Ohtani is the Superman of baseball right now. He’s bringing together casual sport fans from all over the world to watch baseball, which is a beautiful thing for the sport. 🥳
they're all saying not that we are taking anything away from Ohtani blah blah~ you guys are trying real hard to diminish what Ohtani has done this season
Yeah. I've been saying this weeks ago. They'll sprinkle it little bits of compliment here and there to make their statements sound reasonable. Just say if you hate the player and glaze another player so we can move on our day.
It's unfair to hide the fact that a rehabbing pitcher is doing this hitting. Please also explain what other pitchers who have had Tommy John surgery are doing this season.
Other pitchers aren't hitting. I don't even understand the point you are making. If Ohtani was strictly a pitcher, he wouldn't have played this season.
@@TheRexrapperhis point is there is NO Athlete in MLB breaking records that have stood for 100yrs except Shohei. Power and speed with CY caliber arm and he is rehabbing it.
@@Levi-em6ym You still don't get it. He asked to name other pitchers who are doing what Ohtani is doing. Of course there are no pitchers doing what he is doing because they DON'T HIT. Do you not understand that people watch baseball and know who Ohtani is. No one is new to the fact that Ohtani also pitches.
Ohtani's WPA higher than Judge is an evidence that Ohtani's focus is always the winning of the team. He doesn't focus on his own individual stat. His SB record is also a testimony that he wants to run as long as his SB can help the team score more.
Ohtani also has more 400ft homeruns!! And numerous records this year including 50/50. And whata judge stealing pct? Cus ohtani is like 99% when he steals second
They know and don't care. They're purposely not factoring that in because it makes for more interesting narrative. Just like back in the heydays of basketball rivalry. It was Larry vs Magic. It was MJ vs whoever. They need this rivalry for views. So they are deliberately leaving out factors that will boost Ohtani above Judge. And only looking at pure numbers to create this Ohtani vs Judge discussion.
@@TheRexrapper Steals are a lot more valuable than walks, since it gets your closer to home plate to score the run easier. And also puts a lot of pressure on the opposing pitcher.
@@investingty Simply not true. A steals value is dependent on your supporting cast. If they can't do their job, the steals have no impact. A walk guarantees two things: 1. You aren't getting an out 2. You get on base. A steal has no guarantees except advancing to another base. You mention putting pressure on the pitcher. What if your teammates suck with runners in scoring position? Basically what if they are notorious for not producing with men in scoring position? How much pressure is that pitcher feeling knowing that? Probably not much.
Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player. Even when he isn’t pitching, he’s still arguably the best hitter and best overall baseball player. When Ohtani is pitching, there’s no question that Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player.
What's really amazing about Shohei Ohtani is that he has the most child fans in the world. He supports baseball all over the world and is a role model for children. He is also a gentleman and does not spit in the stadium or throw trash on the bench. He picks up trash instead. He does not unbutton his clothes or wear jewelry during games. He simply enjoys baseball with all his might in order to convey the joy of baseball to children all over the world.
Mookie wasn't in the lineup for 3 months my and Freddy has been out too. LA better place for hitters? Yankees stadium is barely 300 at right field lmao. Also judge walks more cause he doesn't steal. Walking ohtani is giving him 2nd base or maybe 3rd.
@@tchlin that’s not why they don’t walk Ohtani- he’s got great hitters behind him that punish you for walking Ohtani. Also people don’t walk the leadoff hitter of the game/inning because of the likelihood that run scores regardless of who it is
Judge walks more because the 4th hitter is a bum, Ohtani had Freeman behind him at the beginning of the season and as the leadoff hitter he had Betts and Freeman. C'mon here, this should be common sense who gets more walk.
@@Maker161st he gets more walks because he's a better hr hitter...and when Soto doesn't get on base ..they can walk him coz he isn't a threat to steal..
Before Ohtani, baseball was globally non-existent. After Ohtani, baseball enthusiasm has grown around the world when basketball is waning down. Let those fan numbers stick for a moment as compared to stat numbers. What matters most? But you know what as a new baseball/Ohtani fan, I do hope Judge gets the triple crown as Shohei broke a lot of records already. It would be a nice promotion for a more exciting and hopefully Dodgers-Yankees match.
People are losing all context here. Ohtani is like if Gerrit Cole got TJ surgery and hit like Judge in his off year while rehabbing. It’s impossibly great. Arguing that Judge is the superior player by comparing his marginally better hitting stats is not only dumb and lazy, it’s disingenuous. No one is close to Ohtani, including Judge. That’s not an opinion. It’s a fact.
His hitting stats are not marginally better. You either are straight up lying or don't know how to interpret stats. An OPS 132 points higher is not marginal. An OPS+ that is 32 points higher is not marginal. An on base percentage that is 67 points higher is not marginal. The difference is dramatic. That's not even factoring in things like wRC+ which had Judge's season as the 7th best hitting season in the history of baseball. The media is trying to make it seem like their hitting numbers are comparable. They aren't.
@@TheRexrapper Of course Judge will have better stats. Dude play in a small ass stadium half of the year. Look at soto for example, I wonder why soto has the best stats he ever had since coming to the Yankees.
Yankee stadium is little league ballpark. There have been many players like judge Ohtani's record is a feat that will never be seen again. Ohtani is the man God created to be the savior of baseball.
@@TheRexrapperduhhh...your like comparing KARL JUDGE MALONE TO Shohei MICHAEL Jordan. Shohei has broken records that stood a 100yrs and now with his 50/50 he stands alone...period.
@@Levi-em6ym Once again, try to read carefully. The original comment said there have been many players like Judge. Name these many players who are 6'7 282 pounds who hits the way he does?
Yankee stadium is one of the most home run friendly parks, and also Juan Soto bats before judge in 3rd position, Ohtani bats leadoff there's no one to bat in yet he still leads the NL.
They forget that who hits behind Shohei is not the reason why he’s not walked. Nobody wants to walk Shohei because that’s basically going up a double and now you’ve got a fast runner on second base.
That wouldn't matter if the players after Ohtani didn't hit. Ohtani could steal all he wants but if the players behind him don't produce, the stolen bases mean nothing unless Ohtani steals home base which is extremely unlikely.
As great Betts and Freeman are, they are not playing as well as they usually do. Freeman and Betts having down years due to son's sickness and wrist injury resoectively.
@@TheRexrapper according to bball savant, Ohtani's expected HR minus actual was higher than Judge's (third highest in baseball behind Santander and Gunnar)
It's clear that deep down, the host isn't just happy for Ohtani's success: even as he praises him, he constantly compares him to other players, boasting about how they excel and highlighting how Ohtani falls short.
Yankees only paid judge 360 million vs dodgers 700 mil for ohtani. Others teams willing to pay ohtani same amount too. So based on that I think ohtani is wayyyy better player.
The fact that you need to bring in the WEATHER as an argument to emphasize Judge says how desperate some analysts are to prop him up. Ohtani doesn’t need any deep dive into his stats, we all know his was the real historic season this year.
There's only one, GOAT and Unicorn. Nobody EVER calls Judge a unicorn or goat because he's doing something that's been done already. Judge also plays at hitter friendly park Yankee stadium. Look at Soto, he average 25 Homers his entire career with .267 batting average. When he goes to the Yankees, he hits 40 HR and over .300 batting. If Judge plays at Dodgers stadium, he will be lucky to hit 45 Homers.
I’m a fan of both, but like 2 weeks ago, Judge dropped a routine fly ball. Then yesterday, he struck out 5 times in a game. Yikes, for the best hitter in the game.
Yankee fans talk about Judge's fielding like he's a Gold Glover when in fact he has a negative DWAR. Some guys' fielding is worse than no fielding at all. At least Ohtani's not hurting his team with negative DWAR fielding.
@@ST-lb9tt No Yankee fan talks about Judge being gold glove at center field. He is playing it to help out Soto who can only play right field (Judge's actual position). A DH will never be as valuable as someone playing in the field everyday. If Judge and Ohtani were in the same league this season, Judge would win MVP over him.
I have great respect for Judge as a player and a man, and his season has been spectacular, but Ohtani does many things that are superior even when they don't show up in the usual stats line. How many bases did Ohtani steal vs Judge? 58-10. Huge discrepancy, and Ohtani has a record success rate at it compared with others in history with 55+ stolen bases. How does his baserunning affect the other teams when they're on defense--disrupting the pitcher's mindset and putting infielders on edge? He often turns a walk or a single into a double or even ending up on third by steals. On the stats front, Ohtani has more extra base hits and total bases than Judge, and fewer strikeouts. Consider Ohtani's daily regimen as well. Ohtani is known for his daily workout regimen, all while rehabbing from a major elbow surgery. He's doing some pitching prep almost every day and now progressed to throwing at almost full-strength. He has yet to miss more than one or two games this year because of injury despite his at-bats, base stealing and more. (When he was with the Angels, I used to see him getting hit frequently from fouling off pitches to his body, etc.) And though he hasn't pitched in a game this year, Ohtani is an elite pitcher. When he's doing both pitching and hitting at an elite level, he's clearly a superior baseball player and contributor to his team's success. The guy is otherworldly.
Judge plays at Yankee stadium where a pop up is a homerun .. if ohtani played at Yankee stadium he would be hitting .400 81 HR 201 RBI slug 931 and a OPS of 5000000$&@&@$@&;:/‘
Look what Aaron Judge has done in his career in the post season. In 175 career post season games he has a .206 batting average with 36 hits, 13 home runs, 30 runs scored, and 25 RBI. He has 69 strike outs and 26 walks. Keep in mind that 175 games is MORE THAN A FULL SEASON. That’s a huge sample size. 36 hits in 175 games. 25 RBI. .206 BA. By the way, this includes the game today in which he was 0/4 with 3 strikeouts. Every GM in baseball would take Ohtani over Judge if given the choice.
Just LOL that they're saying Ohtani has the more "hitter friendly" environment when Judge literally plays in the most hitter friendly park in baseball history
They're both amazing players, really like Ronald and Messi in Soccer football. Judge is an incredible hitter and also a phenomenal fielder. He made his funs say "Wow!" Ohtani is a pitcher in rehab but started 50-50 club. He made every witness says "How?"
Promoting one and putting the other down is the most ridiculous thing you can do. We need to give more praise and gratitude to both of them for this amazing season.
"... and you look at Ohtani - he's only got 81 walks" He says this less than 60 seconds after he says that its important to note that Judge has a better OBP.
And Arraez has very little PA, not much over the league minimum. For Ohtani, a power hitter to be in the chase with him for the batting title shows how well rounded Ohtani's game is.
Shohei is the only GOAT in MLB period....and MILLIONS of people around the world would agree. There is NO athlete in baseball with this kind of POWER and speed. And oh hes a CY caliber pitcher. NY VS LA. We will see who wills his team to VICTORY.
Dodger Stadium......notoriously a hard place to get a homerun. yet this dude just said on national TV, that its a hitter friendly park. And then he goes on to say Ohtani didnt struggle? like the korea series and the first month didnt happen!!! Who is paying these guys?
Notoriously hard? Maybe 10-15 years ago. Mookie hit a career high in homers when he came to the Dodgers. Same with Ohtani lol. Same with Hernandez lol. I can go on and on.
@@TheRexrapper yea the dodgers are having a great year. but that has nothing to do with the park itself. those are just high tier players right in their primes. Dodger stadium year after year has some of the lowest homer numbers in the MLB, it has one of the largest outfield numbers too. Statcast might show one of the highest homer numbers, but thats because the team is full of huge bats.
@@TheRexrapper because stanton didnt play enough games? you're asking me why a team (no team in the MLB does) doesnt have more than 2 30 run hitters? ask the rockies that same question.
I'd say they are equally as terrifying for any pitcher. Can't really put one over the other. Batting, they are both dangerous game changers. For 700 million, he better be this good lol anything less than what he's doing would be a disappointment. On a 10 year 700 million dollar deal, that will age horribly like most of these MLB contracts. Yeah, you'll get your 5 or so good seasons maybe but 10 solid seasons? Not likely. Ohtani is great but he kinda ruined baseball at the same time. One could argue the structure of his deal is borderline cheating. Allowing the super rich Dodgers to grab more top tier players and not going over the cap or breaking the wallet. Not to mention, now he made the market that much harder for teams to get good talent because players are going to compare to his atrocious deal. Sports are becoming a money game and nothing more.
Asian players earn their pay, look at Ichiro hardest worker same like Ohtani, you'd be more worried with Soto pulling a Rendon. Ohtani is getting underpaid if anything and he's not ruining baseball if anything he is saving baseball. Can other players accept such a huge deferral in salary? Bet you Soto won't because Ohtani has $50 mill of endorsements to fall back on. Baseball players have never seen that kind of money from endorsements. That's LeBron territory.
You guys hate on judge so much..judge did play the field and still put up ridiculous numbers and started off super slow..ohtani didnt pitch or play defense..he was strictly dh and didn't have to use to much energy.
So glad you mentioned this. Been saying it for months, Judge's defensive WAR is a negative, one of the worst among baseball centerfielders. Judge is hurting his team more by fielding.
Put Judge in leadoff see how he does. They'll walk him all day. They can't do that to Shohei because if they pitch to him, he hits a HR and if they walk him, he steals and can score without a hit.
I always wonder why alot of people ate talking that the yankee stadium is an homer friendly place... Can anybody explain?.. does it mean that judge will have lesser hr if he bats at a different stadium?
No manager has ever said that. Literally not one. Judge is walked because 1. He is the most feared hitter in the game. 2. No one behind Judge produces enough to warrant not walking him. If Judge had a Mookie Betts or Freeman behind him, he would not get walked regardless on if he stole base or not. What good does stealing base do if your teammates can't get you in?
@@TheRexrapper now don’t be naive, if a guy can steal bases will create more chances. A single will score Ohtani from 2nd than Judge from first. Judge might be a better hitter, but Ohtani is a better overall player
@@xgl175 The chances don't matter if your teammates don't produce with those chances. The value of a steal is dependent on what your teammates do. Ohtani wasn't a better overall player THIS season.
@@xgl175 Ohtani can hit, sure. He can't hit as well as Judge. Nowhere near as well. That's based on stats. Does Ohtani play the field? That's something Judge does that Ohtani doesn't. Ohtani does pitch which is something Judge doesn't do but you said Ohtani can do everything Judge does which isn't true.
yada yada yada. looks like Klutch workkings here. judge is never…NEVER a superior player than Ohtani. Most notable games for both players is the 6 for 6 for Ohtani, and the 5 for 5 in strike outs for Judge
it was about the 60ht against the 50/50 now that we are almost last game not 60hr but othani in 54/58 you talking about batting average, the moving of goal post is crazy, let make bobby witt mvp than for batting over 330 lol.nothing giving and soto obp is 420 judge goes to the box with a man on base almost 50% of the time compared to 8th and 9th batt in dodger
@@gsuandre5579 huh? You yapping about all of judges numbers being better or something? They were talking batting average in the video and if you told me judge would have a higher batting average than Luis arraez preseason I would be surprised but here we are. Ohtani is just a dh this year and judge is a better hitter in every hitting category. Sorry I moved your goal posts scrub
50/50 is harder to achieve than 60 HRs. 50/50 is all about the combination of power and speed. It can also be said that Ohtani can achieve 60 HRs in a season. Ohtani is better as a pitcher than as a hitter, which means he hasn't reached his peak as a hitter.
@@Will-si5ps I’d agree if they didn’t change the rules to help people steal bases. I’d say now the bigger sign of power speed is home runs and doubles - a 50/50 year that way is more elite in todays game and improves your teams chances of winning more
Ohtani is the Superman of baseball right now. He’s bringing together casual sport fans from all over the world to watch baseball, which is a beautiful thing for the sport. 🥳
Worldwide superstar
@@cindymmm11 worldwide legend in his prime 🥳
@@davidh7832 my sentiment exactly
He’s must see tv. He’s aesthetically pleasing especially in that dodger blue
they're all saying not that we are taking anything away from Ohtani blah blah~ you guys are trying real hard to diminish what Ohtani has done this season
Yeah. I've been saying this weeks ago. They'll sprinkle it little bits of compliment here and there to make their statements sound reasonable. Just say if you hate the player and glaze another player so we can move on our day.
It's not diminishing Ohtani. It's putting into perspective what Judge has done.
It's unfair to hide the fact that a rehabbing pitcher is doing this hitting.
Please also explain what other pitchers who have had Tommy John surgery are doing this season.
Other pitchers with TJ surgery no play for the season. Only Shohei play.
Other pitchers aren't hitting. I don't even understand the point you are making. If Ohtani was strictly a pitcher, he wouldn't have played this season.
@@TheRexrapperhis point is there is NO Athlete in MLB breaking records that have stood for 100yrs except Shohei. Power and speed with CY caliber arm and he is rehabbing it.
@@Levi-em6ym You still don't get it. He asked to name other pitchers who are doing what Ohtani is doing. Of course there are no pitchers doing what he is doing because they DON'T HIT. Do you not understand that people watch baseball and know who Ohtani is. No one is new to the fact that Ohtani also pitches.
Ohtani's WPA higher than Judge is an evidence that Ohtani's focus is always the winning of the team. He doesn't focus on his own individual stat. His SB record is also a testimony that he wants to run as long as his SB can help the team score more.
What is the guy smoking, Ohtani has not struggled? He was on an August long slump but he went nuts in Sept tho.
He forgot to mention Aaron doesn't pitch or steal bases like Shohei, not even close. Aaron's hitting numbers are only a little better than Shohei.
Ohtani also has more 400ft homeruns!! And numerous records this year including 50/50. And whata judge stealing pct? Cus ohtani is like 99% when he steals second
They know and don't care. They're purposely not factoring that in because it makes for more interesting narrative. Just like back in the heydays of basketball rivalry. It was Larry vs Magic. It was MJ vs whoever.
They need this rivalry for views.
So they are deliberately leaving out factors that will boost Ohtani above Judge.
And only looking at pure numbers to create this Ohtani vs Judge discussion.
They are talking about this season. Why would they mention Ohtani pitching? Steals are not more valuable than walks.
@@TheRexrapper Steals are a lot more valuable than walks, since it gets your closer to home plate to score the run easier. And also puts a lot of pressure on the opposing pitcher.
@@investingty Simply not true. A steals value is dependent on your supporting cast. If they can't do their job, the steals have no impact. A walk guarantees two things: 1. You aren't getting an out 2. You get on base. A steal has no guarantees except advancing to another base. You mention putting pressure on the pitcher. What if your teammates suck with runners in scoring position? Basically what if they are notorious for not producing with men in scoring position? How much pressure is that pitcher feeling knowing that? Probably not much.
OHTANI IS THE FACE OF MLB THIS YEAR, A GLOBAL PHENOMENON!!! CAN YOU SAY THAT ABOUT AARON JUDGE???
exactly
特に9月 世界で1番インターネット検索されたスポーツ選手は大谷 ヨーロッパでも大谷はジャッジより知られている（笑）
True
Let's celebrate both.. baseball has won..
No one outside of US/Canada would know who Judge is if not for Shohei.
Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player. Even when he isn’t pitching, he’s still arguably the best hitter and best overall baseball player. When Ohtani is pitching, there’s no question that Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player.
What's really amazing about Shohei Ohtani is that he has the most child fans in the world.
He supports baseball all over the world and is a role model for children. He is also a gentleman and does not spit in the stadium or throw trash on the bench. He picks up trash instead. He does not unbutton his clothes or wear jewelry during games.
He simply enjoys baseball with all his might in order to convey the joy of baseball to children all over the world.
Othani is baseball rite now
Now Ohtani has the world's attention in the MLB. He's a legend in baseball at this point. Can Aaron do this?
Mookie wasn't in the lineup for 3 months my and Freddy has been out too. LA better place for hitters? Yankees stadium is barely 300 at right field lmao. Also judge walks more cause he doesn't steal. Walking ohtani is giving him 2nd base or maybe 3rd.
@@tchlin that’s not why they don’t walk Ohtani- he’s got great hitters behind him that punish you for walking Ohtani. Also people don’t walk the leadoff hitter of the game/inning because of the likelihood that run scores regardless of who it is
@Maker161st ...have you ever played baseball? when Soto gets on base and he gets on base a lot....pitchers are forced to throw strikes...
Judge walks more because the 4th hitter is a bum, Ohtani had Freeman behind him at the beginning of the season and as the leadoff hitter he had Betts and Freeman. C'mon here, this should be common sense who gets more walk.
@@stranger333k then why does judge have more walks than Soto you never was scrub? He gets walked bc he doesn’t have studs behind him like Ohtani does
@@Maker161st he gets more walks because he's a better hr hitter...and when Soto doesn't get on base ..they can walk him coz he isn't a threat to steal..
Before Ohtani, baseball was globally non-existent. After Ohtani, baseball enthusiasm has grown around the world when basketball is waning down. Let those fan numbers stick for a moment as compared to stat numbers. What matters most? But you know what as a new baseball/Ohtani fan, I do hope Judge gets the triple crown as Shohei broke a lot of records already. It would be a nice promotion for a more exciting and hopefully Dodgers-Yankees match.
9月世界で1番インターネット検索されたのは大谷 サッカーロナウドなどよりも大谷
アメリカ 日本 韓国 そしてヨーロッパも大谷 野球選手が世界で1番インターネット検索されたのは大谷が初めて？（笑）
People are losing all context here. Ohtani is like if Gerrit Cole got TJ surgery and hit like Judge in his off year while rehabbing. It’s impossibly great. Arguing that Judge is the superior player by comparing his marginally better hitting stats is not only dumb and lazy, it’s disingenuous. No one is close to Ohtani, including Judge. That’s not an opinion. It’s a fact.
His hitting stats are not marginally better. You either are straight up lying or don't know how to interpret stats. An OPS 132 points higher is not marginal. An OPS+ that is 32 points higher is not marginal. An on base percentage that is 67 points higher is not marginal. The difference is dramatic. That's not even factoring in things like wRC+ which had Judge's season as the 7th best hitting season in the history of baseball. The media is trying to make it seem like their hitting numbers are comparable. They aren't.
The gap in hitting between Judge and Ohtani is getting smaller while Judge still can't pitch.
@@ST-lb9tt It isn't getting smaller. It's getting larger.
If Judge were in Dodger stadium, he'd only have 50 HRs
@@TheRexrapper Of course Judge will have better stats. Dude play in a small ass stadium half of the year. Look at soto for example, I wonder why soto has the best stats he ever had since coming to the Yankees.
Yankee stadium is little league ballpark.
There have been many players like judge
Ohtani's record is a feat that will never be seen again.
Ohtani is the man God created to be the savior of baseball.
Name me another 6'7 282 pound center fielder?
@@TheRexrapper name me who can strike out hundred batters and can do 50 homeruns
@@maeztro4461 What is your point? The original comment said there have been many players like Judge. Who are these players?
@@TheRexrapperduhhh...your like comparing KARL JUDGE MALONE TO Shohei MICHAEL Jordan. Shohei has broken records that stood a 100yrs and now with his 50/50 he stands alone...period.
@@Levi-em6ym Once again, try to read carefully. The original comment said there have been many players like Judge. Name these many players who are 6'7 282 pounds who hits the way he does?
Yankee stadium is one of the most home run friendly parks, and also Juan Soto bats before judge in 3rd position, Ohtani bats leadoff there's no one to bat in yet he still leads the NL.
Hitter friendly to who? Who outside of Soto and Judge in the Yankees lineup has that ballpark benefitted?
They forget that who hits behind Shohei is not the reason why he’s not walked. Nobody wants to walk Shohei because that’s basically going up a double and now you’ve got a fast runner on second base.
That wouldn't matter if the players after Ohtani didn't hit. Ohtani could steal all he wants but if the players behind him don't produce, the stolen bases mean nothing unless Ohtani steals home base which is extremely unlikely.
As great Betts and Freeman are, they are not playing as well as they usually do. Freeman and Betts having down years due to son's sickness and wrist injury resoectively.
What is this nonsense. Dodger Stadium is a pitcher's park.
@@xavierfranco5800 it's always been a pitchers park...anyone who follows baseball knows it too..
@@stranger333k No it hasn't. If Judge was in that ballpark it's the same results.
@@TheRexrapper lol no. He would lose 4-7 home runs off his total
@@JasonJia909 Not according to home runs expected. He would hit 63 in Dodger stadium. Ohtani would hit 50 in NY.
@@TheRexrapper according to bball savant, Ohtani's expected HR minus actual was higher than Judge's (third highest in baseball behind Santander and Gunnar)
It's clear that deep down, the host isn't just happy for Ohtani's success: even as he praises him, he constantly compares him to other players, boasting about how they excel and highlighting how Ohtani falls short.
I'm glad they keep doing that, only fuels Ohtani to keep improving.
Yankees only paid judge 360 million vs dodgers 700 mil for ohtani. Others teams willing to pay ohtani same amount too. So based on that I think ohtani is wayyyy better player.
your a smart girl
The fact that you need to bring in the WEATHER as an argument to emphasize Judge says how desperate some analysts are to prop him up. Ohtani doesn’t need any deep dive into his stats, we all know his was the real historic season this year.
If you flipped their races, if Ohtani were black and Judge were Asian, they would still say the black athlete is better.
There's only one, GOAT and Unicorn. Nobody EVER calls Judge a unicorn or goat because he's doing something that's been done already. Judge also plays at hitter friendly park Yankee stadium. Look at Soto, he average 25 Homers his entire career with .267 batting average. When he goes to the Yankees, he hits 40 HR and over .300 batting. If Judge plays at Dodgers stadium, he will be lucky to hit 45 Homers.
One bats leadoff and the other 3rd .... of course Judge has more opportunities with runners on base.
ohtani is a lead off hitter. power number would drastically go up if he hits middle of lineup.
OHTANI IS BASEBALL!! JUDGE IS JUST ANOTHER PLAYER 😂😂
Facts
Ohtani is the first pitcher to receive the MVP without pitching one game. How about that as a resume? 🙄😂🤣
He isn't receiving the award as a pitcher. If that's your logic, Babe Ruth did that before Ohtani.
@@TheRexrapper I think we all know that 🙄😂😂😂😂😂😂
The fact that Ohtani is doing all this after coming off a Tommy John surgery and recovering is crazy
A healthy Ohtani clears judge easy 🤷♂️
I’m a fan of both, but like 2 weeks ago, Judge dropped a routine fly ball. Then yesterday, he struck out 5 times in a game. Yikes, for the best hitter in the game.
It's baseball. You can't base a bad game off of anything.
Yankee fans talk about Judge's fielding like he's a Gold Glover when in fact he has a negative DWAR. Some guys' fielding is worse than no fielding at all. At least Ohtani's not hurting his team with negative DWAR fielding.
@@ST-lb9tt No Yankee fan talks about Judge being gold glove at center field. He is playing it to help out Soto who can only play right field (Judge's actual position). A DH will never be as valuable as someone playing in the field everyday. If Judge and Ohtani were in the same league this season, Judge would win MVP over him.
Ohtani and Judge were in the AL last year and Ohtani won the MVP.
@@ST-lb9tt Judge missed 60 games last year. They both were healthy in 2022. Who won?
Why would pitchers walk Ohtani, he's always a threat to steal. It's more reasonable to walk Judge since his speed is not a threat
I have great respect for Judge as a player and a man, and his season has been spectacular, but Ohtani does many things that are superior even when they don't show up in the usual stats line. How many bases did Ohtani steal vs Judge? 58-10. Huge discrepancy, and Ohtani has a record success rate at it compared with others in history with 55+ stolen bases. How does his baserunning affect the other teams when they're on defense--disrupting the pitcher's mindset and putting infielders on edge? He often turns a walk or a single into a double or even ending up on third by steals. On the stats front, Ohtani has more extra base hits and total bases than Judge, and fewer strikeouts. Consider Ohtani's daily regimen as well. Ohtani is known for his daily workout regimen, all while rehabbing from a major elbow surgery. He's doing some pitching prep almost every day and now progressed to throwing at almost full-strength. He has yet to miss more than one or two games this year because of injury despite his at-bats, base stealing and more. (When he was with the Angels, I used to see him getting hit frequently from fouling off pitches to his body, etc.) And though he hasn't pitched in a game this year, Ohtani is an elite pitcher. When he's doing both pitching and hitting at an elite level, he's clearly a superior baseball player and contributor to his team's success. The guy is otherworldly.
Why are we still comparing? Nothing to talk about? Ohtani is the best ever.
Judge plays at Yankee stadium where a pop up is a homerun .. if ohtani played at Yankee stadium he would be hitting .400 81 HR 201 RBI slug 931 and a OPS of 5000000$&@&@$@&;:/‘
Biggest lie ever told. Ohtani hits terrible in Yankee stadium for his career. Career low numbers.
Im not a Dodgers nor Yankees fan. Im a Nationals n baseball fan. I love watching Ohtani and Judge in play.
Look what Aaron Judge has done in his career in the post season. In 175 career post season games he has a .206 batting average with 36 hits, 13 home runs, 30 runs scored, and 25 RBI. He has 69 strike outs and 26 walks. Keep in mind that 175 games is MORE THAN A FULL SEASON. That’s a huge sample size. 36 hits in 175 games. 25 RBI. .206 BA.
By the way, this includes the game today in which he was 0/4 with 3 strikeouts.
Every GM in baseball would take Ohtani over Judge if given the choice.
Just LOL that they're saying Ohtani has the more "hitter friendly" environment when Judge literally plays in the most hitter friendly park in baseball history
Why does it have to be shohei vs judge, can't we just appreciate both players. Both of em are awesome!
They both are but there are some that see it as a zero sum game.
What you talking about? Elly De La Cruz has 218 strikeouts. He strikes the most by a mile. Oh strikes the most fear?
They're both amazing players, really like Ronald and Messi in Soccer football.
Judge is an incredible hitter and also a phenomenal fielder. He made his funs say "Wow!"
Ohtani is a pitcher in rehab but started 50-50 club. He made every witness says "How?"
Promoting one and putting the other down is the most ridiculous thing you can do. We need to give more praise and gratitude to both of them for this amazing season.
I'd say both equally. Judge is 6'7", 280lb. How can pitchers not be intimidated!
4:10 weather! Lol. Yankee Stadium doesn’t even conform to the minimum distance the outfield wall is supposed to be.
He talks about how Shohei plays with Mookie and Freddie but did he forget that Aaron Judge plays with Juan Soto?
Judge was chasing his history and didn't reach his history he made last year.
Ohtani was producing the history of MLB that was established 50-50 club.
Not compare...diferent baseball players
Judge is superman, Ohtani is batman
All 3 of you need to be in a circus if you think judge is better...did judge steal 58 bases??
One bats leadoff and is recovering from a major surgery lol
Irrelevant to this season. Plus if we want to play that game, in 2022 Ohtani hit and pitched and clearly lost MVP to Judge.
Imagine the dodgers Yankees in the World Series. I mean could there be a more perfect battle?
That all sounds great. How will these teams do in the postseason? Tuesday....that all means nothing.
Love Judge, even got his jersey. But cmon, Ohtani is baseball right now.
Aaron Judge strikes out five times vs Pirates. He has 17 games where he had four strike outs or more. Yeah, not afraid of that puppy.
No one wants to watch a giant trot forward or backward a few steps after batting, it's boring.
Does Judge pitch?
Ohtani didn't pitch this season. Stop shifting the argument. It's about this season.
Ohtani is the only UNICORN in this league
Shohei is so Dynamic
Wow, based on the comments below, these guys are completely tone deaf and context nuance.
"... and you look at Ohtani - he's only got 81 walks"
He says this less than 60 seconds after he says that its important to note that Judge has a better OBP.
Shohei is the only reason I watch baseball, not Judge lol.
Even Shohei looks better HR trotting but we love seeing him run around the bases causing so much chaos for the opposing team.
Who cares
Apparently you do cuz you replied
@@ST-lb9tt That doesn't mean I care
You even cared to edit lol
Why are they comparing full time career hitter with an Injured Ace who hits as a side gig!
Yankee stadium field is like 250ft
MVP Ohtani should deserve a triple crown.
Ohtani => 54 HR, 130 RBI, .310 Avg, 1036 OPS
Luiz Dias => 4 HR, 46 RBI, .314 Avg, .739 OPS
And Arraez has very little PA, not much over the league minimum. For Ohtani, a power hitter to be in the chase with him for the batting title shows how well rounded Ohtani's game is.
5:00 yeah right LOL Judge Strike out 5 times yesterday trying to hit homeruns
I think there’s a Soto in NY
9月世界で1番インターネット検索されたスポーツ選手は大谷 アメリカ 日本 韓国そしてヨーロッパでも大谷
サッカーロナウドよりも大谷が検索数が多かったらしい（笑）これは野球人として初めて？
Shohei is the only GOAT in MLB period....and MILLIONS of people around the world would agree. There is NO athlete in baseball with this kind of POWER and speed. And oh hes a CY caliber pitcher. NY VS LA. We will see who wills his team to VICTORY.
Dodger Stadium......notoriously a hard place to get a homerun. yet this dude just said on national TV, that its a hitter friendly park.
And then he goes on to say Ohtani didnt struggle? like the korea series and the first month didnt happen!!!
Who is paying these guys?
not to mention outside of Coors, Yankee stadium is the EASIEST park to hit a home run.
Notoriously hard? Maybe 10-15 years ago. Mookie hit a career high in homers when he came to the Dodgers. Same with Ohtani lol. Same with Hernandez lol. I can go on and on.
@@Nightfreed If Yankee stadium is so easy to hit homers in, why didn't anyone outside of Judge and Soto hit 30+?
@@TheRexrapper yea the dodgers are having a great year. but that has nothing to do with the park itself. those are just high tier players right in their primes. Dodger stadium year after year has some of the lowest homer numbers in the MLB, it has one of the largest outfield numbers too. Statcast might show one of the highest homer numbers, but thats because the team is full of huge bats.
@@TheRexrapper because stanton didnt play enough games? you're asking me why a team (no team in the MLB does) doesnt have more than 2 30 run hitters? ask the rockies that same question.
I'd say they are equally as terrifying for any pitcher. Can't really put one over the other. Batting, they are both dangerous game changers. For 700 million, he better be this good lol anything less than what he's doing would be a disappointment. On a 10 year 700 million dollar deal, that will age horribly like most of these MLB contracts. Yeah, you'll get your 5 or so good seasons maybe but 10 solid seasons? Not likely. Ohtani is great but he kinda ruined baseball at the same time. One could argue the structure of his deal is borderline cheating. Allowing the super rich Dodgers to grab more top tier players and not going over the cap or breaking the wallet. Not to mention, now he made the market that much harder for teams to get good talent because players are going to compare to his atrocious deal. Sports are becoming a money game and nothing more.
Asian players earn their pay, look at Ichiro hardest worker same like Ohtani, you'd be more worried with Soto pulling a Rendon. Ohtani is getting underpaid if anything and he's not ruining baseball if anything he is saving baseball. Can other players accept such a huge deferral in salary? Bet you Soto won't because Ohtani has $50 mill of endorsements to fall back on. Baseball players have never seen that kind of money from endorsements. That's LeBron territory.
They bring up o he plays defense ....yeah he is among the worst his DRS ranks 20 of 22 his OAA ranks dead last
だから何が言いたいの
翔平がジャッジより優れてるのがよっぽど許せないみたい
どちらも素晴らしい選手
私はスピードとバワーを兼ね備えてる翔平に魅了される
なぜならそれがベースボールそのものだから
You guys hate on judge so much..judge did play the field and still put up ridiculous numbers and started off super slow..ohtani didnt pitch or play defense..he was strictly dh and didn't have to use to much energy.
no one hates judge.
no one cares actually
Who cares if its the best for a center fielder? Judge is the worst defensive center fielder in baseball. He's doesn't belong there.
So glad you mentioned this. Been saying it for months, Judge's defensive WAR is a negative, one of the worst among baseball centerfielders. Judge is hurting his team more by fielding.
@@ST-lb9tt No he isn't. He's helping his team because he is playing a position that he isn't his actual position to help out Soto.
Yeah well Ohtani took over when Mookie was injured and is hitting leadoff, not his position yet he did it better than any leadoff hitter.
@@ST-lb9tt That's a position in the order. Thats not the same as switching to another defensive position. Nowhere near the same.
Put Judge in leadoff see how he does. They'll walk him all day. They can't do that to Shohei because if they pitch to him, he hits a HR and if they walk him, he steals and can score without a hit.
I always wonder why alot of people ate talking that the yankee stadium is an homer friendly place...
Can anybody explain?.. does it mean that judge will have lesser hr if he bats at a different stadium?
Baseball is coming back!!!
Keep it in mind, you walk Judge because he doesn't steal bases like Ohtani does, so you can afford putting him on first.
No manager has ever said that. Literally not one. Judge is walked because 1. He is the most feared hitter in the game. 2. No one behind Judge produces enough to warrant not walking him. If Judge had a Mookie Betts or Freeman behind him, he would not get walked regardless on if he stole base or not. What good does stealing base do if your teammates can't get you in?
@@TheRexrapper now don’t be naive, if a guy can steal bases will create more chances. A single will score Ohtani from 2nd than Judge from first. Judge might be a better hitter, but Ohtani is a better overall player
@@xgl175 The chances don't matter if your teammates don't produce with those chances. The value of a steal is dependent on what your teammates do. Ohtani wasn't a better overall player THIS season.
@@TheRexrapper let me put it this way, Ohtani can do what Judge does, but Judge can’t do what Ohtani does. We’re talking about skill sets
@@xgl175 Ohtani can hit, sure. He can't hit as well as Judge. Nowhere near as well. That's based on stats. Does Ohtani play the field? That's something Judge does that Ohtani doesn't. Ohtani does pitch which is something Judge doesn't do but you said Ohtani can do everything Judge does which isn't true.
yada yada yada. looks like Klutch workkings here. judge is never…NEVER a superior player than Ohtani. Most notable games for both players is the 6 for 6 for Ohtani, and the 5 for 5 in strike outs for Judge
For batting, I think Judge is better.
センターとピッチャー
を比べてどうする
アメリカ人よ
Thompson Patricia Hall Michelle Anderson Dorothy
Have Judge pitch to Ohtani.
Your right! I get your point. Comparing Judge to Ohtani is like Comparing Barkley to Jordan. That's how ridiculous it is!!
@@josephstamp837 It's that ridiculous if you don't know baseball.
Judge having a higher average than arraez is crazy- Ohtani is lucky he got out of the AL
it was about the 60ht against the 50/50 now that we are almost last game not 60hr but othani in 54/58 you talking about batting average, the moving of goal post is crazy, let make bobby witt mvp than for batting over 330 lol.nothing giving and soto obp is 420 judge goes to the box with a man on base almost 50% of the time compared to 8th and 9th batt in dodger
@@gsuandre5579 huh? You yapping about all of judges numbers being better or something? They were talking batting average in the video and if you told me judge would have a higher batting average than Luis arraez preseason I would be surprised but here we are. Ohtani is just a dh this year and judge is a better hitter in every hitting category. Sorry I moved your goal posts scrub
50/50 is harder to achieve than 60 HRs. 50/50 is all about the combination of power and speed. It can also be said that Ohtani can achieve 60 HRs in a season. Ohtani is better as a pitcher than as a hitter, which means he hasn't reached his peak as a hitter.
@@Will-si5ps I’d agree if they didn’t change the rules to help people steal bases. I’d say now the bigger sign of power speed is home runs and doubles - a 50/50 year that way is more elite in todays game and improves your teams chances of winning more
@@Maker161st 🤡🤡🤡
First one to 400 bases wins
Uh, no, not even close. There is not batter in baseball more fearsome than Judge. Ohtani is more of a nuisance on the basepaths.
Only nuisance I see is U.
大谷は神
Judge and Ohtani are not better than Miguel Cabrera
who is that?
Is a bunch of other players I’m tired of othani
Never compare a pro baseball player with a pro kid japan baseball player
Ohtani will be MVP..