@@double.eainoo7020 ? 질책한 게 아닙니다. 외국인 분들도 easpa 분들을 좋아해주시는 것도 물론 팬 입장으로선 감사하지만 근래에 easpa 영상엔 외국어 댓글이 배댓이 된 적을 몇 번 봐 왔던지라 그렇게 말한 겁니다. 어느 부분에서 오해하신 건지 모르겠지만 나쁜 의도가 없었습니다. 그리고 한국어 잘 못 하셔도 다 알아들으니 걱정 안 하셔도 됩니다.
them teasing karina about her aegyo lmfao and karina spitting facts when she said ningning is like their unnie in photoshoots because our maknae always slays!
Giselle admitting she takes the longest to learn choreo, but at the same time stated that she had the shortest training time is honestly everything. Also Karina being the sweetest leader saying that Giselle is the most improved member.
Isn’t that called giving excuses tho? There r trainees with short training periods who r excellent dancers n those with longer periods who aren’t as much
@@mimiaahh yeah there are idols who also trained for a short period of time but it's because TRAINING is part of becoming an idol. Maybe those idols already have a skill in dancing. While, giselle didn't really have enough experience in dancing since she was a choir member. She became an idol because she wants to perform and be a singer. She's not making excuses. She's being honest and we love her for that.
@@mimiaahh Those idols may have attended 'performing arts school' or a 'dance academy' which still counts as an experience to enhance dance skills. Whereas Giselle attended an International (Catholic) School, so you can't really compare them since they are from different backgrounds. She acknowledges she's not the best when it comes to dancing, but at least she's trying to improve herself.
@@nyz-qv2cp not rly. There’s one idol who debuted after training for 2 years at 15 n he has no dancing or musical background n when to an ordinary middle school but is at the level of a main dancer n main vocalist. Similarly he has a member in the group who trained for longer but is worse at dancing.
It's sweet that Karina reassured Giselle that she got better and improved. SM released their winter album just now and Giselle took part in writing lyrics. You're doing great, Gigi
My introvert self aspire to be as extrovert as Ningning. she can't stand laying down on a bed, spontaneous (just like Winter said), and knows the best restaurant in Seoul lol. She is also confident in doing poses during photoshoot. She looks like a friendly and easy going girl. Maybe that's why the Wayv and Dream members are friendly with her.
i like how giselle is self-aware and isn't ashamed to voice out her weaknesses. she knows where she lacks and works hard to improve it. you're doing well giselle!!
i really think her dancing skill is what puts off their performance, but then it makes sense cause she had the shortest training period in sm i think.. (8mos) i know she have lots of years to improve ! i’m excited for that and for aespa’s general growth as well 🥺 fighting my precious girls
Giselle may have longer time learning their choreo, but she slays every time she performs and that’s a sign of how hard working she is. Fighting, Aespa!!
아직 초반 보고 있는데 조곤조곤한 asmr 너무 좋다...들으면서 자고 싶다..팅글 쩐다..다들 의상 메이크업도 너무 찰떡이다....넘 예쁘다..닝닝도 말투 너무 귀엽고 asmr잘한다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 질문에 asmr 로 답하는 포맷도 좋고 질문들도 신선하고 재밌게 잘 짠 듯!
4:21 yes Karina . 100% agree with you. Model Ningning slay every photoshoot. Also her pic for sns update are really beautiful. She does know how to pose.
So no one's gonna talk about how gorgeous and cute Ningning is even her personality is just really fun for some reason I am always looking forward to what she is going to say she is just so genuine and unpredictable but also the most caring and sensitive about the people around her. For me she just instantly lights up every place she goes to 🥺🖤
Okay nobody's talking about Ning's soothing voice. Ning's soothing voice. That's it, that's the comment. Lels but I also wanna say how fun this video was I was smiling the whole timeeee, again listening to Aespa's stories and interviews is so satisfyingggg
@@youknowme8086 I gotchu fam. EQ is for "emotional intelligence." Having a high EQ means you can can read other people's emotions well, use your own feelings in production/effective ways, and high empathy. A good leader will have a high EQ. You can also say that people with high EQ can "read the room/atmosphere" really well.
Omg, Karina is very good at leading Aespa. She praises her members, kind to her members, pays attention to her members, and also give a good example for her members. I just realized, why they (Winter, Ning Ning and Giselle) have chosen karina as leader.
I love that Giselle isn’t discouraged by hate and is always trying to improve! She will continue to become more powerful as time goes on, I just know it!💖
이 영상에서 닝닝 스타일링이랑 헤어 너무 예뻐서 젤 예쁘다.. 퍼컬에 딱 맞게 해줬나보다 에스파 사이 좋아보임 ㅜㅜ 넘 좋다
1:09 지젤 여기 열심히 하겠습니다! 하는거 너무 귀엽다..ㅠㅠ 지젤 자꾸 춤으로 논란돼서 속상했는데 기죽지 않고 더 열심히 하겠다고 해줘서 고마울 따름이다..ㅠㅠ 지젤깅 최고야
마자요ㅠㅠ
천천히 늘어서 잘하고있음
잘했음
지젤 귀엽고 인상도 좋고 이쁘고 최고
@@eunjukim3917 ㅇㅈ
이 영상에서 닝닝이가 왤케 잘생겼지 원래 잘생겼는데 더 잘생겨보임 금발 진짜 너무 잘 어울려 이 영상 에스파 다 잘생김
걍이쁜데 잘샐긴건뭐야...
잘생겼다 = 외모 품평 중
@@무무-d5b 예쁘다든 잘생겼다든 둘다 품평 아닌가 무슨의도로 말한건지…
@@무무-d5b 니기미
여자한테 잘생겼다고 하면 그.. 진짜 이해 안 되고 레즈거나 레즈물 좋아하는 사람 같아보인다 진짜
우리 닝닝이 왤케 애어른같지ㅠㅠ 겉은 귀요미아기고양이여도 속은 진짜 단단한….ㅠ 모르겟고 예뻐 닝아
역시 짱스파,,, 다들 사이 너무 좋구나,,, 케미 폭발에 미모도 같이 폭발,,,, 다들 너무 예뻐
@⏪[지현] 연습섕 R몸 방송 저장소 봇 꺼져
사이는 솔직히 그닥
팀케미는 없음
@@user-uc6df7jd2 간판즈 윈터,카리나
@@user-uc6df7jd2 다들 날카롭게 생겨서 팬아니면 그런거 잘 모름 ㅋㅋ 순덕들도 카리나 성격 잘모름.
@@user-uc6df7jd2 팀케미가 없다니..? 일단 윈터, 카리나에서 정리 가능한데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
01:08 zl젤언니 성격 너무 좋다 ...ㅠ 고마워..어흑 이러는 것도 너무 귀엽고 뻘하게 웃기다 ㅠㅠㅠ 지젤은 진짜 스며드는 게 매력인듯. 묘하게 중독있어
?
원터 좋아할수도 있지 근데 그건 너무 개인 생각이니까.... ㅋㅋ 이런곳에 말하는건 좀;;
@yu r 엥… 진짜 그건 어디 피셜인가요?? 뇌피셜…?????? 애초에 몇년전부터 스엠은 걸그룹 준비했는데요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@yu r ?? 무슨 소리임 엔시티가 2년전에 문특 에서 요즘에 이수만 선생님이 AI 굉장히 좋아한다고 말한적 있는데 애초에 그룹 으로 만드려고 했음
@yu r?
닝닝 원래도 예쁜거 알았는데 이 영상에 특히 더 예쁘게 나온 것 같다,,,특히 피부 되게 좋아보임
이 영상 닝닝 너무 예쁘다 제일 예쁜 듯
이 인터뷰 너무 귀엽고 네명 모두의 매력이 담긴듯 바자 고마워용ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ넷다 각기 다른 매력으로 최곤데 합쳤을때 더 좋기까지함ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ이런데 어떻게 안좋아할수가 있겠어ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
부모님께 잘하세요
@@user-dc4br6ob7e 너나잘행~
외국인 댓글이 베댓일 줄 알았는데 한글 있으니까 반갑네
@@돈내려온다 외국인들은 aespa를 좋아하니 걱정마세요 한국어도 잘 못해서 미안해요
@@double.eainoo7020 ? 질책한 게 아닙니다. 외국인 분들도 easpa 분들을 좋아해주시는 것도 물론 팬 입장으로선 감사하지만 근래에 easpa 영상엔 외국어 댓글이 배댓이 된 적을 몇 번 봐 왔던지라 그렇게 말한 겁니다. 어느 부분에서 오해하신 건지 모르겠지만 나쁜 의도가 없었습니다. 그리고 한국어 잘 못 하셔도 다 알아들으니 걱정 안 하셔도 됩니다.
닝닝 무슨일이야.. 왤케 이뻐 헤어스타일 하고 메이크업하고 옷 색깔 완전 찰떡인데.. 대박이다 진짜 대존녜
M
중 국 인
@ㅇㅇ 중국인이라고 무조건 나쁘건 아니지 않아요? 예쁘기만 하구만
@@ljaehyeon 不至于不至于,中韩一家亲
@@ljaehyeon 착한 중국인 개많음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 중국 인구가 많아서 그렇지 내가 일본 유학 갔을때 결국 잘해주고 친절하고 친해진 애들은 다 중국인들 이였음 뭐 일본인들 중에서도 착한 사람들이 있겠지만
젤이 진짜 귀엽다 노력하는거 느껴지고 ㄹㅇ 끼쟁이 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
닝닝이 서치 저렇게 많이 하는데 악플 달지 마라 진짜 ㅠ 노래도 잘하고 춤도 잘하는데
쫭 꼴 라
닝이 미모 미쳤다.....너모 예뻐..
이번에 눈에 제일 뛰는 멤버는 닝닝.. 카키색 착장이랑 지금 머리색 너무 잘 어울린다.. 눈물 줄줄 ㅜㅜㅜ 중단발 해도 이쁘겠네
카리나 우아진거 봐... 흑발에 흰색 셋업... 어디 부잣집 똑순이 딸래미 같네... 어디 기업 하나 물려 받을것같음
카리나 목소리도 좋다....에스파들 계속 들으려고 귀 대고 뒤에서 쫑알쫑알 얘기하는거 귀여움ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 카리나 목소리 천사 그 자체
닝닝 뭔데 이리 귀여운거야
애들 어쩜 이렇게 다 하나같이 잘생겼을까,,,
성형ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
왜 무플이셔요ㅠ 좋아요 많은데🥲
병원에서 해준거자나
All of them are plastic surgery except ningning
난 수술해도 저렇게 안될듯 ㅜㅜ 이잉 예뻐 스파들
오늘 닝닝 진짜이쁘다ㅏ,,머리귀뒤로꽂은게 진짜잘어울려요
김윈터 분명히 어두운 메이크업에 의상을 입었는데 왜이렇게 귀여운거야
귀여움을 숨길 수가 없네 ㅠㅠ 너무 기여워 엉엉엉 😭
닝이줘 너무 말랑말랑하게 대답하구 진짜 너무 귀여워 어떡해 나…
아 4명다 졸귀네 진짜 미쳤다 ㅋㅋㅋ
사이도 너무 좋아보여서 너무 좋고
아빠미소 지으면서 계속 봤네 ㅋㅋ
닝닝이 스무번에서 스물번 너무 귀여워 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 에스파 너무너무 사랑해❤️❤️❤️ 드디어 우리스파 asmr도 해보네 축하해🥳 이 영상 너무너무 중독돼 ㅋㅋㅋ
카리나는 언제봐도 예쁘다💗💗💖
이팀은뭔가...서로가서로를 되게 귀여워하는 우쭈쭈~ 이런분위기네 좋다이런거♥
카리나 진짜 보면 볼수록 매력 있다..
닝닝 너무 예쁘고 귀엽다💓
어떻게 저렇게 합을 맞추신거죠 수만선생님 정말 감사합니다 우리 에스파 만들어주셔서 …빠질게없는 조합입니다 ㅠㅠ
4명 서로 엄청 칭찬해줘서 보기좋다ㅎㅎ
GISELLE PRETTY AS ALWAYS!!
카리나로 입덕했다가 윈터에 홀렸다가 닝닝이 귀여움에 빠지는 듯. 지젤은 영어할 때 너무 멋있음
4:07 닝이 놀란표정 너무 귀여워 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 윈터도 닝닝이 리액션 잘해준다고 했었는데
닝닝 이번 화장 개잘어울린다 미안해 표현이 저렴해서... 이번 화보 진짜 넘 좋음 ㅜ
I love how honest and transparent they are, it’s refreshing
Dm
닝닝이 디게 언니들한테 사랑받구나😍
멤버들 케미 환장한다ㅋㅋㅋ지금까지 본 걸그룹 중에 가장 재밌고 케미 잘 맞는듯😎
에스파분들 올해 2021년에도 수고 많으셨고 내년에도 열심히 활동해주시길 바랄게요!!에스파 화이팅👍👍
예쁜 애들이 친한 거 보니까 걍 너무 좋다..... 에스파 최고야.....
I love Giselle's positivity. She's cute and witty in her own way.
we have the same taste
That’s why I love her ^^~
🥰
0:32
연예인들한테 아무 이유없이
악플달지말아야함 ㄹㅇ
forever (약속) 같은 노래도 너무 좋으니 타이틀말고 수록곡으로 계속 같이 앨범내주세요 에스파 화이팅! 닝닝이 쨔유~♡
ㅜ 지젤 존나 귀엽다 ㅜㅜ 부담스럽지 않게 중독적인 포인트들이 있어 사람이 ... 휴 ㅜ 곰마워ㅠ0ㅠ 하는 거 누가 쇼츠로 만들어주세요...
이어폰을 끼고 들어도 볼륨을 최대로 해야 목소리가 잘들린다구 ㅋㅋ 진짜 이런 컨텐츠들 너무 좋아ㅠㅠ 애들 너무 귀엽구 이쁘고 아름답고 지들끼리 다 하넼ㅋㅋ 사랑해 우리 애기들❤❤
그 정도면 보청기 사용을 권장드립니다
NINGNING is so natural. I love that she just enjoy the moment with her unnies.
karina in white looks so ethereal
아니 근데 이런 콘텐츠 진짜 재밌음 완전 초집중해서 봄
닝닝 귀엽다ㅠㅠ 노래방 갔다가 오리배 타고 뭐냐고ㅋㅋ 존귀ㅠ
1:06 마이 지젤... 항상 너무너무 잘 하고 있어요... 성장하는 모습 보이는 것도 너무 이쁘고... 평생 에스파 해주기...💕💕
them teasing karina about her aegyo lmfao and karina spitting facts when she said ningning is like their unnie in photoshoots because our maknae always slays!
SM Maknae always slay...
And always be Maknae on top
닝깅이 미모 뭐야,,, 눈부셔,,,
카리나님 눈빛자체에서 멤버들을 향한 애정이 보이네요. 완전 따뜻한 사람이랄까
인성 짱 좋아보여요...
@@s.h6430 맞아요. 완전 스윗하세요
지젤 저 날 헤메스 미쳤다 너무 예쁘고 잘어울려.. 딴 사람인줄 못알아봤어 드디어 찰떡스타일링 찾았다
karina saying that giselle grew the most after giselle saying she’s the worst at learning dances MY SOFT KARISELLE HEART
She really is the sweetest leader 😭😭❤🥺
왜 이렇게 미소가 떠나질 않냐..? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 역시 4명다 너무 좋아
ㅎㅎㅎ 닝닝이랑 하루 같이 놀아보고 싶네요.
그녀의 즉흥성이 어디까지 갈 수 있을지 너무 궁금해, 궁금해 미치겠어~
지젤 귀엽다. 갈수록 연예인 포션이 올라가네요.
닝닝은 언제봐도 귀엽고 예쁘다💞💗💖💖
아 애기들 소근소근하는거 왜 이렇게 귀여운지 몰라..ㅠㅠ
닝이줘 자꾸 고양이 소리 내는거 너무너무 귀여워ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
멤버 전원이 다 예쁘고 귀여운 그룹 볼때마다 익숙한 매력과 새로운 매력이 공존쓰해서 빠져나올 수가 없다 그러기도 싫고 🤣🥰
Giselle admitting she takes the longest to learn choreo, but at the same time stated that she had the shortest training time is honestly everything. Also Karina being the sweetest leader saying that Giselle is the most improved member.
Isn’t that called giving excuses tho? There r trainees with short training periods who r excellent dancers n those with longer periods who aren’t as much
@@mimiaahh yeah there are idols who also trained for a short period of time but it's because TRAINING is part of becoming an idol. Maybe those idols already have a skill in dancing. While, giselle didn't really have enough experience in dancing since she was a choir member. She became an idol because she wants to perform and be a singer. She's not making excuses. She's being honest and we love her for that.
@@mimiaahh Those idols may have attended 'performing arts school' or a 'dance academy' which still counts as an experience to enhance dance skills. Whereas Giselle attended an International (Catholic) School, so you can't really compare them since they are from different backgrounds. She acknowledges she's not the best when it comes to dancing, but at least she's trying to improve herself.
@@nyz-qv2cp not rly. There’s one idol who debuted after training for 2 years at 15 n he has no dancing or musical background n when to an ordinary middle school but is at the level of a main dancer n main vocalist. Similarly he has a member in the group who trained for longer but is worse at dancing.
@@mimiaahh and giselle only trained for 9 months. Besides, why are you comparing them?
에스파는 확실히 다른 걸그룹보다 관계성맛집이야~ 진심으로 서로 챙겨주는게 참 보기 좋음~
진짜 이번 인터뷰 너무 재밌다 다들 넘 귀엽구 ㅠㅠㅠ
닝깅이 진짜 안광이 맑고 또렷해서 너무 눈길이 간다.. 눈망울 너무너무너무 예뽀....
민정아 나 너 너무 조아해
니 왜 반말하는데
너보다 내가 먼저 조아했다
민정아 두철이보다 내가 더 조아한다
진짜 장난들 치지마시고 윈터누나 건들지 마세요
윈터누나는 님들 싫대요
민정아 나 너 너무 사라애
다 예쁜데 오늘 닝이 레전드다❤❤ 너모 예삐야 닝이줘!!
Our Gisselle willing to improve y'all stop bashing her for her dance skills .. just give her more time she will get better and better each day 🌙❤️
Yeah I know, she's trying her best and improving so much but some people just can't see that
닝닝 너무 애기 같아ㅠㅠ
It's sweet that Karina reassured Giselle that she got better and improved. SM released their winter album just now and Giselle took part in writing lyrics. You're doing great, Gigi
Oh really? Where is the info?
She took part in writing lyrics?
Really? I m so happy 😭😭
She is co-lyricist for ZOO with other sm artists for the collab probably the rap part.
@@PrinceInShadow I listen Zoo 🐘🐼🐯 that's a bop 🔥🔥
@@agony3053 you can see it in the credits on spotify :)
My introvert self aspire to be as extrovert as Ningning. she can't stand laying down on a bed, spontaneous (just like Winter said), and knows the best restaurant in Seoul lol. She is also confident in doing poses during photoshoot. She looks like a friendly and easy going girl. Maybe that's why the Wayv and Dream members are friendly with her.
so sweet of karina to compliment/praise giselle after she answered that she's the slowest to learn choreo. you're doing well, giselle!
항상 응원하고있습니다 앞으로도 좋은노래 이런 프로젝트 항상 만들어주세요 ^^
i like how giselle is self-aware and isn't ashamed to voice out her weaknesses. she knows where she lacks and works hard to improve it. you're doing well giselle!!
i really think her dancing skill is what puts off their performance, but then it makes sense cause she had the shortest training period in sm i think.. (8mos) i know she have lots of years to improve ! i’m excited for that and for aespa’s general growth as well 🥺 fighting my precious girls
@@haruhi2815 don't lie it's not that noticeable but go off
@@haruhi2815 who the hell cares, they all as a group do well , u like dancing so much and care about every detail go watch a dance crew
Yeah that's I loved Giselle we all know we have lacking but we focus on it and keep improving 😘😘
@@deadinside-jk It definitely is, we don't need to pretend otherwise. However you can tell she's improving at a very rapid pace.
지젤 진짜 미쳣나 개이쁘네
닝닝 너무 예뻐ㅠㅠ
Giselle may have longer time learning their choreo, but she slays every time she performs and that’s a sign of how hard working she is. Fighting, Aespa!!
@Snuck Pea lol that’s your little opinion “thank u very much”
aeri is the best, i know she will get better and better
ㅔ3
카리나 칭찬은 일부러 잘 들리게 크게 말해주는거 쏘스윗 ❤️
닝닝 웜톤의 정석이다...금발에 카키 찰떡이다
ningning is such a VIBE i love her
아직 초반 보고 있는데 조곤조곤한 asmr 너무 좋다...들으면서 자고 싶다..팅글 쩐다..다들 의상 메이크업도 너무 찰떡이다....넘 예쁘다..닝닝도 말투 너무 귀엽고 asmr잘한다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그리고 질문에 asmr 로 답하는 포맷도 좋고 질문들도 신선하고 재밌게 잘 짠 듯!
4:21 yes Karina . 100% agree with you. Model Ningning slay every photoshoot.
Also her pic for sns update are really beautiful. She does know how to pose.
So no one's gonna talk about how gorgeous and cute Ningning is even her personality is just really fun for some reason I am always looking forward to what she is going to say she is just so genuine and unpredictable but also the most caring and sensitive about the people around her. For me she just instantly lights up every place she goes to 🥺🖤
Giselle in this styling and outfit is just chef's kiss! She's legit looking like a doll or an anime character, don't worry GiGi you're improving
She is!!!! Omg!! GISELLE MANGA GURL
Okay nobody's talking about Ning's soothing voice. Ning's soothing voice. That's it, that's the comment.
Lels but I also wanna say how fun this video was I was smiling the whole timeeee, again listening to Aespa's stories and interviews is so satisfyingggg
i can't handle winter's cuteness, she's naturally cute wtf.
cool and cute
Yep Winter is really cute 🥰
닝닝 왤케 이뻐…
지젤 닝닝 인정 진짜 좋아하네 ㅋㅋㅋ
이영상하나만 봐도 애들 다 착한게 보이네 매력둥이들같으니라고 입덕부정기가 위험하다..
오늘 민정이 너무 귀엽다 진짜 🥺
지젤 진짜 너무 예쁘더..
Karina is so sweet toward everyone especially her members, what a good leader, Im sure her EQ is very high
What does it have to do with her being a good leader. Genuine question cause I just know IQ not EQ
@@youknowme8086 I gotchu fam. EQ is for "emotional intelligence." Having a high EQ means you can can read other people's emotions well, use your own feelings in production/effective ways, and high empathy. A good leader will have a high EQ. You can also say that people with high EQ can "read the room/atmosphere" really well.
근데 진짜 찐으로 친해 보여서 넘 조아ㅏ
닝닝 너무 사랑스러워 기여워어어억
닝닝 요즘 미쳤네 미모 세상 귀여움 혼자 독차지했네 햄스터같다
Omg, Karina is very good at leading Aespa. She praises her members, kind to her members, pays attention to her members, and also give a good example for her members. I just realized, why they (Winter, Ning Ning and Giselle) have chosen karina as leader.
fr she's such a loving and reliable leader 😌
지제리 누나 말이 맞지 리나 누나 애교 엄청 귀엽지 요즘 점점 빠져들고있자나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 세상 졸귀탱탱구리
닝닝님 날이 갈수록 더 예뻐지시네요!!😎
I love that Giselle isn’t discouraged by hate and is always trying to improve! She will continue to become more powerful as time goes on, I just know it!💖
Karina is so beautiful🖤
닝닝 넘 귀여워,,,, 다들 매력이 돋보여서 좋다
지젤 개섹시하다...블랙미쳐 윈터도 블랙+생머리 찰떡이다
아...근데 닝닝이 괜찮으려나 자기이름 많이 검색한다는데 욕이 너무 많아서..뭔가 맴찢이네