I think the sudden ending almost leaves you open because it is supposed to mean it is the end of one revolution, however there will always be another one. Not many countries have one revolution, a revolution is not permanent.
@@moonwalkinmyers3431 I don't know if I'm crazy, but I hear the ending as C: IV iv Isus4 I. given the C major chords some bars before. obviously it could also be the V of F minor, but I hear C as the root, even with the descending line obviously saying C7 to F. I hear it as a I IV I. Anyone else hears it that way?
@@sebastianlionelmartinez6305 I am not the greatest when it comes to music theory (I am still learning) but you are probably right- the chord does not sound like it comes from nowhere, yet it still has tension or a feeling of incompleteness when listening to the whole piece
@@sebastianlionelmartinez6305 C is the root in the ending, and you are correct in that assertion. That iv is a borrowed chord from the parallel minor and the Isus4 usually functions as a subdominant due to the perfect fourth it has which makes it sound like a IV^6/4 that wants to resolve the fourth degree of the scale to the third degree found in a I
I agree the ending is strange, but this recording I’ve linked below does it very tastefully in my opinion, I think it works very well if executed properly! ruclips.net/video/Y6RIwVi1Mjs/видео.htmlfeature=shared
The best revolutionary etude i heard👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻most pianists rush this etude. This one is PERFECT Thank you bravo
omg this is really hard but i live this piece. im actually going to start working on this..
0:50
Why is nobody commenting on this? :/
I think others are having trouble viewing it
Angelo B. still, 3K people viewed this and not a single comment on how brilliantly the young man played this
TheGreenPianist -- Yup. It deserves more praise.
Nice channel btw.
Angelo B. oh thanks :)
i think this is overshadowed by Liu and Fialkowska's videos that presents his whole etude repertoire
the piece is just incredible but the end is a bit strange
I think the sudden ending almost leaves you open because it is supposed to mean it is the end of one revolution, however there will always be another one. Not many countries have one revolution, a revolution is not permanent.
@@moonwalkinmyers3431 I don't know if I'm crazy, but I hear the ending as C: IV iv Isus4 I. given the C major chords some bars before. obviously it could also be the V of F minor, but I hear C as the root, even with the descending line obviously saying C7 to F. I hear it as a I IV I. Anyone else hears it that way?
@@sebastianlionelmartinez6305 I am not the greatest when it comes to music theory (I am still learning) but you are probably right- the chord does not sound like it comes from nowhere, yet it still has tension or a feeling of incompleteness when listening to the whole piece
@@sebastianlionelmartinez6305 C is the root in the ending, and you are correct in that assertion. That iv is a borrowed chord from the parallel minor and the Isus4 usually functions as a subdominant due to the perfect fourth it has which makes it sound like a IV^6/4 that wants to resolve the fourth degree of the scale to the third degree found in a I
I agree the ending is strange, but this recording I’ve linked below does it very tastefully in my opinion, I think it works very well if executed properly!
ruclips.net/video/Y6RIwVi1Mjs/видео.htmlfeature=shared
Hardest piano bass ever
Not at all.
Haha no
Actually surprisingly not bc the right hand is awfully simple so you can focus on the left
@@philipoh9843 i agree but when u are not used to it is a way too hard to play this bass line (at least for me)
@@clmbyl3717 practice makes perfect
ik right
Jan lisiecki
I found this one of the easier etudes , still hard but most of them are harder
he wrote this for Beethoven
19k views and 21 comments lol