I saw the Broadway production of GHOST and cried. I still have tears in my eyes every time I hear the song. My parter of 27 years died of a sudden heart attack on July 2, 2007. He was an avid runner and was out for a run on his lunch hour.
I am crying because this song fits me and my husband who died of cancer 4 mos. ago. I am so lost without him. I sit in our house and am surrounded by his memory. Taking out the Christmas decorations was so painful since he meticulously put them away and his writing is all over the boxes. I know what a broken heart feels like. Sometimes I don't think I can take another breath. Thank you for letting me vent...this song is beautiful and it touches many.
@tays gram .. I feel your pain, right now... As my beloved husband passed away this July.. It is so raw at the moment, lots of 'little - silly' things set me off.. Or being asked by someone I haven't seen for a while, how is Phil doing... My heart just cracks some more.. :( Sending love and my very best wishes to you.. from Wales...
tays gram I know its been 2 years but I hope your healing. I just couldnt imagine the pain you were in and still are. Just know he's in no pain anymore. HUGGS Terrie
The harmonies are great. The expressive emotion of the song was so great, it create a lost memories of love ones gone. Thank you Collabros, you are amazing. Stay as sweet as you are.
My husband of 37 yrs passed in November and I’m still in that place sometimes. It’s proof that we loved and were well loved. The goodbyes are painful but we are comforted knowing we grew a family with love. We were the lucky ones. Bobby always said that before he got sick. I’ll shout it to the mountaintops now! We were the lucky ones. YOU can be lucky too....open your heart
Hello Kathy. I'm so very sorry to hear your wonderful husband died a short while ago. My husband died 23 years ago but this song expresses how I still feel - "You took my heart with you." You sound a lady of great courage and your husband's love has given you the strength to move forward, although in a direction you wish you didn't have to take. My very best wishes go with you.
This shows the wonderful talent these young men have. Their harmonising is a wonder to behold. They are a complete sound that the music industry has been crying out for.
They're all brilliant! But I just have to say that Jamie took a very nice control of the harmony during the peak of the song. Matt did a great job opening and ending the song and Richard wonderfully made it flow and transition the emotions. The two other boys did well on backing up and maintaining a great melody, too! Collabro is the best for me and I know that they're for the hearts of many. Continue sharing your awesome talent to the world boys!
Your voices capture and hold the emotions of the heart. The music you make with your voices is so pure and special. What a sound! Magical! Keep on doing this.
I love this one so much as although some years ago, I lost my husband he was 53 but shouldn't have died, and then I lost my son to cancer he was 36 and this song says it all for me. Life seems so unfair at times sadly no-one can change it but music helps me especially Collabro
Thank you so much for sharing this. Living in upstate New York, I hope I can get to see a Collabro concert in the U.S. Still hoping! You certainly had great seats!
One of my favourite musical songs , and wow first time I've heard it song by male vocalists but you guys did an excellent job loved it well done four very talented guys 👌
This was beautiful, I love this song to death and everytime I perform it it makes me cry knowing that I lost someone I truly cared for. And you guys made it even more special, thank you.. 😂
I saw Callabro sing this at Plymouth Pavillions a few weeks ago.It sent a shiver down my spine then as it has on watching this performance. Thankyou soo much for sharing
Thank you for sharing this. They dedicated this to my mum in Carlisle, as my dad took her dreams with him this summer. I wasn't in any fit state to think about recording it!!
Wow first time I’ve heard a male vocal sing this and wow how amazing I got goosebumps in places I didn’t know exisited❤️ really hit hard as had 4 family loses in a year 💔
Thank you for posting this. I'm not usually a fan of people who record things at concert as I think it's more important for you to capture the moment yourself in your mind, but there are rare occasions I want to see the boys singing something like this. I've never once listened to this song and not cried. Although it was a split rather than a death, this song still captures exactly the emotions I feel and when I searched for it, yours seems to be the nicest version - so again, thank you!!
DrSkyrme I may be wrong but.....this song is from the Play “Ghost.” So I believe it is about a death and not “a split“. And I am like you… I cannot hear it without having tears in my eyes. I recently lost my wife of 37 years and like the song states… “I think of you every day”.🌹
Saturday I'm getting married, the company I drive for tried to keep me from getting home for the wedding but I made it! Makes me realize just how important he is to me. I needed to cry and this did it. Don't know how I would live without him. To the company I drive for you're just a job GET OVER IT!
This version of 'With you' is even more poignant now, as my beloved husband died on the 6th of July this year, after battling so hard against Pancreatic Cancer... The 'silent killer', because when you get diagnosed it's normally at stage 3 or 4 ... Listening to this, with the emotion Collabro put into their performances, has tears running down my face, especially when they get to the 'I'm not ready' part.. :( *broken-hearted and feeling lost* :(
Sally Ann Loveday I can't imagine what you're going through at the moment. My heart goes out to you ❤️ I can't say anything to make you feel any better, just stay strong and know he's with you always 😘
Thank you Linda.. I am just taking this at a day at a time, if I look too far ahead it's too much to bare.. The family are all being brilliant, and we cry and laugh about things he said or did.. But I miss him so so much.. 36 years together and now I have to try and find a 'new normal'.. I am so grateful I have wonderful children (and their partners) and Grand babies to occupy my days.. But I miss him in the evening, when I get back in, from walking the dogs.. The house is so empty now... So many things are missing, his laughter, his whinging and even the snores.. This song is both balm and sorrow at the same time.. Thank you again for posting this wonderful version of 'With You'.. Sally ... xXx
+momforpeace that's because he is a tenor... He can sing the highest but he mostly does the high harmonies or high notes. which is important so in that sense..
I saw their audition for Britain's Got Talent - they sang a song from Les Miserables. It was just plain awesome. Collabro - raw and as they presented themselves. Now the music industry has gotten its claws in them and, meh. So sad. These guys have amazing talent. They need to break free from the mainstream labels. Go back to what they had that endeared them to the fans of BGT. Come on guys - I won't buy this stuff - but I will buy what you were selling in the first BGT audition.
Linda Wellington Thanks! Love this pared down approach (piano and strings only if I'm not mistaken), and the guys really get to shine. Some of the arrangements are stunning!!!
Ohhhhhhh, my poor Richard, my heart hurts for him.....but being the professional he is, he stuck it out. Really look at the way the boys are treating him....1. He doesn't look happy and 2. On stage they all are separated from him. I was mad at him for leaving the band til I listened to his interview on why he left I believe he did what he had to do to be happy. I don't blame the boys they are young. Hopefully when they mature they will have a reunion.
This band is just not the same without RICHARD! He added so much more to this song and I could have just listened to him sing all of it! It’s a shame he felt it best to leave the band, when it should have been the others.
The singers were fantastic. Unfortunately, the recording is rubbish due to the fact that the music is so loud that it almost completely drowns out the best efforts of the singers. This is a classic example as to why theatrical performances are so rarely recorded, as the acoustics of the theatre are not conducive to recordings of any acceptable level of quality
I saw the Broadway production of GHOST and cried. I still have tears in my eyes every time I hear the song. My parter of 27 years died of a sudden heart attack on July 2, 2007. He was an avid runner and was out for a run on his lunch hour.
So sorry for your loss of your partner 🙏
I cry EVERY TIME I HEAR THIS. BEAUTIFUL. XX💔❤️😓😓😓😓
I am crying because this song fits me and my husband who died of cancer 4 mos. ago. I am so lost without him. I sit in our house and am surrounded by his memory. Taking out the Christmas decorations was so painful since he meticulously put them away and his writing is all over the boxes. I know what a broken heart feels like. Sometimes I don't think I can take another breath. Thank you for letting me vent...this song is beautiful and it touches many.
+tays gram My heart goes out to you.
tays gram ivy get over it you must have loved him very very much thank you for sharing
my heart goes out to you. just remember all the good times you shared you were blessed to have such a loving relationship
@tays gram .. I feel your pain, right now... As my beloved husband passed away this July.. It is so raw at the moment, lots of 'little - silly' things set me off.. Or being asked by someone I haven't seen for a while, how is Phil doing... My heart just cracks some more.. :( Sending love and my very best wishes to you.. from Wales...
tays gram I know its been 2 years but I hope your healing. I just couldnt imagine the pain you were in and still are. Just know he's in no pain anymore.
HUGGS Terrie
The harmonies are great. The expressive emotion of the song was so great, it create a lost memories of love ones gone. Thank you Collabros, you are amazing. Stay as sweet as you are.
Love Collabro, always will ❤❤❤❤
who the hell gives these great performances a thumbs down ? must be pretty miserably lives
Matt really shines in this song with Intense feeling, love it.
WOW ... WOW ... WOW ... WOW ...This is absolutely wonderful.. What superb version of this amazing song.. Thanks guys .. WOW..
My husband of 37 yrs passed in November and I’m still in that place sometimes. It’s proof that we loved and were well loved. The goodbyes are painful but we are comforted knowing we grew a family with love. We were the lucky ones. Bobby always said that before he got sick. I’ll shout it to the mountaintops now! We were the lucky ones. YOU can be lucky too....open your heart
Hello Kathy. I'm so very sorry to hear your wonderful husband died a short while ago. My husband died 23 years ago but this song expresses how I still feel - "You took my heart with you." You sound a lady of great courage and your husband's love has given you the strength to move forward, although in a direction you wish you didn't have to take. My very best wishes go with you.
This song is sung with perfection by Collabro, they are all awesome.♡
perfection
This shows the wonderful talent these young men have. Their harmonising is a wonder to behold. They are a complete sound that the music industry has been crying out for.
Tremendous all of you. Richard your voice is so divine. Like a clear beautifully tuned bell.
They're all brilliant! But I just have to say that Jamie took a very nice control of the harmony during the peak of the song. Matt did a great job opening and ending the song and Richard wonderfully made it flow and transition the emotions. The two other boys did well on backing up and maintaining a great melody, too! Collabro is the best for me and I know that they're for the hearts of many. Continue sharing your awesome talent to the world boys!
I'm still gutted by the split :(
Kathryn Hamilton’s
Your voices capture and hold the emotions of the heart. The music you make with your voices is so pure and special. What a sound! Magical! Keep on doing this.
I love this one so much as although some years ago, I lost my husband he was 53 but shouldn't have died, and then I lost my son to cancer he was 36 and this song says it all for me. Life seems so unfair at times sadly no-one can change it but music helps me especially Collabro
So beautiful!
Finally! A full live version of this song. Thank you so much! Perfection.
them harmonies just give me full body chills!
Beautiful
Perfection!
Up until this point i only have heard this song performed by women this was very well performed by these young men Bravo vey well done
Thank you so much for sharing this. Living in upstate New York, I hope I can get to see a Collabro concert in the U.S. Still hoping! You certainly had great seats!
One of my favourite musical songs , and wow first time I've heard it song by male vocalists but you guys did an excellent job loved it well done four very talented guys 👌
Very soothing and heart warming❣️❣️❣️
brilliant group..saw them At leicester,,,,fantastic
Collabro are always consistently good even on live performances
This was beautiful, I love this song to death and everytime I perform it it makes me cry knowing that I lost someone I truly cared for. And you guys made it even more special, thank you.. 😂
I saw Callabro sing this at Plymouth Pavillions a few weeks ago.It sent a shiver down my spine then as it has on watching this performance. Thankyou soo much for sharing
Thank you for sharing this. They dedicated this to my mum in Carlisle, as my dad took her dreams with him this summer. I wasn't in any fit state to think about recording it!!
jacqui reid how wonderful. I lost my beloved father 2 years ago this song breaks my heart so sorry for your loss
What a great cover. Great job, men!!
I think your so so amazing 😉 great voice s, I love you boys 💕
They are really fantastic. Each one could be a soloist.
Wow first time I’ve heard a male vocal sing this and wow how amazing I got goosebumps in places I didn’t know exisited❤️ really hit hard as had 4 family loses in a year 💔
Thank you for posting this. I'm not usually a fan of people who record things at concert as I think it's more important for you to capture the moment yourself in your mind, but there are rare occasions I want to see the boys singing something like this. I've never once listened to this song and not cried. Although it was a split rather than a death, this song still captures exactly the emotions I feel and when I searched for it, yours seems to be the nicest version - so again, thank you!!
DrSkyrme I may be wrong but.....this song is from the Play “Ghost.” So I believe it is about a death and not “a split“.
And I am like you… I cannot hear it without having tears in my eyes. I recently lost my wife of 37 years and like the song states… “I think of you every day”.🌹
Amazing took me away
All are brilliant. But richard WOW
Melting😭
Saturday I'm getting married, the company I drive for tried to keep me from getting home for the wedding but I made it! Makes me realize just how important he is to me. I needed to cry and this did it. Don't know how I would live without him. To the company I drive for you're just a job GET OVER IT!
Congratulations on your wedding, I hope you and your husband will be very happy together! Xxx
The bigger guy is the strongest vocalist. 👏🏼
This version of 'With you' is even more poignant now, as my beloved husband died on the 6th of July this year, after battling so hard against Pancreatic Cancer... The 'silent killer', because when you get diagnosed it's normally at stage 3 or 4 ...
Listening to this, with the emotion Collabro put into their performances, has tears running down my face, especially when they get to the 'I'm not ready' part.. :( *broken-hearted and feeling lost* :(
Sally Ann Loveday I'm so sorry for your loss Sally ❤️
it is pretty awful at the moment, but thank you for you kind message ..
Sally Ann Loveday I can't imagine what you're going through at the moment. My heart goes out to you ❤️
I can't say anything to make you feel any better, just stay strong and know he's with you always 😘
Thank you Linda.. I am just taking this at a day at a time, if I look too far ahead it's too much to bare.. The family are all being brilliant, and we cry and laugh about things he said or did.. But I miss him so so much.. 36 years together and now I have to try and find a 'new normal'..
I am so grateful I have wonderful children (and their partners) and Grand babies to occupy my days.. But I miss him in the evening, when I get back in, from walking the dogs.. The house is so empty now... So many things are missing, his laughter, his whinging and even the snores.. This song is both balm and sorrow at the same time..
Thank you again for posting this wonderful version of 'With You'..
Sally ... xXx
Matt is cute love his voice beautiful song choice
Love Matt Tom Michael and Jamie
Wish they'd let Tom do a few more solos, he's got a lovely voice too
+susie b I agree. Tom has a beautiful voice but he doesn't get enough solos
+momforpeace that's because he is a tenor... He can sing the highest but he mostly does the high harmonies or high notes. which is important so in that sense..
I saw their audition for Britain's Got Talent - they sang a song from Les Miserables. It was just plain awesome. Collabro - raw and as they presented themselves. Now the music industry has gotten its claws in them and, meh. So sad. These guys have amazing talent. They need to break free from the mainstream labels. Go back to what they had that endeared them to the fans of BGT. Come on guys - I won't buy this stuff - but I will buy what you were selling in the first BGT audition.
Can anyone tell which key this performance is in?
Do they acknowledge the musicians' contribution at any time during
the show?
Yes they do :-)
Linda Wellington Thanks! Love this pared down approach (piano and strings only if I'm not mistaken), and the guys really get to shine. Some of the arrangements are stunning!!!
Who were the first 2 singers (and the last) OMG!! 😍😍❤️❤️❤️❤️
Matthew Pagan and Richard Hadfield ❤
Ohhhhhhh, my poor Richard, my heart hurts for him.....but being the professional he is, he stuck it out. Really look at the way the boys are treating him....1. He doesn't look happy and 2. On stage they all are separated from him. I was mad at him for leaving the band til I listened to his interview on why he left I believe he did what he had to do to be happy. I don't blame the boys they are young. Hopefully when they mature they will have a reunion.
Maud Perez not ever happening .
This band is just not the same without RICHARD! He added so much more to this song and I could have just listened to him sing all of it! It’s a shame he felt it best to leave the band, when it should have been the others.
The singers were fantastic. Unfortunately, the recording is rubbish due to the fact that the music is so loud that it almost completely drowns out the best efforts of the singers. This is a classic example as to why theatrical performances are so rarely recorded, as the acoustics of the theatre are not conducive to recordings of any acceptable level of quality
good but Rachel gooding is far better,this not a male song.
This almost too choral? And the rythms aren't correct in some spots.