Honestly, it took a long time and much listening to Rachmaninoff's Op. 39 for me to appreciate this incredible work. I listened to several different interpretations of it, but I found Lugansky's to be the best , not only to understand Op. 39, but to enjoy it and to love it. P.S. My condolences for the great loss of Alexander Vedernikov. He is and will continue to be missed by music lovers around the world.
This comment is 24-Karat gold. It took me nearly 3 months for me to understand Rachmaninoff's works; especially Op. 39 No. 1 and Op. 39 No. 6, in contrast to some of his other pieces such as Op. 39 No.8 and Op. 33 No. 6, which are much more "musically adept," if you could call them so.
What a pianist, Lugansky! The tradition of the great Russian pianists continues, after Richter died and Ashkenazy stopped playing, the gap was succesfully filled with the great Nikolai Lugansky and this interpretation is the proof of it!
His total mastery of the piano is nothing short of genius, particularly in his deep understanding of Rachmaninoff's music. The pure perfection of his execution and the eloquent finesse of his unsurpassed interpretations place him beyond comparison. A unique and irreplaceable musician devoted to serving our perception of musical beauty with his unparalleled artistry. We thank God for Mozart and other great masters - Nikolai Lugansky in his medium is in the same category.
Николаю Луганскому дана высочайшая оценка в предыдущих комментариях. Что можно добавить?.. Это мой любимый Пианист.. Он уникален. Он одарен Богом. Люблю и преклоняюсь. Рахманинов ~любимый композитор Николая Луганского (из его интервью).
I can't think of another pianist who can play Rachmaninov with the same depth, lyricism and artistry as Lugansky. It's really unbelievable. Maybe Richter sometimes but I'm not sure.
But I have yet to hear any other pianist play Rachmaninoff's Polichinelle, Op.3, ,#4 in f# minor or his Humoresque, Op.10, #5 in G major with the kind of humor Rachmaninoff had in mind for both pieces.
Lugansky and Volodos are two of the very few people who are still playing op.39 no.8 in public. Apparently, pianists don't like to play this etude, maybe because of the doubles in the right hand combined with the key the piece is written in. The etude is kind of risky to perform without sufficient preparation. You can't just trust you memory for this piece, it seems. Richter never played the etude in public (at least as far as I have been able to check), Horowitz didn't play the etude either as far as I know, and even Ashkenazy stopped playing op.39 no.8 in public, while still playing many of the other etudes op.39. It's such a beautiful etude, so it's sad that it is being neglected by most pianists today. Fortunately, we have Volodos and Lugansky to keep the piece alive in the concert hall.
But this étude is not as poorly scored as Dvořak's piano concerto which experts say can only be adequately played on one piano by 2 left hands! Did Dvořak develop his melodies first in tbe bass? This all seems bizarre. But this so called concerto of Dvorak is a total failure, unplayable as written and no special joy to the listener. Richarc Sot in Facebook & Messenger
@@ripvanwinkle9592 I never even suggested that this etude would be "poorly scored". Actually, the piece is brilliantly written. It's just that too many pianists of today lack the technique (and perhaps the motivation) to play (melodic) doubles comfortably in that particular key.
@@j.vonhogen9650 too many pianists lack the accessibility to the "ineffable" that the piece requires. To play it, technique does not suffice. Rather, to go into that "ether" from which that music comes.
OP.33 D minor etude tempo is great. Not being rushed through. left hand registry dialogue very clear with clear cascade of varying touch vs other accompanying notes. very enjoyable. Op.39 no.8 soul captivating, not being rushed through, such harmonic nuances, hope & uncertainty ... think of Rachmaninov on the ship to New York, what'd be in his mind?
Not an easy program, and he plays them so well! There is a magnificent documentary on this great composer .. "Harvest of Sorrow." Treat yourself to getting to know Rachmaninoff a little better. And it is free!
I have a couple of technical questions: what are the two rectangular black boxes under the piano? Also what is that mic? (looks stereo). Thanks. These are my favourite piano works of all time and Lugansky is of course a bit good . . .
Don't know about the rest but Lugansky made some mistakes here and there when he played op. 39 no. 4. Probably not enough practice, but he's interpretation is truly amazing. Respect.
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Honestly, it took a long time and much listening to Rachmaninoff's Op. 39 for me to appreciate this incredible work. I listened to several different interpretations of it, but I found Lugansky's to be the best , not only to understand Op. 39, but to enjoy it and to love it.
P.S. My condolences for the great loss of Alexander Vedernikov. He is and will continue to be missed by music lovers around the world.
This comment is 24-Karat gold. It took me nearly 3 months for me to understand Rachmaninoff's works; especially Op. 39 No. 1 and Op. 39 No. 6, in contrast to some of his other pieces such as Op. 39 No.8 and Op. 33 No. 6, which are much more "musically adept," if you could call them so.
@@nishyanthkumar op.39 no.8 is the opposite of musically adept
Try gryaznov if you haven't, not saying it's better but worth a listen imo.
What a pianist, Lugansky! The tradition of the great Russian pianists continues, after Richter died and Ashkenazy stopped playing, the gap was succesfully filled with the great Nikolai Lugansky and this interpretation is the proof of it!
Mazzel Tov agreed, Boris Berezovsky is amazing
I completely agree. He's one of my favourite pianist on the Rach etudes
So natural, a sign of living with these pieces in your fingers for decades
Lugansky makes everything sound like that though.
His total mastery of the piano is nothing short of genius, particularly in his deep understanding of Rachmaninoff's music. The pure perfection of his execution and the eloquent finesse of his unsurpassed interpretations place him beyond comparison. A unique and irreplaceable musician devoted to serving our perception of musical beauty with his unparalleled artistry. We thank God for Mozart and other great masters - Nikolai Lugansky in his medium is in the same category.
Абсолютно согласна с вами!
HYPERBOLE!!
Finally the owner of these études comes back to them!
totally agree with you he is the owner
Just discovered him ... Yes! 100% ..agree
Truly one of the greatest pianists of all time. There is a feeling of total awareness, as he interprets Rachmaninoff's masterpieces.
for me the best pianist!Love to visit his live concerts nowhere they are-in Moscow,Baltimore,Washington
Николаю Луганскому дана высочайшая оценка в предыдущих комментариях. Что можно добавить?.. Это мой любимый Пианист.. Он уникален. Он одарен Богом. Люблю и преклоняюсь. Рахманинов ~любимый композитор Николая Луганского (из его интервью).
Nobody can touch him. The most gifted pianist the world will probably ever see - or hear.
Malofeev is rising. He's the new Lugansky.
Lisitsa can, even better
Sokolov
for Rachmaninov yes
I think Lugansky, Volodos and Gryaznov are all incredible pianists for this kind of music.
I can't think of another pianist who can play Rachmaninov with the same depth, lyricism and artistry as Lugansky. It's really unbelievable. Maybe Richter sometimes but I'm not sure.
Horowitz, please...
But I have yet to hear any other pianist play Rachmaninoff's Polichinelle, Op.3, ,#4 in f# minor or his Humoresque, Op.10, #5 in G major with the kind of humor Rachmaninoff had in mind for both pieces.
I totally agree with you. I love so much his performances. And he is comparable to nobody else for me at this.
hmm not even rachmaninoff himself? :P (he has some recordings too)
Boris Giltburg played quiet well too but overall Lugansky is the real deal.
Best classical channel. Thank you for upload of Genial Lugansky
Lugansky and Volodos are two of the very few people who are still playing op.39 no.8 in public. Apparently, pianists don't like to play this etude, maybe because of the doubles in the right hand combined with the key the piece is written in. The etude is kind of risky to perform without sufficient preparation. You can't just trust you memory for this piece, it seems.
Richter never played the etude in public (at least as far as I have been able to check), Horowitz didn't play the etude either as far as I know, and even Ashkenazy stopped playing op.39 no.8 in public, while still playing many of the other etudes op.39.
It's such a beautiful etude, so it's sad that it is being neglected by most pianists today. Fortunately, we have Volodos and Lugansky to keep the piece alive in the concert hall.
But this étude is not as poorly scored as Dvořak's piano concerto which experts say can only be adequately played on one piano by 2 left hands!
Did Dvořak develop his melodies first in tbe bass? This all seems bizarre. But this so called concerto of Dvorak is a total failure, unplayable as written and no special joy to the listener. Richarc Sot in Facebook & Messenger
@@ripvanwinkle9592 I never even suggested that this etude would be "poorly scored". Actually, the piece is brilliantly written. It's just that too many pianists of today lack the technique (and perhaps the motivation) to play (melodic) doubles comfortably in that particular key.
You need to listen to Szymon Nehring's version
@@admortor- I will. Thanks for the tip!
@@j.vonhogen9650 too many pianists lack the accessibility to the "ineffable" that the piece requires. To play it, technique does not suffice. Rather, to go into that "ether" from which that music comes.
no 8 just hits me right in the nostalgia vein
Bravo Lugansky You are Rachmaninoff reborn its like hearing him I have his recordings you really understand him you are his successor😍
OP.33 D minor etude tempo is great. Not being rushed through. left hand registry dialogue very clear with clear cascade of varying touch vs other accompanying notes. very enjoyable. Op.39 no.8 soul captivating, not being rushed through, such harmonic nuances, hope & uncertainty ... think of Rachmaninov on the ship to New York, what'd be in his mind?
Excellent work and a outstanding technique! Well Done
I love this channel, quality content, the timings and descriptions of the videos are perfect, just good choices! Thank you!!
I will learn to play this immeately. So beautiful. !!
Lugansky è uno dei più bravi pianisti in attività.
Not an easy program, and he plays them so well! There is a magnificent documentary on this great composer .. "Harvest of Sorrow." Treat yourself to getting to know Rachmaninoff a little better. And it is free!
Link is
ruclips.net/video/YUU8gpZWvnA/видео.html
Thank you, damn, so this was literally 3 evenings ago???? 😭 I’m working on a few of these right now, but muchhhhhhhhhhhh slower 😆
Op. 33, no. 4, op. 39, no. 3, op. 39, no. 4 are my most favorite. Currently learning one.
what an interpetation thank you Maestro Lugansky
Браво , Маэстро ! Спасибо !
Алма - Ата Казахстан.
Unisce la forza alla leggerezza, come potrebbe fare un angelo. Non si nota virtuosismo. Mi ha folgorato e riconciliato con Rachmaninov.
Браво! 🎉
Счастлив человек, владеющий этим языком, этой магией!
Nobody plays Rachmaninov like Lugansky.
This is great!! Thank you!!!
Thank you.
Unbelievable playing.....
So many empty seats. What a shame.
Lugansky is great.
Fabulous!
Прекрасно!🌹
I heard some Rach Suite no.2 Intro in Op 39 no. 9 21:38
Interesting observation. Maybe the is that some church bells motive is used there. You also can hear it in Suite No. 2, IV. Pâques
He plays very precise.
MARAVILLOSO!!!!
❤❤
Красная шапочка - такая концовка, мороз по коже
Sei un artista da imitare
Подражать Луганскому невозможно. У него дар от Бога. Когда он был ребёнком, он не читал детских книг, ОН ЧИТАЛ НОТЫ!!!
❤❤❤❤❤❤
💯💯💯✨👌👏👏👏
I have a couple of technical questions: what are the two rectangular black boxes under the piano? Also what is that mic? (looks stereo). Thanks. These are my favourite piano works of all time and Lugansky is of course a bit good . . .
😍😘♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
15:44 that felt a bit slow, and then 15:52 doesn't sound right either ?
Oh my god the masks, Beethoven is cracking up
Rach 2
Why are there a load of pirates in the audience?
Don't know about the rest but Lugansky made some mistakes here and there when he played op. 39 no. 4. Probably not enough practice, but he's interpretation is truly amazing. Respect.
Little mistakes can happen no matter how much practice there has been.
It only shows that he's a human like the rest of us.
So how are you getting on with your Clementi sonatinas? 😁
Bien sûr il est remarquable mais pour les Etudes-Tableaux, j'ai une préférence marquée pour son compatriote Ashkenazy.
I admire Lugansky's Rachmaninoff, but has everyone forgotten Van Cliburn?
В этюде Es-moll у Николая какая-то беда с педалью в первой части, грязновато...
Rachmaninov is god. My dog is named Sergei in his honor. Lugansky stellar as usual.
Потрясающе! Вы бесподобны! Привет!
Helen, Luganski is brilliant but try Ruth Laredo"s complete Rachmaninoff. Incredibly powerful lady!