Inside Al Shabaab: The extremist group trying to seize Somalia
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июн 2022
- For more than fifteen years the extremist group Al Shabaab has been fighting a bloody insurgency in Somalia.
(Subscribe: bit.ly/C4_News_Subscribe)
Now, as President Biden redeploys American troops to the country, are the group winning the fight?
Formed in 2002, by 2008 they controlled much of southern Somalia.
They soon pledged allegiance to Al Qaeda and began conducting attacks at home and abroad.
In September 2013 they killed nearly 70 people in the Westgate shopping mall attack in Kenya's capital Nairobi.
Then again in Kenya in April 2015 Al Shabaab militants killed 148 people at Garissa University College.
Back home in the Somali capital Mogadishu they carried out their most deadly attack in October 2017, killing more than five hundred people in a massive truck bombing.
In the years that have followed, the group's attacks have become routine.
They often kill dozens of civilians a month, as they battle the African Union troops there to try and keep them at bay.
Now emboldened by the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan following the US withdrawal, the group are cementing control of their territory, with the aim to take the whole country and implement strict Sharia law.
At the moment, Al Shabaab control vast swathes of central and southern Somalia but their reach spreads far further, with Somali government control diminishing.
Our correspondent Jamal Osman obtained rare access to film in Al Shabaab territory and travelled to their de facto capital Jilib.
------------------
Get more news at our site - www.channel4.com/news/
Follow us:
Facebook - / channel4news
Twitter - / channel4news
This reporter is a genius.... asking direct questions in an unprovokative way
Very, very good report!
The reporter is mouth for Al shabab don't trust him he is one of them.
@Donnell Okafor sorry to break it to ya he works for the ones he’s interviewing
He is part of them
@Donnell Okafor no any other reporter csn go there except him
The people of Somalia are very friendly & helpful, may God bring peace to their homeland.
Ameen. These monsters will be finished by Somali National troops soon.
Aamiin yaa rabi. Thanks again brother.
Al-Shabaab are people of Somalia.
@@sadiq.2074 who is monster!? I am from Bangladesh. Is Al shabab bad!? I want to know. I support everyone fighting for Allah.
❤
from afghanistan love and peace to the people of somalia❤
Talipan and Alshabab ❤
Do not compare Taliban and Al-Shabaab! The Taliban are internationally recognized government but the Al-Shabab are not! I'm Somali and Muslim, my father was shot by Al-Shabaab so its funny that you think these people are Muslims when in reality their enemy us Muslims! 99% of Somali people are Muslims and we hate these al-Shabaab, all they do is terrorize and kill us, how are they Muslims when they kill innocent people? I think you need to watch the video again and see that their enemy is the Somali government who are democratically elected by the people (The Somali Citizens)
@@MubaarakJaamac
Stand with your country against Pakistan first
Thank you bro❤
@@MubaarakJaamac😡😂
Peace to our Somalian people. My solidarity! From Eritrea🇪🇷
One more islamist terrorist group. Vow I am not surprised at all. 😂
ERITREAN ALWAYS SLAVE BARIYA TO ISIYAS
African countries will free from looters France & America. They will agin rich. No body will die for food & water. Under Islamic Law African countries were rich. Do you know about African Rich Sultan Mansa Musa??
And those Who said A S is a monster, kill many armies! Its not fewer than hirosima & nagasaki?
Do you know How much innocent people killed by America?
How can there be peace when one side is forcing their will with violence
Wtf how did you comment there is no network in eritria
Peace to my somalian people. Love from Rwanda 🇷🇼
Rwanda huh? See what you people are doing to DRC...
Thank u very much
Tnx bro
CJCksV
I love Rwanda i wish my people would put the grudges and past behind their back and rebuild their country like you did in Rwanda..much love❤❤❤
😂somali hadaa thy cabsi kugu jirin 😂like ii saar yaqay
mowducan 2bil.sugaye 13m luu kaso.dhigeeee
shaqo yaalo, intarneetka ka bax
@@letsgetsometruth4516 xaa kaagalay adiii😏
adiga ba cabsi kahadlayo somlai cabsi kamajirto khasatan melaha ay jogan shabaab
alle ayaa laga cabsadaa qof binu adam ah waxba kuma yeeli karo
Peace to my somalian people. Love from Norway
Why are you in Norway?! That’s a Nordic country… not your damn playground.
Love to Norway 🇳🇴
❤
Peace to Somalia - from Canada 🇨🇦
❤
Thnk
highly professional - neutral journalist -- covering so many things in a simple way
African countries will free from looters France & America. They will agin rich. No body will die for food & water. Under Islamic Law African countries were rich. Do you know about African Rich Sultan Mansa Musa??
And those Who said A S is a monster, kill many armies! Its not fewer than hirosima & nagasaki?
Do you know How much innocent people killed by America?
I love the somali people, and it hurts to see this kind of division in their community.
Love Isaaqs lol we actually working towards our problem. South of Somalia supports these dogs
Thank you for your positive comment
How are you doing today
Don't worry about it bro we will defeat them as soon as possible 💯
@@SuperExcuse I love you Somalian people from Malaysian people ❤️takbir allahuakhbarx3
for some reason, their territory looks so clean. their anti plastic bag policy really pays off I see.
Plastic may not litter the streets but the blood of innocents stains the soil of Somalia
Lol! You fool. It’s the middle of no where. Go drive outside of the big city of USAz there no trash. But yea plastic sucks.
Sending prayers. To all my brothers and sisters in Somalia. Your 🇺🇸 bro.
Your vote gave them guns to kill each other. Shame on you
@@abdallah515- factzz ☝🏼🏳️🏳️🏳️🏳️ Allah is the helper of believers
@@abdallah515- you think so? Al shabaab how are they doing? USA gonna evacuate?
@@abdallah515-I’m Somali but will play for Syria 🇸🇾 national soccer ⚽️ team inshallah
I hope one day to see Somalia great again! Long live Somalia! Love and respect from Cape Verde🇨🇻🤝🇸🇴
Respect my Cape Verdean brother
Hellp there it's my firsr time to see a comment from a capo verde
It will. God is Peace and Love. God is not murder and kill.
Great again? When was it ever great
@@patricktate4782 visit Somalia tou will get to learn
Somali hada tahay like isar sa uso xasusta mar un inay naga dhamadan qilafadka 🇸🇴🩸❤️😭
Allah haa inaga dulqaado
Ma filaayo
Aamiin Maalin Xasilooni waarta
Way dhamane insha allah madaxweynaha valibmer Putin baa kuso dhow ino so islaamo allah so hadyeeyo guul islamka uso hooyaty yahuuda io American waxa qasayo caalamka allah naga qabto daalamiintaas
@@jeylanisidi2542 i don't know he kinda likes to drink
How can you justify killing innocent people????
islamic cult so please don't defend man made religion
@@latestjobalert-1
Nothing to do with that. You Americans have a bad trigger habit of pointing
@@user-pm2nv2ck8uAl Shabaab swore allegiance to Al Qaeda. Al Shabaab is evil
this is amazing journalism and this guy is a very good interviewer
I Pray Peace In Somalia 🇸🇴❤️
Reject Islam and find your peace.
Thank me later.
@@adonai7187 Islam is the TRUTH but you Islamophobes are the ones who’ve been supporting terrorism agents and using them as an excuse to bring death and destruction to the civilians. The War on Terrorism has FAILED!
@Jeff Wright The existence of a Creator has been proven by modern science compared to atheism which has been exposed to be false and debunked.
Insha’Allah Somalia 🇸🇴 will RISE again. Every empire have theirs ups and downs
@Jeff Wright I’m laughing at how delusional you Islamophobes truly are. I bet, you’re going to blame Ukrainian people starving and dying at the hand of the West on religion instead of your failed foreign policies huh? Also, Allah clearly says in the Holy Quran that God ONLY changes the conditions of people when they themselves change. I don’t expect you Islamophobes to know about Islam nor basic GeoPolitics for that matter. Haha
African Journalist of the decade... Love from 🇬🇭🇬🇭🇬🇭🇬🇭 great job...
This is outstanding reporting. Give this journalist a raise.
he is my favorite reporter but sadly my people are stupid and call him shabaab for not being bias... i wish him the best!
Wow they are environmentally friendly! No plastic bags. Wishing for Islam, peace and prosperity for Somalia 🇸🇴 from Afghanistan 🏳❤️
@@joelgarner1961 So does the US, China, India, Taiwan, Nigeria, Japan and Saudi Arabia and many many others
@@skp8748 lol. No. These people execute people in the guise of God's will.
@@joelgarner1961of course. Every action has ramifications every where in the world. Do you know how many people sitting in death row in America? Check in Wikipedia.
that's a lie. They kill hundreds of pple everytime in somalia how is that peaceful.
"The suggestion box is a fex meters from where they carry public executions" 😁😁😁 that cracked me up
Neutral reporting and the reporter does not show any remorse but high level of professionalism. Impartial
Remorse and high level of British imperialism and good job of being enslaved reporter.
Bullshit -Abdirahman Ahmed of being impersonating as somali but actually you’re non-somali kenyan .
Let me remind you all foreign army in Somalia leave the country and Somalia belongs to Somalia not channel 4 and foreign countries who wants to remain both Indian Ocean and the land and steal the country that’s all the reason they are connecting all made-up story.
Bro- “word can not fill basket” let them keep parking like a dog. Somalia will move forward.
Very true.
The reason is very clear. It is because the reporter is a native. His knowledge and concept of the indeginous Somali life, of which Alshabab were brought up, is what makes him see them from a native perspective. Moreover he is a Muslim himself, a Somali born of Somalian parents and ancestry. Although significant, not just the above, but also the deep asymmetry in Somali culture itself has a bearing on his conceptualization of all that is happening there.
He is terrorist and part of them
He has been reporter to the government for sympathising alshabb propaganda
Jamal thank for your bravery and show to the world about al shabad activity.
Peace be unto somalia n God protect pur mighty Army .love from uganda pearl of Africa😪
Al-Shabaab's claim that they don't target civilians is ridiculous - they very often target hotels & restaurants.
At the end of the day , just like Afghanistan. People on the ground views will count. So far the Somali government refused the public 1 persons vote even. So why not focus worrying on stopping corruption and helping people in honest way. Somalia is more then 25 year's in a mess.
@@zainzoala1083 they’ll be in a mess for another 30yrs if they don’t stop discrimination
They kill everyone who don’t agree with them
Hotel n restaurants full of traitors against somalinimo but I can't believe they justify suicide bombings in any form or shape 😢
@@somalien9447 aww, but justify a drone strike and nuclear attack.
The journalist asked frank and important questions. Great job.
What you is not the reality this designed before it is like flim alshabaab they live the worst life human live they kill child old women and all under fake Islam the journalist is propagandist and part of them they say allahu akbar and they kill someone in the masjid Allah's house
But right now they get what they have planted in the past 2 decades
allahu akbar
Its heartbreaking,
Stop killing people. Life's too short for all that drama
As a somali Kenyan, it's my prayer one day Somalia will be great again. Peace and Love.
@@abdulabdi9791 waa doqon weyaan nacas ah sowmaha
‘As a Somali Kenyan’ miya islowday nacala waxa tahay ku Yale
@@Tango34 wax la ilowo bad tahay .
Somali Kenyan? What is that?
@@averyj5446 A somali in origin but Kenyan by nationality what's soo surprising about that? There are more than 5 million somalis actually some parts of Kenya were taken from Somalia... Mandera , Garissa, isiolo ... North eastern
As a Kenyan, this worries me because I know my country would be compelled to increase its military involvement if Al Shabaab ever grows bigger than its breeches. Such actions only spur hostility between citizens of our two countries.
Your country will only be compelled to increase it's military presence already is due to your government relying on western aid i.e loans.
This guy is encouraging them Somali sent written complaint against him.
@@hawakarshe7904
Which guy???
You arent compelled to do anything! your country is leaving in 2024 no matter what you say! Thats a signed deal!
shutupd and sitdown and do what england and washington tells you to do like a good slave.
From sudan we love all Somalians and wish peace for thier country
Definition of an extremist ; a coward with a gun.
Coward??GO and try them nonsence you gonna see you neck will sudenly change to a red colour
As An Afghan I wish All my Somalian brothers and sisters Peace love and stability in their country
How is afghanistan now? Peaceful?
Christian Prince RUclips .
Islam is a very bad idea
Thank u from somali girl my brother
@@albusai what is a good idea then if islam is bad idea man
Love Somalia, from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
THANK YOU!!! Oh goodness me the MANY times you have shown support may GOD BLESS YOU ALL 😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏😏🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐
Somalis are some of the most hospitable ppl. May Allah protect them and increase their eman
Ur Allah is destroying humankind and so many country on relegion shame on islam, if u forcibly impose islam other people it will repel.
Peace I pray ,,sorry for those who lost their families due to attack
It was very well explained, peace up upon Somalian people.
Thank you bro
@@az6475 you are welcome
@Isis Amun muhiimada ka raac.
@Isis Amun somali ethnicity, Somalian nationality
Somalian: relating to the African republic of Somalia or its people or their language and culture. Somali language or Somali descent, or a person if is from. perhaps, you'll figure it out anyway.
Great report. Non biased, informative.
قوه عزه الله ينصر دينكم يا شيخ😄☝️
بإذن الله النصر قريب يا إخواني في الصومال المسلم
yaa somalia oo meshan joogo😂😂
Aniga sxb
cabsi cabsi
✋
🤚
Hana Baxareen Ma Daawan 😂😔🤣😔😀
Wadankeena ilahey hanoo xasiliyo 🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
Aamiin yaa rabiiiii 🤲🤲
Aamiin yaa rabiiiii 🤲🤲
Amiin Amiin
as a kenyan i believe yet again we are facing an enemy that is growing in the shadows ..and probably the move to remove our army from somalia was a wrong move ..so this is the time where somali people should take action and fight for their country ... my respect to the somali soldiers and soldiers from neighbouring countries who risk to go and try to restore peace in somalia may God be with them
The United Nations does not allow Somalia to have more than 20k soldiers atleast Somalia should have 200k soldiers cause Al Shabaab only has 12k soldiers
Kenya should help build Somali military with more recruits and more weapons
@user-fc9zs8bb6p no only 12k Al Shabaab fighters exist Islam doe not need to be fight for Islam is peace like it or not Somalia will be peace with government
@@user-fc9zs8bb6p nope uae 🇦🇪 Oman 🇴🇲 Morocco 🇲🇦 all have peace so Somalia 🇸🇴 will have peace and you can’t stop that you terrorist 🤣
All nations neighbouring Somalia should work together to restore order. Its all of Africa's problem.
This was an amazing report.
I wanna salute the journalist who had taken a lot of effort to make this short documentary based on Al Shabab.
He is alshabab ideologically
This is what I call actual journalism, these reporters essentially risk their lives to tell these stories. Standing at a political rally and purposely saying controversial things to wind up people isn’t journalism, nor is it groundbreaking or brave. I’m looking at you Kaitlin Bennett…
The journalist is paid by BBC to prop up England’s newly trained terrorist. This is not journalism this is paid fed and trained by England and USA
It's better 😌 to know more about him
Hahaha what a joke! western mainstream media has no real journalists or journalism, the narrative is controlled by billionaires, they aren’t independent thinkers.
@@muhiyadiinmohammed3812, he’s a good journalist
AYOTOLLAH KHOMEINI land
Alhamdulillah. May Allah make more strong then before.❤
great documentary, incredible reporter, very good interviewing skills
Just as Congo is fighting a war that isn't originally theirs, it sends chills down my spine as a Kenyan. May God restore peace back. If even a few are willing. According to His holy word
Wake up how many Arab countries are funding al Shabaab just check Wikipedia Qatar Iran Saudi Arabia all are funding the jihadist and the us bombing it’s all proxy war
Peace and Love to my Africa🖤❤
As a proud Somali My peace prevail in this nation.
Watching from Brazil my mind can't comprehend this style of living.
You don't understand that the west is really behind terrorism in Somalia.
The west through 'somaliland' & the djibouti regime maintains Al-Shabaab.
Terrorist acts are plotted from inside Somalia by the west using ngos, activists, un etc.
The Somali people will defeat the west and their children the terrorists.
U r soft
I love this People Muslims 🇸🇴 ❤🙏 from Algeria 🇩🇿
🇸🇴❤️🔥🇩🇿
What an incredible journalist. Great reporting!
May ALLAH be with you my muslim brothers. Any one who is fighting for ALLAH and his din will get a reward on jannah.
Let Somalia become Great Nation again , love from Denmark
God will bring us peace insha allah🇸🇴
May Allah restore peace to Somalia and may he bless this journalist
MASHALLAH SUBANALLAH ALLAH AKBAR I AM PROUD OF PEOPLE OF SOMALIA 🇸🇴 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
اللهم أعز الإسلام والمسلمين
It's one of the best journalist I have ever seen. Good work. May Allah bless you and keep you safe!
Thank you to the journalist for this honest and brave reporting, prayers for Somalia and all the people there just looking to get by in peace.
Honest? The man is under the gun of a madman.
He a terrorist junalist he has been held by the UK government
African countries will free from looters France & America. They will agin rich. No body will die for food & water. Under Islamic Law African countries were rich. Do you know about African Rich Sultan Mansa Musa??
And those Who said A S is a monster, kill many armies! Its not fewer than hirosima & nagasaki?
Do you know How much innocent people killed by America?
Love From Bangladesh 🇧🇩
i wish peace to Somalia, from ethiopia
You don't understand that the west is really behind terrorism in Somalia.
The west through 'somaliland' & the djibouti regime maintains Al-Shabaab.
Terrorist acts are plotted from inside Somalia by the west using ngos, activists, un etc.
The Somali people will defeat the west and their children the terrorists.
No peace with Ethiopia until we get back our somali Ogaden region they occupied
"no peace" is never the right answer.@@daviroza4700
peace in Somalia from Pakistan 🇵🇰
May allah bless Somalia, beautiful country with beautiful people.
YOUR ALLAH WILL NOT BE HAPPY IF YOU HARM OTHER PEOPLE.
It’s a beautiful country, too bad it’s full of Somalis.
صهص
ammen good world war🇸🇴❤❤❤🤛🤜🤚👊💪💪💪
am really impressed by these video
Amazing journalism
Jamal Osman....Good ,to the point interview, with dignity and respect.
Kudos to these journalist across all media for going the extra miles to inform us. I wish you all protection. Maximum respect to your team
A bunch of shameful cowards, if they were brave and proud of their actions, they'd show their faces! May peace prevail.
Awesome reporting
"Waiting Game" simple but yet very effective military strategy.
The Somali Civil War has continued for over 3 decades.
Afghanistan you have the watch we have the time the West needs to start putting money into it own people
For 5 years the West were kept out of Somalia and Al-Shabaab was almost defeated. And now suddenly channel 4 is making them important
@@jamaaloromo3698 facts
@@jamaaloromo3698 for real
I pray peacefully my Country 🇸🇴😭
Anaka is dileyna ya loga duceyna marka? Foreigners mahan waxa wadankena burburinayo balse wa anaka.
@@oversees9739 waa runta oo Soomalida fahmi la’yihiin, waxaane jecelnahay dad kale inaa fartu ku fiiqno
@@irrelevant9424 sax wlhi anaka aya gacantena ku burburineyno wadankena kadib dib xagu naga heysta ayan lenahay,
Lkn anku weydiye adiga dorashada wadanka ka dacdey mxaa fikrad ka diban lahed ayado qabil usan opinion kaga so galin?
Somaliland doesn’t have Shabaab problem 😂 I wonder why 😂😂😂😂
The problem is islam it’s dangerous religion
I gotta journal on this also
sending love, peace and prosperity from out of space.🚀🌙❤
From Northern Nigeria 🇳🇬 I really Love Somalia 🇸🇴 and I pray Allah give peace to Somalia 🇸🇴
Thnks Boss also we love you
Thanks brother and God bless
Same way the northern Nigeria 🇳🇬 is a problem in Nigeria 🇳🇬
Thank you brother I greet you from northern kenya
Why is it always the north of each country that houses terrorist islam groups there is something fundamentally wrong with you people
Jamal is great journalist. Brave reporting.
Islam caused way too much suffering in this world
But it's opposite that, islam means peace
@@Abu_xamsasubmission technically 😅
My guy with the belt fed is gonna have a stoppage. Missing a round in the link. Let’s hope his stoppage drills are on point.
Proper journalism! Good item, respect.
"Democracy is a religion"
Yeah i see the problem here.
Well it is a part of their religion. Democracy and its underlying doctrine of popular sovereignty is part of liberalism, which is in turn the political philosophy of the religion of modernism which the West and friends are trying to and have been imposing upon the rest of the world for decades.
That is so dumb
حتى الغزال ألفهم ويأكل من أيديهم ❤
😂😂😂
these animals obey Allah and they know these people are the end time soldiers and the black flag people
Thanks for this amazing documentary.
Wll they are trying to advertise alshabab so they can bring more us and foreign troops in our country and actually the guy who made this documentary is foreign spy
@@hamzaofficial1325 US army is not such a small gang that they will be influenced by this documentary. Why you are fearing? They will prevent al shabab? And establish a puppet govt.?
@@hamzaofficial1325 Doy you support al shabab? Do you want Islami imarah?
@@believers_1 Every Muslim have to support. No muslim is a muslim who refuses Sharia Law. It's not Multiple Choice Question rather here is only one correct way to live the life as a Muslim.
@@IsmailHossain-bq2bo thank u for speaking the truth brother ❤ may allaah bless u and your family
Amazing piece of journalism -- keep up the great work!
ALLAHU AKBAR
May God help Somalia
I live in Europe and im not Somali but I have somali friends who are the best, May Allah make Somalia great again,
Don't be stupid same Allah brought The calamity upon them
Al Shabaab in Europe 😮😢 is every somali alkebab 😂
Allah doesn’t exist
@@mohamedwaititi6192 u ok?
One day in my lifetime peace will prevail in Somalia and I shall visit there soon. God is still in Control
May Allah bring Peace ❤❤❤.we love it's so bad watching my home land getting destroyed 😢😢😢😢😢😮❤❤❤
Peace to the beautiful sea blue land....Somalia.
The day the world was watching the chaos in Kabul airport after US’s abrupt withdrawal one thing that came into my mind was Somalia. The reason why this group who massacred thousands of Somalis is thriving is because of weak and corrupt government that fights itself. A government that relies on foreign forces is eventually doomed so Somali government has to rethink its strategy and learn from what happened to Afghan before it is too late.
Somalia is not Somalia anymore it's "tribe" country now.
abrupt? we made a deal with the taliban in 2020 and europe left Afghanistan in april, it was obviously who ever was intelligence on that mission and the marines doing it they were getting shot at from like 200 meters away the whole evacuation,like stop the fucing evac clear the area at least
Kabul 2.0….Coming soon to Mogadishu??
@@irrelevant9424 God forbid
US and their allied has failed in every mission what do you expect from them just see ongoing war in Ukraine they are in zero idea
I really appreciate America for their consistent help in my country ❤🇺🇸🇸🇴
There is no somali named Will
@Karim k You're ignorant, Karim = terrorist.
Loser where ever USA goes it will never hear apiece
America Are warlords always provoking war
my people and my country
Somali and Kenyans are the nicest people. I pray for peace in these countries ♥️
Kenyans we are okay and very christians.. peaceful people in East Africa.. you should be concerned with these terrorist neighbors
@@samutykuntathebantu8402 there’s terrorist groups all over the world under different names, ethnic groups, religion only purpose for all these groups is materialistic & gain power nothing to do with Christianity, Islam ☪️ or other religion
@@samutykuntathebantu8402 yess we are terrorists to u, do something about it kkkkkk 11 years since linda nchi and u haven't even reached jilib 😂😂😂 stop embarrassing urself and leave, maybe then u can find peace with shabaab
@@ishaaqwardere hehe cry baby cry
@@samutykuntathebantu8402We are coming, and what is coming is stronger
May the lord help the people of Somalia 🙏🏾
the best solution is to give somalia their religious power
subhanallah. 2017 was the most terrifying year for me and I felt my whole neighborhood shake from the ground up, ripples effect through the ground and strapnals flying above us, I was saved from it and shielded from it Alhamdulilaah but some of my family members wasn't 😪
Sorry to hear about your family I pray your country sees peace and prosperity
sorry wllo. ilahey ha unaxariisto intake kudhimatey. It was a sad year for all somalis.
Well balanced interview
Democracies don’t nurture in a vacuum. They need a well-functioning political, social and economic system, and an independent judiciary.
When rotten regimes are abetted by exploitative elites, weak institutions and the absence of an empowered central authority, failure is all but a natural result.
@Playmaking Shotcreator Sure but the solution isn't Islam. In fact the US supported these groups in the 80s. Afghanistan would have been better off as a democratic Republic
@@NovajaPravda No, no it wouldnt! this just tells me that you have 0 undertsanding of the society of both Somalia and Afghanistan, people in these 2 countries are very tribal. Any form of democracy will devolve into tribal factionalism. The only thing that unites Somalis or Afghans is the faith, history is testament to this and its also the reason why these terrorist organisaations like Al-shabaab and Taliban are so damn difficult to defeat, because a large portion of the country supports them.
In somalia when someone squats in your property people go to Al-shabaab, people pay tax to Al-shabaab and many seek justice in the Sharia courts of Al-shabaab which is the only entity in the country that hasnt been corrupted by tribalism. They are literally a state within a failed state. The so called "government' in Somalia is a joke and barely even rules anything outside the capital, the president is protected by foreign troops from other AU countries who no somali wants on their soil. The president of somalia is often called "Mayor of Mogadishu" lol
I guarentee, all the USA is doing here is delaying the inevitable.
@@NovajaPravda Islam isn't the solution but democracy is? In western democratic countries like the US, murders and rapists are put back out on the streets or spend their lives in jail cells costing $35,000 a year without having to contribute anything to society. Under Islam, they are beheaded or stoned to death.
@@NovajaPravda Islam is the solution
@@B10101 No Islam is Slavery and everything that hinder society from moving forward. Communism is the answer