 4:33
Last time i checked passive healing/mp regen skills dont work well with the controllable party cheat. Did somebody found a way to fix it?
As a video encoder with around 8 years of experiece I have to say that I do think we could do something about the anime cutscenes. I have encoded mostly anime and while I usually preserve the original ratio and resolution and keep filters tame, I have experimented with upscaling old DVD footage before and depending on how well the footage has been rendered before it was pressed on the disc, I sometimes could get some pretty amazing results with the right filter settings in place.
I don't know how the footage is stored on a game disc though and if it would be possible to extract it lossless in a format, that can be processed by programs like VirtualDubMod.
But even if the raw footage would be in a bad shape and not that much improvement can get squeezed out, I think it would still certainly look better than just taking over the original footage like what you showed in the video.
Yeaaa p3p was my first persona.
I’m sorry that it ruined your first experience with p3 ):
@@butterflydreamer9649 I'm sorry that your taste in games is trash ):
I've never really messed around with mods like this as I'm a bit of a purist, but I still admire this kind of work from afar and it's nice to see it all showcased in a presentation that does it justice. Awesome work as always, Jon. =)
I have original hardware and Fes and the only change id make is increasing EXP by up too 50% and sub members not in party gaining XP. For a few months the original full team is just fine then all the sudden there’s a hard counter and grinding gets real obnoxious with the protag getting sick from exhaustion.
It's still insane to me that they haven't given us another female MC option after so many years... P6?
These cheat codes are actually mods, they're just machine code patches to edit the raw code of the game to fix things. It's kinda given away by the comments like "nop check for if battle unit is not mc -> ai". Since the modifications are so small and simple, mostly minor adjustments to control flow that fit in place, they can be done just as cheat codes using a cheat device.
WHAT??? PERSONA 3 IS MY FAVORITE PERSONA AND I'VE NEVER PLAYED THE FEM PROTAG VER AND I DIDN'T KNOW THEY MADE IT A POINT AND CLICK GAME OUTSIDE OF DUNGEONS WTF. SDFLSJF ;SJFK That upsets me. D:< I just love exploring so much and to see it reduced...although. I'd be lying if I said shaving down about 20 hours doesn't sound appealing...
Someone is also attempting to make a 3d hub for P3P and even though its only one section that kinda works its crazy how someone is able to pull it off
Multiple locations have been added since then, and they got shops and stuff working too on the overworld
Hey, look! One of my mods made it into a cool video! Deinterlaced Cutscenes and High Quality Music are other mods that I’d give a HUGE shoutout to! We’ve tried to mod Persona 3 FES to match the modern day standards as best as we can without access to the original assets.
I'm hoping these remaster mods will be made for the pc port as well. I can stand these really old games getting very minimal remasters.
I'm thinking I'll probably just play that FES mod and then do a FeMC playthrough of portable whenever that comes out
HostFS for Persona 3 FES is no longer available. None of this works without it. What a bummer.
Yeah I was trying to get it running last night and ran into that too... hopefully we get a workaround somehow
If you didn't already, check the site again for HostFS. Shrine Fox just updated it a little bit ago.
"I guess if you're a heathen you can just stretch the image, but don't do that or *_I'll get you_* ". That last part was so unexpected lol. I would have spit my drink out if I were having any.
Let the record stand that P3P looks great on Vita.
I second that statement
Will those mods work on the Undub patched versions of the games?
You need an unmodifed USA ISO of the game. We do, however, have an undub mod you can add so you can play undub with other mods!
@@Aikerin Good to hear, thank you.