🎦 V#50 Part 2 - 3650 Sensorless Brushless Motors - Maximum RPM Test & Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 141

  • @RcModwerks23
    @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +6

    *****Watch Part 1 here : www.youtube.com/watch?v=db6Zm...​
    This is another test and comparison of the highest RPM ( Revolutions Per Minute ) we can get from six 3650 size brushless motors with different KV ratings.
    Feel free to tell us which of these motors you have in your rc car, and also share us your experience with that motor .

  • @troydoherty2738
    @troydoherty2738 3 года назад +5

    Awesome video, thought about testing the same kv but seeing which one draws least current and what temperature they reach?? Keep up the great work!!

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Thanks! I didn´t get those info because I was only focusing on my speed run builds at the moment ( I was more interested in knowing the motor max RPMs) ... those info will be useful if you run the rc car in the track 👍

  • @bigbeardrc4145
    @bigbeardrc4145 3 года назад +3

    Really really well done mate.really interesting and eye opening

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Thanks! but this is just an RPM test wihout load, and each motor might perform differently under load.

  • @TheRCMaster
    @TheRCMaster 3 года назад +3

    Awesome comparison and tests 👌 great video bro 👏

  • @tyronewilliams3698
    @tyronewilliams3698 2 месяца назад

    Hey. I always watch your videos. I brought (2) EAT 14, after watching your videos. I LOVE WHEN YOU DO YOUR RC RUNS. VERY NICE AND SUPER FAST! I would like to upgrade my cars. What is a good powerful motor and ESC combo that will fit my car? Do you repair RC cars?

  • @operator8014
    @operator8014 3 года назад +2

    Hey, I always wonder how these hobby grade motors compare to the performance of the brushless motors on cordless power tools.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      IMHO the motors they used in power tools are slower but they have more torque, but we cannot make a conclusion unless somebody makes a direct comparison. Thanks for watching !

  • @mark.a.estrecho
    @mark.a.estrecho 2 года назад

    This is a great comparison! Thank you for making this video! May I ask, can I use a 3S LiPo battery on a 80A Brushless ESC?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      Yes you can, as long as the ESC is rated for 2s-3s lipo

  • @DennisLowery-r4b
    @DennisLowery-r4b 11 месяцев назад +1

    I thought the green 1 was castle I was like yep that wins 😂

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  11 месяцев назад

      The motor brand is X-Team

  • @ValFPV
    @ValFPV 2 года назад

    Thank you for this nice video!
    Which motor would you recommend for speedrunning a wltoys 144001 on stock gearing with 3s lipo?
    I'm currently using a 3650 3300kv motor with a top speed around 100km/h, my next goal is 120km/h.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      If your speed goal is 120 km/h in 3s lipo, either the 4300 kv or 4500 kv can do the job. Thanks for watching!

    • @ValFPV
      @ValFPV 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 thanks for your answer! Do you think 5200kv would give me even more speed or would it have too little torque then?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      @@ValFPV Yes, it will be faster but runs hotter

  • @dannywalker6279
    @dannywalker6279 3 года назад

    Nice video thanks I'm thinking bout getting a wltoys 124019 and putting brushless system in it I mainly just drive in street any suggestions as to what motor I should go with

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      Get the ones with lower kv ( 3600-4200 kv ) and it will be good for street driving... the equivalent of the stock 550 motor is aorund 2800 kv only.

    • @darkki94
      @darkki94 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 so a 3100KV + 60A ESC should be fine for 2S and 3S , i want to upgrade my 124018 to brushless and to avoid overheating .

  • @jimiedaytona
    @jimiedaytona 2 года назад

    asalam tuan... esc brand surpass ok tak tuan...

  • @Speedslays
    @Speedslays 3 года назад

    Been using that 4370kv f540 in my traxxas Bigfoot truck. Working awesome so far. If all goes well I'm gonna order 2 more for my rustler an stampede. I might get a fan for it though.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      Good that it´s working well for you. You can also try the 3650 size motor even if it´s the same kv, it will give yuo more torque compared to the F540.

    • @Speedslays
      @Speedslays 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 yes I'll probably have to change gearing for 4x4 Motor gets pretty warm.

    • @chaddison5928
      @chaddison5928 2 года назад

      What's the top speed and would you recommend it for a rustler 4x4?

    • @Speedslays
      @Speedslays 2 года назад

      @@chaddison5928 I thunk it was like 40kmh with the high speed gearing for a 2wd stampede. But I put it in my 4x4 pede and it wasn't as fast. So not sure if I'd personally put it in anything 4x4 long term

    • @chaddison5928
      @chaddison5928 2 года назад

      @@Speedslays oh ok thanks for the info and have a great day/evening

  • @NostalgiaRC1
    @NostalgiaRC1 Год назад

    What attachment did you put on the motor for the test?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  Год назад

      It was a
      dIY piece made from an old pinion gear

  • @kamilthegreat2834
    @kamilthegreat2834 3 года назад +2

    Would be interesting to see this teat on a proper power supply that wont have voltage sag.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Thanks for the input 👍

    • @yogamon
      @yogamon 2 года назад +2

      All you have to do is parallel another lipo or 2 to get no voltage drop or sag over time thru the test

    • @kamilthegreat2834
      @kamilthegreat2834 2 года назад

      @@yogamon itll still dip even with 3 in parallel but not so much.

    • @yogamon
      @yogamon 2 года назад

      @@kamilthegreat2834 well yes. You can't use infinity amount of lipos, but the draw on the lipo is low to begin with, there is no load other than shaft and the adapter for optical reading purpose.

    • @yogamon
      @yogamon 2 года назад

      @@kamilthegreat2834 or use a life battery with flat discharge curve

  • @beachinrc101
    @beachinrc101 3 года назад

    Great 👍🏼 test maybe you can get a prop that can fit these moters & scale so we can determine best torque & with the battery 5300mah is even enough for rpm testing imho but hey I’m just another hobby crazy 😜 lol great 👍🏼 job thanks for the great vid

  • @DinhNguyen-ki7lk
    @DinhNguyen-ki7lk 3 года назад

    So the surpass hobby red better than the plantinum one?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      They are almost the same but the red one is a bit faster in my experience

  • @antoniaydin
    @antoniaydin 10 месяцев назад

    Can they make more rpm with higher batterij voltage?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  10 месяцев назад

      Yes, as long as you dont exceed thier maximum RPM which is 50k RPM

  • @Sam-nz2zs
    @Sam-nz2zs Год назад

    What about a 540/7.5t v3 surpass hobby motor. With a 120hobbywing esc? On 3s??

  • @joelposadas5890
    @joelposadas5890 Год назад

    What motor would u recommend for a traxxas slash 2wd dirt track racing it

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  Год назад

      I am not familiar with that rc car, but i think the lower kv motors will be good

  • @cage-rattler
    @cage-rattler 2 года назад

    What are you using on the shaft to attach the reflective tape to?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      That is a DIY piece I made from a pinion gear

    • @cage-rattler
      @cage-rattler 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 did you just grind down the teeth?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      @@cage-rattler nope, I glued a plastic piece around it

    • @cage-rattler
      @cage-rattler 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 Thanks. Just got my tach delivered and anxious to start testing a few motors. Going to start breaking in some brushed motors and want to see the difference from out of the bag to broken in.

  • @aizatnorman
    @aizatnorman 3 года назад

    Do you have any idea if all of these can run smoothly on a surpass hobby 60a ESC? I don't trust that 120a budget blue ESC. Cogging on those things can be felt more significantly too.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      I can´t tell because I dont own that specific ESC ... but all these motors will pull 60+ Max Amps. If you want a smooth system, better get a Sensored motor & ESC.

    • @aizatnorman
      @aizatnorman 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 thanks boss!

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      @@aizatnorman no problem 👍

  • @niklasmoller4121
    @niklasmoller4121 3 года назад

    Interesting video! The last motor did 41,996 rpm and was the fastest, but in the comparison picture at the end those numbers are wrong.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Yes, true ! That was a typo error ... thanks for watching 👍

    • @niklasmoller4121
      @niklasmoller4121 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 It doesnt matter, its one of the best videos Ive seen in a while! Keep up the good work!

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      @@niklasmoller4121 Thanks for those encouraging words ! 👍

  • @digeolrc8586
    @digeolrc8586 3 года назад

    What the best one?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +2

      The answer depends on how and where you want to run your rc car ... you can check my other videos using these motors in my Speed Runs. Thanks for watching ! 👍

    • @digeolrc8586
      @digeolrc8586 3 года назад +1

      @@RcModwerks23 thanks a lot for your suggest my friend

  • @arif_fadillah_
    @arif_fadillah_ Год назад

    how many amperes of esc do you use?

  • @josuenevarez7209
    @josuenevarez7209 2 года назад

    I have a wltoys 124019 which one fits the stock motor mount and I wanted to get the 5200kv silver one but people say you lose acceleration deos it lose to much or not my goal is 95 km

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад +1

      All of these 3650 brushless motors are direct fit to 124019 ... the selection of motor kv depends on how and where you drive your rc car . If you want speed and drive on-road only then the 5200 kv is Ok ... it can hit 120+ km/h on 2s and 140+ km/h on 3s. But if drive off-road better get a lower kv motor. Check my other videos and see the kv I use and top speed I get with them. The 4500 kv got me 120+ km/h on 3s at 3/4 throttle.

  • @nikko9167
    @nikko9167 3 года назад +1

    What is your tools to measure rpm ??

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Please check the link shown in the Description 👍 .. it is called Tachometer

    • @nikko9167
      @nikko9167 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 sorry i didn't see.. Thanks for your super test 👍

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      @@nikko9167 you are welcome! Thanks for your support to this channel... You will see these motors in action soon.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      @@nikko9167 You are welcome, this is the link: DIGITAL TACHOMETER : www.banggood.com/custlink/KK3hHBwygn

  • @norcalrc
    @norcalrc 3 года назад

    Nice work bro

  • @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198
    @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198 2 года назад

    Hello,can suggest me,which best power brushless motor for 200km?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      Which model is your rc car? You got a very high goal of 200 km/h ... i think None of these motors can get you there. .. you need to look for a TP motor and Castle ESC for that speed goal.

    • @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198
      @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 hello,rc model buggy 124019,?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      @@zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198 There are only 2 persons who were able to reach 200+ km/h with 124019 and they are using TP motor

    • @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198
      @zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 tq,all the best

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      @@zaideybzakariazaideybzakar3198 Thanks, no problem 👍

  • @fran.6496
    @fran.6496 3 года назад +2

    Finalllyyy thank you :)))

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      You are welcome ! Yes, I remember that you were asking for more motor RPM tests few months back 👍

    • @fran.6496
      @fran.6496 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 yes sir! I bought turnigy motor but with higher kv last month, it pushes my 144001 to 79mph on 2s! With castle ESC Idk name but it is perfect fit

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      @@fran.6496 That´s awesome! 79 mph on 2s is very fast 💪

  • @MrPD-uu7wr
    @MrPD-uu7wr 2 года назад

    just subscribed on your channel sir, your vid comparison is very clear, may i know if i can use a simple 3s lipo batt on 3650 5200kv brushless, it says 9.6v is the max voltage. im using an unbranded 120a esc. thank you

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      Thanks, yes you can run it with 3s but watch the temperature so that motor will not overheat... 5200 kv will be very fast even with 2s lipo only

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      Which model of rc car you have?

    • @MrPD-uu7wr
      @MrPD-uu7wr 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 im gonna use it on my built boat ,20 inch outrigger, no gears, direct to propeller.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  2 года назад

      @@MrPD-uu7wr I dont have yet any rc boat, but I think there will be no problem since motors on rc boat generally have a cooling system

    • @MrPD-uu7wr
      @MrPD-uu7wr 2 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 maybe a 3s with a lower c rate, like 25c, 2000mah.will it do?

  • @evgeniyan2426
    @evgeniyan2426 3 года назад

    The main parameters are Output/Input Power and Efficiency at this power.

  • @R-EVLMNKY
    @R-EVLMNKY 3 года назад

    Hi Sir, Is the surpass 4300kv with 60A esc platinum combo fine to run up to 3s?(but I mostly run 2s) I just want to do some pop up wheelies and fair speed on my wltoys A979b truck now with bigger 80mm wheels...thanks for the videos! 👍🏻😊👍🏻

    • @cds1223
      @cds1223 3 года назад +1

      I just blew up my 60amp esc with the 4300 kv on 3s surpass platinum combo. About the 3rd run but it was a 4x4 MT. I only ran it because thats what was in the combo and awaiting my 120 amp. :/. Sorry. Be careful.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +3

      Yes, there will be no issue for the 4300 kv motor to run on 3s since it will only be around 47k RPM (which is not yet exceeding the 50k Max RPM recommended by most manufacturers).The more sensitive piece is the ESC, so just make sure that you will get a good one and 2s-3s capable. I don´t own a Platinum series ESC so I can´t comment about it. Thanks for watching my videos! 👍

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      @CDS ....Yes, we should always be careful with the ESC (personally I always check the Temps) because it is the part which usually fails instead of the motor. The cheaper brands generally are more prone to getting burned when abused or misused, but I also saw many expensive one like Castle Mamba ESCs that also get smoked. So, as you said, be careful.

    • @R-EVLMNKY
      @R-EVLMNKY 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 thanks, will look for 80A or stay with just using 2s on it👍🏻😊👍🏻

    • @R-EVLMNKY
      @R-EVLMNKY 3 года назад +1

      @@cds1223 thanks, will look for 80A or stay with just using 2s on it 👍🏻😊👍🏻

  • @illic0
    @illic0 2 года назад +1

    Top 👍🏻

  • @RickSanchez-vr6ok
    @RickSanchez-vr6ok 6 месяцев назад

    Do you have any problem running the Surpass Hobby KK series 3650 with those BLUE ESCs? I'm trying to have a similar setup for my beetleweight battle bot using the 3650 4500KV + 120A blue ESC.

  • @tooleyzrc1973
    @tooleyzrc1973 3 года назад

    Would you please start showing the name/brand of each motor before you test it. Not just the specs. Thanks. It would really help.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Please check the Description box. Thanks for watchng !

  • @zepol100
    @zepol100 3 года назад

    Link to the motors?

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      please check the Description box, but some of these motors are no longer available since I bought some of them 2 years ago

  • @facbecrawmid1188
    @facbecrawmid1188 3 года назад

    Hello, very good engine comparison. I wanted to ask you if an ESC 80A Surpass Hobby would break down with a surpass hobby kk 3650 7700kv motor (max 95A amps) and a 7200mah 7.4v lipo battery? I think that due to my ignorance I should have bought a 4500kv motor (max amps 75A). Thank you for your help in advance.

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      Thanks ! I dont have that specific ESC, but it sshould be OK since I was also using a Hobbywing 80A ESC with my 7700kv motor without any issues. The motor will easily get hot due to the high kv, so you only need to watch the ESC & motor temps. 👍

    • @Mackstaa
      @Mackstaa 3 года назад

      95Ah @ its max voltage but at 7.4V Lipo (8.4V) it may only simmer, But! your right prolly should of gone for a lower kv to start with and work your way up the motors are pretty cheap these days

  • @vivotw1787
    @vivotw1787 2 года назад

    聲音小轉速快,才是好的馬達

  • @zeurdozeurdo5409
    @zeurdozeurdo5409 3 года назад

    Hello
    You can give me tips for a full engine for a 124019 wltoys
    Thanks in advance

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +1

      All these motors will be good for Wltoys 124019, but the selected kv will depend on what is your goal . Higher kv motor is faster but it will be hotter than the lower kv.

    • @zeurdozeurdo5409
      @zeurdozeurdo5409 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 Just for a leisure ride, I'm a beginner. Thank you

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад +2

      @@zeurdozeurdo5409 you can get 3600 kv to 4300 kv and pair it with 60 amp ESC .... the stock motor is comparable to 3200 kv, so you will get even faster than the stock motor

    • @zeurdozeurdo5409
      @zeurdozeurdo5409 3 года назад

      @@RcModwerks23 Thank you
      I found an engine 3660 4000kv max10 SCT

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      @@zeurdozeurdo5409 that´s a good electronics combo 👍

  • @cvetelingeorgiev1527
    @cvetelingeorgiev1527 Год назад +1

    something is wrong with your measurement. I hear different RPM's with my ears. :)

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  Год назад

      Every motor sounds differently because they are different brands

  • @ACB-R.C
    @ACB-R.C Год назад

    ….when you don’t see your motor in the line up cause it’s cheap and made in china but still rips 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  Год назад +1

      No problem as long as it works well

  • @RingZero
    @RingZero 3 года назад

    Intro is loud and annoying, otherwise video is OK

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  3 года назад

      Thanks for the input and watching my video 👍

    • @veteranrc5307
      @veteranrc5307 3 года назад

      Lol into was dope…

  • @9824359560
    @9824359560 8 месяцев назад

    Sir please tell me . Where can i buy 4000kv bldc motor

    • @RcModwerks23
      @RcModwerks23  8 месяцев назад

      Try Bangood or Aliexpress. Thanks for watching! 👍