Alienware QD OLED AW3423DWF vs Cooler Master Tempest GP27Q. review.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 132

  • @RoiPourpre
    @RoiPourpre Год назад +6

    Amazing comparison, thank you very much for that.

  • @JoeMaranophotography
    @JoeMaranophotography Год назад +9

    I have had my GP27Q here in the UK for maybe a couple of weeks. It came with firmware 1.2 and i have to say this monitor is ASTOUNDING!!! Im replaying games and its like i've never played them before! It's that good! The only issues i spotted were minor blooming on punishing RUclips HDR and local dimming tests which are designed to show this. In real life usage - videos, games etc you arent going to see any issues in my opinion. No flickering noticed either with G Sync and local dimming. I'm very, very impressed!

    • @FrequentlyPlays
      @FrequentlyPlays Год назад

      Do you have any suggested thing to change with this monitor? I just got mine and want to know what to do and not to do to get the best experience, thanks!

    • @JoeMaranophotography
      @JoeMaranophotography Год назад

      @FrequentlyPlays Honestly I just would make sure freesync is on and then g sync in nvidia control panel. Then make sure local dimming and hdr are on. Personally I turn hdr on in windows BUT auto hdr off and use the hdr settings in each game.

    • @FrequentlyPlays
      @FrequentlyPlays Год назад

      @@JoeMaranophotography I don't seem to see a g sync option in nvidia control panel for some reason, I've turned on adaptive sync in the monitor menu though

    • @JoeMaranophotography
      @JoeMaranophotography Год назад

      @@FrequentlyPlays should be under "set up g sync"

    • @FrequentlyPlays
      @FrequentlyPlays Год назад

      @@JoeMaranophotography just done it thanks, should I have g sync and adaptive sync enabled at the same time?

  • @deminybs
    @deminybs Год назад +6

    I got the F version of the 👽 QD-OLED panel this week and it's amazing 🤩

    • @halrichard1969
      @halrichard1969 Год назад +1

      Hey me too!

    • @deminybs
      @deminybs Год назад

      @@halrichard1969 what did you upgrade from??
      I went from the 27" odyssey G7 .
      I'm also being very careful to turn it off when not being used/letting it do the pixel refresh deal when it pops up to lower chance of burn in .

    • @Bckner
      @Bckner Год назад +2

      Im getting one this week with 20% cash back

    • @monke5198
      @monke5198 Год назад

      @@Bckner how do you get 20% cashback?

    • @Bckner
      @Bckner Год назад

      @@monke5198 i actually ended up getting 29%, i had a 20% discount because i do business with dell and the other 9% came from my chase freedom card (5%) and paypal had a 4% cashback for dell products at the time

  • @kingalobaid5834
    @kingalobaid5834 Год назад +3

    perfect comparison, well done!

  • @Lawson7086
    @Lawson7086 Год назад +4

    Your OLED is actually showing black crush at 10.31 the mini LED is the one that is actually displaying the correct scene the extra stars should be displayed that's why they are there and your OLED is crushing them to the point that they cant be seen

    • @memo29b
      @memo29b Год назад

      Black crush can be fixed with calibration

    • @SlavaBagmut
      @SlavaBagmut Год назад +2

      @@memo29b go ahead and do that, but regular user won’t be doing that

  • @DOMINUS.87
    @DOMINUS.87 Год назад

    Hello, my friend. Tell me please, after a lot of tests that you did between collor master and alienware, which of the monitors shows the most beautiful and detailed picture?
    Does Alienware have a lack of brightness or is everything great?

  • @alvarg
    @alvarg Год назад

    surprisingly the ultrawide doesn't actually seem all that much wider than the cooler master panel.

    • @pietroalessandrini
      @pietroalessandrini 10 месяцев назад +1

      it's because it's a lot further back, it's far enought that it's out of focus

  • @NedimTabakovic
    @NedimTabakovic Год назад

    Thanks for this comparison, hope I wont regret 499$ for GP27Q

    • @videocardzrule354
      @videocardzrule354 Год назад +1

      How is the GP27Q? Did you get it?

    • @NedimTabakovic
      @NedimTabakovic Год назад

      @@videocardzrule354I got it and regret it at first…dead-stuck pixels but after I revived dead pixel I’m happy there is still some flicker, distortion on left and right edge of the screen, brightness fluctuation, white screen uniformity colder and warmer parts are visible on certain parts when displaying white (web-some apps...I dislike dark mod), blooming is visible if you just a bit off of axis. I was baited by "futuristic" mini-led tech and high brightness...fald transitions can’t keep up with fast movement and it creates some artifacts(minor but visible). Since revival of dead pixel I will stick with it.

    • @videocardzrule354
      @videocardzrule354 Год назад +1

      @@NedimTabakovic That’s terrible about your experience. I was so close to buying one, and ultimately I did not grab one. I did however just buy my new monitor a different model/brand, Newegg has the Aorus 48” OLED 120HZ for $500 refurb!!! I could not pass it up. Fingers crossed for when it arrives. Not as bright as these Mini LED displays in SDR, but a great display either way.

    • @NedimTabakovic
      @NedimTabakovic Год назад

      @@videocardzrule354 revived dead pixel now I have regret turned to rejoice 😍 I will edit my previous post 😉 be careful of burn-in 😊

    • @videocardzrule354
      @videocardzrule354 Год назад

      @@NedimTabakovic How do you revive a dead pixel? I have a dead pixel on my Asus 27” PG278QR

  • @Nestor.555
    @Nestor.555 Год назад +1

    Hiya, what's your impression of sdr content like movies or games with FALD on? Is there any backlight bleed like you usually see with lcd monitors? Thanks :)

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад

      You'll see more blooming than bleed with this monitor. It's minor but there. SDR is fine. Not amazing but pretty good.

  • @JayTheThugginAlien
    @JayTheThugginAlien 3 месяца назад

    Is the oled matte or glossy

  • @Elmo128
    @Elmo128 Год назад +1

    Nice Video. Thank you. =)

  • @rehzinx6874
    @rehzinx6874 Год назад +3

    Bottom one looks better to me and it's half the price

    • @korn2040
      @korn2040 Год назад +1

      Your eyes need to be checked hahahaha you can definitely see the blacks are so washed out on the bottom. The picture quality of the Alienware is far superior no comparison. You did say it looks better to you so that's subjective and if it looks amazing to you and it's what your looking for that's all you'll need and you save some money.

    • @AppIeOfficial
      @AppIeOfficial Год назад

      I have both and in person the Alienware looks way better

    • @acurisur
      @acurisur 11 месяцев назад

      @@korn2040 It's not though, there are at least 3 scenes in this comparison where the Alienware is producing too much black and reducing the amount of detail in the picture. It happens at 4:56 , 6:19 and at 10:31.
      Yes OLED is better but not on this monitor. LG are still the kings of OLED.

  • @morten1
    @morten1 Год назад

    How do you know “how the scene is supposed to be displayed”?

  • @klintbernas
    @klintbernas Год назад +1

    how is the content when viewing 16:9 on the alienware? looks like noticeably smaller than the gp27q

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад

      Congrats! Nothing is the same after going OLEd.

    • @brunojr9
      @brunojr9 Год назад +3

      16:9 on a 34' 21:9 display is the same size as 16:9 content on a 27'16:9 display like the gp

  • @Thin_Limbz
    @Thin_Limbz Год назад

    why is the top OLED screen not in Full Screen? too dull in brightness department????

    • @gustavomazzia8226
      @gustavomazzia8226 Месяц назад

      It's a ultrawide monitor displaying a 16:9 video, there will be a vertical black bar.

  • @dnsean03
    @dnsean03 Год назад +2

    The brightness is way too low on oleds though unfortunately under 200 nits 100% whites..

    • @xXYannuschXx
      @xXYannuschXx Год назад

      280 nits for this one though.

    • @dnsean03
      @dnsean03 Год назад +1

      @@xXYannuschXx still pretty low my g7 32 1440p holds 500/540 nits 100% hah

    • @Z4d0k
      @Z4d0k Год назад +1

      @@dnsean03 higher brightness isn't necessarily better. Contrast is much more important for image quality.

    • @dnsean03
      @dnsean03 Год назад +1

      @@Z4d0k your losing all the brightness when web browsing esp if its a white webpage.. it matters

    • @RyhtymFiend
      @RyhtymFiend Год назад +2

      @S M alienwares monitor has the least aggressive ABL on any oled. Anyways I dont understand you brightness junkies. I dont use any of my ips displays at more than 200 nits.

  • @sweetdeal8951
    @sweetdeal8951 Год назад

    Worth to wait for new features? Or just grab the F one? I got a Dell Deal for 1000 € (which is quite cheap for germany) so guess its a good to go?
    Is coding fine on the QDOLEDs?

    • @Peter2353654645
      @Peter2353654645 Год назад

      where did you find the deal?

    • @Peter2353654645
      @Peter2353654645 Год назад

      they told me its 1100€

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад

      I would grab it now if you need one. I don't see any game changing features coming down the pipe.

  • @dariomladenovski7047
    @dariomladenovski7047 Год назад

    did you enable FALD on the GP27Q?

  • @arturb5152
    @arturb5152 Год назад

    Price VS performance You know who Wins 🙂

  • @djayjp
    @djayjp Год назад +1

    Unfair to the LCD as the camera isn't set to the middle of the panel, so it doesn't give a good representation of what it would look like, resulting in worse black levels and contrast.

  • @znoozaros
    @znoozaros Год назад

    Lol lock your camera settings next time you do a comparison video. Auto adjusting makes it impossible to compare

  • @tomtomkowski7653
    @tomtomkowski7653 Год назад +4

    I prefer LCD because on OLED everything turns into a black blob, like here at 4:56 - zero details on this mountain on OLED, or at 6:19 - zero detail on the mane lion.
    Of course, contrast and black levels on OLED always will be better but the loss of details is huge, and I like to use a monitor and not maintain it.
    Only what we need are more dimming zones. Just imagine 5000 of them instead of 500.
    BTW - you should invest in some monitor arm, for two or better three monitors to make such comparisons better and easier to setup.

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +7

      I think what you're seeing is actually RUclips compression. The "blobs" aren't present on the actual display and certainly not with higher quality footage/games. It's all about compression.

    • @Z4d0k
      @Z4d0k Год назад +1

      @@BespokeTech the limited dynamic range of cameras is primarily what causes the crushed shadow and/or highlight details in RUclips recordings. No camera on the market can accurately record the full dynamic range of modern HDR displays.

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +2

      @@Z4d0k My camera actually does a decent job of capturing it. RUclips for some reason destroys it when it processes it though.

    • @paullucci
      @paullucci Год назад +1

      This is a video of a video, compressed for YT, and displayed on whatever kind of screen you are watching it on. Not really representative of the actual experience.

  • @potatochobit
    @potatochobit Год назад +1

    27" is too small, my friend.

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +4

      Subjective but can absolutely be true for some users.

    • @ChrisM541
      @ChrisM541 Год назад +1

      Remember, this is a monitor !! ;)

    • @axcn4733
      @axcn4733 Год назад

      potatochobit Shut up, my friend

    • @SlavaBagmut
      @SlavaBagmut Год назад

      Go ahead and get 42 inches TV idiot, if you think that’s small, but that is definitely not small for normal people

    • @Spr1ggan87
      @Spr1ggan87 Год назад +1

      Nope, 27" has the best pixel density for the 2560x1440 resolution.

  • @quolve
    @quolve Год назад +1

    that is not the gp27q, 27inch isnt as wide as an ultrawide lmao

    • @StevoHDA
      @StevoHDA Год назад +2

      he's got it in front so it looks bigger, but he's still a tar d. man blocked someone on reddit because he couldn't even read a manual

    • @danbernardi1
      @danbernardi1 Год назад +8

      It's closer to the camera, dude

    • @vertigo_one
      @vertigo_one Год назад

      @@danbernardi1 Yes but its also slanted (the AW monitor) so you're not viewing directly on and it "seems" less clear. I think side-by-side from a distance would have been better not one closer and one above at an angle.

    • @Heliosvector
      @Heliosvector Год назад +2

      @@vertigo_one Does it matter? You are viewing 2 monitors with a pixel density of 120 per inch on a compressed youtube video from an iphone recording....

  • @ChrisM541
    @ChrisM541 Год назад

    What about that MASSIVE Elephant in the room re this 'review' - WHERE IS THE PC/CONSOLE/DESKTOP/GAMING ELEMENT...THIS IS A MONITOR AFTER ALL, NOT A TV (--> That 3min(!!) video you uploaded 2 months ago is NOT A REVIEW)
    On evidence from your videos, I'm gonna call this out - you were, 100%, paid by Alienware to make that monitor appear 'better' (at >2x the GP27Q's cost !!)

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +1

      I wish Dell was sending me checks.

    • @ChrisM541
      @ChrisM541 Год назад

      @@BespokeTech Then EXPLAIN that 'review' !!

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +1

      @@ChrisM541 I'm not sure what you're asking.

    • @Bradum
      @Bradum Год назад

      You on crack dude?

  • @halrichard1969
    @halrichard1969 Год назад +4

    The top is QD OLED 3440x1440..........The Tempest is 2550x1440. Backlit cannot compete with OLED. This review seems kinda fishy. If you need this guy to man splain Monitors to you then you need to study up a bit. Also, I would watch a few more comparisons.

    • @BespokeTech
      @BespokeTech  Год назад +14

      I did a video directly comparing the two. Not sure how that's fishy. You can see it for yourself and make your own judgement.

    • @dariomladenovski7047
      @dariomladenovski7047 Год назад +3

      it absolutely can compete with OLED and it will win in bright content(which is most games/movies) and not to mention how OLED is too dim for true HDR

    • @SlavaBagmut
      @SlavaBagmut Год назад +3

      Backlit mingled absolutely CAN in fact compete with OLED. Have you even watched the video?