@Jason Prendergast Only united fans count him and he is considered as one of the best goalkeeper of United. But he should be considered as one of the best goalkeeper of all time. And not many people rate him that higher.
VDS has always been respected I don't see how he's underrated. A little overrated perhaps because he wasn't that good same with Schmeichel. Kuszczak was better than VDS but never used. VDS had the reflexes of an old man kind of like Ferguson, made terrible mistakes all the time and cost us matches in the finals against Barcelona. Utd hasn't had too many good keepers but De Gea was good. Onana is a bit clumsy. Kuszczak was good. Carroll was terrible, Foster was terrible, Bailey not that great and Barthez was alright. Not a lot of ground to cover with the goalkeepers.
Lol what? Idiot VdS was never underrated. Only fools like you who just started watching football would think such shit. He was a great keeper for Ajax and the Netherlands. The fact he has 100+ caps for them is a statement. Why do stupid kids nowadays like uNdErRaTeD this UnDeRrAtEd that for something you were too dumb to appreciate?
Barthez was one of the best in his days, especially if you consider his "short" height for a keeper, he was one of the first modern Goalkeepers (Maybe the first) in the world, and just because he made like 3 mistakes doesnt mean anything, and ive seen every game of him at united. it was really a shame that alex, benched and sold him after the real madrid CL loss. He will forever be a Legendary Goalkeeper... TOP 3 Barthez !!
@@geoffbray6996 The IFFHS World's Best Goalkeeper is a football award given annually since 1987 to the best goalkeeper. Barthez won in 2000. That alone shows his class.
I think Peter schmeichel was really great goalkeeper, sad that I didn't see him play during my time, my childhood started with Edwin van der sar.❤️ He's really awesome. But I respect all, and thank you all for what you've done for my fav club Manchester United 🙏 ❤️
@@furypanda4889 So how actually would we go about OBJECTIVELY assesing who is best particulary in a team where anyone is heavily dependent on the other members and it is even worse for the goalkeeper position. Are you better becaise your style is more flashy ? are you better because you are more of a caracther ? Define better the thing is there are way too many variable's is football too really dermine that more wins or less goals against is not even a good standard to go by. Even a percentahe of stopped attempts tells you not much..... But that is tje charm of the game the best does not auto win and best individualigjt never win a price but can still be the best. Therefore a lot comes down to persoal preference.
WE HAVE HAD SOME GREAT GOALKEEPERS OVER THE YEARS👏👏🔥MY FAVORITE WAS VAN DE SAAR🇳🇱🇳🇱. VAN DE SAAR INSPIRED ME TO BECOME A GOALKEEPER. UP THE RED DEVILS❤️❤️
This is the correct one #1. Edwin #2. Peter #3. Big Alex Stepney #4. Gary Bailey Worst #1 Fabian # 2 Taibi( we couldn't count him in, not fair) So #2. Jim Leighton
its may be nostalgia but i love Barthez, he's not the best Goalkeeper that Man utd has had but his madness is going well with the team of the time, and he will always remind me the galactic team that we had early 2000s
Bailey at 8 is a disgrace. You could argue all day about wherein the top 6 he’d be but behind Howard and barthez is ridiculous. Personally I’d have les sealey on the list too, loved that crazy man! Rip
Les Sealey is in the top 4 greatest United keepers and you’re absolute lack of knowledge is astounding! There would not of been a Peter schmeichel without Sealey
Peter Schmeichel once conceded 11 goals in two games. People never remember those things though. He was a brilliant keeper, but even he had some off days. However, he left in 1999. United then wasted 8 years. Messing about in the transfer market on unknowns, unreliable, and Andy gorams. What a waste of time. Taibi, vandergouw, Howard, Carroll...none of them would have warmed a bench at clubs such as Real, bayern, Milan, Barcelona or even Porto. United should have surpassed Liverpool haul of euro champions Cup wins during this time and they didn't, because ? Why didn't he buy van der sar, years before he did. He ended up at Fulham! Wtf. Kahn, casillas, valdes, baia, dida, who did United have? Roy Carroll...and you wonder why I get frustrated. I played fm manager 2010 from 41 to age 73 and I surpassed Sir Alex ferguson as the greatest manager ever. Because I know whats needed between the sticks.
No Les Sealey, Alf Steward or Harry Moger? But you put Barthez, Howard, Romero and Van Der Gouw in. The latter 2 were great but basically understudies. Sealey, Steward and Moger are legends.
Worst Ratio De Gea. Even tho his defence cover a lot of his mistakes all the time. Like can you imagine that we win a lot of games and he is just sitting there watchinhg and at the end you tell me its his cleansheet not the defenders?
Peter Schmeichel is an outstanding keeper, has a charisma, and is the best goalkeeper of his era, but with all respect, Edwin van der Sar is the best United keeper of all time, very perfect posture, good positioning, excellent reflexes, it is unfortunate van der sar came when he was 35 years old, not something bad but the service period to Manchester United was relatively short.
Because VdS had Vidic and Ferdinand to cover his ass. You obviously didnt see all the blunders VdS had while at Juventus and Fulham. Schmeichel bailed us out so many times with different center back pairings throughout the years. Show some respect to the Great Dane.
Sergio Romero is a really underrated keeper! If DDG wouldn't be our Number1 and we couldn't sign anybody to replace him, he would surely do his job!
He distributes the ball better than DDG for a start.
OGS was the culprit for dropping Romero. Thank goodness they fired him so fast after that. Got us to the Europa Final and OGS benched him.
Not to forget, Peter Schmeichel won the UEFA European Championship with Denmark in 1992.
United has so many great goalkeepers.
Edwin Van Der Sar was criminally underrated
@Jason Prendergast Only united fans count him and he is considered as one of the best goalkeeper of United.
But he should be considered as one of the best goalkeeper of all time.
And not many people rate him that higher.
VDS has always been respected I don't see how he's underrated. A little overrated perhaps because he wasn't that good same with Schmeichel. Kuszczak was better than VDS but never used. VDS had the reflexes of an old man kind of like Ferguson, made terrible mistakes all the time and cost us matches in the finals against Barcelona. Utd hasn't had too many good keepers but De Gea was good. Onana is a bit clumsy. Kuszczak was good. Carroll was terrible, Foster was terrible, Bailey not that great and Barthez was alright. Not a lot of ground to cover with the goalkeepers.
Lol what? Idiot VdS was never underrated. Only fools like you who just started watching football would think such shit.
He was a great keeper for Ajax and the Netherlands. The fact he has 100+ caps for them is a statement.
Why do stupid kids nowadays like uNdErRaTeD this UnDeRrAtEd that for something you were too dumb to appreciate?
@@Sigurjon96 Agree with everything you said.... VdS was lucky to have Vidic and Ferdinand at their prime. Howard and Carroll were horseshit.
Peter The Great Schemichel.....Amazing Goal Keeper for United
Yeah peter
Barthez was one of the best in his days, especially if you consider his "short" height for a keeper, he was one of the first modern Goalkeepers (Maybe the first) in the world, and just because he made like 3 mistakes doesnt mean anything, and ive seen every game of him at united. it was really a shame that alex, benched and sold him after the real madrid CL loss. He will forever be a Legendary Goalkeeper...
TOP 3 Barthez !!
Barthez was a liability at Utd & never a legendary keeper
@@geoffbray6996 The IFFHS World's Best Goalkeeper is a football award given annually since 1987 to the best goalkeeper.
Barthez won in 2000. That alone shows his class.
@@JoseLuiz-ep3pn He was a great keeper, but way too inconsistent to be considered a UTD legend.
@@RYx222 no he was great
@@tillyvejdbhe was world class but not at manu
Les Sealey should be on this list.
Yeah, he should be, for saving Fergie's job at the old Wembley. R.I.P. Les Sealey.
My favorite Gk Schmeichel,Barthez,Van der saar, De Gea
I think Peter schmeichel was really great goalkeeper, sad that I didn't see him play during my time, my childhood started with Edwin van der sar.❤️ He's really awesome.
But I respect all, and thank you all for what you've done for my fav club Manchester United 🙏 ❤️
1 _ De gea
2_ Peter schmeichel
3_van der sar
Great video!
My one and only fav goalie : Edwin van der Sar
Cover picture should have included Alex Stepney.
Great video schmeichel will always be the best
Not really more spectacular and more of a character sure but not the actually better guy.
Maurice Matla are you joking
@@furypanda4889 no hes the best
Matthew Parkin ye ik I replied to wrong person
@@furypanda4889 So how actually would we go about OBJECTIVELY assesing who is best particulary in a team where anyone is heavily dependent on the other members and it is even worse for the goalkeeper position. Are you better becaise your style is more flashy ? are you better because you are more of a caracther ? Define better the thing is there are way too many variable's is football too really dermine that more wins or less goals against is not even a good standard to go by. Even a percentahe of stopped attempts tells you not much..... But that is tje charm of the game the best does not auto win and best individualigjt never win a price but can still be the best. Therefore a lot comes down to persoal preference.
All great in their era.
My top 3: Peter Schmeichel, Edwin Van Der Sar and Gary Bailey.
WE HAVE HAD SOME GREAT GOALKEEPERS OVER THE YEARS👏👏🔥MY FAVORITE WAS VAN DE SAAR🇳🇱🇳🇱. VAN DE SAAR INSPIRED ME TO BECOME A GOALKEEPER. UP THE RED DEVILS❤️❤️
Same here bro
They three in the middle was the best
Tim Howard u mean
Are you drunk? lol
1. Roy Carroll
2. Edwin Van Der Sar
3. Peter Schmeichel
Roy Carrol lol is that a joke
@@leonbacon6560 no? He was great. Everyone thinks he’s shit because of that one goal he dropped against Spurs.
Roy caroll swap woth Bailey
@@greaser7765 Clown.
Leighton had a very good season in 1988-90.
Barthez was great!!
No mention of Mark Bosnich on this list?? Sarcasm duly noted
David will be on top in some time
This is the correct one
#1. Edwin
#2. Peter
#3. Big Alex Stepney
#4. Gary Bailey
Worst
#1 Fabian
# 2 Taibi( we couldn't count him in, not fair)
So #2. Jim Leighton
ddg is underrated in his last years at man utd
We cant be forgetting my polish boy tomas kusczak🇵🇱🇵🇱
its may be nostalgia but i love Barthez, he's not the best Goalkeeper that Man utd has had but his madness is going well with the team of the time, and he will always remind me the galactic team that we had early 2000s
Jim Leighton was AWESOME. Cant believe no jim lmao
I go for barthez
Sergio Romero 😍😎
De gea will be the best if the deffenders know how to deffend.
You forgot Tomasz Kuszczak.
Bailey at 8 is a disgrace. You could argue all day about wherein the top 6 he’d be but behind Howard and barthez is ridiculous. Personally I’d have les sealey on the list too, loved that crazy man! Rip
Imagine if VDS join Man utd after Schmeichel leave
Alex Stepney: Second Division 1974-75
Where are Paddy Roche and Massimo Taibi?
Fix!
This is the comment I was trawling through for...🤣🤣🤣
Bartez :D
Les Sealey is in the top 4 greatest United keepers and you’re absolute lack of knowledge is astounding! There would not of been a Peter schmeichel without Sealey
Barthez should be behind van der Gouw, Romero, Bailey and Howard
Despite the howler, Roy Carroll was better than Barthez... so Barthez shouldn't even be at no.10
Barthez was a joke in the name of goalkeeper
@@tarekhasan4690 no
@@tillyvejdb yesss.....he was a joke.....some of his performance were great....but overall his performances were below average
@@tarekhasan4690 he is literally considered a legend at MN united so idk what u are saying, he had many insane saves
Peter Schmeichel once conceded 11 goals in two games. People never remember those things though. He was a brilliant keeper, but even he had some off days. However, he left in 1999. United then wasted 8 years. Messing about in the transfer market on unknowns, unreliable, and Andy gorams. What a waste of time. Taibi, vandergouw, Howard, Carroll...none of them would have warmed a bench at clubs such as Real, bayern, Milan, Barcelona or even Porto. United should have surpassed Liverpool haul of euro champions Cup wins during this time and they didn't, because ? Why didn't he buy van der sar, years before he did. He ended up at Fulham! Wtf. Kahn, casillas, valdes, baia, dida, who did United have? Roy Carroll...and you wonder why I get frustrated. I played fm manager 2010 from 41 to age 73 and I surpassed Sir Alex ferguson as the greatest manager ever. Because I know whats needed between the sticks.
Danish Peter for the win
Where is Dean Henderson he is soo soo good
He has hardly played.
Tim Howard ?
Where is Mark Bosnich????
No Les Sealey, Alf Steward or Harry Moger? But you put Barthez, Howard, Romero and Van Der Gouw in. The latter 2 were great but basically understudies. Sealey, Steward and Moger are legends.
Because 99% of people here arent alive to see those oldies play so who cares?
@@bryanleeyf87 so we forget people when they die? What a weird response.
Gary Baily was better than Howard, Bartez, Stepney & Greg. A shame injury cut his career short.
Tbh Barthez was awful
Barthez Fabien
kuszczak???
Bratheaz is first
Peter schmeichel is the best
Got Nr 1one and 2 mixed up though.
Schmeichel was better than Van Der Sar
Romero not bad
How is the de gea top 3? He should be number 8. What's the point of stats if you're not using it correctly
Yeah got everything right
You missed off Massimo Taibi
Bro where's the lev yashin
Never played for united now did he.
No
Why TF Sergio Romero and de gea are here?
DDG for sure
Vd sar should be 1
Romero? Hardly plays lol
Just know that Tim Howard had autism and still managed to be the greatest American gk of all time in my opinion
Les sealey
Worst Ratio De Gea. Even tho his defence cover a lot of his mistakes all the time. Like can you imagine that we win a lot of games and he is just sitting there watchinhg and at the end you tell me its his cleansheet not the defenders?
Romeroooo
Stepney only 5 🤔, no Les Sealey, I’d have Gary Walsh or Jim Leighton over Romero
Peter Schmeichel is an outstanding keeper, has a charisma, and is the best goalkeeper of his era, but with all respect, Edwin van der Sar is the best United keeper of all time, very perfect posture, good positioning, excellent reflexes, it is unfortunate van der sar came when he was 35 years old, not something bad but the service period to Manchester United was relatively short.
Barthez above Bailey is a joke yeah? Barthez was a liability at Manchester United
Never understood how people rate schmeichel better than VDS. Baffles me.
Because VdS had Vidic and Ferdinand to cover his ass. You obviously didnt see all the blunders VdS had while at Juventus and Fulham.
Schmeichel bailed us out so many times with different center back pairings throughout the years. Show some respect to the Great Dane.
Barthez was awful tbh
Ikr people say he was good
Agreed
Just because of one bad season he's bad? lol.
Still won more titles than David de Klutz.
Sergio Romero? 10th? 🤣🤣 United have had 10 better keepers than Romero in the last 20 years never mind in the last 140.
bartess shouldnt be in the top 10 he was a joke