How India wants to (literally) fix e-waste
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
- Electronic waste is one of the fastest growing types of rubbish on the planet. India, which is becoming ultra digital, is trying an old trick in new ways to deal with its growing and dangerous dump yards.
#planeta #righttorepair #circulareconomy
We're destroying our environment at an alarming rate. But it doesn't need to be this way. Our new channel Planet A explores the shift towards an eco-friendly world - and challenges our ideas about what dealing with climate change means. We look at the big and the small: What we can do and how the system needs to change. Every Friday we'll take a truly global look at how to get us out of this mess.
Follow Planet A on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@dw_planeta?la...
Credits:
Author: Aditi Rajagopal
Camera: Dheeraj Aithal
Video Editors: David Jacobi, Aditi Rajagopal
Supervising Editor: Michael Trobridge, Joanna Gottschalk, Malte Rohwer-Kahlmann
Fact-check: Jeannette Cwienk, Kirsten Funck
Thumbnail: Em Chabridon
Read More (Links):
Right to Repair portal: righttorepairindia.gov.in/
Fixing Planned Obsolescence by Activating the Right to Repair in India: www.researchgate.net/publicat...
Right to Repair in the EU: repair.eu/
Impacts of e-waste: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Cartoon on India’s repair culture: thelogicalindian.com/exclusiv...
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
01:17 Haggling
02:47 Repair culture
04:18 Electronics graveyard
06:35 India's Right to Repair
08:04 The Kataria case
10:08 Progress elsewhere
11:22 Conclusion
What do you do when your smartphone breaks - replace or repair? And why?
Please look up "Louis Rossmann".
if it's not old enough, repair. otherwise, replace
Depends on how it breaks-if it’s the screen-repair! If it’s anything internal-replace! Living in North America we pay too much for cellphones already to not expect a perfect working phone tbh. If we paid less to begin with and repairs were more common and actually done right I think people would be more into repairs!!! Buying used phones here is already considered a huge risk.
Repair
For your next phone you might consider to apply the screen protector and invest for a good case😅
Remember no matter how Unfixable you make your product,
1) There's always a Chinese who'll make it cheaper 🗿
2) There's always an Indian who'll fix it. 🗿
Asians😎😎😎
💯 True
That covers almost 40% of the world population
Indians 😎😎
I’ve had my iPhone 6s for 4 years! And people make fun of me constantly. My phone will not hold an update. It’s Apple that is forcing me to buy NEW. I would love to keep my current phone.
@@itry2understand800 that’s honestly my worry too! Idc about anything else that comes with the new iOS just the security updates. I need a new screen honestly. Gone through a few glass screen protectors now, I hate ordering new ones online, can’t find them anywhere in store anymore for this size. I LOVE having a button still. I can’t imagine not having a physical button, just a touch screen. I plan on keeping this phone as long as I can!! But it’s so frustrating and getting more full by the day I swear. Who can really afford the iCloud prices either?? Such a ripoff!! Smh.
@@itry2understand800 my battery is just starting to go lol won’t charge to 100% all the time anymore, mostly just 99% ugh.
@@itry2understand800i applaud you! repairability is apples exact problem. i got an iphone gifted and take good care od it, but my next phone will be easily repairable. a fairphone most likely. i hope it will be available in the US soon
I used redmi note 4 for six years, still working fine.
Don't Follow their Advice ..... Follow your inner guidance
I wish the United States cared about the right to repair as India does.
Somehow being wasteful is considered opulence
U don't have them?
@@iscifion7122the repair cost is so high people would rather get a new 1
What how is it possible that new is considered cheap instead of fixing ?? @@user-jn7bq8wh1e
@@user-jn7bq8wh1e Is it intentional?
Cuz Repairing is supposed to be a cheaper and sustainable option.
Got my screen repaired for 25$ in India. Costs about one fourth of what it would have costed me in US.
Reddy Anna you're Indian only ra.
@@shravan7623 NRI ane concept undhi tammudu
There is something called PPP.
@@Auror2k05 PPP doesn't really apply to this scenario. My phone costs me the same in India (~15000Rs) and elsewhere (~200$). The difference now is how much it costs to repair (2000Rs vs 100$).
@@Auror2k05 But Every indian can afford 25$ , So Our Economic model is better even if you compare in GDP PPP. As we have more options in every aspect
India is a land of Reduce/Repair/Reuse/Reycle/Resale/Redistribute/Repurpose, we not only just recycle or repair we tend to use less resource, keep reusing stuffs, redistribute them to other family members, maids, Repurpose them to something else, resale them(sometimes to 3rd or 4th level of users). And we do it with literally everything starting from cars and motorcycles to house, furniture, to electronics to clothes to plastic bottles. It's a national level OCD and I am proud of it(because I have that RE-OCD even more than the average). The only thing we do need focus is when it comes to food, we waste a lot of food.
Yes
thry show dirty place to defame India dude open ur mind
But nowdays many bad/showoff/दुष्ट people(पृथ्वी पर भार व्यक्ति), due to having increased salaries are just throwing away plastic, 2-3 year old products, clothes, smartphones, home items into the environment instead of repairing or reusing or repurposing them.
Yes , when my father bought a new phone, he gave the old one to my sister for college, when my sister bought a new phone than the old phone was sold to a carpenter who had visited our house for some repairs
@@itsjustpersonalizedviews its as true as India being the 5th largest GDP. The first step of solving an issue is acceptance, my friend.
I've never used a phone for less than 9 years. Never felt like I was lagging behind technologically.
From my perspective, today's consumers are committing an ecological crime when they throw away a device they've used for an year or so.
We don't throw away, we sell in second hand market
So you have just have/had 2 phones?
@@TheBooban that's not true. You don't need the last OS for apps. Most apps require android 5.0 (2014) or 6.0 (2015). So you could buy a phone on 2010 and still get android 5 or 6, so that's an excuse. I don't say you must have a phone for 10 years, but 5 is a good number.
I have my Poco F2 Pro 4 years (from 2020) and I have android 12. So I can hold it for at least 2 or 3 more years and still be able to use 99% of apps.
@@TheBooban One can easily use a mobile device for 5+years. The biggest concern would be 4G 5G 6G upgrades but for an avg user its not an issue. I am still using an 4G device without any issues except when my friends show off their 5G devices.
@@Anonymous-8080 Yep
THANK YOU, INDIA!!! I FUCKING LOVE YOU!!! I swear! I'm so ecstatic with all the great things coming out of India! Keep on rocking the world with all you do! I know things aren't perfect... All countries have their strengths and weaknesses. But I'm loving how much India is rocking the world!~ GO, INDIA!! 🥰
Lol WHites Praising India. 😂 It's a very Rare Thing
@@Manish_254 Heeey... I'm not white! I'm speckled! 😆😂 It's hard to see my freckles in the picture... I'm honestly a huge fan of India~ I've loved Bollywood and Tollywood since university. I'm even trying to learn Hindi and Telugu. It's so hard! I love Japan for saving my life~ And I love India for her unique culture, lovely people, and fantastic music! If I could tan? I would... I can't help being born with Irish skin. But I get it. I completely understand where you're coming from and I'm glad you get a kick out of it~ I'm on Team Humanity! I don't care what country it is, if they're making the world better? I love them!
You are saying u are not white but u are Irish born 😅@@ariadgaia5932
@@ariadgaia5932 amazing
@@ariadgaia5932 good reply, hope you'll do gr8 in your life. Thanks from india
Louis Rossmanns.... Lots of them. The right to repair movement is 🔥 and the EU is fighting on the people's side ❤
India proves right to repair is working. What LR is complaining about is he cant buy spare parts for cheap so he can make a profit.
@@robertlee6338 it's a big problem everywhere. If not for knockoff Chinese parts, many repairs would be impractical. If original parts are available it benefits everyone Except the company so that's part of the fight. Also, I've been following LR since long and he's been advocating for lot more than just cheap parts.
@@robertlee6338 I guess his commentary went over your head!? The biggest problem is serialisation and inability to buy parts in favour of assemblies.
@@Quarky_ No it didnt go over my head, all parts are available, it is cost that you are complaining about
@@robertlee6338 ngl it did go over ur head. Example. Apple's soldered SSDs, touchbar, rivet keyboards. Serialising things like displays, batteries. Many other manufacturers copying the same stuff. It's made to immediately go to E waste even if its just a simple resistor defect.
Let me just appreciate how beautifully this piece has been presented by DW. Detailed. Both from the ground reality to the highest authority and the lady is a charm . God bless.
Hey there! Glad you liked the video. We post videos like this one every Friday and Aditi is one of our regular reporters. Subscribe to our channel to not miss any video ✨
She's fabulous! Content is top notch and I definitely want to encourage and support the lady to keep doing these, she's fantastic at this!
@@TheSkystriderThat's very encouraging, thank you!
Companies are forcing us to buy new products by not giving updates, making it laggy, reducing battery life, degrading camera, making its spare parts unavailable..all these tempts me to buy a new phone else i would happily use my phone atleast 5 years. Presently my average is just three years.
It's the apps making phones laggy. But also yes Android does need to do better to prevent bad apps from ruining the experience.
@@FlabbyTabbybatteries needs to be changed every few years.
Before 2015 it was rare for phones not to have swappable batteries. Now it is rare not to have a permanant sealed battery.
The most common problem which causes people to buy a new phone is degraded battery capacity.
Manufacturers decided to sacrifice the environment with ewaste to make more money.
This should be against the law.
@@soccerchick1 The "lawmakers" (aka politicians) are owned by the corporations. They won't bite the hand that feeds them.
You can still change the battery in repairing stores
@@soccerchick1I think Europe is getting a new law for the batteries to be replaced. Also you can change it yourself, it's super easy. You just need a heat gun or even a hairdryer and a 15 euros aliexpress battery.
@@albertogog8567 I’m in Canada lmao were WAAAAAY behind. Even farther than the US tbh. We pay the most for phones out of anyone in the world smh. You have to order any part online if you can get it here and the shipping ALWAYS cost more than the part itself. We have jump+ and shops like that to fix some problems like screens but that’s about it. Our government does not care about our cost of living tbh.
Can we build a system where electronics manufacturers have to catalog the repair cost of each of the component in the product and the total cost of the components is not allowed to exceed 120% (arbitrary number) of the retail price of the full product.
This should in theory, prevent manufacturers from having excessive markups on the spare parts.
But they are already selling products at low price. For eg the profit from selling 40+ Lakshmi fortuner is 50k or something because GST and road tax is around 18 lakhs so companies make profit using repairs that is why they don't want people to repair or provide parts it is govt that make customers life sh*t
The price at which you are getting these phones are not their MRP
It will be harder. Assembling an entire phone can be done by an unskilled labour. On the other hand, disassembling a phone, finding fault, correcting the fault, and reassembling the phone requires skilled labour, which is costlier than unskilled labour.
Disclosed manufacturing price or cost Its breaches of contract between brand and part manufacturers/vendors ..so no one ready for this legal risk.
Yes, except no one will ever follow such a rigid system for a variety of reasons.
In Tokyo Olympics 2020, Japan made all of the event medals by recycling e-waste. Just an amazing way of how waste can be literally converted to Gold!!!
Yes it is good but it happens at a small scale but we have to do it on a large scale.
Olympic medals are no made of gold, just coating
Recycling most things often needs a great amount of energy and effort which often has a backdoor carbon footprint.
The best way to reduce e waste is to use devices for proper life cycle and only upg after a decent period.
They also made beds of recycled cardboards for everyone, which were able to take weight of atleast 2 people.
My father used his smart phone for 5 years...
After 3 the battery went bad...
He found a shop in my hometown (Mumbai) that replaces only the battery for 20$ and he extended its life by another 2.5 yrs..
He xhanged the battery 3x in that period before the phone died...
Now manufacturers seal the battery in so theres no scope for such knack
India has had repair and upcycling as part of it's culture for generations. Upon realising the state of consumer electronics, as a step to help, I switched to second hand. My two phones, bluetooth speaker, earbuds, monitor and even wired earphones are all second-hand. And I'll make them long last. Thank you for bringing super-important topics like these which fly under the radar!
Hi Sarang! Glad you liked our video 😀 If you want to see more content like this, subscribe to our channel. We post new videos every Friday✨
Our country has a culture of extreme usage of every product 😎👏😎
Shame u cant wipe the tutti 💩from ur streets 🤣
@@gadidakodaka So Delhi is in Pakistan? 🤯 😂
@@userre85it's called not dumping e waste and being resourceful. Where do you think your phone goes?
@@userre85 It's called not being wasteful. Indians aren't mindless consumers. We buy only what's necessary and maximize their utility, even beyond their original purpose.
@@gadidakodaka ah yes only Pakistan can have such a thing (I'm being sarcastic btw). FYI that culture is bigger in India that's why the documentary is on India. You're a fool if you think such a thing is limited to pakistan
10:52 I'm an American and I have to disagree that we're not far behind. I think public opinion in the US is equally in favor of right to repair as it is in the EU, but legislation is much further behind.
The labor cost is astronomical. In 2017, I want to replace my broken laptop screen, the labor cost was $50 on top of screen cost of $45. I watched a DIY YT video and did it myself.
@souravjaiswal-jr4bj in my experience when getting things repaired they tend to list most of the cost as labor costs, regardless of whether they really are. I had my clarinet repaired recently, there was at the time a shortage of the particular piece I needed fixed, and eventually the repair shop, which specializes in repairs not making parts, had to make their own. But they still listed the part as costing next to nothing and all the cost being labor (it was a fair price in total, just the breakdown was wonky).
U haven't seen the scale of e waste from USA and Australia its astronomi ,repair culture isnt even in the mindset for most ,most of the e waste is dumped in developing countries by ships in name of recycling thus polluting whole world not just america
@@souravjaiswal-jr4bj same as anything else think of a mechanic lol.
Right to repair kinda goes against big corp capitalism.
I love how Indian people (still) have the skills available so widely distributed in their country to repair ANYTHING.
When I was in India I saw a person getting their umbrella repaired on the street after it broke after a heavy rain in August. I would have thrown my umbrella away. It really made me think of how wasteful I lived. Unfortunately, in my home country I wouldn't even know where to go with a broken umbrella. People suggest me always to "just throw it away".
it won't have any useful effect. Taylor Swift's emissions are way higher than millions combined. don't worry about planet. we'll be long gone. ig that's one advantage of being a mortal.
Indians like to save and that is not a bad thing that is not "cheap" that is efficient.
The 12k cost is for replacing the screen they are not really repairing, repairing that display will be much cheaper might be around 20$ depends on vendor for your's model in which only the external glass will separated from the screen and new glass will be installed your display will still be original and you will face no issues after that if it is done correctly. I worked in the field and it was fun to work on phones, screen repair is very common most of technician can do that easily, best part about the job is when someone had problem in the motherboard and has shown phone to multiple shops and have no hopes of getting it repaired and then if we are able to fix that thing, the smile on customers face that's the biggest satisfaction
Yeah, most of repair center are just changing spare, not really repairing smh
@@putraduha3176 yup they just replace whole part they don't do any repairing, even if one capacitor is shorted they will repair whole motherboard which is not required and you will loose all your data
Hi Abhishek, where can i get the original spare? I own a k 20 pro and it's working fine only back glass is broken.
@@gouravfromuk service center can provide you 100% original back glass, but you should go in your nearest mobile market and check the quality and price of their glass, they probably have copy but they are also good quality it's upto you, if you wan't to pay extra premium for some quality, back glass doesn't create any difference in actual working
Xiaomi centre....or if you live in big city you can go to local repairing shop@@gouravfromuk
We need a place like this in America.
You need shari'a, hope ilhan omar gives it to you sooner.
@@y.u.so.who said we have shari a It's hindu majority country not muslim
@@y.u.so. Sharia is definitely the worst thing that can happen to the US. Even crony capitalism is better.
The corporations will burn it down, or stop giving "donations" to the government. They only thing you can do in America is what the corporations want, because they are the real rulers of America.
No we do not need any place like any part of India in the US, no no no!
This is not just exclusive to Delhi i live in Goa, and if you have anything that's broken there's always someone who knows how to fix it at any market with equipment they found in the kitchen
Recognise the beautiful Asian repair shops going against western rich lobbyists. In Thailand I found drum vats of printer ink connected to suction pipes directly on to the printer cartridges, even Philippine’s when I travelled had the same repair shop for everything. The more I grow up the more I understand western greed hiding behind law making governments.
So happy to see someone covering this problem; the throwaway culture has started to penetrate Indian society which is going to be a big problem.
Hey there! Glad you liked our video 😀 If you want to see more videos like these, subscribe to our channel. We post new videos every Friday ✨
Thank you Aditi Rajagopal for another insightful contribution.
Hey there! Glad you like the video and our reporter. Aditi is a regular on our channel. Subscribe to us to not miss any of her videos ✨
8:05 oh my gowd worlds least repair friendly company on right to repair portal 🍎 🤯
unsurprisingly the only thing they have on the portal is some links to their official device support websites. No direct links to manuals or part details.
As of now, that portal is mostly useless. Will be interesting to see how government acts in near future.
Hey there! Right now, the framework is voluntary. The Parliament still has to pass it.
Quite easy to replace screen tbh, only issue is getting good quality display. Often parts are sold as genuine/original yet they obviously are way worse.
The way they'r manufactured, you need specialized tools and gadgets to remove old screen and fix the new one in its place
I study in Germany. In theory we learn a lot about life cycle assessment and reparing, etc.
But very rarely something is repaired here.
And it's disappointing.
Personally i find cheaper phones to be more repairable, i for example have already replaced the battery and the charger PCB for my Redmi phone.
Amazing piece of Journalism. This was so needed in India and around the world
Hey there! Glad you liked our video ✨ If you want to see more videos like these, we post every Friday. Subscribe to our channel to be notified about it 😊✨
In China, there are a biggest market of Refurbished Mobile & these are export to Africa & rest of the country.
India have the opportunities to get the market.
Now need skilled Labour as well as eco collection process of set collection.
Its the companies that are making repair difficult and also not providing spare parts to third party
Loved the detailed information & non biasness towards India, DW ❤
Thank you, we really appreciate it! If you want to see more videos from us, subscribe to our channel 😊
A decade ago, I could have easily repaired most of my electronics with ease and at low cost. Now its difficult to find a store with right knowledge/skills and spare parts. Even if you do find one, its expensive.
Everything has to have a gd computer inside of it now so you’re unable to fix it yourself. Not just a simple fix.
The reporter could have found a better model of her phone at cheaper price in these same market. In India returning products when replacing with new is very common. And hence there is a huge market of selling second products too. Yes mobile phones are sort of very small number but larger appliances, you can buy the best brands at less than half the price any day.
Only wise doing that if ownership is properly transferred. You don't know who will end up having that phone and use it how. It shouldn't link back to you if they do anything illegal using the phone
Remarkable video! It’s alarming to see how rapidly electronic waste is growing and the detrimental impact it has on our environment. It’s heartening to see India’s innovative approach to tackle this issue. The Right To Repair and Circular Economy are indeed crucial steps towards a sustainable future. Planet A’s commitment to exploring eco-friendly alternatives and challenging our perceptions about climate change is commendable. Looking forward to more insightful content every Friday. Together, we can make a difference. 🌍💚
Thank you for your feedback. Make sure to subscribe not to miss any of the upcoming videos! 💎
We have had a repair and reuse culture by default in Indian families.
This culture of buying every two years was new to me as I grew up.
So developing countries in general are proactive in that regard I think, UNLESS consumer behavior is being forcefully manipulated by giants like Google and Apple by bringing annual features and deeming their older models incompetent.
This should be reigned in and a Irrepairabikity tax should be imposed on products that are low on reoairability.
Good that India also tries to tackle this issue. But more impactful are the EUs steps for right to repair as no company can deny the European market. You can see now that this legislation will cascade down to other countries to adopt those norms as well. Happy to see all of these developments.
Yeah E.U needs to keep punishing these big tech companies.
That's why they said, Europe + some months is the timing or deadline.
Yes, he said EU+6 months, EU can take those steps as they have a rich consumer market, so companies will have to follow them for sure
I have had my MI phone from 2019 and still working great, i used to switch phone yearly before but now i am very proud to be using same phone for 5 years and gonna drag one more year, and buy second hand phone after. I am proud because i know the things about the e-waste and climate, if we want more people to have such mindset, right education and messege like this should be promoted so people are proud to use things for years instead of proud to be buying the most expensive and latest gadget available in market (which all company wants you to do).
Hey there! Thanks for sharing your experience with us 😊 we did a video on the concept of degrowth, making less things and fighting overconsumption. You can find it here 👉ruclips.net/video/_22mKe_OLsg/видео.html
While some spare parts are horrendously marked up, this misses the fact that providing a whole spare parts supply chain is far from free, volumes a lower, storage times are longer, and more.
And this doesn’t include the labour costs associated with dismantling, diagnosing and reassembling which is typically a very manual process compared to the highly automated processes of initial assembly
The repairability should be a design consideration to make the manual process smoother. Most companies actually try to discourage this by unnecessarily complicating the design.
I agree with you on the logistics issue of spare parts though
I agree on one part that the supply chain issue is there. But if you document the repair process, then I'm sure there is an equivalent unbranded product in the chinese market that is going to be in the supply chain.
And for the reparibility, phones were fine with metal backs and glue only for the display where the rest of the parts can be removed. And yet they stayed the same weight as phones made now. I mean there is a way to make products look beautiful even with visible screws
these markets wouldn't thrive without people unnecessarily throwing away things that could be repaired
@@sidarthg2477 chinese parts only work for parts that are easily reverse engineered. No company would be prepared to give up sensitive IP so another company can make a spare part without rigorous licensing deals in place. And this actually the current state of affairs. Outside samsung, most major players phones are contract manufactured (in china).
Most phones also offer ingress protection that wasn’t available with the old screwed on metal backs (and while still possible would increase costs significantly. Plus using single/limited cycle micro connectors etc are all there to save costs and make the phones less serviceable
1:38 They're quoting excessive sums b/c she talks and looks like an NRI and is running around with a crew working for a western media outlet lol
Vendors in India will absolutely stiff you if they think you're not a local.
my grandparents still use their old ass nokia from 2003 that's pretty crazy compared to newer android phones that will literally break down after 3 years
Why did you specify android? Are you an iSheep?
A guy who fixes the mobile phone with a lighter 😂😂😂
Hey, as long as it works okay.
Heating loosens the gum attaching the screen.
flame is flame
It is one of the techniques to seal and wiggle tightly wound things
It is called jugaad.
You can sell your broken phone to repair shops. They can use functional parts for other customers.
It's not like corporations who are stealing intellectual property are waiting for the repair bill to pass to do it
appreciate the patience of reporter in doing this story. I am sure she has to go on a learning curve for this
Who’s upgrading from the iPhone 14 Pro Max to the iPhone 15 Pro Max 🙌
People literally do this, which is crazy!
Motorola toyed with the idea of modular mobiles, I wonder why it has not manifested…it’s such a good idea to improve longevity of devices while upgrading functionality and reducing e-waste.
Amazing reporter btw! She speaks so clearly 👍
Google created a project named ARA, a modular smartphone eventually they dropped it in its final stage.
Phone screen repair costs are really expensive especially iPhone display that can cost upto rs30k in India
I only own recycled phones and refurbished laptops - they are functioning ok after the repair
When I have a device "repaired" what happened really was that one component was replaced, usually the screen for almost the same price as a new phone. I'm not sure how that solves this issue bearing in mind all the extra packaging and all that
Loved this episode!! Very informative and shows India in good light for a change!
Hey there! Thanks, happy to hear that you liked the video. We post videos like these every week btw. Feel free to subscribe to our channel ✨
“I just watched and learned”. LOVE IT
Repair of Electronic equipment is very a very delicate work and not many people can do it right. I had a chinese android phone worth $145 and it lasted a good 3 years untill it's display died so I decided to get it repaired with fake non-warranty display which costed me $15 but while fixing the display they damaged the charging IC and tried to charge me another $8 but I refused bcause by then I had realized that it's better to buy a new phone because there's no guarantee if they could fix my phone.
My father has been using his HP laptop since 2009. It cost a lot back in 2009, and has had a couple of battery changes but he still uses it & honestly it's brilliant & beautiful. Same for his phone, till 2021 he was using his beloved Samsung Note 3, had it's screen( broke it while on a run) & battery changed once though. It's genuinely a wonderful thing to repair & reuse, my mum, sister & i do the same thing too & using a phone for 5 years is like the minimum period for us. Infact, i just went to get my old phone repaired yestsrday. Btw, i am Indian.
Please look up "Louis Rossmann".
I can watch mr. Rossmann work for hours on end. True mastery of a craft in action. If you don't know him already (you probably do) NorthridgeFix is a similar RUclips channel and he is also very good at what he does. He's worth checking out too
Making easily repairable devices also has an associated cost. The fairphone is a good example of this, it is bigger/bulkier, heavier and more expensive than equivalent performance models from other manufacturers.
Making electronics compact and “cheap” (automated) to assemble often uses techniques that are inherently difficult to repair.
The fairer option of anything is always more expensive! I think I'm going to buy a Fairphone once my old one stops working - I like that they even have on their site that "the most ecological/fair phone you can have is the one you already own" (paraphrased)
@@hrani not always, but in consumer electronics it is a good rule of thumb. There is definitely a market out there, but the fact is the majority of consumers are either quite cost sensitive, or aesthetics/marketing sensitive
I don't see how repairable makes things always more bulky.
FairPhone is a bad example because
1. They only have access to limited parts they can build with
2. Simply including a fair wage makes it "expensive" (or, in other words: As cheap as can be without exploiting)
An easily repairable device is something that has easily available spare parts and instruction manuals on replacement steps. That is exactly what companies are avoiding by making special custom parts and tools AND not making them available to the public. It has nothing to do with being modular or open.
@@jurgennicht4626 I would assume there's always a very slight weight increase when using less delicate components and shapes, and planning for easy access has an effect on the layout of things... For example, eight tiny screws holding parts in housings and their fixings probably take up more weight and space than a hair thin layer of epoxy holding down a piece that everything else is under!
Making it more bulky because of making it more durable is probably also a design choice: they know people who want it won't mind too much.
I’m using my XR for 5 years now. It’s really cheap to get spare parts. And I’m definitely holding it for a few more years.
This is excellent journalism, very well done !
Kinda motovated to keep stuff now
Hey there! Glad you liked our video 😀 If you want to see more videos like these, subscribe to our channel, we post new videos every Friday ✨
i want that caddy people at 12:07 are playing with, to uprade my old laptop for ssd.
They actually sell a frame for that you can remove your hdd and use a ssd in that frame
@@salempasangasp yah that was what i was referring to. i was looking for one and this video popped up next minute
I really love this documentary or article. I bought my Nexus 6, 2years after the launch (dead cheaper) and used it for 4.5 yrs (I had to resell as it was not going dead).
Bought pixel 2 as soon as it is launched and used it for 6 yrs.
And now with thorough research bought Agni 2 a pseudo Desi product. Very good and very very underrated one. Have been using since it launch. Need to see how long this lasts.
Note: I have spent around 14K-6K for screen replacements. Once with Nexus 6(slipped from my hand) and replaced screen twice of pixel 2 (in my wife's hand😜) later on I took good care of it.😊.
Observation is I never stopped any security/patch updates.
I am planning to stop security updates once the patches tenure is over for Agni 2.
Hi there! Thanks for your feedback and sharing your experience 😊 If you want to see more videos like these, subscribe to our channel, we post new videos every Friday ✨
I’ve got a iPhone 7. Had it forever and didn’t buy new. It’s not as fast or sleek but it does what I need it to do.
yesterday i got my philips speaker repaired for 5 USD in local market, now they work same as new one.
i'd like cost to own and average lifespan as mandatory on all vehicles and houses. the average annual sum of costs that will be incurred for stuff like repairs, maintenance, gas, and such. and if the property is properly maintained how long it is likely to last. before it will need replaced
Repair cost from company's authorized store are very high. For example, my Pixel 4a screen broke last year, and it cost me 10k from an authorized repair store for screen and back cover replacement. At times, parts are not available in the local market, which forces the consumer to go to authorized stores where are charges are way higher. But I should also mention that repair store also changed my battery for free.
Nice documentary, thanks for interesting informations👌🏻
Hey there! Very glad to hear that you liked the video! We post new videos every Friday. If you want to watch them, subscribe to be notified ✨
I'm still using my 6 year old smartphone.😅
Those 6 year old smartphones are quite cheap to buy second hand nowadays and they still run most apps like a brand new one
I love your videos! Talented reporter and always super interesting subjects around sustainability etc 💙
Hey there! Glad to hear you like our videos and our reporter. Subscribe to our channel to not miss any new videos✨
@@DWPlanetA 💙👍🤩
the host, the editing, the topic, the vibe, loving everything about this style of content
Hey there! Thanks so much, glad you liked it. We post videos like these every week and Aditi is one of our regular reporters. Subscribe to our channel to not miss any video ✨
I also like to roam around the market like this and get quotes for stuff before deciding about it long
Must implement the Right to Repair
Underrated documentation, great work
Hi there! Glad you liked our video 😀 You can subscribe to our channel, to see more content like this! We post new videos every Friday ✨
These is a documentary of Shenzen market people should watch that
My iPhone 11 is five years old and still a flagship imo. And its actually pretty repairable. Love it
Don't go looking nice if you want best price
My first PC was an assembled one, and I ran it as long as I could with RAM and video card upgrades. Sadly, there came a time to upgrade the CPU, but the new ones weren’t backward-compatible with the RAM and video card, so the idea of modularity went right out the window.
Later, I owned a Nokia 3310 which was built like a tank and lasted me 5 years before I was forced to buy myself a smartphone to go the digital path that India was marching on.
It took three tries with Samsung before I realised that the security and linearity of Apple software (not hardware, mind you) is what made for much longer lasting phones. Now, I’ve owned an iPhone 11 for the last 4 (5?) years which still works as well as the day I bought it, with a battery that still shows 98% capacity, and I intend to run it till the time it dies on me.
Mandating modularity and the right to repair on the manufacturers is one thing, and lauding the repair culture in India is another, but choosing the right device, caring for it well and running it to the maximum extent possible are also crucial tools in reducing ewaste.
Excellent reporting!
Almost all of my phone is second hand one only 2 new and the reason is change phone cant play game i want or there's no new battery sell ( not refurbished mind u ) so how they solve the battery one ?
Now if only Apple would be okay with such an idea
This is my first video of yours.
I am impressed with the quality of content in the first glance
Keep up the good work
Happy you liked the video! You can subscribe to our channel to make sure not to miss any of the coming videos. ✨🧚♂️
Awesome work
My phone is almost 5yrs old, it had 2 battery replacement, 1 screen replacement, 2 charging port replacement.
And its working fine.
Indian can fix/repair anything.
Excellent stuff shown
Hey there! Glad you liked our video. We post videos like these every week - subscribe to our channel to not miss any!
a fascinating video on an underexplored topic as always, bravo!
Hey there! Glad you liked it 😀 If you want to see more videos like this one, subscribe to our channel, we post new videos every Friday ✨
Same with Malaysia, plenty Malaysian repair back they smartphone, mine Asus ROG phone 2 repair 2X times, still using along Sony Xperia Pro-i
Ive been using and iPhone 5s and iPhone 7 for years and still working to this day.
Good! I hope we return to more reliable and long lasting products, especially ones that can be easily reused/recycled.
I've had my note 10 + refurbished twice since I bought it new in 2019. Still works flawlessly. And a new battery and screen every two years. 300$ and Samsung does it themselves
I've heard many people say 2019 was the peak of samsung
Much needed topic😢😢😢😢
Like SIM give ROM and RAM removable so we can put in new handset?!
We will sure of not leaking private data?! 😢😮
Indian ENGINEERS , Doctors, repair technician come from highly compitative 1.4 billion people nation,..so huge merit to them
I found it's not too hard to replace you phone screen at home! (depending on the model)
From zips to chips let's fix 🤖
😂🎉
@@aditirajagopal 🤖🙏
I used a touch screen Phone from 2013 till 2020, the current one is nearing four years old, and, I plan to keep it for as long as I can. This in addition to a basic Phone which I am using since 2014. Used well and maintained well, electronic gadgets can last very long, but, the best option is to not buy a new replacement device just because it is launched or introduced to the market.
Amazing documentary! The views of these ewaste dumps were so dystopian to me. I'm not a fan of ewaste in general, and it's one of the reasons I'm iffy about aliexpress and temu selling cheap electronics with a short lifespan. To see all this trash piled in such masses is another reminder of how big of a problem that really is. I never understood why the blockphone didn't make the market. A phone with infinitely interchangeable components, much like a desktop computer, and then I learned about profit margins. Companies will choose finance over ethics at all times, which is nothing but natural in the current global climate. This is why a government should intervene, for the sake of the people. You can't expect a financially driven conglomerate to leave money at stake for the sake of society. Like that one man said, it's a difficult balance, but in situations like these answers should be rather obvious. I think the EU made a good decision with the USB-C enforcement, and it's great to see a developing nation like India jump on to that. It's a small start to a better world, and truth be told, it's better to build that world together.
I too tried to get the battery of my iPhone replaced as there was nothing wrong with it, but was rebuffed. Bought a samsung and have had it for many years now.
Still rocking my SE 2 since 2020 and it's getting updates, supports all the apps that I need and functions well enough.. problem in India is many people prefer buying 150-200$ phones 2-3 times within 5 years than getting single phone which will last for the same 5 years bcs former won't get updates/won't support new apps that might be necessary for said person or simply doesn't work as expected after 1st year. If Apple can lover prices or some Android manufacturers can offer better phones at 150-250usd range there will be much less waste
Interesting video great job 👍
Thanks for your feedback! If you enjoy our content, subscribe to our channel 😉 We release new videos every Friday ✨
Remember no matter how Unfixable you make your product,
1) There's always a Chinese who'll make it cheaper
2) There's always an Indian who'll fix it.
Good to see content like this from India....
Hey there! Glad you liked our video 😀 If you want to see more videos like these, subscribe to our channel, we post new videos every Friday 😊✨
I repaired my I phone-7 3 yrs ago with cheap display over brand display only in 1/6th value and it's still working without any warranty...it save me aprox 500 dollars minimum on buying new or replace display
I started leaving my smartphone at home while going out of the house and I enjoy my outings so much more!
Certainly repair is the best option as long as it is possible. I have been using my iPhone 11 Pro since 2020. Still going strong with no slowdown and battery is still good! Lasts the whole day. I thank Apple for this.