@@lxnariiia once is happenstance, twice is a coincidence, but three times is a pattern. i'd say that between the beat, similarities in rhythmic scheme (word matching), and general sentiment behind the two songs, it's delusional to say that they aren't similar and that gidle hasn't taken inspiration from fergie. BUT like i mentioned in my previous comment, it's not a bad thing. some kpop stans are too quick to be on the defense for pointing out similarities in songs, but it's never an innately bad thing. in this case, it makes the song catchy because of elements of familiarity!
Every time gilde make a comeback , people will tape it beside other songs and say that they are “similar” , or even “copying” lol 😂 Soyeon must be used to this.
@@imtatiana”used to” lol . She did ONE song similar and she apologized for making it similar , and it’s a common thing to produce a song that sounds like another. U guys are just hating on whatever she did
@@imtatiana oh baby, if you don't know anything about it don't talk, he only apologized for the similarity, not for copying himself. If she had really copied a song she would not have been made an honorary member of KOMCA (Korea Music Copyright Association). That song that you defend so much is made with samples from another song, don't be hypocritical
@@imtatianabecause not like other kpop groups... The entertainment make their songs but in their entertainment you know how they are!!! So only she had to make the songs😢
the first comparison honestly just sounds like people are hearing the "cocoloco" and "makes the boys go loco" and running with it, i'm not hearing it outside of some beat hits.
As a music producer I can tell that when an old song is a hit, sometimes you want to sample what had already worked to prevent losing money in a risky new sample. Also there are a lot of sample packs already on sale which producers buy and tweak a little but in Essence maybe the same sample actually. Nowadays most music is sampled to not risk investment, they try already proven formalas. Greetings ☀️
yea… people last remember her from her jazzy interpretation of pledge of allegiance so she was basically bullied into exile 😭😭😭 but she’s still such a powerhouse singer and performer. who else can sing an entire riff while doing cartwheels on Good Morning America?
Idk about BGB specifically but Fergalicious for sure samples Supersonic by JJ Fad, pretty sure the black eyed peas tried to straight up rip them off back when the song came out til they got sued and had to give credit 😭
@@leirvohs what are you on? JJ Fad were credited *from the start* on Fergalicious, there was no lawsuit or anything, and they gave Fergie permission to use the song. And it was a Fergie song, not a BEP song btw. And to answer to OP, no, Fergie didn't sample Sir Mix-A-Lot. ^^
@@JordiVanderwaal As I’m rereading, looks like it was the company refusing to pay royalties, but there was definitely a lawsuit involved. Looks like we’re both partially wrong, so I guess we both on some psychs rn
Apparently, that's been a thing for a while, making songs that sound vaguely familiar. It pulls out your nostalgia and makes you like a song even if it's only mediocre. I wouldn't be surprised if the track was made this way on purpose.
@@Furrina89 eh, some of the best songs are heavily inspired by other songs. Some of my favorites have samples in them. I don't need everything to be totally original but please, let it be good.
OMG!!! I didn’t see this until now! The “coco loco” line HAS to be an interpolation from Fergielicious. Especially when “[make these boys] GO LOCO” has the same pronunciation as “coco loco” 😆
Interpolation is the wrong term here. I would say the line is referencing or inspired by that same line. I have been saying it since WIFE was released. People kept saying it was bad and I was like no??? It sounds like Fergie which I love
You can take inspiration from anything. Every single thing that exists physically or it is a temporary phenomenon should have credits then. Even the words of another person can also be an inspiration for someone. All Taylor Swift songs should also have credits from the people who inspired her. Inspiration is such a big concept that it becomes stupid at some point. @@Sooyadream_
Sample is not created by artist or music producer. This is inspiration. Sample is a sound or piece of music that create by sampling. Usually from piano, violin or guitar. But if someone use the same piece of beat with almost same lyrics, it's not sample. More like inspiration.
@@sylvesterpiehkorgay9240uhh sample needs credit. And also they need to pay for the license to use the music. Y'all blind fans out here spreading misinformation to justify your bias huh
It's only colloquially called a "beat". Musical terms are different. Some people say the melody is the "beat" too. It depends if you're talking about the notes or the rhythm. A lot of people call them "hip hop beats" when they're referring to the tune itself
it's no wonder that i simply LOVED this song when I heard it for the first time, and I always had this exact thought that a Fergalicious sample was used, the beat is really good (fun fact: i was a fanboy of Fergie and the Black Eyed Peas 😭💅)
Now , G-Idle's fans are protecting them .. but when pink venom and shut down was released.. all the other fandoms were like "yeahhh , BLACKPINK copieddd" ..
probably they inspired in that? (the instrumental anf the vibes of the song), i mean the producer, like the most of the songs, obviously most of them are more noticeable and another unnoticeable, but yeah sounds familiar btw
no when their being less similar they must have not payed the original😂 sometimes you had permission but lied of paying them lol its a little brainless and jail but i guess foreigners need to respect all country becouse they dont know what will treat them when the royals wants to jail racism
gidle always take inspiration from other songs also because soyeon writes them just look at the mv of their song lion where there are many similarities to other songs like snche queencard and nxde
Music is a culture and we are all products of our culture. Producers listen to pop music from the past and it becomes part of the vocabulary. Unless you intentionally go out of your way to invent a new musical language like Webern and Schoenberg, popular music are gonna sound alike. It needs a common "language" to be popular.
Well, Soyeon is someone who apologized for her plagiarism case with "I haven't heard the song but here's my apology". Let me guess, she heard Fergalicious from years ago and the melody suddenly popped on her mind and she didn't realize it.
I never thought Neverlands are so dumb and deaf. Your biases just copied another song - admit it. No need to argue that it's just a beat, it's just a lyric blah blah blah. Accept the reality.
If it was BLACKPINK, people was like: "YG need new producer." "There's no originality in their music." "It's Teddy. 3R. Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. What do you expect.". Drama....
Anyone who is getting ready to hate them please stop bcoz they work hard for each songs and( n ik it's kinda similar) An idol dosen't mean your doll to F- with
inspiration isn’t considered copying. one line having similar beats =/= copying a whole song. if the whole song had the same exact rhythm and chord progression, then yes it would be copying. but since it does not, it is inspiration. throwing around the word “copying” and “plagiarism” is exactly how words like this gets watered down and no one takes it seriously when it does happen. inspiration happens all the time in music.
Thank God it's a (G)i-dle song. If blackpink did the same thing they will get tonnes of hate . It's true that hating blackpink is a trend in k-pop By the way (G)i-dle really disappointed me by there song wife song. I hate it.
The irony of complaining that your favourite idols get unnecessary hate whilst also trying to tear down a completely different group... do you think it's idle's fault that BP get hate? Also, you really disappointed me with this comment. I hate it.
It’s just a fun fact that we found why it sounded familiar, we know it happens all the time with music and it’s completely fine, absolutely nobody is criticising it lol
i dnt hear it. how about not accusing them of something before u do the research to make sure. they dnt have permission to use the sound. Just starting conflicts just for views. Shame do better blocked from now on.
![[Limbus Company - PV] Chapter.7 - Oblivion](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VUpkXPkvoxU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] Soyeon Teacher Gets Extremely Angry😡 at the Chaotic Stage 🔥 #GIDLE #SOYEON](/img/1.gif)
It's the beat but - that's it
ending on "loco" was also similar! but not a bad thing
@@lxnariiia they used it nearly in the same way tho
@@lxnariiia once is happenstance, twice is a coincidence, but three times is a pattern. i'd say that between the beat, similarities in rhythmic scheme (word matching), and general sentiment behind the two songs, it's delusional to say that they aren't similar and that gidle hasn't taken inspiration from fergie. BUT like i mentioned in my previous comment, it's not a bad thing. some kpop stans are too quick to be on the defense for pointing out similarities in songs, but it's never an innately bad thing. in this case, it makes the song catchy because of elements of familiarity!
@@lxnariiia i don't think everyone in south korea uses "loco" lol
@@idk_why_cant_i_just_be_idkwell you prob don’t even know if u haven’t went there tbh .
Is that we can applaud Fergie for releasing some iconic sounds, whether on her own or with Black Eyes Peas, the iconic band.
She had like 3 number 1’s and two top 5 off of her debut album… a hit maker like no other
@@jardon3004No one cares
She sampled music for this as well. She aint that original 😂😂😂
@@urhypeboy Who hurt you
@@mochimonster3880 Fr.
Every time gilde make a comeback , people will tape it beside other songs and say that they are “similar” , or even “copying” lol 😂 Soyeon must be used to this.
Yes, because she is used to copying other people's work, she apologized for a reason when she was discovered, right?
@@imtatiana”used to” lol . She did ONE song similar and she apologized for making it similar , and it’s a common thing to produce a song that sounds like another. U guys are just hating on whatever she did
@@imtatiana oh baby, if you don't know anything about it don't talk, he only apologized for the similarity, not for copying himself. If she had really copied a song she would not have been made an honorary member of KOMCA (Korea Music Copyright Association). That song that you defend so much is made with samples from another song, don't be hypocritical
@@imtatianabecause not like other kpop groups... The entertainment make their songs but in their entertainment you know how they are!!! So only she had to make the songs😢
It sounds like Soyeon drew inspiration from Fergalicious and used it to create her own sound. No wonder I loved Wife so much
Or she just made the beat her own
@@aliminasirz no
@@aliminasirzthat's why she said "drew inspiration"
you explained really well what i was thinking
@@tsuyuasui7297 or didnt take any inspiration
Kpop stans need to remember that a lot of idol producers sample music!!
Every normal K-pop stans does..
I mean most producers sample from other songs not just idol producers. We see the same kind of stuff in western pop music as well.
@@NicoleCinnaroll i know that but specifically this video is about kpop… so i’m of course going to explicitly mention idol producers
@@HiHi-uz2fe not all. cause i still see those comments about groups "copying" music even if they're just sampling it
@yun_nd yes! but I'm specifically mention idol producers because this is about Kpop songs not western songs
No wonder I loved it the second I heard it this song was my SHIT back in the day!
But.... If it was BP, it would be different reaction. Don't you agree?😅
@@ygfamily47 no reason to bring up bp...!
@@ygfamily47 If taylor swift did this song, would it fit her 🤦♀️
@@ygfamily47I agree!
@@ygfamily47why did u bring bp up bro
the first comparison honestly just sounds like people are hearing the "cocoloco" and "makes the boys go loco" and running with it, i'm not hearing it outside of some beat hits.
The whole verse was pretty much beat hits 😅 with rap on top, so it's 2/2 similarity
It literally has the same beat & tune
Except for the lyrics, everything else is the same
same lol
As a music producer I can tell that when an old song is a hit, sometimes you want to sample what had already worked to prevent losing money in a risky new sample.
Also there are a lot of sample packs already on sale which producers buy and tweak a little but in Essence maybe the same sample actually.
Nowadays most music is sampled to not risk investment, they try already proven formalas. Greetings ☀️
i definetly hear it
Ok payola group fan
@itachilimbu3752 don’t insult others over a similarity in song that’s so very immature!! you should act like a better person from now on
@@hdajq892ey7where did they insult them…?
Where’s the insult ?
@@Matthew-sl8dx the reply, not original comment
That's cocoloco and Loco. There is no way it's coincidence.
I think so too
it is cocoroco, not cocoloco
@@sofia_822it’s coco loco. in Korean the l and r are the same sound basically
Its a funny phrase used a million times in different songs hrbdbshs
@lucindaruiz9623 no, it's Cocoroco because it says "taste cocoroco". Cocoroco is a type of alcohol so strong that it's considered a poison.
I kinda forgot how good ferga whatever is
yea… people last remember her from her jazzy interpretation of pledge of allegiance so she was basically bullied into exile 😭😭😭
but she’s still such a powerhouse singer and performer. who else can sing an entire riff while doing cartwheels on Good Morning America?
put some respect on her name, she is (was) FERGALICIOUS
@@ThemedNumber02National Anthem, not pledge of allegiance. That’s a different thing.
Is Fergie. Respect her name.
Girl it’s Fergie a 2000s icon
I think all these songs sampled “Baby got back” by sir mix-a lot or at least a bit of it
Idk about BGB specifically but Fergalicious for sure samples Supersonic by JJ Fad, pretty sure the black eyed peas tried to straight up rip them off back when the song came out til they got sued and had to give credit 😭
@@leirvohs what are you on? JJ Fad were credited *from the start* on Fergalicious, there was no lawsuit or anything, and they gave Fergie permission to use the song. And it was a Fergie song, not a BEP song btw.
And to answer to OP, no, Fergie didn't sample Sir Mix-A-Lot. ^^
@@JordiVanderwaal As I’m rereading, looks like it was the company refusing to pay royalties, but there was definitely a lawsuit involved. Looks like we’re both partially wrong, so I guess we both on some psychs rn
so that's why i was getting a lil bit of anaconda
I thought the same thing!!!
Apparently, that's been a thing for a while, making songs that sound vaguely familiar. It pulls out your nostalgia and makes you like a song even if it's only mediocre. I wouldn't be surprised if the track was made this way on purpose.
oh its like a subliminal message! Cool
They do. But all it does is make me remember the OG song and I write that artist off as an unoriginal loser.
@@Furrina89 eh, some of the best songs are heavily inspired by other songs. Some of my favorites have samples in them. I don't need everything to be totally original but please, let it be good.
That's why when I hear Houdini, I hear the original song and vocals instead of Dua Lipa's
Yes. Agree. It's been a thing for a while. But if it was Blackpink, it would be different reaction ngl.
OMG!!! I didn’t see this until now! The “coco loco” line HAS to be an interpolation from Fergielicious. Especially when “[make these boys] GO LOCO” has the same pronunciation as “coco loco” 😆
Interpolation is the wrong term here. I would say the line is referencing or inspired by that same line. I have been saying it since WIFE was released. People kept saying it was bad and I was like no??? It sounds like Fergie which I love
Your ears are always something!💀
We all know (G)I-dle are always having references to different things on their songs
they must've been taken the inspiration from her
Credit?😂
You can take inspiration from anything. Every single thing that exists physically or it is a temporary phenomenon should have credits then. Even the words of another person can also be an inspiration for someone. All Taylor Swift songs should also have credits from the people who inspired her. Inspiration is such a big concept that it becomes stupid at some point. @@Sooyadream_
@@Sooyadream_It is sample,it does not need credit
Sample is not created by artist or music producer. This is inspiration. Sample is a sound or piece of music that create by sampling. Usually from piano, violin or guitar. But if someone use the same piece of beat with almost same lyrics, it's not sample. More like inspiration.
@@sylvesterpiehkorgay9240uhh sample needs credit. And also they need to pay for the license to use the music. Y'all blind fans out here spreading misinformation to justify your bias huh
thats why i thought it sounded familiar,i couldn’t pinpoint it tho🌝
The first line about cream soup is giving a little Kesha's TiKToK "The party don't start till I walk in" too
Well Soyeon is know for getting “inspiration “ from other songs
Those first couple notes made me think of the opening of f(x)’s Rum Pum Pum Pum.
For me, there's people use ACM mode.. Analyze-Copy-Modification.. so I think she's (soyeon) good at that
That's called beat, woman
when she said that the start sounds a bit like blackpink like no shit, blackpink literally used a sample for that
It's only colloquially called a "beat". Musical terms are different. Some people say the melody is the "beat" too. It depends if you're talking about the notes or the rhythm. A lot of people call them "hip hop beats" when they're referring to the tune itself
@@primetimehomeI agree. I think she's deaf or something???💀 I think that's just the same Korean instrument named geomungo nothing more.
@@user-parksoomin Why so triggered dude? She probably doesn't know that?? 🤷♀️
10-20% similarity
OMG I LOVE G-IDLE EVEN MORE NOWWWW SOYEON YOU ARE AMAZING !!! ❤
"inspiration" lol
"Make the boys go loco" and Wife's "taste like cocoloco" wow
OMG Your profile picture 😢 I love B.A.P ❤
it's no wonder that i simply LOVED this song when I heard it for the first time, and I always had this exact thought that a Fergalicious sample was used, the beat is really good (fun fact: i was a fanboy of Fergie and the Black Eyed Peas 😭💅)
the intro beats sound like best friend by saweetie and doja cat too
I thought that too...
In my head, the lyrics of "best friend" were switched to "My Bag," so I couldn't pin point it. 😭
P1harmony - Scared
I think it shounds like Super freaky girl
You know the "one thing about" part
I heard nothing😮 and this song is really stuck in my head 😊❤🎉
Well, it's just a part of it, and it's not the same lyrics. Have you heard the whole song like the rap part it's amazing❤
Now , G-Idle's fans are protecting them .. but when pink venom and shut down was released.. all the other fandoms were like "yeahhh , BLACKPINK copieddd" ..
But don't forget that Fergalicious has samples of JJFad's Supersonic
i kind of hear it but gosh fergalicious was so CATCHY such a bop
probably they inspired in that? (the instrumental anf the vibes of the song), i mean the producer, like the most of the songs, obviously most of them are more noticeable and another unnoticeable, but yeah sounds familiar btw
no when their being less similar they must have not payed the original😂 sometimes you had permission but lied of paying them lol its a little brainless and jail but i guess foreigners need to respect all country becouse they dont know what will treat them when the royals wants to jail racism
The "mmm, mmm, mmm" reminds me of New Face by Psy
Yes! In my head im doing the dap everytime :D
it sounds like "Want me a wipe, but shit is mm mm mm"
Definitely but the song is still unique
It’s more like artificial intelligence writes music, lyrics, they can finish for example
It's sample song from supersonics
gidle always take inspiration from other songs also because soyeon writes them just look at the mv of their song lion where there are many similarities to other songs like snche queencard and nxde
It's something called bpm.
Itz mostly the beat, which is itself a genre. The singing/rapping is very common in pop. Nelly Furtado, Kesha r quite known for this kind of singing
well there are so many songs on the market it’s hard to come up with something that doesn’t sound similar to anything
Music is a culture and we are all products of our culture. Producers listen to pop music from the past and it becomes part of the vocabulary. Unless you intentionally go out of your way to invent a new musical language like Webern and Schoenberg, popular music are gonna sound alike. It needs a common "language" to be popular.
O m a g a a a ! ! ! 😱
P1harmony - Scared
Well, Soyeon is someone who apologized for her plagiarism case with "I haven't heard the song but here's my apology". Let me guess, she heard Fergalicious from years ago and the melody suddenly popped on her mind and she didn't realize it.
i mean sampling is quite common in kpop so I wouldn't be surprised if they got inspired from that song
i feel like it sounds familiar too but i can't wrap my head around which song it was, your idea is pretty near.
Si vas a estar comparando una canción con otra nunca vas a disfrutar nada😂
Its funny cause Fergalicious actually samples another song called Supersonic
No i dont hear it!
This is just another one of your many attempts to hype up BP and drag GIDLE.
Enough already!
Fr and she successfully failed in dragging gidle down. They're slaying hard.
The whole album is just lit.
Yep definitely 😂
the melody sounds familar but idk what it is. it's something from BACK THEN. baby got back influenced maybe
Off topic but in the first clip of fergie the guy in the back is wearing a trix cereal shirt I just noticed that
I just hate it when something is very similat and some fans like “not at all” like dude let’s be real
Listen to Supersonic by JJ Fad. A late 1980’s hip hop record. I’m sure (G)-Idle got their inspiration for this song from it. Maybe I’m wrong.
fergalicious actually samples this song, so all three are similar!
Yes you're wrong 😊
Its just the beat,and when you look at it its very common,but hes it does sound alike for a bit
Same Same but diFfeleNt 🤡
it seems to me that this is just a coincidence, but even that is not enough
It does sound similar.
they do sound similar but the feel is different.
Nah it's completely different lol
RIGHT
Thank you for pointing this out, its in my head the first time I listened
I never thought Neverlands are so dumb and deaf. Your biases just copied another song - admit it. No need to argue that it's just a beat, it's just a lyric blah blah blah. Accept the reality.
Imagina ser burro igual você kkkkkkk
I hear the SNL skit about Emma Stone slipping on jelly and breaking her arm lol
vocal 10/10
dance 10/10
rap 10/10
visual 10/10
charisma 100000000000/10
Copy infinity
@@disarasemika6480Yeah your faves songs are definitely copy= infinity ♾️
It sounds like that Emma Stone SNL song where she broke her arm
If it was BLACKPINK, people was like:
"YG need new producer."
"There's no originality in their music."
"It's Teddy. 3R. Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. What do you expect.".
Drama....
Frrrrrr
Fergie sounds like Gidle, Gidle queens never sounds like fergie. RESPECT THE QUEENS
yes Fergie copied Gidle... in 2006 🤣💀
I think more people need to know that in real time we tried TOO MANY combinations of notes that we couldn't compose smth original
It ALL comes from JJ Fad Supersonic
I agree that it sounds like snl’s I broke my arm lol
This 👆 I hear it too
Fergalicious with a little bit of twenty and swipe from Itzy!!!!Very clever Soyeon!!The best rapper-produced of kpop in general!!!!
Anyone who is getting ready to hate them please stop bcoz they work hard for each songs and( n ik it's kinda similar)
An idol dosen't mean your doll to F- with
Definitely 1,000,000,000% the music and even the words
they sound really similar imo
Also sounds like the beginning of Aespa - Spicy
Thats why they called copyidle ✔
Idk if your joking 😭 but they are NOT copying
inspiration isn’t considered copying. one line having similar beats =/= copying a whole song. if the whole song had the same exact rhythm and chord progression, then yes it would be copying. but since it does not, it is inspiration. throwing around the word “copying” and “plagiarism” is exactly how words like this gets watered down and no one takes it seriously when it does happen. inspiration happens all the time in music.
I don't know why remember red velvet when i listen it, maybe because all members rapping and the short hair all members like them
Still haven’t run out of ideas to make Gidle look bad it’s embarrassing bcs they outdid 😂😂
Cringe
💀no one is trying to embarrass gidle here
I'm getting Soyeon all over my recommended for some reason wtf
Pen pineapple apple pen
soyeon does this regularly with alot of songs actually😭
Sounds nothing like fergalicious.
We're talking about the beginning of the song and the beat behind it. You can't deny that Kpop samples a lot of Western artists.
No way you don’t actually hear the similarities 😅
@@erickacornu774 sampling requires copyrights. This song isn’t a sample. And it doesn’t even sound similar to me. I don’t know what she’s on about.
Everything is just a random mind in perfect pitch people
G I-DLE still did the best 😆
I think it reminds me of my phone alarm 😭 idk how to explain it
Thank God it's a (G)i-dle song.
If blackpink did the same thing they will get tonnes of hate .
It's true that hating blackpink is a trend in k-pop
By the way (G)i-dle really disappointed me by there song wife song. I hate it.
The irony of complaining that your favourite idols get unnecessary hate whilst also trying to tear down a completely different group... do you think it's idle's fault that BP get hate? Also, you really disappointed me with this comment. I hate it.
I mean Wife isnt meant to be a serious song, the group is just having fun which is why it's not getting a lot of hate.
the first notes remind me of fergies "my humps" XD
There's no similar okay
GIDLE is the best group ever
Actually the 1st beat reminds me of many 2nd gen songs around 2011-2013 😅
Girl almost all music is inspired by something else. Get a life fr lol
Fr 😂
lol you told her to get a life :)
@@Khinh-xq6lx yeah you should do the same :)
It’s just a fun fact that we found why it sounded familiar, we know it happens all the time with music and it’s completely fine, absolutely nobody is criticising it lol
@sandraswan9008 I’ll do whatever the f I want to, child lmao that’s how the world works. Talk to me once you’ve grown up.
I don't hear it. But they both make you want to get up and dance!!
It sounds like Spicy by Aespa kinda, the beginning and the pre chorus
Not even close.
@@Bobozeeros starting from I Cook cream soup and you want my a to the z verses whatever thing
@@baconboi9893 it doesnt...
Whether its kpop or just pop they always have been using what is already existing as samples for ages😊
i dnt hear it. how about not accusing them of something before u do the research to make sure. they dnt have permission to use the sound. Just starting conflicts just for views. Shame do better blocked from now on.
YESSSS
She's replying to a comment that its in top left, she's like just asking
There’s no accusation of anything lol
I mean yeah but i don’t think it’s so similar that I would get too concerned tbh
Kpop is literally saying no orignal 😂
Have you never heard of sampling? It's done in every country 😂
@@allyh7075 ik and sampling means reuse so stop being offended by every little thing 😂
@@lilikrystal1135 you know all art is inspired by other art, right?
@@allyh7075 lmao well some obsessed fans like u can't accept truth 😂