@@youannoyme6288 Yes people do say they can’t sing all the time lmao. Just because you don’t see it happen doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen. Edit : oh nvm you’re just a hater lmao. You have 8 comments on this channel & it’s all you being bitter 😂😂😂
지젤은 핸드마이크 쓸줄도 모르는데 무슨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ춤출때는 그냥 입에서 점점 마이크 멀어짐 원래 연생때 다하는건데 연습안하고 뭐했나?? 그리고 노래에 원체 더블링이 많이 되어있는데 브릿지는 코러스 없으니까 윈터닝닝 목소리가 아예 안들리고 카리나 애드리브는 무슨 일반인이 노래방에서 부르는줄 알았닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅈㄴ웃기네
I swear they sound better with each live performance. By this time next year they may be on a world tour, and by that I mean Asia, Europe, and the Americas, north and south. (I really want them to come to Toronto) Fingers crossed!
giselle's adlib at 1:13, ningning's sweet voice at 2:08, karina's badass tone at 0:10 and winter's tender, elegant vocals at 0:22 just proves aespa has one of the best vocalists in gen 4
Love Giselle's vocal @1:13 and choreo @1:17. She enjoys being on the stage. Also keep repeating @2:34 Karina's vocal. Awosome. Can't wait to see their performance in the nearly future. MY from 대만.
the girls were very worried before the performance at Coachella, because it is important, so they could miss the notes a little. they also danced all the time. anyway, they had a good performance that delighted many
everytime i hear this song i can't help but fall into a trance by ningning... ik my winter bias won't be able stay strong if our maknae keeps on slaying like this
누구야 누가 라이브 못 한대
I want more of Karina's vocals grrrrr. Winter looks so good in blonde, Giselle looks more comfortable now. And as Usual, our cute maknae Ningning.
2:21 & 2:35 omg 😭 karining's vocals are killing me 😍😍
isnt it! i love them
Karina's vocals is insane
winter vocal makes me comfortable and happy
ningning 's voice is killing me so beautiful!!!!
Ningning vocal!!♥
WINTER, LOVE YOU SO MUCH. I really can't take off my eyes from her lol...
Giselle's outfit, vocals, visuals, dance everything is on point and am here for it💜💜
i really really love karina’s voice
Winter 😍
2:21 Ningning’s vocal is sooooo stable~❤️ And her hair style is so cute~🦋
에스파 파이팅!!! 언어폭력에 주늑 들 이유 하나도 없어요!!!!! 언제나 마이가 같이 맞설게요 에스파가 더 잘했으면 좋겠다고 격려하고 걱정해주신 분들께 더 멋진 모습 많이 많이 보여주자고요~!!!!!!!
Yet people say they can't sing💁🏻♀️ guess they too afraid of the talent these girls hold 👑
@@youannoyme6288 your dn really described what I feel about u
@@youannoyme6288 Yes people do say they can’t sing all the time lmao. Just because you don’t see it happen doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.
Edit : oh nvm you’re just a hater lmao. You have 8 comments on this channel & it’s all you being bitter 😂😂😂
@@youannoyme6288 You should find some better seeds to sow. You seem a bit confrontational.
@@youannoyme6288 many ppl say they cant sing lmfao
@@youannoyme6288 you should be in aespa's fandom so u will see what others say always
And this show I love how Giselle looks so happy and had fun the entire time! 😍✨🌙
진짜 이걸보고도 립싱크라고 하는 사람들은 무슨생각으로 사는지 모르겟다 ㅋㅋ
너야말로 이거 하나로 라이브 한다고 믿고 싶은 건 아니고?
@@-hong 하나 라니? 다른영상들도 라이브 있는데? 보고 말 좀 해줄래요?
@@TookaCut 다른 영상들도 립싱크 있어요~~
@@-hong 제가 쓴글에 논점을 못잡으시네요
Loving how Giselle is rocking the long white t-shirt like a dress just like how seulgi also rocked the long red t-shirt a few years back.
She also kinda looks like seulgi here with red hair
@@earlanagaran1017 now that you've said it she really do look similarly.
Winter gained some weight and am here for it! I'm so happy when I see them lookin healthy. Keep it up, girls!! ❤️
Winter ❤️🔥
winter just killing me as usual
울 엣둥이들 ❤️ 라이브 수고했어 잘한다 잘해 오늘 푹쉬고 내일 쇼케도 좋은 무대 보여주길!
내일도 공연 있어요?
@@日の上神楽 오늘,,내일 이틀 공연이예요
@@user-po5vq5gc4t 내일 몇시에 해요?
지젤은 핸드마이크 쓸줄도 모르는데 무슨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ춤출때는 그냥 입에서 점점 마이크 멀어짐 원래 연생때 다하는건데 연습안하고 뭐했나?? 그리고 노래에 원체 더블링이 많이 되어있는데 브릿지는 코러스 없으니까 윈터닝닝 목소리가 아예 안들리고 카리나 애드리브는 무슨 일반인이 노래방에서 부르는줄 알았닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅈㄴ웃기네
@@PARKGEUMOK1 라이브 잘하니까 이젠 마이크 잡는거로 까냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 핸드마이크 저렇게 잡는 아이돌 못 보긴 했는데 귀여워서 오히려 좋음
쇼케이스 보신 분들 너무 부럽다🥺
우리 애들 라이브도 좋구 무대도 잘한다💙
립싱큰데 라이브 이지럴 ㅋㅋ
@@tiger-de7xg ㅁㄱ
@@tiger-de7xg ?
@@tiger-de7xg 라이브 맞는뎅,,
@@tiger-de7xg 뉴욕 쇼케 라이브라고 또 미국에서만 라이브냐고 개까더니 무슨 이제는 라이브도 아니라 하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
닝닝 보컬 최고…❤️❤️❤️
We want more Ningning and Karina adlib. ❤❤
NINGNING is on fire！Go ahead bravely girl
Ningning's vocal 🔥
my winterrrr ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I swear they sound better with each live performance. By this time next year they may be on a world tour, and by that I mean Asia, Europe, and the Americas, north and south.
(I really want them to come to Toronto)
Fingers crossed!
@@youannoyme6288 so what? You the annoying one
@@youannoyme6288 what's your point? I said they sound better each time. Is that a false statement?
@@youannoyme6288 literally u in every comment what r your business act.. yk life is too short.. do ur own business instead 😭 leave my girls alone!
@@youannoyme6288 you annoy us.
@@youannoyme6288 don't get started
I Know that the song hit you but go get a life
Don't waste your time here
진짜 수고했어 ㅠㅠㅠ항생 행복하고 행복하게 해줘서 고마워 🤍
Omg their live vocals sounds really really good. Even winter and ning ning sounds like recording.. Spechless
역시 에스파 넘 잘한다!!!
aespa live vocals are fire
Very good recording! Great job! Thanks for doing justice to Aespa ❤️❤️❤️
지젤이 너무 너무 수고많았어 오늘 최고였따 푹쉬고 푹 잘자구 내일도 화이팅~~💭🫶🏻🖤
억까쟁이들 뭐가 불만인지 이리 좀 와봐~
내가 관심 좀 줄게
Karina seriously wows with her vocal n live.
N ningning winter giselle too! 👍❤
라이브 개쩐다
@@nash9937 mistranslation…She/He is praising aespa’s live vocals
@@smame-n4b i'm sorry
giselle's adlib at 1:13, ningning's sweet voice at 2:08, karina's badass tone at 0:10 and winter's tender, elegant vocals at 0:22 just proves aespa has one of the best vocalists in gen 4
i love winter and ningning vocal
닝 애드립 라이브 미쳣댜옹
Winter literally shines everytime
KARINAAAA I LOVEE UUUUU❤❤❤❤❤❤
They sound SO GOOD live! They need to sing live all the time.
@@youannoyme6288 Why don't you just leave this chat line? All you're doing is arguing with people who are praising Aespa's live vocals.
@@youannoyme6288 haters life too short bruh
@@youannoyme6288 no blackmamba was live ㅋㅋㄲwtf
They are clearly lipsyncing
@@fchick you’re deaf and a hater. Listen to Karina sing stop at 2:20. THAT IS LIVE. Also Karina at 2:36. That is all improvised. So, now just shut it.
0:17 im in love with this part lmao
Same!
Karinaaaa♥♥♥♡♡
Karina and NinNing's vocals T.T
Love Giselle's vocal @1:13 and choreo @1:17. She enjoys being on the stage. Also keep repeating @2:34 Karina's vocal. Awosome. Can't wait to see their performance in the nearly future. MY from 대만.
NIng NIng!!!
Ning Ning’s vocal fantastic
언니들 한국에서도 해줘 라이브
Winter's vocals during "you need to get a life cause life's too short" so angelic omg
Karina!!!
Ningning start💞💞💞🐰
2:35 KARINA !! 😩😩
WINTER’S VOCALS!!!
Winter's voice is as sweet as honey.... But yeah everyone slayed it.... I live for their vocals
karina's ad libs omg
Winter,, you make me heart ❤💞❤💞
Winter 😍
Ningning and Karina ~~~❤️❤️❤️❤️🦋🦋🦋
Ningning's voice 😭😭😭😭💕💕💕
OMG KARINAAAA WITH HER LIVE VOCALS IM CRYINNN
Ningning fits well to this genre. Look how comfortable she is.
Queen Vocalists of 4th Gen!
2:35 still can't get enough of Karina's ad-libs ❤️
코첼라때는 아쉬운게 조금 있었지만 이번에는 다들 너무 잘했다 짱스파!!! 💙🖤💜💜
the girls were very worried before the performance at Coachella, because it is important, so they could miss the notes a little. they also danced all the time. anyway, they had a good performance that delighted many
KARINAS VOCALS
라이브 진ㅋ자 잘한다
And this show I love how Giselle looks so happy and had fun the entire time! 😍✨🌙
I love ningning voice 🫶🏻
2:00 ningning low voice was beautiful 😍😍😍
karina is really the one
엣멤버들 모두 고생 많았어~!
NingNing say mic on they all sound so good
everytime i hear this song i can't help but fall into a trance by ningning... ik my winter bias won't be able stay strong if our maknae keeps on slaying like this
you must be ningning biased already seeing as your profile pic is ningning :)
I know I have no hope so I stan all 4 lol
@@TeachLikeBenni :") girl u be stating the obv :)) it's still too painful to admit that i'm biaswrecked
😍😍agree
Giselle
Karina Vocal ❤
Karina dance ❤💗
Cute little maknae nining movements, voice, performance and presence
Winter rambutnya di pendekin gitu keliatan baddas donk
Giselle slay 😍
Aespa is much better with live vocals, i hate sm for the lipsync
Karina ace
Karinaaaa vocallll
Live vocals🔥
this vid is to all those haters who shamed them for lip syncing
Ningning and giselle are finally shining here
윈터는 진짜 딕션 장난 없는 거 같음 말할 때도 그렇고 노래할 때도 그렇고 귀에 소리를 때려 박음 근데 음색도 진ㅋ자 좋다 참나
I'm glad they're getting to sing live more, they sound amazing!
라이브 너무 잘하자낭ㅠ ㅠ
Winter 💗
I love winter's dance
Karina is proven that no need highnote to standout.
Thanks for ur videos 😭😍
今回の衣装さんどうしたんだろ…
ウィンターの服、骨格に合ってなくて太って見える…
明るい髪色だから顔の輪郭もぼやけて見えるし…
んー😶せっかくのビジュアルが…
Ningning!!!!
My Ning ning we love you~
I’m really surprised of their vocals especially Karina..!!! I love her deep and strong vocal…💕 I need more of her vocal…😍😍
Wow karina 😇🥰😍 I love them I wish I was there awe
“aEsPa DoEsN’t SiNg LiVe” 🤡
Giselle knows how to enjoy the stage much better than before