Pull-ups vs Chin-ups: The Big Difference

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 дек 2024

Комментарии • 685

  • @7msjster
    @7msjster 8 месяцев назад +73

    I'm female, almost 69 and fit! listen to your body...i began my pullup journey doing narrow grip, palms facing. It was easy on my shoulder. As I got stronger, I started changing the width and the angle... I'm now doing Lhangs with pullups, over and underhand grip! I hang or pull myself on anything I find and just do a few. I even go to a couple of playgrounds where I am the grandma doing the monkey bars! Just do it!

    • @chriswashingtonbeats
      @chriswashingtonbeats 4 месяца назад +4

      Big respect

    • @poi__peter
      @poi__peter 3 месяца назад +4

      Interesting that you started with a narrow grip and then worked your way outwards over time. 🙏

    • @Em-yo6by
      @Em-yo6by 3 месяца назад +3

      Hell yeah!

    • @7msjster
      @7msjster 3 месяца назад +3

      ​@@poi__peter It was logical because narrow grip allows you to pull up easier because you engage your back more when you are not focused on how much it hurts the shoulder to be in it's weakest dynamic. As I was getting stronger to then go into a bicep pullup or chin up. All of that was just conditioning for what the shoulder has to go through being the smallest muscle group that gets hurt the easyest. I feel that my shoulders had to get into condition of strength and mobility...Now that I can do them, I'm cleaning up the movement.

    • @poi__peter
      @poi__peter 3 месяца назад +3

      @7msjster Thabks ! this is Fantastic information on some of the pull up progressions
      and strength building / conditioning for your shoulders that occurred over time. very useful to know for my own practice. Take it slowly and work on mastering the easier progressions before moving on to avoid injury🙏

  • @JamesFischer_35
    @JamesFischer_35 Год назад +681

    according to Mike Mentzer, close grip chin up is by far the best biceps exercise. Its much better than ANY of the curl movements because biceps is a 2 joint muscle and curls only activates lower part of biceps whereas chin ups activate both lower part and shoulder connection of biceps.
    old but gold.

    • @jackcarpenters3759
      @jackcarpenters3759 Год назад +21

      yes narrow grip chin up was best in overal emg in a study. It also works your pecs!

    • @reconstructionwouldhavesav9472
      @reconstructionwouldhavesav9472 Год назад +19

      It sucks for actual bicep mass

    • @jackcarpenters3759
      @jackcarpenters3759 Год назад +17

      @@reconstructionwouldhavesav9472No, but there are 2 ways to even increase more according to studies: Do a biceps exercise afterwards, especially concentration curl. Or do instead of the narrow grip chinup the pull where your head goes alternating left/right of the bar, where your grip is like playing a trumpet. It had biggest biceps emg.

    • @miquebts
      @miquebts Год назад

      He was lying, chin ups are for lats

    • @DonHoinbaras
      @DonHoinbaras Год назад +5

      Mentzer also recommended chin ups and chin-grip pulldowns for the lats

  • @cas2985
    @cas2985 Год назад +241

    Pull ups are more functional. You wouldn’t climb up onto a ledge using an underhand grip.

    • @bxnxjmin
      @bxnxjmin 8 месяцев назад +125

      how often are you climbing ledges that this is a consideration? lol

    • @revinhomerescamposano2654
      @revinhomerescamposano2654 8 месяцев назад +15

      I think you punch better with pull ups

    • @superbigidiot
      @superbigidiot 8 месяцев назад +8

      I feel like underhand grips are fairly useful when climbing overhangs that require compressions though.

    • @j.m.w.5064
      @j.m.w.5064 8 месяцев назад +12

      ​@@bxnxjmin how often do you need to peek over a bar? lol
      🙄

    • @jackcylow
      @jackcylow 8 месяцев назад +13

      But chin ups make me perform my shoryuken better.

  • @eric669
    @eric669 Год назад +513

    I alternate them in the gym, both adding weight to my belt. I can do 7 or 8 reps in my first set of both variations with a 20Kg plate added to my bodyweight. Not bad for 54!

    • @fit_4ever
      @fit_4ever  Год назад +16

      👏

    • @irishmick6709
      @irishmick6709 Год назад +1

      @@freespeech4023….I've got one for you! My latest routine ( once or twice a week) is to perform 150 pullups/ chins/ mixed grip in under 20 minutes (18 minutes even just yesterday) just body weight though - 180 pounds 70 years young!

    • @Sezam3k
      @Sezam3k Год назад +13

      @@freespeech4023 and I can do 100 push ups with you and your weights on my back 😂

    • @freespeech4023
      @freespeech4023 Год назад +2

      @@Sezam3k 😂

    • @randomscandinavian6094
      @randomscandinavian6094 Год назад +12

      I’m also 54 and I’m nowhere near being able to do one pull-up. Been training specifically for that now, a few times a week for 3/4 of a year. 😂

  • @davepazz580
    @davepazz580 Год назад +69

    Pull-ups using gymnastics ring... starting with a pull-up grip at the bottom of the rep, then rotating the hands while ascending until you end up in a chin-up grip at the top of the rep.

  • @jimmyjustright1609
    @jimmyjustright1609 Год назад +106

    It depends on what your goals are. I do weighted, wide pull ups and have noticed significant growth in my lats. I only do chins when I also want to target my biceps during a back set. Time is important, so I'm always incorporating supersets or more during a workout.

    • @jimmyjustright1609
      @jimmyjustright1609 Год назад +4

      @thetej2227 yes, sir! Spreading the word even on a workout channel. I can dig it! Surrender your will daily!

    • @Jalabeoth
      @Jalabeoth Год назад +1

      ​@@jimmyjustright1609surrender your will? I thought God gave us free will. Why would I surrender it?

    • @jimmyjustright1609
      @jimmyjustright1609 Год назад +3

      @mjollnirjc because we all fall short of God's glory. All men are fallible and unless we accept Christ we cannot have a relationship with our Creator. We're called to surrender to our Lord. My will has and always will fail me. I chose to surrender my will to the Father's daily. It is a choice. Will you continue doing what you've always done and maybe find worldy success or will you surrender your will to your Creators who'll bless you for eternity. All men, No matter how successful you think they are have failed themselves and others and always will. There's only one who is perfect.

    • @1saadx
      @1saadx Год назад

      God never had a son - Jesus christ was a man and a prophet - and if he ever decided to have one why do you think He would choose a weak human race instead of creating a mighty being or an angel?@@thetej2227

    • @theironsheik6322
      @theironsheik6322 Год назад +2

      @@thetej2227 Austin 3:16 said I just whipped your ass!

  • @luv4tig
    @luv4tig Год назад +56

    I had only did pull ups in the past. But decided to also add an equal set of chin ups to build the biceps and eliminate curls. I do weighted sets for pull ups and chin ups.

    • @El_Guapo321
      @El_Guapo321 Год назад +1

      Do you notice more gains with the chin ups?

    • @MarcoAshford
      @MarcoAshford Год назад

      @@El_Guapo321I noticed my bicep blows up in size. Just doing 4 sets of 5 slow and controlled rep

    • @noweare1
      @noweare1 Год назад +14

      I use my fat belly for the weights.

    • @johand3004
      @johand3004 Год назад +4

      Eliminating curls is stupid. Don’t reinvent the wheel

    • @jonmoris9354
      @jonmoris9354 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@johand3004why not curls are not needed

  • @FourHorsemen-k2y
    @FourHorsemen-k2y Год назад +118

    You cannot go wrong alternating between both pull ups and chin ups, throw some Dips and push-ups to the mix and that’s going to be a beautiful thing when you start a push - pull program doing body weight exercises ⚡️

    • @igorkonforovich3497
      @igorkonforovich3497 Год назад +3

      Dips are terrible both for shoulder and wrist joints, throw them as far away as possible.

    • @allucardesubs777
      @allucardesubs777 Год назад

      ​@@igorkonforovich3497tf.. nah

    • @razikazmi6840
      @razikazmi6840 Год назад

      @@igorkonforovich3497i thought they help shoulders if u get form down? Idk abt wrist tho

    • @v01d_r34l1ty
      @v01d_r34l1ty Год назад

      @@igorkonforovich3497how?

    • @francisco77220
      @francisco77220 Год назад

      ​@@igorkonforovich3497no man, it'all about mobility. Dips are fundamental

  • @Jaye-dd8dg
    @Jaye-dd8dg Год назад +50

    both pull ups and chin ups should be in your routine as well as the neutral grip variation... you can build a well developed back/shoulders/chest/arms/core using these 3 exercises alone; master them and you'll build a strength that will translate positively to every lift in the gym - neglect them and you'll likely never even bench 2 plates.

    • @okdac2559
      @okdac2559 Год назад +3

      How pull ups and chin ups improve chest?

    • @dantemustson
      @dantemustson Год назад +4

      @@okdac2559 benching is not only a Chest/tricep excerise. It engages lats, core to stabilize. Strong posterior chain allows you to arch better and more stable. Also strong quads will give you a leg drive

    • @topman6727
      @topman6727 Год назад +2

      I can go weeks and months without doing chins or pulls and bench 100kg 😮

    • @Ahrone1586
      @Ahrone1586 Год назад +2

      ​@@topman6727thats not the point xd

    • @shinigami9859
      @shinigami9859 Год назад +1

      I know plently of people who bench for more than 225 who don't train them lmao.... tf u on

  • @baronmeduse
    @baronmeduse Год назад +39

    Better for what? Since it is primarily considered a back exercise and clearly hits the back more, pull ups are the best exercise for that. In chins your arms can exhaust far more quickly than your back will so that the exercise peters out before the back is ever anywhere near failure. Making it more like an overblown exercise for biceps and a moderate exercise for the back/core. Doing pull ups and then taking biceps immediately to failure with a curl gets you the entire thing. Pull-ups are better.

  • @noosphericaltarzan
    @noosphericaltarzan Год назад +48

    When I trained calisthenics, I started with pull ups and finished with chin ups. Really: wide grip pull ups, standard pull ups, chin ups, narrow grip chin ups (by then it’s like three reps per set). They are all great, but if I only did one, it was a chin up.

    • @vidalbalkaran3691
      @vidalbalkaran3691 Год назад +1

      especially if done on gymnastic rings

    • @SolidestAutumn
      @SolidestAutumn Год назад

      Did your biceps grow a lot with Chin-ups?

    • @noosphericaltarzan
      @noosphericaltarzan Год назад +2

      @@SolidestAutumn A bit. Not like what happened from constantly cleaning weights in Olympic weightlifting and kettlebell sport. If I wanted to target biceps for hypertrophy using calisthenics, I would combine false grip chin ups (with isometric) holds and things like high rep pelican curls.

    • @TakenBySS
      @TakenBySS 8 месяцев назад

      Hey, I have a question how do you still have the strength to do all that?

    • @noosphericaltarzan
      @noosphericaltarzan 8 месяцев назад

      @@TakenBySS One or the other.

  • @Ex0dus111
    @Ex0dus111 Год назад +82

    Hopefully absolutely no one takes this seriously.
    The Pull Ups are a back building exercise that unlocks the lats, like no other exercise can. This is ESSENTIAL for a full body program to keep your physique balanced.
    Venturing into the harder pull ups, like wide grip and archers, is the best way to ensure a strong a functional back.
    Yes, Chin Ups are a good biceps exercise, but so are lots of other exercises.

    • @until3am
      @until3am Год назад +8

      Exactly

    • @mikaelbentley9870
      @mikaelbentley9870 Год назад +19

      Pull ups also translate into getting onto an object. Chin ups are cool, but I haven’t figured out how to punch through a wall to obtain a grip to do chin ups onto a roof or fence.

    • @monkemode8128
      @monkemode8128 Год назад

      @@mikaelbentley9870 strength is strength. From only training chin ups and now weighted chin ups I went from having a pull up 1RM of +10 lbs to now +65 lbs. They're very similar, building strength in one is going to build strength in the other. It's like leg press and squats, someone who squats 500 lbs is going to be a strong leg presser regardless of it they train on the leg press consistently.

    • @jericho-tube
      @jericho-tube Год назад

      ​​@@mikaelbentley9870why you want to jump over the fence ? Only monkey does that 😂😂😂. Are you planning to steal or what ? 😂. These youtube kids are insane 😂

    • @jericho-tube
      @jericho-tube Год назад +2

      Stong and functional back ? Chin ups will also keep yr back functional, your back won's break while walking on the street 😂

  • @baidajel
    @baidajel Год назад +70

    Chin ups = More biceps, Pull ups = More Back

    • @Nobody-Nowhere
      @Nobody-Nowhere 2 месяца назад +1

      chin ups = beginner stuff, pull ups = the real thing

    • @baidajel
      @baidajel 2 месяца назад +3

      @@Nobody-Nowhere lol just an FYI I can do muscles ups as well, it's not about skill it's about what body part you wanna hit

    • @Ben-zr5ib
      @Ben-zr5ib Месяц назад

      I can do more pull ups than chin ups
      Im just more used to it i guess

    • @baidajel
      @baidajel Месяц назад

      @@Ben-zr5ib your biceps must look significantly small compared to your back and triceps I'm guessing ? if not small then maybe you have a weaker biceps

    • @Ben-zr5ib
      @Ben-zr5ib Месяц назад

      @@baidajel i guess , been doing only pullups so generally feels easier

  • @owenwright4927
    @owenwright4927 7 месяцев назад +9

    Starting off with chin-ups is a good start for me I can’t do pull-ups so chin-ups are a good movement to start on working your biceps but your still working your whole back

  • @PeacePham1991
    @PeacePham1991 Год назад +44

    Chin-ups do work on your abs as well. When I was in high school, I got 6 packs from doing chin ups

    • @Alexanderthenotsobad
      @Alexanderthenotsobad 6 месяцев назад +3

      Dude, I hate to break it to you, you may have been born with "six-pack abs"... You were likely just been very fit.

    • @ekie7473
      @ekie7473 6 месяцев назад +12

      ​@@Alexanderthenotsobadboth chin ups and pull ups still will train the core.

    • @gonderAmh
      @gonderAmh 5 месяцев назад +11

      @@Alexanderthenotsobad everyone is born with "six-pack abs" most people are just too fat to be visible. But he's right, I have more soreness on my abs by doing pullups than by doing specific abs exercice

    • @Alexanderthenotsobad
      @Alexanderthenotsobad 5 месяцев назад +2

      @@gonderAmh Although I appreciate your profile pic, and your comment, not everyone is born with "six"-pack abs. Some naturally have "eight" pack abs (the freaks of nature), and some only four... feel free to look it up...

    • @gonderAmh
      @gonderAmh 5 месяцев назад

      @@Alexanderthenotsobad most people have 6, and yes some people are also born with 3 tits and 3 balls

  • @maulekuul
    @maulekuul Год назад +44

    I've actually been doing mixed grip sets with one palm forward, one palm backward, and alternating sides each set. It feels like a nice balance and a very natural motion, like climbing a tree. You wouldn't pull your body weight up to a branch in a pull-up or chin-up style. You'd wrap your hands around the branch with a mixed grip.

    • @iangraham-white5717
      @iangraham-white5717 Год назад +3

      I would because I can do multiple sets of 8-12 weighted pull-ups

    • @maulekuul
      @maulekuul Год назад +10

      @@iangraham-white5717 I guess you are extra special

    • @austintorrence5400
      @austintorrence5400 Год назад +3

      Crazy thing is a guy that works out at the job was just telling me thats how he do his pull ups.
      I said I have to try it.

    • @USERA15
      @USERA15 4 месяца назад +1

      El agarre mixto me encanta,.es.muy natural y además también trabajan muy bien el abdomen y el pecho.

  • @SCALES1992
    @SCALES1992 Год назад +10

    Great core activation as well especially if you maintain a straight posture while performing the movements.

    • @ramon3077
      @ramon3077 Год назад +1

      Used to be fat, got incredibly solid abs from doing hollowbody chins over the years. Highly recommended for this.

  • @mishkosimonovski23
    @mishkosimonovski23 Год назад +16

    Pull Ups and Chin Ups are best exercises, it blows my back, biceps, chest and abs like no other. And i dont injure unlike from Dead-L or Barb-Row. Sadly i was never able to do more than 6.

    • @WhoFlungDung
      @WhoFlungDung Год назад +3

      I've noticed my abs are the most sore after doing pullups/chinups over any isolated ab exercise. It's great for the core.

    • @shahbazkhan-ek7hp
      @shahbazkhan-ek7hp Год назад +2

      Try L Sit chinups and you will feel it in the quads and lower abs as well.

    • @USERA15
      @USERA15 4 месяца назад

      Son los ejercicios más completos para todo el torso

  • @Fitness4London
    @Fitness4London Год назад +11

    Both are great to incorporate into your workouts.

  • @johns7530
    @johns7530 Год назад +11

    For many people who are not that strong, doing assisted chin ups or pull ups on either an assisted machine, or doing them on a pulley type machine is much better, b/c you can reduce the weight. If you can only do a couple chin or pull ups, it's gonna be real hard to progress. If you do something where you can do 8-10 reps and steadily increase how much weight you do (or decrease the amount of assistance), you are much more likely to maintain and use better form than if you are straining using maximal effort all the time. Sometimes less is more, esp if somebody is not already strong enough to do several unassisted pull or chin ups.

    • @Ollieoost28
      @Ollieoost28 Год назад +1

      I started doing 2 chin ups weighing 240 pounds. I started doing it everyday. After 1 month can do now 10 strict pull ups and chin ups. Train hard and be patient. Nothing is hard if i believe in it. Your mind is stronger than you think 💪

    • @johns7530
      @johns7530 Год назад

      @@Ollieoost28 Solid achievement, very glad that approach worked for you! Depends on your age though. I'm in my early 50's, and a friend of mine who is close to my age tore his rotator cuff a couple years or so ago attempting to do pull ups. Sometimes less is more, and the hardest exercises not the best place to start. It's not that different from starting out with maximum weight on a bench press, most people are better off starting to work with a weight they can do 10 times or something rather than just once or twice. I used to be able to bench press twice my body weight about 25 years ago, and have had all kinds of neck, back, and shoulder issues, with tons of chronic tension in those areas. Heavy and intense training is not always the best for people's bodies in the long run, and sometimes the negative effects are not visible until the wear and tear on the body becomes evident years later. Based on my own experience in the gym 5 days/week for more than 20 years, I think lighter weights and less resistance (and greater variety) are better places for most people to start. Just be careful and notice how your body feels, but that's not to take anything away from your progress, great for you man! 💪

    • @JustanamebroDK
      @JustanamebroDK 10 месяцев назад +1

      Just do pull up negatives, inverted rows and band/pulley assisted pullups and you will have pull ups in no time no machines needed. There's always a natural progression without machine, I prefer pure calisthenics myself but both will work.

    • @BWater-yq3jx
      @BWater-yq3jx 9 месяцев назад +1

      Lat pull-downs, visualising pullup technique, are better.
      There's something about assisted pullup machines that just feels disconnected and 'off'.

  • @ChicagoJ351
    @ChicagoJ351 8 месяцев назад +5

    The biggest issue with chin ups is if you use a doorway pull up bar, there isn’t usually a good grip to use.
    The way the bars are constructed, there are usually bars in the way of a good grip. You need a gym, solid bar, rings or some other way to do them. I love chin ups, but it’s hard to find equipment to do them.

  • @Autonomous_Don
    @Autonomous_Don 4 месяца назад +3

    I’ve toggled between lat pull downs (reverse/regular grip) and pull ups/chin ups my whole lifting life and chin up are it. They give your back a nicer v-taper and biceps get BIG.

  • @asprinklingofclouds
    @asprinklingofclouds Год назад +17

    Pull ups are better for posture, they reinforce the shoulders back cue and involve the traps /rear delts more . Chin ups sacrifice that with more chest (and of course bicep) activity. Too many people, including some fitness influencers, have a hunched over posture and pull ups are one weapon in your armoury to help correct that.

    • @fit_4ever
      @fit_4ever  Год назад +2

      Yeah, are right. pull ups are better for posture

  • @baidajel
    @baidajel Год назад +12

    guys trust me 3 sets of 12 reps chin ups, 3 sets of 7 sets pull ups will make your upper body aesthetic af

    • @itz_AbuzarKhan
      @itz_AbuzarKhan 6 месяцев назад +1

      How many reps are in one set?

    • @baidajel
      @baidajel 6 месяцев назад

      @@itz_AbuzarKhan do a total of 40 chin ups with rest and 30 pullups

    • @baidajel
      @baidajel 6 месяцев назад

      @@itz_AbuzarKhan just try to do more chinups for compensation to ur biceps

    • @danialnajmuddin3729
      @danialnajmuddin3729 Месяц назад

      did u do normal variation for all set or diff variation of pull/chin up?

    • @baidajel
      @baidajel Месяц назад

      @@danialnajmuddin3729 for chin ups i mostly do shoulder length and close grip chin up , and for pull up it's wide pull ups or shoulder length bro

  • @hgffgghhj
    @hgffgghhj Год назад +18

    it always suprises me why most people choose pull ups over chinups but when it comes to squats they choose normal squats over front squats although they elicit more quads activation but we choose normal squats because we're stronger at them so it means theyre better for hypertrophy the same should go for chinups.
    If you choose weighted chinups you can lift more and your hypertrohhy will get better the
    biceps doesnt take over the lats like most people say the truth is you will be just stronger using that grip thats why
    I choose chinups and i never do pull ups

    • @blacklyfe5543
      @blacklyfe5543 Год назад

      Chinups are more harder for me because I have to use more of my biceps and the way how I grip the bar

    • @blacklyfe5543
      @blacklyfe5543 Год назад +3

      You should use both

    • @JJbouncetrio
      @JJbouncetrio Год назад +4

      Na Front squats are much better for hypertrophy for me . More weight on the bar doesn't always mean better , Less weight means the desired muscle u want to work is doing all of the work.

    • @androidaccount7743
      @androidaccount7743 Год назад

      You're an idi*ot if you refuse to do pull ups.

    • @boolaofmt8815
      @boolaofmt8815 Год назад +1

      front squats are goated for me. I have naturally bigger glutes and they steal most of the gains with squats, but front squat just demolish my quads and upper back. Used to hate it back then tho.

  • @drmitofit2673
    @drmitofit2673 Год назад +17

    I use the padded grip perpendicular extensions on my doorway pull up bar for a midway "neutral" grip. I feel that it distributes the effort between the biceps, lats, pecs, and back. I am into high rep pull ups and can do 100 in two sets, such as 51+49 or 52+48 with 4 minutes rest in between. This requires intense cardio training on a bicycle, deep breathing to the point of hyperventilation, and pre-workout super beet chews. It's all about blood flow at high reps. For completeness, I also do feet on bench push ups , plank ring rows, and ab roller crunches.

    • @chrisw5742
      @chrisw5742 Год назад +2

      @@thetej2227 Hail Odin

    • @ZyroSugar
      @ZyroSugar Год назад

      51 pull ups in one set? No way you’re locking out and chin above the bar using no momentum

    • @drmitofit2673
      @drmitofit2673 Год назад

      @@ZyroSugar The world record is 651 pull ups, so why would my relatively puny numbers be out of the realm of possibility? My workout wouldn't even be that dude's warm up routine. I have since given up on two sets because it didn't really get me out of my fitness plateau and the only advantage was the bragging point of 100 pull ups in two sets. I have since moved on to single set pull ups with a 20 lbs weighted vest (as well as all of my other single set calisthenics with the same weighted vest). I feel like there are fewer garbage reps and with fewer reps and single sets, it's much easier to find time to work out. Started at 40 pull ups with weighted vest and gradually worked my way up to 50 pull ups with 20 lbs weighted vest, personal best. Then for the next work out I attempted a body weight pull up personal best. Without the added weight, it's like I am flying up with minimal effort. In fact for the first 20-25 pull ups the hand grip pressure drops to zero as my chin goes over the bar. This allows a split second of blood flow and micro rest to the muscles at the top of the pull. Some pull up competitors rest by hanging at the bottom but this is too uncomfortable to me, personally. I like to get the set over, ASAP. In my experience it is people stuck at low rep pull ups that cheat the range of motion, not high rep competitors. I am not doing the body flex or kipping method, so no momentum there. One trick it to look up the whole time so that your chin is already high and you are not cranking your neck into extension with each pull. Also, my neutral grip allows more pectoralis activation so I can pull my chest up to the bar (beyond the mere chin up). Another trick is to go to full arm extension at the bottom and use the reflex muscle tension stretch/bounce to come out of the bottom. I use full range of motion this way, but lingering at the bottom does you no good at all. So with the weighted vest single set up ups< I was able to bust through my previous fitness plateau and I was finally able to achieve my fitness goal of 60 body weight pull ups to match my age. Now I just have to get to 61 within a year.

    • @chrisw5742
      @chrisw5742 Год назад

      @@drmitofit2673 hmmm I have a pacemaker with a bad heart and had my whole neck fused front and back. Had some of the back muscles cut. I do workout though but I would be lucky to do 10 pullups. :-P

    • @ZyroSugar
      @ZyroSugar Год назад

      @@drmitofit2673 well that’s incredibly impressive, the most I’ve seen someone to pull ups on a row is like 40. how did you train to get there? Also how do you breath correctly doing so many reps? What’s your Push ups dips record as well if u don’t mind me asking.

  • @AntonioRillera
    @AntonioRillera 10 месяцев назад +27

    Summary: Do Both.

  • @bagley232
    @bagley232 Год назад +10

    I do both daily, 10 sets 10 reps. once a week with a 35lb plate, once a week iso holds with a 45 lb plate

  • @gregorioponichpereira2330
    @gregorioponichpereira2330 3 дня назад +1

    I like the neutral grip as well! great video

  • @Dtp2296
    @Dtp2296 Год назад +5

    Do both and in many grip variations, i concentrate more on pullups though and to my bellybutton, aiming for hips. I workout to form failure

  • @MultiMyNickName
    @MultiMyNickName 8 месяцев назад +2

    The latest studies show there is literally no difference between pronated or supinated or wide or narrow grips in pull ups. They all target the lats the same and they all hit the biceps the same. The only difference is how it feels. The results will be the same no matter which one you choose. What I'm saying is pullups and chin-ups are identical in results. Unsurprising when you do pullups correctly you would realize it hits the lats far more than the chest or biceps when you do the full extension range of motion. You can check this, its been confirmed.

  • @obrienortega6942
    @obrienortega6942 8 месяцев назад +3

    Personally, I get a better activation on my lats when I perform Chin-ups. The only difference is you have to do chest-to-bar.

  • @Pepeekeo808
    @Pepeekeo808 4 месяца назад +2

    Just make sure you go all the way down to a full extension "dead hang" before going up again to your chin above the bar position if you want to get the full benefit of chin ups and pull ups.

  • @Tbonesteak23
    @Tbonesteak23 8 месяцев назад +3

    0:28 Why isn't his head hitting the bars? a moment later: ohhh

  • @timetravel6913
    @timetravel6913 Год назад +3

    I feel my upper back more in chin ups and I think is because it is easier and can do full range of motion. In pull ups I am not going as high their for less range of motion. But I think chin ups will make me better at pull ups eventually since they basically work same muscles but a bit differently.

  • @thesittingpigeon138
    @thesittingpigeon138 Год назад +2

    It depends on what you want to do. I want to get better at bouldering, so I do pullups more because of the hand position.

    • @ramon3077
      @ramon3077 Год назад

      From what I've read, some bouldering/rock climber folk barely even train pullups. The hardcore enthusiasts probably favor finger boards over bars.

  • @BPS12484
    @BPS12484 9 месяцев назад +1

    What about neutral grip pull up?

  • @johnwesa9379
    @johnwesa9379 5 месяцев назад +4

    I find chinups more relaxing on the shoulders and the better at progressive overloading

  • @aborigine777
    @aborigine777 11 месяцев назад +3

    I do both along with neutral grip pull-up.

  • @FusionThunder
    @FusionThunder Год назад +3

    With a Chin-up it's also easier to tear your bicep. No one talks about this. If you're doing chinups make sure it's nice and slow, make sure to control the rep and don't do jerky motions

    • @tappajaav
      @tappajaav Год назад

      That should be given regardless of the exercise done

  • @uncletony6210
    @uncletony6210 2 месяца назад

    I do a hybrid - one palm in, one palm out; then switch to other palm in, other palm out.

  • @grantbradley5084
    @grantbradley5084 Год назад +2

    I’m in the process of installing my Rogue pull up bar in my yard so I can work on muscle ups. I’m 66.

  • @Rahilda
    @Rahilda 8 месяцев назад +321

    Pull ups not being "as heavy or tiring" is completely false. Your biceps are at a mechanical disadvantage with an overhand grip. Pullups are absolutely harder to do than chin ups. Your video is bad info.

    • @Rahilda
      @Rahilda 8 месяцев назад

      @Nev91280 What if I did? Would that change anything? The point is, even the most basic understanding of human physiology and anatomy tells you that chin ups are easier. Don't believe me? Go do some chin ups and then pull ups and tell me which one was easier and which you could do more reps of. It's going to be chin ups, jackass lol

    • @Nicolas-fb6pu
      @Nicolas-fb6pu 8 месяцев назад +67

      ​@@Nev91280common sense, bud!

    • @maiden5427
      @maiden5427 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@Nev91280Lat pull down machines exist for a reason. Never heard of a chin pull up machine.

    • @SchrödingersMath
      @SchrödingersMath 7 месяцев назад +10

      A neutral grip...produces less Torque and stress on the biceps...better if you want to avoid injury

    • @Rahilda
      @Rahilda 7 месяцев назад +26

      @Customx-qs3hu No lol Pull ups are harder for every human because of the way the wrists turn the muscles and put the biceps brachii at a mechanical disadvantage. You can't just make up false info lol

  • @PINKALIMBA
    @PINKALIMBA 8 месяцев назад +1

    Train both. Alternate between days of chin ups and pull ups. Also mix some days with weights for low rep and some days with resistance band for high reps.

    • @mannyquintana8074
      @mannyquintana8074 2 месяца назад

      I heard it’s good to stick to the same thing for a month or two then switch it up

  • @jakemccoy
    @jakemccoy Год назад +2

    Advanced calisthenics athletes practice all grips, at least 50 more grips than what this video shows… Various holds on rope, climbing boards, balls, towels, polls, ledges, FatGripz, slippery bars, etc… Advanced calisthenics athletes don’t ask “which hold is best?” They just do them all.

    • @tappajaav
      @tappajaav Год назад

      That's ridiculous, 50 grips? You don't need all that nonsense to become strong.
      Also climber = / = calisthenic practicioner

    • @jakemccoy
      @jakemccoy Год назад

      @@tappajaav It sounds like you already know everything. So, you're all set.

    • @tappajaav
      @tappajaav Год назад

      @@jakemccoy Cheers! Planning to be CEO of universe by tomorrow

  • @surrealistidealist
    @surrealistidealist 10 месяцев назад +1

    Any interesting studies on neutral-grip chin-ups?

  • @sylvesterhurt447
    @sylvesterhurt447 Год назад +1

    Great vid💪🏿

  • @georgiosdoumas2446
    @georgiosdoumas2446 Год назад +2

    I always do the same amount of sets for chinups and pullups, and my maximum is 15 reps for both exercises. I am completely symmetrical! And I can do 45 good form pushups as maximum, so my pushups are 3 times more than my pullups/chinups. Is everyone on the same ration of 1/3 ?

  • @Ratatosk80
    @Ratatosk80 Год назад +2

    If you can do pull ups you don't need to do chin ups anymore. Yes there is benefit to doing chin ups as well but pull ups are a much better exercise to focus on. Yes better bicep activation from chin ups and if you do close grip chin ups the emphasis on the biceps is even bigger. Here is the deal though, do you really need to focus on your biceps? Biceps are used a lot in many exercises.
    Today for example I did weighted pull ups, lat pulldowns, singe arm rows, dumbbell shoulder press, dumbbell chest press and cable lateral raises. The pull ups, lat pulldowns and rows already hit my biceps plenty. Sure every now and then you could throw in some bicep specific work but it's not needed to get a great looking physique.

    • @lewisyaworski8962
      @lewisyaworski8962 Год назад

      I agree with that different exercises will recruit the biceps/brachialis without performing a curl or chin-ups, it always depends on your goal. For me, I am working on building my deadlift strength and grip is the major link to make it work. I am using a double-overhand grip, so I can keep my shoulders in rotational symmetry. I use chin-ups because I need another movement that does not require pulling from the floor and there is the added benefit of improving my relative strength at the same time.

    • @tappajaav
      @tappajaav Год назад

      Forgive the hyperbole but that's like saying that you don't need to squat once you can do a bodyweight squat.
      You can always add more difficulty to chin-ups by doing them slower, adding weight, or slowly transfering to one arm chin-ups.
      They are also incredibly time-efficient exercise, so if I were limited with my gym time doing them would be very beneficial

  • @fit_4ever
    @fit_4ever  Год назад +20

    Which do you prefer: pull-ups or chin-ups?
    Watch our new video: How To Increase Your Pull-Ups in 1 Month -- ruclips.net/video/JY-J5yPlkBI/видео.htmlsi=8SEEwb_z_vAENdlp

    • @BRUH-ws3kg
      @BRUH-ws3kg Год назад +10

      Chin-ups

    • @ictdpowerstroke4591
      @ictdpowerstroke4591 Год назад +6

      Chin ups

    • @TheOakenwulf
      @TheOakenwulf Год назад +2

      Chin-ups for sure.

    • @noudialp
      @noudialp Год назад +5

      I do them both and pull-ups always feel harder for me. However, I can do the same number of reps for each.

    • @wojfer87
      @wojfer87 Год назад +3

      Chin-ups. :)

  • @ivandimov9712
    @ivandimov9712 8 месяцев назад

    I used to mainly pull ups. But now due to injury in my elbow I replaced them with Chin ups and my lats remain as strong.
    The angle of the chin ups remains when you are tired. While the body angle while doing the pull ups is usually decreased when you’re getting tired.

  • @ThanhNguyen-el6yz
    @ThanhNguyen-el6yz 20 дней назад

    the video is great but from 1:50 the subtitle and voiceover does not match so it is very unpleasant to watch and listen to 2 different things at the same time

  • @kb01663
    @kb01663 Год назад +2

    If you wanna grow a bigger and stronger back, you should do every variation possible

  • @jejunamja
    @jejunamja Год назад +2

    I wish I could do pull up as it gives me golf's elbow ( pain on the inner side of the elbow) but ican do as many pull as I want and I get no pain there so...

    • @qwerty975
      @qwerty975 Год назад

      You warm up for your pull ups?

    • @jejunamja
      @jejunamja Год назад

      @@qwerty975
      Yep I warm up. It just seems to be that particular exercise I can do push-ups shoulder, but that particular exercise by hand that kills my elbow.

  • @gorillahottortilla9194
    @gorillahottortilla9194 6 месяцев назад +1

    Ok it's gonna be a bit controversial but for lats I am all into chin ups. If we will compare standard grip chins and pulls the back has almost the same activation (I feel better stretch on chins). Differencece lies in arms. You might get more activation for bicep with chin ups but it doesn't take anything from back. During pull ups sonething still has to bent the arm right? Tension goes more into other elbow flexors. There is more than just a bicep that does this function. For best growth of Your back You need full spectrum of grip width, that was purely theoritical, I just wanted to bring up chin ups a bit cause people still believe this exercise is worse cause of bicep activation while this argument doesn't take anything from back unless Your form is reaaaaly biasing bicep to the point it becomes a point of failure. It happens to me but I am doing that intentionally. You will have to choose Your variations and ecercises according to Your demands and current standpoint.

  • @zachhendo8379
    @zachhendo8379 Год назад +1

    You should be doing both, and neutral grip pull ups, and closed grip pull ups and archer pull ups, and dead hangs.

  • @ducoh2093
    @ducoh2093 9 месяцев назад

    When I do Chinups, I place my hands like you with a Hammer Curl, palms pointing towards each other. Are those good too? I figured it would just be like a chin up with more emphasis on the brachialis

  • @Stantheman848
    @Stantheman848 Месяц назад

    Pull up doorway bars are too narrow for effective pull ups?

  • @Bullshittalk08
    @Bullshittalk08 Год назад +9

    both are great but i injured my wrist for 4 month by doing chin up on bar and push up combination, thats why pull up is better on bar, but chin up is saver on rings

  • @ElGitarico
    @ElGitarico Год назад +1

    I make a superset of both allways starting with pullups until failure, then chinups until failure.

  • @ouroboros6125
    @ouroboros6125 Год назад +5

    I can do 5 chin-ups, but I can't do a single pull-up. Does this mean my back muscles are uber weak?

    • @farrelltreviano1198
      @farrelltreviano1198 Год назад +6

      Means you have weak scapula foundation, start by training your scapula 10 reps for 3 sets

    • @ouroboros6125
      @ouroboros6125 Год назад

      @@farrelltreviano1198 Thank you :) I'll look into that muscle group. Found it strange because for most of my life when fit and working out chin-ups were harder and pull-ups easier. After having lost all my muscle and having been inactive for a few years. Casually testing again & seeing the result left me in "WTF?" mode.

    • @blacklyfe5543
      @blacklyfe5543 Год назад +1

      Yes

    • @UY-SCUTInohomo
      @UY-SCUTInohomo Год назад

      bro i need to know your progress update

  • @Kormac80
    @Kormac80 14 дней назад

    I'm amazed that people don't emphasize the grip more. The grip should be thumb wrapped around the bar and knuckles point up to the ceiling. So the back of your hand is perpendicular to the floor. That grip allows one to activate the chain of muscles that begin in the hand and travel up the arm.

  • @kristiannoel4866
    @kristiannoel4866 Год назад +2

    Very good video with much to learn from. I'll be watching this again. I also do a mix of both in my training.

  • @midnightblue1874
    @midnightblue1874 Год назад +1

    I started recently with chinups and from a getgo i can do 4 clean ones, but pullup barely 1...For me pulluls almost seems impossible...Still having a problems and don't know how to squeeze them into my exercise routine.

    • @tappajaav
      @tappajaav Год назад

      Try doing eccentric pullups. Get to the top position(for example use a nearby object to stand on, grip the bar,) and slowly lower yourself. Repeat.
      Could help you to eventually hit good form pullup.

  • @maze400
    @maze400 Год назад +3

    Chin-ups are great there is no doubt but the back is the foundation for the upper body. Never neglect your back!

  • @puco66
    @puco66 5 месяцев назад

    I've been doing supinated grip pull-ups ("chin-ups") exclusively for the last 2 years because pronated grip pull-ups started causing me a lot of elbow pain. The chin-up didn't cause me any problems in that regard so I just naturally migrated to them.

    • @randominch8940
      @randominch8940 4 месяца назад

      And the results?

    • @puco66
      @puco66 4 месяца назад

      ​no pain now, I prefer supinated grip, but I know I need to start back with pronated

  • @donniethedealer2623
    @donniethedealer2623 Год назад +1

    Chin ups for biceps and pull ups for back. Both have a value and both should be included in your program

    • @ramon3077
      @ramon3077 Год назад

      Sternum chinup is incredible for back.

  • @NikDeCesare
    @NikDeCesare 10 месяцев назад +1

    Pull ups are better, they allow you to pull higher than the bar, accesing a differnet plane of pull strenth.

  • @usermk99
    @usermk99 Год назад +2

    Pull ups build solid back. Pull ups also hit your biceps with different angle. So you probably should do both Or alternatively. Can't say anyone of this is better than other. Both are good in their own way.

  • @chaosdragon6588
    @chaosdragon6588 11 месяцев назад +1

    I focus more on weighted pull-ups, mainly for my training to muscle-up, now i can do weighted muscle-up with 20kg for 1 rep max

  • @michaelboom7704
    @michaelboom7704 Год назад +2

    Took the grandson to the playground so I decided to see how poor of shape I am doing pull ups on a bar. Guess I better get going as the number was pretty low!

  • @CeciL1v1
    @CeciL1v1 4 дня назад +1

    मेरे खयाल से chin-ups ही बेस्ट है ❤🎉

  • @joy2406
    @joy2406 Год назад +2

    I find it much more difficult to do chin-ups, but pull- ups are easier than chin-ups for me. When I can do 15 pull-ups in a row , I can hardly do 9 chinups. However, It may be different for men, and depends on fingers and body type.

    • @frede.simsjr.3780
      @frede.simsjr.3780 Год назад

      That is very unusual because chin up 3:37 so much easier than pull-ups by far because because it allows you to use more of your arms it's always a second to the rule but I can do pull-ups and channels but I do the pull-ups first because they are the hardest and as I fatigue then I do chin UPS

  • @vaughnalexander32
    @vaughnalexander32 Год назад +2

    i do them all, i used to hate doing p.t... now if i miss a day, my body craves activity.. i cant sit still

  • @humble_integrity
    @humble_integrity 5 месяцев назад

    it depends on range. try doing a high pull up to your belly vs high chin ups to your belly. which one is easier? it all depends.

  • @EvanZamir
    @EvanZamir 9 месяцев назад +1

    If you want to target mostly your lats, do pull-ups. If you want to do more of a biceps "isolation" then do chin-ups.

  • @strawberryyogurt0
    @strawberryyogurt0 Год назад +1

    So unlike your thumbnail, pull-ups are in fact better for me, which is exactly what I’ve been doing.

  • @luis.vuitton
    @luis.vuitton Год назад +2

    Chin ups & last rep I switch to pull ups if I don’t have access to rings

  • @taijgrant4088
    @taijgrant4088 4 месяца назад

    My inner forearm, right below where the elbow bends, gets SUPER tight with pull ups…so I stick to chin ups now but I def wanna get back to pull ups too

  • @martinivanov1817
    @martinivanov1817 Год назад +1

    What if you don't go near failure, but until you just can't do anymore ?
    I'm doing 3x6 pull ups and 3x6 chin ups where at the last set I have to bring my best to complete it and sometimes I can't.

    • @perrygriffin2371
      @perrygriffin2371 Год назад +2

      Thats failure

    • @president8102
      @president8102 Год назад

      that's failure. if 6 reps is your max on the first set then most likely you will not be able to do 6 reps on the following sets.

    • @martinivanov1817
      @martinivanov1817 Год назад

      My one set max isn't 6. The strategy is to be harder and harder until i reach the 6th set where i have to give me best to be able to finish it@@president8102

    • @president8102
      @president8102 Год назад +1

      ​@@martinivanov1817 6 sets of the same exercise is a little excessive. you can increase reps biweekly just off of one set alone. you should be going near failure every set. if you can do 6 sets of a certain rep range it's not close enough to failure.

  • @henryToped
    @henryToped 3 месяца назад

    At first i was only able to do 5x3 partial chin up, now 5x5 full ROM. How should i progress? Should i make it 5x6, 5x8, 5x10, then maybe 2x25 finally 1x50? Will this increase intensity? Thanks.

  • @joebot9309
    @joebot9309 Год назад +2

    Chin ups can really bake (shred) the bicep tendon overtime. If you want to be lifting at 56 yrs old like me, limit the chin ups to perfect reps.

  • @Runtz_Runtz-h1e
    @Runtz_Runtz-h1e День назад

    I've been struggling with pull-ups for a while, but I think I might switch to chin-ups to build up my strength first.

  • @tugsatbaris
    @tugsatbaris 8 месяцев назад

    I think, the best combination is weighted muscle-ups (lower reps, mostly strengh-focused) + weighted chin-ups (higher reps, mostly hypertrophy-focused). This is what I consistently do.

  • @defenderoftheadverb
    @defenderoftheadverb 3 месяца назад +1

    Chin ups are conducive to tendonitis, golfer's elbow. I had that once. Never again. It takes ages to heal.

  • @gorillalilla216
    @gorillalilla216 Год назад +1

    Very clear and interesting video!

  • @PRAGMATICJAY
    @PRAGMATICJAY 3 месяца назад

    I have alternate every week and keep my back from adapting. I also kettlebell swing during the week with 176lb which works my mid back and traps.

  • @johnnyman1392
    @johnnyman1392 11 месяцев назад +1

    Excellent compound exercises. But one is for back day...the other is for bicep day.

  • @ZFlyingVLover
    @ZFlyingVLover Год назад +2

    chinups are easier and less strenuous on your elbows so good for older people. idk if chinups are better but they're definitely easier

    • @jumbothompson
      @jumbothompson Год назад

      And less strain on the shoulder joint. I got some nice tennis elbow doing pull ups. Neutral grip is best.

  • @basutiputhreebrothers2245
    @basutiputhreebrothers2245 Год назад +1

    This is good information love from India 😊❤

  • @gregmartin2455
    @gregmartin2455 Год назад +1

    Great Video. Finally someone who makes exercise videos and actually knows about it. The grips are not mutually exclusive. I do both with four different combinations of grips. I do at least a hundred a day and sometimes more. Chin ups / pull ups are the best exercise you can do for over all fitness. People at the gym can't believe I'm 69. The abs get an excellent workout too and this helps a lot at my running.

  • @shortycareface9678
    @shortycareface9678 11 месяцев назад +1

    I'm chin up biased (just enjoy them more), but I do pull ups when I feel some need for variation.

  • @MataramMeuBode
    @MataramMeuBode Год назад +2

    Unfortunately chin ups are not for everyone. A few sets of chin ups and my elbows and wrists are dead. Tendinitis and inflammation everywhere. So for me pull ups work best. It's all about finding what works best for you.

  • @Forky1993NA
    @Forky1993NA 11 месяцев назад +1

    I usually use neutral large and neutral grips

  • @r.675
    @r.675 Месяц назад

    I wrecked my rightside of my higherback muscles and shoulder and triceps. I did explosive chin ups and pull ups. I even pushed down when I was up. I felt some kind of suppression in the gym it felt like competive eyes. It was my new method and I liked it. I think i got the injury because the body was not supported as usual. It feels like fundamental and natural energy and strength are gone as if it has been taken from me. I hope I will recover fast because I like it the explosive way my back immedeately started to grow it was spectacular. I am sensitive to things that happen in a specific environment the way that they are experienced in that environment I don't like it when it is too overwhelming and exluding my own method and energy that i rely on. Some gyms are chaotic and crowded some are dull and sedating and some are dynamic and energizing. And mixtures of those together. The body reacts to that.

  • @dashroundaustralia
    @dashroundaustralia 8 месяцев назад +1

    Both mate .
    Diff angles , parts etc

  • @Guitar-pro-lk
    @Guitar-pro-lk Год назад +2

    Why many people do pull ups? There are so many videos about pull ups but but chin ups videos are not to be found

  • @deadlee7871
    @deadlee7871 3 месяца назад +1

    Why is this I can do 10 chin ups but not even 1 pull up man

  • @luismarin2655
    @luismarin2655 Год назад +1

    I advice doing both of them and the neutral grip pull up. I regular do two sets of each one to reach 6 sets. it feels good. 😉

  • @YMC
    @YMC Год назад

    How about natural grip??