Is Peter Hitchens Right About the Tories? - Rory Sutherland

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
  • Watch the full episode: • Why Logical Thinking i...
    To support my work and get early access to videos, ad-free, visit / alexoc
    Main channel: / @cosmicskeptic

Комментарии • 69

  • @louithrottler
    @louithrottler 4 дня назад +24

    good smeagol hates nasty tories

  • @benwakefield93
    @benwakefield93 4 дня назад +12

    'Mr Hitchens, I won't tell you which one' 😂 Legend

  • @ilikebinky
    @ilikebinky 4 дня назад +51

    Alex's style is clearly inspired/influenced by Christopher Hitchens. I do sometimes wonder if this similarity, this reminder of his brother, is what caused the Peter Hitchens rage quit.

    • @skepticalcentral8795
      @skepticalcentral8795 4 дня назад +3

      I think that's a genuine possibly, though I can't decide if that makes his hissy fit funnier or sadder.

    • @cerdic6305
      @cerdic6305 4 дня назад +3

      I think he’s just a bit of a diva really. There are plenty of interviews where he seems to just dislike the interviewer right away and is then incredibly rude to them and decides to be outraged about innocuous things.

    • @lrvogt1257
      @lrvogt1257 4 дня назад +5

      He didn't have an answer about drugs and crime in Portugal and realized he's been outmatched by someone he didn't think was worthy and he snapped.

    • @handcrafted30
      @handcrafted30 4 дня назад

      That’s actually a very interesting analysis.

    • @handcrafted30
      @handcrafted30 4 дня назад

      @@gow2ilove erm they absolutely didn’t.

  • @tommurrell125
    @tommurrell125 19 часов назад

    Interesting and thoughtful analysis of Peter’s view of the Tories.

  • @natmanprime4295
    @natmanprime4295 4 дня назад +21

    andy serkis let himself go wat da

  • @julianshepherd2038
    @julianshepherd2038 6 часов назад

    Tories came 4th where I live in Scotland.
    It is like a different country.

    • @freddiepatterson1045
      @freddiepatterson1045 4 часа назад

      By seats yes but it was very close. On votes however they were 3rd with 350k VS LD at 250k and SNP at 700k

  • @OBGynKenobi
    @OBGynKenobi 4 дня назад +10

    The stache must go forthwith! Unless it is accompanied by the beard.

  • @nickanfuso4868
    @nickanfuso4868 4 дня назад +4

    In any discussion about voting systems I find it utterly infuriating how binary the choices are presented between PR and first-past-the-post when in reality there are a plethora of alternate systems. In a UK context it would seem entirely consistent with the constitutional arrangements to have preferential voting. Regard should be had to the Australian system for the lower house where minority governments are relatively rare but there exists scope for independent voices in the senate which is elected by a modified and regionalised PR system

    • @chrisdickens4268
      @chrisdickens4268 4 дня назад

      I suspect because it historically was the Lib Dems trying to rig the system to favour them as the "not the other" party. I find it amazing how many people want electoral reform but can't actually describe the system they'd adopt why it would be good (By no means do I mean you!). There're some really big advantages (as well as problems) with first past the post but they're rarely discussed seriously

    • @kidslovesatan34
      @kidslovesatan34 3 дня назад

      I think a strong argument could be made for proportional representation in the lower house as a better representation of democracy in action. Minor parties would need to form coalitions to affect a majority government. Now, whether that's a better system in practice is a different question. And yes the Australian senate is proportional representation. The New Zealand lower house has the model that I just described above. New Guinea too I believe.

  • @randomusername3873
    @randomusername3873 4 дня назад +1

    What's his opinion on drugs?

    • @ketongu
      @ketongu 4 дня назад

      firmer laws and persecution of addicts etc

  • @ThelemicMagick
    @ThelemicMagick 5 дней назад +25

    I actively dislike viewers that don't give this video a thumbs up

    • @c.jishnu378
      @c.jishnu378 4 дня назад +2

      I believe they are called flat-earthers.

    • @_jazzypants7321
      @_jazzypants7321 4 дня назад +5

      I disliked the video just for you. And then blocked the channel so I never have to come back. And turned off all notifications so I won't even know if you responded to me. Enjoy your apples.

    • @Jesus420.69
      @Jesus420.69 4 дня назад

      I’m gonna thumbs up now

    • @alphabetaxenonzzzcat
      @alphabetaxenonzzzcat День назад

      Don't forget to storm off with your backpack(like a stroppy teenager) and ride your bicycle home.

  • @topcat5553
    @topcat5553 4 дня назад +20

    "Left wing politics" Starmer is NOT left wing. He is centre right. The Tory party is 100% right wing.

    • @rkdeshdeepak4131
      @rkdeshdeepak4131 4 дня назад +9

      no, he is far left

    • @topcat5553
      @topcat5553 4 дня назад

      @rkdeshdeepak4131 Show me some of his "far left views." He refused to reverse the 2 child benifit cap! He ain't Labour, or Left😂 he quotes Margaret Thatcher ffs. He is a Tory dressed as Labour. The real Labour party got destroyed from within. Jeremy Corbyn was "fat left," not SIR Tory Starmer.

    • @topcat5553
      @topcat5553 4 дня назад +13

      @rkdeshdeepak4131 Jeremy Corbyn was far left.... Starmer quotes Thatcher and refuses to reverse the 2 child benifit cap...he is about as far left as Winston Churchill was. 😂

    • @bigwow4548
      @bigwow4548 4 дня назад

      @@topcat5553 They should get rid of child benefit altogether and start providing stamps/rations for school equipment, clothing and food.

    • @sit-insforsithis1568
      @sit-insforsithis1568 4 дня назад +1

      Inshallah I agree 😂

  • @stocktonheath
    @stocktonheath 3 дня назад +2

    Peter Hitchens is never right about anything.

    • @SageGamersX
      @SageGamersX 2 дня назад +1

      That's a stretch there is a long list of things he is and has been right about.

    • @alphabetaxenonzzzcat
      @alphabetaxenonzzzcat День назад

      But he has been telling us that he has been predicting the UK's demise for the past 20 years and is "the official biographer of Britain's demise". 😁

    • @bobbysbits2575
      @bobbysbits2575 День назад +1

      ​@@alphabetaxenonzzzcat A nation state can spend a long time falling apart before everyone agrees it's happening.