MSI Afterburner (default values) to blame.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024

Комментарии • 78

  • @Nikos4Life
    @Nikos4Life Месяц назад +12

    “MSI Afterburner is to blame,” but this issue also occurs with Precision X and HWINFO64.
    These problems have persisted since the release of the 3000 series and have never been resolved. Most of us who have encountered this issue simply shut down any monitoring tools before starting a VR gaming session.
    This problem has been around for so long that I’ve stopped looking for a solution and just accepted that it’s easier to close these apps and move on.
    Thank you for addressing this issue. Hopefully, it will gain some traction and eventually get fixed. Ideally, we shouldn’t have to choose between monitoring our hardware and having a smooth VR experience.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +2

      Thanks dude. I've changed the title to be less misleading.

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад +1

      @Nikos4life What about geforce experience ? And Rivatuner statistics server ?

    • @Nikos4Life
      @Nikos4Life Месяц назад

      @@bmwM3M5M6 I do not use them anymore so I can not give you an update on those, but you know ymmv... try and see if there is a better experience otherwise go back using them, GFE I do not expect to generate any issues tbh, RTSS not sure though.

  • @zorrothebug
    @zorrothebug Месяц назад +6

    Well, read the manual, read the forum. If you add sensors for no reason and especially those who have a high polling time sure it is having an impact. It's not the software itself, but how you configure it.
    In the Monitoring Panel of MSI Afterburner you can right click and enable the profiler panel which will show you exactly which sensor takes how much time to poll. Especially external sensors like those by perfcounter.dll have a huge impact.
    Use only those which you do need, preferably the internal ones and untick every other sensor.
    FPS, Frametime, GPU temp, GPU load, CPU temp and CPU load are not heavy and won't give you a noticeable impact while gaming.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +3

      Thank you for the info! I've confirmed "GPU1 power percent" as the leading culprit.

    • @zorrothebug
      @zorrothebug Месяц назад +1

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys just an addendum, when you are not using MSI AB for monitoring but RTSS overlay. When you are in the OverlayEditor and opened the "Add new data sources" dialog, hold CTRL and instead of the value of the sensor you get the polling time of each sensor value. So even there you can already inspect if the sensor you are about to add will have a significant impact.

    • @baumstamp5989
      @baumstamp5989 Месяц назад +1

      i think the problem is that these are polled as per default. which is not optimal. rather have users who REALLY need power sensors in their overlays read the manual and configure it to add these. than having ALL users have the performance heavy situation right from default installation.

    • @dstendo64
      @dstendo64 14 дней назад

      @@zorrothebug Hey, do you know if only checking the box for "GPU power percent" causes the stuttering, or also just looking at the sensor value in the RTSS OverlayEditor under "Add new data sources"? If the value is being displayed in the OSD with help of RTSS and MSI AB, it stutters (especially in the original black ops 1 from 2010). But if simply monitoring the value causes high ms and stutter, then looking at it in RTSS should cause stutters or not? Even if I remove the value from the OSD In MSI AB, I still get stutter as long as the Box for monitoring is checked for "GPU Power percent" under Settings → Monitoring, or the checkbox "enable unified gpu usage monitoring" is checked under General Settings. So what exactly causes the stutter, the monitoring or displaying of the sensor value, and how can I be sure that I fixed it?

    • @zorrothebug
      @zorrothebug 14 дней назад

      @@dstendo64 it is the polling of the sensor data which causes the stutter due to the time it takes to get the data from the driver. It's a driver thing, not MSI AB nor RTSS. Displaying that data on screen is negligible time, not even a single ms. So when you are monitoring that sensor, it gets polled and causes the stutter you witness.

  • @kristaps2010
    @kristaps2010 11 дней назад +1

    brilliant advice. these apps do some work in background, I agree. Will test to turn it off .7900xtx and ryzen 7 7800x3D CPU. VR is Pimax Crystal Light.

  • @baumstamp5989
    @baumstamp5989 Месяц назад +1

    precicely because of similar problems like this i have for years now, during normal gaming sessions, completely shut down all 3rd party tools & programs that i can. i do not need an overlay during gameplay at all!. the only time i use rtss / afterburner is for initial testing of settings of new games to find my preferred performance corridor to enjoy the gameplay. with a nice balance between fps and visual quality.

  • @2BeerMinimumRacing
    @2BeerMinimumRacing Месяц назад +1

    I'm a firm believer in there are too many polling type events that are happening. IRQ events, so to speak. Too many of these interruption events are preventing computers from working as expected and to their potential.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      Since this video I've fallen into a bit of rabbit hole researching. This type of trouble shooting is a lot to ask of a 'normal' sim racer. However, we use a lot of USB devices, plus 3rd party software of varying sophistication and quality, and iRacing is always going to slam a couple CPU cores. Then there's the user requirement for smooth, perpetual forward motion across 3 screens or VR... and it's a recipe for a stutter stew!
      I would need to find a way to clearly capture the stuttering, especially if the 'on screen' image is the only real evidence. The only thing I can think of is a high speed camera like rtings use to collect motion tests on monitors. It's not a small undertaking. And I worry that the results won't be interesting or consumable.

  • @Moelders109
    @Moelders109 Месяц назад +3

    Can confirm I had this same issue with stutters with other Sims (Assetto Corsa and IL2 Sturmovik) when I had used Afterburner in the past. Stopped using it and they went away.

  • @RealNC
    @RealNC Месяц назад +3

    Some sensors (like power or voltage) can have quite high latencies. The GPU driver can stall (it's the driver that actually does the polling when Afterburner or HWinfo or whatever requests it.) You can enable the sensor overhead calculator in Afterburner to see which sensor group is problematic and disable those. Although as always, it doesn't make sense to keep playing with monitoring software running. Use them only initially to find the performance sweetspot for your system, and after that's done, keep them closed.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      @RealNC Cheers mate! I will confirm the latency issues. Great reminder about closing unnecessary apps, especially when you've signed into a race and can't do anything about it until the finish line. [Edit] Yup, definitely "GPU power percent" at a constant 14ms and spike even higher.

  • @TalkieT
    @TalkieT Месяц назад +1

    Have been seeing similar symptoms and will try this tonight. I have heaps of monitoring (including logging iracing telemetry to influxDB) and have been chasing this issue for ages (13900k/4090/1440p triples)

  • @robcampbell6099
    @robcampbell6099 Месяц назад +1

    Good work, funnily enough I was having a audio popping issues every 4 or 5 secs. traced it back to afterburner as well. Uninstalled it and instatly problem solved. Haven't really driven in sim since but definitely, I'm going to check to see if removing afterburner has helped there as well

  • @kobiblade
    @kobiblade Месяц назад +1

    MSI Afterburner has been causing stuttering for years, I surprised it took you this long to figure out, no offense.
    I used to be an avid user of MSI Afterburner, but after so many issues of it causing crashes in specific games, I started defaulting to have MSI Afterburner closed, and performance across all my games was way more stable.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      None taken. If I was afraid to be wrong, I wouldn't publish content to YT lol

  • @Creep4EverMV588
    @Creep4EverMV588 Месяц назад +2

    Interesting, do you know if having the amd adrenaline software opened in the background does the same? Since it's the main tool for overclocking/undervolting etc for amd gpus... I know that there is a way to make it stop registering/recording your pc stats in the background (it's sadly on by default, even when the amd perfomance overlay is off), but not sure if it's similar to the afterburner if you want to just oc your gpu with the performance penalty

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      I have not noticed the same micro-stuttering from Radeon. In fact, I actually think the image presented by AMD is more smooth than Nvidia (with or without SMP). I haven't discovered an empirical way to show that, besides my own eyes B)

  • @CharlesDRACOULIDES
    @CharlesDRACOULIDES Месяц назад +1

    Thanks for this video, i get 5 second screen freeze (but iracing continue with the sound). First time i disabled the nvidia surrond and after no isue... But, i install racelab, msi afterburn and update my nvidia drivers and get the same issue. I close racelab and for the moment, no issue 😅

  • @reviewforthetube6485
    @reviewforthetube6485 Месяц назад +1

    Yeah I wont use afterburner lol but i will say sim racing games all have some slight stuttering at times. It just happens. Maybe in iracing this is because of afterburner but many games just do it randomly. Its very fast moving motion rven at high fps you cant expect 0 stuttering at all times. Im very sensitive to micro stutters even when people cant see it i do. Ive yet to find a single game, a single year or a single gpu or build that doesnt stutter while im gaming at least a few times lol.

  • @dubby_ow
    @dubby_ow Месяц назад +1

    I have only GPU temp monitoring checked and polling is 2000ms also you can entirely pause monitoring if you right click on the graphs, on my MSI skin I can click DETACH and show graphs and you can pause it forever this way

  • @ATG1985
    @ATG1985 Месяц назад

    Precision X1 had hope, but then EVGA threw in the towel (sadge). What headset do you use?

  • @bmwM3M5M6
    @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

    I get stuttering 24/7 at night Spa dry races even when FPS is 130, it’s really annoying and takes away the fun.
    When everything is butter smooth I forget that it’s a game but when stutters happen I say: Damn it’s obvious just a game.
    I’m not an expert regarding these things to find the cause but have Geforce experience running but it ran previous season also without any problem so don’t think that’s the issue. I think 99% it’s an iRacing problem with those latest updates you mentioned in the beginning of the vid…

  • @markus4692
    @markus4692 Месяц назад +1

    Can also confirm this issue. Happens/happend in DR 2.0 with a 3080 Ti and a Pico Neo Link. Must have something to do with Nvidia drivers. Had been using it for years without any issues. Tried many old drivers but unfortunatly without luck. Also disabled all monitoring. Had to uninstall Afterburner.

  • @opminded
    @opminded Месяц назад +2

    In my case stutters were caused by running Virtual Desktop with max bitrate. I have installed VD months ago and have forgot there is still a known issue that is mentioned in Virtual Desktop Discord announcements that relates to Quest 3 and NVidia. Running at lower recommended bitrates has solved my stutter issue. In my case these stutters, when they appeared, were exactly 20 seconds apart.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      @@opminded interesting! Is 500 low enough?

    • @opminded
      @opminded Месяц назад

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys I use AV1 codec and in VD maximum for AV1 and HEVC is 200 Mbits. My router can handle this no problem. But there is a known issue: "AV1/HEVC encoding with Nvidia GPUs will sometimes cause high decoding/networking/encoding times at at high bitrates". They recommend lowering HEVC 10bit bitrate to 150 and AV1 to around 120. I followed this recommendation and these 20 second apart stutters disappeared.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      @@opminded Gotcha. I haven't experimented with VD yet, I'm a bit intimidated by its customization. But the wired connection I've been using with my Quest 3 is becoming finicky (random alerts of debris in the port), and I don't trust it for long stints like this upcoming 24 Spa race. Maybe it's time I jump into the VD pool.

    • @bdtef0199
      @bdtef0199 3 дня назад +1

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys If you have it plugged in with the stock charger you will need to upgrade to a 30w+ charger. Like Ugreen. I tried that solution with my Oneplus charger and also ugreen's and it immediately stopped being an issue.

  • @manic_miner
    @manic_miner Месяц назад

    Interesting... I struggled with stutters on a Gsync 120Hz TV but fixed them (I think) by switching GSync off for iRacing, setting the TV to 60Hz and turning VSync on in iRacing and locking to 59fps in RTSS. I don't see why we should have to stop using Afterburner (for underclocking and custom fan curve in my case) just to use iRacing smoothly. The stutters I see happen mostly on newer tracks like Circuito de Navarra, so I'm not sure if it's also down to optimisation perhaps on iRacing's end.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      Interesting, I do not have experience with Gysnc TV. What I noticed with Afterburner, however, is that a lot of parameters were selected for monitoring (even with at default) and a few have latency spikes for the 4080S and 3080Ti I tested. If you don't notice a difference in stutters when Afterburner opened or closed, then you do not need to investigate further.

  • @cloudnine5651
    @cloudnine5651 Месяц назад +2

    user error. you have 500 things being polled/tracked in afterburner, of course its going to cause lag/stutters

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      What about geforce experience ?

    • @cloudnine5651
      @cloudnine5651 Месяц назад +1

      @@bmwM3M5M6 thats full of telemetry. nobody should be using geforce experience

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      @@cloudnine5651 But when I uninstalled it, I really didn’t noticed any differance regarding performance and stuttering… why is that then ?

    • @cloudnine5651
      @cloudnine5651 Месяц назад

      @@bmwM3M5M6 uninstallation doesnt always equate to all services being turned off. you would have to compare to a fresh never installed upon system

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      @@cloudnine5651 Damn that’s tooo much work then. I’ll pass and hope for iRacing that they fix their sim

  • @TarzanGTI
    @TarzanGTI Месяц назад +1

    I’ll try it without afterburner and compare. Do you know if disabling the voltage and power monitoring stuff off affects undervolting?
    I used it to undervolt my Gigabyte Gaming OC RTX 4080 which only really helped with power consumption and keeping noise lower as the card rarely went above 65C on its default settings anyway with the default fan curve. I don’t think it’s critical so if I get better performance without it, I’ll use it without.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      It should not affect your undervolt. You can also apply your settings with Afterburner and simply exit the app, and your GPU will still behave as you configured.

  • @unwinder
    @unwinder Месяц назад +6

    Learn how to use MSI AB's performance profiler panel. It is not Afterburner, it is PEBCAK user to blame. Experienced users know how to troubleshoot issues like that and MSI AB contains the most detailed diagnostic tools for that.

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      If I had a nickle for every PEBCAK moment I have, I could upgrade to a 4090 :D

    • @unwinder
      @unwinder Месяц назад +4

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys if I had a nickel each time MSI AB & RTSS is blamed due to wrong reasons and I have to comment it, I'd be richer than Rockefeller. :D

  • @TalkieT
    @TalkieT Месяц назад +1

    I resorted to filming my screen at 240FPS using my cellphone to show the effect of the stuttering - ruclips.net/video/fyG19fPtNGM/видео.html

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      I tried doing something similar with VR and reprojection, however, there's some fancy tech and predictive imagery going on with the phone. I had more accurate results with recording at max native framerate (60 on my phone) and slowing it down in the video editor software. It's not as smooth but at least it's more authentic to the experience you see on the screens.

  • @nanoverse
    @nanoverse Месяц назад +2

    Don’t have stutters and am very picky. Undervolted Rtx3080, 5800x3d

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      @nanoverse You run Geforce experience and/or Rivatuner statistics server ?

  • @bmwM3M5M6
    @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

    What about Geforce experience ? And Rivatuner statistics server ? The first I use for max fan control rather then auto fan when it’s hot weather and 2nd use for capping my FPS…

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      I do not install GeForce Experience on my benching systems, I just use the standalone driver. Other ways to cap the FPS include within the Nvidia Control Panel (Manage 3D Settings -> Program Settings -> Find and select 'iracingsim64dx11.exe' then scroll to Max Frame Rate), or within iRacing itself.

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад +1

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys I did both but had also not smooth experience with capping on those 2… had best experience with Rivatuner but yeah iRacing update messed it up

  • @facemob360
    @facemob360 Месяц назад

    Great video. May I ask what headset you’re using? Looks comfortable

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      @facemob360 I was using Valve Index for this capture, and trying to keep my head as still as possible for video capture, heh

    • @facemob360
      @facemob360 Месяц назад +2

      @@BenchmarkOdysseys thanks for your response. I was actually asking about your headphones* lol

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      @@facemob360 Hah, oops! Audeze MM-100. Quick review: The fit is actually tight and I'm hoping it relaxes over time because it can generate physical ear soreness. The cups are also smaller than most other planar magnetics, so if you've got big ears, they may get pinched or squished inside. Build quality is excellent which is why I picked them, I expect them to last at least +5 years (at this price I want 8-10 years). Performance is good, although not 'wow' but they are marketed as neutral. I'm a little annoyed they claim 'open back' but they have that hollow can effect. For example, if you walk with them, the thud of your step reverberates into each speaker. Thankfully this doesn't present itself during sim racing and battle FFB over kerbs.

  • @marcinpohl3264
    @marcinpohl3264 Месяц назад +1

    Have you tried it with any other hardware monitoring programs? HWinfo64, AIDA64, OCCT...? Are the stutters a result of contention for the resources, or is the monitoring software too aggressive, or too inconsiderate in how it polls the hardware?

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад

      I have not (yet) experimented with other programs. Other commenters suggest HWinfo can produce this polling issue, perhaps AIDA64 as well.

  • @Gaas35
    @Gaas35 Месяц назад +1

    a bit misleading, I agree that 3rd party apps can introduce weirdness as for you in this case, but to blame is iRacing and its engine and nothing else

    • @BenchmarkOdysseys
      @BenchmarkOdysseys  Месяц назад +1

      I've changed the title to be less misleading. You are right, there is still more stuttering in iRacing than previous seasons, and this driver stutter from polling GPU power makes it unplayable.

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      @@BenchmarkOdysseysYes normally I get 230 Watts but sometimes i only get 180 Watts…

  • @vx220ukct
    @vx220ukct Месяц назад +1

    i have stutters, and don't have afterburner running.

    • @bmwM3M5M6
      @bmwM3M5M6 Месяц назад

      @vx220ukct it’s just iracing thing

  • @buzzKillerCSS
    @buzzKillerCSS Месяц назад

    Can anyone explain what "Frame Re-projection" is exactly? Hardware is trying to recreate something it missed?

    • @SianaGearz
      @SianaGearz 6 дней назад +1

      It is functionality of the presentation layer within all VR software stacks, it's not generally implemented in hardware as far as i'm aware.
      When the hardware or application hasn't managed to render a frame before the start of frame scanout (video data transmission) deadline of the VR headset, the VR middleware will reuse the previous rendered frame, and quickly warp it to match your new head orientation. Without reprojection, when the deadline is missed, old image data would be scanned out verbatim and a very sharp increase in motion sickness is observed.
      Frequent reprojection presentation events are evidence of insufficient or inconsistent performance of the rendering application, and it's unpleasant since while it tries to suppress visual jitter, it's still somewhat evident.

    • @buzzKillerCSS
      @buzzKillerCSS 5 дней назад

      @@SianaGearz Thank you!

  • @NVMDSTEvil
    @NVMDSTEvil Месяц назад +1

    Yeah, afterburner/rivatuner have been doing this for 10 years. This is nothing new. Almost all monitoring software can/does cause this.

  • @AI.Musixia
    @AI.Musixia Месяц назад

    afterburner or in german arschbrenner! .. 😂😂😂 is only useless old, nothing for oc or uv or optimizing, the best software is amd adrenaline! (joke) iam a linux gamer nohing goes over corectrl