I would absolutely LOVE to see this with every color. I eat up these kinds of videos. But especially green, given that green eyeshadow is my absolute favorite.
I'm on a quest for true red shimmers.. so hard to find ! I have just three, Leon from Oden's eye (which I compare to every red to see if it's a true red 😂), one multichrome in the Gloss Gods Venus palette, and one multichrome in the pretty poison palette from Notoriously Morbid. 🕵♀️
Honorable quest 🙇♀️ I'm seeing this comment a bit late, but do you have Clionadh Poinsettia yet? There's also an insane, no holds barred staining red shimmer in C-beauty brand Joocyee eye palette F07.
You are not in the minority when it comes to chunky/spiky eyeshadows. I won't buy them if they're not smooth and metallic. But I'm I'm in the minority of not liking overly sparkly and glittery formulas 🙈 This was interesting to watch. Your videos are so relaxing. Thanks for all of your dedication and hard work, Riley.👏
Side note I want all of Ellie & Brittany x BBB’s singles, omg they’re so amazing! Strength looks so beautiful omg ❤ I hope they come back in stock soon, I’d love to support those two fellow amazing strong women in recovery! The single in Recovery is the other one I wanted. I was so happy to see that collection because I’m sorry, what other brand has done a recovery themed collection? Cause I definitely can’t think of one! It’s so cool to see bellabeautebar doing that, they earned my respect with that collection for sure!
Yay!! ❤️ I’ve been saying I want to try glaminatrix every year for what feels like centuries at this point 😅, but I’m going to do it for real this year! Im waiting for the fairy lights palette to restock to place an order!
Oooooo YES! What a fantastic idea! The perfect red shimmer was so difficult to find for years! So many of my fav red shades in here. Olympus mons has been a recent true obsession. It's so foiled, reflective sparkly, shifty, yet doesn't have a dark base & it actually wears fantastic even without a tacky base. I cannot stop wearing it!
I almost picked up that single from Odens eye with my Black Friday purchase but I decided to pass on it so I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts. I started following you recently and was looking for unique shades from Clionadh because I wanted to try the brand. I own alot from Devinah & Glamshop so I was trying to find things that are truly unique. If you have a video like that and I’m just missing it pls let me know. I binged a lot of your Clionadh videos already. I really like light to mid tone shades, love pastel shades as well. Thank you for all your content and help ❤️
I haven’t done a video like this but this would be a great idea for a series! Like going through each brand and saying which ones I think are truly the most unique! Thank you for the idea!
Red is my favorite color, so this is super helpful . By the way, I do use your code, and thank you for the comparisons and descriptions they definitely help with purchases
@@seekingshifts they're beautiful. I'm probably older than you, but I remember like between 2006-2010 but seeking red shadows for the longest. Like this is when L'Oreal HIP high intensity pigment was where it was at and Urban Decay really was for the edgy girls. But now I have like BH cherry in top, glamlite icee, and glamlite Freddy. I'm drowning in red and my lids are blushing. Also idk if you remember when I asked about like a byop rainbow multichrome set. Don't feel pressured, if you do, don't. If you even remembered little ole me. I ended up just really studying terra moons pictures in conjunction with your lovely videos that I could use and managed to build a little curated multichrome and then I said no more money spending. 🙃
This is so helpful and so beautiful to see all swatched together! Green would be most evil colour to pick next, but also: green. Maybe split into categories like 'pale greens', 'olives', 'true greens', and 'teals'? I am really interested to see all the pale greens like Ganymede or Echidna type shades. Would you ever make a version of this type of video for iridescents?
Omg yes absolutely I will do greens. Thank you for doing the most difficult part for me - parsing them out in a way that makes sense. I REALLY want to do a video swatching all of my iridescents- I’ve pulled them out to sit down and film with multiple times but for some reason it feels so intimidating! I think I’m just unsure of the best way to showcase the tiny differences for those who are looking for that. If you have any suggestions/feedback I would greatly appreciate it!
Red eyeshadow was something I was terrified of for years, and I was always told to try it because “it’ll make green eyes pop!” and I was like… isn’t that what purple is for? Lmao but ever since I found indie makeup, I’ve been wearing red so much more often! It really is so beautiful on everyone. So glad I got over my fear lol! I have enough decent red mattes but don’t have many true red shimmers/multichromes though. I wish I got the dualism shade! So stunning. This was so much fun to watch ❤ so many gorgeous tones of red 😍 thank you so much Riley!!! You’re the besttttt and I’m forever in love with your insanely beautiful sparkly gorgeous swatches ❤️❤️❤️
Omg do you remember those like almay makeup collections that were for different eye colors back in the day? Your comment just made me think of those 🤣 I remember I used to think people could only wear certain colors based on their eye color and now I just slather on allll the colors. It’s surprisingly difficult to find a true primary red shimmer/multichrome! I feel like all of them lean really warm or cool
@@seekingshiftsYES omg I totally remember those! I know my mom had a couple 😂 freaking Almay!!! I have always had an unjustified dislike for them, they’re just so boring and I don’t understand why they refuse to innovate or rebrand! And yes omg I used to think that certain colors were only for certain people but nope, that’s bs! One reason why I love this community: we all just wear whatever we want lmao ❤
Could you do a video compairing formulas of different brands like bbb, ensley reign, adept etc? I only own pat mc grath eyeshadows and I wanna buy indie palettes but don't know what I would like. Perhaps there are more people who want a video like this 😊 😀 thanks for all your videos bye the way! They are great!
Ooh the cool reds might be a clue towards me duping ABH Rose Gold from the original Norvina palette. I haven’t been able to find one because it has an uncommon black base and a strong foil but these kind of look like amped up versions of that shade.
That was so much work! Thank you. Red toned colours are favourites of mine. I don’t wear it too close to the eyes because I look like I’ve been crying or dying or wildly allergic. Have you ever been tempted to makeup your arms with temporary tattoos and eye shadow colours? Have you ever just gone out and about with swatches? I’d love to see greens.
“Crying or dying or wildly allergic” is hilarious 🤣 I havent done that with swatches but I’m sure I will at some point! And yess I will do greens for sure!
All this tells me is that I still desperately want Leon from Oden's Eye, and I don't think my wallet can handle the shipping, but more importantly, I don't think my oily, hooded eyelids can handle the formula, even the new one. I cry in the corner. Great video though XD Super informative, love it.
@@seekingshifts I'm so surprised noone has released one yet! I feel like the brands are finally starting to kick up their red game now but it's still coming kind of slow.
Love videos like this! More please:) Also, are Arcturus and Tombstone not similar at all? I keep thinking they would be but I can't find side by side comparisons anywhere. I have Arcturus (because of you lol) and am contemplating getting the Harvest Moon palette just for the sake of comparing...
Id love to know if theres a reason why theres so few true red super textured metallics? 🤔 wonder if the pigments are just really difficult or expensive to source cause i have hundreds of palette and can count one hand how many i have and some arnt even actually good or truly red
Sadly I don’t know of an exact dupe 😭 it’s surprisingly unique. I wish Clionadh would release the Deep Sea Treasures Palette as singles! I have hope since they ended up doing that with the Dragonfruit palette
Omg thank you so much! It's so hard to find red shimmer eyeshadow, I only have four. Do you want to do this with yellow eyeshadow too? I'm on the hunt for a yellow shimmer eyeshadow like Cytryna by Glamshop (it's sold out and I think about it all the time) and I can't find a dupe 😭
Horizon from pretties for your face is one of, if not the most beautiful true yellow shimmers I own! Kristen Leigh cosmetics potion is a stunning chartreuse yellow, or devinah vela (it has a blue/green shift tho) is also truly beautiful yellow shimmer!
Im going to do all the colors! I think im going to start with primary colors so blue next then I’ll do yellow 💛 i think I’ll include golds in that video too since I don’t have too many true yellows
Surprised to see so much green in these reds! So informative, you always do an amazing job! Thank you so much for this, I know others will find this incredibly helpful as well❤❤🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
Thanks for the thorough comparisons!! 🌹♥️ They're perfect for before Lunar New Year. I have my shades for this yr, but will likely pick up some singles sometime in the future. I just made my own Lunar New Year BYOP using mostly ER Harvest Moon shades, Devinah Fairy Fire, and the red and burgundy singles from Nomad's Hudson Valley collection. Hopefully Boo-Jee from ER looks good w the Nomad mattes. 🐉🧧
19:20 is Proxima , not Eris! My bad lol
I would love to see this with every color 😂 I can watch swatches all day
Same. Swatches with color description are my kind of ASMR
Agree 100%! I love swatch videos, and I love how you put together your videos. The nerd heart of mine just adores the comparisons and descriptions! ❤
Amen 🙏 🎉😂🎉❤🎉😂❤💯!!!!!!! Agreed 🤝
Studying this as if I wore red eyeshadow and had a big paycheck coming. Blues and yellows have my heart, but I just like looking at sparkly eyeshadows
This was a really helpful and pleasing to the eye kinda video.. I didn’t want it to end. Blues like the cosmos would be my take for the next round 😍😌
Yay you’re the second person to request blues for the next one!! Blues it is 💙
Wow, it was really helpful, do next purples please 🥰
And thank you, of course, for this video ☺️
I would absolutely LOVE to see this with every color. I eat up these kinds of videos. But especially green, given that green eyeshadow is my absolute favorite.
I'm on a quest for true red shimmers.. so hard to find ! I have just three, Leon from Oden's eye (which I compare to every red to see if it's a true red 😂), one multichrome in the Gloss Gods Venus palette, and one multichrome in the pretty poison palette from Notoriously Morbid. 🕵♀️
Omg Leon has sent me down a rabbit hole looking for true reds as well!!
Honorable quest 🙇♀️ I'm seeing this comment a bit late, but do you have Clionadh Poinsettia yet? There's also an insane, no holds barred staining red shimmer in C-beauty brand Joocyee eye palette F07.
I, too, am seeking multichrome / shimmer / matte reds. This video is just what I needed.
You are not in the minority when it comes to chunky/spiky eyeshadows. I won't buy them if they're not smooth and metallic. But I'm I'm in the minority of not liking overly sparkly and glittery formulas 🙈 This was interesting to watch. Your videos are so relaxing. Thanks for all of your dedication and hard work, Riley.👏
I don't do spiky shades either. Especially for my sensitive eyes.
Love @mostlymatte and I love this video! Shimmery redddsssss
YAYYY!! Please do blue next 🥹🩵💙
Oooh blue would be fun!!! I’ll do that next!
Juliette read my mind! I've been on the great red search so thanks!
I love this comparison video! I would love to see pinks!
My favorite kind of content! Organizing by color for the win!!!
I really love reds, thanks for this interesting video and for the hard work.
Happy new year. ❤❤❤
Happy new year!!! ❤️
This is AMAZING! I love red eyeshadow and cannot wait for your deep dive on Leon! ❤
I love this! This needs to be a series with every color! Your videos have helped me so much with my purchases!
Omgg I love this category of videos. I’d love to see blue/purple shifting comparisons, green/pink/purple, blue/pink etc! ❤
Please please please could you do a purple edition of this? Such a genius idea!!!
❤🎉 I'm a VISEART lover and appreciated your Viseart videos, thank you for being so helpful!! 😍😊🥰♥️😊
Side note I want all of Ellie & Brittany x BBB’s singles, omg they’re so amazing! Strength looks so beautiful omg ❤ I hope they come back in stock soon, I’d love to support those two fellow amazing strong women in recovery! The single in Recovery is the other one I wanted. I was so happy to see that collection because I’m sorry, what other brand has done a recovery themed collection? Cause I definitely can’t think of one! It’s so cool to see bellabeautebar doing that, they earned my respect with that collection for sure!
I have 2 of them and they’re gorgeous!! strength is definitely a standout! I really admire the collaborators and the theme of the collab 💕
I would love to see oranges😍😍😍
Such a cool resource! My favorite chrome red is definitely Elixr from Glaminatrix
Yay!! ❤️ I’ve been saying I want to try glaminatrix every year for what feels like centuries at this point 😅, but I’m going to do it for real this year! Im waiting for the fairy lights palette to restock to place an order!
Oooooo YES! What a fantastic idea! The perfect red shimmer was so difficult to find for years! So many of my fav red shades in here. Olympus mons has been a recent true obsession. It's so foiled, reflective sparkly, shifty, yet doesn't have a dark base & it actually wears fantastic even without a tacky base. I cannot stop wearing it!
It’s one of my favorites from the last 2 collections! So impactful but somehow still “wearable”
@@seekingshifts it really is!! 😍✨
It was such a cool video! I hope you will continue doing this lil serie with every color possible :) ! Thank you so much :)
I loved this video, would love to see blues next!
Blues will be next!! Definitely the most popular request 💙
Yellow next!!
red/orange eyeshadows 😌🤌
I almost picked up that single from Odens eye with my Black Friday purchase but I decided to pass on it so I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts. I started following you recently and was looking for unique shades from Clionadh because I wanted to try the brand. I own alot from Devinah & Glamshop so I was trying to find things that are truly unique. If you have a video like that and I’m just missing it pls let me know. I binged a lot of your Clionadh videos already. I really like light to mid tone shades, love pastel shades as well. Thank you for all your content and help ❤️
I haven’t done a video like this but this would be a great idea for a series! Like going through each brand and saying which ones I think are truly the most unique! Thank you for the idea!
Thank you for this. Still want leon so bad.
Also, it is fun to see all the type of sparkling reds out there.
Once you know Leon, you can pick Leon out of a lineup of a hundred reds. Its pretty special.
Im super picky with reds, this was super helpful. Love this type of video ❤
Red is my favorite color, so this is super helpful . By the way, I do use your code, and thank you for the comparisons and descriptions they definitely help with purchases
Thank you so much!! I appreciate your support 🥰
Amazing video, Riley. I’m taking a wild guess of 2500 single eyeshadows. I don’t dare count mine. And I’m not a content creator.
I was scared to count mine 🫣🤣
Living for this video!!!!!❤❤❤ Thank you I love reds so much! Would you be able to do oranges please!🙏
Yessss I decided I’m going to do all the colors! Haha
@@seekingshifts I honestly think you are mad crazy and I LOVE THAT❤️
I'm going to die watching this. I'm a cool toned lady. But there's something about reds that drive me wild.
They’re the most fun to swatch!!
@@seekingshifts they're beautiful. I'm probably older than you, but I remember like between 2006-2010 but seeking red shadows for the longest. Like this is when L'Oreal HIP high intensity pigment was where it was at and Urban Decay really was for the edgy girls. But now I have like BH cherry in top, glamlite icee, and glamlite Freddy. I'm drowning in red and my lids are blushing.
Also idk if you remember when I asked about like a byop rainbow multichrome set. Don't feel pressured, if you do, don't. If you even remembered little ole me. I ended up just really studying terra moons pictures in conjunction with your lovely videos that I could use and managed to build a little curated multichrome and then I said no more money spending. 🙃
This is so helpful and so beautiful to see all swatched together!
Green would be most evil colour to pick next, but also: green. Maybe split into categories like 'pale greens', 'olives', 'true greens', and 'teals'? I am really interested to see all the pale greens like Ganymede or Echidna type shades.
Would you ever make a version of this type of video for iridescents?
Omg yes absolutely I will do greens. Thank you for doing the most difficult part for me - parsing them out in a way that makes sense.
I REALLY want to do a video swatching all of my iridescents- I’ve pulled them out to sit down and film with multiple times but for some reason it feels so intimidating! I think I’m just unsure of the best way to showcase the tiny differences for those who are looking for that. If you have any suggestions/feedback I would greatly appreciate it!
Thank you so much for doing this!
Red eyeshadow was something I was terrified of for years, and I was always told to try it because “it’ll make green eyes pop!” and I was like… isn’t that what purple is for? Lmao but ever since I found indie makeup, I’ve been wearing red so much more often! It really is so beautiful on everyone. So glad I got over my fear lol!
I have enough decent red mattes but don’t have many true red shimmers/multichromes though. I wish I got the dualism shade! So stunning. This was so much fun to watch ❤ so many gorgeous tones of red 😍 thank you so much Riley!!! You’re the besttttt and I’m forever in love with your insanely beautiful sparkly gorgeous swatches ❤️❤️❤️
Omg do you remember those like almay makeup collections that were for different eye colors back in the day? Your comment just made me think of those 🤣 I remember I used to think people could only wear certain colors based on their eye color and now I just slather on allll the colors. It’s surprisingly difficult to find a true primary red shimmer/multichrome! I feel like all of them lean really warm or cool
@@seekingshiftsYES omg I totally remember those! I know my mom had a couple 😂 freaking Almay!!! I have always had an unjustified dislike for them, they’re just so boring and I don’t understand why they refuse to innovate or rebrand! And yes omg I used to think that certain colors were only for certain people but nope, that’s bs! One reason why I love this community: we all just wear whatever we want lmao ❤
Thank you so much for making this 🎉🎉🎉
Could you do a video compairing formulas of different brands like bbb, ensley reign, adept etc?
I only own pat mc grath eyeshadows and I wanna buy indie palettes but don't know what I would like. Perhaps there are more people who want a video like this 😊 😀 thanks for all your videos bye the way! They are great!
Ooh the cool reds might be a clue towards me duping ABH Rose Gold from the original Norvina palette. I haven’t been able to find one because it has an uncommon black base and a strong foil but these kind of look like amped up versions of that shade.
I just looked it up and omggg I see what you mean! I wish I could swatch because I’m SURE I have a single that’s super close if not spot on
what's the single? :o@@seekingshifts
That was so much work! Thank you. Red toned colours are favourites of mine. I don’t wear it too close to the eyes because I look like I’ve been crying or dying or wildly allergic. Have you ever been tempted to makeup your arms with temporary tattoos and eye shadow colours? Have you ever just gone out and about with swatches? I’d love to see greens.
“Crying or dying or wildly allergic” is hilarious 🤣 I havent done that with swatches but I’m sure I will at some point! And yess I will do greens for sure!
Please do purples next!
All this tells me is that I still desperately want Leon from Oden's Eye, and I don't think my wallet can handle the shipping, but more importantly, I don't think my oily, hooded eyelids can handle the formula, even the new one. I cry in the corner. Great video though XD Super informative, love it.
Hahahaha I’m PATIENTLY WAITING for literally any other brand to come out with a dupe. I will immediately buy it for science so I can tell the world
@@seekingshifts I'm so surprised noone has released one yet! I feel like the brands are finally starting to kick up their red game now but it's still coming kind of slow.
The true reds collection makes me DROOL!
Love videos like this! More please:) Also, are Arcturus and Tombstone not similar at all? I keep thinking they would be but I can't find side by side comparisons anywhere. I have Arcturus (because of you lol) and am contemplating getting the Harvest Moon palette just for the sake of comparing...
Do you follow me on IG? I would be happy to compare on my stories :)
Of course I do! And that would be so awesome thank you!😊
Have you seen the colour of the year? I will love to create a palette a palette inspired by it with you in live like we did for fall. Please
Great idea!! Yess I will find a time that I can do that and poll for what works best! 🧡
🩺
🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨
I'm going to guess 700 :) thanks for the impressive video!
Im on a quest for a matte red that doesnt blend pink on me. So hard to find 😢 and I dont want to buy a palette only for that.
Ahh that’s difficult because it depends so much on skin tone/undertone!
Id love to know if theres a reason why theres so few true red super textured metallics? 🤔 wonder if the pigments are just really difficult or expensive to source cause i have hundreds of palette and can count one hand how many i have and some arnt even actually good or truly red
Is there a dupe for ring of fire ? I don’t want to commit to a pallete for one shade 😩
Sadly I don’t know of an exact dupe 😭 it’s surprisingly unique. I wish Clionadh would release the Deep Sea Treasures Palette as singles! I have hope since they ended up doing that with the Dragonfruit palette
I'm still a bit scared of red eyeshadow 🙈
I was too but now I love it!! Haha. I feel like the last category is your type of red
🩺 👍🏿
Omg thank you so much! It's so hard to find red shimmer eyeshadow, I only have four. Do you want to do this with yellow eyeshadow too? I'm on the hunt for a yellow shimmer eyeshadow like Cytryna by Glamshop (it's sold out and I think about it all the time) and I can't find a dupe 😭
Horizon from pretties for your face is one of, if not the most beautiful true yellow shimmers I own! Kristen Leigh cosmetics potion is a stunning chartreuse yellow, or devinah vela (it has a blue/green shift tho) is also truly beautiful yellow shimmer!
Im going to do all the colors! I think im going to start with primary colors so blue next then I’ll do yellow 💛 i think I’ll include golds in that video too since I don’t have too many true yellows
@@seekingshifts wow, thank you so much for all the work you put into that 💖
@@blendofdays wow they look so pretty 🤩 thank you for the recommendations!
@@halloundtschuess yw! True yellow shimmers with no shift are rare! I do have a few other yellows but they all have shifts. 💛
Have you tried glossgods palettes?
Not yet but I’m planning to pick up the First Gal on Jupiter with my review budget for this month! They’ve been on my radar for a while ❤️
Surprised to see so much green in these reds! So informative, you always do an amazing job!
Thank you so much for this, I know others will find this incredibly helpful as well❤❤🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
Yay!!! I’m glad it was helpful! ❤️❤️❤️
Hi I'm new here hope that you don't mind that I'm a guy I love makeup I love your video
Dang that's a lot of red.😆
So much red 😅
I think you own 3942 single eyeshadows. I confess I went to to seeking pans to cheat but you have yet to post the number😂😂
LOL very specific number
Thanks for the thorough comparisons!! 🌹♥️ They're perfect for before Lunar New Year.
I have my shades for this yr, but will likely pick up some singles sometime in the future.
I just made my own Lunar New Year BYOP using mostly ER Harvest Moon shades, Devinah Fairy Fire, and the red and burgundy singles from Nomad's Hudson Valley collection. Hopefully Boo-Jee from ER looks good w the Nomad mattes. 🐉🧧
That sounds like a GORGEOUS color story!! ❤️
🩺 Thanks for doing so much work for us.