THE VINTAGE LENS CLUB Guide to Canon FD, Leica R and Contax Zeiss

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 425

  • @ajaxfilms
    @ajaxfilms 11 месяцев назад +3

    Thank you. Great comparison. Love that you left the shots long enough to really see the images and not a bunch of quick flashy cuts.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  11 месяцев назад +2

      No point doing it otherwise! Thanks for watching 🙏🏼

  • @raksh9
    @raksh9 3 года назад +5

    60 second film school making 60 minute videos. This is so well written and presented.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Went a bit over my allotted time with this one 🤪

  • @theothermarkwilliams
    @theothermarkwilliams 2 года назад +14

    My god, this is such an amazing video. I've never seen anyone compare these three "vintage" lenses back-to-back-to-back like this. These are arguably the "big three" of vintage glass (at least at present). Just an excellent, excellent video from beginning to end. HUGELY inspiring, Ben and Jack. So grateful for your work on this.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +2

      thank you very much for watching and even more for such a lovely comment :)

  • @CraigMarshall_HDvideo4K
    @CraigMarshall_HDvideo4K Год назад +4

    Until recently, I owned nearly all the Contax primes including some of the rarer models and several zooms - all of which are vastly underrated. I loved them all but the documentary world does not wait whilst you change lenses so I sold most of them to finance a pair of stunning Sony 18-110mm servo zooms for my FS5 and FS7. The one Contax prime I kept is the coveted 21mm Distagon F/2.8 which when adapted to S35 via a Speed Booster, sees about F/1.9 at the sensor. IMO, the 21mm Distagon is one of the best wide angle lenses ever made. Little if any breathing, a 90 degree AoV with zero distortion and a front glass that does not rotate so perfect for a light weight matte box. Note also that the Contax 50mm F1.4 is soft wide open so smart money would buy the cheaper F1.7 and use a Speed Booster.

  • @Ryomichi
    @Ryomichi Год назад +2

    Your video is quite mesmerizing. Its like watching TV documentary, and fashion show, and nice things. I have to watch this twice because I forget to listen. Nice narration too.

  • @MarkHoltze
    @MarkHoltze 3 года назад +96

    Love it Ben! Very helpful to see the side by side comparisons. Also a huge fan of long format youtube videos! Bravo on the effort, execution and delivery!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +3

      Thank you Mark. Not sure how much more long form we will do, but I agree in principle! :)

    • @topicruben
      @topicruben 3 года назад

      First time here!

    • @DANAMIONLINE
      @DANAMIONLINE 2 года назад +1

      Side is the only way I can notice the nuances.

    • @sallhame
      @sallhame Год назад

      Very informative video even if I only shoot stills. But with a new mirrorless camera I'd like to use adapters and shoot movies with my old FD and Nikon manual lenses.
      Question: Why is Canon FD so popular for shooting video while Nikon manual focus lenses are not?
      And, of course I'd like to see the FD 24/1.4L, and the still cheap to get 50/1.4 SSC in a comparison like this. The last is one of my favorite lenses, even if I have the L-versions of the 24, 50 and 85mm.

    • @jmoss99
      @jmoss99 Год назад +1

      The Price most likely. Canon lenses are not that great as can be seen here. Plus there were gazillions of them made. It just happens to be what this guy owns. In fact, all the lenses happen to be what they own. These are three young guys comparing their lenses. I don't even know how scientific the comparisons are as they appear to be making changes in lighting destroying a direct comparison. If I look at these 3 frame sections it would apear to me that the Leica R has a blue green tint to it... or they adjusted the lighting. The FD guy refuses to clear the yellow from his lenses. So then what does this all mean?

  • @danienelphoto
    @danienelphoto Год назад +2

    Vintage...artisinal...organic... even when I say it, I have to roll my eyes. ... but I love these. Vintage lenses have given me back my passion for photography, after 20 years of pro shooting, and it's basically all I talk about on my channel now!
    Great video. Really like the comparisons.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад

      Thank you, glad you enjoyed it
      Will check out the channel :)

  • @ejacks3
    @ejacks3 2 года назад +8

    Great video, mate! As a photographer who has beed using CONTAX Carl Zeiss for years, it's good to see the brand get the recognition it deserves. But not too happy seeing the prices for the lenses shoot up because we are competing with film makers now for the limited supply of great lenses. 🙂 Glad I picked up my stable of lenses years ago. Appreciate your effort. Keep up the GREAT WORK!!!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +4

      Contax I believe are still very well priced for what you get. It really is subjective and it depends what you are looking for but Contax are the least expensive of the big three and in my opinion the best all rounders

  • @JBNL1
    @JBNL1 2 месяца назад

    Thanks ben! Loved how there are no overstatements in this video at all, very hands on from actual professionals. Instead of some youtube gearheads.

  • @damiendehorn6350
    @damiendehorn6350 3 года назад +2

    Holy shyte, this is the most comprehensive guide to the vintage lens world.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Haha. Don’t buy too many!!!!

    • @damiendehorn6350
      @damiendehorn6350 3 года назад

      @@BenandJackStudio TOOOO late for that. Already biten by the Takumar, Leica, Rollei, Tomioka, Pentax, Minolta, ....vintage bug. Its what my internet time is spent on now....😥

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      @@damiendehorn6350 yep, same!

  • @DevaStationCrew
    @DevaStationCrew 3 года назад +5

    This video is a hidden gem. There is nothing as good as this on RUclips. Appreciate the effort. I want to build my first vintage set for video work but I can't really afford the Leica R/Zeiss and I can't find any Canon FD wide lenses in my local market. Can you recommend a good budget frendly set for video? let's imagine there was no Canon/ Leica/ Zeiss option... what would be on your list ?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +2

      Oh goodness. There’s a lot to choose from. If you are really looking for a bang for your buck I would possibly be looking at some of the Soviet lenses. Maybe have a look at iron glass!

  • @linjicakonikon7666
    @linjicakonikon7666 3 года назад +6

    One of the best equipment videos I've seen. Well done 👍🌟🌟🌟

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      That's very kind, thank you. The kit speaks for itself though :)

  • @raf_raw
    @raf_raw 5 месяцев назад +1

    This is the best and most informative video I’ve ever watched on this topic on RUclips! I’m just starting out with GFX cameras and mainly focus on photography, but this video has been an absolute game-changer. The wealth of information and fascinating history about these top-notch camera makers is truly incredible. I feel so inspired and excited to dive deeper into the world of GFX cameras (with vintage lenses) thanks to this fantastic video. Keep up the amazing work!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  5 месяцев назад

      Amazing! Let me know how you get on
      I am actually looking to get a GFX 50R, just need to sell some vintage lenses to fund it!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  5 месяцев назад

      BTW you should check this one out too ruclips.net/video/mnXujc4SZhI/видео.html

  • @MattSchulze
    @MattSchulze 2 года назад +25

    Just a small correction to the Zeiss name: It is correct that before the war all Zeiss lenses were named "Carl Zeiss Jena". However, after Germany was divided after the war, the manufacture in East-Germany continued to use the "Carl Zeiss Jena" name and kept producing lenses. A new factory was established in West-Germany in the town of Oberkochen under the name of "Carl Zeiss", dropping the Jena as they were no longer located in the town of Jena. But after reunification in 1990 the Carl Zeiss AG took over the East German factory in Jena. Everything is just Carl Zeiss since then.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +2

      nice, thanks for the info :)

    • @apocryphal_man
      @apocryphal_man 2 года назад +1

      Also there is a noticeable difference between the Western German and Jena lenses (the non-Jenas are considered by most to be superior and are worth much more).

    • @MrSimonj1970
      @MrSimonj1970 Год назад +1

      Also - it's pronounced Yay-ner, not Jenner. Wetzlar is Vetzlar.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад +2

      As I said ‘I’m no expert’

    • @jimjimskimmer1935
      @jimjimskimmer1935 Год назад

      I'm a Carl Zeiss fanboy, I own the Contax, gorgeous lenses

  • @HonJazzz
    @HonJazzz 2 года назад +6

    I love vintage lenses I’m currently rocking an FD set.

  • @Democratiser
    @Democratiser 9 месяцев назад +1

    Wonderfully witty instructional video. Love it!

  • @herrreinsch
    @herrreinsch 3 года назад +2

    when the video ended at 1:03:10 I didn't wanted it to end, that was absolutely amazing work. highly appreciated.👍

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Amazing, thank you for sticking through the whole thing! Much appreciated :)

  • @chuckgliderable
    @chuckgliderable 7 месяцев назад +1

    Awesome video! Beautifully shot and written, great humour and wryness! After a 30y break in photography (film), I'm discovering 'vintage' lenses on mirrorless, and addictive is the right word! Although I seem to be at the cheaper end at this time...

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  6 месяцев назад

      Enjoy 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼♥️♥️♥️

  • @giljesusseraspe9225
    @giljesusseraspe9225 3 года назад +2

    Great video. I just acquired 2.8/50mm Silver Jena, 2.8/45 mmTessar, 2.8/28mm Distagon and I can't wait to try them out and even hunt for more.

  • @Iam-mad
    @Iam-mad 2 года назад +1

    In my young days I bought an Angenieux 180mm 1:2.3 for my F1n, the colour quality blew me off my feet, taking pictures parallel with my FD 300 2.8 SSC the slides where 2-3 stops better exposed at the same time setting, fully opened evening in the opera house, crazy good. When printing on my Fuji minilab, the colours of the Angenieux where so stable, one could shift magenta, cyan, whatever, the picture never got color biased, so stable.
    Somehow the Leica R grade colors with the Zeiss contrast if I had to describe it.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      Sounds incredible, we would love to get our hands on some Angenieux lenses!

  • @NitroHotFire
    @NitroHotFire Год назад +1

    Paul out here rocking the adult themed shirt 😝

  • @Exploredinary
    @Exploredinary 3 года назад +3

    Love hearing cinematographers discuss whether the Contax AE or MM is better. Trying to decide which 85 1.4 to get...do I want perfection/ more contrast or that old school flare/slight softness?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      I know what I would choose but its a personal taste. The AE set of Josh's are absolutely beautiful

  • @elgenyg
    @elgenyg 2 года назад +3

    I appreciate this video in so many levels

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @theCFXchannel
    @theCFXchannel 2 года назад +2

    This video is amazing!!!!!! Such high quality, I absolutely love it!
    However, there's one thing to keep in mind. At the end of the video, you compare the lenses. I definitely understand the choice to go f4 on all of them, BUT... I've heard many big cinematographers say that the real character of a lens is at full wide open. I've even heard some state that "every lens is the same starting at around f4-f5.6".
    So comparing then wide open or close to wide open would've shown their true character better I think.
    That being said, I really love this video and I'm so grateful you guys made this, don't take any of my critique as a common negative view on this video
    Cheers!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      Thank you very much for watching! Of course, critique is welcomed! I agree with you. Wide open is where the magic is, but f4 is wide open for that Contax glass so it would be totally unfair to compare them at different apertures
      I would agree that all of the lenses are sharp at f4 but you can still see the difference in the flares colour renditions etc
      Anyway, more importantly, which ones did you like best?!

  • @UnraveledJA
    @UnraveledJA Год назад +1

    Gentlemen, really appreciate this, helping me to make a decision , its the cannon for me

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад

      Awesome. Hit me up on email. Got loads of canon footage you can check out hello@benmarlow.com

    • @UnraveledJA
      @UnraveledJA Год назад

      @@BenandJackStudio mad respect, I am upgrading from my sony a7sii 8-bit to a Panasonic s5 10bit, and I know I need good glass, so this was wonderfully done, again much love!! and I will check out those footages as well

  • @douglasamarfio256
    @douglasamarfio256 Год назад +1

    Dope footage at the start. Great lineup

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  10 месяцев назад

      Thank you, that was from a bunch of different cinematograpohers who very kindly gave their footage to this project :)

  • @robertbrown4563
    @robertbrown4563 2 года назад +2

    I have been waiting for this video for so long thank you so much!! A master class in true vintage glass! Love it.. Please bring more of this to your channel.

  • @dogsgowoofwoof23
    @dogsgowoofwoof23 Месяц назад +1

    I really enjoyed this. Well done and thanks for posting.

  • @f0t0b0y
    @f0t0b0y 9 месяцев назад +1

    I just found a 35-105 FD for $45 bucks at a local antique market! No haze, no fungus. I'm freaking out! I also have way too many vintage lenses. I use them on my corporate taking head work and the client loves it more than I do. For any youths reading this wanting a 2k+ modern autofocus lens, think again and put that money towards lighting.

  • @BboyGraphicx
    @BboyGraphicx 2 года назад +1

    This was really insightful & a feast for the eyes, many thanks for making it from Cape Town South Africa

  • @lifetimesofamultiplemediam1003
    @lifetimesofamultiplemediam1003 3 года назад +6

    That was deeeeep!… Was hooked all the way through!… Gwaaanmyooots! ✊🏿

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thank you for watching it. Glad we managed to keep it entertaining

  • @harlangleeson9496
    @harlangleeson9496 2 года назад +1

    Excellent work here. Very much watched the whole thing. The honesty, intelligent feedbackm and the hard work of all the research, with the dead pan humor mixed in (the vintage hair shot) were appreciated. All worth the effort to educate a beginner like myself. Thank you.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      We are all beginners really! But thank you and we are very happy that you enjoyed it :)

  • @orangebetsy
    @orangebetsy Год назад +1

    Great piece of work! I used a Leicina Super super 8 for a while. Now i have a Canon 1014 and i wish i could take off the 7-70mm and put it on my C100

  • @dutchvideoshooter
    @dutchvideoshooter 3 года назад +3

    Great video!! I love my FD set! I don't have the unicorns but the mid range and the cheap 55 F1.2 . It is just amazing and I shot a 48H short film with it last weekend. Even used the 135 F2.5 wide open 😍

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Sounds like an incredible set of lenses! Let us know where we can see the film :)

  • @HiddenOaksMedia
    @HiddenOaksMedia 3 года назад +4

    This was the video that put me on the addicting hunt for Leica Rs. I’ve just completed a set finally. 19v2, 24, 35, 50, 90, 135, and now the 28-90mm.
    The prices even since this video have exploded much higher. Imagine how many people are coming for these now with the future of lidar autofocus. I feel I’ve just slipped under the gate before it closed. Thanks Ben.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      I totally agree. We did the same, bought up FDs, Leica's (same ones as you!) and Contax. Will be storing them safe and occasionally using them!

    • @magiccarpetrider4594
      @magiccarpetrider4594 2 года назад

      I’ve had ALL those lenses on Leica R bodies. The 90 was the only stellar one. Also the 19, but it mechanically failed on me. The rest aren’t that special. I’m now on Canon using the full kit of Zeiss lenses. I’ve even got it converted Contax Zeiss 24- 85 with full EOS coupling.

    • @HiddenOaksMedia
      @HiddenOaksMedia 2 года назад

      @@magiccarpetrider4594 I use the 90 and 19 mostly. The 50 I’m actually not a fan of. The later 35s are really nice. But we’re talking about using these on digital here

    • @magiccarpetrider4594
      @magiccarpetrider4594 2 года назад

      @@HiddenOaksMedia come to think of it, I had the 60mm (macro?) and 35 f2. The 24 was good I suppose, but I sold them all off for child support. 😖 I learned after that, that I’m a 28 and 50 lover. The Zeiss 28 is the closest you’ll find to the Hollywood. 35, to me, is boring as can be. The Zeiss 25 and 15 are the best architectural lenses ever, maybe next to the Hasselblad SWC. 50 love is the right lens design; the classic 50 1.4 ZE was horrid, with the same jittery bokeh up close and wide open, but the Milvus fixed that. The 50 and 100 makro planars are stellar beyond any Leica lens I ever had.

  • @AndreFernandesMovies
    @AndreFernandesMovies 3 года назад +3

    Realli liked the video. I became really interested in these lenses because of the
    CREAMY RENDERING

  • @jordanh2710
    @jordanh2710 7 месяцев назад +1

    Great video guys, it’s helped me so much in picking which vintage lenses I wanted to buy! I was just wondering which version of the 24mm Canon FD was used in the video? I haven’t got one myself yet and I was hoping it might be the F2 🙏

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  7 месяцев назад

      24 f2 👍🏼

    • @jordanh2710
      @jordanh2710 7 месяцев назад

      @@BenandJackStudio great news, thanks mate. You’ve just saved me 10 grand 😂

  • @OuTsiDE_tHeBoX-qz9ps
    @OuTsiDE_tHeBoX-qz9ps Год назад +1

    hey, great one hour content, very inspiring, thx!

  • @oceansidesounddesign8770
    @oceansidesounddesign8770 3 года назад +7

    What an amazing video. Appreciate the effort. Simply the best review of these lenses I've seen. Just getting into the vintage lens market and this was invaluable. Even the candid commentary at the last section was brilliant. Massive thank you from Australia.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      You're welcome, thank you for watching and good luck building your set!!!!

  • @patrickstroh8
    @patrickstroh8 2 года назад +1

    Thank you so very much for putting this together! This is unbelievable and your analysis is absolutely incredible! Thank you for everything you do for filmakers and enthusiastic alike! The history as well is absolutely amazing!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      You’re welcome Patrick. Glad you enjoyed it and got something out of it :)

  • @julioandres4215
    @julioandres4215 2 года назад +1

    @Ben and Jack Studio Thank you so much for this video! I always get back to it and learn new things. I was wondering, if there a particular focus rings of good quality that you recommend for the canon FDs. Looking at many options, but would love to get your insight on this!

  • @jcsuarez8970
    @jcsuarez8970 Год назад +1

    Excellent video, guys, but I wonder why they didn't include the Helios 44-2 in this video, being a lens that has been used in many movies?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад +1

      Because it was a zeiss contax, Leica r and FD comparison
      There is some helios footage in the video but that’s not the focus of the comparison

  • @carbonejack
    @carbonejack Год назад +1

    Super video. I love the FDs.

  • @EmileModesitt
    @EmileModesitt 3 года назад +1

    So much useful information in one place, and entertaining to boot! Thank you!

  • @GuernB2
    @GuernB2 11 месяцев назад

    I have been very much enjoying your videos since I found your channel. I appreciate your vibe and vision, and the way you share your process with the viewer in this interesting first person fov.
    Would you mind sharing some of the thing you are doing in post to get your video footage to match the look and feel of the film shots? The bloom and halation effects look really good.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  11 месяцев назад

      Thank you. This is all in the lenses!
      However, I definitely recommend that you check out dehancer. It’s far and away the best film emulation tool there is. And we can get you a discount :)
      Dehancer
      BJSTUDIO10
      Thanks again for the comment 🙏🏼♥️

  • @terencemorrissey4413
    @terencemorrissey4413 Год назад +1

    Great video.

  • @damiendehorn6350
    @damiendehorn6350 3 года назад +3

    Just wow, a full long form comparison of the top 3 vintage lens brands. Really well done and highly entertaining too.
    I thought the guy’s at media division had it covered but direct comparisons, had to watch it 3 times.
    Now all I need is someone to do a similar long form video about lower priced vintage lenses, Pentax K, Minolta, Zeiss Jena, Topcon, Tomiokas etc as alternatives. Or a video about Russian glass.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thank you so very much for watching it! That’s impressive to put up with those terrible jokes three times! Thanks again and we hope it was helpful for you

  • @Sam-em1ic
    @Sam-em1ic Год назад +1

    Very eye opening. I'm trying to put together a set for a low budget feature and I think I might go with a combination, as certain ones are definitely stronger at different focals (the 50mm contax blew me away). They seem very able to be matched together for the most part

  • @ScottClintonPhotography
    @ScottClintonPhotography 3 года назад +2

    Well done gents... Very much enjoyed it!

  • @NickVago
    @NickVago 3 года назад +3

    Great video! Thank you for taking the time to give us that valuable information. I recently purchased a Contax Zeiss 28mm 2.8 and had it cine modded. I absolutely love it. I'm looking at picking up the 35 & 50 in 1.4.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +2

      Nice! The contax lenses are beautiful. Good luck with the hunt!!!!

  • @terryjacob8169
    @terryjacob8169 3 года назад +2

    Excellent video. Very informative with lots of interesting insights even for stills photographers.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thank you for watching Terry, glad you liked it :)

  • @YourMovieFix
    @YourMovieFix 2 года назад +2

    Absolutely incredible video. Beautiful, informative, and you're a great host. Came here for the Leicas, stayed for all of it.
    Silly question, what cases do you use to store and transport lens?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      We still need to get our cases made, but the plan is to have a peli case with inserts for each of our sets. We use case-design.co.uk

  • @atwistedlens
    @atwistedlens 2 года назад +1

    I have a chrome nose 50mm FD that I picked up last year and I love the pastel look I get in the bokeh.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      We love a chrome nose. Jack particularly. Enjoy!

  • @Djonatable
    @Djonatable 3 года назад +2

    Oh well I guess my addiction is coming back.. Thanks for the great content!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      We do our best not to enable. Sometimes it is unavoidable. Thank you for watching :)

  • @robertmuhammad8842
    @robertmuhammad8842 3 года назад +1

    Great work. Thank you for taking the time to do this. Thanks to your mates as well for contributing. I’m at the beginning of my vintage lens journey. I decided that I want lenses to bring a little something more to the party than just sharpness. I appreciate your insights. Very helpful.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      So pleased you found it helpful Robert, good luck with the set building!!!

  • @alanvidot344
    @alanvidot344 3 года назад +1

    Love this!! I went the canon FD route, 24, 35, 50, 55 and 85 with the 35mm f2 being the only one that isn't ssc but nFD. I always wondered how the compared to Zeiss and Leica and being able to see them side by side was awesome!! Correct with the EF modding. My 24, 35 and 50 were done at The Lens Doctor in 2020, the 55 and 85 will be the kit mount version through Simmod in collab with Ed Mika, which I have purchased this week, so eagerly awaiting the kits!!

    • @firstnamelastname9955
      @firstnamelastname9955 3 года назад +3

      Just fyi: all of the nFD lenses have the S.uper S.pectra C.oating, except for the nFD 50mm f/1.8
      If you want a better way to distinguish between the newer and the older fd lenses, most people refer to the older lenses (non-nFD) as breach-lock.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Pretty sure the nfd have the SSC coating :)
      Look forward to seeing your results with the FDs!

  • @harryvasutabu5523
    @harryvasutabu5523 Год назад +1

    Zeiss looked the best for me, joint third for canon and Leica

  • @alexmirza5210
    @alexmirza5210 11 месяцев назад +1

    Genius video. I wish I could get hold of a sony-zeiss 50mm f1.4 ZA for FE. I mean it's around 5 years old, doesn't that make it ..vintage already? But for a true timeless modern classic lens, a zeiss 135mm apo sonnar is technical perfection in a silky metal body. I don't have any older zeiss or leica lens, but I do have a very bashed up FD 300mm f2.8L. That one is the extent of my actual vintage "collection".

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  10 месяцев назад +1

      any collection is better than none!
      The Zeiss lenses are absolutely beautiful :)

  • @harryvasutabu5523
    @harryvasutabu5523 Год назад +1

    This will be a resource for me

  • @alesterleong249
    @alesterleong249 2 года назад +1

    You are amazing for making this an educational yet practical and truly a fun to watch video. Can’t thank you enough and excited to see more of these. 🤟🏻❤️

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      You are amazing for watching it! Thank you we’re very pleased you enjoyed it

  • @ultrageeky1
    @ultrageeky1 3 года назад +9

    More of this, PLEASE! Phenomenal video. Loved every second of it. Incredible to see the side-by-side comparison of all three classic lenses. Never seen that before. And so expertly done. If you could do something with Mamiya-Sekor lenses, that would be freaking amazing. Thank you for this dope ass video.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      I'll get hunting! Thanks Allen

    • @damiendehorn6350
      @damiendehorn6350 3 года назад

      Trying my hand at Mamyia glass now. Which would you recommend?

  • @GlitteratiLive
    @GlitteratiLive 3 года назад +1

    Lovely, thank you. Any idea why Konica is always kept out of the scope for content like this?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +2

      Thank you for watching :)
      Konica is included in the intro. In terms of comparisons, we don't have any Konicas, have never used them and therefore can't really compare or comment on them
      If I had the money we would own a set of all of the big name vintage lenses and I would do nothing but comparisons! Sadly, we are not there yet

  • @tonytenpound
    @tonytenpound 3 года назад

    I literally had no prior knowledge of lenses of any type, but I very much enjoyed watching this video! 👍

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      They’re game changers. Which were your favourite?

  • @Analogbrain
    @Analogbrain 2 года назад +1

    Great work, and a very nice video! I've seen a lot of lens comparisons, but this one stands out.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      Amazing, great to hear, glad you enjoyed it :)

  • @mosswareproaudio6328
    @mosswareproaudio6328 Год назад +3

    I think I heard you say that someone had recommended you put your yellowed lens out in the sun to deyellow it. DON'T. That will heat up your lens and cause the grease in the lens to begin to outgas which will forever fog your lens. Heat is bad for your lens. Around here I do silk screening of front panels. I use a UV lamp to expose the emulsion through a negative. I have a lot of radioactive lenses.
    For the lenses, what I did without hurting a lens was get a step ladder, hang a brooder lamp through the middle with a CFL UV lamp in it. This was in my garage where it is cool. Then get a mirror out and lay it on the ground facing up. Then get your first lens, check that the rear lens does not extend to a point where it will allow the lens to touch the mirror. If it does you will scratch the coating on the rear lens. Then face the lens up toward the light as you lay it down on the mirror. Adjust the brooder lamp with the power cord, so that it is about 8 inches above the lens. You will not need to turn the lens over. The mirror will reflect the UV back up into the lens. You can keep an eye on the temperature of the lens using a thermometer gun. For me it took about 10 hours, but this depends on your setup. Keep in mind that sometimes the lens coating might goldish and look like yellowing. There should be an area between the lens and the CFL that will let air flow and keep things cool. Use a mirror, not aluminum foil, as the mirror will be smooth and flat.
    If you have any questions, message me back.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  10 месяцев назад +1

      It was the suggestion that UV light comes from the sun. The best way to do it is with a UV lamp and a bit of tin foil :)

    • @jimmoss9584
      @jimmoss9584 10 месяцев назад +1

      Tin foil is not flat and can scratch the coating if you are not careful. Take that mirror you use for your drugs and clean it off and use that instead of the foil. If you scratch the coating on your 1970s lens you will be saying, "man, this lens came to me all across time and I scratched it." Of course, then you will try to hide the lens with the damage from your friends there. Ooh the shame. Oh the shame.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  10 месяцев назад

      @@jimmoss9584 ok 👌🏼

  • @oncameramastery
    @oncameramastery 3 года назад +1

    I use loads of old glass, mainly M42 screwfit stuff and Pentax K mount stuff. I got into it mainly because I cant afford anything brand new, and I use a Pentax DSLR for RUclips, not a great video camera, but the entire range of Pentax/Takumar going back decades is available to me, either native K mount, or with just a cheapo K to m42 adaptor! :-) I'm not seriously suggesting people buy Pentax bodies for filming, but pentax/takumar lenses adapt easily to Sony. I also recently jumped on the Helios 44 2 bandwagon and absolutely love it! :-)

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Absolutely, A full set of primes for a fair bit under 1000, amazing value!!!! Keep up the good work!!!

  • @LensofWyant
    @LensofWyant 2 года назад +2

    Love that real time post edit commentary lol

  • @user-nc4if1nv1f
    @user-nc4if1nv1f 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for taking the time . . very helpful : )

  • @AlbertKarhuFilms
    @AlbertKarhuFilms 3 года назад +1

    I loved every second of this video! This old lens thing is new to me, i just bought a Sony A7SII few weeks ago and started experimenting with old lenses but im SO hooked i just wanna buy more lenses that inpire me to grab my camera. I think this will lead to a bankrupt and/or divorce but what the heck the journey is worth it. I know it is. It will be, right?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      I haven't been thrown out yet!
      Yet
      Glad to hear you enjoyed the film :) Let us know what lenses you get!

  • @bobceffo
    @bobceffo 3 года назад +1

    enjoying the infos and, collateral damage...
    your video!
    what a beautiful lightning!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thanks Roberto, mostly down to Paul Cook re the lighting. Amazing DOP

  • @chrispickett6069
    @chrispickett6069 3 года назад +2

    Outstanding video , so glad I stumbled on this, beautifully filmed and entertaining - I am a Leica R stills guy and really enjoyed this - would love it if you could offer more info on the guy who made the lens adapters and caps
    thank-you

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Of course. Email Gary, he makes exquisite caps info@countrystarproductions.com

  • @chrisbeard9113
    @chrisbeard9113 2 месяца назад

    Side by side lens comparisons for me seem to show how arbitrary the differences are. Artistically you can create great photography and cinematography on almost any lens brand and any budget, but when you have experience seeing through your lenses day after day for thousands of images, you really appreciate those small differences. I think that’s what the cameraman wants to convey, is that personal love for the images they create, and being really in love with your lenses and comfortable with their dynamics can boost your ability to create as an artist. Those FD lenses looked great, however the contax does it for me, especially with the background bokeh, and being more forgiving to my photography. I love the old nikkor glass and canon FL but I find them to be good only in certain situations compared to all the other great glass out there. We are lucky to live in a time we can pick and choose what we like and find affordable options

  • @chrisbanbury
    @chrisbanbury 2 года назад +1

    Love the shameless gear xploitation and lurid lens handling 👀

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      I don't even know what this means but it sounds amazing. Thanks for watching

  • @vissentetapiacuevas5814
    @vissentetapiacuevas5814 Год назад +1

    Hola, buen video, una consulta ¿Que cámara usaron para grabar las tomas al final del video?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад

      Gracias
      usamos sony a7s3 para el comienzo y RED para la comparación

  • @contaxpaulharrison942
    @contaxpaulharrison942 3 года назад +1

    You do get ninja stars on some of the yashica lenses. Perhaps not surprising as they came out of the same factory as some of the contax lenses. The zeiss contax you are reviewing are the Contax / Yashica (C/Y) manual focus lens mount, there were also separate lens lines for the G series AF rangefinders, and Contax 645 AF Medium Format SLR, and the N series AF SLR's.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      I love me a ninja star ⭐️

    • @contaxpaulharrison942
      @contaxpaulharrison942 3 года назад +1

      @@BenandJackStudio I did toy with the idea of doing a video on the Contax / Yashica lenses that ninja star, number of stars different degrees of it etc. I suspect that is a bit beyond my video skills, and there are rather a lot of them.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      @@contaxpaulharrison942 would be great to see 😍

  • @bloodswarms
    @bloodswarms 2 года назад +1

    Just found you. Smashing channel! Liked and subscribed.

  • @vasya_v_
    @vasya_v_ 2 года назад +1

    1:50 awesome shot!, What the FD lense used there?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      Thanks!!! It was a very long time ago so I can’t be sure but I have a feeling it may even have been an old Vivitar FD 24mm

  • @ulhasarolkar
    @ulhasarolkar 3 года назад +4

    Thanks for sharing your knowledge

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +2

      You’re very welcome. First time anyone has ever suggested we have knowledge so double thank you 🙏🏼

  • @jeremymolinari6597
    @jeremymolinari6597 2 года назад +1

    ... dammit I was happy with my contax zeiss set.
    But deer god and his majestic antlers, I... I think I might need a set of Canon FD's. All gorgeous, gorgeous lenses, but for the price I'm pretty much sold. Thank you for doing such an in depth test! You've earned a subscription from me sirs.

  • @romain_do
    @romain_do 3 года назад +1

    that is beautiful !!! thanks for taking the time to make this

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thanks for taking the time to watch it!!!!

    • @romain_do
      @romain_do 3 года назад

      @@BenandJackStudio of course. Watched it while browsing eBay to get me some contax haha

  • @masoomehtanghatari8750
    @masoomehtanghatari8750 2 года назад +1

    you are the best and the cutest man I have watched review from. God bless you

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching. This is the best and cutest comment :)

  • @Scriptfella
    @Scriptfella 3 года назад +1

    Inspiring stuff, Ben, thank you. I was very happy with my Contax Zeiss lenses but now you've got me Jonesing for some Leica R glass. Will this obsession ever end...

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +2

      DO IT DO IT DO IT !

    • @smallbrownfox594
      @smallbrownfox594 3 года назад +1

      You’re entering the vortex - don’t worry, there are a few of us in there already...

    • @Scriptfella
      @Scriptfella 3 года назад +1

      @@BenandJackStudio It was that outdoor shot you took with the blonde actress - the way the Leica glass renders the blacks and caresses the skin tones....

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      @@Scriptfella when it comes to flattering skin tones, the leicas are in pole position I think

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      @@smallbrownfox594 see you there 👌🏼

  • @f0t0b0y
    @f0t0b0y 9 месяцев назад

    54:15 FD looks amazing!

  • @davidheadonvisualsandsound
    @davidheadonvisualsandsound 2 года назад

    My Tamron 135 f3.8 Adaptall ( mid 70s? ) has 'ninja-star' blades, unlike earlier Tamrons with 8 smooth blades.
    An amazing and informative video! I have a huge number of 50-58mm primes, and my Cannon 55mm f1.4 S.S.C. is incredible, close to the Tomioka made 55mm f1.4, which looks like an even sharper Zeiss Planar- but as yousay, much warmer in colour temp.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching david. That 55 is beautiful
      Glad your Tamron has the stars too ⭐️

    • @davidheadonvisualsandsound
      @davidheadonvisualsandsound 2 года назад

      MyTmoioka 55 mm F 1.4 is badged 'Super Reflecta', is identical to the Porst Clour Auto, and Sears Auto, one of the most desirable 55s.. I have also got a 50mm f 1.8 super takumar, it is radioactive enough to warm my hands over🤓.
      I've done the opposite way and not collected a matching set from anyone supplier, aside from Tokina, I have probably got around 30 different tokina lenses dating from the early 60s to the late 70s. Love them to bits🤓

  • @mattsiiteri4366
    @mattsiiteri4366 3 года назад +2

    this is incredible. Exactly what I was looking for. Subbed and looking forward to your next stuff! btw which camera was used?

  • @aodhbreathnach7298
    @aodhbreathnach7298 Год назад

    Thank you for the great video. Do you know of anywhere in the UK selling DIY Canon FD to EF conversion kits?

  • @finnflachsmann8474
    @finnflachsmann8474 2 года назад +1

    awesome video man

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      Thanks Finn. Hope you got something out of it :)

  • @ricciocamposfilms1017
    @ricciocamposfilms1017 3 года назад +1

    Wow this is worth watching 👍👍👍. Love the Leica 19mm 35mm and 50mm. That's 7K U.S. dollar . But looks like 50mm to start with or 35mm. What do you think ?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Hi Ricci. The Leica's are beautiful. They have gone a bit mad with the pricing so I suppose start with what you can afford! The 50mm and 135mm are probably the cheapest Leica's around at the moment :)
      Let us know how you get on!!!

  • @wisun
    @wisun 3 года назад +1

    Fantastic job. I appreciate it very much. I have a set of Contax Zeiss which I mix it at times with Yashica ML's. I have to say that I'm really surprised about how well they match. Do you have any experience to share about it? Given the shared story between both brands, it doesn't surprise me.
    Have you ever compared Leica R's and Minolta Rokkor's? I've heard rumors that some focals are almost the same in terms of sharpness and colour rendition. Again, any experience about it?

    • @mariuszach1344
      @mariuszach1344 3 года назад +1

      The Minolta 35-70/3.5 and the Minolta MC 24/2.8 (not MD!) are identical to the corresponding Leica R lenses. Leica might have changed coatings but the optical calculation is the same.

    • @damiendehorn6350
      @damiendehorn6350 3 года назад

      Minolta had a sharing agreement with Leica, the Minolta 35-70 3.5 is a sonar design while Leica R 24mm 2.8 is a copy of Minolta 24mm 2.8 MD2. Minolta also used Leica body design for their MD3 range of lenses.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Awesome, thank you! I would love to get my hands on some! Maybe one day...

  • @stevechang2135
    @stevechang2135 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for the great video. Learned a lot. In your view, what is the most useful Leica R focal length on your Komodo, besides the 19mm?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад +1

      We do t really use the 19 all that much. The 35 is beautiful. And the 90. They’re the two we’ve used the most for sure

    • @stevechang2135
      @stevechang2135 2 года назад +1

      @@BenandJackStudio Enjoyed your channel a lot. Thank you for sharing all these.

  • @aybee5908
    @aybee5908 2 года назад +1

    Big shoutout for this comparison. Wish you had the Pentax Takumar series, too. Do you have a good address for cinemodding FD-lenses?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      I wish we had takumars too!!! Where are you based?

    • @aybee5908
      @aybee5908 2 года назад

      @@BenandJackStudio I´m based in Europe (Germany). I own a set of Super Takumars (28mm 3.5, 35mm 2.0, 50mm 1.4, 85mm 1.9).
      It`s not too easy to declick them, so I´m not really sure to do it by myself.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  2 года назад

      @@aybee5908 ok, send me an email. I will let you know your options hello@benmarlow.com

  • @MB-or8js
    @MB-or8js 3 года назад +1

    Great video! Of the lenses mentioned, I am only having FD lenses. Regarding Leica, I am vested in M-mount lenses which were not covered here because they likely don't adapt to the RED camera for videos where you need SLR-type lenses.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Ooh I be they are lovely those Leica Ms. Exactly right. The Leica R lenses are the best for adapting to video/cinema cameras :)

  • @dna8269
    @dna8269 3 года назад +2

    Amazing work! Thank you so much for this and the comparisons. Contax vs Leica is a tough choice!

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Yeah the poor little FDs don't really get a look in. I still love them but the Contax and the leicas are just a cut above! Thank you for watching :)

  • @yeahyeahyaha2
    @yeahyeahyaha2 2 года назад +1

    Wonderfil video! Thanks for the effort

  • @CraigMarshall_HDvideo4K
    @CraigMarshall_HDvideo4K Год назад +1

    As for de-clicking Contax primes: I did them all myself then ended up 're-clicking' them all. Why? Answer: Sony's FS5, FS7 Mk II and FX6 with their unique 'floating' internal electronic ND filter: simply choose each lens' sweet spot - say, about F8 then let the camera's ND set your exposure whilst you worry about focus & framing.

  • @nothingaroundus_
    @nothingaroundus_ 2 года назад +1

    This is some quality content right here
    Thanks very much

  • @ModernVintageFilm
    @ModernVintageFilm 3 года назад +1

    It took so long to put this together but the outcome wasn't very high unfortunately. Fantastic production quality.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      I don't really understand the comment but thank you for watching!

    • @ModernVintageFilm
      @ModernVintageFilm 3 года назад +3

      @@BenandJackStudio This deserves 2m+ views.

  • @rodolphenavarro4253
    @rodolphenavarro4253 3 года назад

    Wahoo superbe vidéo pour tous les amoureux des objectifs vintage.Pour ceux qui veulent essayer , on peut se faire plaisir avec des objectifs bien moins onéreux que les objectifs zeiss ou Leica .Mon objectif préféré est un pentacon 50 mm F1,8 que j'ai payé 15 euros.C' 'est une première étape découverte que je crois nécessaire pour essayer avant de faire des investissements plus importants.Very very nice vidéo , very very good job.Tks ..

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад +1

      Oui. il existe de nombreuses options moins chères. et ils sont de bonne qualité aussi
      Thank you for watching :)

  • @CoutoCameraCompany
    @CoutoCameraCompany 3 года назад

    Absolutely incredible!!! Ben, you did right by these lenses.

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  3 года назад

      Thank you Ben. The lenses are the real stars here 🤟🏼

  • @goo-o8g
    @goo-o8g Год назад

    Amazing stuff. I'm just curious why I don't normally see equivalent discussions or content for older Nikon's. Are they inferior or just not as sought after compared to these other three brands given their role in more film and video productions? Because personally I love my Nikkor AIS lenses for video work.
    I guess part of my question is also - is it risky to build up a set of nice Nikkor primes for video work as I move into higher end work? Are companies just that much more inclined to hire on for Leica, Zeiss or Canon FD?

    • @BenandJackStudio
      @BenandJackStudio  Год назад

      If I had a set, I would have done!
      They are definitely not inferior! And probably a fair bit cheaper!