Thank you so much for getting this up so fast! And thank you for saving me $54! What a huge bummer that this palette was so disappointing in every which way, I was looking forward to continuing the tradition of kicking off Holiday Makeup Season with this release. Luckily I have all the previous years palettes in my collection that I can use. That lipstick is cute though, maybe I’ll pick it up on sale.
@Shawne I know, right? I was really looking forward to another holiday palette from Too Faced, too! 😭💔 I might still pick it up, but not for any less than 50% off.
thank you so much Amanda for all the details! It's the little things that we really want know - the packaging, the smell, the pan sizes, the comparisons - I love it when a creator shares the whole experience of the palette. You're the best!
Thank you for the comparison of the other palettes! I have both the gingerbread spicy and cinnamon swirl palettes. I was so surprised to see how similar this palette is to the spicy! I, too, am disappointed with the cardboard packaging. It’s like come on, the tin packaging is apart of the appeal to buy these every year. Sadly, Estée Lauder is ruining brands. The liquid lipstick is the only thing that I’m really interested in. It’s beautiful and looks great on you! 😊
Yes they are watering brands down to being safe and repetitive. They're cutting costs on packaging but keeping those prices way up there. Part of the appeal IS the packaging with Too Faced so to water that down- HUGE mistake
I cannot believe I only subscribed today, thought I did long ago. So sorry I’m slow. I have been watching your reviews for months now, and very much enjoy you reviews! I watch your present videos to ones from long ago as only discovered RUclips 2 years ago. Love all your truthful Too Faced reviews as I love Too Faced but appreciate the honesty as I’m not rich and I find review so helpful. Thank you! 🥰
Thanks, as always, for taking one for the team Amanda! What a bummer! I always look forward to September for this palette and the beginning of my favorite season, but this was such a let down. It’s basically a Gingerbread (the original) dupe, but with bad performance formulas! They definitely cut in the production cost. I’ll be passing on this one, but will pick up that lipstick because, at least, that they got right.
Amanda, thank you for the video! Your makeup looks poppin!! I will wait for this to go on clearance! I was so excited for Too Faced to launch their fall collection just to be so disappointed. I feel your pain! Great video!
I’m so glad I saw this video! I was so excited for the new palette (it’s one of my favorite releases of the year too) and I’m sad this one didn’t stack up. Thank you so much for your review!
I’m really surprised to hear you talk about the problems you had with the shadows and the patchiness. I e used this palette a few times now, and I haven’t had any problems. I thought that darkest matte with sparkles performed excellent, in fact, I was surprised how well it performed. I will say I wish there was a warmer dark shade, and I wish there was more variety of shimmer colors. It seemed like there were so many orange shimmers. I guess that’s the color of a pumpkin, so I don’t know. But I was very impressed with how well the palette performed. I think it performed as well as the first pumpkin spice palette. But, I do prefer the purples in the first palette.
Thanks for being so honest Amanda! Im sure u being so honest does not help ur career as some of the ytubers who lie n promote stuff to make money..I am so so impressed n overwhelmed with your integrity all through this time. Your reviews are so thorough and good. I always check on ur opinion before buying anything. Stay blessed!
I love my Pumpkin Spice from 2 years ago. I feel it has more variety with the oranges, greens, pinks and purple. ❤💚💜🧡💖 I didn’t buy last year's palette and will not this one either. It’s a bummer, I love the idea of them, but it doesn't translate to the actual palettes. ☹
Wow…I am so GLAD that this time, for some reason, I decided to look at reviews. You were my FIRST one and quite frankly, the ONLY one I needed to see cause those comparison swatches made me GASP..!! Thanks a BUNCH…👍🏼
THANK YOU for showing both the gingerbread palettes which I have .. so I definitely do not need to buy the new pumpkin spice palette. Yes, such a shame they also moved to paper vs traditional metal. I would not even spend $20 for this new palette!
I was surprised how nice the cardboard packaging is. I guess I was expecting it to be like their holiday cardboard palettes, or even the born this way palette, but this one seems. Over thanksgiving all of those. I miss the tin packaging, though, too.
This is the wake-up call i needed. I don't have any too-faced fall palettes and I was really keen on this but truly, I don't need so thank you for saving me the money 😅 I'm keen on that melted matte though!
As a Too Faced fan, I feel like they were phoning it in this year 😔 First we had Sunset Stripped palette with its super strong perfume scent and now this palette with subpar shadows. Ngl I’m also pretty bummed bc Chocolate Bar was the first high end palette I’ve ever owned so I’ve always had a soft spot for this brand
Me too! Chocolate Bar was my first!!! And while I like the new Chocolate palette, there is a lot of repetition in that palette. And the pop shimmers are really toppers and not metallic. Still, I'm glad it got it because it has the tin packing.
@@SophieTheArtist Trendmood already posted a sneakpeek of the Christmas collection it's the same one they put out every year. They need to hire new creative people they just keep filling up palettes with the same colors. Sigma has better variety than TooFaced and TF is going to go down like UD and MUG
Thank you so much for an honest review. These are always my favorite releases from Too Faced. I really have no desire to pick this one up now. It’s so disappointing. Are you going to review the new Tarte palette? It looks promising.
Very informative video,I only have one Two Faced Pallette and unfortunately it's not any fall limited edition. Sorry your so bummed out I would be as well. Love the lipstick and your earrings.🎃🎃
Thanks for the review video.. I was eagerly awaiting this release and I am so glad I didn’t pick anything up. Such a huge bust! I loveeeee my cinnamon swirl palette from last year and I love the classic too faced tin so this is such a huge bummer. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for such an honest review, I feel the love you have for this kind of collections and feel your same pain 😔 I love this collections but wasn't able to get any palette before the cinnabon rolls and was really looking forward for this palette (even hopping they bring back the past palettes like 3 years ago) Hope next year they surprise us
I'm so torn. I was ready to jump on the fall Palette this year cause I missed all the prior ones. Either talked myself out of buying or straight up missed the fall release (was not up on the makeup trends during the pandemic).... so I was so excited for this release. I might still but maybe, idk. Thanks for the review. Loved the comparisons!
Those earrings are super cute! Pity about the palette. I never buy Two Faced, but I always enjoy watching your review of the fall release. I definitely think you're right about the original Pumpkin Spice being the best of the bunch. I really like the color story of that one.
Thank you for this review! I will keep using my cinnamon swirl palette along with the cinnamon bun lipstick. I had thought about buying the other palettes like the pumpkin spice and gingerbread in the past but I noticed that some of the colors look the same. I will pick up the melted matte psl lipstick though. It looks so pretty and spicy! ❤️ 😍 💖 ❣️
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! You just confirmed that I don't want this palette this year - I will instead be reveling in the new Shroud x Batty Bean palette! 🤗
It's a shame this year's palette is not as good as the previous years. Holiday makeup is something I always look forward to, especially with Too Faced. The only thing I am interested in is the lipstick...and I may just wait for it on sale. It's pretty but I can wait. Thanks for your review and comparisons :') so helpful 💗💗💗❤
I picked up the lipstick this year, but decided to skip the palette because I was very underwhelmed. It’s super disappointing because I have the Pumpkin Spice palette from two years ago and love it. It has so much more variety to create beautiful fall looks. Thank you for your review and showing all the comparisons! It’s very helpful.
Thanks for the review! Enjoy watching your videos.. Iwas going to buy this but I see that it is so similar to others I have. I like to treat myself to a new holiday palette but honestly bummed out it is so similar to others
I'm super glad that I decided to watch this video, I usually don't pay too much attention to any Too Faced products, just not a brand that I really care a whole lot about, they have a few products in their brand that I do really like, like the melted matte liquid lips I think are great and one of the most comfortable liquid lips I have but their eyeshadows are always inconsistent especially when it comes to their holiday launches and we always tend to find these things at TJ Maxx later on for a heavily discounted price. But taking about THIS particular line of palettes from Too Faced, I can't believe how awful this palette really is! It looks like they put no thought into the color story, the shadow quality, and they made it MORE EXPENSIVE 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ I just can't believe my eyes right now! Thank you for this VERY informative video 💜💜💜
I missed out on gingerbread extra spicy and the 1st pumpkin palletes. Those color stories spoke to me. I finally, finally ordered a holiday pallete because I liked the 2nd slice color story. Wishing they kept with the tin packaging and usually waiting for reviews but not wanting to miss out.... I am so sad to see this. Thank you for the video ♡
I’ve been having fun using the pumpkin pie (First slice) to recreate looks that I would do if I had the Huda Love Fest palette, and I am loving it all over again.
It would have been better if they just rereleased the original pumpkin spice palette. I wish they would actually do that. People who got it the first time would buy it again and there would be new customers. The tin packaging change is a huge bummer too. It makes sense to have holiday items in tins!
Wow it's practically identical to the gingerbread extra spicy! With bad performance. What a shame. I do like the new packaging. And your look turned out super cute! Thanks for keeping us well informed! 👍💕
Wow. I'll just be using my gingerbread pallet again this year! Curious about their Christmas release...again cute but will it be the same terrible quality? Tarte stepped it up this year so Im always hopeful!
I was a HARD core TF tin palette lover, and own almost all of them. I bought the new chocolate palette and absolutely hated it. I returned it the day after I first wore it. I decided to skip this palette, and the Cinnamon Swirl is my final TF palette purchase. I can get the same looks with my CP You’re Golden palette, which seems to have much better quality. I spent my $50+ on the new Nouveu (not sure I spelled that correctly) ABH palette.
I wish too faced, and other brands, would do more brownish bronze colored shimmers instead of so many orange shimmers. It’s like they do every shade of orange shimmers and that’s it.
I'm actually so sad that this palette was a dud because I missed all the other fall palettes and I love the pumpkin spice theme. But at least I saved money... If anyone knows of a palette available rn with a similar vibe I'd love to hear about it.
If it were still in the tin palette, I would get this one , because I only have the cinnamon swirl and a few of the minis - which I loved deeply.... Glad you did this review !! Thank you Amanda the pumpkin earrings are adorable 🎃 oh and the nail color is gorgeous!
Too Faced has been letting me down for some time. The last fall palette I bought just smelled like faint vanilla. Then I got the ethereal palette, lovely color story, but it was tiny! And it cost the same as all their palettes, plus it was cardboard. 😩
The melted matte lipsticks in their regular line. If you have a bunch of them, I’d love to see a swatch video! I have and have had some of the original shades. I have and love sell out. I’ve tried cool girl. And another shade but I can’t remember. Anyways, I looked at the shades that they have and they have so many new shades! I have no idea which to get and I know I love them.. please help!
most people say the best quality eyeshadow formulary was in the tins and the other was very inconsistent and some were a dead loss so if I couldn't buy any in the tin pan formulary I wouldn't bother a load of influencers say that as well xx
I bought the PSL lipstick and I think it’s a dupe for the shade Caramel Apple that came in a mini holiday set a few years ago. I hope you find your stash because I’d like your opinion. I was kinda bummed.
I've been super excited for this launch too! So I was glad to see this video. I'm also bummed that it isn't in the classic tin container 😔 So, I did immediately buy it in Ulta too...but now I'm second guessing it because of how you said the quality was in comparison to the others (you can 100% see the difference too!). So maybe I'll go back into ulta to swatch it a bit more before I decide if I'm going to keep it or not. I'd been considering the lipstick too, so we'll see about that one...
I'm gutted that the annual autumn Too Faced release isn't in tin packaging. I love the tin packaging. I wonder if they'll ever release it in the tin one day? I wonder why they went eith cardboard? It's not like they've moved away from tin for environmental reasons or anything. I will still be buying though as like you I love this release every year but it's not available in the UK yet
Thank you for reviewing this new palette. I was so excited about it till I saw your video. In Canada this sells for $69.00 before tax. I was so disappointed in your swatches. I can’t believe Too Faced would even put a palette out like this when there are sooo many great palettes out there now. It’s like they don’t care or have just given up. It’s as if they picked a bunch of colours but didn’t even test them to see how well they worked. I will not be purchasing this palette and like you I always purchase the one this time of year😢😢
aww I love the look of this palette as I missed out on the original pumpkin spice palette however im a little reluctant as I purchased the cinnamon swirl palette last year & it performed so well at first, very pigmented and pretty shimmers however now theres way too much fallout & the quality has dropped as its no longer new. 😭
If i did get this i WOULD wait until back friday because Ulta puts it for 50% off. The lipstick I want. I'm wondering what's going on in the too faced labs. I want them to do a caramel apple with reds, oranges and only 4 browns. I don't know why they keep filling the palette with browns. If too faced doesn't step up they're going to end up like Becca and MUG
I still have and love (and it still smells like cocoa!) my ancient TF chocolate bar semi-sweet. And your review seems to have a bizarre effect on me - I have no intention to pick up the new release HOWEVER I immediately started to look for cinnamon swirl and gingerbread extra spicy palettes online as the shades suddenly spoke to me 🤡 thank you for the super early and insightful video!
I did not love how disappointed you were but loved your honest take. Too faced is a brand that in my opinion charges way too much for what they offer, basically just throwing out cute packaging and recycling looks over and over. I have all of these shades in better formulas, too. That lip is very pretty on you, though! 🎃🍂🍁
For the third year in a row, I'm sure I only want the Melted Matte. From the Holiday teasers that have dropped, I'm all set for disappointment again. This said, there's nothing wrong with the palette.
The black matte with sparkles in the gingerbread extra spicy, I think that one performed terrible. That one was more pigmented, but it seemed so messy. Even with eyeshadow primer and tapping off brush. I’d still end up with black fallout all over my face. I definitely prefer the dark matte with glitter in this new palette over the one in gingerbread extra spicy. Extra spicy might swatch better, but the shade didn’t perform as well, imo. I was very impressed with performance of pumpkin spice extra spice, even if it didn’t swatch well.
The difference in quality is so sad. I got the original Pumpkin Spice palette and glad I did. Looks like it'll remain my only TF palette for a while though!
Pumpkin spice is the only too faced fall palette I've fallen in love with, and I love it to this day. It is fall in a tin. I was already feeling disappointed by the packaging (it doesn't feel like it belongs with the others) and the colors (it felt to me like extra spicy with a green olive as a nod to pumpkin spice and a pink for ginderbread). Knowing the quality is a dud is the final nail in the coffin. This makes me worry about the future of too faced without Jerrod. If this is what happens with one of the most beloved releases of the year (quality wise), what will it be for the rest? I can't remember if the mini major love came before or after he left. It appears that it didn't do that well and is already discounted, heaven knows if because of quality or because it wasn't really promoted. I like the colors, though the military theme threw me off; too faced isn't the military type. Currently considering that one, though I'm not sure. Haven't seen a single review.
Hi, Amanda! Thanks for the review. Aw. Kind of disappointing. I have the Holiday 2020 and 2021 releases and really like them. MIss the metal packaging, too. Your pumpkin earrings are adorable.
I am SO sad about this, Amanda! I also look forward to this release each year and this is just disappointing. Fingers crossed for the end of year Huda palette release (if she has one).
Amanda, this was so good! Thank you! I saw they released a second slice and was very apprehensive and now i am 100% turned off haha I, too, love the tin packaging...it's a signature Too Faced thing they do. No one does it and that's what sets them apart.
I like the old tin packaging. It's cuter, more collectible and yes nostalgic.
Agreed!
Thank you so much for getting this up so fast! And thank you for saving me $54! What a huge bummer that this palette was so disappointing in every which way, I was looking forward to continuing the tradition of kicking off Holiday Makeup Season with this release. Luckily I have all the previous years palettes in my collection that I can use. That lipstick is cute though, maybe I’ll pick it up on sale.
@Shawne I know, right? I was really looking forward to another holiday palette from Too Faced, too! 😭💔 I might still pick it up, but not for any less than 50% off.
thank you so much Amanda for all the details! It's the little things that we really want know - the packaging, the smell, the pan sizes, the comparisons - I love it when a creator shares the whole experience of the palette. You're the best!
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for the comparison of the other palettes! I have both the gingerbread spicy and cinnamon swirl palettes. I was so surprised to see how similar this palette is to the spicy! I, too, am disappointed with the cardboard packaging. It’s like come on, the tin packaging is apart of the appeal to buy these every year. Sadly, Estée Lauder is ruining brands. The liquid lipstick is the only thing that I’m really interested in. It’s beautiful and looks great on you! 😊
My exact same thought if fenty beauty or any other brand would’ve brought Too faced they would’ve absolutely slayed the excitement to too faced again
Yes they are watering brands down to being safe and repetitive. They're cutting costs on packaging but keeping those prices way up there. Part of the appeal IS the packaging with Too Faced so to water that down- HUGE mistake
OMG, the craft store smell! Thank you! I couldn't put a name on the scent it reminded me of. 😆
Wow! The comparisons to the previous palettes put the new one to shame! Thanks for the review Amanda!
I cannot believe I only subscribed today, thought I did long ago. So sorry I’m slow. I have been watching your reviews for months now, and very much enjoy you reviews! I watch your present videos to ones from long ago as only discovered RUclips 2 years ago. Love all your truthful Too Faced reviews as I love Too Faced but appreciate the honesty as I’m not rich and I find review so helpful. Thank you! 🥰
I'm so sad they're not using the tin packaging! It was my favorite part tbh
Thanks, as always, for taking one for the team Amanda! What a bummer! I always look forward to September for this palette and the beginning of my favorite season, but this was such a let down. It’s basically a Gingerbread (the original) dupe, but with bad performance formulas! They definitely cut in the production cost. I’ll be passing on this one, but will pick up that lipstick because, at least, that they got right.
Amanda, thank you for the video! Your makeup looks poppin!! I will wait for this to go on clearance! I was so excited for Too Faced to launch their fall collection just to be so disappointed. I feel your pain! Great video!
I’m so glad I saw this video! I was so excited for the new palette (it’s one of my favorite releases of the year too) and I’m sad this one didn’t stack up. Thank you so much for your review!
I’m really surprised to hear you talk about the problems you had with the shadows and the patchiness. I e used this palette a few times now, and I haven’t had any problems. I thought that darkest matte with sparkles performed excellent, in fact, I was surprised how well it performed. I will say I wish there was a warmer dark shade, and I wish there was more variety of shimmer colors. It seemed like there were so many orange shimmers. I guess that’s the color of a pumpkin, so I don’t know. But I was very impressed with how well the palette performed. I think it performed as well as the first pumpkin spice palette. But, I do prefer the purples in the first palette.
Thanks for being so honest Amanda! Im sure u being so honest does not help ur career as some of the ytubers who lie n promote stuff to make money..I am so so impressed n overwhelmed with your integrity all through this time. Your reviews are so thorough and good. I always check on ur opinion before buying anything. Stay blessed!
I love a theme too Amanda and you look beautiful despite the disappointing palette.
I love my Pumpkin Spice from 2 years ago. I feel it has more variety with the oranges, greens, pinks and purple. ❤💚💜🧡💖
I didn’t buy last year's palette and will not this one either. It’s a bummer, I love the idea of them, but it doesn't translate to the actual palettes. ☹
Wow…I am so GLAD that this time, for some reason, I decided to look at reviews. You were my FIRST one and quite frankly, the ONLY one I needed to see cause those comparison swatches made me GASP..!! Thanks a BUNCH…👍🏼
THANK YOU for showing both the gingerbread palettes which I have .. so I definitely do not need to buy the new pumpkin spice palette. Yes, such a shame they also moved to paper vs traditional metal. I would not even spend $20 for this new palette!
You are so welcome! Thanks for watching!
@Crab369 I tried Liking your comment twice! 😅
I was surprised how nice the cardboard packaging is. I guess I was expecting it to be like their holiday cardboard palettes, or even the born this way palette, but this one seems. Over thanksgiving all of those. I miss the tin packaging, though, too.
I missed out on the the original pumpkin spice palette, which I am so sad about. Could you do a byop with the original pumpkin spice?
This is the wake-up call i needed. I don't have any too-faced fall palettes and I was really keen on this but truly, I don't need so thank you for saving me the money 😅 I'm keen on that melted matte though!
As a Too Faced fan, I feel like they were phoning it in this year 😔 First we had Sunset Stripped palette with its super strong perfume scent and now this palette with subpar shadows. Ngl I’m also pretty bummed bc Chocolate Bar was the first high end palette I’ve ever owned so I’ve always had a soft spot for this brand
I agree 😓
@@MakeupJustForFun That being said, I don’t think all hope is lost! We’ve still got the Christmas collection, so maybe they can redeem themselves
Me too! Chocolate Bar was my first!!! And while I like the new Chocolate palette, there is a lot of repetition in that palette. And the pop shimmers are really toppers and not metallic. Still, I'm glad it got it because it has the tin packing.
@@SophieTheArtist I saw it sneak peeked… literally looks like all the others they’ve done. I’m bored tbh And the price doesn’t match the quality.
@@SophieTheArtist Trendmood already posted a sneakpeek of the Christmas collection it's the same one they put out every year. They need to hire new creative people they just keep filling up palettes with the same colors. Sigma has better variety than TooFaced and TF is going to go down like UD and MUG
Oh wow, thank you for this. Because I missed the original pumpkin spice I was thinking of getting this one. You saved me from that mistake!
Thank you so much for an honest review. These are always my favorite releases from Too Faced. I really have no desire to pick this one up now. It’s so disappointing. Are you going to review the new Tarte palette? It looks promising.
Very informative video,I only have one Two Faced Pallette and unfortunately it's not any fall limited edition. Sorry your so bummed out I would be as well. Love the lipstick and your earrings.🎃🎃
I agree with you! The melted lipstick looks great on you. Thanks for reviewing! 🎃
Thank you for all you do Amanda. This review is so helpful!!
Thanks for the review video.. I was eagerly awaiting this release and I am so glad I didn’t pick anything up. Such a huge bust! I loveeeee my cinnamon swirl palette from last year and I love the classic too faced tin so this is such a huge bummer. Thanks for sharing!
I was finally going to cave and buy one of these collections 😕. I’m so glad I watched this before I decided! Thank you for another amazing review!
Thank you for such an honest review, I feel the love you have for this kind of collections and feel your same pain 😔 I love this collections but wasn't able to get any palette before the cinnabon rolls and was really looking forward for this palette (even hopping they bring back the past palettes like 3 years ago)
Hope next year they surprise us
Yes, I really wish that all of the old palettes were available since I am just discovering them.
Iv never had any of the other pallets but sense i work at ulta I bought it and i love it! Its so beautiful
I'm so torn. I was ready to jump on the fall Palette this year cause I missed all the prior ones. Either talked myself out of buying or straight up missed the fall release (was not up on the makeup trends during the pandemic).... so I was so excited for this release. I might still but maybe, idk. Thanks for the review. Loved the comparisons!
Those earrings are super cute! Pity about the palette. I never buy Two Faced, but I always enjoy watching your review of the fall release. I definitely think you're right about the original Pumpkin Spice being the best of the bunch. I really like the color story of that one.
Thank you for this review! I will keep using my cinnamon swirl palette along with the cinnamon bun lipstick. I had thought about buying the other palettes like the pumpkin spice and gingerbread in the past but I noticed that some of the colors look the same. I will pick up the melted matte psl lipstick though. It looks so pretty and spicy! ❤️ 😍 💖 ❣️
Yess to Bare Necessities 😊
I was honestly not planning to get this, but thank you for sharing!!
Thank you so much for this review! I really wish that all of the past palettes were available.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! You just confirmed that I don't want this palette this year - I will instead be reveling in the new Shroud x Batty Bean palette! 🤗
It's a shame this year's palette is not as good as the previous years. Holiday makeup is something I always look forward to, especially with Too Faced. The only thing I am interested in is the lipstick...and I may just wait for it on sale. It's pretty but I can wait.
Thanks for your review and comparisons :') so helpful
💗💗💗❤
I picked up the lipstick this year, but decided to skip the palette because I was very underwhelmed. It’s super disappointing because I have the Pumpkin Spice palette from two years ago and love it. It has so much more variety to create beautiful fall looks. Thank you for your review and showing all the comparisons! It’s very helpful.
Thanks for the review! Enjoy watching your videos.. Iwas going to buy this but I see that it is so similar to others I have. I like to treat myself to a new holiday palette but honestly bummed out it is so similar to others
I'm super glad that I decided to watch this video, I usually don't pay too much attention to any Too Faced products, just not a brand that I really care a whole lot about, they have a few products in their brand that I do really like, like the melted matte liquid lips I think are great and one of the most comfortable liquid lips I have but their eyeshadows are always inconsistent especially when it comes to their holiday launches and we always tend to find these things at TJ Maxx later on for a heavily discounted price. But taking about THIS particular line of palettes from Too Faced, I can't believe how awful this palette really is! It looks like they put no thought into the color story, the shadow quality, and they made it MORE EXPENSIVE 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ I just can't believe my eyes right now! Thank you for this VERY informative video 💜💜💜
I missed out on gingerbread extra spicy and the 1st pumpkin palletes. Those color stories spoke to me. I finally, finally ordered a holiday pallete because I liked the 2nd slice color story. Wishing they kept with the tin packaging and usually waiting for reviews but not wanting to miss out.... I am so sad to see this. Thank you for the video ♡
That lip colour is delicious, love a burnt red
I’ve been having fun using the pumpkin pie (First slice) to recreate looks that I would do if I had the Huda Love Fest palette, and I am loving it all over again.
I missed all their lipstick last 2 years, gonna get it this year. Thanks on the review
It would have been better if they just rereleased the original pumpkin spice palette. I wish they would actually do that. People who got it the first time would buy it again and there would be new customers. The tin packaging change is a huge bummer too. It makes sense to have holiday items in tins!
I love seeing comparisons, thank you!
Wow it's practically identical to the gingerbread extra spicy! With bad performance. What a shame. I do like the new packaging. And your look turned out super cute! Thanks for keeping us well informed! 👍💕
Wow. I'll just be using my gingerbread pallet again this year! Curious about their Christmas release...again cute but will it be the same terrible quality? Tarte stepped it up this year so Im always hopeful!
I totally agree with you Amanda after seeing those swatches ! I’m defs saving my money! Thanks for your review Amanda 💗
Love those pie jokes Amanda 🥰🤔😅😅✨️
The tin packaging was half the fun!
I was a HARD core TF tin palette lover, and own almost all of them. I bought the new chocolate palette and absolutely hated it. I returned it the day after I first wore it. I decided to skip this palette, and the Cinnamon Swirl is my final TF palette purchase. I can get the same looks with my CP You’re Golden palette, which seems to have much better quality. I spent my $50+ on the new Nouveu (not sure I spelled that correctly) ABH palette.
Thank you for this video! I passed right away because it wasn’t in a tin. Now I know I don’t need it. Or want it for that matter.
I wish too faced, and other brands, would do more brownish bronze colored shimmers instead of so many orange shimmers. It’s like they do every shade of orange shimmers and that’s it.
I'm actually so sad that this palette was a dud because I missed all the other fall palettes and I love the pumpkin spice theme. But at least I saved money... If anyone knows of a palette available rn with a similar vibe I'd love to hear about it.
Mind doing a review on the new tarte pallete? I’m thinking of picking that one up besides this one. Might wait for it to go on sale lol
Thanks for your honest review!
Please do Too Faced mini palettes ranking 🙏🙏🙏
I like the tin packaging too but the new one is probably more recycling friendly?
If it were still in the tin palette, I would get this one , because I only have the cinnamon swirl and a few of the minis - which I loved deeply.... Glad you did this review !! Thank you Amanda the pumpkin earrings are adorable 🎃 oh and the nail color is gorgeous!
Too Faced has been letting me down for some time. The last fall palette I bought just smelled like faint vanilla. Then I got the ethereal palette, lovely color story, but it was tiny! And it cost the same as all their palettes, plus it was cardboard. 😩
I have more more than one of their previous Autumn palettes so won't go for this one. Thanks for the comparisons.
Thank you for the review and comparison. I will save my $$
The melted matte lipsticks in their regular line. If you have a bunch of them, I’d love to see a swatch video! I have and have had some of the original shades. I have and love sell out. I’ve tried cool girl. And another shade but I can’t remember. Anyways, I looked at the shades that they have and they have so many new shades! I have no idea which to get and I know I love them.. please help!
Thank you for this review and the comparison's 💕
most people say the best quality eyeshadow formulary was in the tins and the other was very inconsistent and some were a dead loss so if I couldn't buy any in the tin pan formulary I wouldn't bother a load of influencers say that as well xx
Thank you for this extremely helpful video. 🙂
I bought the PSL lipstick and I think it’s a dupe for the shade Caramel Apple that came in a mini holiday set a few years ago. I hope you find your stash because I’d like your opinion. I was kinda bummed.
I just got this palette today bc I didn't have any of their past palettes so I am sad. I haven't played with it yet so we will see if I like it or not
I'm so glad you did this, you saved me some money 💰.
I've been super excited for this launch too! So I was glad to see this video. I'm also bummed that it isn't in the classic tin container 😔 So, I did immediately buy it in Ulta too...but now I'm second guessing it because of how you said the quality was in comparison to the others (you can 100% see the difference too!). So maybe I'll go back into ulta to swatch it a bit more before I decide if I'm going to keep it or not. I'd been considering the lipstick too, so we'll see about that one...
"Pumpkin Spice, don't grab another slice"
Me: "😱 omg gurl savage" 🤣🤣🤣
Informative review. Thank you!
i waited to get this and i am so glad i bought it on sale for 18 bucks ...after xmas sale
LMFAO I literally describbe it as the "michaels smell" too! Im glad im not the only one.
I LOVE your earrings!!
You created a beautiful look and I'm so sad the quality went down 😢
Thank you!! 🥰
I'm gutted that the annual autumn Too Faced release isn't in tin packaging. I love the tin packaging. I wonder if they'll ever release it in the tin one day? I wonder why they went eith cardboard? It's not like they've moved away from tin for environmental reasons or anything. I will still be buying though as like you I love this release every year but it's not available in the UK yet
Thank you for reviewing this new palette. I was so excited about it till I saw your video. In Canada this sells for $69.00 before tax. I was so disappointed in your swatches. I can’t believe Too Faced would even put a palette out like this when there are sooo many great palettes out there now. It’s like they don’t care or have just given up. It’s as if they picked a bunch of colours but didn’t even test them to see how well they worked. I will not be purchasing this palette and like you I always purchase the one this time of year😢😢
Too Faced sold their company to Estée Lauder, unfortunately. Blame Estée. They phoned this one in and threw it at us. Lol! 🙄😂
Ugh I just ordered this! I’m so disappointed it’s not in a tin. I love the too faced scented products. I’m afraid it’s over now 😢
The colors are more my style. Squash it is gorgeous, but the tin packaging is my fav.
aww I love the look of this palette as I missed out on the original pumpkin spice palette however im a little reluctant as I purchased the cinnamon swirl palette last year & it performed so well at first, very pigmented and pretty shimmers however now theres way too much fallout & the quality has dropped as its no longer new. 😭
If i did get this i WOULD wait until back friday because Ulta puts it for 50% off. The lipstick I want. I'm wondering what's going on in the too faced labs. I want them to do a caramel apple with reds, oranges and only 4 browns. I don't know why they keep filling the palette with browns. If too faced doesn't step up they're going to end up like Becca and MUG
I still have and love (and it still smells like cocoa!) my ancient TF chocolate bar semi-sweet. And your review seems to have a bizarre effect on me - I have no intention to pick up the new release HOWEVER I immediately started to look for cinnamon swirl and gingerbread extra spicy palettes online as the shades suddenly spoke to me 🤡 thank you for the super early and insightful video!
Pumpkin Spice... Do not grab a 2nd slice! Lol! That was so cute! #momjokes 💜💜💜🤣🤣🤣
my ulta only got 6 in and sold them already. i kind of wish i had collected the previous ones.
the two gingerbread palettes basically have pumpkin spice 2 in them
I really had to dig in mine to build up pigment. Not worth the $54. I'm more excited with the tarte maneater after dark.
I did not love how disappointed you were but loved your honest take. Too faced is a brand that in my opinion charges way too much for what they offer, basically just throwing out cute packaging and recycling looks over and over. I have all of these shades in better formulas, too. That lip is very pretty on you, though! 🎃🍂🍁
For the third year in a row, I'm sure I only want the Melted Matte. From the Holiday teasers that have dropped, I'm all set for disappointment again. This said, there's nothing wrong with the palette.
The black matte with sparkles in the gingerbread extra spicy, I think that one performed terrible. That one was more pigmented, but it seemed so messy. Even with eyeshadow primer and tapping off brush. I’d still end up with black fallout all over my face. I definitely prefer the dark matte with glitter in this new palette over the one in gingerbread extra spicy. Extra spicy might swatch better, but the shade didn’t perform as well, imo. I was very impressed with performance of pumpkin spice extra spice, even if it didn’t swatch well.
I am hoping this isn’t the old tin pan release for the year!
The difference in quality is so sad. I got the original Pumpkin Spice palette and glad I did. Looks like it'll remain my only TF palette for a while though!
Pumpkin spice is the only too faced fall palette I've fallen in love with, and I love it to this day. It is fall in a tin. I was already feeling disappointed by the packaging (it doesn't feel like it belongs with the others) and the colors (it felt to me like extra spicy with a green olive as a nod to pumpkin spice and a pink for ginderbread). Knowing the quality is a dud is the final nail in the coffin. This makes me worry about the future of too faced without Jerrod. If this is what happens with one of the most beloved releases of the year (quality wise), what will it be for the rest?
I can't remember if the mini major love came before or after he left. It appears that it didn't do that well and is already discounted, heaven knows if because of quality or because it wasn't really promoted. I like the colors, though the military theme threw me off; too faced isn't the military type. Currently considering that one, though I'm not sure. Haven't seen a single review.
Hi, Amanda! Thanks for the review. Aw. Kind of disappointing. I have the Holiday 2020 and 2021 releases and really like them. MIss the metal packaging, too. Your pumpkin earrings are adorable.
I am SO sad about this, Amanda! I also look forward to this release each year and this is just disappointing. Fingers crossed for the end of year Huda palette release (if she has one).
Love the colors wow
Amanda, this was so good! Thank you! I saw they released a second slice and was very apprehensive and now i am 100% turned off haha I, too, love the tin packaging...it's a signature Too Faced thing they do. No one does it and that's what sets them apart.
Thank you, I’m no getting this either! ❤️
I really like the new packaging!! But to me it looks almost exactly like Gingerbread Extra Spicy. I wore it today.