They are both slow talkers with long pauses, because they are thoughtful. So it sounds like they are done making a point, and then the other one feels the need to say something, and then the first one starts speaking again.
@@derek4412 that's how civilized discussions happen, now contrast it to stupidity that happens in the circus that is the elections. it almost makes the technocracy that's coming seems like justifiable, those are baboons, let the AI machines run the thing already
@@derek4412the person who's speaking gets the dopamine dump. Therefore it's difficult to listen to someone else because you're waiting to get your dopamine dump. That being said it is difficult to not talk over someone especially when you're not in person.
thanks guys, this was really interesting and fun to listen to. I commented on your last convo that the turn-taking and sharing of conversational threads was way off, this time you guys held something that felt much more contiguous, and it's appreciated. Samo's a jedi. Rudyard is a samurai.
54:00 a few years ago, someone observed that our civilizational capacity to do things- almost everything- peaked in the 1960s and early 1970s, and has steadily declined since then. With no end in sight.
The cheapskate, as it were Lively discussion...they were streaminging it, if u cudnt hear. Erbuddy had earbuds in. I kno, rite? Weird bar vibe...oh, I c now, setup like a boxing ring esthetic 😂
Great conversation. But I will push back on the Baltimore bridge getting rebuilt. They close to awarding the design contract. It should be completed in about 3 to 5 years definitely under the 10 years mentioned on this podcast
Haitian culture was successful in expanding, albeit briefly, its a culture which has effectively survived against much larger enemies. Now those counter parties are shrinking in influence, Haiti now has access to the worlds library of technologies, while maintaining a steady population. Look into the actual dynamics of the black-Afro-Caribbean-African populations will culturally adjust to these predicted global changes.
René Girard's theory about the mimetic crisis and its violent resolution with a scapegoat and the production of the sacred (culture) explains why all early civilizations appear so similar. Interestingky, like Samo, he was a European who found freedom to work in the US
during the Roman republic the Sahara was not yet desert. Desertification of the Sahara follows a circa 12k year cycle. It goes from lush to desert thanks to the stellar weather, really, which is both amazing and terrifying.
@RudyardLynch It is known from genetics now that the Americas were settled from Beringia, but also from Polynesia, and that the settlers from Beringia were basically the same people now living in East Asia/Siberia. The cultural influences were limited since culture -20k years ago was not so developed e.g. no writing yet. When Islam lost primacy it was not due to foreign invasions and corruption which was the case of Rome. Islam, like feudal China and ancient Greece lost (to a lesser extent) lost primacy due to intentional stagnation: all those innovaters are threats to the regime! They must be suppressed to maintain social stability! This has held back human progress by at least 3000 years so far.
I find it odd that Rudyard said that Joseph Campbell was a terrible writer. It may just be a ding to my ego because I am a Joseph Campbell fan, but I also wouldn't say I ever excessively struggled with his writing. His writing can be clunky and dense, but no more or less so than other scholars of his time. There have been other areas in his writing that I found to be awe inspiring.
If anything, Colombia is a Cargo Cult, is an occidentaloid country. We adopted forms, customs and rituals that we do not understand or know where they come from. We only had one military junta after the second dictator Gr. Gustavo Rojas Pinilla (the first was Simon Bolivar).
Excellent debate guys.Liked the use of hands to illustrate loss of intellect, by Samo. Reminded me of the time Maggie Thatcher used this to differentiate with socialists in the House of Commons. Effective.....
Our ppeak intelligence was around 1890, by several measure but think number of geniuses is the easiest to see. Think Dutton has covered several factors if his At Our Witts End.
An important element is the ability of black African cultures to continue stable reproduction and peaceful interaction across large distances amongst different kingdoms. If the northern hemisphere population is shrinking, there can be a brain drain to black Africa for peace and stability as a trade for the technically advanced northern hemisphere.
Im convinced we in the Usa are in a sociocultural moment closest to the year 224 AD NOT 50 BC. The republic fell long ago in the 1930s. We just don’t realize or admit it. The Romans pretended that the republic still existed well into the 3rd century, formally until emperor Diocletian in 285.
That is to say that the Republic was better than the empire, which it wasn't. Diocletian was a solidifying of the despotic faction in the ruling dynasties not actually an emperor at all but an overlord.
We are nowhere near the decadence of the empire since at least half of the public is opposed to the degeneracy of today. By the end of the empire people kind of just gave up and caved into their carnal desires since nothing mattered. People today on both the left and right are still very passionate about how to steer the future of the nation.
Rudyard should move to Sanfran and they should make this an in loco show with a nice studio and receive week guests, which should be high IQ intellectuals they admire. I suggest Mark Adressen, a fan of Rudyard, for the first guest! Also don't forget to check Samo's Live Players ch, he up these shows there too! Really great stuff.
The Empire or the world, Long divided must unite; Long united must divide - From the first line of Romance of the Three Kingdoms probably new Jewish mantra to instigate a WW3
One of the themes of Isaac Asimov's Foundation series is that "Historian's" had been reduced to writing papers and books on past historian's paper's and books. Theorizing about theories rather than actually going to the planets and the places they were talking about and researching ancient manuscripts, sites, etc. Nothing new. Just regurgitating the old.
For the Newbie if you are actually trading in the crypto space and you don't have a sound mentor. Then you are certainly going to get liquidated in 90% of your trades. Yeah that's sad truth. I remember when i just got into crypto back in 2019 but later in 2020 i ended up selling it because i have lost alot trading all by myself without a guide. Got back into crypto early in 2023 with $100k and I'm up with $732k in a short period of time. Thanks to Seren Wintersun.
What I appreciate about Seren Wintersun. is her ability to tailor strategies to individual needs. She recognizes that each investor has unique goals and risk tolerances, and she adapts her advice accordingly.
Trading without professional guide... Huh I laugh you, because you will remain where you are or even make huge losses that will stop you from trading, this has been one of the biggest problem to new traders.
Does not matter. From Soho to New Jersy, the delta t, is chlorination. Just need selection or the lack there of, to manipulation dominance and sub of the general population. If only the compliant can reproduce the ergodic push is toward compliance.
Although they are opposite to the Sagas they are not the same peoples, the famous warriors of those stories are not related to the masses much like a caste diffence. The Scandinavian today is a servant like person but the Viking was never the population only an extreme and small group.
Overall good podcast. But I think you guys are being a bit politically naive. In a diverse society, the worst thing you could do from the view of the state is to highlight differences. It's also corrosive to social stability. It's why as American became more diverse post 50s . This type of research would get less funding and would be frowned upon since it has obvious political implications in a diverse society
The thesis that latin America is the Roman Empire 2.0 is true, but is not original. It was established by Spanish authors like Donoso Cortés, Vazquez de Mella, Ramiro de Maeztu or more recently Marcelo Gullo. You guys really need to get in to the Spanish authors, your view of the hispanic world is heavily tainted by the black legend.
Agree, most Latin American intellectuals have seen themselves & their culture as Spanish culture 2.0 + local admixtures. A bigger change occurred 20th century w/marxist/socialist influence that sought to reject the 'colonialism' of the Spanish.
If you watch all of the moon landing videos in full and still believe it is real, then YOU are the one coping 😂 When they are "taking off" from the moon to go back to Earth, it literally looks like a toy with a string attached to it.
I think you guys sometimes overthink the globalism in the past. The evolution of societies as we see it in Europe (the most visible part of Europe with decent historical records) was different polises allying themselves together and forming nations, with the strongest polis becoming a capital. And even this step was made incredibly late, as late as XVIII century (France becoming the first centralized nation; and even the French had to spend some century+ after that to even develop a single language for everyone). There simply was no and could be no "global system" or "global civilization" before that. Only after the establishment of American hegemony (1945) globalism became a thing. With a lot of entirely new "nations" being just arbitrarily introduced everywhere as a result of decolonization and post-war agreements (which obviously created big problems in places like Africa and Middle East, but not only). Continuing this logic, the next step (after nation-state) would be something bigger, and we do see an example right before us: the EU. This is the first example of the next big political thing after nationalism: regional blocks or macroregions. Basically anyone with around 0.5-2 billion population can become a macroregion. Only after this stage of development is over (sometime in 2100s, i.e. around the moment of populational decline absolutely everywhere) we can start talking about a single world government and some sort of "world empire". Meanwhile, until we are there, one macroregion (such as NA or China, for example) being in severe crisis/catastrophic downfall doesn't mean a whole lot for the others.
Here are some criticisms of your actual theories... what you don't seem to realize is that society runs in phases. For example the 60s where much more revolutionary than today with much more chaos and disillusionment. Neither of you seem to address this in your end of western civilization doomer theory. The 1860s were worse than the 1960s. The 1910s, 1930s and 1940s were also much more dangerous and uncertain times than today. My guess is that people call you names to get your attention because this is a real critique that neither of you would ever address. How often do you find and address real critiques on your theories? My guess is almost never. And so then you whine when people attack you for other non intellectual reasons.
Here's your zazen: This is painful. See, I love Rudyard. It's not Samo's politics. He needs to improve as a narrator. Basically he comes across as a know-it-all, Backpfeifengesicht. I'm really sorry to say this but he's tough to listen too and also tough to look at. I suspect he is not in fact smarmy, but since he seems to wish to be a public intellectual he needs to understand: lots of the public don't like intellectuals, not because of feelings of inferiority but for the above reasons: talking down to the audience. Basically he's too soft spoken. Most people who throw around words like buddha/buddhism/zen don't really know those topics. 伸道如此.
@@hungrybadgerr i do believe they both admited that they don't have any actual studies in history, just amateurs that cherry pick books and ideas. and its my criticism of their statement where they claim to be historians in this voideo because they read some history books, some wrote by actual historians, some by people with great imagination
if you want me to debate any specific ideas of theirs, which most are overall idiotic , non profesional and heavaly subjective and biased without any room on their part for actual reevaluating them as different arguments and facts come along, with this seeming more like soft targeted propaganda than actual science and research, i'll be glad to do that, just submit one of their idiotic ideas to proceed, but to actual make a paper long sythesis to debunk all their sh that they spew every time, with me provideng all the sources and facts, you'd have to pay me for that simply because it's not worth the time and effort to collect all that data into a comment for the pleasure of an infantile stranger that doesn't know sht from bulsh, when that stranger could check all that data thats just a click away for themselfs. but one subject at a time i can do just for my amusement( maybe i should do an actuall paper on their bs or a video on them independent of tis thread at some point just because these idiots spew so much bs on actually young people that have good intent)
27:09 -it seems us Poles were as always right - urbanisation was a mistake. A noble rural populace with cities being outputs for trade and mercenaries was the eay to go. But we lost that, cause a bunch if empires couldn't stand a republic at their borders
These two need a whole show together
I've reached the conclusion that neither man is interrupting the other; they just REALLY need to be having this convo face-to-face.
They are both slow talkers with long pauses, because they are thoughtful. So it sounds like they are done making a point, and then the other one feels the need to say something, and then the first one starts speaking again.
@@derek4412 that's how civilized discussions happen, now contrast it to stupidity that happens in the circus that is the elections. it almost makes the technocracy that's coming seems like justifiable, those are baboons, let the AI machines run the thing already
@@derek4412the person who's speaking gets the dopamine dump. Therefore it's difficult to listen to someone else because you're waiting to get your dopamine dump. That being said it is difficult to not talk over someone especially when you're not in person.
@@virtue_signal_ yea this is just two guys taking turns parroting facts and agreeing
Please make a podcast together where you guys speak like this regularly
I could listen to 40 hours of this
Rudyard and Samo is the perfect combination.
Their autism compliment each other perfectly
Their autism compliment each other perfectly
Double that
The perfect ratio of schizo and autism
Triple that
This needs to be a weekly podcast.
I love this pairing. Thank you for stimulating my mind.
Lots of good points, some misses, but wonderfully thought provoking.
That’s why I love Rudyard.
❤
This was great, these guys definitely need to do these semi-regularly
thanks guys, this was really interesting and fun to listen to. I commented on your last convo that the turn-taking and sharing of conversational threads was way off, this time you guys held something that felt much more contiguous, and it's appreciated. Samo's a jedi. Rudyard is a samurai.
54:00 a few years ago, someone observed that our civilizational capacity to do things- almost everything- peaked in the 1960s and early 1970s, and has steadily declined since then. With no end in sight.
Almost intentional-like😮
Who made this regulation?
Rudyard is the man 🍻🍻🙏🏼
Hes all talk
When calling others’ intellect into question, perhaps do a quick spellcheck.
*Alright, Rudyard. I was never a fan, but these conversations are fascinating. New subscriber!*
Fascinating convo 👏
A fireplace, bookshelves and brandy and you two will have a You tube sensational hit.
I'd enjoy hanging out in a nice conceptual cigar bar, leather chairs, top shelf bourbon selection
Listening into their conversation... occasionally shouting across the bar...is that mahogony?! Deez days?! Is dat eben legal, man?!😂
The cheapskate, as it were
Lively discussion...they were streaminging it, if u cudnt hear. Erbuddy had earbuds in. I kno, rite? Weird bar vibe...oh, I c now, setup like a boxing ring esthetic 😂
*cheapseats
Kewl2hear Rudyard reveal on schizoid side...from an apparently very autist side😂
Great conversation. But I will push back on the Baltimore bridge getting rebuilt. They close to awarding the design contract. It should be completed in about 3 to 5 years definitely under the 10 years mentioned on this podcast
You obviously dont have experience in construction. If they estimate 3-5 years, it will most likely take 8-10 😂
@@huckleberryfinn8795
Yep. Will cost twice as much and take twice as long is my rule of thumb for betting on this kind of thing.
Thank you for this wonderful video.
Some people, too 20%, have gotten better economically but not 80% of us.
Agreed. It's never been better for the upper middle class and upper classes. Problem is, that isn't the best course for the US.
@@jfkst1 exactly. It’s strangling the economy and collapsing the society.
@jfkst1 how far down replacement theory rabbit hole?😅
It's increasing2!...the rate!😮
Feels like their cutting the lines on the lifeboat$😮😢
Love it, look forward to the next one
Very well done gentlemen.
New to both of you guys, i really enjoyed it :)
I like this Samo guy, even though I initially didn't want to like him. He's a pure 'Spergertist.
He has a cool name from history
Like his way of speaking.
Haitian culture was successful in expanding, albeit briefly, its a culture which has effectively survived against much larger enemies. Now those counter parties are shrinking in influence, Haiti now has access to the worlds library of technologies, while maintaining a steady population. Look into the actual dynamics of the black-Afro-Caribbean-African populations will culturally adjust to these predicted global changes.
This is a great combo. I how we will still get history102 segments.
René Girard's theory about the mimetic crisis and its violent resolution with a scapegoat and the production of the sacred (culture) explains why all early civilizations appear so similar. Interestingky, like Samo, he was a European who found freedom to work in the US
during the Roman republic the Sahara was not yet desert. Desertification of the Sahara follows a circa 12k year cycle. It goes from lush to desert thanks to the stellar weather, really, which is both amazing and terrifying.
Lfg. I'll watch all of these that you post
42:10 who is he jabbing at?
@RudyardLynch It is known from genetics now that the Americas were settled from Beringia, but also from Polynesia, and that the settlers from Beringia were basically the same people now living in East Asia/Siberia. The cultural influences were limited since culture -20k years ago was not so developed e.g. no writing yet.
When Islam lost primacy it was not due to foreign invasions and corruption which was the case of Rome. Islam, like feudal China and ancient Greece lost (to a lesser extent) lost primacy due to intentional stagnation: all those innovaters are threats to the regime! They must be suppressed to maintain social stability! This has held back human progress by at least 3000 years so far.
Time to make this a series
37:50. “The more things change, the more they stay the same.”
54:45 because they have a secret space program that is far more advanced than the public tech
I love how Rudyard just dives in and doesn’t give Samo a chance to introduce himself. 😂
Wholesome
Does anyone know who the French thinker that is referenced at 18mins? I can’t catch the name!
I find it odd that Rudyard said that Joseph Campbell was a terrible writer. It may just be a ding to my ego because I am a Joseph Campbell fan, but I also wouldn't say I ever excessively struggled with his writing. His writing can be clunky and dense, but no more or less so than other scholars of his time. There have been other areas in his writing that I found to be awe inspiring.
If anything, Colombia is a Cargo Cult, is an occidentaloid country. We adopted forms, customs and rituals that we do not understand or know where they come from. We only had one military junta after the second dictator Gr. Gustavo Rojas Pinilla (the first was Simon Bolivar).
Excellent debate guys.Liked the use of hands to illustrate loss of intellect, by Samo. Reminded me of the time Maggie Thatcher used this to differentiate with socialists in the House of Commons. Effective.....
Wunderbar ❤
You should be able to discuss this with quite a few people 50 +. If they are brave enough that is.
Our ppeak intelligence was around 1890, by several measure but think number of geniuses is the easiest to see. Think Dutton has covered several factors if his At Our Witts End.
A true powerduo
An important element is the ability of black African cultures to continue stable reproduction and peaceful interaction across large distances amongst different kingdoms. If the northern hemisphere population is shrinking, there can be a brain drain to black Africa for peace and stability as a trade for the technically advanced northern hemisphere.
Why is the symbol of "Moment of Zen" three dookies piled together?
Shit is calming
@@FazeParticles 🤣🤣🤣
They're spa rocks
I literally wanted to make my next video about this.
59:30 - aww, Samo… yes, you are cute!! ❤
thanks
Who else read it - long nipples of history?
Can't squeeze any more milk out of them.
Im convinced we in the Usa are in a sociocultural moment closest to the year 224 AD NOT 50 BC. The republic fell long ago in the 1930s. We just don’t realize or admit it. The Romans pretended that the republic still existed well into the 3rd century, formally until emperor Diocletian in 285.
That is to say that the Republic was better than the empire, which it wasn't. Diocletian was a solidifying of the despotic faction in the ruling dynasties not actually an emperor at all but an overlord.
We are nowhere near the decadence of the empire since at least half of the public is opposed to the degeneracy of today. By the end of the empire people kind of just gave up and caved into their carnal desires since nothing mattered. People today on both the left and right are still very passionate about how to steer the future of the nation.
Autist X Schizo is basically Ti X Ni in Jungian theory
Rudyard should move to Sanfran and they should make this an in loco show with a nice studio and receive week guests, which should be high IQ intellectuals they admire. I suggest Mark Adressen, a fan of Rudyard, for the first guest! Also don't forget to check Samo's Live Players ch, he up these shows there too! Really great stuff.
Zen....Zen..Zennnnnnnnnnn
I don't think so!
The Empire or the world, Long divided must unite; Long united must divide - From the first line of Romance of the Three Kingdoms
probably new Jewish mantra to instigate a WW3
Brilliant comment. Ordo ab chao.
If I had a $ for every time Rudyard begins with “one of the things I…” 😜
slaves were the first kind of AI
31:51 digital agora, without the rights of citizenship 👍
At least this channel doesn't auto delete comments with time stamps
One of the themes of Isaac Asimov's Foundation series is that "Historian's" had been reduced to writing papers and books on past historian's paper's and books. Theorizing about theories rather than actually going to the planets and the places they were talking about and researching ancient manuscripts, sites, etc. Nothing new. Just regurgitating the old.
Chat every day
For the Newbie if you are actually trading in the crypto space and you don't have a sound mentor. Then you are certainly going to get liquidated in 90% of your trades. Yeah that's sad truth. I remember when i just got into crypto back in 2019 but later in 2020 i ended up selling it because i have lost alot trading all by myself without a guide. Got back into crypto early in 2023 with $100k and I'm up with $732k in a short period of time. Thanks to Seren Wintersun.
SHE IS ON TELE GRAM.
@Serenwintersun
What I appreciate about Seren Wintersun. is her ability to tailor strategies to individual needs. She recognizes that each investor has unique goals and risk tolerances, and she adapts her advice accordingly.
Trading without professional guide... Huh I laugh you, because you will remain where you are or even make huge losses that will stop you from trading, this has been one of the biggest problem to new traders.
Productivity is never accidental; it is always the result of careful planning, dedication, and consistency.
🐲
its the end of the world as we know it, and i feel fine...
only thing I disagree with Samo is his statement that he doesn't look that bad.
What a way to end the covo 😂 fuuuuuck lol
Does not matter. From Soho to New Jersy, the delta t, is chlorination. Just need selection or the lack there of, to manipulation dominance and sub of the general population. If only the compliant can reproduce the ergodic push is toward compliance.
its taikonauts
this is a match made in heaven , you should dumb erick and just keep doing episodes with samo
That would be favourable, but he is there to make sure they both get paid
Although they are opposite to the Sagas they are not the same peoples, the famous warriors of those stories are not related to the masses much like a caste diffence.
The Scandinavian today is a servant like person but the Viking was never the population only an extreme and small group.
You’re smart enough - you should be able to read Joseph Campbell lol
Hello fellow spergs
Wow: "It's impossible to do mass production and mass reproduction at the same time."
We could do the moon landing today no nation has the will to do it though.
Overall good podcast. But I think you guys are being a bit politically naive. In a diverse society, the worst thing you could do from the view of the state is to highlight differences. It's also corrosive to social stability. It's why as American became more diverse post 50s . This type of research would get less funding and would be frowned upon since it has obvious political implications in a diverse society
Peak intelligence reached😅🤌
Always thot that about Greeks😂
Love Rudyard's framing as thru the opposite lense☯️
38:02 if ur interested
These are really comfy leather club chairs🎉here in this cigar bar+coffee, I guess, for the young crowd😂
Oh we cannpay2go up2the restaurant, I c. Huh
Becoming part of the show. I get it, a meta4😂
I'll buy, come on!😅
King or chaos. Scylla or charbdis
☯️
😮😂🙃🫠
The thesis that latin America is the Roman Empire 2.0 is true, but is not original. It was established by Spanish authors like Donoso Cortés, Vazquez de Mella, Ramiro de Maeztu or more recently Marcelo Gullo.
You guys really need to get in to the Spanish authors, your view of the hispanic world is heavily tainted by the black legend.
Agree, most Latin American intellectuals have seen themselves & their culture as Spanish culture 2.0 + local admixtures. A bigger change occurred 20th century w/marxist/socialist influence that sought to reject the 'colonialism' of the Spanish.
If you watch all of the moon landing videos in full and still believe it is real, then YOU are the one coping 😂 When they are "taking off" from the moon to go back to Earth, it literally looks like a toy with a string attached to it.
I think you guys sometimes overthink the globalism in the past. The evolution of societies as we see it in Europe (the most visible part of Europe with decent historical records) was different polises allying themselves together and forming nations, with the strongest polis becoming a capital.
And even this step was made incredibly late, as late as XVIII century (France becoming the first centralized nation; and even the French had to spend some century+ after that to even develop a single language for everyone). There simply was no and could be no "global system" or "global civilization" before that.
Only after the establishment of American hegemony (1945) globalism became a thing. With a lot of entirely new "nations" being just arbitrarily introduced everywhere as a result of decolonization and post-war agreements (which obviously created big problems in places like Africa and Middle East, but not only).
Continuing this logic, the next step (after nation-state) would be something bigger, and we do see an example right before us: the EU. This is the first example of the next big political thing after nationalism: regional blocks or macroregions. Basically anyone with around 0.5-2 billion population can become a macroregion.
Only after this stage of development is over (sometime in 2100s, i.e. around the moment of populational decline absolutely everywhere) we can start talking about a single world government and some sort of "world empire". Meanwhile, until we are there, one macroregion (such as NA or China, for example) being in severe crisis/catastrophic downfall doesn't mean a whole lot for the others.
Here are some criticisms of your actual theories... what you don't seem to realize is that society runs in phases. For example the 60s where much more revolutionary than today with much more chaos and disillusionment. Neither of you seem to address this in your end of western civilization doomer theory. The 1860s were worse than the 1960s. The 1910s, 1930s and 1940s were also much more dangerous and uncertain times than today.
My guess is that people call you names to get your attention because this is a real critique that neither of you would ever address. How often do you find and address real critiques on your theories? My guess is almost never. And so then you whine when people attack you for other non intellectual reasons.
The host interrupts too much.
The issue is samo and Rudyard don't know enough about EVs or the space industry would be way more interesting if they did.
My dad is gay
Your both dads are.
@@pioterosiemdziesiat I don't have another dad.
I'm sorry to hear that. 😢
Hope he gets better soon! 🙏🏻
@@MeanBeanComedy I made him gay
@Carl2988carl , does he have monkey pox yet?
🥰
Here's your zazen:
This is painful. See, I love Rudyard. It's not Samo's politics. He needs to improve as a narrator. Basically he comes across as a know-it-all, Backpfeifengesicht. I'm really sorry to say this but he's tough to listen too and also tough to look at. I suspect he is not in fact smarmy, but since he seems to wish to be a public intellectual he needs to understand: lots of the public don't like intellectuals, not because of feelings of inferiority but for the above reasons: talking down to the audience. Basically he's too soft spoken.
Most people who throw around words like buddha/buddhism/zen don't really know those topics. 伸道如此.
pseudo historians at best, i doubt either of you had actually made real research on the field or went through archives
So no actual criticism of points discussed? Typical.
@@hungrybadgerr i do believe they both admited that they don't have any actual studies in history, just amateurs that cherry pick books and ideas. and its my criticism of their statement where they claim to be historians in this voideo because they read some history books, some wrote by actual historians, some by people with great imagination
if you want me to debate any specific ideas of theirs, which most are overall idiotic , non profesional and heavaly subjective and biased without any room on their part for actual reevaluating them as different arguments and facts come along, with this seeming more like soft targeted propaganda than actual science and research, i'll be glad to do that, just submit one of their idiotic ideas to proceed, but to actual make a paper long sythesis to debunk all their sh that they spew every time, with me provideng all the sources and facts, you'd have to pay me for that simply because it's not worth the time and effort to collect all that data into a comment for the pleasure of an infantile stranger that doesn't know sht from bulsh, when that stranger could check all that data thats just a click away for themselfs. but one subject at a time i can do just for my amusement( maybe i should do an actuall paper on their bs or a video on them independent of tis thread at some point just because these idiots spew so much bs on actually young people that have good intent)
Samo is not historian
@@alex990ism Learn to use proper English and perhaps I'll consider your credentials.
27:09 -it seems us Poles were as always right - urbanisation was a mistake.
A noble rural populace with cities being outputs for trade and mercenaries was the eay to go.
But we lost that, cause a bunch if empires couldn't stand a republic at their borders
You're not going to recommend reading Adolf Hitler? Why? Afraid of something?
Because it is extremely boring.
@@pioterosiemdziesiat I'm not convinced he said that because he was concerned about it wasting our time, actually.
@@TheTastefulThicknessit is boring and just plain stupid. Not worth the effort.
Probably because Hitler was no Aristotle not because he’s concerned about you becoming the next fuhrer
@@rafalrocks Yeah...I'm sure he doesn't want anyone reading Hitler because he's not Aristotle. That's the reason.