Re:Zero Greed IF Story Animatic
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 авг 2024
- This animatic contains spoilers for Re:Zero’s Greed If story.
Este animatic contiene spoilers de Re:Zero, la ruta de la codicia.
Thanks for watching! Consider subscribing for more!
Thank you to Aingero for the Spanish translation! / ¡Gracias Aingero por la traducción al español!
Art: Willow412 (me!)
Echidna: Moth MakesSense VA
-Discord: Moth.#7458
-Twitter: Moth MakesSense VA @MothVa
Music: mafumafu 命に嫌われている。(Life Hates Us Now.)
Story: Tappei Nagatsuki
Softwares Used: AutoDesk Sketchbook (mobile), iMovie (mobile), Photoshop
Time taken: 18 days (May 8-25)
Total Sketchbook Layers: 1,087
Phew! It’s finally done! This took way longer than everything else I’ve done, but I’m glad I stuck with it!
Despite being shorter than my Gluttony If animatic, this managed to take eleven more days and far over twice as many layers. My phone storage is dying!
Thanks for watching, and huge thanks to Moth MakesSense VA for playing Echidna! I really hope to do more like this in the future!
Follow me on Twitter if you want: / willow4127
[Ah, even so――]
[――Why must love, always fade?]
#rezero #リゼロ
This animatic contains spoilers for the Re:Zero Greed If Story. Thanks for watching, and thanks to Moth for voicing Echidna! Consider subscribing for more
I am going to be honest I didn't notice any mistakes, I was to busy admiring the amazing art and edit, nice job
GOOOF JOOOB !!!!! NICE ANIMATION :")
Great job indeed, but there is one thing I do not understand: at 3:38 we can see Minerva right before Satella. Could you explain why is she significant enough to be shown? I can't remember her even being mentioned in the Greed IF
@@Kelibarth Oh yeah!! I included Minerva because in the canon route, she’s the one who interrupts Echidna and Subaru’s contract. She’s the one who appears and tells him it’s a bad idea. Her significance in Kasaneru IS the fact that she doesn’t appear-or at least, those were my thoughts while I was making this!
@@willow4124 Oh, that makes sense now that I think about it. Thanks a lot!
Trade offer: you receive echidna guidance but Otto leaves
Subaru : I'm never gonna emotionally recover from this
Neither will we.
Otto has something to do with Pandora so her goals wouldn't be able to be achieved so I'm not sure how that would effect Otto.
@@Donsps5 most probably* but it isn't 100%
@@greenmix6586 wait wait wait... What?
@@szalyn8849 Otto changed his decision and left Subaru only when he accepted Echidna's contract. In all other If stories he kept going with Subaru. Also his hair colour is a bit similar to Pandora's. He also seems to have an interested in a book that Roswaal had, which was one of the things that Witch cult needs, if I remember correctly
Greed IF is definitely one of the saddest ifs. Subaru has to go through millions of deaths to get through everything by himself, but he never gets his happy ending. Emilia’s broken, Beatrice is depressed, Reinhard is depressed, Garfiel is resentful, Ram is cold and distant, only Roswaal and Echidna are happy.
Yeah im pretty sure someone did the math and said that he went through 270,000 years of just dying
I guess that really depends on how long it takes to get from one checkpoint to another, it makes a big difference if it's daily, weekly or every few hours. I guess that 270 000 years makes sense with daily checkpoints, but we can't confirm it was always the case.
@@Jk_fk Subaru this time wasn’t fighting, he was controlling things from the back. So I assume checkpoints are rather distant.
Subaru risked months of progress in order to tell Petra the day’s weather. I don’t know if you can call that “ has to go through”. I agree that he isn’t having a good time though.
I’m pretty sure the checkpoints are pretty recent if he’s not in a life threatening situation, like when he killer himself to try and go back to save Rem. The only reason he goes back multiple days is if he needs to go back that far to be safe.
It's implied deep down that Subaru knew he made the wrong choice to accept Echidna's offer - which is what further motivates his desire to be inhumanely perfect in the eyes of his friends (right down to correctly guessing the weather - which mildly surprised Echidna at one point when she and Subaru spoke again at the end of the story). It's gotten to where he feels "I dug myself in too far, might as well go further."
*Echidna:* why must love always fade?
*Me:* It is our duty to rekindle it.
cause greed
the answer is: because you have an authority.
@Defito Ash you read it too?
@Defito Ash already done, did you join the fanfic kingdom and his discord server? It's fun talking to him.
@Defito Ash eyy, another fan fic reader
Ngl WHDAA opened fanfics for me
Seeing satella cry really broke my heart. From art to symbolism. Everything was amazing!! So beautiful
I imagine she was crying because she felt bad for him?
@@buniboi2163 True, in the end she loves Subaru so she will definitly at least feel bad if he suffers
@@alinastanescu4430 (for some reason didn't get this notification) Why didn't she try to stop him in Greed though.. i know it's an IF path but still, unless her and the others didn't show up. But why would Subaru accept it? Reason can't be only to make her happy.. right?
@@buniboi2163 well in the end she wants subaru to choose his own path.
@@mananpatel9235 i think we re zero fan really understand the show right
I feel really bad for satella,literally watched the love of her life get stolen from her by another witch AND see him get tortured More and more.
I feel like Satella would enjoy that.... Dunno, i haven't watched Re:Zero 2nd season
@@cc9787 ...Dude...Finish the series and you'll understand.
@@cc9787 satella wants the good for Subaru
Yeah finish the 2nd season, it's great so far.
With the very same power she gave him to live, Echidna wasn't lying when she said she was an evil witch
Re:Zero is the only series that makes me go from, "wow, these first episodes of the arc are so cool, everything is chill, a lot of interesting dialog and interactions between characters" to "How did everything degenerate into this, my boy Subaru only wanted something to eat from the convenience store" while reading it, this happens to me in every arc however this if story makes that feeling even stronger, it pains me a lot to see Subaru in such a state, i mean in the other if routes at least he has a bit of control over what's going on, but here?
My respects to slothbaru though, he got the girl and formed a happy family, good for him.
Hah....arc 5 and Wrath....I remember that....just let him get back from the convenient store will ya?
Gluttony if hits harder in my opinion
@@user-ee7nc8bi4n yeah cuz instead of someone else doing the deed it's him killing the people he cares about only to find out he cared for them and they cared for him back........when he gets the memories back, he's nothing but a worthless husk.....even lower than before he was isekai'd and it's technically his fault AND he can't put himself out of misery.......sheesh
Slothbaru left Ram and Emilia to die, Garfel traumatized and I don't know if beatrice died but if not she still could be in a libary. Oh an Otto probably starved/died/was turned to cultist or something like that
Maybe Subaru might be happy but all the persons he cared/would cared about died or are left to suffer a years to come
Slotharu is actually kinda depressing since iirc his checkpoint never updated so when Subaru dies of old age he’ll go right back to before everything with rem happened
So greed if is everyone is alive but everyone except Roswaal and Echidna are depressed.
This why abuse of the return by death isn't the answers.
Seeing Emilia going insane was so sad :(
Honestly everything is sad
@@YTraveler Except Roswaal
@@alinastanescu4430 and Echidna
This the most depressing IF out of them all. Subaru kills himself and abuses his RBD power. Death means nothing to him. He doesn’t care about himself.
@ahsjkfnd Sushzoor muss agree here gluttony is more depressing
@ahsjkfnd Sushzoor I mean while reading gluttony was more depressing but if you think about it later then you will feel greed was even wayy more depressing. Imagine dying million times.
@@srimanjha5112 idk, I've seen gluttony if , getting killed by the guy who you put in your trust so much is sad
@@srimanjha5112 - at least Greed knows who he is and has some sort of guidance - he is achieving his goals with the price being the complete lack of self-worth and the Emilia camp never solving their own problems like Emilia never getting over her childhood trauma or Garfiel coming to terms with his past. (that's partly the reason why Otto left, because Subaru took everything on himself). As for Gluttony, he doesn't even realise he IS the real Natsuki Subaru and it is quite obvious to the audience that Gluttony's plan to read all the books of the dead is doomed to fail from the start.
@@srimanjha5112 both are pretty depressing in their own ways. In one way, Subaru doesn't value his life and wastes it like it's nothing, leaving him mentally broken. On the other hand we have Subaru who is living with the false notion that once "Subaru" is complete, he will fix everything. So he goes and kills everyone and reads their book in order to become "himself", but it doesn't do shit and never will.
I am just amazed how Subaru is always on the brisk of taking the wrong decision but ends up doing the right thing 🙏🏻🙏🏻👌🏼
Everybody is safe and will continue to be safe because Subaru gave up. He did not give up and stop, he gave up his freedom and feelings for the sake that everybody is alive and in some distorted way...in peace. Everybody is not happy and Subaru is also not happy. Hell, is Echidna even happy, "Why must love fade?". even as Omega she did not feel any great sensation in being "alive" and sensing things again. Whether she has Subaru to clear all the routes of the world like a player from a VN or becoming Omega....is she really happy?
I'm pretty sure nobody is happy. I bet even Rosawal is not happy, he just is delusional that he is. Everybody is safe, everybody will continue to move on in peace, but without being happy.
well we can assume that this vesion of subaru will find the peaceful soloution to everything, having a witch at his side with this knowledge and no humanity, i guess he could even become the ruler of whole re zero
@Iamfromvjetnam Hmm, this is from a LN series. Although more specific this side story comes from a tweet the author gives every April first on Subaru’s birthday.
They are a basically what ifs? What if Subaru would have given up on the moral way and decided for the sin. Each what if story is a cardinal sin like greed. This specific what if is the Greed route.
They are also little easter eggs and foreshadow of future events.
This what if story made me realize how important Minerva did by stopping Subaru on taking that contract.
This is really good! I especially like the part where Subaru is holding his hand out for the butterfly. It can be seen as him accepting Echidna's contract.
On the other hand it can be seen as his willingness to die using it as a tool as butterfly's can be seen as symbol for death as well
Yep! I was thinking about both of those, and also the butterfly effect-Return by Death is the ultimate tool of an inquirer. Everything in the world could be dependent on Subaru’s actions. There’s a ton of symbolism you can draw out of it 😁
@@willow4124 damn that's another great one! Great job on this amazing anmatic!
Butterfly is not as much a symbol of death, as of rebirth, change, renewal and hope. Come to think of it, in the S2 ED you can see Beatrice reaching for a butterfly, but it doesn't land on her hand, implying the future rejects her.
@@user-li5cr6wv5b did Tappei-sensei know that when he wrote it? Everything in rezero has so many hidden meanings as an average follower it’s so hard to notice them
@@DivineSeaDragon thats why its great
If you think about it, otto is the one who prevented this from happening
Otto played a part, but Minerva is definitely the biggest reason. She undeniably saved Subaru from a terrible, unavoidable fate.
Amazing work as always Willow!!! Hype
One last comment before this disappeared
[Attempting to both secure the future of those precious to you and to keep your human heart, you are choosing the path of exceptional difficulty. And above all else... - that of Greed.]
He is actually compatible with greed as a witch factor.
@@aburriiiiiiiiiiido that's because he's a safe candidate
Reading this if story after finishing the trumphant ending of arc 4 is so nauseating, sad, horrible and nauseating again. He'll eventually gets whatever he would want, but not what he really was after, a future where everyone, including him, could smile genuinely and be a happy ending.
Great animatic!
well he is succesful, no matter which opponent, no matter how bad the situation, he will safe everyone, by sacrificing his humanity, his self worth, he become worse than any villain could ever be, by the time we reach the original greed if subaru is already are old man, unable to smile with in his friends, the people he actually cared about are empty shells, he has reinhard, but still feels guilty to what he did to felt and how it crushed reinhard, he has this guilt over all his decisions that he made, the thought alone that he may have made a mistake terrifies him to his soul, therefore allowing him to dig deeper into that destructive terrifying act for dying, he doesnt care anymore
Best Artworks Subaru for IF Greed
I Love it
Im very love this song too
ironically how the song used in this video by mafumafu tells you to value your life and make the most out of it.
meanwhile greed subaru throwing his life away everyday to achive his goals...
This was so well made.All the if stories are so intresting and i havent read them all but all the ones i have read have been really really good.
Willow, there are literal tears in my eyes. The song choice, how the lyrics and images go together, the gorgeous images, the mood, the lighting, the focus on the butterfly flapping its wings. It all came together so beautifully. Gorgeous. Absolutely amazing.
“And so, the man who could only thrive through death, was hated by life itself”
Subaru can't feel emotions properly in this if heck he has to put on a facade larger then ever
This was awesome! And moth and the end saying echidna's classic line, chills. Great work Willow!
The greed if story is amazing ngl.
tbh I think it's one of the weaker if stories out, but what makes it so intriguing is how close it was to actually happening
@@prosoul396 it's weakly written, but the potential it has is *immense*
@@dead3067 What are you even talking about? There's nothing weakly written about it. It's simply a day in the monotonous life of a Subaru that's willing to kill himself and repeat over and over again due to the smallest details. It does its job well.
Every ReZero story is amazing. Well, except Lust if
@@dead3067 It's INCREDIBLY written! The desperation is tangible. Every second of Greed IF is gut-wrenching and unbearable, and even though it's not the most catastrophic IF, it manages to be the saddest by far (for me, at least).
I cannot wait until you do Oboreru as it is my favorite IF:Story, specially if you end up using Frozen Rain from Myth & Royd, this Animatics are all just too good to not rewatch them all over and over again, i still remember when your Pride:IF animatic was released on Subaru Bday, i already Re:Watched it several times, and i cannot seem to get enough of it lol, keep on doing the good work!
6 emilia in re zero if story
Pride if : sad emilia
Wrath if : simp emilia
Sloth if : death emilia
Greed if : yandere emilia
Gluttony if : fake emilia
Lust if : b**ch emilia
Lol
Comment ça yandere?
@@tinae1492She was gonna kill Beatrice because she saw the scratches on Subaru’s neck and knew Beatrice did it, that’s why Subaru was practicing his smile in the mirror because he knew he would need it for Emilia
Remember, dont accept contracts guys
And especially not by lovely maidens who offer you bodily fluid tea 🍵
We still want Trap IF. Don't you think you can run from it.
Opa, vc por aqui kkkk
Another amazing animatic
I am so confused how you able to produce such quality on a phone
Honestly I don’t blame Subaru. He was already doomed from the beginning. His choice never mattered when some monster is out to get him.
I mean it technically does matter since his choice is what changed the route he went down, but yeah from his point of view things are pretty bleak
Uau está increíble, buen trabajo.
Back at it again with another amazing animatic, it looks amazing.
This looks great!!! Thank you for animating this I’ve heard of the greed if but I’m so glad to see it animated like this
Luckily Subaru didn't accept the contract
...OR DID HE? (Illuminati theme intensifies)
@@tiredtraveler4536 you mean the witch theme
@@tiredtraveler4536 "Mystery theme" = "Call of the Witch"
Looked great and the song choice fits really well thanks for making it, it was nice seeing the greed if in a animatic,
I have been repeating this video for perhaps the 10th time already and I had to comment. Amazing work, thank you for this sad but beautiful art.
Poor Betty...
Betty lost herself in depression
Emilia lost herself in madness
and at the same Satella Sees Subaru with pain...
It is Too sad
Haven't even read it, just watched a video summarizing it, but man.. still tugs at my heart
Nice work
You Sir did a beautiful work
That Face expression is just astonishing
Specially Satella and Betty, Emilia
They should do the IF stories as Re:Zero movies
Guys let get this video to 105 k
216,548 views!
ENGLISH LYRICS
Don’t say you want to die.
Live on without giving up!
...How foolish it is to say songs with lyrics like that are correct.
In truth, I couldn’t care a bit if I died, but I’d be pretty sad if the people around me did.
I suppose it’s some kind of ego; that goes “because I just wouldn’t like it”
-
Not caring if strangers live or not,
And hating someone else just seems like some kind of fashion now.
But “Live peacefully” nevertheless?
What a wonderful thing that would be indeed...
-
On the other side of the screen, someone dies
Lamenting that, someone else sings.
Influenced by that, a young boy
Ran off carrying a knife.
-
We are hated by life itself.
Pushing values and ego,as always
So very simply we broadcast songs about wanting to kill somebody else over radio waves.
We are hated by life itself.
We who thoughtlessly say we want to die And look at life thoughtlessly, are hated by it.
-
I’ve got no money, and so throughout the day again,I sing songs of praise to indolence
Still without grasping the meaning of life,
I come to a epiphany that it’s pointless and take a breath.
Are these wounds really ok to be
Expressed with words like “I’m lonely”
-
Carrying nothing but such obstinacy
Today again I sleep alone on my bed.
We who were but youths at some point start to change into young adults.
Growing old, one day we rot away like fallen leaves with not a soul in the world knowing of our existence.
-
Obtaining an immortal body, and living our whole existence without dying…
...I’m just daydreaming about these kinds of science fiction situations..
I couldn’t care a bit if I died,
But I’m wanted alive by people around me
Living on and carrying such contradictions...
I think I’ll get yelled at.
-
“Things that are “correct” should stay “correct””
“If you don’t want to die, then live”
If we’re going to end up sad and if that’s fine,
Then you gotta laugh alone forever.
-
We are hated by life itself.
Without even grasping the meaning of joy, we just hate the hand life has dealt us and merely curse our pasts.
We are hated by life itself.
We who simply like the idea of the word “goodbye” a little too much,
with no knowledge of a true farewell, are hated by life itself.
-
Happiness, farewells, love and friendship;
They’re all goods that can be bought for money… within jokes made by comical dreams.
I might just die tomorrow you know,
Everything might just end up being for naught.
Mornings and nights,
spring and autumn,
Unchanging,
someone dies somewhere.
I don’t need dreams or even a tomorrow
If you’ll have lived on then that’s all I need.
Yeah..so..
That’s actually what I want to sing about!!!!
-
Hated by life itself
In the end, we’ll die anyway
You will, I will,
one day all of us will rot away like fallen leaves.
But regardless, we live on frantically--
Shouldering our lives, frantically, we live--
Killing, struggling,
laughing, shouldering it all
Living, living, living, living-- just live.
I hope The lyrics make sense and you guys can understand it with the video... normally I don’t do stuff like this at all haha, but I been listening to this, watching this animatic and love it to bits. Re:Zero is personally my #1 anime and seeing this and your other videos... I knew I had to stick around and see what else you come up with! Now you’re a part of prominence studios making a name for yourself in the community!
Thank you for your work! It’s really great! I look forward to seeing more in the future!!!
Imagine dropping the song with the English name that would be funny i think
@@averagemohgjoyer456 description.
@@pohncam the thing is I've looked in the description but I couldn't find it. I finally found it after looking again thanks
Oh my god I am listening to this song for months now without ever knowing the lyrics. Idk if that's a coincidence but I know why that hits me now.
im in love with your stuff - all of it - thank you so much for contributing this sort of stuff oh my god
Bro these are amazing
HOLY-
How haven't I found you before? Why doesn't this have more views? This is fucking awesome!!
GAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I WAS SO HYPED FOR THIS AND IT TWAS SO GOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDD. Well done Willow! I loved how well you brought across the completely dead inside GreedBaru. Moth was great too! As was your Elsa!
this is amazing
that quote on the end was a magnificent addition
This song though. Makes me cry once again
Woah, this is great, amazing work!
Crazy work, animation and music. I don't often put likes, well, it's fully deserved here... It's a pity to evaluate the work differently!
This makes me really happy and it’s incredible work there I really like theses stories you make!
Me encanto❤❤
If you don't know why emilia has short hair bc Subaru everyday visit rem to check that rem is ok and emilia think that is Subaru like short hair so that emilia cut her hair
Funny how in the other IF Rem grew her hair out to look more like Emilia
Tappei loves his parallels
Great art! Sums up the IF pretty well.
Underrated
Underrated
this is so good!!!
Heavily underrated video
Damn...... This is very good
Oh yes! I cant wait for all IF Story
Good, nice work
That's flipping amazing man!
I find this the saddest cuz there is no end.
No end to Subaru's isolation and dying.
no conclusion to if he ever will save rem and get to an end
Yup. Out of all the stories, Greed and Gluttony has no end.
@@a5hen thats because canon story isnt finished yet i doubt that we want spoiler
@@lordescanor8232 even if the canon story finishes, there still won't be an end due to the nature of the sins.
The author stated in one of his QnA's once that Greed IF Subaru would never be able to wake Rem up from what I remember. I think because he'd never be able to find Gluttony no matter what he or Echidna tried. None of the IF end except for Pride where Subaru actually does die. Sloth IF seems like it has an ending but when Subaru dies of old age he'll just be return by death back to the appa stand. That's why he never dies once in Sloth IF. Aganau IF showed him returning by death 20 years back into the past and in another QnA the author stated Pride was the only IF he stayed dead because Subaru has to fulfil the goal of the person making him Return by Death which is either Satella or Subaru himself when he said he'd "absolutely save Emilia".
LETS GOOO!!, its so well made
amazing work dude, this had me floored
aaaAAAAAAHHHH HOLY SHIT WILLOW!!!
this truly blew me away
everything from the beautiful art, color choices, and symbolism to the amazing song choice... not gonna lie, i teared up a bit at the end. great work! Out of all the IF stories, Greed IF's my favorite, and you've certainly done it justice!
1:30 this is the exact look Echidna was giving him from the day one, Echidna was like " Witch of Envy" who wants him but appears to act normal while cornering Subaru into accepting her, both don't care whether Subaru hate them and are fine as long as Subaru is with them, unlike Satella who actually don't want to be hated by him, even if Echidna got bored of him she's not giving him to Satella
Actually echidna wont get bored if if she did she will still help subaru, thats also their contract
However subaru doesnt even want to talk to echidna anymore i wonder who is bored subaru or echidna... subaru is already on the track of being the perfect human and he has reinhard/elsa and probably even more strong mates in the future
He could probably make halibel ceciles join his side too
That was fucking awesome.
Not only the Animation was really good but also the music was perfect 👏👏👏
WOOOOW Willow!!! Excellent work!!!! I'm always so blown away by your talent!!
I feel really bad for Subaru
Subaru has no trauma his life is trauma
Couldn't have played any better song bro
Nice work.
All if story costumes , i like greed if costume the most , it kinda fit to him
Nice my fav anime characters in re zero ... Subaru .. + it was my fav artist who sings this song ...
This Is good, And the song matches, Is named "Hated for life itself " Is of an artist named "Mafu Mafu"
dang it *sniff* why was this so good *sniff* especially the art with Emilia :(
It’s curious that Echidna kind of acts like the ‘Butterfly Effect’, AND has the motif/theme of it because she has a butterfly hair-clip. Despite moths being more of a witch symbol.
Loved this can’t wait for wrath
Comentário aleatório em português avisando que esse vídeo fico bom d+
é bom ver algum br aqui
Concordo
Mi español te entiende a medias.
Opa kkk
It will fit very good if this song one day will be an opening of re zero
I love Re:Zero for the amount of emotion it can put in just a short chapter, Greed : IF is a perfect example of this.
Great video! Enable subtitles! The music and lyrics fit absurdly well! 0.55 is my favorite line :)
Subaru saved everyone ....but at what cost ?
Absolutely amazing 😭🤝
Sometimes I wish I wasn't busy
and could do something like this myself
😭😭😭
Pog ! Another animatic video. Thanks
good stuff man
love this
this is great
Amazing work
*pretends to know what happened*
thank you for this beautiful content
It's an IF story where Subaru chooses to accept Echidna's contract.
no i mean i'm saying this as someone who doesn't read it or watch it
@@Jwle7 wait if that's the case, hpw the hell did you end up here?
@@yusufahmed715 Jwle7 and I are friends 😆
Damn, I haven't seen an animatic like this in years. I got so nostalgic.
Great video!
Well Done! Dude I love all your work so far, all your animatics I feel perfectly encompass the IF stories and consequences that come out of them.
YOOO THAT LOOKS SO GOOD!!!
i'm also doing an animatic with that music but, its about an videogame.
great work!
But man Subarus story is basically always tragic
Amazing 🤩
Buen video
It is like music is written for it. Magnificent
Damn i wish that there was some kind of OVA for every what if in re zero and maybe mini series from sloth if bcs it's the longest