"Do nothing? Offer him up as bait?" | Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июн 2012
- “Potter is a boy! Not a piece of meat!”
Professor Minerva McGonagall (Dame Maggie Smith), Professor Severus Snape (Alan Rickman), Alastor ‘Mad-Eye’Mood (Brendon Gleeson) and Professor Albus Dumbledore (Michael Gambon) discuss Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe’s) participation in The Triwizard Tournament.
When Harry Potter’s name emerges from the Goblet of Fire, he becomes a competitor in a grueling battle for glory among three wizarding schools - the Triwizard Tournament. But since Harry never submitted his name for the Tournament, who did? Now Harry must confront a deadly dragon, fierce water demons and an enchanted maze only to find himself in the cruel grasp of He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named. In this fourth film adaptation of J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series, everything changes as Harry, Ron and Hermione leave childhood forever and take on challenges greater than anything they could have imagined.
Harry Potter Blu-Ray and DVD available at selected retailers.
J.K.Rowling’s Wizarding World & © Warner Bros.
Cast: Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint
Director: David Yates
Producers: David Barron, Debbi Bossi, Roy Button, David Heyman, Tim Lewis, J.K. Rowling, John Trehy, Lionel Wigram
Writing Credits: J.K Rowling (novel), Steve Kloves (screenplay)
The Harry Potter channel is the only official and largest collection of licensed movie clips from J.K Rowling’s Wizarding World. Here you will find all of your favourite lines, moments, and memories from all your favourite Harry Potter films.
Facebook: / harrypottermovie
Twitter: / harrypotterfilm
Instagram: / harrypotterfilm 
Кино
![Prefessor Snape vs Lupin and Black | Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban [Open Matte 16:9]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_RB3pv-mbL0/mqdefault.jpg)
"Potter is a boy, not a piece of meat!"
"I agree.... with Severus"
later in snape's memories:
"You've been raising him like a pig for slaughter!"
Remorf Chucket True xD
He's a piece of bacon
Horse Radish it makes you question everything about harry”s life did Dumbles send him to his aunts place to make him look weak and easy to control and did he allow Harry to be ostracized year after year so he would prefer to die?
I know 😂😂😂 That part on of that memory is my fav 😅💔
That's just what I was thinking about. This happens when you write a script with no idea how characters work.
That awkward moment where McGonagall is the only one who gives a crap about Harry not getting mauled by a dragon.
Potts is a mieeewww
I believe McGonagall dated Harry's grandfather when they went to Hogwarts
Besides Molly Weasley, she is the only mother figure Harry has
@@thebandit0256 evidence?
we find out actually Snape does
at the end McGonagall was so done with Dumbledoor's shit
Lol I never noticed this in the movie
Aden Barber shes like eurgh allow this shit
Minerva Mcgonagall imposter!
*Dumbledore
Aden Barber pofkfur
Alan Rickman says the word "however" many times in all eight films. For some strange reason, I love every one of these moments.
"furthermore" is nice aswell
True, I’ve heard Snape say “However” and “furthermore” a lot of times that whenever I read those words, I hear it in Alan Rickman’s voice.
And "Always"
You can see McGonagall exhale in surrender when he says it too. "I knew there was a 'but' coming..."
But the greatest "however" in the entire series comes from Dumbledore
I would never forget Maggie! Especially after she performed so well in the Deathly Hallows while battling breast cancer. She is an inspiration!
TheK9chief she had breast cancer during that?!?!?!
I never knew this!!
Oh bless her old heart.....
yeah most surprising to me was her effortless Scottish accent while she's actually british!
She was my favorite female professor.
Oh my God 😖😖😖😖😖
I guess she didn't make it?
1:01 McGonagall be like "Why do I even bother?" #McGonagone
Joys of being a Virgo moon
@@googlebarbaralernerspectre2581 Life is so much more than astrology and horoscopes, darling ;-)
@@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 Of course but it's still fun stuff to talk about
@@googlebarbaralernerspectre2581 Omg you're so kirky, that's so leo 🙄
😂😂
Am I the only one who LOVES scenes with Dumbledore, Snape and Mcconagel?
Not only are the the past 3 headmasters, they are probably the 3 of the greatest wizards at the school
minerva is a witch not a wizard
Yeee
@@talatnoor2445 I just pictured Snape having two older twin brothers who owned a joke shop and it make a whole lot of things clear.
@@chloerose5999 if in general, its wizard
@@buddyobbard2176 Snape does have two older twin brothers though! Don't you remember Sebastian Snape and Saul Snape?
0:44 Is one of my favourite lines in the whole film series XD
"Potter is a BOY, Not a piece of meat?!"
"You've been raising him like a pig for slaughter!"
0809AriAri, Cllouddless AJ
Don't tell me now, that you've both grown to care for the boy...
Always
Cllouddlless AJ and when Dumbledore said "I agree, with Severus" it sounded like he admitted that he sees Harry like a piece of meat.
Minnie McGonagall cared greatly for all her little cubs.
"Potter is a boy, not a piece of meat"
"actually, he is a pig for slaughter... oh, did I say that out loud?"
Hehehe lol
Snape found out about that pig for slaughter thing when dumbledore got cursed by the ring..and told about Harry being a horcrux
@@anirudhnair__4034 and even he was horrified by it.
Maggie Smith is a national treasure. Seriously, there's no-one who could've portrayed McGonagall better.
Snaps: let him compete
Mcgonagall: Don’t let him compete
Dumbledore: I agree...
Mcgonagall: Oh thank god you agree-
Dumbledore: ...with Snape
Snape: AAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYY!
Dumbledore: AAAAAAAAYYYYYY!
Mcgonagall: (How many more years until Half blood prince?)
He roasted her XD
@Ravenclaw BNed, OMG. This is absolutely hilarious.😂
_AAAAYYY~~!_ XD
And a Brofist at the end
😂😂😂
I love it when Professor McGonagall's like, "What?" After Snape puts forward his suggestion 😂
Snape: "is mayonnaise an instrument?" 0:35
McGonagall: Huh???????
I loved McGonagall, both in the movies and in the book. I think it was one of the most accurate adaptations of the character in the series. Strict, but lovable and very protective of her students.
I always put my finger to my head and try to suck my uncomfortable memories out of my head as Dumbledore did.
Fox Teen thanks for the brilliant idea
Say 'Obliviate' doing so.
We all do, son.
Omg I do this all the time! Glad I’m not the only one. It makes me feel better afterwards.
Screw muggle therapy and psych meds.
I want a pensieve,to get rid of bad memories for good.
I actually agree with Snape’s idea to put Harry in danger. They had no evidence on why Harry’s name was in the Goblet of Fire or how it got there. By letting the events unfold they thought they could piece it together before something bad happens.
At 1:02 Mcgonagall is like: why am i even here.
Lmao
"Offer him up as bait? Potter is a boy, not a piece of meat!"
**_years later_**
"So when the time comes, the boy must die? You've been raising him like a pig for slaughter!"
well quite frankly its only one year
@@fumuso It's two years, Dumbledore says this to Snape after he gets cursed by the Gaunt family's ring.
@@fumuso well quite frankly it is 3 years later but…. yeah
"Potter is a boy, not a piece of meat!" is my absolute favourite line in every movie ever. And in real life. It is the best sentence ever spoken. Because Maggie Smith.
nah sorry its gotta be 'i always wanted to use that spell!' and mrs weasley is like what?!
poor mcgonagall she didn't know this was all a plan between dumbledore and snape
@@HazzerJazzer1 debatable
This is one of my favorite line of Maggie but my favorite is in that on scene in Downton Abbey when she said " do you promise " still all Maggie's line is so good.
Hm...what was that McGonagall said in the previous film?
"It can only be signed by a parent or guardian and since I am neither it'd be inappropriate!"
For someone who is "neither a parent or guardian" to Harry, she sure does act like one in this scene. And I love it.
Thing is she would do this for any of her students
@@youtubeistryingtocensorme But not the students of other houses, slytherin needs to rebrand itself
0:37 the most adorable and underrated "wat?"
I laughed so hard at Professor McGonagall at 1:03
She’s so over it 😂
1:01 minerva just being so done and walking away lmao
Seriously, I never understood why Harry HAD to compete in the tournament.
A binding curse, according to fanfic, harry would have died if he had not.
Deux ex machina it is!
The idea is that the fake Moody knew this was the case. Its hardly an after fact retcon. The whole point of entering his name is the fact that Voldy knew he'd have to compete if his name was entered.
cn😄😄😄😄😄😄😄
i think if Crouch senior wasnt under the imperious curse influence he would never have allowed Harry to compete in the tournament
The only person who can call Albus, Albus and not Headmaster. That tells you the bond and power of Minerva.
Madam Pomfrey , Aberforth , the lady at Three Broomsticks , Horace. Slughorn ... The list goes on dude
@@apurvchaturvedi I was about to bring that up--all of the staff members seem to be on a first name basis with one another in general.
"Keep an eye on Harry will you"?
i can do that
Badum - ting!
The greatest wizard of all time my ass 😂
Geezer can't even recognize a Death Eater posing to be a respected auror.
Akira Sah
Ya do know it’s been 30 years since they saw each other... just sayin but Dumbledore is old, really really old.
@@akirarsah he was great at faking Moody tho.He was showing the same personality as Moody,being the best DADA teacher in years etc.
In some ways Dumbledore was really was a villain. He used people as he saw fit to accomplish his goals. His brother was right
I just love how McGonagall throws her hands in the air, I think she lost faith in men. Also Moody just standing in the corner, not being bothered at all, kills me😂😂
alastair aka barty is like mcongall is scaryyy
what struck me the most...was dumbledore never aware that moody wasnt the real him for so long he stood close to him in the movie until the revelation?
Barty is just like "oh you guys have no idea what's gonna happen to Potter"
@@monarcmonarc8881 Barty played Moody well. So well in fact that Dumbeldore didn’t realize who he was until after Harry comes out of the graveyard and Fake Moody takes him to his office out of site from Dumbeldore after what happened. The real Moody wouldn’t do that
Lost faith in men?
1:01 i like how McGonogall is like: I give up on dumbledore, him and his big brain
Lol I just realized that if Dumbledore listened to McGonagall, Voldemort wouldn’t have been reborn and the next 4 books/movies wouldn’t be necessary.
Trust me Voldemort servants would have found other ways even if this failed. From what I remember, in the first and second movies, they already attempted to revive him so....
Well Dumbledore never accepted that Voldemort was gone completely and knew by speculation that Voldemort would eventually find a way to return. Even if Voldemort's plan didn't work, his return to power would only be postponed.
Wrong. Voldemort didn't need Harry's blood to be revived, he could've just used someone else's. In fact, if Voldemort hadn't gotten Harry's blood there, Harry's protection from his mother wouldn't have survived and he would've died when the killing curse was used on him by Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest, meaning the War would've been lost. So, Dumbledore remaining on his decision actually saved the Wizarding World from Voldemort's reign.
There is a theory that
The original plan wasn't for Harry to run away from Voldemort.
Voldemort had planned to polyjuice himself or a supporter into harry and return using portkey to attack the school from inside . Imagine if a harry double killed Dumbledore .
That's why the port key worked the second time. So they would have returned as the winner and then use Harry
@Jake agree. Also Voldemort wouldn't have become Harry's Horcrux, eventually becoming one of the reasons that in Deathly Hallows Harry came back from dead
Maggie Smith's performance as Minerva McGonagall was truly awe-inspiring in my opinion she truly deserves an Oscar if that is the highest award any actors/actress can be awarded because her work as McGonagall was truly both perfectly Cannon and flawlessly accurate together with heartwarming Lee tender once you get past the characters outer shell
Notice how Minerva throws her hands up, knowing full well, Dumbledores decision.
And this is why Professor McGonagall is one of my top favorites. She truly cares, but rarely shows it.
mcGonagall on 00:25 : yes Snape backup me!
mcGonagall on 0:39 : what's wrong this guy😅
Alan Rickman is such an amazing actor
and he'll always be remembered as one.
@@frankpoole8645 "always"
Truly, madly, deeply...
Its the same movie where dumbledore asks harry, "DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE" calmly.
I feel like Mcgonagall was the only one who truly gave a damn about Harry ! She cared about him as a person and not just an experiment ! Maggie played this role amazing! I want to see more about mcgonagall ! She was such a strong character and women ! 💚💚
"Do nothing"? "Offer him up as bait"? "Potter is a boy, Not a piece of meat". Best quote by Professor McGonagall
Dumbledore agreeing with Snape's suggestion really kinda shows that Harry was just a tool for Dumbledore to use for his own ends
And Snape disagreed with Dumbledore on this point
+Eric Graham actually Snape disagreed with Dumbledore on this, on a side note I'm of the opinion that Snape actually cared for Harry its just he has never shown it
Just like the Bene Gesserit wanted to use Paul Muad'dib for their own purposes in Dune, because he was the Kwisatz Haderach. But he would not be their tool.
Your comment shows you have no understanding of either Snape nor Dumbledore. Snape wanted nothing more than for Harry to be safe. Facts are though, that Harry IS indeed already in it, and someone wants him in it. They have to know what's happening, for the greater good of everyone. It comes back to the question "save the baby or a thousand people".
I think its more complex than that. I mean, Harry IS the child of the woman he loves and his worst enemy. Every time Snape would see Harry he'd be reminded of Lily, but also the mistakes he made with her. And not only that, Harry would be a living reminder to Snape that the woman he loved chose another man; even worse, his worst enemy. Every time he saw James in Harry he'd feel the desire to humiliate him; not to justify his picking on Harry. But I'd say his feelings towards Harry were more complex. He saved Harry numerous times. His love for Lily wasn't so much an obsession that carried onto her son; Lily's death became Snape's ambition which kept him on Dumbledore's side from then on, till his demise. It was also likely an atonement for him to protect Harry. That being said, I think he disliked Harry despite caring for him.
At 1:01 #McGonagone
Grayson Peoples I concur #McGonagone
Grayson Peoples I like she
#McGonadone
The way Michael Gambon handles the elder wand suits him very well.
When you have these 4 actors. Especially Maggie Smith And Alan Rickman. The best scene!
I love how concerned and carring Moganagle is towards Harry (almost like another mother figure to him just like Mrs. Weasley).
Id say surrogate nana
I love the dynamic character interaction scenes like this. It’s so human.
Even tho Minerva wasn't related to Harry,she cared about him greatly.But she cared about all her little cubs( Gryffindor house crest is 🦁).
Yep surrogate granny seeing as lily was close to her
I love how Dumbledore does magic so casually
My first time watching harry potter series and i thought dumbledore was gonna Avada Kedavra himself at 0:57
what the :,DDD
😂😂😂😂😂
Hahahaha!!!
I think Albus is really aggressive in this film
But I love Minerva's line!
And people call me crazy when I say that Dumbledore is a Slytherin at heart.
“...I think we sort too soon” -Albus Dumbledore Deathy Hallows Snapes Memories
He was brilliantly ingenious and a master manipulator. However he used these traits for good. It was he who caused the eventual downfall of Voldemort using Harry and Snape. To counter someone like Voldemort, you need someone as powerful, clever, far sighted and ultimately good at heart person like Dumbledore.
I think the Sorting Hat sometimes sorts people into whichever house they need to learn from the most, instead of which traits they already have. For instance, Peter Pettigrew was a Gryffindor - maybe the Hat hoped he would learn bravery? Also, Hermione was a total nerd, which would usually mean she'd be a Ravenclaw, but she was sorted into Gryffindor. She was always the most hesitant of the three when rules and respect came into question, so maybe she needed to learn bravery, too, in that way.
@@piequals314 interesting point
@@piequals314
Peter was sorted into Gryffindor for the same reason that Harry was; he *wanted* to be sorted into Gryffindor.
i'm surprised no one has tried to steal dumbledore's memories, or at least watch them
Not sure about how many people did know about the Pensieve, apart from staff members such Snape and McGonagall, who were extremely loyal to Dumbledore
ah that makes sense
0809AriAri and harry
and Barty Crouch Jr. who is in the room here
After he died I'd spend months going through his memories! It would be like doing the same for Einstein, or Bill Gates, or MLK, just to name a random few. Imagine what insights you could gain. Dumbledore was one of, if not thee greatest wizard that ever lived. Having access to all his memories puts you on the same path yourself, or very close to it. I could see Harry becoming and even greater wizard by learning from the previous best.
Can I just say that the movie made a big mistake here, Snape would have never suggested using Harry as bait! he didn't like Harry but still wanted to protect him at any cost. He was furious later when Dumbledore told him that harry needed to be sacrificed!
Snape was essentially Dumbledore's spymaster and double agent. From his perspective, allowing things to proceed gave them a chance to watch for Voldemort's influence and maybe get some insight into his plans, capabilities, and whereabouts. Unfortunately, Voldemort outplayed both Dumbledore and Snape by having a double agent of his own.
If u actually read the books, u should know that it was dumbledore who order snape to keep an eye on him and "protect" him, altough he kinda "helps" harry, he has done nothing more than humilliate him and mock him until his dead where he reveals harry his role of double agent, snape was essentialy always at dumbledore mercy or voldemort's. It was the movies who portrayed him at the end as kind of a father to harry, yet harry took his name for the love and loyalty he have for his mother and the "sacrifice" he has to make as a double agent.
The movie never portrayed him like that mugen.
McGonagall was the mom that Harry never had and that his aunt could never be.
Don't forget Molly Weasley tho
Snape and McGonagall scenes were one of the best scenes in the movies imo
"potter is a boy not a piece of meat"
"I agree with severus"
"yOuvE bEeN rAiSiNg hIm lIKe A PiG fOr sLaUgHtEr"
Poor Harry..being treated like baconxD
McGonagall is like the only professor who cares about the students honestly
"POTTER IS A BOOOY, not a piece of meat"
Later on we discover Snape giving Dumbledore a hard time by knowing that he had to die in order to kill Voldemort.
You know that if Mcgonagall was able to, she would have raised Harry herself
She commented on how foul the dursleys were and didnt like the idea of harry staying with em as if she would have preferred her or hagrid take care of him over his own only family.
Awww I like McGonagall in this scene :)
Maggie Smith's acting in this scene is underrated.
"I agreee.......with Severus"
"Potter is a boy! Not a piece of meat!" -Mcgonagal
HarryPotter Fan4eva Dumbledore's reply , HAVE YOU GROWN TO CARE FOR THE BOY?
1:01 a teacher was like " wut's this doing here"😂😂😂😂
Snape: so when the time comes the boy must die
Dumbledore: yes, the pig must be slaughtered
Hahahaha she's like "Fuck this shit".
Rickman (RIP) gets so much praise for his Snape, and rightly so - but boy, was Maggie Smith an absolutely triumphant bit of casting and a wonderful servant to the series also.
Anyone else see professor McGonagall storming out of the room out of frustration?
Meanwhile Barty jr. Is there like
"I have to stand here and listen to their babbling..."
Alan Rickman and Maggie Smith are just perfect. Pity the same can't be said for Michael Gambon.
Yes, the original dumbledore was perfect though.
michael gambon was perfect. in my opinion he was better than richard
Helena Nußhart You clearly haven't read the books.
+Ihdc1 i think some people prefer the movie dumbledore, because the first one was too calm. i did like him better though but i can see why some people dont
Laura Rizik The book Dumbledore was calm so Harris was more true to the book than Gambon.
Identity misplaced aside - the fact that Dumbledore was smart enough to have Moody around and keep an eye on Harry does show that at the very least he cares for Harry's safety. Can never accuse Dumbledore of not taking safety measures.
Let's not forget Maggie Smith!
The fact Dumbeldore let Harry compete, and the part about the supposed look of triumph on Dumbeldore’s face when Harry mentions that he took his blood, really makes me think that Dumbeldore was attempting to steer Voldemort in this direction all-along. He knew that confrontation was inevitable, so he drew it out.
Macgonagall actually had a point and Dumbledore was being an idiot (this one time)
Dumbledore has been an idiot a couple of times actually. He himself noted that eventually, though not referring to himself in that way of course.
You mean all the time?
Yap if only he did not send harry away then, cedric will never die because moody will never enhance the cup as a portkey.
Minerva has the absolute faith in Dumbledore, but that won't stop her from stating her opinion or calling him out when she thinks he's wrong.
It is a common theme between Harry Potter and Star Wars. Obi Wan and Dumbledore manipulated the main character and put them in danger with mis-truths and for their own ends. Yes it was for the greater good but there it is.
In the book dumbledore is all calm and relaxed and believes harry, but here he is literally raging off his beard with anger.
Maybe that’s why Voldemort is so afraid of Dumbledore.
I love how his accent keeps slipping between English and Irish.
Damn, I wish I could experience Hogwarts with McGonagall as headmistress
McGonagall is only one with sence of security in the school. I know she offered a position of seeker to Harry in the first year. But this is absolute different, fighting a dragon, creatures in the lake and maze. And when the goblet chose Harry it's just too obvious someone manipulated it. Letting Harry compete was arrogant and stupid. I know there is a contract btw a competitor and the goblet, but in the second task they could disqualify him from the game or they should persuide him that "Harry you must abandon the game, there is something evil behind it, if you countinue your friend and the whole wizardy world will be in danger pls HARRY" :D
r.i.p. alan rickman :(
Severus: If we are to discover the meaning behind these events, we for time being should turn to page 394
Dumbledore: “I agree.............. with Severus.”
McGonagall: “The hell? So you’re gonna send the only person who can defeat Voldemort to battle dragons to see what’s going on? That’s it I’m out.
1:02
That’s it. She’s done with yall.
Weird how we find out later that Snape was always in a weird way looking out for Harry, but in this moment is okay with him competing in this little tourney thing as bait. Which we find out is quite dangerous, even without the element of knowing it's clearly someone setting Harry up. Was he testing Dumbledore, was he okay with it cause he wanted Harry to learn something, was it just a moment of sub par writing? It just feels weird for someone that cares about Harry to sign off on this. Unless he was confident everyone else would protect Harry and he didn't wanna blow his cover as a Voldemort supporter. Clearly I am overthinking this.
This scene kind of summarizes the entire franchise.
This is one unique scene that wasn't in the book, but still done perfectly on depicting the Hogwarts Staff's concern for Harry.
mcgonagall mother instict kicking in
1:01 McGonagall be like "Fuck you guys, Am I the only one who actually cares about Harry's health?"
Even though Dumbledore didn't know this was Voldemort's plan being set in motion, he did turn out to be correct on believing that Voldemort would find a way to return.
I like how McGongall cared Harry as he is her grandson.
I can imagine the look on the Professor's faces out of all of them McGonagall is so scared.
1:01
McGonagall was like: iM OuT
Every school has a teacher like minerva
me snooping around the to find out what's for dinner- 0:44
McGonagall's career dealing with the Potter/Weasley/Granger legacy is pretty much just 7+ years of the blinking guy meme
This scene is so powerful. That's why the movie where essential. Sure they lack a lot of details from the book and i don't consider them enough alone but they also give us more insight better visualisation things that can't be put in the book. We see harry's day to day life in its normality aswell enjoying his time in the dorm for example like in prisoner of Azkaban and now this conversation and many other details.
1:01
Mcgonagall: well im done! good luck, fools.
Ya know, for as easy as it was to get your hands on pollyjuice potions, you'd think they would have measures in place to deal with it.
McGonagall being the mother figure here is sweet.
I love McGonagall's outrage
Potter is a boy not a piece of meat!!!! I love that line
one of my most favorite scenes from the series... wish the rest of goblet of fire was this serious
She really knows how to take charge