Rabbi Aviad Neiger: How I escaped a Zionist sect.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
- Rabbi Aviad Neiger, born into a secular Israeli family, studied in one of the top Religious Zionist schools. As an inquisitive student, he decided to investigate the doctrines he was being taught in the name of Judaism and uncovered some uncomfortable questions. Upon discussing his question with his mentors he realized that Zionism is baseless political propaganda disguised as Judaism. Today he writes books and holds lectures exposing Religious Zionist forgeries and distortions of the Torah.
As someone who was raised Jewish, and was once passionate about the religion I was brought up in, but became steadily alienated from it over time due to my disagreements with the policies of the state of Israel, thank you for showing me that the door is still open for me to return to Judaism. The way that so many hardcore Zionists are unable or unwilling to discuss this issue in either religious or political terms has steadily pushed me more and more away from the religion, but I see now that that does not represent all of us. Thank you.
There are not many positives we see out of the current events in Gaza, but if I am to point out one positive is that I, and the world, now understand not all Jews are Zionist. And as a Muslim I have to say I am proud of my Jewish brothers and sisters who are able to see the truth despite all the propaganda and brainwashing, and able to say and do something about it. I can't even imagine what a Jewish person goes through in their own community when they take an anti-zionist stance.
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
ya...you found reasons to eat mcdonalds
good for you
Namaste Gee,
Vedas:Svetashvatara Upanishad chapter 4 verse 19 As well as in:
“There is no image of Him”
(Svetashvatara Upanishad 4:19)
It is mentioned in Yajurved Chapter 32 Verse 3
“There is no image of Him”
(Yajurved 32:3)
It is also mentioned in
Yajurveda Chapter 40 verse 9
“They enter darkness those who worship natural things (for e.g. air, water, fire, etc.).
They sink deeper in darkness those who worship sambhuti i.e. created things (for e.g. table, chair, car, idol etc.)
(Yajurved 40:9)
Idol worship, which is very common amongst the Hindus, is prohibited in Hinduism. It is mentioned in Bhagavad Gita Chapter 7 verse 20:
“Those whose intelligence has been stolen by material desires they worship demigods i.e. idols.(Bhagavad Gita 7:20)
* Hindu Scriptures: "There is only ONE God, not the second; not at all, not at all, not in the least bit."[Brahma Sutra]
* Hindu Scriptures: "He is ONE ONLY without a second." [Chandogya Upanishad 6:2:1]
Hindu Scriptures: " O friends, do not worship ANYBODY but Him, the Divine One. Praise Him ALONE."[Rigveda 8:1:1]
Hindu Scriptures: "I am the goal of life, the LORD and support of all, the inner witness, the abode of all. I am the only refuge, the ONE true friend; I am the beginning, the staying, and the end of creation; I am the womb and the eternal seed. I am heat; I give and withhold the rain. I am immortality and I am death; I am what is and what is not"[Bhagavad Gita 9:18-19]
Hindu Scriptures: "There is no likeness of Him." [Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:19]
* Hindu Scriptures: "His form is not to be seen; no one sees Him with the eye." [Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:20]
* Hindu Scriptures: "That which cannot be seen by the eyes, but by which the eyes see, [Kena Upanishad]
* Hindu Scriptures: "The Formless Supreme Spirit that pervades the universe can have no material representation, likeness or image." -- (Yajur Veda
Hindu Scriptures: "He is bodiless and pure." [Yajurveda 40:8]
Scriptures: "Of Him there are neither parents nor lord." [Svetasvatara Upanishad 6:9]
Hindu Scriptures: "They are enveloped in darkness, in other words, are steeped in ignorance and sunk in the greatest depths of misery who worship the uncreated.
eternal prakrti -- the material cause of the world -- in place of the All-pervading God, but those who worship visible things born of the prakrti, such as the earth, trees, bodies (human and the like).
In place of God are enveloped in still greater darkness, in other words, they are extremely foolish, fall into an awful hell of pain and sorrow, and suffer terribly for a long time" (Yajur Veda)
What are your thoughts on the Jews whining about the shoah 24/7 and most countries jailing or banning anyone who speaks about the orchestras and swimming pools in Auschwitz
Thank you so much for Reb Yaakov. you are the greatest person of our generation. I have learned so much from you the last few years. ❤❤❤❤
The empty wagon book is genius. It’s a MUST for every jew to read it.
As a Palestinian I have hope one day Zionism would go a way and Jews true Jews should stay in holy land and live among all the other indigenous Palestinians
Palestine is holy for everyone under one civic law not ethno state
😂😂😂we not eating this shift 😂😂😂
The old ! Muslim ! resonance still exists
No one on the Palestinian side is hoping and planning a secular civil state.
You're not very good at conveying your message. What did you attempt to convey?@@פינחסטחבש
@@פינחסטחבשIsraeli troll - evil nazi
@@פינחסטחבש Muslims literally saved sehardic jews from extinction and maimonides wrote the his writings in eghyt muslims generally ont have roblem with jews only the zionists
My sincere Thank You to the Honorable Rabbi Neiger, and
outstanding author and Host, Yaakov Shapiro. As a Gentile, I am so grateful to the both of You for giving many of us a wonderful overview of the ancient and profound Religion of Judaism and the difficulties modern times has presented to it. Zionism has indeed attempted to Hijack the beautiful, ancient, traditional, and wisdom filled, Jewish Faith. Your book, and your deep conversation on this vital subject is an education in and of itself! Again, my heartfelt Thank You to the both of you.
Thank you for another interesting upload Rabbi Shapiro! Please keep it up! Baruch HaShem.
כל הכבוד!
Keep up your great work Rabbi Shapiro שליט"א!
These discussions are one of a few things that really inoculate me personally against anti-Semitisn. Jews that try to follow the Torah and speak about righteousness is balm to the soul and keeps the negativity away that I get from the Zionists.
Zionists really do try their best to stoke anti semitism. It's the whole point. By refusing to engage you are doing exactly what they don't want. Keep it up!
Thank you Yaakov. 🙂
Thank you for providing this content I can't find anywhere else. And thank you for explaining it to us non-jews. Thank you Rabbi
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
@@omarlittle-hales8237 You've oversimplified. First, you left out the CIA. More importantly, though, you don't address the power behind the agencies. The WEF is the business arm of the UN, which was created with the help of the Rockefellers to become the One World Gov't. You can search the name with everything from people (Fauci, Bill Gates, Kissinger, Klaus Schwab) to industries (big-pharma, -ag, -tech) to agencies (Mossad, CIA) to eugenics (mengele, Planned Parenthood) to mind control (Tavistock, MK Ultra), etc. Of course, Rockefeller is only one of several wealthy families & Foundations; but it's a good place to start.
Thank you to both of you! I was giggling about all the discrepancies taught to those that do not seek out the truth on their own. It may take you decades, as we are constantly learning as we pray, read and seek enlightenment from HaShim, but we must always remain students willing to seek truth always.
thank you rabbi , god love you and may you live in safety and peace the world should respect and love men of truth
Thank you Rabbi. Your content is really eye-opening for me as a Muslim. I pray that more Jews listen to you rather than the likes of Ben Shapiro or, even worse, Evangelical Christians Haigee.
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
As a born again Christian who is seeking truth with prayer and the Holy Spirit's council, I agree!!!
@@roseschmidt2478 Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Alpha = Greek = A For Allah
Aleph = Aramaic = A For Allah
Alif = Arabic = A For Allah
Alef = Hebrew = A For Allah
A = Latin = A For Allah
A = English = A For Allah
Aa = Russian = A For Allah
lol Ben Shapiro is not a jew, do not let them hijack that name and disrespect Judaism
@@roseschmidt2478Bless you!
Thank you so much for opening my eyes❤❤❤
Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord.
I did not understand much of this, but enjoyed listening to it. I wish the Hebrew terms would be better defined.
Really??
@@sonofsowetoyes really
@SeanRhoadesChristopher just listen again brother but this time with a humble heart
@@sonofsowetoThat's not what he meant.
Ask me any question about the Hebrew.
Exalted is the Most High!
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
Thank you from Portugal. I would like to thank you for this because since 1912 and mostly since the 1980s Zionism invaded Portugal. My Hebrew ancestors who fled to Brazil would be appalled an ethnostate was created in the name of their religion.
Thank you Rabbi, really appreciate these videos so I can better understand Judaism ... as a believer in peace and inter-faith respect its good to understand this 😌
Good interview. Who is the rabbi mentioned at @16:55 ? Ulshelkie? Sharky? Thanks
Thank you for this podcast, however this was hard to watch because i didn't understand the hebrew terms and words used throughout the podcast.
Ask me any question about the Hebrew.
Much love from a Muslim brother.
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
And I too
I met some genuine good Muslims in Brookln
I am not Muslim
I do NOT know very much
I KNOW that I have been fed from the Orthodox such lies!
I on my own begin to see wisdom
The Sufi Five Pillars
I listen to one scholar and was impressed with this Iman
He claims we are no longer Chosen
I SEE HIS POINT!
❤ and 🤔 will with the help of Allah will save the day!
@omarlittle-hales8237
I doubt you
But I would not be shocked
I am sickened by Mossad , Bibi , Rabbi Kook and ZIONISM 🤪
A link for rabbi Neiger’s books?…
Please up date " committing high reason" podcast
יישר כח רב שפירו
This desperately needs to be wider spread in english!!!
In Spanish a charismatic person who deceives is called "embaucador" which means to bewitch.
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
Your explanation is totally incorrect, besides you are comparing an adjective and a verb. "Embaucador" is a Spanish word used to depict someone who is deceitful while "to bewitch" (embrujar) is to cast a spell on someone.
Live in peace gentlemen.
B"h
Hope that you'll forgive for my 3am english
Rabbi Shapiro you're truly a holy man
Everything is present on earth with its opposite.
Is there a way to contact Rabbi Yaakov?
Contact form at CommitingHighReason.com
Just waiting for moshiach straighten all this division out and put the law of Moses first like your Channel
Can you link his website? I looked it up and did not find it :(
As a None Jews, some of this is difficulty to follow by I'm starting to get the picture.
2 much strange words
I learned so much from you. Thank you
I dont see any evil in Rabbi Aviad Neiger eyes like I do most Zionists. He looks very peaceful 🙂
He's not a Zionist anymore.
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
• Bhagavat Gita 7-[19-21]:
All those who do idol worship, All those who worship demigods are materialistic people.
• Bhagavad Gita 7:20:
Those whose intelligence has been stolen by material desires surrender unto demigods and follow the particular rules and regulations of worship according to their own natures.
• Yajur Veda 3:32:
...Of that God you cannot make any images.
• Yajur Veda 40:8:
shudhama poapvidham
He is bodyless and pure.
All those who worship the uncreated things, they are in darkness, and you'll enter more into darkness if you worship the created things.
• Yajur Veda 40:9:
Andhatama pravishanti ye asambhuti mupaste
They enter darkness, those who worship the natural elements (Air, Water, Fire, etc.) They sink deeper in darkness, those who worship sambhuti. (Sambhuti means created things, for example table, chair, idol, etc.)
• Rig Veda, Vol.6,45:16:
There is only One God, worship Him.
• Rig Veda, Vol.8,1:1:
All Praise are to Him alone
• Chandogya Upanishad 6:2:1:
He is One only without a second.
• Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:19:
There is no likeness of Him.
• Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:20:
His form is not to be seen; no one sees Him with the eye.
• Svetasvatara Upanishad 6:9:
Of Him there are neither parents nor lord.
Mossad, behind a lot! You had scriptures from Hinduism I had never seen before. They explained the ONE God, not to worship anything else. AMAZING. Then they disappeared, I tried to replace them as best I could below. Namaste.
@@OniWa-u6n Salam, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
DARVO: Narcissistic Traits
DENNY = The Truth
ACCUSE = The Honest Informer
REVERSE = Reverse The Subject
VICTIM = Play The Victim
OFFEND = Offend With Insults
@@OniWa-u6n Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad, CIA, MI6 Behind 9/11
Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Behind The Afghanistan War
Behind The Iraq War
Behind The Libyan War
Behind The Lebanon War
Behind The Syrian War
Behind The Sudan War
@@omarlittle-hales8237 👍👍👍
It definitely sounds like a sect indeed! Typical how they dont want to talk to you if you ask question, only if you 100% admire and agree with their ideology. Its narcissism 101. Either you`re an extention of them reflecting THEIR views, or you`re their enemy
So true about narcissism 101. You're either their flying monkey or a life-long enemy. We know the methods they use: smears, lies, projections, fantasies... it's a true la-la land!
What an amazing journey ! הבא להיטהר מסייעין בידו!
Salam, Shlama, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
Mossad Behind 9/11
Mossad Behind The Creation Of Hamas
Mossad Behind The 7th Oct Attack
Mossad Behind The Afghanistan War
Mossad Behind The Iraq War
Mossad Behind The Libyan War
Mossad Behind The Syrian War
Mossad Behind The Sudan War
Tikva in Slavic means pumpkin and in Judaism something totally different. So Interesting
Suho meso.
Wow
1 John 4:8 ESV - Anyone who does not love does not know God, because God is love.
=========================================
The "Promised land" supposed to be the land of "Rivers of Milk and Honey"...They turned into "rivers of Blood !".
Is your Torah written the same as the first 5 books of the Holy Bible?
Question: according to science, everyone where melinated and degenerated into lighter skin complexion, this is facts isn't?
Yes and no.
some zionists have the same hairstyle. fashion designer Isaac Mizrahi is syrian jewish
Oury Amos Cherki
😸👌🙏
Yaakov why you said so far on your channel nothing about the genocide of palestinians?
Because he wants to distance judaism from zionism to deflate the power of zionism that they got by identity hijack.
Its funny I was listening to this video and I heard this discussion of the kara'im and I thought, wow, what has this tiny group of Jews done to deserve such attention among the Jews? Is it worse in Judaism not to believe in the Oral Torah or not to believe in your god? This hatred of the kaaraites confuses me.
I was at one time an evangelical christian, and over time I read the bible and realized that evangelicals knew some of the words in gospel of John, but they obviously never read the entire new testament, otherwise they would not do as they do. And as people like Jimmy Swaggert and Jerry Fallwell rose to fame and fell I isolated myself from the movement, thinking that someday the movement will find itself. Then one day I found its founder. And I realized that evangelicals are doing exactly as their founder. Once this kicked in I looked for a foothold. As I looked for this magical foothold I reached the place of Yacov the pious, who was declared by both christians and Jews to be neither. And more or less, his Evyonic search for the messiah never came to fruition as I traveled down the tree of Judaism look for a firm place to put my foot, I found not 1 god, but two 'l (the mesopotamian sky god) and the god of peaks and Y--H an arabian god. And as I sorted and compared texts and commentaries on those text, but I found many gods: Shalim (dawn), Anath (Hunt, War), Shamesh (Utu, Sun), Suen (Nanna, Wisdom), Tammuz (Dumuzi, hus wife Ishtar-Astarte, dying and rising gods, Ishtar likely the template for the whore of Babylon), Asherah (🕎, divine wisdom, mother earth, athirath), Hadad (rider on the clouds, Ba'al), and Yahu (Ia, Ea, Enki, the trickster, god of Beth Lahmu). I did eventually find a trustworthy foothold in Apsu and NinAbsu (waters within the earth and Tahom) but not in any place in the biblical story, but in the ancient holy city of Eridu, the birthplace of Yahu. Also found, Kallubah, the village that built the first temple to 'l (Anu) which became the Eanna of Uruk. Both are prehistoric and emerge from the neolithic. But even Uruk and Eridu squabble over whether Anu ('l) or Enki had paternal precedence, but both unite that Absu and his wife, the crashy sea, are the origin of everything. Not to put down the mother earth goddess, I did find a "god" from Israel, she dates back to 250,000 years ago, a small fetish to mother earth, but even she is not the oldest version of 🕎, there is still an older version in Morocco.
The thing that I found is you can, in a process of deidentifying with extremist belief, find convinient stopping places, like Elaine Pagels has done by trying to find common ground between the gospel of John and the secret sayings of Tomas. But if you continue looking for solid footing, footing free of someone, some priest or scribe, did not like what the other priest or scribe had said or written and so changed it, that with enough intertextual comparisons you will find your foot falling through the beginning of civilization.
Its a warning to those who want to carve their religion into tiny pieces because of percieved flaws. If you even have fuzzy vision about truth and are looking for solid footing, you wont find it. While I completely agree with the problem of Zionism, I should point out that sectarianism within Judaism preceded the Jewish revolts. The orthodox often want everyone to believe that they are the "one true scotsman". But in the first century there were three notable sects (Saducees, Pharisees and Essenes) and together these represented less than 10% of the Jews. Jonathon Adler makes the point that Torah practice is not evident until the second century BCE, and if we look at the Elephantine Jews, they believed in a divine couple, Y--H and his Anath. So it looks like Judaism's unified look was something that John Hycanus force on alot of people in order to expand Judea.
Be careful where you shoot, you might be mistaking you backside with your enemy. If the future unfolds in familiar ways look back to the past, the Yahwist state never lasted very long, not under solomon, nor Maccabeans/Herodians. The voices of the past do not quieten easily, the voices of the gods Yosiah suppressed, they stayed in Judea, and Hycanus tried to suppress these again. But the old sky god and the mother (wisdom,🕎) reappear in christianity as Father and Holy Spirit and was built into the trinity, the weapon used by the Christians to oppress the Jews. I advocate none of these, I am just point out that if you seek to be pious by segregating yourself from other pious notions, you have effectively divided yourself for others to conquer.
How could you gloss over the fact that the original gospel was written in Hebrew by Matthew, or neglect that the sect at Qumran through the DSS where Messianic and anti romanized? You also seemed to pass over the fact that your using the wrong name that was attribute to God. And how could you spend such a significant time in evangelical Christianity and not even read the real dilema therein?
@@Joe-pc3hs Matthew was not originally written in Hebrew. Matthew quotes from the LXX nit from the hebrew bible. Papios says that there was a hebrew matthew, but the text we have was not attributed to matthew in the text. Scholars like Dennis McDonald think that on of the Matthews Papios is refering to is the Q source (See "From the first gospel (Q) to the gospel of Mark") The Hebrew text Papios is refering many people think is the lost Hebrew/Ebionite gospel. Much of the ideaology is found in the epistle of James, and the Q source. The author of the gospel of Natthew is a greek speaking writter with considerable education, likely from Anatolia, not a tax collector for fishermen from Capernaum.
The Qumran sect was messianic, however they believed not in a return of one, but two messiahs, one messuah was a sage and teacher (thats what scholars believe early jesus followers thought Jesus was) and the other messiah a kingly messiah. The romans to the Qumran are a minor distraction, the Qumran sect was anti-saducee. They believed that the temple priesthood and the temple itself was corrupted by the Maccabees, there first high priest vacated the position in Jerusalem and helped to build the cult. Why did this occur, the yehud priest was a kind of elite group in Jerusalem following Exile, but the Maccabees were warrior priests, but war and violence made them unclean. John Hycanus forcibly converted large numbers of levantine groups to Judaism, and this was detestable in the eyes of many of the priestly class, so they left. The Essenes believed that Jerusalem must be destroyed so that the righteous messianic duo restore the city back to god.
Gods evolve, names evolve.
When the Egyptians first encountered Yahweh it was YHW, YH is the god of Bethlehem, Beth Lahmu, guadian of Enki.
Evolution of Yahweh. Enki (Sumer), Ea (Akkad), Ia (Ebla), YH (late bronze age confederation), YHW (late bronze age bedoins), YHWH (edomite-arava-tenmah), Yahweh (Samaria)-Yahweh (Judea), Yahweh (Yathrib), Yahweh (Elephantine Ilse).
**[divine sky] An(Sumer), Anu (Early dynastic), Ilu (Akkad), El (Canaan incl. Israel), Al (Arabia)
You should note that "'l the most high" in canaan uses the exact same cuneiform 𒀭𒀭 as the original name of An in sumer. The two versions of god are virtually identical except that in Canaan/Israel 'l is the bull of the heavens and in later Akkad and Sumer An owned the bull of the heavens.
Gods evolve, deal with it.
@@Darisiabgal7573
Youre still predicating the name "Yahwey" as significant to the issue of Judaism, when its still a false conclusion. We have text's with vowel points that do away with that conclusion, so why you keep repeating that focal sentiment is beyond me. You're also over looking the over lap of Assyrian/ Akadian/Phoenician lingua franca that naturally exists in Hebrew, which explains the symmetry in what you see as a progression "of God", when its only a societal one. That isnt to say that baal worship didnt occur with Hebrews, but you use the opprotunity to draw other conclusions where they dont exist.
And did you NOT see the irony in establishing Matthews quotations from the LXX while still referencing the Greek Matthew? A little ironic to say the least. Not to mention the glossing over the significance of roman polytheism into Judaic thought and practice which resulted in modern Christianity. Is there a reason you dont discuss the Pauline epistles and the amicus brief of Luke via Acts? And try not to placate to logical fallacies on the next reply.
Akkadian is an East Semetic Language, Eblaite is a unique semetic language, Phonecian and Hebrew are NW semetic languages, Edomite/Arabian are West semetic. Sumerian is a Language isolate.
The original form in protosiniatic (NE African) would have been Ya Hu V/We Hu. Something on the order of Yahu with. . . .divine arms(Strength) , but since the original encounter with the egyptians did not have divine associated with arms we could interpret as arms of divine wisdom, similar to guardian of Enki, Lahmu, Bethlehem. The original paleo hebrew pronunciation is lost for the tetragrammaton, but its not likely static because, for the reason I stated above, the god was followed in different afro-asiatic languages so that you are essentially begging the question what was the pronunciation by the last high priest of the Sanhedrin in a belief system that is already transcontinental for 1000 years.
In terms of the vowel pointing. Hebrew, as a language is a reconstructed language, it was not spoken outside of the synogoue for 1600 years, the vowel pointe did not appear until 1000 CE
"The Masoretes (Hebrew: בַּעֲלֵי הַמָּסוֹרָה, romanized: Baʿălēy Hammāsōrā, lit. 'Masters of the Tradition') were groups of Jewish scribe-scholars who worked from around the end of the 5th through 10th centuries CE, based primarily in medieval Palestine (Jund Filastin) in the cities of Tiberias and Jerusalem, as well as in Iraq (Babylonia). Each group compiled a system of pronunciation and grammatical guides in the form of diacritical notes (niqqud) on the external form of the biblical text in an attempt to standardize the pronunciation, paragraph and verse divisions, and cantillation of the Hebrew Bible (the Tanakh) for the worldwide Jewish community."
There is no doubt what so ever among secular scolars that early iron age Israel was polytheistic.
The evidence of its polytheism, while white-washed by later scribes is clearly evident in the deuteronomistic text. Your idea is a non-starter. In fact, the first time we see anything even resembling a testimony to YHWH in the archealogy is in Edom.
"In the Early Iron Age, the modern consensus is that there was no distinction in language or material culture between Canaanites and Israelites. Scholars accordingly define Israelite culture as a subset of Canaanite culture. For example, the Israelite religion consisted of Canaanite gods such as El, the ruler of the pantheon, Asherah, his consort, and Baal. Yahweh is described as one of the sons of El in Deuteronomy 32:8-9, but this was removed by a later emendation to the text."
"From the perspective of the Kenite hypothesis, it has also been suggested that the Edomite deity Qōs might have been one and the same as Yahweh, rather than a separate deity, with its name a title of the latter. Aside from their common territorial origins, various common characteristics between the Yahwist cult and the Edomite cult of Qōs hint at a shared connection. Doeg the Edomite, for example, is depicted as having no problem in worshiping Yahweh and is shown to be at home in Jewish sanctuaries."
And so we need to be clear here, there is no Yahweh on the map anytime before the 9th century, only claims about Yahweh written centuries after. Here is the oldest depiction from Edom.
kuntilat Ujrad Inscription. End of 8th century BCE
Pithos A
This says [PN1]... Say to Yehal and to Yoasah and to [PN2... I have b]lessed before Yahweh of Samaria and his Asherah.
Pithos B
... before Yahweh of Teman [Yemen] and his Asherah [...] whatever he shall ask of anyone, may he grant it [...] and may Yahweh give him according to his heart.
"Plaster Fragment
When El dawned in the mountains melted the peaks grew weak Bless Baal on the day of wa[r] The Name of El on the day of wa[r ]. "
Phrases within this also appear in the bible.
" [May] he lengthen their days, and may they be satisfied [...] may they be given by [Ya]hweh-of-Teman by [his] Ašerah [and] Yahweh-of-the-Te[man] favored..."
In other words, the YHWH of the south is favored. We can see here, in the time of Assyrias conquest of Israel that El, Yahweh, Ba'al (Hadat), Asherah are still practiced over a wide area, signs of all of these gods are found in literature earlier period (In Judges, We also see clear signs of Ba'al gad, Anath, Molak, Shalim worshipp among the "in" group of Israelites, this extends into Samuel and Kings) and we see archaeological signs of practice to polytheism after the Inscription.
Judges.
"Yahweh, when you went out of Seir,
when you marched out of the field of Edom,
the earth trembled, the sky also dropped.
Yes, the clouds dropped water.
The mountains quaked at Yahweh's presence,
even Sinai at the presence of Yahweh, the God of Israel.
...
From the sky the stars fought.
From their courses, they fought against Sisera. "
Who killed Sisera, the Kenite Jael. In the Song of Deborah, the earliest versions don't use Yahweh they use Yahu. So at least in ~1075 BCE, Yahweh and Yahu (Ia) were two separate gods. Yahweh might not have even existed at that time.
Kibbit Beit Lieh 6th century
"Yahweh (is) the God of the whole earth; the mountains of Judah belong to him, to the God of Jerusalem". Phraseology dated to 7th to 6th century BCE Earth does not equal world.
The conclusion is there were many Yahweh, the bible even says as much, and that Yahweh, hus names and his attributes evolved over time. No secular scholar will dispute this. Arabian god, a volcano god, volcano's are from Yathrib south to Ethiopia. A god of shepherds, of midianites, Edom is now known as the settled end of the midianite peoples were they came to trade their flocks which easily explains why the Author of the KA inscription infers that the Authority of Yahweh comes from the south, though tenmah translates to Yemen, it probably just means that that half of the pastoral grazing routes.
@@Joe-pc3hs Luke Acts is a second century digest of first century sources, many of which were embellished which notes frequent contradictions, the anthology within Acts is very loosely historic, the author tries to harmonize Paul with the Evyon, which contraficts Paul himself.
You need to divorce yourself from this notion of inerrancy in the bible, If you want to know exactly how matthew deviates from Judaism, take all the passages that matthew references from the LXX and make a list, and go talk to a Orthodox Rabbi. Or you can buy the Jewish Annotated New Testament by Amy Jill Levine.
Whats wrong with walking on Har Habayit. Its a histrocal site recognized as the place where Solomon built the temple and Herod rebuilt it. Yehuda Glick is considered observant and doesnt think twice about going up there with groups. Hes been the target of Muslims who shot him numeous times in attempt to assasignate him. Being Anti Zionist is the only thing that helps Jewish fanatics and non observant western Jewish peaceniks togethor despite both groups despising each other.
What's wrong with going on Har Hanayit? The Jewish Law (the Halacha) is against it! This should be enough of a reason!
@@borisbukalov9407 No shortage of Torah observant Rabbis have been up there. Besides if Muslims are permitted to walk around up there and pray then it shouldn't be an issue for Jews.
@@adamk5700 There are very strict limitations to where and how Jews are allowed to walk on the Temple Mount. This has to do with the special laws of purity and impurity under the Halacha (the Jewish Law). What muslims do doesn't change that.
@@borisbukalov9407 When Temple stood, Aharon Hakodesh was off limits. Temple isnt standing anymore. If davening up there makes a Yid feel good then G-d bless.
@@adamk5700 A yid should be concerned about making the G-d feel good rather than the other way around.
Allah is G- d
Do not give up
My prayer too
I am mentally ill
I was
No longer
I am sick of so much i was fed by Jews
Sounds like Zi ON IS A LITTLE ZI OFF
quaran reads like a stupid book you pick up at sam's club......horrible 'screenwriting'....so obvious it's false.
Have you read the whole Quran? No.
Oh, because it doesn't read like a Hollywood script? Not Western enough for you? You need a comic book version? Typical of supremism, "Its not like WE do it, so its no good!"
2 פסיכופתים
This seems like a baseless claim.
Sounds like another brainwashed Zionist.
Projection ?
כל הפוסל במומו פוסל! 😉
The Chanukah thing is not exactly the way you are saying it. The holidays because we were able to go back to the temple and observe the Mitzvos.
The "Shalosh Shavuos" is a Midrash which doesn't even make sense. How will the Moshiach himself be able to conquer the land? How was Bar Kochba who was backed by Rebbe Akiva and his Talmidim who were all massacred because of it be able to make war with the Romans? And whether or not the Rambam went is irrelevant. In Halacha it is completely Mutar for a Tamei Meis.
There were Kedoshei Elyon who risked their lives to learn in Chevron. My grandfather survived the pogrom. You are also risking your life by living in exile. Remember the holocaust?
Remember how many Jewish lives have been lost for the Zionist nightmare?
Remember the slaughter of thousands of innocent Palestinian children?
Total Amaratzus (ignorance)! Can you even cite one source from the Mishnah and Gemara that you are not allowed to go to Har Habayis??! Of course you have to to the Mikvah and observe Moreh Mikdash. The Rambam says in the Teshuvos did he went to Har Habayis to Daven.
You are using Midrash about miraculous food which is not Toras Moshe Misinai. It is clear from the Gemara and the Rambam did nothing miraculous or prophetic will happen. When we have a chance we have to build the temple.
What are you crazy? We wouldn't fight a war for the Beis Hamikdash???!! That's what the Meraglim said!
The meraglim never said that. Stop twisting Torah!
Why are you so bored you have nothing better to do or nothing better to learn?
Wow