No Spoilers Review Of Batman: Gotham By Gaslight

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 99

  • @lukeskywalkerthe2nd773
    @lukeskywalkerthe2nd773 6 лет назад +39

    I freaking love Gotham By Gaslight. And its a pretty great adaptation of the original comic too IMO!!!! :)

  • @ashleytripp8111
    @ashleytripp8111 5 лет назад +3

    I love how they added the first 3 robins in the movie. I really liked it.

  • @vexween784
    @vexween784 6 лет назад +48

    DC animation kicks Marvel's ass in animated and some TV shows but cinema eeehhhhh sorry DC

    • @demonemperorastaroth7867
      @demonemperorastaroth7867 6 лет назад

      soullessleaf 578 I guess DC needs at least 1 win over marvel

    • @vexween784
      @vexween784 6 лет назад

      jalen tyler definitely

    • @stonechen2480
      @stonechen2480 6 лет назад

      I'd say right now, MCU TV kicks Arrowverse's ass. Except for The Inhumans, the worst Marvel TV show is Iron Fist, which is still on par with Legends of Tomorrow. Book-wise, Marvel has put out too many cross-overs over the last couple of decades and has become stagnant, not to mention it never had its own Vertigo. Animation-wise, Marvel has always been too safe comparing to DC, even during the 90's, the X-Men cartoon was still second to the BAS.

    • @benjamin-ing
      @benjamin-ing 6 лет назад +1

      soullessleaf 578 much agree

    • @stonechen2480
      @stonechen2480 6 лет назад

      I'd wholeheartedly disagree. Sharon Carter was slow to find its rhythm and got canceled before its time, and if you got passed the first half of the first season, AoS has continuously improved season by season, which is a rarity in itself. The current season especially is so much better than anything the Arrowverse has right now. I'd say the only good DC show right now is Gotham (I also like Lucifer, but I like the original comics much more), Arrow has shown its age since season 4, and Flash since 2. The Runaways is also very well done, improving on a already excellent comic. The Gifted (X-Men, but still, Marvel) also surprised me. In term of quality, I think both are comparable to the first season of Arrow.

  • @xeno527
    @xeno527 6 лет назад +7

    Yes the background music is back

  • @andylai7222
    @andylai7222 6 лет назад +17

    I thought the movie was great and well-plotted out. The only complaint that I have was that the ending felt abrupt like how you said it. They should have added an extra scene at the end to properly conclude the movie.

    • @Olivman7
      @Olivman7 6 лет назад +3

      Yeah, this screams "production cut short" problems. You can almost imagine the missing scene:
      "A few days later, in broad daylight, Bruce and Selina stand in the middle of the world fair being reconstructed, while Dick says something about how the new version pays more attention to the poor and downtrodden. Bruce and Selina make a speech where they announce new founding to the orphanage or something. Then the last plan shows them kissing, and zooms out to show the fair, the city, looking to the future. THE END"

    • @jonarbuckle778
      @jonarbuckle778 6 лет назад +1

      I would have also thrown in a few teasers to future villains to appear in this world, like a new madman who leaves a particular calling card behind with his victims wearing horrible huge smiles, or a criminal master mind who sends riddles to the police about his next crime. Just to imply that the Batman's work is not done and leave room for a potential sequel.

  • @TomMcD71
    @TomMcD71 6 лет назад +18

    The only sad thing related to Gotham by Gaslight was that the game was cancelled

    • @demonemperorastaroth7867
      @demonemperorastaroth7867 6 лет назад +4

      Tom McDaniel Yeah, but it may come back some day

    • @TomMcD71
      @TomMcD71 6 лет назад

      jalen tyler that would be awesome if it did come back like Star fox 2 on the SNES Classic

  • @Rampaging_Rhino_Customs
    @Rampaging_Rhino_Customs 6 лет назад +6

    Best Batman movie I’ve seen in a long time

  • @erinv1232
    @erinv1232 6 лет назад +7

    DC Animation hits a home run.

    • @lukeskywalkerthe2nd773
      @lukeskywalkerthe2nd773 6 лет назад

      Darth Stalker ikr

    • @VulcanGray
      @VulcanGray 5 лет назад +1

      What? How?! It looks worse than any episode of the show! The animation is more like a slideshow.

    • @bgw316
      @bgw316 5 лет назад

      @@VulcanGray I don't get it either honestly. Pretty much every DC film since the new 52 adaptions have looked cheaply produced and lazily plotted; especially compared to the JLU which released more high quality episodes per year than the current DCAU for the past decade.

  • @tigermacc8850
    @tigermacc8850 6 лет назад +3

    This was actually pretty good

  • @sheevthesenatepalpatine8863
    @sheevthesenatepalpatine8863 3 года назад

    This and Battle For The Cowl are my favorite Batman stories

  • @michaelbrent854
    @michaelbrent854 6 лет назад +4

    I have respect Bruce Timm soo I'm wonder why he can't go back and work with Paul Dini? Don't get me wrong I looved this movie , but again it was done without Paul Dini and I feel Bruce Timm would get a lot of success if Paul Dini was involved.

  • @vaggelitsapapa9356
    @vaggelitsapapa9356 6 лет назад +2

    Spoilers!!!!!!! Spoilers!!!!!
    Don't see the comment if you don't want to spoil your movie
    And I suggest you to go watch this movie before see this comment.
    So the movie was pretty nice and jack the ripper was Jim Gordon!!! Omg I couldn't even imagine that!!! Also,at the end it was very nice that they put all the characters together( Dick, Jason, Tim, Selena, Alfred and Bruce) and kept their personalities! And at the end Batman adopted all of the children and stayed with Selena Kyle!!! So nice ending and a very good plot twist!!!!
    Great movie!!!

  • @ozan8636
    @ozan8636 6 лет назад +1

    I just watched it yesterday and I love it. did not expect who jack the ripper was hahahaha

  • @disk3001
    @disk3001 6 лет назад +1

    tbh I hope they make a second movie set in this universe

  • @tigermacc8850
    @tigermacc8850 6 лет назад +5

    Hopefully long Halloween will be next

    • @boipboi3225
      @boipboi3225 6 лет назад

      Tiger Macc yesssssssssssssss

    • @hitlowftw9804
      @hitlowftw9804 6 лет назад

      Tiger Macc hopefully we stop having Batman movies and focus on other characters

    • @josiahjenksisawesome
      @josiahjenksisawesome 6 лет назад

      Maybe then the War of Jokes & Riddles, or Hush, or even Dark Nights Metal. The possibilities are endless.

  • @vaggelitsapapa9356
    @vaggelitsapapa9356 6 лет назад +1

    I have just watched the movie and it was amazing!!! I really liked that the movie showed Batman's detective skills( because he hasn't all that tech in that century)!
    And also the plot twist for who the jack the ripper is amazing!!! Seriously you will not even imagine who the jack the ripper is!!! I am not saying more.

  • @KooroshFarahani
    @KooroshFarahani 6 лет назад +1

    Pretty good movie but i can see what you were saying with the ending

  • @BenjiDWJ
    @BenjiDWJ 6 лет назад

    Awesome video & content as per usual :) keep up the stellar work as always!.

  • @funtimegameryv5037
    @funtimegameryv5037 6 лет назад +2

    Well done man ur my inspirational please do more

  • @cameoshadowness7757
    @cameoshadowness7757 6 лет назад +1

    You make me want to get this now...

  • @markburns2371
    @markburns2371 6 лет назад +1

    I can't wait to see this film hopefully it will download well

    • @yousf9709
      @yousf9709 6 лет назад

      stream it online :p

  • @kaibaman9651
    @kaibaman9651 6 лет назад

    I think this would also be a good time to talk about the gotham by gaslight game. That was pretty much the prototype to the creation of the arkham games.

  • @gibsverses9501
    @gibsverses9501 6 лет назад

    Well damn I need to read the comic now. I didnt know about all the changes.

  • @HenT8991
    @HenT8991 6 лет назад

    Did anyone notice the easter egg at the end with Jack the Ripper "vanishing" into the flames?

  • @EstherHulst-Artist
    @EstherHulst-Artist 6 лет назад

    I loved it accept the ending it was to short. I liked the explination of why jack did it but wanted more of it

  • @Blackblax
    @Blackblax 6 лет назад +1

    Good review, I'm going to watch this movie soon.
    When I heard the name Anthony Stewart Head, I also instantly thought "Giles from Buffy: the Vampire Slayer" too. LoL.
    That's one show that definitely deserves a sequel or at least an updated remake (along w/ Xena). They are what heroines should be, especially in this supper SJW climate.

  • @ashutoshprakash3017
    @ashutoshprakash3017 6 лет назад

    spoiler: the ripper isn't joker or harvey dent. in the original he was a family friend of the waynes (how many more friends of the waynes are gonna become evil?) but i won't reveal it though HINT: it's someone who's very close to batman.

  • @victorial3588
    @victorial3588 6 лет назад

    I didn't think that I would like it so much!! It certainly didn't disappointed me.. The only thing that bothered me a little was the ending (it was a bit "quick") but other than that.. Really good movie!

  • @batmanbeyond5766
    @batmanbeyond5766 4 года назад +1

    My phone must be gliching because the best youtuber ever hasn't even got 1k likes on this vidio

  • @davidvorhees3961
    @davidvorhees3961 6 лет назад

    Let me start by saying i loved the original comic, not so much the sequal. I felt the sequal was more a piece to keep making them. In the first comic, Batman caught his parents killer so why continue to be Batman and the sequal was an excuse to give him a reason and it could have been better. I thought a second better story would be to introduce Dent and have him be a Jekyll and Hyde type character, since that is what two-face is, but instead of half his face being scarred he could transform like jekyll into his alter ego giving him literally 2 faces.
    As far as the movie goes i enjoyed it thoroughly. I felt the addition of adding other dc characters set up the possibility of more movies, i just hope they keep it darker much the this movie and the first comic and not the 2nd comic. My only true misgiving was the twist and that was for 2 reasons. The first was the motivation behind the Rippers killings. The motivation provided would allow him to kill but not the antagonizing the police or cannabilism he alluded to in the letter. Second was the fact that they used an existing DC character to be the ripper. They could have easily introduced mutliple new characters into the universe including Jacob Packer, so then when it turned out to be someone other than Packer it would have been a surprise. Personally i would have had a background character who was seen at the club, at ivy's dance, the fair announcement but given no lines or focus and that would have also given Batman much more detective work to do to find the killer and make a longer movie. Using an existing DC character just seems lazy and using the one they did use was just for shock value, again lazy. But overall i felt the movie was really good and like the comic i will probably watch it many times.

  • @ScarecrOmega
    @ScarecrOmega 6 лет назад +3

    Loved GbG, but there weren't enough characters to guess who Jack was, I was thinking the whole time "well it's either the red herring or the other guy". I thought there would have been more rogue gallery cameos than what we got. Also there were a couple scenes that were very similar to Mask of the Phantasm.

  • @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
    @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache 6 лет назад

    All I can say is: I said "but why, though" a lot during this movie.

    • @vincentblanco2032
      @vincentblanco2032 6 лет назад +2

      Just Some Guy with a Mustache why do i see you everywhere? xD

  • @atem9170
    @atem9170 6 лет назад +6

    Dc Animation>>>>>>>Marvel Animation

    • @ozan8636
      @ozan8636 6 лет назад +1

      DC live action is shit though (dont get me wrong i like DC 100% more)

    • @slendus8363
      @slendus8363 6 лет назад +1

      Fire lord zuko same i love dc more but marvel has better live action

  • @josiahjenksisawesome
    @josiahjenksisawesome 6 лет назад

    Not gonna lie, I kind of want a sequel fleshing out the idea of a Victorian Gotham and continuing Batman's career in the era. Like imagine Batman going after Sweeney Todd and teaming up with Sherlock Holmes (but make it serious), you can even throw in nods to other famous characters by having Bruce Wayne rub elbows with people like Mr Darcy and Ebeneezer Scrooge.

  • @kingmuizz708
    @kingmuizz708 6 лет назад +2

    Good shit

  • @DarthSidious11
    @DarthSidious11 6 лет назад +1

    who is the jack in the comic

    • @davidvorhees3961
      @davidvorhees3961 6 лет назад

      Darth Sidious an old family friend of the Waynes, Jacob Packer. Packer was a med student with Thomas Wayne before giving up on medicine and becoming a lawyer, all on Wayne's dime. He was also in love with Martha and when she rejected him in favor of Thomas he went mad, eventually leading him to hire the highwayman that killed them. He also killed women, as the ripper, that reminded him of Martha and would cause him to hear her "laughter" at his advances spurned causing his aggression and homicidal tendencies.

  • @flintlockwood25
    @flintlockwood25 4 года назад

    I'm a big fan of Gaslight, great film
    It's funny how Marvel have become conglomerates in movies, but DC is still kicking their FAT ARSES in animation (if you get the reference, then good for you)

  • @stonechen2480
    @stonechen2480 6 лет назад

    I pretty much got the identity of Jack after their first fight, and it was made clearer later on. However, I really don't like this change. Overall, the movie is only marginally better than the last two outings. Harley Quinn at least had a few chuckles.

  • @stefanmilanovski8020
    @stefanmilanovski8020 6 лет назад

    Im on the later episodes of young justice season 1

  • @mega-mz7oj
    @mega-mz7oj 6 лет назад

    good video keep it up

  • @megatron2171
    @megatron2171 6 лет назад

    i saw the movie its good but the changes on the ripper was really big

  • @farmincrops
    @farmincrops 6 лет назад

    I think Jack the ripper is Alfred. it only makes sense

  • @1989TS..
    @1989TS.. 6 лет назад

    Why did they ruin the killing joke?

  • @RoboBoomStick
    @RoboBoomStick 6 лет назад +1

    They made it too obvious it was Gordon

    • @ozan8636
      @ozan8636 6 лет назад

      no not at all

    • @RoboBoomStick
      @RoboBoomStick 6 лет назад

      why?

    • @RoboBoomStick
      @RoboBoomStick 6 лет назад

      first If they cared so much they would of watched the movie already, and second it was super obvious, try paying attention to movies not just being a mindless drone.

  • @xeno527
    @xeno527 6 лет назад

    Do you watch Gotham

  • @thingswrongwithstufftwws8925
    @thingswrongwithstufftwws8925 6 лет назад

    Who is Jack the Ripper(identity) in the movie?

  • @dianedenonneville4259
    @dianedenonneville4259 6 лет назад

    What age do you think that this is good for?

  • @callejacobson8487
    @callejacobson8487 5 лет назад

    I GIVE BATMAN GOTHAM BY GASLIGHT 10. 10

  • @IllMatic97
    @IllMatic97 6 лет назад

    Batman and Harley Quinn was not that bad as people claim. It just wasn't serious and edgy.

  • @anthonyorea1119
    @anthonyorea1119 5 лет назад

    I like this movie at the end was a plot twost

  • @elwinmartin9160
    @elwinmartin9160 6 лет назад

    james gordan

  • @VulcanGray
    @VulcanGray 5 лет назад +2

    One of the worst movies ive seen period.

    • @dustinakadustin
      @dustinakadustin 5 лет назад

      Straight up ruined one of my favourite Batman stories. I hated it. I was really angry after watching it.

  • @GezbelleGaburgably
    @GezbelleGaburgably 6 лет назад

    Early.

  • @funtimegameryv5037
    @funtimegameryv5037 6 лет назад

    First

  • @amut6647
    @amut6647 6 лет назад

    LOL Jack the Ripper? I'm guessing all the other super heroes rip on Batman for having the easiest and dumbest villains. Jack the Ripper was a loser who picked on vulnerable people like women who were alone... Probably the dumbest villain in a superhero movie yet.