I love how Ning Ning can flex her voice so perfect. Her Darara at the beginning and at the end are different somehow and it gives a pleasant different vibe and it doesn’t sound repetitive.😍 I LOVE HER! She is such a pure diamond.
Welcome to My World is one of the best thing happened in Kpop. WTMW is real pure gem! Musicality, instrumentality, magic vocals are on the highest level!
it's actually my favorite aespa track. i love their title tracks too, but the whole vibe of wtmw is so different to the rest. feel like it got engraved into my brain lol
I've always loved NingNing's vocals, she always gives me chills. I adore Karina's vocals & Winters too (both girls can really sing, but we knew that already) but Giselle's?! I kept replaying her part over and over because it honestly shocks me how incredible she sounds and how does she not have more singing lines in their songs?! she sounds like the studio version 100%. she's so stable. It's really mind-blowing. Aespa is an all-rounder group and there's no denying that.
Haters will say that the girls is lip-syncing here. Just accept the fact that when singer sing better than the studio version doesn't mean it's not live, and there is no backing track here, just pure talent by beautiful ladies.
Ningning's voice has brought me a great touch, it can make you feel as if you are in the real world and completely driven. Her singing voice has emotions, and I can even imagine that scene when I close my eyes and listen. In addition, the song "WTMW" is very grand, and the opening of the microphone scene can better reflect this characteristic.
She is already the best vocalist of 4th gen. SM is still hiding herr true ability. Heck, we even still dont know how high she can go with the high notes. All her high notes so far is nothing for her
@@danissegomez7953 she really is. And yes they don’t let her show the totality of her talent, I’m sure she’s even more amazing that what they want us to see. She’s is so powerful and I know there is a lot of power inside her but they don’t letting her show it. But the little we see, she is Indeed the best vocalist of this generation. That’s a fact
I feel like I'm in a fantasy world. Ningning's Intro and heavenly verses I'm crying just how wonderful her vocal were and how gorgeous our maknae is especially this come back? she keeps on glowing! Winter and Karina always did great but GISELLE's LIVE Vocal!?!? I can noooot! It's as clear as glass! SM usually put lower mic volume on Giselle and Ningning but this LIVE? I'm adding this on my playlist baby. Jaw dropping, Mic drop! 😍💕💋💪🎤
원래 어떤 아이돌 무대든 다 이뻐도 특별하게 그 무대에서 이쁜 사람을 콕 찝어서 이쁘다고 감상 남기는 편인데 에스파는 진짜 4명 다 다른 느낌으로 이뻐가지고 한명을 고르지 못하겠다 카리나는 화려하고 성숙하면서 이쁘다보다는 아름답다가 어울리는 느낌이고 지젤은 언뜻보면 화려하게 생긴 핫걸인데 계속 보면 볼수록 에스파중에 가장 청초하게 생긴것 같음 윈터는 귀여운데 어찌보면 에스파중에 가장 냉하게 생긴듯 그리고 닝닝은 화려함의 극치 정말 눈이 커서 인형 같음 너무 이쁘다 다들
I can’t keep my mouth closed, their vocals are so amazing. The imaginary fairy and forest vibes in this song is too strong. They bring me straight into their fantasy world.
Ningning sounds just as rich and majestic as in the studio recording. Extremely stable vocals from all four members. Ballads are harder to sing than pop dance songs, but you can always trust the SM idols to give justice to ballads.
Their vocals are INSANE (as usual) but can we talk about the song too? I mean, this is literally the best song ever released in a while and it’s criminally underrated! I need more people to appreciate this masterpiece 😭
I think that this is not pre-recorded; this is live vocals. Ningning and Winter interchangeably sang the naevis part "dararadidada" and also "this city is so pretty when the lights on" by all of them. Or you meant "live" with something else?
Definitely one of the best stages of live vocals I've seen so far! Girlies sound so amazing like even without a backtrack it's so outstanding. Istg if anyone hates them for vocals I'm gonna whack their heads with this performance and their encores-
This is pure magic 😍I need more aespa like this. Without dancing or fancy make up. Just give them microphones an let them sing. This group it's absolutely vocal diamonds when they sing together like that❤
Развлечения![[4K] aespa - “Thirsty & Spicy” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WJMBzYraE7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] aespa - “Thirsty & Spicy” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](/img/tr.png)
![[LIVE] EVERGLOW - ZOMBIE Stage Media Showcase | E:U Sihyeon Mia Onda Aisha Yiren [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2QuqcFAJxmk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[First Stage Performance] LE SSERAFIM - Sour Grapes l @JTBC K-909 221022](/img/1.gif)
'CC' 를 클릭👆하시면 가사와 함께 무대를 즐길 수 있습니다.
We need Eng sub too
❤Wow....❤I LOOVEE YOU ❤aespa❤❤❤❤
@@boo_lan1546Learn korean
Á 😂@@boo_lan1546
NINGNING VOICE MAKES ME WANT TO LISTEN TO IT AGAIN AND AGAIN ❤️🤌
Goosebumps NingNing!
as expected your vocals never dissapoints.
No lipsync, no backtrack, just instrumental with pure vocals!
Exactly
better than studio version 😅
@@HumanBeing402frr
Actually they are just standing there showing their beauty
@@Spacewind-sb1cqbitter hater aw
닝닝 목소리 정말 sm의 보물이다
Siii
Ningning's vocal technique is really great! All member are really good at controlling their breath too so that it sounds smooth
Ning Ning vocal fit this song so much and she's enjoying the stage. Feels like I'm in heaven
이 노래 진짜 너무 좋아.. 뭔가 저 세상에 멸망이 다가오고 있는 느낌임 뭐라 설명을 못하겠는데 진짜 내 스타일
ㄹㅇㄹㅇ똑같은 기분입니다
멸망?ㅋㅋㅋ 이라곤 생각 안했지만.. 어떤 새로운 세계의 지평을 여는 듯한 이 느낌 너무 좋음.. 선공개곡으로 넘 탁월했음
ㄹㅇ ㅋㅋㅋ 어떻게 해볼 수 없는 거대한 뭔가가 오고 있고 그냥 받아들여야하는 그런 느낌적인 느낌? ㅋㅋㅋ
I agree with you and if Aespa is destruction then I want to be destroyed 100% 😂
아케인 ost같음
No one's gonna talk about how Giselle is so good in live?
Literally 🙏
Giselle is underrated. Her vocals are amazing
Her vocals are top notch it's just that SM doesn't give her the spot light she deserves
@@naimaravenshe kind of went off in thirsty, she shone the most there for me
NingNing's vocal is soulful and heavenly.. indeed a diva *\0/*
Nigning's warm and direct voice is the best thing in this theater I can't believe this girl is talented ❤🦋
I love how Ning Ning can flex her voice so perfect. Her Darara at the beginning and at the end are different somehow and it gives a pleasant different vibe and it doesn’t sound repetitive.😍 I LOVE HER! She is such a pure diamond.
이래서 내가 스엠을 좋아해…… 스엠보컬은 뭔가 독특하고 다 다른 느낌이라 듣기가 재밌고….결정적으로 엄청난자본으로 여러 다양한 컨셉의 시도를 하는데 그런 특이한 분위기가 스엠덕의심장을 뛰게함
ㄹㅇ 보컬 트레이닝이 획일화된게 아니고 개성을 살리는쪽인가뵤
ㄹㅇ 슴돌만 좋아하게 되는 이유,, 경험도 많고 돈도 많으니 할 수 있는 듯
뭘 엄청난 자본이야
장사안되서 수만이가 회사내놨는데
@@user-uq2zq1mu9x 걍 무시하셈 답도없음
ningning's vocals are insane IM OBSESSSSSED I NEED TO HEAR MORE OF HERRRR
Ningning is a beautiful fairy with a heaven voice
If this is 100% live then I’m so impressed with ALL of them! Like wow they can SING! Ningning is so good like she sounds exactly like the recording.
@@dbltrbl do you have the link of it? Cant seem to find it on this channel.
it really seems live!
이노래는 닝이 보컬이 많은 이유가 있다… 몽환적인느낌 젤 잘 살려줌ㅠㅠ
ㄹㅇ 제스쳐까지 완벽함
에스파는 노래마다 잘 어울리는 보컬에게 파트 더 줘서 좋음… 스파이시는 윈터 파트가 많은데 이 곡은 닝이 파트가 많은 것도 그렇고 실력이 받쳐 주니까 음색 어울리는 대로 파트 짜는 듯
몽환적인 느낌은 디렉터가 녹음을 잘한거
@@user-uc6df7jd2 알겠어~ㅋ
@@user-wb9ex8sb3h녹음 몰라여?
Ningning’s vocal is so angelic and beautiful. My ears are like in heaven
Welcome to My World is one of the best thing happened in Kpop. WTMW is real pure gem! Musicality, instrumentality, magic vocals are on the highest level!
it's actually my favorite aespa track. i love their title tracks too, but the whole vibe of wtmw is so different to the rest. feel like it got engraved into my brain lol
only show how really this group is DONE... vocal gapp wider than ocean wat the point just let those 2 go SOLO let the other 2 sell asss
1:17 닝닝이 보컬폼 미쳤다 닝닝만의 몽환적인 음색이 노래랑 잘어울리는 것 같아서 개인적으로 제일 좋아하는 부분 ㅜㅜ
Ningning voice is so soothing😭😭!! Ningning lets keep moving! We're here for you❤
THEIR VOCALS?! Truly a vocal group!
This sounds even better than the audio
Yesssssss
@@lithitrabu3399 yepppp
They are vocal and visual ❤
@@lithitrabu3399 wait is this live???
Winter cute baby face and her wonderful live vocals 🥹💕
yall need to stop infantilizing her she’s a grown ass 22 year old woman.
@@tsuki2258 here you go😂
it's always hilarious for me when we baby Winter and then the replies say "she's a grown ah woman" 😭
@@tsuki2258why do y’all never let us praise winter tf??
@@tsuki2258 yall are chronically online. Saying that someone has a baby face does not necessarily mean people are infantilizing.
I've always loved NingNing's vocals, she always gives me chills. I adore Karina's vocals & Winters too (both girls can really sing, but we knew that already) but Giselle's?! I kept replaying her part over and over because it honestly shocks me how incredible she sounds and how does she not have more singing lines in their songs?! she sounds like the studio version 100%. she's so stable. It's really mind-blowing. Aespa is an all-rounder group and there's no denying that.
Haters will say that the girls is lip-syncing here. Just accept the fact that when singer sing better than the studio version doesn't mean it's not live, and there is no backing track here, just pure talent by beautiful ladies.
NingNing slayed it but I love when all of them harmonizing at the end of the song. So calm and cool
Winter and Ningning looks so beautiful and attractive
Their vocal is too perfect and heavenly
Their visual is overflowing
I agree with u
Their live vocals are too great
Their mic is surely on but the backtrack is so loud we can barely hear their live vocals
@@siyeonwife6810 Sorry but i didn't hear any backtrack i mean i hear it RAW.
@@siyeonwife6810 There's no backtrack you better shut up
Ningning's voice has brought me a great touch, it can make you feel as if you are in the real world and completely driven. Her singing voice has emotions, and I can even imagine that scene when I close my eyes and listen. In addition, the song "WTMW" is very grand, and the opening of the microphone scene can better reflect this characteristic.
케이팝의 한 획을 그을 명곡이다... 아이돌이 얼마나 피곤한 직업인줄 알면서도 한번쯤은 이렇게 멋있는 사운드, 멋있는 무대의 주인공이 되어보고 싶기도 하네. 하지만 감상자로서도 충분히 행복한 곡이다.
NINGNING IS REALLY THEE 4TH GEN VOCALIST SHE'S SUCH A DIVA EVERYTHING ABOUT HER IS SO PERFECT 🥺🤍
Ningning is killing me. How can she be better and better in every comeback ? Her voice gives me chills she’s from royalty 😭 she’s breathtaking
She is already the best vocalist of 4th gen. SM is still hiding herr true ability. Heck, we even still dont know how high she can go with the high notes.
All her high notes so far is nothing for her
@@danissegomez7953 fr 😭
@@danissegomez7953 she really is. And yes they don’t let her show the totality of her talent, I’m sure she’s even more amazing that what they want us to see. She’s is so powerful and I know there is a lot of power inside her but they don’t letting her show it. But the little we see, she is Indeed the best vocalist of this generation. That’s a fact
FOR REAL, SHE SOUND SO HEAVENLY
Yeahhh i remember when winter said ningning used to sing listen by beyonce which is really high note.. SM please give ningning more!
People who doubt Aespa’s singing are funny. One thing SM never fails is their groups vocals.
I feel like I'm in a fantasy world. Ningning's Intro and heavenly verses I'm crying just how wonderful her vocal were and how gorgeous our maknae is especially this come back? she keeps on glowing! Winter and Karina always did great but GISELLE's LIVE Vocal!?!? I can noooot! It's as clear as glass! SM usually put lower mic volume on Giselle and Ningning but this LIVE? I'm adding this on my playlist baby. Jaw dropping, Mic drop! 😍💕💋💪🎤
Ningning's intro, the chorus, her second verse part, everything from her wow just wow her voice is sending me to paradise.
FOR REAL
She is UNBELIEVABLEEEE and breathtaking
Yesss!!!
THEIR VOCALS NEVER FAIL TO GIVE ME GOOSEBUMPS! MY GIRLS ARE SO TALENTED 😭
원래 어떤 아이돌 무대든 다 이뻐도 특별하게 그 무대에서 이쁜 사람을 콕 찝어서 이쁘다고 감상 남기는 편인데 에스파는 진짜 4명 다 다른 느낌으로 이뻐가지고 한명을 고르지 못하겠다 카리나는 화려하고 성숙하면서 이쁘다보다는 아름답다가 어울리는 느낌이고 지젤은 언뜻보면 화려하게 생긴 핫걸인데 계속 보면 볼수록 에스파중에 가장 청초하게 생긴것 같음 윈터는 귀여운데 어찌보면 에스파중에 가장 냉하게 생긴듯 그리고 닝닝은 화려함의 극치 정말 눈이 커서 인형 같음 너무 이쁘다 다들
닝닝 진짜 바다같다 너무좋음
Ningning owns this song, her vocal collours shines do much in this song
Ningning vocals. Their vocals. Winter, Karina, Giselle OMG. Stan talents
닝닝 음색 무엇ㄷㄷㄷ 와 이렇게 좋았다고??
See how Ning Ning so confident to sing in this songgggg yesss
NINGNING'S VOICE IS VERY IMPRESSIVE AND BELONG, IS SHE FROM HEAVEN HOW IS THERE A GIRL WITH THAT BEAUTIFUL VOICE
I can’t keep my mouth closed, their vocals are so amazing. The imaginary fairy and forest vibes in this song is too strong. They bring me straight into their fantasy world.
1:28 I'm addicted to your voices aeri-ya
I got goosebumps hearing Ningning's voice
닝닝 라이브 대박이다 ... ㄷㄷ 여태 들어본 여자아이돌중 원탑인 듯
Ningning's heavenly vocal. WTMW is her song. Ningning proved why she's the main vocalist.
Their live vocal is another level !!! 4 Main Vocal
ningning sounds extra magical in this song
이노래 진짜 이번앨범 첫트랙인게 신의한수야.... 웅장해짐
웅장뜻모름?
에스파 여덕줌마들 진짜 무식하구나
위에 도태남 검거
@@user-dd9ry1yk2i 나이먹고 결혼못하고 아이돌하녀짓하는 아줌마 검거
@@user-uc6df7jd2님...한테서 진짜 쭘내나요
their vocal is insane🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️
Ningning sounds just as rich and majestic as in the studio recording. Extremely stable vocals from all four members. Ballads are harder to sing than pop dance songs, but you can always trust the SM idols to give justice to ballads.
Ning's vocals is a mixture of Bada and Taeyeon. She has similar tone to Bada but has that rich , whole and strong tone of Taeyeon❤❤❤
I can't describe how beautiful ningning voice is, so angelic, beautiful, heavenly....!!😭✨✨
2:59 this adlibs was heaven
I can't get enough of Giselle's angelic and relaxing vocal
She gives everything to prove people that they were wrong and that she is *talented* ! I love her
ISN'T THIS A LIVE VOCAL?
WoW they're a truly NEXT LEVEL!
100% live
Singing live or no, people will still call them lipsing. because their voices are good and stable. people are reluctant to admit it
Yep pure live. We were already informed about this from knetz who attended the show before this thing release
이 무대 계속 생각나서 보게 됨... 라이브도 너무 잘하고 무대랑 코디가 게임 캐릭터 선택창 같은 느낌임 노래 자체도 딱 현실에서 판타지 세계로 넘어가기 전의 오묘한 분위기... 너무 좋음
Wow. I really love Ningning's voice. Main vocalist indeed.
Their vocals are INSANE (as usual) but can we talk about the song too? I mean, this is literally the best song ever released in a while and it’s criminally underrated! I need more people to appreciate this masterpiece 😭
the best vocals, the best visuals, the best music for our younger generation, this song is for all of you, look at them, goddesses with message
ningning... I have no words to describe your voice. so angelic. I love you.
Ning ning when live is always totality, she's very serious and enthusias.. Give hers more live mic on
this is too good~ my ear is 🤰!!! Ningning!~!!!!! that vocal~!! should flex more!
Giselle so good~! Karina so good~!!! Winter so good~!!
Truly the 4th Gen Vocal Queens.. ❤
Ningning has a natural gesture that makes this song very beautiful
얘들아 광야 버리지 말아주라..ㅠㅜㅠ나 sf아이돌 컨셉 꽤 좋아했나봐..몽환적이고 신비롭고 미래적이야..에스파 홧팅
광야 안버렸어여....근데 컨셉바꿀때마다 광야 버리네 마네
일희일비하는건 좀 아닌거같네여
hold on tight도 그렇고 사이버펑크 컨셉 안버림 ㅋㅋ 이걸 에스파 아니면 누가하냐
이번엔 현실세계로 온 컨셉이라니까 다음이나 다다음 앨범은 다시 광야 가지 않을까,,,ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
광스라이팅 제대로 당해버리다
@@user-xw2n9yss 이번 앨범 내용이 ae들이 리얼월드로 넘어온거임 ㅠㅠㅠ
I’m so proud of Giselle. Her vocal is so mesmerising!
Omg, SM please give us more of this from your artists. We want to hear them live ok? Perfect stage.
I think that this is not pre-recorded; this is live vocals. Ningning and Winter interchangeably sang the naevis part "dararadidada" and also "this city is so pretty when the lights on" by all of them. Or you meant "live" with something else?
That person is asking for SM to give us more live performances I think 😅
@@jodypratamapongtiku1827 they didn't imply this stage wasn't live, read the comment again
this was live man people are used to voice cracks and off key live that they think its lipsync
@@ArtwithPRAGYA nobody said this was not live??
이번앨범 제일 최애곡.. 무슨 애니ost 같음 진짜
닝닝 보컬인 이유가 있구나 ㅜ
Ningning slayed this stage ❤❤❤
Ningning’s vocal is crazy
몽환적이고 디스토피아,판타지 느낌 .. 진짜 좋네
Giselle is so charismatic! Even in this stage which doesn't really allow much movements and crowd engagement.
Woaaaaaaa.... this song is soooooo goood in live stage!!
Ningning ddadadaa made my heart achesss! Omg!! Loveee this song!!❤❤🎉🎉
ningning's voice is perfection
never understood people that say that aespa can't sing...like cmon ya'll they're still a group from sm
멜로디에 서사가.... 진심 듣기만 해도 영화 한 편 뚝딱임 뮤비도 너무 신비로움 ㅠㅠ 선명한 몽환 그 자체
I like Giselle's voice, its so addictive
The people who watched this live said this has no backtrack and they sound soooo good whoa ❤
1:03 Giselle’s voice in this part is so satisfying ✨🌙
다들 라이브 너무 좋은데 닝닝이는 제스쳐마저 너무 자연스러워서 더 집중하게 된다
Ningning's vocals. She's in her elements fr
The shortest training Giselle, omg she sound exactly like the recording one 🔥 our vocal queens, Aespa
Definitely one of the best stages of live vocals I've seen so far! Girlies sound so amazing like even without a backtrack it's so outstanding. Istg if anyone hates them for vocals I'm gonna whack their heads with this performance and their encores-
Wtf...aespa is insane. That vocal live. They really are an SM group. And I'm a proud MY.
I love you 4. ❤
OMG NING’S VOCAL 😭❤️
닝닝 노래 정말 잘한다 ❤️🔥❤️🔥 공주 ㅠㅠ
Omg... Live singing of Welcome to my World song was so special and they sang beautifully especially Ningning vocals. So proud of Aespa
I love Giselle's vocals so much. Her voice is so beautiful and sweet. She is not only an amazing rapper but also an amazing vocalist!
Me too. She is so talented! 😭
Me too
OBSESSED💜
Me too ❤️
Because she is originaly a best vocalist but she can be an amazing rapper.. ❤️🔥
When I listen their songs I'm always surprised. Why Winter voice is suits all aespa songs.
Winter's voice is very versatile! She can be soft & relaxing or intense and powerful. + her vocal growls and high notes 😩 hits the spot
Agree😩👍❤
Ning ning angelic voices... Beautifull voice.. Proud of you
천사가 아니면 말이 안됨... 목소리도... 미모도... 그냥 존재 자체가 엔젤 4명... 에스파... 짱스파... 갓스파...
Omg Ningning voice is so soulful 😊❤
This is pure magic 😍I need more aespa like this. Without dancing or fancy make up. Just give them microphones an let them sing. This group it's absolutely vocal diamonds when they sing together like that❤
NINGNING VOCAL IS SOOOOO INCREDIBLE
So glad NingNing is getting the positive recognition she deserves
Giselle’s voice is so on point here!!! 😮❤
I live for Ningning's vocals 😭 like no doubt, this girl is the top vocalist of her generation!
This song was so underrated😢
wow Ning Ning, her voice is pretty amazing