I think for $350 it is a bit pricy for a well built box and a slightly improved book! If the MBM had been an actual book then yes. Also the closing strap is missing from it!
Really good point of the strap. And yes they really missed out of not making the monster book of monster the real thing. Like put the creatures vault as the monster book 🤔
I wish they’d just make a proper bestiary book already. One that makes me feel like I’m in the restricted section trying to find something to do with Basilisks. None of the prop pictures etc. Like a proper Wizarding world creature guide.
I don't know what's been made/not made to the publlic, but some ideas for replicas...The Weasleys' locator clock; a nice place setting of the official Hogwarts dishes from lunch or dinner; a few of Dumbledore's mysterious mechanical devices; cauldrons(!).
Same book tbh! It would be an adjustable fabric cover of the beastiary and could fit any/most large books, cause I imagine that one is quite hefty as its made from acrylic?
This book was originally part of a whole set of books some time back now.. They then released it again as a stand alone book.. I was to say around 2020. But could be earlier…I know I spotted it for sale around then I believe.. I did an unboxing and review on my Instagram on 21 February 2020.. The monster book is amazing. I did love it. However for me what let it down was the missed opportunity of making the limited edition book smaller and the two fitting together… Just having a different cover on the book was not enough in itself.. if the book had fitted in the box then it would have more of a purpose.. Its too fragile to keep opening and not really big enough to store much.. it takes up a lot of space on a shelf and too fragile to have stuff on top of it. The original version came with several books and a display stand (bookshelf) that they all lived on… ps some awesome books in that set.. wish I had bought it back in the day… The Monster book of Monsters is one of my all time favourite props.. This one is Ultimately cute.. however in the long run I retuned my box as it was not for me… to me a prop replica should look and feel like the original.. This is a box is nothing like the books at the Studio tour and was let down by the “limited edition” book not fitting inside…
Yes we need the fully readeable school books really want them too be readeable not like note books. Would buy them instandly. And from Rita her books. Wish they made the monster book of monster a real book. Like made the creatures vault the actual book not just a box plus the book. Still thinking too buy it because it looks really good. Still need a proper golden egg. The big one that complitely opens up and looks amazing on the inside. And a proper size wizarding cup. Some really nice portraits that really hang on the walls in the movies would be nice ❤
I bought this last week after seeing this video. It IS a lot of money to spend on something that is so fragile I'm afraid to display out of the foam protective packaging, but it's BEAUTIFUL! I suppose $350 for the version of the prop replica that I wanted Noble Collection to do plus a collector edition of the Creature Vault book is probably worth that considering the cheap cardboard version is $50. I mentioned to Insight Editions that I bought it after seeing your review. For people who are willing to spend the money for this to add to their HP collection it is definitely worth the price. I think the fact that it is a BOX that could be put on a stand with small HP souvenirs like the Gringots coin collection, potion bottles, and the small horcrux replicas inside for display is what made it really worth the price for me. Thanks for your review Cherry!
I really want an official replica rememberall in my collection. There was one from a subscription box that come up on ebay but I want an authentic one from Nobel. Maybe one day they will make one :)
Overall, this is bad. The book should be part of the item, so that it is, in actual fact, a book. The eyes are too low profile. The area in front of the eyes is wrong - it should be furry.
I'm in the process of doing our little first home up to sell for a bigger property so we can have a extra guest bedroom and games room and I can't wait to collect all harry potter memorabilia.. we have lots of starwars Grogu and Lord of the rings but Harry potter is next.. I can't wait . I just don't want to buy now for it all to be stuck in boxes. . I'm also so excited for your little shop .. I can't wait for your website to start selling items xx
I have this! It's beautiful and I actually have it sitting on the floor peeking out from under the bed! I know it's an expensive replica to put on the floor but it really looks cool there, I promise! Thanks for comparing the creatures vault book too! I've always wondering what the different is between the editions but I only have the one that came with the monster book! I would love more Luna related items!
It's not a replica...it's a late 1970s original piece . The light made from crystals in the Half-Blood Prince at the house Prof Slughorn is squatting in...the one they put back together & Harry is standing on one crystal...that is in my house. I actually liked it when we first moved in (many years ago now) & then I realized the same light is in the movie so i really don't want to change it!! It's a beast to clean but it's gorgeous & so sparkly next to the double window in my dining room.
It’s been on my wish list for a long time now. Initially, the only way to get it was to buy the complete deluxe Hogwarts library that currently sell for $800 + CAD. I am happy that they’re now selling it on its own. I think it’s been 1-2 years
Its nice but its not £278 nice...Basically made around a plastic box, its marketed as a screen replica and for me and its easy to compare...its not, and the book is just a revamped old book. Liked your jumper though Cherry👍
Awesome review as ‘always’… checked my standard copy of the creature vault and it only came with the one poster. Sadly this is outside my price range but one can dream 😂
I would’ve liked it to be the actual size of the original book and have pages instead of being a box. The outside looks nice but I just think it’s a bit small.
That is pricey in my currency it's double so nearly $600 , it would be better if they can actually make these book props in to actual books an not boxes.
Hi Cherry! Thank you for reviewing The Monsters Book Of Monsters for us!! It's gorgeous!!😍 There are quite a few different prop replicas from the HP & FB movies that I would love to have, one of them being in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald and its Nicholas Flamel's crystal ball. Omg I would love to own it!! Take care!! Xoxo 💙💜💚
I think this is gorgeous and I love that it's functional, I could definitely think of some things to store in there. For what you get, I don't think the price is outrageous, but I think they should be up front in that the price is really for two things... it seems kind of disingenuous to price it so high and then "throw in" another book, almost like forcing you to do a combo deal. Especially for collectors who, like you, may already have another version of the book and might not want another copy. They easily could have sold these separately rather than forcing you to get both.
The school books would be cool. As for the Monster Book of Monsters, the supplies for making it are around $50-$75. The only reason for it to be $300+ USD would be because it is Harry Potter related and sold by a major replica company.
Yes they are totally worth watching, but if u don't like violence or if u are sensitive and get scared easily, u don't need to watch them, or watch them but with a parent, personally I watched them all at 6 or 7 years old sobi reccomend! ♡
I think they missed a trick by not putting the "special addition " book inside the monsters one. Basically all they did was change the cover and add a poster, making it smaller to fit would have cost more.
Did the book fit in the box? Didn’t look like it. For me it would be worth it if instead of a box it was actually the book when you opened it. Wishful thinking I’m sure. Enjoyed the video 🧡🖤🧡
Are there any MUST HAVE Harry Potter replicas that are new on the scene?
First! Love you cherry❤❤❤
THE SORTING HAT
I think they should definitely make more magical creatures like a Pygmy puff I would buy❤
IDK if I've missed it already being but I think a Nimbus 2000 would be an excellent addition to the replica collection!😮
@@marshawargo7238cinereplicas still offers the nimbus 2000 for $499 USD quite a few channels have done videos on them!
I prefer to see this "Monster book of monsters" replica like real book already. That would be coolest, I think.
Couldn't agree more! Seems like a no brainer 2me. Maybe even just put the creatures vault inside it n create like a mixture
I think for $350 it is a bit pricy for a well built box and a slightly improved book! If the MBM had been an actual book then yes. Also the closing strap is missing from it!
I agree! If it was a replica it would be worth $350 USD! For $700 AUD I could get a really thick, big, fully illustrated book of shadows from charmed!
Really good point of the strap. And yes they really missed out of not making the monster book of monster the real thing. Like put the creatures vault as the monster book 🤔
Rita Skeeters book, and the advanced potion making would be awesome as a real props/books !
That looks amazing! I also agree the school books would be cool to have not just notebooks that look like the book.
A good way you could display it, is by getting on of those cheap plastic angled laptop stands. That would showcase him nicely on a shelf. ❤
Love your videos! You can put all your creature pages from the subscription boxes inside😃
Yes! Perfect!
Ha lovely idea!
Your one collection behind you is magnificent
Would love to see replicas of the House of Black china set you can see in the background at 12 Grimmauld Place kitchen. Such a beautiful set.
They can make me a prop replica of Sirius Black. I'd buy that so fast.
Can't wait to see it on the shelf! ❤❤❤
me too
I love your vocal sound effects. I think they should make a battery operated womping willow with the Ford Angela stuck in it.
As a money box😊
I wish they’d just make a proper bestiary book already. One that makes me feel like I’m in the restricted section trying to find something to do with Basilisks. None of the prop pictures etc. Like a proper Wizarding world creature guide.
I would love a replica of Luna's Lion hat
I don't know what's been made/not made to the publlic, but some ideas for replicas...The Weasleys' locator clock; a nice place setting of the official Hogwarts dishes from lunch or dinner; a few of Dumbledore's mysterious mechanical devices; cauldrons(!).
Same book tbh!
It would be an adjustable fabric cover of the beastiary and could fit any/most large books, cause I imagine that one is quite hefty as its made from acrylic?
Omgosh that is so cool! Love the attention to detail
This book was originally part of a whole set of books some time back now..
They then released it again as a stand alone book.. I was to say around 2020. But could be earlier…I know I spotted it for sale around then I believe.. I did an unboxing and review on my Instagram on 21 February 2020..
The monster book is amazing. I did love it. However for me what let it down was the missed opportunity of making the limited edition book smaller and the two fitting together… Just having a different cover on the book was not enough in itself.. if the book had fitted in the box then it would have more of a purpose..
Its too fragile to keep opening and not really big enough to store much.. it takes up a lot of space on a shelf and too fragile to have stuff on top of it.
The original version came with several books and a display stand (bookshelf) that they all lived on… ps some awesome books in that set.. wish I had bought it back in the day…
The Monster book of Monsters is one of my all time favourite props.. This one is Ultimately cute.. however in the long run I retuned my box as it was not for me… to me a prop replica should look and feel like the original.. This is a box is nothing like the books at the Studio tour and was let down by the “limited edition” book not fitting inside…
Yes we need the fully readeable school books really want them too be readeable not like note books. Would buy them instandly. And from Rita her books. Wish they made the monster book of monster a real book. Like made the creatures vault the actual book not just a box plus the book. Still thinking too buy it because it looks really good. Still need a proper golden egg. The big one that complitely opens up and looks amazing on the inside. And a proper size wizarding cup. Some really nice portraits that really hang on the walls in the movies would be nice ❤
If I could have anything it would be official school books and official copies of the quibbler.
I bought this last week after seeing this video. It IS a lot of money to spend on something that is so fragile I'm afraid to display out of the foam protective packaging, but it's BEAUTIFUL! I suppose $350 for the version of the prop replica that I wanted Noble Collection to do plus a collector edition of the Creature Vault book is probably worth that considering the cheap cardboard version is $50. I mentioned to Insight Editions that I bought it after seeing your review. For people who are willing to spend the money for this to add to their HP collection it is definitely worth the price. I think the fact that it is a BOX that could be put on a stand with small HP souvenirs like the Gringots coin collection, potion bottles, and the small horcrux replicas inside for display is what made it really worth the price for me. Thanks for your review Cherry!
Very well done - the teeth and "coat" especially
I've been thinking it for years, and still do, I wish you did audio narration for novels. Your voice is asmr.
It is beautiful but not totally worth the price. I am a collector but have a beer budget unfortunately. But i do really love this
You need a Godric Gryffidor box cutter mini sword knife. There had to be one...
I really want an official replica rememberall in my collection. There was one from a subscription box that come up on ebay but I want an authentic one from Nobel. Maybe one day they will make one :)
I would love to see a full size mirror of erised ❤
Overall, this is bad. The book should be part of the item, so that it is, in actual fact, a book. The eyes are too low profile. The area in front of the eyes is wrong - it should be furry.
That's awesome! Very similar to the replica included with the page to screen box set, but the face is different.
Magnificent 🎩🪄👌🏽
I have the special box set of the Page to Screen books that this prop originally came with.
I'm in the process of doing our little first home up to sell for a bigger property so we can have a extra guest bedroom and games room and I can't wait to collect all harry potter memorabilia.. we have lots of starwars Grogu and Lord of the rings but Harry potter is next.. I can't wait . I just don't want to buy now for it all to be stuck in boxes. . I'm also so excited for your little shop .. I can't wait for your website to start selling items xx
This would be such a fun piece to have, but in reality it would be tough to keep my cats from cuddling with it. 😅
Cherry i’m a big fan, keep up the good work your videos are great
Thank you so much! 🥰
Hello, can you please do a new/recent tour of your studio or shelves? Thank you!
I have this! It's beautiful and I actually have it sitting on the floor peeking out from under the bed! I know it's an expensive replica to put on the floor but it really looks cool there, I promise! Thanks for comparing the creatures vault book too! I've always wondering what the different is between the editions but I only have the one that came with the monster book!
I would love more Luna related items!
This is awesome. Monster book of monsters is one of my favorites
It's not a replica...it's a late 1970s original piece . The light made from crystals in the Half-Blood Prince at the house Prof Slughorn is squatting in...the one they put back together & Harry is standing on one crystal...that is in my house. I actually liked it when we first moved in (many years ago now) & then I realized the same light is in the movie so i really don't want to change it!! It's a beast to clean but it's gorgeous & so sparkly next to the double window in my dining room.
OMG. Will comment again but the title has me shivvering. tickle my spine....
It’s been on my wish list for a long time now. Initially, the only way to get it was to buy the complete deluxe Hogwarts library that currently sell for $800 + CAD. I am happy that they’re now selling it on its own. I think it’s been 1-2 years
hiii cherry just got a notification before going to bedd can’t wait to see it tomorrow ان شاء الله 🤍🤍!!
Sleep well! 😆
I've been on the wait list for this. After seeing this, I don't think it's worth 350.00
Can you do a tour of your shelves and other collectibles you may have? I'd love to see an up close view of those shelves behind you in every video!
It wouldve been perfect if the vault book was inside the monster book of monsters!!
I absolutely LOVE it! I must have one! ❤
Love your content Cherry Thanks for all the hard work and congratulations on your new store! 🎉❤
Im not sure if it exists but i would love to have a replica of Hogwarts a History book. That would be amazing.
This book is BRILLIANT!! ❤❤😊😊❤
I would LOVE if there was a plush of how the fwooper is depicted in the legacy game. Theyre literally the cutest thing, especially the babies 😭😭
My biggest nitpick with this replica is the size. This is a bit small, compared to the actual movie prop.
This replica is very well made. I wouldn't buy it, but it's a really nice collector item =) this is nice they made it as a box
Arent there supposed to 2 belts on it to keep it closed?
Love your videos cherry you are the best
Thank you, hope you enjoy! ✨
I think you missed the Heylops Owl Emporium catalog that was tucked in one of the pages. Overall, it was an amazing prop replica. 💙
Love to see you doing your thing, missed ya😊
As cute as it is, living in the US... it's not worth over $300 imo 😵
But it has inspired me to try to make my own tbh 😬
There’s some good DIYs on RUclips that I’ve seen before!
🎉😊Luna's earrings and also snake pins, rings.
Would be great the book fit inside aswell. Like a book cover.
Liked. Shared. Commented. Up the algorithm!
Its nice but its not £278 nice...Basically made around a plastic box, its marketed as a screen replica and for me and its easy to compare...its not, and the book is just a revamped old book. Liked your jumper though Cherry👍
8:00 But Cherry, you opened it the wrong way. Aren’t you supposed to stroke the spine to open it!? Your hand would have been bitten off by now!😳😝
I got the same thing for Christmas❤ I love it!
I don't know how I hadn't seen it before! 🤯
@@cherrywallismy mum just bought it for me! Ilysm❤
Awesome review as ‘always’… checked my standard copy of the creature vault and it only came with the one poster. Sadly this is outside my price range but one can dream 😂
I wonder if the Creature Vault was included because it fits inside the monster book.
I would’ve liked it to be the actual size of the original book and have pages instead of being a box. The outside looks nice but I just think it’s a bit small.
I really love your chanel❤❤
Thanks, means a lot! 😊
It would be interesting to see a Slughorn potion ingredient case replica.
This book is so beautiful I am definitely gonna go and get one ❤
Love it so cool looking
That is pricey in my currency it's double so nearly $600 , it would be better if they can actually make these book props in to actual books an not boxes.
Hi Cherry! Thank you for reviewing The Monsters Book Of Monsters for us!! It's gorgeous!!😍 There are quite a few different prop replicas from the HP & FB movies that I would love to have, one of them being in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald and its Nicholas Flamel's crystal ball. Omg I would love to own it!! Take care!! Xoxo 💙💜💚
I remember seeing this edition years ago so yes i do think you just missed it❤
the prop I want to get (it already exists) Is the Ravenclaw diadem and also the mirror of erised
I have an oficial plush of the monster book of monsters from noble collection
I’ve remember that it was expensive but the quality is very good
You must have just missed it. I’ve had this since March of 2017.
Wild! Well, I’m happy to have it join my collection!
I love this❤❤I am a big Harry Potter fan
I think this is gorgeous and I love that it's functional, I could definitely think of some things to store in there. For what you get, I don't think the price is outrageous, but I think they should be up front in that the price is really for two things... it seems kind of disingenuous to price it so high and then "throw in" another book, almost like forcing you to do a combo deal. Especially for collectors who, like you, may already have another version of the book and might not want another copy. They easily could have sold these separately rather than forcing you to get both.
Would love to see a review on the house of sillage Harry Potter collection! ᵔ ᵕ ᵔ 💛
I love this the only thing I have is a timeturner
The school books would be cool. As for the Monster Book of Monsters, the supplies for making it are around $50-$75. The only reason for it to be $300+ USD would be because it is Harry Potter related and sold by a major replica company.
It's ok but I'd prefer it with actual pages. I wonder when they will do that x
Great replica.
I got one it came with the page to screen collectors limited edition
Astonishing ❤️
I have that exact book
is it better than D and D monsters books one and two?
You have an amazing stamina to keep it for a week and not opening it. Gorgeous books.
Self control!
Love you Cherry and you are amazing and the best ❤❤❤❤
Fact that the poster didn't have a Graphorn is a big no for me, they are my favorites
So I am 8 years old should I Watch the 5 6 7 Harry Potter movies 🍿
Yes they are totally worth watching, but if u don't like violence or if u are sensitive and get scared easily, u don't need to watch them, or watch them but with a parent, personally I watched them all at 6 or 7 years old sobi reccomend! ♡
broooooooo thats sooooooo cooooooool
Nice thanks 4 sharing
I think they missed a trick by not putting the "special addition " book inside the monsters one. Basically all they did was change the cover and add a poster, making it smaller to fit would have cost more.
Beautiful books! 😊😊😊😊
Love it!!!!
It's just perfect. 😍😍😍😍😍
First!! Yay I need more of these!
Woohoo! 🏆
You should've checked the date of making on the box
It looks nice!!! Not sure I am going to jump on it.
Perfect timing to go on youtube
Haha good timing indeed, enjoy the video! 😊
Did the book fit in the box? Didn’t look like it. For me it would be worth it if instead of a box it was actually the book when you opened it. Wishful thinking I’m sure. Enjoyed the video 🧡🖤🧡