Culture of brute majority is to be brutal, coalition govt better for Indian democracy, Kapil Sibal
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- #ThePrintUninterrupted #kapilsibal
Ten years of Narendra Modi rule is an aberration, says eminent politician and lawyer Kapil Sibal, who believes coalition government is better for India's governance. In an interview with ThePrint Sibal questions ECI's partisan role, need for an independent judiciary and calls for a debate on all laws cleared in the last five years.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Kapil's concern against three new criminal laws is well conceived. He should make effort to ensure that these three laws are widely debated across the country before their enforcement.
True. These efforts have to be supported by citizens en masse.
The elections have produced a hung parliament. The results do not favour any political party. The elections are too much stretched. Why does it take such a long time? The VVPATs should be fully counted to ensure the correctness of elections. The battle is not over. In order to restore democracy in the country, the fight must go on. The INDIA Alliance should work hard and take up different issues facing the nation. The bulwark against slipping the country to authoritarianism is to maintain greater vigil. People also should weigh the pros and cons of electing autocratic leaders. The formation of a government doesn't mean India's problems are solved. Democracy is an evolving process. I greatly appreciate that Kapil Subal Saheb is doing an excellent job in educating the people. That is indeed a great thing.
Sibal is absolutely right. The country is made to function by federalism and when this is followed in spirt and actions, the nation would develop and the upcoming states would be happily supported by the states that have moved ahead.
Core professional stands for INDIA 🙏. Thank you Kapil Sibal
When Kapil Sibal speaks wisdom and truth flows like a river ❤
Coalition shouldn't be like - "Rajiv Gandhi overturning SC's judgement on Shah Bano" to appease Muslim Community and "Unlocking gates of Babri" to appease Hindu Community. These kind of appeasements - give and take - balancing act is disaster. There should be a moral benchmark that the appeasement decisions should pass.
Oh like Modi overturning SC decision on Delhi.
@@ajitpati9324 You are comparing overturning of decision of Executive authority with Rajiv overturning Moral Justice. Actually, it is not overturning. The bill created a clarified structure and process for transfers. It is not like you go to CM and ask for transfer and he just transfers on his whims or CM don't like the guy, so just transfer him. That is Dictatorship.
@@srkchandrala1071 Prime Minster has executive powers provided by constitution. Get some civics lesson.
@@ajitpati9324I don't get it. PM Modi didn't appease anyone.
What's the connection between coalition and Mr. rajiv Gandhi's decision??
India needs so many reforms. We should hope for more individuals such as Mr Sibbal to help country bring such reforms in reality.
Thanks for bringing this for your viewers.
South rejects BJP Wale aaj kal Thankyou Uttar Pradesh bol rahen hain 😂😂😂😂
😂south me to Moye moye ho gya indie ka
South 😂😂😂😂😂 they vote on religion basis... Especially kerala..
AP THIS time had split issues with telegana... Karnataka BJP... Congress DMK distribute money, solar panel, rice to get votes, so that they can rule 5 years and get 100x return what they gave to people.....
Are bhai 2024 me patanahi INDI walo ne kaise campaign kiya 1 Saal ke andar sabko graduate banadiya🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@anahita-bn6cywrong. Still zero seats in Tamil Nadu. Only one in Kerala, and that too only because Suresh is secular and not a chaddi like most of BJP. That’s the true south. All andhra seats were won by TDP. Not by BJP lmao. Even BJP’s own 3 seats were TDP men😂. Only Karnataka has a BJP base and even there they lost 8 seats from 2019. South main abhi bhi moye moye hain andhbhakts kein😂
@@fawaaza.7743you're wrong, Middle Class in South is as much radicalised as Middle class of Kanpur or Delhi
Era of coalition will continue because best solution was inked under Anandpur Sahib resolution strategy back in 1978.
As always you are a beacon of light.
Please push Bhadra on the issue of “ appeasement “ Mr. Kapil Sibal. She has concerns on this issue in the case of coalition government.
Not just bail plea, simple cases take 50years
Coalition govt gets little to nothing done. Has this gentleman read Indian history
Are you high? Historically, Coalition governments produce better economic results, get your facts straight
Coalition are those that pass humanitarian progressive development program.
In history the best results in developing a nation is when there is coalition government.
@@benaffleckisanokayactor If you look at the history of Coalition govt, then people will disagree and think the that there is no thing worse than coalition govt.
1977-1979 Janata Party Morarji Desai (Congress (O))
1979-1980 Janta Party (Secular) Charan Singh (Janata (S))
1989-1990 National Front V.P Singh (Janata Dal)
1990-1991 Janata Dal (Socialist) or Samajwadi Janata Party Chandra Shekar (Janata Dal (S) or Samajwadi Party)
1996-1997 United Front H..D Deve Gowda (Janata Dal)
1997-1998 United Front I.K Gujral (Janata Dal)
1997-1998 BJP-led Coalition A.B. Vajpayee (BJP)
1999-2004 National Democratic Alliance (NDA) A.B. Vajpayee (BJP)
2004-2009 United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Manmohan Singh (Congress)
2009-2014 United Progressive Alliance - II (UPA-II) Manmohan Singh (Congress)
So, if you look at the above data, you can see a single coalition govt can run a single year on average, except UPA time. But if you look at the UPA time, there was a big scam every year: 9 big scam in 9 years and countless small and medium scams. Congress could not prosecute the scammers because they belong to smaller parties and could bring down the govt. Those coalition govt compromised RAW and I&B agencies for their selfish desires, and Pakistan could do big terror attacks without any repercussion taking advantage of this infighting.
Even Pakistanis reached our Parliament in 2001 and Indian govt could not fathom it because of lack of intelligence.
Check facts.
LPG , US-India Nuclear Deal, RTI, RTE, of course you might feel the latter two are liberal policies but I think they are good for the nation
Evm is not used any other country except India because machine is liable to tempering because of artificial intelligence era.
In fact the winning party should let go off all the seats beyond the simple majority of 272. And all the MPs should vote in electing the Prime MInister, not just the Winning party MPs. The Winning Party should put three MPs for the PM election within Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha to choose from....
He is one of the few reason of congress decline. He played very leftist kind of politics and even blamed RSS for 26/11 mumbai attack...
2 face snake, not more than that.
I admire and respect Sachin Pilot and Sashi Tharoor from congress, and all Hindus will definitely vote for them if they become the PM face in future, otherwise, Congress has no option if they go with Rahul Gandhi( silver spoon baby)...
looks like your biological clock didn't move after the exit poll. Reset it. Voters have spoken. The emperor became beggar.
Look @jaatkthaat you need to address two main issues that India is facing. 1. Persistently low wages 2. unemployment. When you look at other nations like Mexico President elect Claudia Sheinbaum political party address these two issues. 1. Her party raise wages in Mexico by 30% 2. Her party then got investments (money) from the United States and even China to build factories inside of Mexico there by lowering unemployment.
Currently, India is doing better and is 4th largest economy in world. However, the average Indian per capital income doesn't even breaking the top 100 countries in world. Also, India is severally lagging behind in foreign investments.
Khaat par lete raho...
I am assuming that Kapil Sibal never used ATM center to get money. Judgmentally its not right.
Mr. Sibbal, I was listening to you respectfully till the issue of election commission, - and election in varied phases. But perhaps you should explore the situation of west Bengal, why election had to be done in so many phases. We are victims, which you can not imagine sitting far away in Delhi.
Why Nehru betrayed Sikh community by refusing to implement the commitment made to the Community before independence?
Mr Sibal, A party getting a big majority is part and parcel of the democratic process..
Really? Mr. Starship, we humans have a saying - stop stating the bleeding obvious. Get BACK on your ship and RETURN HOME. TRUE "GHAR WAPSI".
Mr Sibbal is the face of Lutyens media. Now he is talking about concensus 😂. Why didnt he say anything when congress extreme socialist policies kept India poor. Also appeased minorities.
He lost the argument at the onset itself when he said coalition government is the best. No point in wasting time in viewing the further interview. 👎
See, everybody thought BJP will get single majority, but that didnt happen. That doesnt mean, this experience and phase of coalition will be bad for bjp. If bjp continue to do business with NDA coalition, they can easily win even more acceptance from the indian public, as that shows tht bjp is flexible and adaptive. But what about other parties like congress. Trouble will mount within congress day by day, since congress walas dont see any perspective for the party.
Prospects? What perspectives are you referring to? And there is no need for a comma after "That doesn't mean" (Horrendous English notwithstanding!) - the comma, if you must use one, can be used after the word experience in the sentence above.
And no I'm not an English teacher. I strongly oppose any "What about" people- and the reason for me taking you down a peg, is because you need to get an education BEFORE your opinions on Politics are formulated. Otherwise, you will REMAIN a part of the herd and your bleating will not really lead to serious debates, which are catalysts for positive change.
Kapil Sibal makes a few laughable statements:
1. He believes the country being held hostage to the whims and fancies of a few politicians is better than having a government with a proper majority.
2. He forgets that India adopted EVM after long trials stretching over a decade. The EC repeatedly offered doubters to demonstrate hacking. All of Kapil’s alleged experts failed.
3. Historically, elections have been won by stuffed ballots and booth capturing. The EC introduced measures , including EVM, to capture the power of every vote. However, Lutyen’s Delhi hanger ons, like Sibal, want to have the opportunity to tamper the system.
4. His argument that Western countries do not have EVM reflects his slavish mentality. If India does something better than other countries, applaud those involved. By his logic, India should go back to being a British colony.
A person who is a failed politician and whose only credential is that he was one of independent India’s most incompetent ministers. Why does Print give publicity to such persons?
it is better to 'be held hostage to the whims and fancies of a few politicians' than to 'be held hostage to the whims and fancies of one single non-biological entity''
Why are you crying for
the MVM so much, he clearly made the point that all machines can be manipulated by the person who operates/programme it. Even a person with simple coding knowledge can program it to his advantage. If the EVMS were not tweaked the BJP would not have fallen below 100.
@@007tj5 All his arguments are laughable. Elections, before EVM, were often won by stuffed ballots. EVM eradicated many malpractices. Kapil Sibal makes no valid or intelligent point - just rants. The rants were patiently listened to by EC and judiciary but found to have no merit.
In the past, EC had provided a challenge to all doubters to show their tampering skills. All of the experts - touted about by Sibal - either failed or were unwilling to take up the challenge. On the other hand, EVM in western nations, with different design, were found to be easy to tamper with.
Sibal’s main grouse is that voters do not vote for him and he wants a system where he could manipulate the system and win elections.
Please get your facts right before commenting.
Some interesting points made.
Having said that, please understand that as a developing nation, we are in a position to cherry pick from more developed nations. If the German Supreme Court has disapproved the use of EVMs, then that judgement is worth reading, before forming or positing an opinion.
Further, if we were to extrapolate your line of binary thought, we should insist that every male in this country should wear kurta pyjamas, or dhotis and not western clothes.
It's not a binary world.
@@rayzimmerman6740 So anything Indian is bad? That is the basis of Sibal's argument
The simple fact is the EC challenged anyone to hack their machines. Sibal's so called experts tried and failed. The Germans had different machines which could be tampered with. Sibal is simply a politician who succeeded in manipulating the system but failed to get voter support
India is changing and these old men don't understand it. We need visionaries and strong leaders so that we can become a dominant force in world order.
Actually evidence from around the world suggests that strongman leaders are actually less beneficial for a country. Countries which don’t have strong top-down leadership and instead rely on local officials to solve local problems raised by citizens do better. In a diverse country like India it is even more important to have local leaders who understand ground realities making decisions rather than a guy sitting in Delhi.
@@varshasindhu5672 absolutely correct
@@varshasindhu5672 Good sense, strongmen bring destruction eventually.
@@varshasindhu5672yours is a spam message being circulated since assembly elections.
Look there are two main issues that were not address in this election. 1. persistently low wages 2. unemployment. We see that over all that India is doing much better economically, but these two issues were not addressed.
Such one sided debates are useless where the guest go on eulogising congress but anchor not pointing out damage done to federalism by the congress.
You and your ilk should wake up and smell the coffee. This bi-partisan approach to debating serious matters is unhealthy.
This "whataboutism" has had its day, and the country is seeing through these smoke and mirrors politics.
The people of this country cannot be lulled into slumber indefinitely.
And unless you are an alien, you have eyes in front of your head - which is nature's way of telling you to look forward most of the time. This is diametrically in opposition to idiotic cancel culture political plays.
Lastly, this video is not a "DEBATE" and the INTERVIEWER is not an "ANCHOR". IT WAS AN INTERVIEW. You are so used to the GODI MEDIA FRAMEWORK THAT YOU CAN"T EVEN TELL THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A DEBATE AND AN INTERVIEW.
MINION!
Simply because Congress limped to less than 100 seats, he's saying coalition government is better. Dr MMS did admit that 'compulsions of coalition politics' did indeed refrain him from taking action on corruption. Sibal says coalition but means appeasement 😂😂
Sibbal is still legal mouth puppet of COngress. He may say he parted from Congress but ideologies still lies with congress.
We never wanted the PM seat. But to be a strong opposition with Vishwaguru's string . So that he can't dance according to his wills and pleasure with his shadow Shaw
How do you manage to laugh at your own comments ?
Actually doing corruption improves democracy🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@ushavijayan2031 Pappu never wanted to be PM? Yeah....sure 🤣🤣
All hyenas have come out to nibble on wounded lion forgwtting that the lion has few cubs still.
They were talking since t beginning you are new hearing because your ears and eyes were busy in seeing lies of godi medias.
And you are referring to attacking a wolf a wolf in sheeps clothing
That is not a lion who comes with crutches of CBI, ED, media and cronies. That, my friend, is a snake.
@@ThunderLightStrikes Lol. Maybe after buying snake oil you have become too acquainted with snakes.
There was never a Lion... It was more like a little naked Wizard of OZ scared to face press.... His balls were nibbled away by millions of ant
Err....you may find that lionesses have cubs....
in your particular case, maybe this is an exception. Would explain your line of thinking.
Congress men are always classy not like the ruffians .
Forgot Sanjay Gandhi squad😂😂😂😂?
@@muralidharbarkur Maybe that's why the lineage of Sanjay Gandhi chose to go with the party that matches his characteristics😊
Thank you RUclipsR’s for sharing your thoughts and insights, what was happening in northern part of India, because main stream MEDIA was not showing anything AT ALL what other parties were doing other than MODI MODI MODI………
You all made an effort for 235 seats…..!
Continue you hard work
Wish you all the best.
Love from Chennai -Sivaraman.
In case if you happen to be in chennai please let us catch up for coffee.
Fenku will now learn to be humble....
I certainly hope so....But wait, maybe the Parmatma doesn't agree with us... Let us bow and ask for his forgiveness.🤣
Nehru was the worst dictator who would not listen to any body but his on obsession.
Nehru was a democratic visionary and a principled statesman. He was the opposite of dictatorship. It is because of those qualities India got a good foundation which is why we did not turn into another Pakistan. No amount of Savarkar Golwalkar whatsapp propaganda can change this truth.
this whatsapp university guys think they can change people with lies😂 but will fail even miserably in next time . The guys don't know t people of India people they know lies they know this foul plays i just ❤ our people cz they waited silently till election and shown this guys u are just clowns for us and we ill laugh at your lies as jokes and when its time we will show u we are not fools.
this whatsapp university guys think they can change people with lies😂 and will fail even miserably in next time. These guys don't know t people the people know lies they know this foul plays i just ❤our people cz they waited silently till elections and shown them this guys u are just clowns for us we will laugh at your lies watch you act as clowns and when its time we will show u we can't be fooled.
But people are at peace with the concept of their money being all saved electronically in the banks...
But you know how much money there is in your account, and there are procedures to follow, if any disputes arise.
In the EVM case, it's a black box - a button is pressed, and a winner is declared at the end of the voting. There is NO TRANSPARENCY!
@@rayzimmerman6740 And then inflation eats into your money. Black box exchangevrates and so on. People happy to invest in bitcoins and blockchains without understanding and not physical medium like gold. At least EVMs have VVPAT
First uttered by Papu was getting rid of “Modiji and Shah”
You go according to his thoughts nothing will ever get done. Try getting family members together in one room , you’ll all fall apart and in the end you’ll please no one.Nehru chacha tried but today no one India respects what he stood for apart from “appeasements “.
Here he is blaming Modiji his venom comes out again Respect institutions my friend which ever country you are in .You should see this people go to West they respect police and officer in uniform, but not in India .Immediately his sceptical views about everything is the way of the world , even in States Trump questioning the validity of institutions.
Kapil, I am a hardcore fan of yours.
I don't think he's making any videos of that nature. If he is, then I think his hardcore fanclub will remain at 1. YOU.
What an absolute crap of an example explanation in terms of EVM. And that reporter over there simply hmmd and haawd as a response. What ever question she raised was utterly nonsense. Anyways Sibal comes from an era of Corruption. He shall always be a shady character
Shady Character?? Have you taken a moment to look at your profile picture, Mr M_D_M_? I wouldn't trust you with my breakfast sausage!!
I think you should add an A to your moniker and partake - The world will be a better place..
Sibal sir - go back to 30 years ago no EVM, no no no... go back to 50 years ago without any computer that eases human efforts....no no go back to 76 years ago...oops no Vote😂😂😂
Ha ha ha er....fart noises. Why don't you back being a lustful thought in someone's head before you were conceived?🤣🤣🤣🤣
This lady does 140 blinks per minute 😂
This guy talking about coalition.. Arey Gadha when India and China were almost same stage, how they grew and how you congress spoiled Indian growth..
This is one of those 'sounds good on paper' type romantic idea which has proven to Never work, especially with the likes of opposition of the recent past.
Plus, after a brief 120 seconds, he started going in circles.
Mdm host, can you use truckload more force asking questions, does he bite ??
What happened to his opposition to EVM. Now that congress has got some good number of seats they will not find anything wrong with EVM Or the Election commission Or the democracy of India😮
Sweety 240 bec of evm, else they would be less than 200, also wasn't BJP who were dancing evm is bad before they came to power. You can't change every evm machine but you can swing few , see how many they won with just few thousand votes
Since Congress can not form Govt on its own , started the Sermon on Coalition; The record of coalition compulsions led to Corruption, large scale scams , Dilution of Indian security ; Country needs a strong centre at any moment for security , Economic reasons ; Unfortunately votes are for sale in exchange of freebie ;
No. Country needs an accountable government and a strong opposition as well. There is no data that indicates that there is no corruption now. Several scams like Adani Hindenburg scam needs to be investigated once the NDA is voted out. There is no security crisis in the country. We have not had a war since 1999. Freedoms cannot be traded for security.
i love two shows kapil sibal and kapil sharma
Very befitting and appropriate comments of Mr Kabil Ji
It is a reality
Only educated people
Could digest it
To " chai wala" will not go through it
Not digestible to them
They do not know the plurality of India.....
Not at all. Coalition govt is worst. We have seen UPA era how worse the administration was due to the coalition govt. Hoepfully Modi , BJP , RSS will come back stronger with full majority.
Congress likes coalition because they can always blame others for their lack of performance.
He said coalition is difficult to run😮
Peter pattigrew
He is quite a wise and knowledgeable person worth listening to.
Jo ke
Media and India has forgot main issue
How to make election process robust
Voting .
Counting
Fool proof
People who say ban EVM also are making a wrong arguments.
Keep EVM but improve verification.
Improve process of voting easy even for people who are old or uneducated
Voting process is already easy for old and uneducation. Use brain before commenting
For all his logical sense, sibbal is wrong in rejecting the evm. Asking for a slip is ok but ballot counting was as influenced and error prone.
This man is prejudiced & wrong man to say anything
Very well spoken wise
Indi with 21 parties will be able to negotiate and bargain to form and run a stable govt better than....
Hes a known bootlicker of the parivar, whatever he says is twisted to suit them. We witnessed 10 years of slow growth and policy paralysis when these guys were in rule.
😂😂😂😂coalition govt is not good
Modi factor is losing shine. What he can learn from his partners?
Chandra Babu Naidu:
• Vision, Development, Delivery
• Smart City is not about digging, widening and drainage creation
• Project management for cost control and timely execution
• Team building, delegation and coordination/ cooperation
• Walk the talk
Nitish Kumar:
• Coalition formation for balancing the needs, expectations Vs resources and opportunities
• Reaching out to people on the ground and assuring them with actions not rhetoric and false promise
• Communal unity and harmony
• Retain the trust of the voters for decades by remaining true to self and true to voters
• Life lessons learned through poverty, hardships, education, experience etc as opposed to shortcuts like stories, pretentions and slogans
Even if they don't have majority it hardly matters to BJP
Good insight. Logical
Love these people in the comments who laugh at their own comments
If "brute majority" means a very large majority (in numbers of voters), does this cause the "brutal" behaviour Mr Sibal suggests or is it the usage of brute force regardless of majority? I'd say it is the latter.
Bright and Brilliant Mind ❤Congress lost his services
No logic in his words
Esat or west cibal is the best
Sibal
Congress men taking about not supporting any pary
Selective think
Coalition are those that pass humanitarian progressive development program.
In history the best results in developing a nation is when there is coalition government
Majority better
Army ke pension ki batein non army wale kyu kr rha h kya chate army ka pension army wala ko Mila ya kisi aur ko Mila h
Gharelo jagra mein aunty ka Salah
Wo log kya bol rhe malum nhi
Aunty log kaise dusro Salah deti h
The slips needs to be scanned and counted
Nice interview
❤
This guy 😂😂😂😂😂.... He should be in Pakistan with his friends or in dubai
Unity in diversity
Paida bhi coalition me huva hai !
Paida to hua, Mr Kumar. Aap to atkey hue ho.
Nehru donated lands to Pakistan and China 😂
Coalition is bad as Mr. Pranab Mukherjee said it do u think u know better than him u foooool
To ensure that there is almost always a coalition rule, and that no party ever gets a brute majority, India needs a proportional representation electoral system. Does Kapil Cibbal agree?
The interviewer appears to have her strong personal views, which is preventing her from listening to the interviewee.
G
If our country produces people like u coalition will happen
As a Muslim I haven't felt so good as much I have to see BJP winning this election. He's at the mercy of Muslim friendly allies. I love it. हाय रे किस्मत😅..This proves Hindus and Muslims want to live together and work together for the development of this country. PM Narendra will be a dummy PM for the next 5 years.
His government still wouldn't tolerate sar tan se juda attitude nor will his supporters
@@SK123-l4s Not will be only tolerate he will obey..and sometimes even support sar tan se juda
U r happy because NDA can not take decision on its own Modiji will not spare anyone wait n c
When u had the power u all involved in corruption right
What i c in u is that u r always after power which u will never get