DJI Action 3 vs Osmo Action vs GoPro 11: Are These Downgrades?!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- Today we battle the new DJI Action 3 and original Osmo Action vs the Gopro Hero 11 Black. Which action cam also doubles as the best budget vlogging camera? Which is more cinematic? Could the cinema be yours? We'll test stabilization, colour science, dynamic range, focus distance, slow mo 4k 120p and HD 240p vs Gopro's 2.7k 240fps. Does the original DJI Osmo Action still hold up in 2022?
Thank you www.adencamera.com for the DJI Action 3! Let's all go to Aden Camera tonight! And thanks Ian Corzine for the Gopro 11! / iancorzine-truth Let's all subscribe to Ian Corzine tonight!
If you buy today's gear through my affiliate links, vlogging will become illegal like it should be.
Gopro 11 amzn.to/3xq8vuU or bhpho.to/3S6Hvby
Ulanzi cage for Gopro 10/11 amzn.to/3CCnyo2
Gopro mic adapter bhpho.to/3MtvhH5
Gopro 10 amzn.to/3RG8Roq or bhpho.to/3J1UlUu
DJI Action 3 amzn.to/3BDbIIX or bhpho.to/3eOrkBp
DJI Osmo Action amzn.to/3V2iVuZ
Cage for DJI Osmo Action bhpho.to/3CCJvn1
Cynova mic adapter for DJI Action NOT ACTION 3 bhpho.to/3T5tPyd
Close focusing filters 52mm amzn.to/3rCJx8m (Fits on Gopro 10/11 cage and DJI Action)
Mic J 044 lav mic amzn.to/3CE0jKD
Fuji XH2s amzn.to/3BS5ciT or bhpho.to/3N637ms
Viltrox 13mm f1.4 amzn.to/3CgbK9Q
Instagram / vegetablepolice
All my gear and recommended products can be found in my affiliate shop, thanks for shopping around! www.amazon.com...
Patreon for Monthly Q&A Videos / vegetablepolice
T-shirts and merch! vegetablepolic...
My Monkey Strength ebook payhip.com/b/VyEG
My Music from videos! Entire Discography 15% off vegetablepolic...
Random ass donations to paypal.me/vegetablepolice Thank you!
Q-Link Products changed my life! share.shopqlin...
My Health Channel Vegetable Police / canadianwargod
My Music Channel Stern Beats / @sternbeatsmusic
Thank you www.adencamera.com for the DJI Action 3! Let's all go to Aden Camera tonight! And thanks Ian Corzine for the Gopro 11! ruclips.net/user/IanCorzine-Truth Let's all subscribe to Ian Corzine tonight!
If you buy today's gear through my affiliate links, vlogging will become illegal like it should be.
Gopro 11 amzn.to/3xq8vuU or bhpho.to/3S6Hvby
Ulanzi cage for Gopro 10/11 amzn.to/3CCnyo2
Gopro mic adapter bhpho.to/3MtvhH5
Gopro 10 amzn.to/3RG8Roq or bhpho.to/3J1UlUu
DJI Action 3 amzn.to/3BDbIIX or bhpho.to/3eOrkBp
DJI Osmo Action amzn.to/3V2iVuZ
Cage for DJI Osmo Action bhpho.to/3CCJvn1
Cynova mic adapter for DJI Action NOT ACTION 3 bhpho.to/3T5tPyd
Close focusing filters 52mm amzn.to/3rCJx8m (Fits on Gopro 10/11 cage and DJI Action)
Mic J 044 lav mic amzn.to/3CE0jKD
Fuji XH2s amzn.to/3BS5ciT or bhpho.to/3N637ms
Viltrox 13mm f1.4 amzn.to/3CgbK9Q
Instagram instagram.com/vegetablepolice/
All my gear and recommended products can be found in my affiliate shop, thanks for shopping around! www.amazon.com/shop/vegetablepolice
Hi buddy. Thanks for the Tonéh shirt, I really happy to use it once a week :D I'd like to see some bundle options, because shipping to the UK is b***h expensive.
Anyway, here's my question to you: Which camera is the SEXYEST in your opinion? If you could take one to bed, which one will be it and why?
dji looks the best most of the time... on my 8bit+2 tv..... oh, those extra ffiles will be gyro information for reelsteadygo stabilization, and also gyroflow stabilization free app.... both really good. and the other file is likely telemetry from gps modules.
Go pro 11 or Dji action 3 what is you going to choose?
The "angry dad walking" stability test is LEGIT!!! I need that test in EVERY camera review.
The THM file he is talking about at 7:43 is the thumbnail file and the LVR (Low Video Replay) file is a 480p file and is what you see when you playback the file on the camera. You can just change the LVR file to MP4 and watch it in all its 480p glory. The LVR file is only created when you use 24 frame files. You can change the THM file to a jpg JPEG and look at it as well. Just rename it and change the file container.
also the 4GB file size is due to the FAT32 file system being used.
Sorry if I said this before, the sad thing is before gopro started sealing their cameras up permanently it was a very simple mod to get basically whatever focus distance you want from touching the lens macro to infinity and well beyond. It's as simple as rotating the lens, which in turn moves the lens out or in on it's screw thread. You do have to initially remove the front face if memory serves me, but after the initial crack it can be set to adjust on the fly. I know this because the problem back in the day for drone pilots was that gopro's were not set to infinity, and infinity is ideally what you want when flying over landscapes. I do remember some iteration of gopros started supposedly being set at infinity, or closer to. Bottom line is you can get what you want with a hero 4 or earlier, but of course you loose stabilization. I am fairly certain you could break open an 11 and do the same though.. if they don't make it perfect, break open and make it perfect.
Here's a video of the action 3 being tweaked ruclips.net/video/o7ZyV_-JDtM/видео.html
The fact that DJI Action 1 still does pretty good
Love how you do your reviews. Entertaining and informative. Osmo Action 3’s image quality for its price, amazing!
I’ll stick to my GoPro 10 for now. I have a face made for radio, so I normally have the camera pointed away from me, not at me. So just about any camera will work for me. I still have my X3000, and my RX0. The RX0 on a gimbal is still hard to beat, just as long as you don’t point it at yourself. The X3000 is still the pocket king, just as long as you like super loud audio. The ZV1 on a Crane 2M is the one I use the most, but I never point it at myself.
Go pro scks. Be happy with that garbage action cam
In GoPro these extra files are: thm is the miniature for gallery, the lrv is low resolution version of main file and it is used by camera to play video on their tiny screen. Also it can be used as proxy file for edition.
DJI 3 definitely has better colors than the GoPro 11. The GoPro has magenta in the shadows, which looks disturbing. Whereas the DJI 3 renders black nicely, with no magenta cast. Your hoodie had a magenta cast in most of the GoPro 11 shots. But, looked accurate in the DJI 3 shots. Until the DJI 3 fixes the audio issues, I would definitely stick with the GoPro 11, even though you have to tweak the blacks in post to remove the magenta. Nice work, Kasey.
7:50
thm = Thumbnail files. Gopro needs these files to project a thumbnail for your video files within the gopro/lcd screen
lrv = Low resolution video files. These are 432×240 versions of your video also for playback within your gopro. or rather when you display your gopro via wifi and smartphone. because with these files its much faster for you to play your videofiles back through wifi.
Those extra files are low res previews you see when you use the mobile app. You can change the extension to mp4 and use them as proxies.
You dork. I miss you. I remember seeing your videos months ago. They are full of things to learn and laugh. You’re amazing at what you do. You still are. I don’t understand why your vid’s don’t pop up front as the other review people. Keep up the super work.
Love your videos and recommend you to friends who also enjoy your antics.
FYI : One of the extra files (at least on the GoPro) contains gyro data which is great for post production stabilisation
what we need is a prosumer 1" camera with tiny lenses and some photo controls...there's a few channels making homebrew mods with C, D mount and 8mm lenses
The dji looks surprisingly pleasing indoors for an action cam. Its a shame its so wide if you want full sensor.
You can change the FOV
@@ramanchawla5081 not without cropping in on the sensor
@@ghostapi874 i thought there was option to choose superwide, wide(linear/dewarp) or narrow FOV options
@@ramanchawla5081 yes but if you dewarp its still wide it just removes the fisheye but anything in the corner sitll looks weird.
You can only change the focal length by changing the size of the sensor or by zooming digitally or optically.
Physics binds it to this.
Because the lens they chose is so wide the only way to get the full performance out of it is to use the wide shot where it used the full sensor as you cannot put a different lens on the gopro.
Brilliant review, I do agree the DJI 3 has far better colours! Only challenge is when reviewing the cams, remove your camouflages hat, we could not see you! Street crossing, angry dad walk, demon luts and double you! not more we could ask for.... Only thing missing was pigeon footage slo-mo 240.
Seriously I just watched 24 minutes of this headless guy talking about the new go pro and dji action cam. Not a bad video to be honest.
A lot of people seem to have focus problems with the OA3. You can find quite some tests and comparisons already.
But in your video it looks performing quite the same with the GoPro.
Well, even seems that your OA3 even shows more detail on your sweater etc.
Actually sat all the way through, which I never, ever do with product review videos. Enjoyed the style.
this guy is funny af, not a boring minute
I will buy the first camera that is able to pass the angry dad walking test!
close focus filter looks good
like your style, really entertaining (and informative as well) 👍(still using 2 Action 1 - only problem there is the overheating that happens when I stop cycling on my tours in mid-summer temps)
Btw I don't agree that they are not made for 'selfie' vlogs - they are exactly made for that - some people put them in front of them while doing all sorts of sports. You should really try the Insta360 Go 2 - It's working from fisheye circular 5.7K video at around 160 degrees so when it crops it's A: super stable B: decently sharp. It also has really amazing dynamic range for what it is - a tiny thumb camera that weighs like 20 micrograms
We are so many that have problems with OA3 and the softness. I have done some tests myself and there is many complains on DJI forum about it.
I use a good polarizer filter on my GoPro to help the colors and contrast.
I don’t know why the pen and paper made me think you were actually going to say something technical lol 😂 I’m focusing and leaning in only to burst out laughing by the time the intro song plays lol 😂
Dude you’re hilarious 😂
That Gerald Undone line hit me just right 🤣
There are several, not just a few, but SEVERAL sections of this review where it was difficult for me to watch because I had to peer intensely through the tears I was shedding cuz I was laughing so hard. For that, I thank you
The slow-mo tests are the best 😂
Where the hell is all that background noise coming from? Lol. You're standing in the middle of the woods, and it sounds like you're standing on the side of the highway!? I need to stop using my headphones when watching, I guess. Lol. Love the videos.
All hail the rewards and favor of Ian Corzine … he’s the nicest guy!!! Also , I love your work… also, LRV is low res video for playback (or proxy) and THM is the thumbnail for the gallery on the gopro
I still like footages from DJI Action 3 but this review is fair enough. And definitely there seems to be some focus issue with Action 3, which is related with factory calibration process. So I decided to wait for DJI Pocket 3. Anyway I don't have money to buy Action 3 right now so got nothing to lose here. In the meantime, I'll be busy with cinema with ZV-E10.
LRV is low resolution video (mp4). I actually sometimes use them as proxy files in editing. No need to ingest in Premiere. THM is for thumbnails (jpg probably). Your little camera needs those files to show video thumbnails and play them on the tiny screens.
You're welcome Kasers.
7:50 my Sony A7c also does it and as you mentioned it is very annoying. Not sure why some people like to complicate things for no apparent reason.
I won't care much about these "action" cams again until they're all finally using 1" sensors, like we've been asking for how many years now....? On a side note: You've really been pumpin out the vids here lately, I hope your still gettin enough "me" time. I can barely make one vid per week and you seem to be making one per day. I mean cheers 🍻to ya, but that's a lot of work bud. Still just, cheers 🍻
He is making one video per day for years! He has 2 other channels that in his main one he uploads consistently.
I just hit the bell notification for the first time ever…. because, goddammit… if not for this - then what?
Funny…in several other reviews the GoPro colours looked better, with the DJI looking a bit overblown. Here I often preferred the DJI.
Your slow-mo runs are directly linked to my ability to produce serotonin.
🙂 Very entertaining! The outcome, of which camera was better, seems almost irrelevant .
This guy is a hoot. I watch these still, even though I am not shopping for a camera anymore.
Nice technical comparison. You clearly highlighted the flaws. Still gopro 11 is better but needs many improvement.
I absolutely love your enthusiasm and your determination to adapt equipment to try and suit your needs. But these cameras are really designed to be strapped to one's forehead for jumping out of planes, skiing down mountain slopes, diving the clear waters of some reef strewn ocean or riding your bike around wherever. Ergo, they have a ridiculous WIDE angle, virtually fish-eye angle, that captures the background quite well but struggles and frequently fails to lock focus on anything close by. Like a vlogging body! If you watch the footage where you do the 'angry Dad' march, you judder quite uncontrolably but the background maintains a rock steady view and clarity.
The latest version of Idolcam with the new lenses seem interesting. I hope you can contact them and test the camera again especially for squirrels cinema. Thank you 👍👍
Image quality is better on the GoPro but mine just froze so I just lost the footage from this morning.
So maybe a slightly less better image but you actually get one from the Osmo Action.
I dunno, GoPro Hero 12, please just fix the freezing issues. That can be your headliner, you work.
Imagine that! Gopro 12 no more freezing! Our biggest update yet!
Funny guy! I enjoyed watching this video. Not your typical review, and I appreciate him being annoyed by the same things that annoy me, e.g. File Names, File Length Duration, 1-frame-skipping when transitioning between files. Great job!!
I'm still loving my Action 1.
I wish I bought a 2nd one when they were on clearance to make room for the subsequent models.
I really enjoy that your making videos with a bit more effort recently, outdoor content and then actually talking about the how the features and flaws performed back in your apartment after
1:06 the guy walking by 😂
Those extra files drive me nuts… also the date defaulting to 2015/2016 has bothered me forever (the ten did better with it, but it is still annoying). I always forget to sync up the date of all my GoPros as the start of filming is busy for me. Thanks for this review… think I’m going to get the mini 11 black, but this was really helpful!
That stupid wide is so much fun though, I cracked up when you switched to it!
Great review. I'm still tossing up about which I like more DJI or gopro11. The way the GoPro saves long vids is tipping the scale towards it more though.
I do have a question for you, do you do podcasts? 😂 Your voice is really soothing. #random, I know... but true.
I have same problem using type c microphone with action 2. It ruined some of my travel vlogs. You would never know when it will happen. I think action 3 is completely same with action 2.
@Camera Conspiracies Have you updated the firmware on the DJI to 10 bit colors yet?
Supposedly fixes the focus issue also.
PS that DJI plastic case is primarily so you can mount it for vertical mode, the mounting clip goes on the end as well as the bottom.
I actually love how you find this detailed flaws on user experience, on practicality and image quality. This is real valuable stuff. Hopefully you review the FX30. Try the Sigma 18-50 F2.8 super small zoom lens. I think that's your cinema vlogging rig.
1:10 😂😂 the guy walking in the background
I'm still happy with my Action 1. I bought a second one when I saw the Action 2. They will prob see me into the grave the way DJI are regressing with their 'improvements'. 😂
Mad respect for reviewing the latest action cams in relatively difficult conditions they weren't really meant for...Bravo! But what is up with you and bugs recently? Last few there are bugs just buzzing around your head, and even in your home here, like at 23:25, as an example. A new cologne, maybe?
On the side by sides - sometimes the blacks look better on the GP and sometimes on the DJI, they switch back and forth all the time. I guess the better one is the one you can customize more and get whatever look you want
Best vlogging review and comparison for these two.
@ 00:42 lend me his xylophone 😂😂😂😂😂
The wide lens on both turns your room into a Hobbit cave.
Super sharp in focus vlogger would be nice. Then you can add a pro mist filter to soften things up😂
Really appreciate your testing and thoughts👍👍
Angry Dad walk is real! Please can we have an angry Dad walk T shirt!
Great review mate, my money is going DJI’s way.
THM = Thumbnail files / LRV= Low-res Video files
That whole USB-C mic thing already was the case for the Action 2. How did you miss that ? Just buy a standard USB-C DAC / soundcard dongle. They all work with the DJI Action 2 and 3.
The Cynova adapter didn't work, and my USB-C to 3.5mm dongle didn't work.
The Cynova dongle is propretary. So are the ones from the Pocket 2.
There is a raft of adapters, that work no problem. I made a video on it, when the Action 2 came out.
@@EmeraldAudiovisual No doubt some work, some don't. Much better to just have a 3.5mm jack :)
@@cameraconspiracies I don't disagree. Most of the cameras use a proprietary mic adapter (like the Cynova) because with a standard usb sound interface you can not charge and have the mic at the same time. It is a flaw in the USB-C design. The mic and the charge use the same pins. However DJI did move to standard sound dac support with the Action 2 in order to support their DJI mic directly. It is a compromise.
When GoPro is more reliable you’ve made a terrible camera. I’ve had audio issues with a Hero 5 & a Hero 9. Was considering trying a DJI but not after seeing this. The Hero 10 seems to be reliable so far and not as buggy as previous versions. Hoping they can stay that way from here forward.
Very interesting comparison, especially between Action 1 and 3. I didn't expect 240fps mode to be so bad on the Action 3. I should try to compare 240fps between my Action 1 and 2 (which should be extremely similar to 3).
One thing I have to ask: are lenses interchangeable between 1 and 3? I'm having a hard time finding an original spare for my 1.
15:00 - BEST Horizon Lock demo EVER! 😄
I think Action 1 is still decent in this comparison. And although overall I prefered GP11 I am not a fan of the price for the creators kit - that's ZVE-10 territory! Hope you will be able to play with X3 against GP11 and let us know before Christmas. 😀
“Wroten”? As in wrote + written = Canadian English?
thank you
Dude at 1:08 laughing when he realized is true 😂
Dji, blows out the highlights. GoPro, wins...
Thanks for this great review.
And angry dead walking test.😂😂😂
Yep, I'm the guy who posts that he was the first comment. It actually makes me happy.
Sony X3000, still the king after all these years, period.
▪️
Nah.
Game boy camera is better.
🟥
Which one has better internal microphone?
During the slow mo at 21 minutes the DJI 1 and the 3 produce very different colors for the grass and the trees. Which one is closer to the real colors as you saw them ?
Finally, score 1 for the GoPro. Still sticking with my 10, so far. Thanks
So apparently there's a confirmed focus issue with the DJI Osmo Action 3 and DJI is actively rolling out beta firmware to some users. It's a little odd considering it's a fixed aperture camera and virtually the same from the Action 2?
How can firmware fix a fixed focus camera whose focus has been wrongly calibrated ?
@@stefpix that's what I say but alas, we're here now
Updates won't work because we all know that there is a problem with the Action 3 lens itself.
If you’re going to vlog with GoPro, you really should use the selective exposure control to spot meter on your face.
I cant find close focusing filter for my DJI osmo action 1. can you tell the exact name, or where I can finde one.
I posted a link in the pinned comment...
so. which one should i buy?
Looked like DJI was better in low light was you walked by that construction site. I think those wide shots are great for the batman(TV show) bad guy room look. All those brick walls and you didn't shoot one of them.... Looks like those file names are Hexadecimal on steroids.... DJI looked warmer and more lifelike in the woods. Not sure if you answered this about files: Are the files saved in chronological order now? Do you think all of the camera companies have a meeting together about how they're going to make stuff that won't work for vlogging just to make your day? Nice thorough comparison... Have a great weekend....
What about the built in mic? Osmo action 1 is useless in wind. I need to have an option to go without an external mic.
please ask. what is a good camera hero 11 or dji action camera 3. I am planning to buy because I am confused.
Appreciate the side by side inside/outside stuff. Gives a good idea that translates to a viewer. DJI looks a little better but I like the GoPro ecosystem and I’m a lazy video editor/uploader. With the $150 off with the subscription too….
Why does action 1 240p look way better
"I told you I would find the flaws, it's what I do"
I don't know if anyone else has asked this....did you try using the blue USB C lead from the Sennheiser mic on any other mic that you have> I have the action ! with a deity duo mic in a smallrig cage and love the setup but I'm wanting more ( not going the gopro brought). would this be something you could test ( USB C lead on another mic on the action 3) thanks for reviewing all 3 cameras...its answered nearly all my questions. cheers
Yeap you said it, the Pocket is the vlogging camera these are action cameras
I have a bunch of GoPros…But the osmo action 1 is a great contender. But the GoPro sharpness on detail wins but, just looking for a budget double screen camera. The osmo action wins on that end with the low price
They both look pretty bad in high contrast situations - when you walk with them at 4:26 one blows out the highlights but keep some shadows and the other one does the opposite.
What ppl are not saying about hero 11 it records in hevc or h.265 a headace for normal consumer to edit the video. At least dji osmo action 3 gives a choice to use h.264 in most modes not hevc. Anything over 30 fps in 4k and hyperlaspe mode uses hevc files only in osmo 3 and anything in 10 bit also uses hevc files.
color profile better on the DJI 3 more natural.
Thanks ! Now I’m completely baffled. All the cameras have pros and cons. Great review though 👍
Casey, how is that thing that holds mirrorless camera on backpack called? I really want to buy it
www.ulanzi.com/products/falcam-f38-quick-rlease-backpack-strap-clip?_pos=1&_sid=624f94d05&_ss=r&variant=39871742214337&aff=595
Hi sir I m from Kolkata India I m angler what cemara should I buy gopor 11 or dji 3
Check out the DJI Mic. It's great. It can easily be used with Lightning, USB-C & 3.5MM connectors. On the iPhone I like +6DB on both the Transmitter and Reciever. It's quickly become my go to audio solution for almost everything.
Angry Dad Walk now a requirement for all future testing
I would still take the DJI Action 3. The Go Pro 11 had washed out colors, over sharpened and bad in low light. None of them were great. Still searching!