Prefessor Snape vs Lupin and Black | Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban [Open Matte 16:9]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 янв 2021
- Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004)
Scene: Prefessor Snape vs Lupin and Black
DIscription: Harry Potter, Ron and Hermione return to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry for their third year of study, where they delve into the mystery surrounding an escaped prisoner who poses a dangerous threat to the young wizard.
Director: Alfonso Cuarón
Writers: J.K. Rowling (novel), Steve Kloves (screenplay)
Cast: Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter), Gary Oldman (Sirius Black), David Thewlis (Professor Lupin), Emma Watson (Hermione Granger), Rupert Grint (Ron Weasley), Alan Rickman (Professor Severus Snape)
WarnerMedia©
#HarryPotter
**********************************************************************
If you like 'DC Comics' - welcome! "come together, right now!"
SUBSCRIBE: goo.gl/fHigf5 
Кино
![Dementors attack Harry and Sirius | Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban [Open Matte 16:9]](/img/1.gif)
Just think, if Remus and Sirius had killed Pettigrew here, Voldemort would've never returned.
*brain starts breaking*
Doubt that. At most, his return would be delayed, but I'm sure Voldemort would have had someone else help him eventually
I mean he had many horcruxes containing his soul so it was more than likely just a matter of time before he came back.
@@armadyl1212 but still, in the cemetery all of his old death eaters weren't loyal to him anymore. i doubt they would've came back for voldy. only wormtail did.
@@armadyl1212 Barty crouch jr
I can’t imagine the trauma Ron would’ve had when he found out a full grown man was sleeping in his bed for 3 years 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
I didn’t really think about that until now. Very disturbing, but insightful for the most part
Loll
Honestly, I would have killed Peter for that. You sleep in my friends bed? You’re an adult, he’s a minor, and you think I’ll let you live after that?
What about percy he slept with it for 4 years and it probebly lifed in his room.
"Vengeance is sweet" Snape isn't talking about getting back at Sirius for bullying him as a kid. He's talking about finally coming face to face with the person he believes caused Lily's death.
It could be both, revenge for Lily's death, and revenge against one of his bullies.
@@josecuestas7246 but really, which do you think would be the much more significant reason?
@@Wingsaber Again, could be either. Bullying can leave life long mental scars. It can be just as traumatising as losing a loved one. Attempting to generalise either is insolent.
Wasn’t Snape in the loop and knew that it was Pettigrew who betrayed the Potters and just didn’t know that Sirius didn’t kill Peter?
@@Z3ZP No, Snape wasn't aware until PoA.
The acting in this scene is incredible, especially by Gary Oldman! He was the perfect Sirius Black.
Alan and Gary did great job in the movies. they way their old rivalry comes up like two grown ass kids still fighting over past grief.
@@loremaster8475 RIP Roger Lloyd Pack who did the role of the waiter in Mr. Bean
I know right ? This is when they stopped being “kids movies” lol
Gary Oldman is pretty much perfect for any role. The great thing about Gary is that he never looks or acts the same in any movie so you don't even notice that's it's him.
@@disinfect777 couldn’t have said it better myself big facts bro
"Harry, you attacked a teacher!!!"
Dumbledore: I doesn't matter, 50 points to Griffindor
In the book, Harry, Ron and Hermione attacked him simultaneously.
@@vetarlittorf1807 then 150 points for Griffindor 😉
@@holymackenaw For saving two people from losing their souls for something they haven't done? Absolutely!
Dumbledore: "Oh Harry, you faced off Quirell and the spirit of Lord Voldemort as an 11 year old? Well that's just as bloody good as a Hufflepuffer answering 10 questions right in charms class! 50 points!"
😆😆😆
"Look at you two quarrelling like an old married couple"🤣🤣🤣
They maybe married
Before Sirius died
“Why don’t you run along and play with your chemistry set?”
@Bellatrix Lestrange Who knows🤷♀️👬🤣
@@scottmurphy4278 No way....I want to play with you...
@@leakotlica2472 🤣
4:11 “I WOULD’VE DIED! I WOULD’VE DIED RATHER THAN BETRAY MY FRIENDS!” Powerful line.
Harry's godfather everyone
Sirius Black- An honorary Potter who was true to his promise to James and Lily until the very end. Respect💯💪🏽
@@AdrianMC692 I prefer one of my theories that James and Sirius are half brothers sharing the same mom yes Walburga Black
@@thebandit0256 That would've been cool. They already felt like brothers to me anyway💯👍🏼
That’s easier said than done, Voldemort would have just used the crucioartish curse on him until he gave in
“Severus.. don’t be a fool..”
“He can’t help it it’s habit by now”
“Sirius be quiet”
“BQUIYATYASELFREMUS!”
I love this dialogue 😂😂😂 old school goers who know how to press each other’s buttons; I love it.
Remus: You shut up!
Sirius: No, you shut up!
😂😂☠️
I love how Remus just throws his hands up like "Whatever man, I can't believe you guys are still this immature." 😂
"Look at you two, quarreling like and old married couple!"
@@darkstorm0433 Why don't you run along and play with your chemistry set 🤣🤣😭😭
This had to be the most awkward high school reunion *ever*
LMAO
VENGEANCE IS SWEET
you got that right friends betrayal death vengance always gona be awks with those in tow
You madlad
I beg to differ! This is the most entertaining high school reunion! So much drama lmfao 🤣
"I did my waiting... 12 years of it... In Azkaban!" Sirius said calmly.
LMAO
lmao
Honestly he actually was relatively calm for someone who spent 12 years in a hellhole surrounded by soul sucking monsters
Yes we get it the book and movie are different from one another
"HURRAHDUPUTCHERNAMINTHAGOBLOFIRE?!" Dumbledore asked calmly
"Listen to you two, quarrelling like an old married couple." "Why don't you run along and play with your chemistry set?" This dialogue was BRILLIANT, and the way they delivered the lines had me intrigued all the way through, I dream of writing a dialogue THIS good
the script is great for this scene for sure
except chemistry isnt a field in magic, its muggle. how would've either of them known what it was
@@chokemewithmydiamonds9456 snape is half blood, he knew muggle ways. i don't know where sirius would have learned the term but i do know that was taken from the book
@@chokemewithmydiamonds9456I always assumed that sirius was taunting snape for being a death eater, despite him being a half- blood with a muggle father, since snape would certainly know what chemistry is.
@@Emedinazyberi yeah but how did serius know what it was. it seems like a slip up on jk's part to me
The way Sirius's whole body convulses when he said "I would have DIED!" - like the idea of betrayal is something that is literally foreign to his being, his body REJECTS it
It’s one of the best moments I’ve witnessed in the Harry Potter films..
foreign is not the right word, but I l know what you mean. Sirius unlike Pettigrew is amazing
@@jennysd1061 foreign is the perfect word for it.
Because Sirius would’ve died before giving up the Potters location.
I think of it like this. Your animagus form reflects your personality, right? Sirius turns into a dog, a loyal companion. Will literally die protecting you. A rat, like Peter, will jump ship at the first sign of danger.
the banter is literally hilarious 1:32
Lupin: Severus don’t be a fool
Sirius: He can’t help it. It’s habit by now
Lupin: Sirius be quiet
Sirius: Go quiet yourself Remus.
Snape: Oh look at you two quarrelling like an old married couple.
Sirius: Why don’t you run along and play with you ChEmIsTrY SeT
I love the fight between serius and snape..although its deep loathing for one another but still it's funny
..😆
Hilarious
" i cOuLd dO iT y'KnOw. "
@@dxrkerrxses "Do I detect a flicker of fear?"
The dementor's kiSS...one can only imagine what that must be like to EnDuRe
Imagine being one of the kid actors and being surrounded by these legendary actors
daniel said he was always particularly awestruck by gary oldman and he became his role model for acting
@@jhibbitt2896 I don’t blame him. I would’ve done the same.
@@jhibbitt2896 Just a shame he's still a shit actor.
The luckiest kids of all time
@@jhibbitt2896 Irony...
Harry's potter "father figure" was Sirius, like Daniel's "role model" is Gary Oldman...
1:18 Sirius hasn't said a single sentence in a sane way until this point, when his retort to Snape becomes intelligent and composed. It's like his urge to make fun of Snape was so strong that it snapped him back into his old self
I suppose making fun of his old bullying victim gave him a sense of control back. Bullying is always about power and control. Love Sirius but he was also mad wrong for the way he treated Snape. Yes, Snape was not the loveliest person, neither as an adult nor when he was younger. But he was clearly at the bottom of the social hirarchy in school while the marauders were at the top. And I'm sure their bullying pushed him only further into isolation and to the dark arts as a teen.
@@dreamfaller6372 Bullying is only natural. It's about how you handle it.
@@KE-yq2eg Bullying is not natural. It's a pathetic way for someone to uplift themselves through causing harm to someone else. But yes, let's blame the victim because they're not handling it correctly🙄 I have no time for this nonesense
@@dreamfaller6372 Let us get certain things straight here.
1) Snape never went down the dark path due to bullying by James and Sirius. He even before he attended Hogwarts wanted to join Slytherin despite fully knowing it's dark reputation
2) At Hogwarts all his friends were highly problematic, dark arts lovers like Avery and Mulciber. He chose his friends himself despite Lily many times asking Severus to abandon his wrong friendships. Snape was never really isolated in general, he did have his friends circle. Just the wrong sort
3) Snape even as a first year was totally immersed in dark arts. The bullying incident in Snape's pencieve only happens in the fifth year.
4) The relationship of Marauders to Snape was complex. Snape hated James because he knew James fancied Lily. He hated Sirius, Lupin and Pettigrew because they were James's friends. Sirius among James's friends especially hated Snape. Snape also often sneaked after the marauders attempting to discover them in their adventures and later to expel them for that. SO IT WAS FAR MORE COMPLEX THAN FEW TOP STUDENTS BULLYING A KID LOWER IN THE "SOCIAL HIERARCHY"
4) Snape also attacked James at every possible opportunity.
If he was lower in the social hierarchy, it was cause of his own dark art fancies, bad associations, and ambition to later join voldemort (Lily herself accused Snape of wanting to join the dark side and having the worst friends, Snape does not deny)
JK Rowling also described Snape as a vindictive and bullying fellow in general who finally died for the right cause.
Even if James and Sirius totally left him alone, his fascination with the dark arts or his evil friend circle would never have changed. It was also entirely Snape's own choice to join voldemort.
@@Hari-kx2er wouldn't say that's why snape hated james.
The acting and chemistry between the four adult actors makes you fully believe that these three characters have a lot of history between them.
Heh, chemistry
Exactly as it should be! ❤️❤️
History they DO NOT COVER in this movie :(
Snape's Expeliarmus: gently disarms Sirius
Potter's Expeliarmus: yeets Severus a few meters away and knocks him unconscious
It could be that Snape intended to just Disarm where as Harry intended to just attack Him. It’s like focusing on a single Detail vs looking big picture and just attacking
Snape's spell hit Sirius' hand. Harry's spell hit Snape's chest
It was Hermiones wand so his magic wasn't the same strength, he wasn't used to her wand, plus they had different intentions. Snape wanted to disarm, Harry wanted him to shut up so he could get some answers.
In the book, Harry, Ron and Hermione casted the spell simultaneously; the movie's depiction was quite off.
@@anthonydeshields9613
Well, in the book, all three of them used the spell against him at once
Even with a wand at his throat, Sirius still feels the need to call Snape a nerd
Had balls of steel
Why don't you run allong and play with your chemistry set 😂😂😂
@@srikarvetcha8894 more like, “ why don’t you run along and play with your chemisTRY SEt!!”
@@quanmichel3747 Nah, he’s just a bully and a jerk.
@@n.s.9156 true can’t deny that
1:20 Look at Lupin's face. He's like, "oh dear god, here they go again."
Ah shit, here we go again
Actually Rickmans expression is like " That dialogue was not in the book"
His reaction is just like: this is why we dont sit together at lunch or in class or any table anymore
Or anywhere
Cuz of you 2
Sirius, Snape, Lupin, and Wormtail, perfectly cast and these actors really killed it. Some of the best acting ever. The subtlety of their actions indicating such intimacy between all of them, friend and foe. Truly four of the greatest actors of our time just stealing the scene from each other back and forth to create magic. What a masterclass.
I only realize now how intense this scene is after so many years. "Vengeance is sweet." Snape isn't just looking at the man who bullied him in school, he's looking at the man who he believes to have killed Lily. Knowing that, Alan Rickman's line feels so different.
Also, the entire reunion is a breakdown of trust and beliefs. Lupin appears guilty but isn't. Sirius is innocent, Pettigrew is alive, there was no Scabbers, and Harry attacked a teacher. All the creaking noises in the Shrieking Shack compliments how fragile and unstable everyone's old beliefs are in this space.
Snape is the one responsible for Lily's death
@@Tommy_111 @Wonga Nyathela Snape, Sirius and Peter all played a part:
Snape: telling Voldemort the prophecy leading him to hunt down the Potters.
Sirius: making Peter the Potter's secret keeper.
Peter: turning traitor and telling Voldemort where the Potters are.
Y
Exactly
@@Tommy_111 james and sirius are responsible for lily’s death.
The way they make the whole set move is so cool
movie*
@@katiagiannakidou537 No he's referring to the whole "building" they were in was swaying. Watch the double doors through the whole scene.
@@strixxusmtg30 ok
You know I somehow missed that fact for years watching this? I was always so focused on the characters I hadn’t noticed until like a month ago
Fools Errand same, but i didn’t even figure it out myself, i saw bts footage of them planning a moving set for this scene and it finally hit me
Ron's face when he says " Me???. .. he's mental"
Not you, your RAT! 🐀
"High school reunion would be very fun !"
The high school reunion in question :
Harry really just went: “Don’t kill him. We need to torture him first”
His true reasoning in the books was that he didn't want his dad's best friends to become murderers.
@Ayla Alya A correction: only Ministry aurors were allowed to use the Unforgiveable Curses. That did not apply to wizardkind as a whole, including the Order of the Phoenix. We never see or hear of an Order wizard/witch killing someone during that first war. We don't even see it in the second war until Molly Weasley goes full badass on Bellatrix. The idea is that since the Order wizards/witches don't kill, they're at a fundamental disadvantage against the Death Eaters, and therefore often lose.
@@Cailus3542 He says this in the film too.
@@Cailus3542 It's also his reasoning in the movies.
I like Sirius Black a lot it would be great if he was alive for sure he died quickly.
He is great person for sure who treats Harry like his child for sure.
Fun fact. The adults in this scene are supposed to be 33 to 34 years old. How old were the actors at the time? Alan Rickman, 58. Gary Oldman, 47. David Thulis, 43. Timothy Spall, 48.
Also fun fact. The subtitles for this video suck. : \
Wrong.
True, but Snape's whole life has been a mess and he's severely depressed, so it makes sense for him to appear older than he actually is. Same with Sirius, who has been rotting in a cell for 12 years.
@@vetarlittorf1807 Same with Lupin, who has to be a little torn up (from being a werewolf) and Pettigrew who has been a mouse for 12 years
And Sirius has been in hell in Azkaban. Tbh i’m surprised he looks this good. Poor marauders era, they all get the shit kicked out of them
3:52, I love how guttural Sirius sounds in this moment. It's like thirteen years of rage at his imprisonment combined with his Animagus form just leapt out of him. Gary Oldman is one of the best casted people in this entire series.
In the book: Snape actually entered the room wearing Harry’s invisibility cloak because he left it outside the womping willow. & Snape knew to go their because Snape went to lupins office to give him his potion & he saw the map and all their names
Yeah and Snape went completely insane. In the movie, he just wants to hand Sirius over to the dementors but he like lost his mind in the book
@@ohio-onlyhappensinohioI just read this part for the first time in the books and it actually shocked me to see how unhinged and murderous Snape was. Even with overwhelming evidence that Sirius was innocent, he still said he didn't care and wanted to see Sirius dead. It's crazy how different they made this in the movie.
@@jasonsinn9237 not just wanting to see Sirius dead, but also caring little to none about Harry's health even when Ron and Hermione warn Snape of the Dementor's attraction to him.
Thank god for the film. I much prefer the Movie Snape over the Book Snape. Also Alan Rickman is so fantastic in the role
0:09 I love the way Sirius reacts when Remus is asking Hermione how she knew he was a werewolf. You can see Sirius in the background so annoyed that they're still talking instead of killing Peter lol I love it great acting.
LOLL
Nimoys acting in this is an example of what made this franchise great. R.i.p. head of Slytherin.
@@kjherms369 what
@@anitabonghit7606 Severus snape (Alan Rickman) died January 14th, 2016, RIP 🪦 the Half-Blood prince
@@gabriellopez4111 dude he said Nimoy thats why i said what i know alan Rickman died
Notice how Snape didn’t look remotely worried when Harry pulled out Hermione’s wand. He fully expected Harry to kill Sirius and was fine with it. Makes sense when you know how Snape feels.
Edit: Damn, came back to 1k comments a year later 😧
Edit 2: Damn, came back to 5k likes 2 years later 😨
He did betray me there.....
@hadia ahmad I am. But this place has wifi.
@hadia ahmad NONE of YOUR Business Mr./Ms. Ahmad
@hadia ahmad Hm...
@@severussnape8468 it has wifi? Omg its better than here
"It's said to be nearly unbearable to witness, but I'll do my best." To me, that's the best line in the whole franchise, delivered perfectly. A scene with those 3 could go on for a whole movie length and nobody would get bored.
Imagine a whodunit movie with them and a few select others like Anthony Hopkins and Christopher Lee! 😳
He really did nail that line, it was pretty badass. And considering what he thought to be true at the time without knowing Wormtail was alive, it feels even better watching it knowing his general feelings are 100% justified even if they’re directed at the wrong man. Would be satisfying to see Snape give a chilling speech like this to Wormtail.
Finally someone who appreciates the brilliance of this line
4:43 I love when we see moments like this from Harry. Sure he’s a great guy, however he’s not like a goody two shoes who constantly does the morally correct thing. He wants to give Peter to the dementors because as someone who has faced them, he knows it can be a fate worse than death. Or in the 5th movie when Bellatrix kills Sirius and he’s willing to use the cruciatus curse on her. He’s one of the best people you could ever meet, but he has a breaking point
I mean I’d say in this instance it’s an appropriate verdict. Pettigrew is one of the few characters I would say deserves the dementor’s kiss
Alan Rickman, Gary Oldman, David Thewlis, Timothy Spall. All four are among the greatest British actors of all time. The series had a phenomenal cast list
Plus the addition of Julie Christie and Emma Thompson to the main adult actors.
BTW the fact that Timothy Spall was Nathaniel in *_Enchanted_* is freaking insane.
The Brits nailed acting to the point of creating a new religion.
They’re great but nowhere near the best , there are literally thousands of amazing top tier actors
@@mattoniy2840 I wouldn’t count thousands. A few hundred maybe. We’re talking about the greats here, not great actors, but the greats. Who are the most highly regarded, well trained, famous, been in good roles and the most well known films
Harry’s biggest mistake is not killing Peter. Oh well
wormtail*
@@ii_khalid2778 is there any need
@@lucasmurray4713 To set Sirius free.
It wasn’t a mistake. Now, I’m assuming your implication is that killing Wormtail would have prevented him from reviving Voldemort in the graveyard during the Triwizard Tournament. This might be true, but it’s also very likely that another would have managed to do so if he hadn’t. Voldemort had many loyal followers, and would have simply moved on to prey on others until he found someone who would be willing to bring him back. (ex. Quirrell in Sorcerer’s Stone). The key here is, Wormtail owed Harry his life from this moment on. Without this debt, events would have mostly played out the same, except come Malfoy Manor, no one would have felt an obligation towards Harry to let him out of the basement. Sparing Wormtail’s life is an absolutely pivotal moment for the success of Harry over Voldemort.
At least he should do petrificus totalus to him before they get out of there
Severus, Sirius and Remus must have gone through some variation of that dialogue hundreds of times in the past. Severus was clearly enjoying the fact that this time he was the one with the wand and not the one being hung upside down with his trousers off and being made fun of by James Potter and his friends.
rightly
@@laliceinwonderlandl no not rightly? Yes The Maurauders we’re bullies to Snape but you forget thatSnape was a literal death eater and it’s not like Snape didn’t give it back.
And while they hung him upside down, he literally tried to murder them both here.
@@tomfox6084 Where do you get that he tried to murder them? Snape wanted them sent to Azkaban, and that was because he didn't know that Sirius was innocent.
@@wvu05 have you not read the books? He tried to get both Sirius and Remus kissed by the dementors. Also Snape 100% knew Sirius was innocent. Pettigrew was on the run specifically because the Death Eaters thought he had betrayed Voldemort, so they all knew it was him, not Sirus, who gave them the Potters’ address.
@@tomfox6084 Clearly, it has been a while since you did. Snape was knocked unconscious before Sirius and Remus had the chance to reveal the truth. The Dementor's Kiss, while some argue may be worse than death, it is not execution. Based on what Snape knew at the time, he wanted to see an escaped serial killer and the person aiding and abetting that serial killer punished to the maximum extent of the law. Far different than "wanting to murder them," as you described, and he only revealed himself after Snape justified what he did to Snape 18 years earlier.
And, while when Snape was unconscious and being taken out of the Shrieking Shack, Sirius repeatedly and intentionally hit his head against the wall, when the situation was reversed, Snape (when no one was looking) gently and safely removed Sirius.
So much intensity in this scene for everybody. Harry is in the room with the man who got his parents killed, Snape is in there with the man who got the woman he loved killed and Sirius and Remus is in there with the man that got their best friends killed who it turned out to be another one of their best friends. It's like a real stand off situation here
The acting in this scene is hands down some of the best in the entire series. Fascinating like hell to watch
For real though you don’t get great actors like these their pure gold🧡✨
Yes it is. The lines are delivered perfectly by everyone. It's a fast-paced, dialogue-heavy scene and they nailed it!
It’s probably top 5 best scenes in the whole series tbh
@@vladdracula8103 riiiight? i't almost amazes me how "overlooked" this scene is, fantastic acting, insanely relevant to the plot, also the pacing is perfect it doesn't feel dragged or pointless at any moment I wish we could have gotten Cuarón to direct the rest of the movies, Yates wasn't bad but his directing was mediocre and never even got close to Cuarón's craft
Fr I get chills every time Snape points his wand at Sirius and says "Give me a reason. I beg you." He wasn't playing lmao
Funny how fred and George had the map and probably saw Peter pettigrew with Ron and thought "yea that's fine Ron's fine with a guy we don't know"
Only marauders can see other marauders on the map.
@@johnpepper8603 but harry isn't a marauder so....
@@bluefirewolf1991 son dude, son of a marauder.
Lmfao
No, only Maruders can see each other on the map. Lupin saw him on the map, *not Harry* in the book.
The blocking in this scene is insanely good. The way they grouped them (Sirius, Lupin and Harry, then Snape, Sirius and Lupin, then they added Pettigrew in there) and moved them and moved the camera *Chefs kiss*
Just consider how much backstory and secrets are being revealed in this one scene. Great storytelling.
One detail is Lupin revealing that he, Pettigrew, Sirius, and James are the Marauders.
plot twist: Petigrew's finger cut Petigrew off so it can escape Voldemort.
Further plot twist: Petigrew's finger cut Petigrew off so it no longer has to be attached to Petigrew
If The Thing existed in Harry Potter's world
Like deadpool
Not funny
@@AAAisAAA your mom is not funny.
Fun fact=In the book, Lupin cast a spell that turns animagus into people while seizing Peter/Scabbers by the hand. He said “If he is an actual rat, this won’t hurt him”
Yee. It's so an animal suspected of being an unregistered animagi can be tested. Apparently it was a big punishment in the Potterverse to be caught being unregistered. To avoid shit like this I guess.
@@scottwpilgrim No it's because it's risky to become animagi
@@rockingamingwiththesahit2145 you register after becoming one, not before
It was actually Lupin that did that, not Sirius:)
@@mrcloud3608 Yeh I reread it today
The pain in Sirius Black’s voice when he shouted “I DID MY WAITING!! 12 YEARS OF IT!! IN AZKABAN!!” The pain of losing two of your closest friends and being framed for causing the murder and then being thrown in the most inescapable prison to rot and suffer while the real culprit got away scot free. He really wanted to avenge Lily and James. I don’t think anyone could’ve portrayed that better. Gary Oldman is extremely talented.
Alan Rickman vs. Gary Oldman
Two monsters in acting
What priviledge to work with them...
This scene is epic!!!
I couldn't imagine Snape's rage and swelling hatred after he woke up knowing his worst enemy's son knocked him out.
Yet he still shielded him and his friends from a werewolf
@@flunked Oh, Snape was bloody pissed off in the book. He went completely mental in front of Fudge which caused the latter to try and advise Dumbledore to sack him for being nuts.
@@flunked he did not react the same in the books. He was pissed off and was screaming about Harry in front of Fudge and Dumbledore about it. Making Fudge think Snape went nuts lmao
It was harry, hermione and ron attacking him in the book.
Snape: This is a new feeling. Pride in my enemy’s son. Unfortunately, it’s overshadowed by all this unyielding rage.
I feel really bad for Snape, he finally found the person who he thought was the reason that the woman he loved was murdered, just for him to come to the wrong conclusion, and on top of that was bested by a student, and on top of THAT the man who was actually the reason that the woman he loved was murdered got away, and on top of THAT, that man went on to bring back the person who killed the woman he loved and went on to eventually kill Snape himself. Snape's life sucks.
snapeis the principal instigator of lily's death, he was fine having a random baby killed. when it was decided that lily was in danger he first asked to voldy to let her live and didn't think of that as literaly lily seen her husband and child murder so he can get her broken emotional state.
@@LuffyuzumakiPotter hes a grey character that's what makes him so interesting, it was only because of his regret for being a part of lily's death and the love he felt thereafter which prompted him to do the things he did to save Harry and the by extension the wizarding world, had it not been for lily we would have had another Voldemort
he already hated sirius anyway though because sirius bullied him at school. though certainly his hatred must have doubled in believing that he betrayed lily.
@@jhibbitt2896 Lilly doesn’t apology to snape.
@Ayla Alya very well thought through!👆👍
this entire scene is just so captivating. the acting, the dialog, the way the set literally shifts with the conversation on screen, the way the frame pans around during the slow leaning and creaking... its just perfect lmao. and the lighting... a+
"Brilliant Snape. Once again you put you keen and penetrating mind to the task and, as usual, come to the wrong conclusion."
"Severus, don't be a fool." - "He can't help it, it's habit by now."
Sirius burning Snape is the best part of this scene. 😂
He didn’t burn Snape, Snape really was brilliant. The only feat Sirius has is becoming an animagus at 15, Peter was able to do it as well so it’s not really a feat. Snape was a potions master he could’ve easily done it but his focus was on superior magic, they only focused on becoming animagus due to Remus being a werewolf
@@horsekfobster7823 Ok fanboy
@@janm3781 He’s literally the only dude who passed Slughorn’s test, created Sectumsempra and the counter, and he learned how to fly just from watching Voldemort.
@@horsekfobster7823all that accomplishments are separate. Sirius doesn't care about that. He just wants to roast Snape. And his ability to get under Snape's skin is why Snape hates him so much. Nobody can beat Sirius when it comes to roasting, apart from maybe James
@@saimcheeda93 He didn’t roast Snape though, called him a fool when he’s a genius. Sirius was killed by Bellatrix and framed by Peter bruh, having 12 years of his life taken. Snape fooled Voldemort and died because he was thought to be the master of the elder wand.
*Harry attacks Snape*
James in the afterlife: “That’s my boy!”
Snape:
James was such a bitch
@@grrumakemeangry snivellous was the bully that was mad over hs beef YEARS later. he was the one who bullied his students, to the point that neville’s boggart was him. not the woman that tortured his parents to insanity but his Teacher. what james and the rest of the marauders did was purely public service because i too would bully a racist bitch.
as he should! james and lily would be proud
@Sc0ut Op ? what do i mean with what?
@Sc0ut Op snape was a horrible bully that deserved everything he got.
Shows how committed Snape was to protecting Harry. Harry attacked him in favour of listening to Black and Lupin to then, ironically, protecting Harry from Lupin as a wolf.
Being fair, he would have protected any student from a werewolf but it was a brave action nonetheless. And make no mistake, Snape was LIVID. He want absolutely nuts about Harry later in the book
But i think that professor snape did a right things, he was struggling to go to that creepy place and protecting him. That was massive effort for me. Also we should've appreciated it how generous he was
@@aimanla5602 lmao you think he followed them MERELY for Harry's protection? Lmao he had his vengeance reason for going up there. He had his guilt reasons for saving Harry, not because he cared for him.
@@sandiego2380 Oh shut up, your're just another Snater looking for drama 🙄
@@sandiego2380 Snape never had any amount of guilt towards Harry. His guilt and sorrow towards Lily never extended to Harry. It's so obvious you've never read the books.
"I did my waiting! Twelve years of it! In Azkaban!"
The reaction on Lupins face is haunting and brilliant.
Snape just having a nap on the bed in the background is such a mood.
Just realized the horrific idea that Ron had been cuddling that dude for 12 years.
II would honestly obliviate my memories if that happened.....(jk)
So Ron is gay so Harry has to sleep with both Ginny and Hermione
fuck people are gonna ship them now🤣
Ohhh not Just Ron the rat belonged to percy first
Him and Percy, Scabbers technically belong to him first before his parents got him an owl, wich Ron ironically got after "loosing" Scabbers
Imagine Snape’s restraint here. He wants to kill (As far as he knows) the man responsible for Lily’s death but just decides to turn him over instead
A dementor's "kiss" would've killed Sirius anyways
@@LeveledRogue to be honest he knows that’s a fate worse than death
Not just that, he was practically tormented by Sirius and James so the hatred really runs deep
@@TheMaineMeta exactly! He knew that very well and definitely enjoyed imagining it
yes but snape was also responsible for lilys death aswell
The cinematography, staging and acting in this scene is absolutely phenomenal, one of the most memorable moments of HP movies
It’s such a shame this is the only time Alan Rickman and Gary Oldman appear on screen together. They bounce off each other perfectly.
Snape when Harry knocked him out:
Well, I wonder where he learned that spell from, OH WAIT ME 😂😂😂
Who are you?
exshhh...pelliarmus 😩
@G E T R E K T good teacher???are u kidding me??
Lupin: Sirius be quiet!
Sirius: Go quiet it yourself Remus!!!
Lupin steps back😂😂😂
Sirius probably vice captain in Maraunders after James XD
I swear this cracks me up every single time😂
Sirius: Why don't you run along and play with your chemistry set.
snape: "look at you two, quarreling like an old married couple"
He knows the drill lmao
Is it just me or it is strangely satisfying when professor snape says expelliarmus
I love the blocking of the shots in this scene: the positioning of the actors scattered about the whole premise with spaces in between them due to distrust, the flow of dialogue where everyone is talking to each other adding a sense of urgency, the entrance (Snape) AND an exit (an attempt by Wormtail) making the whole sequence feel like a play on-stage. To top it off the creaking transitioning to gradual screeching of Wormtail's reveal is brilliant.
2:19 Hermione-You attacked a teacher
Also Hermione 2 years back sets Snape's robes on fire
Edit: Thanks for so many likes
Harry: Killed one a couple o' years ago keep up.
@Drake Barnes on both occasions as well he was jus trying to do the right thing
@@joannejones8629 to be fair Harry was defending himself that time, and he couldn't fight without burning Quirrell in the process
Snape must have a lot of patience to put up with that.
@Bryan Anbarasu Wow, I actually liked your original comment. I'm taking that back, this shows your just an insecure baby.
3:47 is my favorite part cause it shows how disgusted Sirius is that the man who betrayed James is even attempting to talk to James’s son
HOW DARE U SPEAK TO HARRY? HOW DARE YOU TALK ABOUT JAMES IN FRONT OF HIM?
Yep
Sirius and Harry relationship is beautiful, spans two generations
In the book, Snape uncharacteristically goes completely apeshit here, in a way that doesn't entirely make sense until you've read the last book.
"Brilliant Snape, once again you've put your keen and penetrating mind to the task and as usual come to the wrong conclusion." 1:18 Always gets me.
This scene is truly special.
SAMEE
3:58 honestly this scene to me explains why Peter's and Sirius's animagi forms make sense. Peter is a rat; he's meek and ultimately a coward, as demonstrated when he betrays James and Lily. Sirius is a dog; he's loyal and faithful and willing to die to protect his friends.
And james was a deer coz he loved getting shot
lol dogs only care about protecting their food and shelter source.
@@CGJUGO80 says someone who never owned a dog
Isn't Sirius a werewolf, and wolves are loyal to their pack?
@@invictuz4803 Sirius is a dog, Lupin is the werewolf
Sirius: *I* *WOULD* *HAVE* *DIED!!!*
*I* *WOULD* *HAVE* *DIED* *RATHER* *THAN* *BETRAY* *MY* *FRIENDS!!!*
Powerful line
And can i be honest with you?
Peter Pettigrew is one of the characters i hate the most, his animagus form it's actually his REAL form because he's such a rat. And in the end his betray became his doom
Edit: Sorry if my english is not perfect
Damn right! Sirius would have died a billion times over and never turn to Voldemort, no true family would turn their back to save themselves! 💖
The English was good, don't worry about it. This is one of the best books and one of the best films in the series, it's got more intrigue and the characters are more interesting.
The actor played Peter Pettigrew so well . It made me so hate him haha
English good 👍
Their animagus forms are pretty good representations of their characters. Sirius is a dog, dogs are tough, good friends and specifically for Sirius, very loyal. Wormtail is self explanatory. Stags have a lot of representations but they are both powerful yet gentle which James certainly displayed in the limited scenes with him or about him. Hell aren’t all the animagus’ in the series essentially symbolized perfectly in the animal form they take?
“Brilliant, Snape! Once again you put your keen and penetrating mind to the task and as usual, come to the wrong conclusion!”
One of the COLDEST lines ever put to film. 🤣🤣 Expertly delivered by Gary Oldman 👌🏾
Complimented and insulted him at the same time
Mind reading ability is useless if the mind reader cannot tell facts (an objective truth proven with evidence) from perceived truth (something someone believes as real)
Bro I lost my shit when I first heard that nuclear assault.
0:55 The directing is amazing. Just as Sirus Black is calling out Peter Pettigrew, Snape enters the frame. This takes the audience's attention away from where Sirus is looking to avoid giving away the idea that he is looking at the rat.
actually the line come out come out is a cue for calling out snape
1:00 Snape sneaking up on them still gets me to this day, love that detail so much
You know his emergence in this scene was so terrifying right ?? I thought that was a ghost who went through the upstairs with the black robes 🥺😰😰
Snape has style 😎
I like how after Snape disarms Sirius, Pettigrew (as a rat) squeals, as if to say “Oh shit, the quiet kid got a wand”
The way Sev moved soundlessly, like a mouse or a ghost, just beautiful. Say what you want about him, but you can't deny he's got style when making an entrance entirely unnoticed.
And the sound effect of the spell
I really love that once Lupin realized Sirius was framed he didn’t really have any hesitation about killing Wormtail. Wish they would’ve done more flashbacks showing the marauders
I mean he thought the person who did it was suffering but in reality the real villain was living it up as a house pet. I’d be down to murder his ass too
Except one of the only ones also showed them bullying Severus Snape, and Snape can't simply forget or forgive something like that because it reminds him of his own dysfunctional parents.
I wished they had said they were the Marauders. After this film, Pettigrew is called Worm tail, and audience members who didn't read the books were mostly likely very confused.
4:24
The MercIIIIAGGGHHH button
1:02 I love Snapes
"Expelliaar-muuss"
"Brilliant, Snape. Once again you've put your keen and penetrating mind to the task and as usual come to the wrong conclusion."
priceless lmao
I love how this is the first time Sirius sees Snape in almost 20 years and the first thing he does is insult Snape like before
He is such a bully to Severus still after the fact he wanted to kill Severus Snape in the tunnel when Remus was in wolf form!
@@priestessmikokikyo77 Well, Snape isn't much of a saint himself, bullying Harry for being the son of his bully, evn though it's thanks to him James got murdered.
PS: not that this makes up for Sirius' or James' behaviour back in school
@@anjum3847 All this proves is that “Bullying.” is a vicious cycle.
@@kenudice9841 uh oh
I don't quite think so, there can instances where victims turn bullies at later points in their lives, but this specific case has more to do with Snape's generel bitter persona and his incapability to let go grudges.
"It's said to be nearly unbearable to witness but I'LL DO MY BEST" 😂That line and the delivery is underrated I think
Literally been looking for comments on just how good this line is and found embarrassingly low support for it
Especially the "I'll do my best" part
He really wanted to watch Sirius suffer for what he believed he'd done to Lily
@@gerstein03 That and for all the torment Sirius and James did to him as a kid.
@@robertolmstead1346 well yeah that was part of it too but mostly he really wanted him to suffer for what happened to Lily. In OotP Snape is much more subdued towards Sirius because he now knows Sirius didn't get Lily killed
Knowing now that Sirius bullied snape this makes a whole lot more sense
Gary Oldman, David Thewlis and Alan Rickman together is just a masterpiece in acting. It’s a short little sequence but it flows so well
"How dare you speak to Harry?!" Love how protective Sirius already is and he barely met Harry.
Also I love comparing this Sirius to the Sirius in order of the Phoenix. He seems so calm and collected in Phoenix compared to this one. Sometimes I forget they're the same character. Gary Oldman is one phenomenal actor.
he was still fresh out of azkaban and unhinged by the place. by the time of the 5th film he'd been out long enough to have calmed down although he did hate being trapped in his childhood home with the family he'd hated
Sirius, Remus and Peter had all met Harry before: when Harry was a baby. I'll bet they were all happy then, celebrating the first Marauder child, as close as family. Then Peter fell into darkness, Sirius was sentenced to a living hell, James was viciously murdered and Remus lost his three closest friends in one fell swoop
Oldman also played James Gordon in the Dark Knight trilogy.
@@aguyonastreet And Zorg in Fifth Element.
@@Renville80 And Lord shen in KFP2
That has got to be the most melo, weak, yet severe burn one can deliver to a alchemy nerd
"Why don't you run along and play with your Chemistry Set!"
What makes it better is that he's probably said that same line to Snape when they were students.
Snape: Hold my Bezoar...
Made worse by the fact that Snape resents the fact that he’s been forced to teach potions when he’s always wanted to teach DADA
i DID MY WAITING!!!! TWELVE YEARS OF IT!!! IN AZKABAN!!
my god. beautiful acting. you can hear the strain in his voice, how insane could you imagine you would go, 12 years in what is basically hell, knowing you were innocent, your old friends dead, the rest disappeared? gave me chills then, does now. wow.
The music and the atmosphere is so mysterious in this scene and I love it. Still don't understand why poa wasn't as successful as the other movies
0:22 I've always been so focused on Gary Oldman's incredible acting in this scene that it's the first time I realize Remus's shocked/empathetic look at Sirius. Initially he seems to treat him as the old Sirius (witty, impatient) but that's the first moment he truly grasps how traumatized from Azkaban Sirius is.
Sdsdsd sdsdds erw z sd
Yes, i believe him when i saw this movie. I was Seven and i realize that Ron's rat was a villain and i was shocked. My family had right because they read the books. I was a baby when Harry Potter First book came and three years later, my grandfather bought the First Four books in french for my Sisters. Now i feel like Sirius that he had been for twelve years in Azkaban to gets Revenge against Peter that he betrayed him because when i was 19, After i watched Angry Birds and Fantastic Beasts when i was waiting for star Wars Rebels season three in my country, my father find accidentally a horrible TV Series names This Is Us and it's look alike funny and volgar at the beginning but it's sad and i was trapped in the grim like in the prison for Seven years but the important thing Is that Ezra Bridger and Ahsoka Tano must sense Anakin Skywalker kills Palpatine if they will made Rebels season five set during the original Trilogy of star wars in Disney Plus as i saw Ahsoka that She sense Anakin fell into the Dark side of the force in clone Wars season Seven set during the movie Revenge of the sith that i was waiting when clone Wars was interrupted in 2013 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
@@beatricesanfilippo6925 bro what-
All it could of taken was a shout saying "The rat is peter petter pettigrew"
Sirius so dramatic lmao
Yeah like why the hell was he so angry with Snape? Like dude as far as anyone knows you're a wanted criminal and calling the person, one of the people who would probably give you a chance, who caught you dumb should really be at the bottom of your list right now.
@@junesmind7325 it’s actually the other way around, snape despised Sirius because he, lupin, and James potter bullied him to the point of depression when they were students at hogworts. And snape at this point still believes it was him who betrayed lily and James, though of course he would find out the truth later on
@@junesmind7325 Sirius had no reason to ever believe that Snape would even listen to what he had to say to begin with, and considering the situation Snape would likewise be less inclined to believe anything Remus might say as well, since Snape believed Remus to be Sirius' accomplice at this point. Snape & Sirius *hate* each other, so Snape would logically be more inclined to think that anything Sirius might have said was a lie meant to just save his own skin. Remember, Snape was jealous of James being the one who married Lily, when Snape also harbored feelings for Lily, and that jealousy led to him ending up on less than stellar terms with not just James, but the rest of James' circle of friends.
Had Snape actually known the truth, however, he likely would have sided with Sirius and Remus as much as he hated to do so, since the love he felt for Lily would have left him obligated to go after Pettigrew for his hand in Lily's death.
@@alceusrydan6237 well he was in azkhaban for 12 years
*Snape:* Give me a reason. I beg you.
*Lupin:* Severus don't be a fool.
*Black:* He can't help it it's habit by now.
*Lupin:* Sirius be quiet-
*Black:* OH BE QUIET YOURSELF!
*Snape:* Apparently it isn't you two quarrelling like an old married couple.
*wHy dOn'T yOu rUn aLonG aNd pLaY wiTh yOuR cHemiStrY sEt?*
@@wafflecult27 😭
The way this scene is shot always made me belive black was gonna kill harry and lupin was helping him to do it even snape thought that too
Bro this scene is a masterpiece. The whole movie just gives me goosebumps. The acting is perfect.
The dialog between snape, lupin and black is probably the best part of the movie
It’s amazing how different this scene plays after you’ve seen the whole series.
Damn, Alan Rickman, Gary Oldman and David Thewlis in one room together ... Truly a clash of legends.
2:16 It looks like Emma was about to say her lines but forgot Rupert wasn't done with his yet.
Yeah, but it could also be that Hermione was shocked and speechless when she found out Harry attacked a teacher. But if it was as you say, it was a perfect mistake because it could look like Hermione was speechless and shocked with that expression by Harry attacking a teacher.
Or maybe Emma was mouthing ruperts line. She was notorious back then for doing so😂
@@nathanielsantoso2173 😂
@@nathanielsantoso2173 Will Smith would do the same thing in Fresh Prince. 😁
I love how Daniel Radcliffe on set really enjoyed filming this scene because he thought it was the first “proper acting” scene he’d been a part of
This scene is legendary, but why did Lupin have to say his line at 0:07 like such a villain? 😂
Lol i thought exactly the same
They needed a lot of drama
Because he was supposed to? Audiences were supossed to believe Sirius was looking to kill Harry and that Lupin was helping him
I love how much history is behind this scene and they do a great job conveying that.
Ron’s head is just going “I’ve changed in front of that guy.”
Ron: (I've done things in front of that guy) Kill him Harry!
Peter: Don't you start you little wanker!
Ron: He's mental!
Peter: Why even have a rat when you like stroking 🐓 more!
3:59 I think Ron is having a stroke in the background after realizing the pet he owned for so long was in fact a filthy middle-aged freak 😂😂
Who could blame him?
Everything about this scene is perfect. The humor, acting, etc. It's all amazing.
My favorite thing about these films is that EVERYONE I pictured for certain cast members in the books were actually cast in reality and every last one of them was PERFECT!!!
"The map never lies"...
The most iconic line..
Sirius: I'M COMPLETELY INNOCENT OF THE CRIME I WAS CONVICTED FOR, BUT I'M GONNA MAKE MYSELF LOOK AND SOUND LIKE I'M GUILTY AND INSANE!!!
Exactly y did he act like a lunatic
@@ob982 to be fair, he was actually unhinged. Spending 12 years in isolated confinement while surrounded by dementors would turn anyone into a lunatic lol
Also the reason he escaped was partially due to him staying in his dog form to lower the impact dementors have on him. Might have some effect too.He is innocent, but he's not sane at all here.
12 years of torture
And then play the cool collected calm god father for the next two years.
This film really gave so much more character to Snape than just "scary mean teacher".
The tension with the Shriecking Shack moving left and right and the dialouge being so good merged in these 5 mins of footage, shows why the 3rd one is the best.