They Thought They'd Get Away with It

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 2 тыс.

  • @JerryRigEverything
    @JerryRigEverything Год назад +26010

    Glass is glass and glass breaks.

    • @triccks6184
      @triccks6184 Год назад +1928

      It's the man himself, hope you win this battle.

    • @DubuTrash
      @DubuTrash Год назад +594

      Pretty open and shut case *ba dum tss*
      But really tho wish you and dbrand the best. It's unfortunate the situation, but you guys definitely got this! Love the videos 👍

    • @thedarkforce9596
      @thedarkforce9596 Год назад +175

      I hope you and dbrand when this lawsuit this is disgusting coming from a big company like casetify

    • @momcomegetmeimscared
      @momcomegetmeimscared Год назад +80

      good luck brother! doubt you'll need to tho

    • @megatronskneecap
      @megatronskneecap Год назад +66

      Bitch better have my money - RiRi 2016

  • @yammy
    @yammy Год назад +1099

    I once did a brand deal w/them and they asked me to drop my phone in the ad bcus their cases protect to up to 10ft & my phone’s glass back smashed lol. Didn’t offer to get me a new one cause I had Apple care so I went without my phone for a week. Never again! ☠️

    • @cindy8966
      @cindy8966 Год назад +28

      Nahhh 😭

    • @PTS-Maid
      @PTS-Maid Год назад +72

      Now I want to see the ad

    • @hersugardaddy...
      @hersugardaddy... 11 месяцев назад +4

      yammy!!

    • @maekkis
      @maekkis 11 месяцев назад +63

      i guess glass is glass and glass breaks

    • @parknich081
      @parknich081 11 месяцев назад

      LMAO

  • @AkhierDragonheart
    @AkhierDragonheart Год назад +3561

    This is literally the classic trap for catching things like this. Map makers would include fake towns. Phone book manufacturers would include fake numbers. And now, tear down skins and their Easter eggs

    • @BonziBUDDY
      @BonziBUDDY Год назад +270

      Dictionaries would make fake words. It really is a timeless trap because it works so well.

    • @ColinTimmins
      @ColinTimmins Год назад +41

      I forgot about this fact. Very cool stuff. =]

    • @isabelward7783
      @isabelward7783 Год назад +17

      I never knew this this is cool

    • @Klust413
      @Klust413 Год назад +66

      Those fake towns are known as paper towns, and they're the first thing I thought about being they serve such a similar purpose.

    • @fatusopp4739
      @fatusopp4739 Год назад +36

      these mfs is mice. so focused on the cheese, they forgot about da trap :(

  • @obi_wanshinobi
    @obi_wanshinobi Год назад +891

    Whoever made the decision to put those little Easter eggs into the design is definitely getting their Christmas bonus this year.

  • @j4nk3n
    @j4nk3n Год назад +7156

    I guess if you're a design company, adding eastereggs is your watermark and a great move to combat copyrights

    • @BigStrongACG2023
      @BigStrongACG2023 Год назад +1

      DIDNT ASK:MY CONТЕNT = WAY BETTER!!!!!!!😂💀⚡️⚡️

    • @245sleepwalking
      @245sleepwalking Год назад +275

      @@BigStrongACG2023we didn't ask either

    • @nathanielheron970
      @nathanielheron970 Год назад +283

      Map makers have been doing this too they’re called paper towns

    • @Diamond1234
      @Diamond1234 Год назад +87

      Lol yeah, they didn't even do their homework on what it actually looks like because they took the easiest way out, which was copy it and change pieces of it to make it look different enough and sell it, not knowing the parts that were Easter eggs exposed their theft.

    • @j4nk3n
      @j4nk3n Год назад +58

      @@Diamond1234 I mean they even swapped some of the parts around, so they knew it was wrong and even tried to make it look like ass to cover their tracks 😂 this is why the company is worth a billion, most money made from the least effort, but for this at least it's come to bite them, probably won't be enough to make them stop in other ways though sadly

  • @Vinsternator40
    @Vinsternator40 Год назад +2317

    What's insane is Casetify literally copied and pasted the designs from Dbrands marketing photos. For the Galaxy, specifically, they didn't even line up the stolen art with the phone itself so there is a random lens printed on the case.

    • @BigStrongACG2023
      @BigStrongACG2023 Год назад +1

      DIDNT ASK:MY CONТЕNT = WAY BETTER!!!!!!!😂💀⚡️⚡️

    • @camronh14
      @camronh14 Год назад +2

      yep

    • @MysteryMii
      @MysteryMii Год назад +58

      And it turns out that they’re also ripping off iFixIt as well by taking a 6 year old X-ray photo of an iPhone X from them and slapping it on to their cases without permission.
      How cheap is Casetify to not make their own designs? They certainly have the money (given how expensive their cases are) and resources to make their own teardown and X-ray designs.

    • @Rurike
      @Rurike Год назад +23

      Its almost like the biggest companies make the cheapest crap

    • @burp2019
      @burp2019 Год назад +9

      @@MysteryMii funny thing is that it likely would have been easier for them to make their own than putting in the effort of stealing and (horribly) hiding it

  • @_ndless
    @_ndless Год назад +6904

    Crazy how a billion dollar company would attempt this blatant plagiarism. I’ve seen mass Chinese manufacturers on Temu put more thought in their products

    • @VioletMilks
      @VioletMilks Год назад

      @@InstagramUser2don’t translate guys, it says “hey guys, you ever see that temu ad with the girl in pink leggings? Yeah I’ve busted to that because I’m a naughty boy~”

    • @RobbieStacks90
      @RobbieStacks90 Год назад +24

      Brand recognition matters to consumers. That's why I only shop at Whole Foods Market because I know I'm getting high-quality organic food there. Never date a woman who will settle for less.

    • @peteryeeterson5766
      @peteryeeterson5766 Год назад +362

      @@RobbieStacks90 “Don’t ask questions, just consume product. And then get exited for next product.”

    • @BigStrongACG2023
      @BigStrongACG2023 Год назад

      DIDNT ASK:MY CONТЕNT = WAY BETTER!!!!!!!😂💀⚡️⚡️

    • @TopScope_
      @TopScope_ Год назад +200

      @Zenigundam oh hey you're the guy who tried hitting up a bot that posed as a woman yesterday lol

  • @mkbdnews
    @mkbdnews Год назад +264

    By the way this isn't the first time Casetify has been caught. They've stolen from smaller creators before and I’m glad someone can finally fight this with justice.

  • @Geoff69420
    @Geoff69420 Год назад +1606

    It's always funny when plagiarists get caught, in a "Let's point and laugh at the idiot(s) who thought they could get away with it!" sort of way.

    • @BigStrongACG2023
      @BigStrongACG2023 Год назад

      DIDNT ASK:MY CONТЕNT = WAY BETTER!!!!!!!😂💀⚡️⚡️

    • @bobhanson1037
      @bobhanson1037 Год назад +8

      Companies and people do it all the time. Just getting caught so bad is whats funny

    • @phatal4573
      @phatal4573 Год назад

      yet they did get away with it and wont have to pay a dime... china is plagued with counterfeited stuff thats nothing new nor is it special

  • @gabbievee
    @gabbievee Год назад +14238

    casetify is so absurdly overpriced i’m glad to see they’re gonna have to pay all those legal fees

    • @crashnebula7
      @crashnebula7 Год назад +546

      If only it'd put them out of business so I could stop seeing their ads💀

    • @wugira76
      @wugira76 Год назад +254

      If a product is shilled by a youtuber, or just publicised, somewhat consistently, you are better off just ignoring it and looking for a better product

    • @justinromero4563
      @justinromero4563 Год назад +113

      I feel like casetify is the apple of phone cases the only difference is apple actually does something and casetify is just a phone case brand thats no different from others like dbrand or spigen

    • @AltraHapi
      @AltraHapi Год назад

      ​@@justinromero4563Casetify is more comprobable to Supreme where they just put their hideous logo around the camera

    • @terra_the_nightingale135
      @terra_the_nightingale135 Год назад

      I’m currently using a casetify case lol I always thought they were cool and cheaper than other cases I had come across but only found out about them from RUclipsrs and oop 🫢 yike

  • @megatronskneecap
    @megatronskneecap Год назад +5250

    As JerryRigEverything mentioned, a company that is worth near billions ripping off another company that isn't even worth a quater of that using a design from a simple at-home husband is just another level of depressing - And they couldn't even be bothered to crop it properly or anything either. That's what annoyed Zack from JRE as yes, they obviously stole the designs but not even bothering to crop them a little bit is just disrespectful 😭

    • @InstagramUser2
      @InstagramUser2 Год назад +3

      No replies? Lemme fix that.

    • @polan7429
      @polan7429 Год назад +120

      "simple at home husband" isnt exactly how id describe him but i get the idea

    • @MokohiChan
      @MokohiChan Год назад +70

      The only thing I know about Casetify is that they are sponsors for a bunch of RUclipsrs and frankly, that's all I needed to know to know they're scum. I've never seen a popular sponsor that didn't come out to be scumbags a year or two after sponsoring a shit ton of people. It's like an automatic red flag nowadays.
      (Nothing against the RUclipsrs. They usually don't know. It's just I've noticed this is a trend.)

    • @megatronskneecap
      @megatronskneecap Год назад +1

      well he's not a multi-billion dollar in network ceo is he?@@polan7429

    • @unmasking7974
      @unmasking7974 Год назад +22

      cus big coorporations got F U money they just do whatever they please but maybe this lawsuit can put a sizeable dent in their grimey company

  • @K-Anator
    @K-Anator Год назад +724

    9:57 The reason the images look so bad is because Casetify downloaded the 72DPI image from dbrand's website and never bothered to upscale it to print at a proper 300DPI after making their meagre modifications.
    You can see this for yourself by creating two identical images in Photoshop or the like. Make one 72DPI (web standard) and the other 300DPI (print standard) and despite both images being say 1080x1080, the one printed at 300DPI will look infinitely better.

    • @goopyhead
      @goopyhead Год назад

      yeah lmao looks like a shitty magazine scan

    • @Iblamethebarrels
      @Iblamethebarrels Год назад +15

      Absolutely hilarious that they were so lazy and hoping to not get caught 😅 great add

    • @SioxerNikita
      @SioxerNikita Год назад +6

      That's not how "DPI" and Resolution works...
      You don't create more detail by changing the DPI, especially since DPI is an arbitrary number you can change as you please.

    • @K-Anator
      @K-Anator Год назад +20

      @@SioxerNikita Apparently you missed the part where I mention upscaling it, perhaps utilising something like Waifu2x.
      A 4x6 photo, if available at 300DPI, will look better when printed at 300DPI than it would at the web standard 72DPI.
      And yes DPI may be arbitrary, but you go ahead and make a picture at 300DPI, print it out, then change the file to 72DPI, print it again, and try to tell me that the 72DPI version looks just as good.
      I'll wait.

    • @SioxerNikita
      @SioxerNikita Год назад

      ​@@K-AnatorAnd then it wouldn't be the same resolution, so no, I didn't miss that.
      You are using an ARBITRARY measurement here, that is DPI, which is essentially irrelevant for computer graphics parts, it is only relevant when printing...
      The 72 DPI and the 300 DPI, the major difference between those two if you use the exact same file, is the 300 DPI image will be significantly smaller...
      I really find it interesting that you talk so confidently about this.
      DPI stands for Dots Per Inch... I can make an image that is 10x10 and make it 1 DPI, and it would be 10x10 inches...
      Or I could make a 1x1 and make it 300 DPI, and it would be a single pixel that is 0.003(repeating)mm x0.003(repeating)mm
      You have no fucking clue what you are talking about. DPI is literally an arbitrary number in terms of computer and image files.

  • @mage1439
    @mage1439 Год назад +144

    It's hilarious they got caught with a map trap. Beautiful. This is the first time I can remember this ever happening. I've never even heard of an actual map-maker being caught at this.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад +6

      Please do share. When have you ever heard of a map maker to begin with?

    • @ccalvinn
      @ccalvinn Год назад +4

      ​@@StierenklootI mean there's published map books at Walmart here, that leads to belief of makers of those maps. It's not an out of this world thought process m8 😳

    • @ticklemebreathless1394
      @ticklemebreathless1394 Год назад +4

      ​@@StierenklootAre you insinuating that cartographers don't exist?
      Lists exist online of the most famous and accomplished cartographers, and they are not hard to find. I believe Marion A Frieswyk was the first female intelligence cartographer in the CIA. There is also Abbas Sahab, who was the first cartographer to produce an atlas of the Persian Gulf. Cartographers do some amazing work!
      (If you were being sarcastic... Sorry. :p)

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      @@ticklemebreathless1394 I was genuinely curious. Because I know they exist but I’ve never heard of any. Most people haven’t.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      @@ccalvinn kinda dumb of you to assume I implied they don’t exist. I really just said “which ones have you heard of”. Dummy

  • @cabb6573
    @cabb6573 Год назад +447

    This is like copying your friend's homework and changing bits so it doesn't look too similar but they forgot to change the name 😂😂😂

    • @MrMegaDanila
      @MrMegaDanila Год назад +17

      well as shown in the video they didnt even bother to change any bits... all the "easter eggs" are there...

    • @mrfoxmcfox
      @mrfoxmcfox Год назад +9

      or writing your homework in your friends notebook 💀

    • @YimYum911
      @YimYum911 Год назад +1

      @@MrMegaDanila I watched Jerry’s video, they did remove some obvious ones and replaced Dbrand’s logo with their’s, the audacity 🙄

  • @MaxxDW
    @MaxxDW Год назад +456

    This is more than just theft, it's an embarrassment.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад +1

      Dude this is standard practice in China. Casetify is Chinese. This is how most Chinese companies operate. I guess you just had your little “welcome to the real world” moment or something?
      Don’t do business with China if you value your intellectual property. And even still, expect they will steal and copy from you. I have personal experience with this.

  • @sl3kii875
    @sl3kii875 Год назад +1179

    It's honestly just sad when companies completely rip off each other

    • @menace4319
      @menace4319 Год назад +97

      especially when its a bigger company ripping a smaller one

    • @cagethelonewolf
      @cagethelonewolf Год назад +1

      its literally the inside of the phone, you literally can't claim copyright

    • @f3ds.
      @f3ds. Год назад +40

      Casetify is outrageous on cases too and they’re bad quality for 80$ 😭💀

    • @jakethefinn2353
      @jakethefinn2353 Год назад +37

      ​@@cagethelonewolfbrother you have no idea of what you're talking about

    • @layZlad
      @layZlad Год назад +46

      @@cagethelonewolf but its Dbrand's printed design that Casetify stole. The original design has little Easter eggs referring to JerryRigEverything which was also copied over, so either way its still copyright infringement

  • @jacob79001
    @jacob79001 Год назад +439

    The largest player in the phone case market (Otterbox) has a disgusting clause in their design submission portal that gives the company full rights over your product the moment you send it and there's also a clause saying they don't need to give you any financial compensation if they use it... I hate to think how many unsuspecting designers are going to lose a lot of time, effort and money because of that. Not to mention the huge risk of being sued if they don't scan the policy properly and then take their design to other companies.

    • @michaelbuto305
      @michaelbuto305 Год назад +25

      Its because these little thing that give LOADS of profit.
      Thats the reason why Fan PC is the MOST profitable business, more than boards and etc.
      10$ can become 200$. And the moment you have China with their Auto-Tech which other company built there, you can have 1$ case and sell 50-100$ on US/EU.
      The profit in this case controversy is soo big. And people doesnt realize that.

    • @grahamb7947
      @grahamb7947 Год назад +14

      Same clause happens with any company you can submit data to. Check some more Privacy Policy documents and T&Cs and you'll be surprised how often such a clause comes up.
      That's why you always have a lawyer draw up documents and present designs in person, otherwise you're going to get shafted.

    • @HiDDENk00l
      @HiDDENk00l Год назад +10

      This is different from that, because they took the design from dbrand without their permission or even their knowledge.
      And they didn't even buy and scan a physical case, they just right-clicked and copied the preview on the website.

    • @jeasydj123
      @jeasydj123 Год назад +9

      my face literally shifted into shell shock as I read this comment on my phone with an otterbox phonecase

  • @AndrewNineTen
    @AndrewNineTen Год назад +369

    It's crazy how similar this is to so-called "paper towns" where map companies would put fake towns or other intentionally incorrect details on their maps to catch copycats. Same thing with the easter eggs on these case designs even if unintentional.

    • @KryaDiere
      @KryaDiere Год назад +29

      Yeah my country had a map app company that got sued to bankruptcy by Google for stealing all the maps of our country off google maps and just redrawing over them lol... including some non-existing places google threw in for fun lol.

    • @cagxplays9602
      @cagxplays9602 Год назад +6

      What happens to the people who take those map locations seriously and end up in the middle of nowhere? Sounds like a good way to get sued yourself.

    • @MathewRodeiguez
      @MathewRodeiguez Год назад +19

      @@cagxplays9602no one’s gonna search up a fake place to go to? So it Doesn’t matter

    • @tundra4331
      @tundra4331 Год назад +22

      ​@@cagxplays9602it's happened but I don't think anyone's sued before, you just go "oh wow it's just a plot of land actually" and go on your way

    • @pyramear5414
      @pyramear5414 Год назад +18

      *Spends 3 weeks stranded in mountains with only a map*
      "Finally! There should be a town just over this last hill! I'm saved!"

  • @ramachandra776
    @ramachandra776 Год назад +1053

    Dbrand was playing chess while casetify was playing checkers . Copying the purposefully added water marks or easter eggs is probably one of the stupidest things casetify could have done . As Charlie says , "Scholars mate" , referring to his famous chess game between him and Xqc . 😊

    • @coryyoung7544
      @coryyoung7544 Год назад +31

      Funny though that they literally when through the same thing with Sony when they copied the X, square,triangle, O logo.
      They got sued and lost then changed it to have skulls.

    • @BigStrongACG2023
      @BigStrongACG2023 Год назад

      DIDNT ASK:MY CONТЕNT = WAY BETTER!!!!!!!😂💀⚡️⚡️

    • @shadowbannedbyyoutube0
      @shadowbannedbyyoutube0 Год назад +21

      @@BigStrongACG2023 Didn't ask + ratio

    • @emiami458
      @emiami458 Год назад +3

      Right, two absolute geniuses at the game of chess, penguinz0 and xqc... 🙄
      More like two special ed kids playing a game of tic tac toe with each other during recess.

    • @sakurahirawa
      @sakurahirawa Год назад +14

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@emiami458
      Tbf, those kids playing tic tac toe in recess a lot are probably tic tac toe gods. They’ll probably have the most competitive game of tic tac toe to ever exist.

  • @TomoEriGoto
    @TomoEriGoto Год назад +84

    For as much as Casetify charges for their cases, I expect my phone to survive being tossed by Superman.

  • @MattePurple1
    @MattePurple1 Год назад +92

    Displates "can withstand a lifetime of staring" made legitimately laugh out loud. Charlie really has a way with words.

  • @TheBo0m
    @TheBo0m Год назад +114

    I can't stop laughing at how utterly fecked Casetify is and how beautifully clever it was for Dbrand to put sooo many little easter eggs in their designs. Reminds me of fictitious entries in dictionaries and maps as copyright traps and it's making my night

  • @garywatson
    @garywatson Год назад +29

    Best guess is that Caseify assumed that Dbrand couldn't claim copyright on a mere photograph of an Apple or Samsung innards, but in this case Dbrand put a lot of effort into enhancing the photographs to highlight the various doodads inside each phone. Those enhancements, plus the easter eggs as proof, make the copyright case very solid. Some of the facts make it pretty clear that the theft was intentional, which at least in US courts can lead to massive judgements.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      Cute guess. But in actuality Casetify is a Chinese company and they intentionally copy and steal IP. And the government backs them so you can’t win lawsuits

    • @Person01234
      @Person01234 5 месяцев назад

      photographs absolutely carry implicit copyright. You have to get permission to use people's photographs commercially. If you didn't stock photo companies would have been out of business a long time ago.

  • @IncognitoOrange
    @IncognitoOrange Год назад +344

    The fact the genuinely didn’t even consider this happening is insane to me 💀

  • @clockwork3494
    @clockwork3494 Год назад +10

    I love how easter eggs in designs or art have unironically become a better way to spot plagiarism than watermarks since people typically cut or crop them out, so easter eggs or inside jokes that only people who follow the original creator know are easy as hell to spot if replicated or outright stolen and not covered up.
    You love to see it, a clear cut case like this would have their lawyer drooling with such an easy paycheck.

  • @tomasviane3844
    @tomasviane3844 Год назад +18

    They used to have the same 'easter eggs' in encyclopedias and world maps. They either put in non existing words or non existing towns, just so they could check who blatantly copied their stuff.

  • @fabiopauli420
    @fabiopauli420 Год назад +89

    If it wasnt for the easteregg i could give them the benefit of the doubt and say: hey you know most Electronic devices look the same when you open them up, but with all of those copied eastereggs no chance this is legit

    • @mh-rl4sz
      @mh-rl4sz Год назад +4

      yea firstly I was like "all electronic look same" but at half of video you realise it is just stealing

    • @linecraftman3907
      @linecraftman3907 Год назад +24

      Dbrand skins are not actually how devices look inside if you simply remove the back plate, they edit it to look pretty, like move/remove ribbon cables, cover plates and stuff like that so that you can see more of the stuff inside, along with color corrections

    • @mh-rl4sz
      @mh-rl4sz Год назад +5

      @@linecraftman3907 tnx now all make sense.

  • @IDrag
    @IDrag Год назад +12

    dbrand went as far as posting all these tweets at 11:11am, to ensure that casetify does not copy there tweets as well

  • @nomoretwitterhandles
    @nomoretwitterhandles Год назад +10

    This isn't just Casetify btw!! Rhinoshield is also hiring artists who are tracing/copying other people's works. I was looking through Rhinoshield's catalogue and found a case that looked eerily similar to a photograph I had seen years ago; sure enough, I found the photograph, and the drawing is a 1:1 direct copy--most definitely traced. I wouldn't be surprised if that artist stole other works as well, as they had an entire collection.
    If you're going to buy art, please do your research!

  • @Riftabot
    @Riftabot Год назад +191

    This is going to get settled out of court for a lot of money. They know they're completely fucked and have no chance.

    • @ConnorwithanO
      @ConnorwithanO Год назад +8

      Why would Dbrand settle a case that they're 100% going to win?

    • @mylesnewton1226
      @mylesnewton1226 Год назад

      ​@@ConnorwithanOSave $ on Lawyer fees and time, ideally Caseify just pays out what they want

    • @burp2019
      @burp2019 Год назад +21

      Dbrand's already said Casetify's not getting out that easily, and why settle a case you're basically guaranteed to win

    • @groundbreaker91
      @groundbreaker91 Год назад +8

      @@ConnorwithanO Because 9/10, it's not worth the hassle of going to trial, even if you're 100% in the right. Notwithstanding all the legal fees that would come from pursuing that avenue, just attempting to get to a trial itself would take months, so it's just easier for all parties involved to have the guilty party pay a settlement and be on their way.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      Casetify is Chinese. The Chinese government actively endorses IP theft like this. Even patents mean nothing in China. The lawsuit will get nowhere.

  • @PhDMario
    @PhDMario Год назад +40

    I was like “duh! It’s an x-ray-thing case, of course the design will be the same”. Then Charlie went through the Easter eggs part 💀

  • @Dimitrakiiron
    @Dimitrakiiron Год назад +16

    Matt in the background during the ad is the most wholesome thing I’ve seen today

  • @dontaskme7004
    @dontaskme7004 Год назад +15

    It's quite common for products to have deliberate mistakes as a way of spotting copies. Maps will have mistakes, like a short road or alley that runs NW to SE being drawn in NE to SW. No original map will have that same mistake. Some sites and publishers will have what appear to be typo's.

  • @Jfam11638
    @Jfam11638 Год назад +10

    The first time someone’s caught plagiarizing something usually isn’t the first time they’ve actually done it

  • @niccalee
    @niccalee Год назад +3

    I like to think that the employees looking at all of the Casetify cases had fun and kept points for finding each of the stolen designs. Like a scavenger hunt.

  • @Coco-Loco
    @Coco-Loco Год назад +26

    I hope Jerry wins! Not only does he and dbrand deserve the win, Jerry also said they'll put the money towards growing his company that makes good wheelchairs for people who need them. He's like the sweetest guy ever!

    • @ivorym6158
      @ivorym6158 Год назад

      unus annus?

    • @Coco-Loco
      @Coco-Loco Год назад

      @@ivorym6158 memento mori.

    • @Greenhawk4
      @Greenhawk4 Год назад

      they are guaranteed the win the evidence is concrete.

  • @classydays43
    @classydays43 Год назад +10

    The only thing I could think is CaseTify must have thought the internals of a phone were copyrighted to the company that made the phone and figured DBrand wouldn't have a leg to stand on during a court battle, as though the designs don't belong to them. They probably never took a phone apart to see DBrand's own design choices to make it their own.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      You think wrong. This is a simple case of a Chinese company not giving a shit about IP and just proudly stealing for profit. It’s ingrained in their culture. The lawsuit won’t even go anywhere because the Chinese government endorses this behavior to boost GDP

    • @Person01234
      @Person01234 5 месяцев назад +1

      Doesn't matter, if they take a picture of the internals, they own the rights to the picture. Same as if you take a picture of the golden gate bridge you own the rights to that image, not the state of california or whoever tf owns the golden gate bridge. I doubt a company as large as casetify doesn't understand this.

    • @classydays43
      @classydays43 5 месяцев назад

      @@Person01234 ah, fair point. I never considered that aspect.

  • @hidden_animator522
    @hidden_animator522 Год назад +28

    I was about to be like “why would the designs look different if it’s the same internals?” But then I saw they didn’t edit out the Easter eggs and I knew this was open and shut.

    • @WayStedYou
      @WayStedYou Год назад

      because the actual skin is already touched up from what the internals look like in the first place to make it look nicer too, and casetify would've had to do exactly the same adjustments.
      the easter eggs being copied is the slam dunk on it being 100% copy.

  • @ex5080
    @ex5080 Год назад +4

    Definitely a open-and-shut case, there's literally no reason why those hidden references would be on another brand's design

  • @HpToujoursPur
    @HpToujoursPur Год назад +2

    It did save effort. Taking photos of pre-existing cases is easier than buying and disassembling phones and scanning them to make a high quality render

  • @extraterrestrial.cherries
    @extraterrestrial.cherries Год назад +6

    I love some of casetify's cases like their sailor moon and twice and powerpuff girls collabs and some of the collabs with artists are with artists I really love- but they're so overpriced like it's UNREAL-- especially to be that expensive and some of the designs are stolen 💀💀 and the fact that the cases were probably double the price

  • @kratz_creed8427
    @kratz_creed8427 Год назад +38

    honestly being early to see the performance of matt presenting the displates is an honour and an absolute delight, i hope he wins an oscar for his incredible skill

    • @A.Mack1o2
      @A.Mack1o2 Год назад

      ​@RonnieMcfloydUTTPyou suck bro

  • @rapzalg_music
    @rapzalg_music Год назад +7

    ive seen aliexpress retailers put more thought into their products than the "inside out"

    • @cagxplays9602
      @cagxplays9602 Год назад

      Casetify is a drop shipping business, most of their suppliers were/are from ali express and similar sites until they paid them to be private suppliers.

  • @NekomiyaRimi
    @NekomiyaRimi Год назад +4

    The irony of talking about art theft while being sponsored by art thieves

  • @oceanman180
    @oceanman180 Год назад +26

    What an entertaining case! Copyright law is super interesting. Sad how Casetify so blatantly ripped off of Dbrand though, and smart of Dbrand to include those eastereggs for excellent proof of infringement. Excited to see how this turns out, and hoping to see Dbrand win!!

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      Copyright law is interesting shre. But what’s even more interesting is that it’s just some arbitrary agreements between western gentlemen. And casetify is a Chinese company and the Chinese don’t give a flying fuck about copyrights or patents. You cant even successfully sue them for anything because the Chinese government is pro IP theft

    • @Greenhawk4
      @Greenhawk4 Год назад +2

      I understand what you mean but you dont really have to hope I mean its concrete evidence

    • @kharmachaos667
      @kharmachaos667 Год назад +1

      Only thing I'm worried about is casetify consistently delaying.

    • @cooltwittertag
      @cooltwittertag Год назад

      this reads like chatgpt

  • @AnonymousKev
    @AnonymousKev Год назад +289

    they literally couldve done this themselves in like an hour

    • @awarepillow1180
      @awarepillow1180 Год назад +62

      JerryRigEverything (the partner of Dbrand for the Teardown skins) made a video where he included a 10 hour timelapse of him cleaning the scan of the inside to make it more appealing and add his own easter eggs. And that was all just for the first draft.

    • @InstagramUser2
      @InstagramUser2 Год назад +1

      No replies? Lemme fix that.

    • @O90EKQZVP9
      @O90EKQZVP9 Год назад +40

      the dbrand version was edited to make it more appealing, the actual internals look pretty bland and monotone

    • @StuninRub
      @StuninRub Год назад +6

      ​@@awarepillow1180That's because he wanted to add Easter eggs, but for the use case, it was not necessary.

    • @justadefaultguy
      @justadefaultguy Год назад +5

      JerryRigEverything in his video it look over 10,000 to make all the designs

  • @crystallakedood
    @crystallakedood Год назад +3

    The funniest thing to me about the whole situation, is that a buddy of mine tried to upload an image to their "make a custom case" section of their site... only to be told by the site: "this is a copyrighted image, you can't use this."
    He had gotten permission from the artist, too, but obviously the site had no way of knowing.
    But still... they tell users "you can't steal art", but then they go "only we can steal art!"

  • @ayanahmed202
    @ayanahmed202 Год назад +5

    i think cartographers use a similar technique where they make maps with fake towns (i.e. “paper towns”) to see if competitors copied their maps
    if i’m wrong, it’s because john green lied to me

  • @boogbug8244
    @boogbug8244 Год назад +3

    This is like if you photocopied another kid's homework so their name is still on it when you turn it in

  • @JacobMcdonald-od9ho
    @JacobMcdonald-od9ho Год назад +501

    Charlie isn't the pizza delivery man but he never fails to deliver

    • @Baronnax
      @Baronnax Год назад +47

      Literal bot-tier comment.

    • @jackygemme863
      @jackygemme863 Год назад +7

      Beep boop 🤖

    • @arghpee
      @arghpee Год назад +8

      THIS COMMENT IS SO ORIGINAL HAHAHAHAHA

    • @DjDummo
      @DjDummo Год назад +5

      bot comment

    • @rosee8140
      @rosee8140 Год назад +2

      ​@@BaronnaxGotta get those likes, right?

  • @willuigi64
    @willuigi64 Год назад +2

    An AD for Displate of all companies, on a video about how a company infringed on another's copyright. How ironic.

  • @Not_Ferrari
    @Not_Ferrari Год назад +4

    Interesting choice, in a video about a company stealing artwork, to have an ad for Displate who have ALSO been accused at times of stealing artwork...

  • @JesseP189
    @JesseP189 Год назад +195

    Charlie's chat being brainrotted as always with the takes. Expect nothing less

    • @Mizznimal
      @Mizznimal Год назад +41

      ok but maybe they just made an oopsie

    • @CosmicNermal
      @CosmicNermal Год назад +58

      That's twitch chat in general

    • @Loafster_P
      @Loafster_P Год назад

      Forreal. Gotta love some corporate shills masquerading as devils advocates

    • @Dylan-yy3rw
      @Dylan-yy3rw Год назад +31

      ​@@Mizznimal117 oopsies to be exact.

    • @youknowwhat9911
      @youknowwhat9911 Год назад +1

      What’d they say

  • @irExron
    @irExron Год назад +8

    Imagine getting got by the oldest spy hunting method.

  • @hakuji...
    @hakuji... Год назад +106

    charlie's voice is so soothing that i can fall asleep within 10 seconds of his videos

    • @Icky_b
      @Icky_b Год назад +6

      I actually fell asleep watching one of his videos one time

    • @CRWSKILU6
      @CRWSKILU6 Год назад +2

      honestly same

    • @urgae9125
      @urgae9125 Год назад +5

      I regularly put Charlie on whenever I’m going to bed, it’s like a wacky bedtime story.

    • @wolfgunworld
      @wolfgunworld Год назад

      U mean boring

    • @csengeredl2787
      @csengeredl2787 Год назад +3

      i feel you, i fall asleep to his videos on a regular basis

  • @hjue44
    @hjue44 Год назад +1

    My lawyer heart dies a little whenever someone wants to patent a copyright

  • @vcpolo5
    @vcpolo5 Год назад +2

    Ironic Displate sponsors this video about ripping off designs when Displate rips off people's art all the time to make a profit off it.

  • @nemuriyagi
    @nemuriyagi Год назад +3

    to answer the question of how casetify's printings look so bad, right clicking and saving the internet jpg is not the same as having the file in terms of DPI. Zack from JRE said they used 48000 DPI images; standard jpg internet formatting just resets images to 72dpi. Makes for horrendous physical product prints.

  • @MoA-Reload...
    @MoA-Reload... Год назад +102

    Of all the content creators and companies to do it to too. Like DBrand are renowned for their Twitter shenanigans and humour. They have so much reach and earned respect in the tech community and Jerryrigeverything is also very well known and has a hell of a lot of respect in that community. It's a space that has a lot of loud voices like LTT, Gamersnexus, Jayz2Cents, Paul's Hardware, Louis Rossmann and so on and so on and that community has memories like elephants! You'd have to be an absolute moron to think "huh, that looks cool. Let's just rip it off from the images on their store page and make bank on it. No one will notice" and actually think that's going to work out well 😂

    • @sammiller6631
      @sammiller6631 Год назад +10

      LTT doesn't have clean hands with their selling a prototype that wasn't theirs and the questionable practices around Madison

    • @DezaltOfTheDreg
      @DezaltOfTheDreg Год назад

      ​@@sammiller6631point still stands

    • @MoA-Reload...
      @MoA-Reload... Год назад +4

      @@sammiller6631 very true, and not only did they sell that prototype, they did a proper number on the company when they proper balls the review of that prototype... Before accidentally selling it 🤦

    • @sammiller6631
      @sammiller6631 Год назад +2

      @@MoA-Reload... Yeah, you're right that I didn't mention the major trashing review hit piece Linus did before selling the prototype. It seems Linus enjoys being spiteful and intentionally sold the prototype as a spiteful passive-aggressive power flex. His "apology" video is a snarky way to twist the knife even more to signal to us that he's able to get away with that and nothing will happen to him.

    • @0NeeN0
      @0NeeN0 Год назад

      @@sammiller6631 On the one hand I get you as those two things had happened, on the other those are real drama, Madison and people who were doing those questionable practices but it wasn't anyone on the top level and possibly they didn't even know, and second drama (not so real) is just a fck up done for charity (I know it doesn't matter what the intent was but what is the outcome). Yes Linus sold prototype of one of the kind, possibly revolutionary technology to someone (could be competitor) and yeah that's bad. On the other hand nothing was criminal (Possibly Madison with mobbing but I think the case isn't shut yet) or deserving more than internet stoning like reposting a graphs of old benchmark instead of doing new one because of crunch related to product release and that's ALL that happened in 15 years in LTT history.

  • @visuallybread
    @visuallybread Год назад +10

    This is honestly great outreach for dbrand, they'll win the lawsuit but also get thousands of new customers because these cases are sick and i've never seen them before and i'm definitely ordering one for my 14 pro right now

  • @RMDragon3
    @RMDragon3 Год назад +2

    If it was just a very similar design, you could argue it's just that both are faithful recreations of the inside. However, the Easter eggs make it clear it's stolen.

  • @kennethliu3268
    @kennethliu3268 Год назад +2

    The casetify case looks low res because DBrand bought their product and scanned physical copy, whereas DBrand's images are the original digital copy.

  • @bigyoshi5170
    @bigyoshi5170 Год назад +12

    To be fair they would’ve if it wasn’t for those meddling kids, and their dog too

  • @bigboi8203
    @bigboi8203 Год назад +70

    That is one of the most blatant rip offs I’ve ever seen😂. Truly Shameless. Really sad to see big companies still pulling shit like this.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад +1

      I guarantee you that you’ve seen worse rip offs on a daily basis. You just don’t notice unless someone spells it out for you.
      Chinese companies copy shit. That’s old news pal.

    • @bigboi8203
      @bigboi8203 Год назад +1

      @@Stierenkloot why are you so agro? Do you work for Casetify 😂

  • @Drewqes
    @Drewqes Год назад +4

    So I actually know the reason why some of the text look kind of hieroglyphic, I use upscaling software all the time in photography to make photos look higher Rez, but part of what it tries to do is fill-in pixels to make everything looks smooth and so a lot of the time text looks AI generated or really wobbly because it doesn’t know how to fill it in properly.
    So chances are what they did is they downloaded a JPEG or took a screenshot and then upscaled it so that they could put it on their cases

  • @Xeonerable
    @Xeonerable Год назад +3

    They spent just as much time coming up with the lame name of "inside parts" as they did with downloading the website images and copy/pasting it into their product line. Corporate theft happens all the time but its particularly sad they couldn't be arsed to change all the easter-eggs in the images and get caught with their pants down.

  • @puttingmyphoneoncharge
    @puttingmyphoneoncharge Год назад +4

    i think the slide 5/6 slide was run through an AI image alteration programme which is why the letters around also look similar but off in like abstract lines

  • @awakenedgoat4488
    @awakenedgoat4488 Год назад +4

    I remember Displate from awhile back, some years, and back then at least it was rife with stolen art, giving profits to people that didn't make the artwork at all (since a portion is supposed to go to the account holder).

  • @ditzylilorgans
    @ditzylilorgans Год назад +1

    I got a Casetify x Sailor Moon case a few months back and it's absolutely destroyed now. The glue came undone and there's several holes in the design now. I drop my phone a lot, but the damage done to my case isn't even from getting dropped. The amount of money I paid for a silly limited edition phone case and how horribly it's held up is terrible.

  • @andromeda_va39
    @andromeda_va39 Год назад +1

    If a brand sponsors a RUclipsr, don't buy from them. Simple as that.

  • @kohanrains776
    @kohanrains776 Год назад +11

    5:58 I hate that they have to say things like allegedly, and hard to refute evidence... thats irrefutable... hands down they are guilty

    • @_Salok
      @_Salok 11 месяцев назад

      As long as the judgement hasn't come out, you can't legally say someone's guilty. "Allegedly" is simply legal leverage at that point.

    • @kohanrains776
      @kohanrains776 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@_Salok right I guess I mean I hate that that's how it works, when it's irrefutable they shouldn't be able to come back at anyone for saying it... but I do get in some cases how that's necessary we just have cut and dry laws regardless of circumstance

  • @Bess9779
    @Bess9779 Год назад +3

    They'll prob say they have independent contractors who provide designs & they had no idea this was going on. They'll pay some money amount that doesn't really hurt them & keep moving along. This is how it usually goes.

  • @anchovy5325
    @anchovy5325 Год назад +6

    They did indeed think they'd get away with it

  • @mrtweetie202
    @mrtweetie202 Год назад +1

    4:22 "how do u even argue against this."
    -"nuh uh."

  • @zain.munirzain5872
    @zain.munirzain5872 Год назад +11

    I don't know what to comment but here is a comment. You are awesome Charlie. For those wondering according to Jerry it takes around 10 hours to edit and add details and easter eggs for a single phone after it's internals are scanned by taking it apart, all in all about 10,000 hours of work casetify here trying to steal, thinking no one will catch on.

  • @CreateAmazment
    @CreateAmazment Год назад +4

    I literally do not a see a single world where Casetify wins this lol. Charlie didn't even show the one phone where the lens is literally misaligned from the JPG they stole off dbrand's website and slapped it onto their phone case. It is like some of the most damning evidence in a case like this

  • @kindofanmol
    @kindofanmol Год назад +5

    Charlie diving into tech-related stuff is an event I never expected to happen but am glad it did. Next he needs to switch to Samsung/Pixel.

  • @CGR89
    @CGR89 Год назад +1

    I just can’t believe a Hong Kong based company would blatantly steal designs like that.

  • @chrise8275
    @chrise8275 Год назад +1

    It’s comical how obvious the plagiarism that Casetify committed here is and how many times they stole from them.

  • @drizzet11
    @drizzet11 Год назад +3

    i can 100% see a totally reasonable way to explain this. they are just super lazy and did something like google "phone internals" and by sheer luck the image they took and put onto the cases was the dbrand phone case, since thats EXACTLY what they do with most of their other cases where they just google something like "naruto fighting goku" and steal some guys entire deviantart gallery.

  • @ScalHust
    @ScalHust Год назад +10

    3:10 The synchronization between Mat's overly shocked face and the music is hilarious 😂

  • @Raven74947
    @Raven74947 Год назад +8

    Dbrand makes the best phone case I've found so far. Hope the lawsuit doesn't drag on for years.

    • @Stierenkloot
      @Stierenkloot Год назад

      Casetify is Chinese. The Chinese government wipes their ass with IP related lawsuits. Nothing will happen.

  • @chroma1004
    @chroma1004 Год назад +2

    Adding an Easter eggs on your product makes it good idea for IP checking against companies or some individual who didn't check their homework.

  • @KittyxKult
    @KittyxKult Год назад +1

    Dbrand was SO smart about this. Those Easter Eggs are gonna tear casetify’s ass up.

  • @aidanmay1148
    @aidanmay1148 Год назад +41

    Charlie being more reliable than the news. As always

    • @TjallieBrrr
      @TjallieBrrr Год назад

      Well to be fair the homeless crack addict claiming to be hungry but doesnt want food, only money, is more reliable then damn near any news outlet

    • @corbeaudejugement
      @corbeaudejugement Год назад +8

      he's literally reading the news

    • @cj-3810
      @cj-3810 Год назад +4

      He’s literally just reading a news article?!?

    • @renaub4340
      @renaub4340 Год назад +2

      braindead fan spotted

    • @Zorgot.
      @Zorgot. Год назад +1

      fr, always love him for it

  • @SKXMANE
    @SKXMANE Год назад +7

    Grass is a plant with narrow leaves growing from the base. A common kind of grass is used to cover the ground in a lawn and other places. Grass gets water from the roots in the ground. Grasses are monocotyledon, herbaceous plants.
    The grasses include the "grass", of the family Poaceae (also called Gramineae). Also sometimes it is used to include the sedges (Cyperaceae) and the rushes (Juncaceae). These three families are not closely related but belong to different clades in the order Poales. They are similar adaptations to a common life-style.
    The true grasses include cereals, bamboo and the grasses of lawns (turf) and grassland. Uses for graminoids include food (as grain, sprouted grain, shoots or rhizomes), drink (beer, whisky), pasture for livestock, thatching thatch, paper, fuel, clothing, insulation, construction, sports turf, basket weaving and many others.
    Many grasses are short, but some grasses, like bamboo can grow very tall. Plants from the grass family can grow in many places, even if they are very cold or very dry. Several other plants that look similar but are not members of the grass family are also sometimes called grass; these include rushes, reeds, papyrus, and water chestnut.
    Grasses are an important food for many animals, like deer, buffalo, cattle, mice, grasshoppers, caterpillars, and many other grazers. Unlike other plants, grasses grow from the bottom, so when animals eat grass they usually do not destroy the part that grows. Without grass, dirt can wash away into rivers (erosion).
    Graminoids include some of the most versatile plant life-forms. They became widespread toward the end of the Cretaceous. Fossilized dinosaur dung (coprolites) have been found containing grass phytoliths (silica stones inside grass leaves). Grasses have adapted to conditions in lush rain forests, dry deserts, cold mountains and even intertidal habitats, and are now the most widespread plant type. Grass is a valuable source of food and energy for many animals.
    Lawn grass is often planted on sports fields and in the area around a building. Sometimes chemicals and water is used to help lawns to grow.
    People have used grasses for a long time. People eat parts of grasses. Corn, wheat, barley, oats, rice and millet are cereals, common grains whose seeds are used for food and to make alcohol such as beer.
    Sugar comes from sugar cane, which is also a plant in the grass family. People have grown grasses as food for farm animals for about 4,000 years. People use bamboo to build houses, fences, furniture and other things. Grass plants can also be used as fuel, to cover roofs, and to weave baskets.
    In English, the word "grass" appears in several phrases. For example:
    "The grass is always greener on the other side" means "people are never happy with what they have and want something else."
    "Don't let the grass grow under your feet" means "Do something".
    "A snake in the grass" is about a person that will not be honest and will trick others.

    • @drunkenhobo8020
      @drunkenhobo8020 Год назад

      Roughly 50% of the calories consumed by humans are grasses.

    • @SKXMANE
      @SKXMANE Год назад

      @@drunkenhobo8020 fr

    • @SKXMANE
      @SKXMANE Год назад

      @My_pfp_beats_all_dog_breeds. Wow Sherlock, thanks for spotting that one

    • @SKXMANE
      @SKXMANE Год назад

      @My_pfp_beats_all_dog_breeds. So was your reply dude

    • @SKXMANE
      @SKXMANE Год назад

      @My_pfp_beats_all_dog_breeds. 💀

  • @thedeadkid5515
    @thedeadkid5515 Год назад +8

    It's a smart idea to place hidden references to your own company so that way if someone tries to steel it, it would be really difficult to hide it. Probably an unintentional save by Dbrand designers, they should be given a rise.

    • @halogeek3784
      @halogeek3784 Год назад +4

      It's completely intentional. Almost all industries do this in some way or another.

  • @darkithnamgedrf9495
    @darkithnamgedrf9495 Год назад

    Reminds me of how maps and dictionaries will have fake words/places to essentially watermark their work and prove if someone has copied their stuff

  • @pieguy311
    @pieguy311 Год назад +1

    Always sign your work. Maybe even hide your signature is your art

  • @datankz2498
    @datankz2498 Год назад +12

    so glad to have been there on stream

  • @Metal_Maxine
    @Metal_Maxine Год назад +6

    I've never bought anything from dBrand but I really appreciate their dark sense of humour on their website and their sponsorship of Linus Tech Tips is a lesson in passive-aggressive behaviour.

  • @nikt12
    @nikt12 Год назад +4

    Yep this is an easy lawsuit win.
    Those easter eggs is kinda what programmers do to "mark" or "sign" their code, protecting it from theft.
    When you build a program for a major company as a contractor, and you specify thay YOU own the code,it cannot be edited or replicated without your consent... what you Need to do is add a few useless code blocks ( which if deleted will break the App) that don't really do anything practical except spell out your name, spit out debug log with your initials,etc.
    So if a company desides to steal or not pay you, you have proof to sue

  • @chezthegreat
    @chezthegreat 9 месяцев назад +1

    Castifiy must be the glass.

  • @nick.100
    @nick.100 Год назад +3

    Guys give them a break it was only a oopsie poopsie

  • @JoshLeitzel
    @JoshLeitzel Год назад +7

    Utterly baffling. It seems like it would take way less time and effort to simply make your own scan! Good timing cause I was teetering on buying one of their Evangelion cases. 😮‍💨 dbrand gets a W for this one.

    • @JoshLeitzel
      @JoshLeitzel Год назад

      @@ダルマック looking at the situation, you’re probably right

  • @thsudy
    @thsudy Год назад +7

    So you’re telling me a Chinese company is stealing ideas? No way!!!

  • @Voodoofairy88
    @Voodoofairy88 Год назад +2

    They've been accused of ripping off independent artists artwork for years so are we surprised they decided to rip off another case makers art?

  • @dulltimes8905
    @dulltimes8905 Год назад

    matt miming behind charlie while he does the ad read is the best part of this video

  • @cotyton
    @cotyton Год назад +4

    I say this is great publicity for dbrand as well, never heard of them before this but now I'm just full on supporting them, those cases look cool af

  • @cagxplays9602
    @cagxplays9602 Год назад +2

    Casetify is literally just a drop shipping business that took off, there isn't a single ounce of originality in any of their products, they have suppliers, they don't even make it themselves.