Modi speech: 1 decision, 5 targets, 5 nudges & a strategic point gone unnoticed | ep 240
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024
- In episode 240 of Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta explains the absence of Pakistan in Prime Minister Modi's important Independence Day speech and why his several "nudges" in domestic and foreign policy are a trailer of things to come
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/Subscrib...
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
India have not seen such a prime minister in a long time whose independence speeches are being discussed and thought of as a peek into what he might do next.this is a changing india. Happy independence day
It has become possible because of the social media. There was no widespread internet in previous PMs time. Any prime minister from now on will elicit same response.
@@nachiketdhende8681 Some what true but not completely.......even though internet was not there but yet prior PM'S never did discussed any issues to fight for.....
@@omnandita12 Nobody had such brute majority. I wish it was used for improving economy though. Instead of vote bank politics.
@@nachiketdhende8681
What about newspapers/ tv/radio
What about the immediate audience present there?
I am in 3rd Year of B.Tech. By 2021 I will become part of India's workforce and I am Fully dedicated towards making India a $5 Trillion Economy. Sir Students of my generation are very patriotic and hard working and we will not hesitate in paying taxes for the development of our country. Also, Entrepreneurship is on rise in kids of my generation. *Only Capitalism can make India a Golden Bird Again* We have to be an Economic superpower after US and China till 2050 at any cost.
you can help only if you are a entreprenuer. 9-5 job wont do it
@@yog-sadhna3415 Why not.Even a 9-5 job provides a lot of revenue to the economy.The salary spent on fmcg and other things and the income tax paid in future will help in building the nation.No job is big or small as all of it when spent or invested helps in nation building.
@@dhrumilmodi2813 that is the problem. Manufacturing needs to improve. We need brands like huawei, zte, alibaba ,softbank. We dont have money because manufacturing leads to high income economies and service leads to middle income trap.
@anant saini: cant agree more dude. We should target to be the second biggest economy by 2030. It is inevitable
@@yog-sadhna3415 My point is not about what we need.
Its about that even after education if he gets a good job, that will also do.What we need actually is more sme's which provide much more jobs and support the economy and as well together with it we would want bigger manufacturing units.
But the new enterprises should be sich that they work in an honest manner and not try to do business in black.
I was born in 1996 so was too little to understand Vajpayee Ji's leadership
(My father says he is one of the most prominent and able PMs our country has ever seen..kind of like Sushma Swaraj Ji..loved across all party lines.)
But I can proudly say when I am old,
I lived to see this man NarendraBhai Damodardas Modi as our Prime Minister.
You may love/hate him but you can't ignore/deny his charm, leadership and oratory skills.
Shouvik Roy if you like his oratory, Vajpayee oratory would mesmerize you, event his thoughtful silence. In such a short term, he almost managed to bring resolution to Kashmir not by sending 1000s of more troops but by diplomatic channels and peace efforts keeping his ego aside. Only wished he was elected in early 90s or we had another Vajpayee ‘thoughtful’ man after he retired !
@@abhijitsinha5387 only getting to know more abt him now
Need this kind of analysis on TV instead of useless debates.
Watch DNA analysis on Zee news
@@sipunsahoo6553 😂😂😂
Another hebetudinous nincompoop.
This kind of useless opinion from sacked out of jobs ndtv journalists opening up their own ventures for money and just money?
Useless opinion from prestitutes?
@@newsupdates3622 I'd love being "carried away' by an intelligent Journo like Shekhar Gupta rather than morons on Zee, Republic etc. 😉😊
This speech showed why we are different and much ahead of Pakistan
Come out from pakistan. Aspirant of world power should not compare self with looser.
Yes we are different and in a good way... But we should now work so that the difference keeps increasing for good or at least maintain the difference.
Indeed!! Thats true
Being ahead of shit isn't an achievement. We should keep a watch on pakistan in the rear view mirror, but never lose our focus on the road ahead
It's just sad. We should be focused on making India better. Not compare with Pakistan. We have been better than Pakistan for half a century now. Our goal is to change ourselves to be a better nation. Nation without bias, without hatred, without class division and casteism.. Happy independence day doston. Jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I am a woman and I love watching these clips. I don’t know why you feel that woman in general gets bored or feels that someone may insult their intelligence. I love having debates with my peers on political issues. And watching your videos really helps to cut the clutter.
Good for you Sneha!
Good for you Sneha, but a lot of men do exclude women from discussion on those pretexts which is sad.
Mr. Shekar changed a lot these days. Good analysis. Become a true media man with lots of knowledge. Don't be selective. Govt. /religion /ideology/history Might be wrong or right, tell the truth only. All the best. This is called achche din.
Yes. Mr.Sheksr Gupta has changed a lot but I am still circumspect about his motives since his close associate is Prannoy Roy.
Yes have you seen since last one week print is continuously taking interview of stone pelters and Kashmiri what they think about removing 370
Bhai corruption me naam he, talwar latak rahi he isliye sur badal gaye. 😂
@@orange7536 pranoy Roy K saath Kya hua h? You know
@qr agusta westlend me ED ka chargesheet me bhai ka naam he.
This is how criticism should be....it should help the government.
He has made a great change by not mentioning Pakistan, virtually he don't have to now because he proved that he can tackle Pakistan without announcing it. Also he may have ended the long gone era of comparison with Pakistan, we shouldn't compare ourselves with losers.
This is how u should criticize government..
Praise what good they have done, & criticize the same for their bad decisions. Constructive criticism always welcome, but always don't just yell at government like Raveesh Kumar
NATIONAL NEWS perfect
True AF
maybe ravish will get there when he gets older.
@@ajsujit as a bihari i tell u ravish will not back down. Somewhere it had hit his ego.
Ravish kumar might have been a extremist towards the government and its policies, but it has been the case for over congress-rule as well, and i believe he's doing right cuz right now, no one dares to speak against the govt (or better say every news is sold out), so if someone has the gut to speak up, we all should respect or atleast not criticize.
Modi supporter here … I look forward to Shekar Gupta for objective analysis!!! 🙏🙏
Don't be antinational they will send u to Pakistan
Gupta became a bhakth to get views hahaha
Only request to The Print is plz never ever stop the episode of cut the clutter..your media is one of the finest as of now..very liberal views with good research..Keep up the good work , we will support you ..Just keep going
father of presstitutes of india
Thank you, Rahul ! Keep watching.
I am Jain, much smaller community .. I dont feel unrepresented.
Why will you??? The second most powerful person in the country is a jain himself...
@@msdadsfsx its the other way around. Hinduism gave birth to Jainism.
@@msdadsfsx why would Jains want to have their own country if they are happy in India?
Besides they are some of the most peaceful and harmless people..and sooner or later powerful nations will take advantage of their non violence and humility if they live in a country.
@@msdadsfsx other way around
@Ayush Chaturvedi exactly my point. He is talking abt sovereign Jain republic so his Islamic invaders can come and conquer. One who is a citizen of republic of India cant even think of such things. We should read and learn from history.
There is a lot difference between india and Pakistan where Pakistan pm and president speech on india centric and on ours there is not a single mention of Pakistan
If India is to blame, then Pakistani leadership is not responsible for any of their actions or policies.
agreed
Bhai beta jab award jitta h Toh bolta h na thanks to my mom dad 😂😂😂
Your PM won two elections on Pakistan bashing lol
@Mukesh Murali baat sahi hai
Finally INDIA has a leader in MODI with a true vision for the future. Jai Hind
Are u kidding..a police state..I've lost my respect for shekhar. Hope ndtv does not use him anymore....shame.modi lied today and he knows it
ScamgressMuktBharat
@@ruzbehmowdawala2202 I love seeing you cry. Some more tears please 🤣
@@manigopal92 im also loving it 😂🤣🤣
@@manigopal92 yes love to see these crying faces😅😅😂
Thank you for the shout out for women! It was definitely an excellent 'nudge'!
was looking for some lady to comment this XD
Good one...😄
I second that! Not questioning Mr. Shekar's immense knowledge. Do fewer women watch news in India? I am a psychologist and love the do research! Any clarity would be appreciated. Thanks.
Dr. Saakshi Arora
@@saakshiarora1407 how can we get rid of procrastination??
@@saakshiarora1407 I can't speak for everyone but I do feel that a lot of news and information sources on television is just too aggressive and sort of more appealing to men than women (highly generalized comment though). While RUclips or apps like inshorts are more appealing to me as a women, shoutouts to women like the one Mr Shekhar gave leads to more encouragement. I can't comment about newspapers as I don't consume much in that form..
1. CDS
2. Water
3.population controle
4.improvement in exports
5. Nudge theory
6. Asking each citizen to be tourist
Every Point was valid and doable
@john doe its a big mistake to compare indian right and left with the american left and right. We are in different dimension. Copy Paste Journalists cant come up with a new way to define political idealogies. Bete population control is needed. Your freedoms shall be further restricted if you have to share the country with so manu more ppl. So look at it as if your freedoms are being protected by controlling more free individuals to be born😆
You can be tourists only if you have enough food on plate first. Economic meltdown is a BIG concern ! US came out of it in 2011 as Obama’s policies has positive impact. Can just hope this govt changes its view of economic policies and not treat them as an ‘event’ management
Happy Independence Day to you also Sekhar Sir.
Entire day many learned persons have been analyzing the PM's address. Lekin mazza aur asli samajh aap se hi aayee hai.Thank you.
🙏
👍
Have anyone noticed his views increased from around 50k to around 250k after stopping pan criticization of Modi govt after elections,which he is now performing true journalism
Thank God he didn't mention a failed country which is known as Pakistan. We also have to stop giving them (bhaaw). Poori duniya me sbse jyada hum hi Jihadistan ko bhaaw dete hai. Our Army will take care of them. We should learn from korea , japan , france, US, how they grow how they become so powerful how they have better technology how they have better standard of living.
Precisely.
US, Europe, Israel, China should be our aspirations.
You moron.The US is scared to attack Iran.Israel is scared and yet Indians talk of war with a nuclear power who can hit all their major cities.
Of course ignore them.... Bhai they don't deserve our attention 😆
Abbey muttar kerne ki auqat nahi 😂
@@movizdar8818 yeah bro biggest toilet in the universe is Porkistsn 😆
I initially didn't like you because you seemed to be biased, but ever since the elections I've noticed you've become very fair. I like it. Please don't collaborate with good journalists not rubbish Kumar or Burkha Dutt Begum
Population control in India is inevitable and I'm glad that PM of our country is talking about some measures.
Bhai rural areas mei educate Karna hoga pehle 👍
And Congress is opposing this
@@GovExamsJobsofIndia congress is a lost cause now, best they can do is addressing the bill as Shekharjii
Its too late . Population of india blasts like nuclear bomb. India will surpass China in 2-3 years.. Modi hai toh mumkin hai😊
Too little too late?
I thoroughly enjoy these videos; and I often share it with my family on our WhatsApp group. I live in Toronto (Canada), so when you recently made a reference to flooding in Toronto, ON., I had a smile on my face, because I currently live there (Islington Ave). Keep it up!
P.S. As a Modi supporter, I must say that media should critically criticize shortcomings/loopholes in government’s policy but should refrain from having politically motivated agenda against an individual/group (which they did against Modi for a long time)! We are NOT blind-bhakts of Modi, but common people who wishes to access objective/non-biased news/debates/discussions/analysis!
I would be the first person who would welcome constructive criticisms of Modi government. I do not subscribe to views of Ravish Kumar (NDTV), who does not support anything that Modi government has achieved over the past 5 years. They continue to live in denial that he could be re-elected; and run malicious campaign against him and his government.
I don't know I feel very positive and energetic after hear modi's speech......btw I am not a bhakt..
A Modi bhakt is thoudands time better than A Congressi Chamcha or A Tukde Tukde Gang Member or A Award Wapasi Gang Member
Well said... I usually feel he is genuine. It's great example, how a individual can grow to great heights irrespective of his or her background.
Im not a bhakt is no more required !! Feel proud bhakt !!
I'm a bhakt of this nation.. and so i will praise all those who are doing genuine work in building our country.
Jai Maa Bharti.
bhakt hona koi buri cheez nahi hai
Thank you Shekhar for appreciating women's interest in politics. Have started watching your program recently but hooked on it!
In India if you want debate on any policy and reach any solution democratically then it can take more than 70 years 😂😂😂😂😂
Thank you, Sir, for noticing the great points from PM Modiji's speech. Ppl are focusing on many important topics like Cheif of defense, 370, Triple talaq, etc but in between of all these topics of utmost importance didn't get much of the attention - Our earth. No earth=No life then no use of any of these laws! Single-use plastic waste, overpopulation, uncontrolled use of chemical-based fertilizers are the real threat to our mother earth and the very existence of our life. I am so glad that our PM emphasized these issues in his address to the nation but same time disappointed that its doesn't catch spark or debate like other issues. I am so grateful of you that you included them as 5 most points in your analysis. Very well done!
I appreciate this kind of neutral analysis. Thank you.
Thanks Mr Shekhar Gupta for a very balanced commentary. When you are objective and unbiased, your presentation is very incisive.
I think the speech by PM Modi was very personal, reaching out to the public but also very strategic and statesman like. I am glad my country has given him another term to realise the projects he has started. A proud OCI Indian 👍👍👍 on this great day for our country.
OUR PM has raised the status bar of reforms, no longer congress/ left policy of zero development, corruption is under contral..support.
Poor C9ngress will lose everything
Corruption is under control? The RTI has been crippled. News channels are doing bhakti! Whistle-blowers are being murdered. 50 people died in the Vyapam scam! Who is going to dare talk against the government?
@@ankurdubey3061 बीजेपी आयटी सेल? मिल गया रोजगार? गाली देकर सच्चाई तो नही बदलेगी.
Feeling Proud to be born in such a time that is witnessing such historical changes in our Country and also being able to play a role to make that change. :)
Finally.. Someone acknowledged success of swacch Bharat 🙏 fed up of naysayers
I had heard that you Sir are a congress stooge but I have now listened quite a few of your episodes and have found every bit of it very balanced and accurate. Thank you for letting me know I was wrong 🙂 ! Great analysis !!!
Wait till he becomes Congress stooge again
nishant ky as opposing upa for corruption didn’t meant you were a fan of rss, similarly opposing bjp does not mean you support congress. But we need a strong opposition to challenge govt and not make it a one way traffic, good or bad !
"Nudge economics"..fab observation!
Good Analysis by SG. Mr Modi’s policy is going places. It really cut the clutter. Thanks. Nathan Sekhar Sydney, Australia.
Thank you, Nathan !
The PM's speech was in the right direction.
1) No. of Doctors only can be increased if the cost of medical education reduces. 2) There is no policy in paramedical education and basic medical education for all. All must be aware of basic medical practices which can save lives. 3) Tourism straightway related to infrastructure and social safety. Make better roads and lower the crime rate then it will increase. 4) Religion-based participation in powers is an awful idea. 5) Scrap MCI/AICTE/UGC/PCI/BCI/NCTE/NAAC these all are the reason for poor quality education and the source of corruption. Other than improving the quality of education they are more of license raj. Universities must be rated by their employment ratio of its students and the no. of patents filed by them. 6) Declare in advance and Offer many subsidies and favors for single-child parents.
AICTE is shit. These bastards have given the license to everyone who has 2 acre land and a few rooms.... That's why the quality of engineering in India has degraded so badly
Good summary
Right. I got 495 in neet and got seat in several medical seat in private colleges in my state Bengal. But could not continue due cost almost 17 lakhs. Need more govt college.
@@bengalitiger5370 That is so sad.
Very happy to see Shekar Gupta sir’s transformation...this is how the reporting should be...very constructive in criticism n well balanced analysis...lovely clutter ready for you to have a look 😍😍
Excellent analysis and I look forward to your views..thank you.
I like it when Shekhar Gupta said "Inflict another Cut the Clutter". One should respect a self aware person. I subscribe today ...
Mr. Gupta, Hi! Please make this show of yours more frequent. Thank You.
this comes daily at night
Making it frequent may reduce quality
One video per day is better than than the alternative is
father of presstitutes of india
WoW Shekhar ji, what a fine analysis, and a keen observation on differentiating high-jump vs long-jump! one of the surgical analysis I have heard so far on I-Day Speech!
Thank you, Meena !
Should we not even dream and work towards 5 trillion economy? Those who are content do not achieve anything.
Modi Gov is doing thier job.....Not looting the country
@@GovExamsJobsofIndia exactly
ya history was created by dreamers, if we stop dreaming then we are not indians ,jai hind
Actually as per the economy if our gdp grows at 8% every year then it is possible to reach 5 trillion economy.... Our GDP growth is not bad at all... It is Forecasted arround 7% which is great... But not enough to make 5 trillion until the deadline....
Per capita income is more important than gdp size..... 2800 usd.......china has a per capita.. 9500usd.... USA has a per capita 65000 usd
Super analysis
Very good analysis sir.
No man all our media is sold. He used take money from Congress.. Now he is funded by BJP
@@bengalitiger5370 peshwa ji aap karo analysis fir
NaMo ji speech was awesome... What I liked is Tourism idea and Ease of Living... I am fed up of pot holes and traffic jams...
I am woman and I subscribed!! Thank you Mr. Gupta! Appreciate your honest views- Modi has good intents for the nation- no one can deny it; we can argue methods and policies and critique him I agree, but lets unite behind this man in making our country great! WE can't argue that taking a tough stand on Kashmir was necessary- 70 years of failed policy gave rise to Islamic militancy in the region and nullifying article 370 became important. Population control and water are main issues for India- but each one of us have to be an active citizen in solving these issues- we can't just expect the prime minster to do all the work.
Upwards and onwards, India! Happy Independence day!
Really good episode, Shekhar. Watch your telecasts and read your tweets & articles regularly. Absolutely, we are lucky to be a part of this multi-ethnic country, that so strongly rooted in democracy. Happy Independence Day to you all.
I was thinking about raga if by any chance he would happen to be PM would he gave such intelligent speech 😶😶😶
Vishesh Kumar Yadav listen to his election campaign interviews, he is a genuine person deep inside, just don’t have right oratory to convey them. Lets not judge a person by cover, where NaMo looks a hero and RaGa looks a comedian or was this the intentional image building by the troll army !
Sir, I watch almost all your episodes. Was never interested in politics till couple of years back. But internet and easy access to news and the interesting general elections made me interested. Cut the clutter is something that I follow regularly.
I am from Visakhapatnam ( Andhra ) , thank u for ur de-cluttering, I never miss ur videos.
I have two questions :
1) Pushed to corner on Kashmir issue, what are chances of Pakistan coming to war against India ?? Wouldn't that dent our economic growth ??
2) I worked with political survey during recent elections, I travelled extensively in nearly 100 villages, there were a lot of diverse groups living with each other based one principle - " compromise " ( largely becoz , they are illiterate , no knowledge of their rights and cultural histories, so they find some or the other compromise solution , " just to continue as usual "). However , the same is NOT true for URBAN EDUCATED INDIA , they seem uncompromising , only bothered about their rights , have no "DUTIES", educated youth is more CASTIEST, EDUCATED Hindus feel they have more rights, similarly EDUCATED Tamil is more agitated about language,,,,, AND HENCE they are NOT going to compromise . Do you think threat to INDIA's integrity is growing as India is getting more and more educated ????
Good questions....
But on q1....Is economy more important when others attack you?
Threat of India is with hyper regionalism....
That’s a good point...I guess if the crucks lie in the education, lets make our education more integrating in nature. We are never taught about our duties and responsibilities as citizens and respect our coutry and its diversity.These things are taught in a shallow manner. So, what I mean is not an education that promotes jingoism, but an education that aims to cultivate mutual respect and national pride in an organic way..there should not be contradiction between ones own ethnic and linguistic identity and national identity..also, our education should promote a North Indian to learn at least one language from the south...don’t know if this makes some sense
First of all before replying to anything I want to ask you, what did you mean when you say "educated Hindus feel they have more rights"?
Now coming to my reply of yours I am a tamil myself. First of all the Regressive mentality of us tamils is our extreme jingoism towords our linguistic identity. This is because of our useless dravidian politics since independence and I as tamil I hate it and there are people like us who hate it too and you don't to hear our voices.
Secondly this so called hate filled separatist dravidian politics is backed, promoted and propogate by Christian missionaries here in tamilnadu. Church's hold on tamilnadu politics is very strong.
@@appumini Nice. I would like to learn two language. Tamil and sanskrit
Hey I am a woman🙋🏻♀️. I watch you guys. Cut the Clutter was my main reason for subscribing😄
Mr Gupta, I like your analysis of the current affairs. I would be really interested to know your opinion regarding NDTV frauds. My intention is not to make you uncomfortable but to know your perspective.
Regards.
NDTV FRAUDS.............reevaluate please.......
father of presstitutes of india
Very well analysed. As a practitioner of data science and analytics, I like to think your words hit all the right notes. Well done!
Mature of Mr Modi to not go with a pak bashing in speech but talk of the development and future roadmap
Good and healthy analysis and not being negative just for the sake of doing so. I started watching Shekar Gupta and I am liking his analysis 👍
Farmers can be associated with technology from Israel.
Excellent episode. Thank you Shekar. Water management is a challenge to every citizen. We need to get technology, policy and behavior in sync to address this problem.
I am much impressed, not only now, but by your previous analysis on farmers/ farming in India. I am a farmer albeit a large scale one, but, I understand the problems that we are facing. I agree with you that we need something akin to a second green revolution and this government definitely lacks the intellectual capacity to deliver it. The insignificant growth in the rural areas is a ticking time bomb. I think this is the greatest threat facing our nation.
Happy Independence Day. Yes, This is the revolution India needs.
Floods in monsoon and droughts in summer are now common. As responsible citizens, it is our duty to do something about this, if we want to leave a better India for our kids. 🙏 Please make a conscious effort by supporting #rallyforrivers. Join me in donating to CauveryCalling.org to end India’s water and Farmers crisis. You can make a difference.
Sir, I absolutely loved your perspectives. In regards to PMs speech I was expecting fireworks. But Im so happy to see the contrast in the messages of Mr. Modi and Mr. Imran Khan.
Mr. Khan and pakistan in general seems to have the same fever from 1947/48 ( To Occupy/Liberate J&K) They are obsessed with it. How do u send an entire nation to see a shrink? Its a sobering thought...🙂
On the other side was Mr.Modi. Looking to the future and planning for it.
My fav line in the entire speech apart from all the points you covered was when he said. We are not afraid of tackling problems and we wont breed problems either. I thought it was a nice way to tell the kids in the house to behave and the kids next door too.
I do hope that India achieves all its objectives that the PM set out and hope that INDIA becomes the first country in the world to effectively tackle the PLASTIC Problem.
Look forward to hearing more from you especially on what it means for china to have a so called closed doors meeting regarding J&K and Pakistan.
Regards
Since you mentioned about freedom of speech, I too would use it to criticize you for not wishing the Indians auspicious Rakshabandhan today even while appealing to our woman power.
I am a regular viewer of your episodes and admire your command over the topics. Keep it up!
Happy Independence Day & Happy Rakshabandhan to every Indian!
🇮🇳Jai Hind!🇮🇳
correct. well caught ! smooth commentary to make ppl agree with elite-jurnos. But Off-the-covers by his communist ways.
Thanks Guptaji,
You are gradually putting me addicted to your analysis, you made me to develop a habit of waiting for your analysis before I make up my mind on some thing.
About 5 trillion economy, you had even gone up-to say it is impossible to get (with some qualifications of course), but hope you would have seen Chidambaram's debate in RS where he said, achieving this will not be a big deal though his 'money lender' reference was a bit too much, but he was repeating that it would not be a big deal.
Thank you so much Sir again and wish you too a very very happy Independence Day and I am happy that I too was immediately thinking about the 'high jump' comment while listening to pm's speech broadcast on live, Thanks, Regards,
Rajesh Iyer
So you are saying BJP's attack on single-use plastic bags has more to do with the protection of cows and less with trying to stop pollution, involving cows was completely unnecessary.
A very worthy analysis by Shekhar Gupta. A Very thorough review as per as noticible points are concerned. He is a very intelligent analyzer. I liked it & hope to listen further from him.
Sir although i don't agree with you sometimes, but you're a great teacher. Your analysis of every subject is very informative. Respect.
Excellent analysis! listening to Mr. Shekar's analysis make me think if I was not attentive enough during PM's speecch:) am going to listen to PM's speech again.
He should give incentive for one child policy
The incentive should be suspension of voting rights and exclusion from wellfare schemes. Maybe an additional tax. That maybe a step slighlty too far. But these are desperate times.
No
One child policy would be a disastrous initiative. The population replacement rate stands at 1.8, i.e. every 10 women in the country will have to give birth to 18 children (preferably 10 female, 8 male to rectify our horribly poor sex ratio) to maintain the status quo. China implemented a one child policy and as a result, they now have a HUGE chunk of population which will enter the retirement age, with no significant younger population to replace the older ones. This leads to reduction/ slack in the socio-economic growth of the country.
@@angaatkeeda7971 I would like to live in a less populated country
@@rd-gr3xx what you are referring to is "population density". You might be living in an area with a lot of people. Metropolitan cities and the alluvial plains of India have always been densely populated (as evidenced by the seemingly massive armies of the Nanda, Gupta and the Maurya Empires). Unfortunately, our country has a very disproportionate pop. density. The North has always been very very densely populated compared to the relatively sparser South.
No matter how the economy is now, PM has to think big first to make it happen. So his vision of 5Trillion is spot on.
Nice to see a big change in the approach of SG. All the best!
Sathyanathan Menon hmm, lets make the dream baggage heavier with a ‘bullet train’, ‘smart city’, ‘make in india’ already keeping the bag worthwhile 😐
fixing judicial system would help law and order situation in the country.. that's the biggest concern to deal with intolerence if any
Yes. But no one seems to be bothered about it.
Yes courts and police is the main problem India is failing at
One of the best De-cluttered, interpretative analysis, that sadly has been missing on traditional TV channels. I miss reading your editor-columns in the Indian Express.
Great analysis. Earned a subscriber sir
Thank you, Gurpreet !
I know shekhar gupta's past background and I follow day to day news since years. I would like to say shekhar gupta is however doing a very good job on the analysis part. Very interesting to hear cut the clutter. Happy to see efforts
Share your comments on misbehaviour of Priyanka Gandhi's PA with ABP reporter and that too in the presence of Priyanka Gandhi's.
Sir, i always look forward to watch Cut the Clutter more than TV news channel
Thank you !
With the changed Guptaji ( even on exterior side)... Waiting for cut the clutter on "NDTV FRAUD"...
That will never come from his end
We have to pressurized him for that since we are the once coz of he is making the money so we the the customer... And customer is always a KING..
Yeah. Good point! He should take the challenge
Shivraj this isn't your local vegetable seller who will reduce prices if you ask for it. He's a journalist making reports. If you want to hear stuff that makes you happy then you can just Google it yourself, no need to wait for validation from Shekhar.
Bhai teko kyu Mirchi lag gayi...
I truly appreciate your posts and I am reacting to your appeal to us women viewers! Sitting here in NJ, USA, I feel you are one "talking head / Pundit" who provides the most erudite explanation and reporting of what happens in India. Thank you!
Look forward to more content Shekhar Ji.
U r very balanced in your views. I have been watching your space here. Always good analysis. Keep us informed
Thank you !
Mainstream Indians are fed up of long debates and discussions on issues which are distorted by opposition parties. I hail Modi and his core team which make decisions.
Sir I admire u a lot ,ur analyses are very correct and exact 🙏😊
Thank you !
@@ThePrintIndia really appreciate ur reply ,feels lucky 🙏jai hind
@shekargupta : I am loving the cut the clutter show by you sir, it is simple, understandable, a person like you with vast amounts of knowledge on politics & history and way you explain things is outstanding. I am addicted to cut the clutter show now a days.
Atleast start with Happy Independence Day
Shekhar sir, just want to say, 'Thank you so much'. Your cut the clutter videos are one of the best things that I have ever discovered.
Thank you, Varun !
From an outsiders point of view, population and pollution are the big two. India is one of the world's greatest nations, but...stop with the trash, clean up the air and water. If Modi goes to war on this the benefits will be seen in the smiles of healthier children.
Absolutely. But since he's a communal monster, you can expect the opposition to oppose even these vital changes.
@@SC-yj7fc That is very sad, it is the same where I live. More important to stop your opponent than to help those who are most in need.
Its a great change listening to intelligent, unbiased analysis like this. Loved the video.
Thank you and keep watching !
A very good analysis and deep sight into the speech. A very happy independence day to you too sir.
Thank you and same to you !
Very clear analysis of speech of our PM Modi by Mr.Shekhar Gupta . Wish our main stream TV channels would had followed this pattern or style but they care on TRP
Wen PM mentioned Afghanistan, I was sure it would be ur strategic point for cut the clutter. Happy Independence Day.
Mt Gupta, Your assessment the I Day PM speech is fantastic. The way you present is also good short, concise and 'to the point'. Apart from the high jump stuff I think there was another anomaly in the PM speech. My understanding is, India is still not a 3 tr USD economy as the PM claimed (2- to 3 tr USD in last 5 years), expected to reach the milestone this year unless INR depreciates. Otherwise I liked the PM speech. Please continue to provide a unbiased (not left / liberal biased as I found in some of your previous videos) assessment in future 'cut the clutter ' episodes where you also give your opinion on the matter separately like what you did in this episode. I wish you and your team all the best.
Nowadays, I do not find kejriwal supporters' comments online...
Where are they. Have they lost confidence in their yugpurush??
Mukesh Kumar why are you triggered?
Did he ever performed in a pressure situation or have he been ever in opposition? Shows real mettle of a person. With the kind of politics he does, he can either be in power or if not will quickly turn into nothing !
Now are the days, we do not trust an IITan and an ex Income tax officer fighting corruption, to do good for the nation !
Thank you Shekhar ji! Happy Independence day to you too!
how could you implement demonitization after a consensus sir. Secrecy was the key, just as it was in the case of article 370 and 35a.
Thank you sir and thanks to the entire cut the clutter team for the unbiased news. Feels like cut the clutter actually does favaor to me by this show
Now, there you are. How much did it take to filter away your biases and (what I believe) your unsubstantiated "nudges" to your viewers?
Thank you for a very engaging, a very erudite and a very simple 'trustworthy' analysis.
And happy Independence Day to you too.
Long may you live and long may your brand of forthright journalism flourish.
Jai Hind.
I have observed change in Shekhar Gupta's analysis. He is on right path to become true Journalist
100% tax redemption for those with 1 or none child. 40% for those with >2. Proper sealing of Bangladesh border and tough dealing with illegal immigrants.
Should work hard on formalising the informal economy
@Chirag Patel nobody can do anything about reserved categories. Actually the UR the real minorities
@Chirag Patel I know a lot of people who are actually rich with many kids especially muslims
And have you wondered with reduced tax income, how will you build 21st century infrastructure and bullet train , heck how will subsidies and pensions be payed 🙄
Excellent, balanced and unbiased analysis.
Is there any way to promote only Cut the clutter?
Interesting and illuminating analysis ...much appreciated. Overall, I find ‘The Print’ has a good & competent team covering various streams and I enjoy reading and listening to the commentary on RUclips. I have for past many months stopped tuning to news channel debates, which in my opinion are utter waste of time. Special mention on witty and intelligent twitter responses and articles from Ms.Inayat. Lastly, my wife is also a regular listener of your commentary - ‘cut the clutter’ and finds it interesting. Looking forward to interesting times and objective reporting ahead ... thanks
There is already a 5 trillion dollar economy all Modi needs to do is file it how come people are noticing that? Modi is a genius.
He meant high jump you dumb, he was taking about overcoming obstacles and challenges as a high jumper jumps high to overcome an obstacle not to jump ahead. Each and every thing he says have some dose for future. Modi's speech is like real life Easter egg
R u high on weed?
@@lordx4641 that's your opinion the only problem is you don't listen to modi and remember it if you were follow the discussion on budget you should know how they are going to make the 5 trillion dollars economy just wait and watch
@@sabertooth207 thats not my opinion i know indias gdp(ppp) is 9.6 trillion i was just taunting the anxious way u made this comment no hate to modi modi is the boss😎😎
@@lordx4641 hate Modi? Wtf are you smoking?
@@sabertooth207 nigga learn to read first then comment
Sir , wonderful analysis of the Independence day speech . A gentle request . Please keep the length of an episode less than 15 minutes .
Look forward to hear from you on the Indian judicial system , tourism , medical system ....a more diversified arena of issues .