American School Tries to Ban Manga For STUPID Reasons

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @LorenzoF7
    @LorenzoF7 Год назад +1749

    I don't know what's funnier, the fact that its Assassination Classroom that's being referenced, or the fact that its a Floridian school that is receiving the complaints...

    • @Paul20661
      @Paul20661 Год назад +12

      XD

    • @requiemforameme1
      @requiemforameme1 Год назад +29

      Assassination Classroom: Open Carry Boogaloo

    • @fro5ty208
      @fro5ty208 Год назад +42

      Yeah cause my school in Florida, has berserk volumes.
      It is a highschool though

    • @Anon-cp6bm
      @Anon-cp6bm Год назад

      If youve seen their new death penalty decisions and detainment of non-binary and trans children then it should be no surprise

    • @nathandrake5544
      @nathandrake5544 Год назад

      @@fro5ty208 These censorious crybullies are so dumb. They literally just judge an entire book based on the title and retroactively come up with reasons why it should be banned. Same reason why Gender Queer is their No 1 target.

  • @Undydamon
    @Undydamon Год назад +1069

    "While the characters are fictional, the setting is realistic"
    What are you gonna tell me next?
    That Harry Potter is realistic because it's set in a School?
    That MHA is realistic because it takes place in School?
    That Percy Jackson is realistic because it's set in New York, Los Angeles and other places in the USA?

    • @happyhattergamer8078
      @happyhattergamer8078 Год назад +15

      Have my like XD

    • @smauguh
      @smauguh Год назад +45

      Bro of course! And that's why Isekais are extra realistic, because a person dies in japan due to a traffic accident, which happens a lot in real life! Think before saying dumb things with a sarcastic tone.

    • @Dadan-dan
      @Dadan-dan Год назад +1

      Funny, Harry Potter was banned in some schools because it "promoted witchcraft". Or at least the usual crowd tried to ban it.
      EDIT: MHA *obviously* promotes vigilanstism! jk

    • @farcan9400
      @farcan9400 Год назад +25

      attack on titan is real since it takes place in a city

    • @mxrc3604
      @mxrc3604 Год назад +1

      EXACTLY ITS THE SAME LOGIC

  • @kenoandfriends
    @kenoandfriends Год назад +859

    Hey Joey! I'm a librarian born and raised in Florida. Thanks for covering this. Although we'd like to think Assassination Classroom won't get pulled from more shelves, FL culture-wars legislature has gotten so ridiculous they'd die on this hill if given the choice. I got out of Florida a couple years ago but it's sad to see how low that state has fallen in terms of censorship

    • @MrShagification
      @MrShagification Год назад +86

      Sorry to hear of your unfortunate circumstances. Being born in Florida is something I wouldn't wish on anybody.

    • @tonypilcher4200
      @tonypilcher4200 Год назад

      Florida is not the problem. Censorship isn't happening unless you want to talk about how some books are being rewritten because some progressives don't like certain sections or the plethora of books banned by left win groups including Mark Twain and Dr. Seuss. These books actually have an educational value unlike the books they are removing from schools today.

    • @Boomdizzle99
      @Boomdizzle99 Год назад +21

      Good thing you got out. Used to live in florida as a kid when the state used to be somewhat decent. Its a hell hole now. My sister was born there even she wont ever go back.

    • @cheyennemoore8380
      @cheyennemoore8380 Год назад +15

      Ikr? It wasn’t like this when I went to school there. We had access to so much, but I didn’t read anything with my brain turned off, because I was taught how to decide for myself what I could handle in books. (Also you librarians were my favorite ppl and still are so ty for what you do).

    • @TheKewlPerson
      @TheKewlPerson Год назад

      Everything is a culture war. If one side says they love puppies, the other will start making a whole campaign against puppies.

  • @ChainedThoughts
    @ChainedThoughts Год назад +97

    As a teacher, I really love Assasination Classroom. I love that Koro-Sensei never gave up on these students even though society did just because they were not getting good grades. In a way, it's similar to Gokusen. Both of these teaches not just students but teachers and adults alike that they shouldn't give up on someone just because they are different, they should try to find a middle ground. Koro-Sensei is such a good teacher. He even got mad at them when they actually did something wrong like putting their classmates in danger, etc. He even teaches them life lessons and help them find themselves.

    • @kellychuang8373
      @kellychuang8373 Год назад +5

      That's good and compared to these people doing the bans you're either more smarter than them or you have more sense than they do.

  • @emilyjones9787
    @emilyjones9787 Год назад +974

    I really feel like parents should have to include a book report before they can go after them. Would save taxpayers a lot of money and time

    • @shino4242
      @shino4242 Год назад +133

      Bold of you to assume these people can read.

    • @Slendysis
      @Slendysis Год назад +56

      The funny thing is I think that's a great idea both ways as it would allow people to more fully understand the content and, if it is banned, why that should be in place

    • @EnhancedTrashBin
      @EnhancedTrashBin Год назад +35

      ​@@Slendysis I feel like banning it would only just make people curious as to why and just read it. Since its so accessible through online lol.

    • @Slendysis
      @Slendysis Год назад +9

      @@EnhancedTrashBin Of course, but there's a difference between students reading something online on there own and a school offering it

    • @TheTimelessOne26
      @TheTimelessOne26 Год назад +5

      @@Slendysis I said it before; their reason is shit but assassin classroom isn't as innocent as some people make it out to be. I think most people forgot about this but a certain mom (Hiromi Shiota) did some questionable things during the manga/anime (verbal abused her son, forced him to cross-dress because she wanted a daughter, etc...). That and the age limit of this (take it with a grain of salt) is ‎14 - 17 years old. I think the overall ban in all schools is stupid. But I definitely can see it being banned for elementary school (not every book should be in every school library..... for instance: berserk). If they said it that way, I can see the parent's pov. As for the other levels, maybe middle school but def not high school. Also, this ban isn't that big of a deal of itself. Like, the internet still exists and there is still a public library. So, I think people are overreaching. Making it to be a much bigger problem then it is. Also, I remember back during when I was school, there was no manga or comics in my school libraries to begin with. The fact that there are and they are getting banned (therefore people are becoming aware of it) is really weird to me.

  • @Saphirakii
    @Saphirakii Год назад +380

    Assassination Classroom made me care more about learning, education, and appreciate good teachers, more than the American school system ever did. I was the edgiest I ever was in my life in American public school and Assassination Classroom completely mellowed me out.

    • @cheyennemoore8380
      @cheyennemoore8380 Год назад +18

      Good! Please support your local schools and help end this violence that makes us teachers fear going into work on the daily.

    • @nathanmcclung3564
      @nathanmcclung3564 Год назад +8

      Funny that I loved this anime/manga a lot due to the life lessons and such that it brought and even being of the reasons I wanted to become a teacher only for it to get attacked for well stupid reasons. Parents these days are so dumb it is insulting even to the point where they probably did not even look past the cover and looked at the teacher and prob said it was close enough to a real person.

    • @farcan9400
      @farcan9400 Год назад

      FOR Fucking REAL

    • @elimDBZ
      @elimDBZ Год назад

      My younger brother told me that the American education system is basically designed so that the masses are taught to be sheep that follow in line. American schools are just prisons but with extra steps.

    • @MrNajibrazak
      @MrNajibrazak Год назад

      as a Japanese i have to say that there is a place and time for everything and even for a manga fan myself i cant help but feel that schools in America is out of track when manga is available in libraries of a learning institution.
      there is a time and place for everything and school is not meant for that. if you have to rely on manga for positive social qualities then social decay must be a rampant problem in your society.

  • @rpgenius3968
    @rpgenius3968 Год назад +193

    Well if past trends of books getting put on ban lists holds, Assassination classroom volumes and box sets are about to see a spike in sales. Also of all the manga to get banned, wild it’s the series centered around a teacher helping students seen as rejects embrace their strengths and appreciate their individual talents in order to surpass expectations

    • @cheyennemoore8380
      @cheyennemoore8380 Год назад +9

      I wanted to read it before but now I really want to. Thanks for saying that. It inspires me as a teacher myself.

    • @zhongxina728
      @zhongxina728 Год назад +4

      Good old Streisand effect

  • @anhluu9417
    @anhluu9417 Год назад +143

    As someone who's been living in Florida, I'm not at all surprised. The politics in state is a clownshow in itself and then a school trying to ban...Assassination classroom out of all things? Bruh moment.

  • @darkdawn9926
    @darkdawn9926 Год назад +161

    First time seeing news like this Joey? Where I live in the states, a lady was blaming Death Note for supposably pushing Satanism and it was on the local news. It was cringe.

    • @Zanji1234
      @Zanji1234 Год назад +10

      .... pls tell me that this happend YEARS ago O_o

    • @Zanji1234
      @Zanji1234 Год назад +2

      @@darkdawn9926 dafuq

    • @idno4856
      @idno4856 Год назад +6

      I like how Joey was like how stuff he's seem makes this look like a Dr Zeus book... they've been banning those also (or trying to)

  • @sonnysumo8172
    @sonnysumo8172 Год назад +139

    There’s been a disturbing trend in some US schools targeting comics. I remember last year a Tennessee school district tried to ban MAUS by Art Spiegelman for ridiculous reasons like language and some non-pornographic nudity. Or a group of parents in Missouri which tried to have Blankets by Craig Thompson and Fun Home by Alison Bechdel banned from a public library. It’s said it’s because of nudity, but it’s comes off because it’s an objection to the depiction of a person’s disillusionment with fundamental Christianity in the former and a woman dealing with her duysfunctional family while also growing up as a lesbian in the latter. Yeah, needless to say US comics aren’t even safe from the concerned parents brigade.

    • @Zanji1234
      @Zanji1234 Год назад +27

      and some school banned a kids book about two gay penguins from NY Zoo because... GAY AGENDA xD

    • @angiee1603
      @angiee1603 Год назад

      This trend is not just limited to comics. There are so many book bans being considered right now. It's crazy. Just last night I saw a story where someone was trying to ban In The Night Kitchen by Maurice Sendak. There was an animation made of this children's book I played for my son. Now suddenly it's pornographic. There is a concerted effort to ban anything about black history or just the ugly parts of America history by saying they are indoctrinatibg our kids with Critical Race Theory. They want to ban anything LGBTQ+ by saying it's grooming or sexualizing children. It's all about control.

    • @EveioxVT
      @EveioxVT Год назад +18

      My school bought copies of maus for us to read, the teacher made it into a lesson about how most states are dumb to ban books for teaching authentic history (Ohio school btw, in the city, so not bad)

    • @HentsSauce
      @HentsSauce Год назад +11

      @@Zanji1234Reasonable. Blame the ones including homosexual books in libraries that kids are reading.

    • @Zanji1234
      @Zanji1234 Год назад +22

      @@HentsSauce it's a story ... about PENGUINS. HOW should make you reading about PENGUINS you gay?

  • @AceW
    @AceW Год назад +341

    Joey: "...Because everybody in Florida recognizes how dumb of an argument that is."
    Me, a lifelong Floridian: "How do we tell him, boys?"

    • @cheyennemoore8380
      @cheyennemoore8380 Год назад +11

      Idk. It is tough. I used to be a Floridian so I feel this

    • @Jyiber
      @Jyiber Год назад +65

      Florida is... a special place... where reality is whatever the loudest person says it is... and everyone agrees because their brains are humidity cooked on top of all the meth and/or coke damage.

    • @straelboraaaa
      @straelboraaaa Год назад +19

      @@Jyiber And a strange weirdo priest asking folks "Do you believe in gravity?"

    • @mintman325
      @mintman325 Год назад +14

      As someone who lives in Florida, I’m surrounded by boomers who do not understand manga.

    • @tmbgmonkey
      @tmbgmonkey Год назад +15

      As a non-Floridian American, I laughed at Joey's naieveness with that comment. 😢

  • @KingJH0510
    @KingJH0510 Год назад +43

    These parents thinking all the school teachers are indestructable, have tentacles and can move at mach 20

  • @weebgraphy
    @weebgraphy Год назад +124

    That's why people need to view the content rather than just assuming by reading the synopsis. Like they say "Don't judge a book by its cover", it's probably the most fitting proverb describing this situation. Honestly sad.

    • @gateauxq4604
      @gateauxq4604 Год назад +15

      These people aren’t even reading a synopsis, they’re just looking at the title and see guns and thinking somehow that will encourage potential shooters and not the complete lack of mental health care and overabundance of guns.

    • @weebgraphy
      @weebgraphy Год назад

      @@gateauxq4604 they think the manga was the reason for school shooting and violence but not the actual guns that the children taken along with them at school 💀

  • @tamago8042
    @tamago8042 Год назад +36

    These “parents rights” activists never care about rights, just about gaining control for themselves. I’m glad more people are seeing just how ridiculous they are, but the fact that they exist and are getting away with enacting policies like these is scary.

    • @hunterking87
      @hunterking87 Год назад

      From my understanding it's a astroturfing group with "parents" who conveniently don't seem have children currently going to public school. It's been reported that these astroturf groups in some cases put parents that don't live in Florida to go before these boards of education to wail that thier 1st ammendment rights were violated because children that are thier own may read books that talk about how unjust the world is. All you need to know about citizens defending freedom is that they want to defund the PBS of federal funding because they are too "woke" and liberal.

    • @varnix1006
      @varnix1006 Год назад

      This is why I cannot trust anyone that have attended a riot/activist gatherings. Clearly they do not care about the thing they champion and are just looking a way to ruin someone's day.

  • @SutekkaGhost
    @SutekkaGhost Год назад +193

    Thank you for doing this video, Joey. I've been wanting to do something similar myself but I don't have any credentials at all. So I'm grateful that someone with your influence is bringing attention to it despite not being American. This is happening in New York and a few other states as well over the same series. What a way to showcase their ignorance of the source material (as you said)
    Edit: Finished the video. Didn't know about Staten Island. The New York school I was referencing was somewhere hours away. That's so unfortunate, lmao. I really hope Gen X rises to the occasion and attends some school board meetings in protest. Rise up, young weebs!

    • @migvinu8620
      @migvinu8620 Год назад

      this is not happening in New york fuck are you talking about it happen in Florida.

    • @SolCresta3405
      @SolCresta3405 Год назад

      New York? I thought the banning happened in Florida…

    • @SutekkaGhost
      @SutekkaGhost Год назад

      @@SolCresta3405 It's being done in districts in other states as well, not just Florida 👍

    • @SolCresta3405
      @SolCresta3405 Год назад

      @@SutekkaGhost I see…

  • @pumirya
    @pumirya Год назад +251

    Yes, let’s blame manga and other media for society’s problems. Well, that is a lot easier than actually addressing the root problems.

    • @onepunchmanabat4107
      @onepunchmanabat4107 Год назад +25

      We would be very depressed if all manga and anime are banned. Some people do not know how to distinguish between reality and fictional entertainment.

    • @virutech32
      @virutech32 Год назад +19

      @@onepunchmanabat4107 les be real. if someone cant distinguish between their fanatasies & reality, the media available is irrelevant. unhinged is unhinged & at that point what u need isn't media control it's a mental health intervention. god forbid our leaders actually spend their time & efforts making mental health services more accessible or anything actually useful.

    • @rohitpaul805
      @rohitpaul805 Год назад +2

      my words exactly

    • @Zyscheriah
      @Zyscheriah Год назад

      Once they banned everything but the root cause I bet they would create something out of nothing to ban just to not address the root cause.

    • @Antarctide
      @Antarctide Год назад

      They already are trying to address the root problems though. By banning LGBT stuff for example.

  • @stormcloudcoon4546
    @stormcloudcoon4546 Год назад +57

    I had the assassination classroom books at my school and it was one of the most popular manga series in the library

    • @KyleTheMurderer
      @KyleTheMurderer Год назад +3

      Almost turned this into an “encouraging school shooters joke” but it always feels too soon these days.

    • @sssrankotaku7643
      @sssrankotaku7643 Год назад +3

      How come your teachers are still alive then 😆

  • @DaakkuuYRS
    @DaakkuuYRS Год назад +36

    When schools nowadays have manga in their library to begin with. Yeah, that didn't happen during my age.

    • @arniie5288
      @arniie5288 Год назад +3

      Ikr, thats actually sick

    • @SHADOMEGA7569
      @SHADOMEGA7569 7 месяцев назад

      Man my school days if the average student saw any form of anime their thought is instantly "you're looking at porn!?!?"

    • @DaakkuuYRS
      @DaakkuuYRS 7 месяцев назад

      @@SHADOMEGA7569 when I was at high school watching anime was like a social death. I was "in the closet" as anime fan until I finished school. Then somehow it was accepted as "cool" years later.

  • @willoyd614
    @willoyd614 Год назад +13

    Thinking about how Shakespeare's works are read in English class, violent stories sexual stories, and even suicide.

  • @rumplstiltztinkerstein
    @rumplstiltztinkerstein Год назад +31

    Thank you for talking about the message of the manga. That class the alien is teaching is the worst class of the entire school. It has an entire system that incentivizes the "best" students to bully that class into submission. It is literally an anti-bullying story. Showing that everyone has the potential to be great. It has nothing to do with your status or what others think of you. It comes to how much you value and respect yourself.
    The story of the manga is literally a story to give support for the students most likely to be on depression during school. The irony is impressive.

  • @roggonval
    @roggonval Год назад +177

    The worst thing is that it is safer to be in a classroom with an octopus as a teacher who they have to kill than in a school of the US

    • @heathenspider
      @heathenspider Год назад +1

      omg hhhhhhhhhhh

    • @kellychuang8373
      @kellychuang8373 Год назад +6

      Oh yeah especially now.

    • @Kostte-zp6he
      @Kostte-zp6he Год назад

      Oh no

    • @kellychuang8373
      @kellychuang8373 Год назад +2

      @@Kostte-zp6he You're right on that and these people behind the bans really are out of their minds and can't think of a realistic solution either.

  • @GamerConnoisseurRei
    @GamerConnoisseurRei Год назад +34

    Man this makes me want to rewatch Assassination Classroom, such a good series, also speaking of controlling parents remind me of Nagisa's psycho mother just like these Floridian Mothers lol

  • @nagi159
    @nagi159 Год назад +75

    assassination classroom literally changed my life and helped me out during a massive depressive phase. i learned a lot of valuable life lessons from it as a kid and it had a big impact on me. makes me so sad to see such a fun manga like that getting banned. if any of the parents or the teachers read it for more than 2 minutes they would probably realise that it's harmless :(

    • @loodgack
      @loodgack Год назад +6

      this is the thing people never talk about (I mean, we, anime/manga lovers do, but others don't)
      anime and manga can help people through depressive states. can prevent you from doing bad things. I not once heard stories, both from friends' friends and other random people, (heck, even I have personal a story or two, related to this) that they went home from a school, from people, who harrassed them, and they just watched anime nonstop, and it was the thing, which literally helped them overcome through their dark times. not a damned teacher, who often does nothing, to protect the bullied children.

    • @ArbytheStrawberry
      @ArbytheStrawberry Год назад +1

      Me too!!

  • @GrandMoffJoseph
    @GrandMoffJoseph Год назад +16

    Based on video title alone I guessed this was going to be about Florida and BINGO!
    "America does X for stupid reasons" is basically an evergreen statement as it is. But Floriduh takes it to a whole other level that no state (not even Mississippi or Texas) can hope to touch.

  • @DinoDawgCreations
    @DinoDawgCreations Год назад +10

    I hate my state Florida sucks I want to move..

  • @faenethlorhalien
    @faenethlorhalien Год назад +63

    A few years ago, the RAE (Real Academia Española de la Lengua, Royal Spanish Academy of Language, the maximum organism in charge of deciding what words are correct and not in Spanish) actually incorporated the word "manga" into the language as something like "Japanese pornographic comic". You can imagine the fury coming from not just fans but anyone of Spanish citizenship living in Japan and the Japanese authorities. They were forced to change the definition, OF COURSE, because the first one was churned out by some idiot who didn't know the world they lived in.

    • @becarus3616
      @becarus3616 Год назад +9

      They changed it, now it just says japanese comic

    • @IR-Fan
      @IR-Fan Год назад +9

      Curious as to what were the RAE thinking when adding the word "pornographic". Do they just read and handpicked one manga with lots of sexualization?

    • @mikeostwald9645
      @mikeostwald9645 Год назад +7

      @@IR-Fan Yeah it's like when guys complain about Only fans girls on Instagram and Tik Tok and at the same time always watch and click on those videos so the algorithm promotes them even more lmao.

  • @RaykinaBreaker
    @RaykinaBreaker Год назад +24

    Florida parent must've didn't read this manga properly. The story is soo wholesome. The point of the story isn't even about killing Sensei, it's all about setting Koro Sensei as a target of inspiration to improve themselves to become a better student. If they can't comprehend this Work as a good material, that mean they itself didn't learn anything from their past mistake.

  • @MaddogYasha
    @MaddogYasha Год назад +7

    Bruh how they literally wanna blame the problem on everything but the actual cause

  • @projectanmu4546
    @projectanmu4546 Год назад +29

    i couldnt agree more, my parents didnt let me play shooter games for a long time and it went so far that i wasnt allowed to play need for speed when i got my driver license, like cmon i can seperate fiction and reality, my parents watch crime and murder tv shows but im not allowed to watch some animes and read some mangas?

    • @irtwiaos
      @irtwiaos Год назад +1

      Some people are just not good parents or good at parenting.

  • @PK88.
    @PK88. Год назад +8

    Once you said "FLORIDA" I already had context. That state is in a war with itself.

  • @MikeAruba69
    @MikeAruba69 Год назад +8

    Lol. This reminds me of that news video where a mother was upset that her daughter's middle school had Ms. Kobayashi's Dragon Maid in the school library.

  • @Vozird
    @Vozird Год назад +25

    *Parents of america after banning a comic book
    "We have done it. We have solved school shooting"

    • @jame254
      @jame254 Год назад

      but is really guns fault though?

    • @SHADOMEGA7569
      @SHADOMEGA7569 7 месяцев назад

      **3 weeks later**

  • @wintertoastie
    @wintertoastie Год назад +8

    The things that bothers me is with cases like this, they claim it's the reason for violence is US schools. When killers write manifestos and leave traces of their plans behind, there's never any mention of anime, manga, video games, or television anywhere. And guess why

  • @royalkumar795
    @royalkumar795 Год назад +5

    I guess these parents need watch Great Teacher Onizuka anime

  • @SethStovallVO
    @SethStovallVO Год назад +1

    I didn’t even know most school libraries had manga in America. I do live in Oklahoma, and in my school I never found any manga once so ever.

  • @ok.9654
    @ok.9654 Год назад +12

    Dude, they have manga at a school library!? I wish mine had that :(

  • @Melissaalvarado0731
    @Melissaalvarado0731 Год назад +5

    With the laws states are enforcing, they might take them down. I have already seen so many librarians say they have had to take out many books that are banned. Some teachers have also had to send in a list of the books from their classroom’s library for review 🙃

  • @artfire28
    @artfire28 Год назад +17

    I remember when Philippines banned the title card just for the censorship board to please themselves. Not the parents, teachers, and guardians. This is like Death Note all over again.

    • @Kuroji07
      @Kuroji07 Год назад +1

      What was it exactly? How come I didn't know about this.

    • @artfire28
      @artfire28 Год назад +2

      @@Kuroji07 PH change the title to Invisible Teacher. It was lame.

    • @kongvang5359
      @kongvang5359 Год назад +3

      My GF, who is Filipina, actually told me she was scared to watch death note because it features devils and the Philippines is heavily catholic. I thought it was funny but she was totally serious about it.

    • @DA-qn3id
      @DA-qn3id Год назад +1

      Lmao diba tas pag mimilitary training tayo which is equally violent

  • @misake
    @misake Год назад +7

    It reminds me of Mama Doctor Jones, I believe it was Florida too, the schoolbord wanted to ban her RUclips videos from class (think it was for sex Ed). They said that she's giving the wrong information and corrupting the students to go out and have sex. 😅 She has a video about it. It's pretty funny, and they probably never watched any videos. 😅

  • @DarkDragonSlayer
    @DarkDragonSlayer Год назад +100

    as a filipino american from california, this is truly an "only in florida" moment lol
    edit: this was hysterical. also, the abbreviation for assassination class room is called a*s class, thanks to someone from team 4 star.

    • @SeaSerpentLevi
      @SeaSerpentLevi Год назад +19

      Ass class 😭😭😭

    • @mikolajmyjak
      @mikolajmyjak Год назад +9

      As a European (German)
      this is an only in America moment for me xd

    • @tejasdalvi3583
      @tejasdalvi3583 Год назад +6

      "Ass class".... Damn I fell called out😂, I also call it ass class for shortform

    • @maxiwaxipads
      @maxiwaxipads Год назад +1

      We’re the same :D
      Filipino-Americans apparently from California 🤝🤝

    • @patty1418
      @patty1418 Год назад +2

      as a mexican american from california, indeed this is an "only in florida" moment. but also its crazy that manga was even available at a library to begin with, i dont think either my middle school or high school carried manga, like ever.

  • @Zahri8Alang
    @Zahri8Alang Год назад +1

    I remember specifically in secondary school, I remember our homeroom teacher was pushing us to record(list) the books, magazine or any reading material of sort(aside from adverts or pamphlets) in our NILAM book(a library thing). They said even mangas count, so I listed like almost EVERY volumes of Doraemon manga innit

  • @troywestleybailey
    @troywestleybailey Год назад +11

    Someone is trying to start a political bid. That’s how this happens.

  • @nuggetster
    @nuggetster Год назад +8

    here in Brazil there was a whole rumour about a shit ton of school massacres going to happen in the 4/20, nothing actually happened, and my school was actually super chill and just did the best to calm us down and all. But i remember i bought a volume of this manga before the rumour started but it only arrived like a week ago. My mom heard about the whole thing and was scared as hell when she saw that i bought this manga lmao. She thought it would fr tell us how to kill people and school violence. But she did read it all before me and said i could read it and actually giggled a bit with some stuff. Fun.

  • @onejapanesetexan5763
    @onejapanesetexan5763 Год назад +10

    Bro ngl they should ban all classical books like Edgar Allan Poe and the like if they're getting rid of Assassination Classroom, he alone is absolutely nutty. Not to even mention Spirit Bear as well, they had homie smashing heads into the sidewalk and my school made us read and do an assignment on it. 💀💀💀💀💀

    • @onepunchmanabat4107
      @onepunchmanabat4107 Год назад +5

      That's crazy. I liked your point. I feel like that school is trying to discriminate Japanese culture. It's so unfair that the Japanese art medium or perhaps the ones we like better are getting banned.

    • @ジュレジュ
      @ジュレジュ Год назад +1

      @@onepunchmanabat4107 Yeah, the double-standard is very strange. Its clearly xenophobia disguised as concern for kids' well-being.

  • @andrewfields5779
    @andrewfields5779 Год назад +4

    I used to read O-Parts Hunter in High School in '08 and I was banned from reading it because they claimed it was "satanic"

  • @egon8947
    @egon8947 Год назад +40

    It's crazy that, in my school assassination classroom is also a complete no-go. Even though we literally have the entirety of berserk in the same section

    • @Zanji1234
      @Zanji1234 Год назад +13

      well... it's the Name that triggered helicopter Parents since BESERK well they see some guy with a sword and are not interested but ASSASINATION plus CLASSROOM

    • @TheTimelessOne26
      @TheTimelessOne26 Год назад +5

      Now. That is fucked up. Wtf.

    • @IchiSAO
      @IchiSAO Год назад +3

      LOL

    • @V.U.4six
      @V.U.4six Год назад +2

      The irony is whack

    • @onyxcrowe4511
      @onyxcrowe4511 Год назад

      Berserk is a seinen series it's attended for young adults and it's shows very explicit content like r*pe

  • @jacobdrolet4262
    @jacobdrolet4262 Год назад +2

    Amazing video Joey of parents in USA trying to banned a popular manga from a school library without looking up what’s the anime/manga about in the place,it’s ridiculous 😅too. Fantastic job

  • @indranilroy4822
    @indranilroy4822 Год назад +7

    That 'realistic setting' comment reminds me of a comment I read somewhere that for anybody in Japan (or anywhere else in the world really), the idea of gun-toting kids trying to kill their teacher would be downright ridiculous and then there's America lol

  • @KeiichiGreen36
    @KeiichiGreen36 Год назад +17

    As a Floridian myself, this is just plain embarrassing. 😮‍💨

  • @user-nv8rq6nb4y
    @user-nv8rq6nb4y Год назад +3

    When a street slasher tabbed and killed random people in Akihabara in 2008, the media reported that that guy was an otaku, full of anime videos and manga in his room. And this has caused a huge negative image on anime fans and otaku culture.
    There are absolutely nothing to do with anime or manga and those incidents. This is ridiculous.

  • @RandomSwiftie13
    @RandomSwiftie13 Год назад +1

    This has only made the manga and anime. I didn't even knew about it's existence until this all went down and now I'm watching Assassination Classroom, and I'm from India, not even American.

  • @lynxraide
    @lynxraide Год назад +4

    I think it was in Texas, they introduced a law where parents could put forward books for review due to violent or sexual content (cause they also seem to be jumping on the book burning/anti LGBTQ bandwagon) and 3 parents from one district actually put forward The Bible, because of the depictions about it. Haven't heard the outcome yet, but those who implemented the law aren't happy about it cause it wasn't what they were intending

  • @appointedbard1076
    @appointedbard1076 Год назад +1

    they are trying to ban a bunch of books over here from schools and it is always stupid

  • @kanchi21
    @kanchi21 Год назад +4

    getting really sick of this crap happening all the time

  • @gallantgamer4728
    @gallantgamer4728 9 месяцев назад

    I think the most messed up part about this Florida and Wisconsin. They don’t really think about it. They just go after it. But you can still find a copy of goodnight Pun pun in many libraries and that one’s way more concerning for a kid to reed in their worst mental state time

  • @shouryuuken4147
    @shouryuuken4147 Год назад +68

    When a fictional story for teens is considered to be too violent, but then they sell all kinds of guns to 18 year olds (and in some states even younger).🤡

    • @irtwiaos
      @irtwiaos Год назад +4

      18 year old? Didn't you hear the granddaughter of South Dakota own a assault riffle at age 2?

    • @bonda_racing3579
      @bonda_racing3579 Год назад +1

      @@irtwiaos “assault Rifle” is a term used for infantry units in an Army. Not generic rifles. That term is misused like crazy

    • @testchimp
      @testchimp Год назад

      you are an adult at 18 years. so, your argument is nonsense.

  • @thealvinpodcast2024
    @thealvinpodcast2024 Год назад +3

    I am literally studying in a catholic school whose library allows Spy x Family manga.
    This issue is just insane.

  • @shantel_
    @shantel_ Год назад +10

    I am also from Florida and I am just…. Not even surprised anymore.
    This is bringing me back to being a kid and my mom saw me watching anime for the first time- which was Inuyasha and she didn’t want me to watch anymore because of the “violence” the show had. It was kill the demon of the week and she saw that ONE bit. I had to watch Inuyasha in secret because I’m like???? There are way more violent things on tv… but yeah “ Inuyasha is going to corrupt my brain”

    • @thewolface2339
      @thewolface2339 Год назад +2

      From the amount of memes about Florida people doing stupid things, i'm not surprised either.

  • @JC98x_o
    @JC98x_o Год назад +7

    I don't remember how long ago this was, but an American school tried to ban manga before and it was Death Note. Probably because of the same reason.

  • @ZayecValentine
    @ZayecValentine 11 месяцев назад +2

    After watching the anime this manga should be in school because the Sensei is actually one of the best teachers in manga/anime.

  • @strangerice4467
    @strangerice4467 Год назад +8

    Agreed Assasination classroom is an incredible wholesome series, about misfit students learning who they are through this strange and amazing teacher. Ironically to the annoying parents, One of the biggest themes in Assasination classroom is that violence is not always the answer. In fact no violence is just better. Love the series and the characters, read the manga go watch the anime its a good ride.

  • @Blueflameraven17
    @Blueflameraven17 Год назад +3

    To start with ya like of all things Assassination classroom is like the least problematic manga for this they probably read the title and did not like the idea. Heck my high school had parasite. I find it funny they parents will hate on these books for whatever there reasons are but things like Lord of the flies is a mandatory read in high-school and that book literally talks about the animalistic nature of humans

  • @thehangmansdaughter1120
    @thehangmansdaughter1120 Год назад +6

    So, they're complaining about kids getting books from the library? They're complaining that their kids are reading? FFS.

  • @dumbanimenerd4169
    @dumbanimenerd4169 Год назад +1

    7:36 the thing I wish you woulda mentioned about this panel is the context for this panel was the kids acted in a way that would harm Nagisa and it was a threat to not fucking hurt your classmates.

  • @danielferrieri7434
    @danielferrieri7434 Год назад +10

    Schools after seeing Assassination Classroom: HERESEY

    • @TheOtakuDude
      @TheOtakuDude Год назад +2

      Why did I read this as Hershey? HAHAHAHA!!!!!!

  • @thecleeze6359
    @thecleeze6359 Год назад +4

    Thank you for your video. Yeah, it's insane to think that with 'the internet' being what it is, parents are going after books... and I think that the label of 'anime' or 'manga' causes a detachment in thinking of these things as what they really are - books. Groups have been trying to ban books in schools for decades (centuries?), because nothing is more dangerous in society than words and drawings on paper. Ideas and creativity. BAN IT! Go back on the internet if you want something wholesome to do... and use the computer so I can pretend you're studying, and I'm a good parent.

  • @beast9270
    @beast9270 Год назад +33

    What I don’t get is why parents aren’t okay with manga that have “violence” and “sexually explicit content” but there fine with schools teaching there kids about slavery, war and many other more dark and violent history stories

    • @poggershoggersdoggers
      @poggershoggersdoggers Год назад +4

      Fr let them learn that sht when they're in highschool or smth. Let the kids eat dirt, play and do kid things.

    • @boxcarwilly
      @boxcarwilly Год назад +14

      These same people aren't find with those things, either. Or, at least, they aren't fine with actual history being taught.

    • @TheTimelessOne26
      @TheTimelessOne26 Год назад +6

      @@poggershoggersdoggers what isn't stated is that this ban applies to every level of school. From elementary to high school. I think their approach is dumb but I generally or you could argue that assassin classroom isn't for elementary schoolers (one reason: Hiromi Shiota). It is prob ok for middle schoolers but def for high schoolers. That being said, some manga should never be allowed in high schools as well. Ie: berserk. Def not below age 16.

    • @cheyennemoore8380
      @cheyennemoore8380 Год назад

      And allowing ppl to shoot up the place

    • @bloodnessx
      @bloodnessx Год назад +1

      well i dont mind them teaching history, cuz atleast those kids know how bad it was and history wont repeat itself. but one of the main problem is simply how legal guns are in america

  • @spicybeantofu
    @spicybeantofu Год назад

    Been in one that tried that to the point they wanted to take our books that we own away from us. They got some nasty calls from parents.

  • @RianLKLock
    @RianLKLock Год назад +13

    Parents be dumb sometimes

  • @cecilia8515
    @cecilia8515 Год назад +1

    Florida has banned the Heartstopper books which is also ridiculous, there is nothing inappropriate about them either.

  • @barretwallace5336
    @barretwallace5336 Год назад +15

    I'm pretty sure if the Bible were to be drawn into a comic/manga, its graphics to describe all kinds of punishments would be more horrifying than any panels in Assassination Classroom.

  • @Ryuk-is-here
    @Ryuk-is-here Год назад +1

    Hello, Floridan born and raised here 👋🏻
    Florida is broken, so many things have made me lose hope here

  • @KeshetAylonit
    @KeshetAylonit Год назад +8

    Considering the fact that the show is the one show I watch when I need motivation to study or attend school…. This is definitely a “wtf”. That manga + show are perfect for classrooms wtf.

  • @porcelina956
    @porcelina956 Год назад +2

    Thank you! I work for a library system in Minnesota in the U.S. It's frightening what is happening in this country censorship challenges are at an all-time high and it is not just manga/anime it is non-fiction books on history, and classic literature. Then we have parents and politicians who are bullying kids for being themselves by policing dress codes, what gender students want to identify as, refusing to teach anything but abstinence only. Meanwhile, gun violence is at an all-time high and we have the NRA refusing to give up the second amendment even though guns are the number one killer of children in the U.S.
    This is why people need to study history because if you don't you are doomed to repeat it. The same problems keep happening over and over again.

    • @jame254
      @jame254 Год назад

      two different things not related at all. Take away the guns you get law abiding citizens with what? fisty cuffs to defend themsleves with a possible intruder with weapons? possibly even stolen or black market guns.

  • @animechic420
    @animechic420 Год назад +7

    I honestly don’t care if they ban Assassination Classroom from Florida. I watched it already it, liked it’s premise and the end game. If they have a problem with AssClass, then let them read Wolf Guy.

  • @hollyt.6856
    @hollyt.6856 Год назад +1

    This reminds me of when I was in school. I was the person everyone went to with manga concerns, and I was even approached by the school librarian, because she needed to read a manga due to a class she was taking. I gave her a few options, none of which were too extreme, but she legit turned to me and asked "Are any of these not weird?!" It's like people don't want to understand. They just want to control.

  • @nyankrauss
    @nyankrauss Год назад +3

    there's one more thing they forgor about: when you forbid anything for kids (literally anything) - they will do it with extra dedication. Your ban is like an advertisement that would hang over school entrance, with 6 feet tall letters, in Comic Sans, in red color😅

    • @jame254
      @jame254 Год назад

      I remember when they did for American comics growing up. glad my parents weren't that stern when it came to comics or literature

  • @deadkitsun6667
    @deadkitsun6667 10 месяцев назад

    Yet, my elementary school pushed to have more books on things useful to people later in life. Of course that was 2001-2005, but we legit had a "How to make bombs and explosives book" that, when pointed out, was seen as informational, right after 9-11. Crazy on the double standards of people, but this video will get me to finally watch/read assassination classroom because I always saw it, but never knew what it was about. Thanks for the videos as always Joey and can't wait for more informational/news related videos such as this

  • @RamaDeeZ
    @RamaDeeZ Год назад +5

    Bro I discovered manga because of Ass Class through my library and I loved it so much, It taught me so many lessons that I still hold dear today, but of course people are gonna take it out of context. Folks really need to chill.

  • @wii3564
    @wii3564 Год назад +2

    I'm more surprised by the fact that there is Assassination Classroom in a school library in Florida tbh

  • @ITSaPendragon
    @ITSaPendragon Год назад +7

    they prob should start with guns

  • @shoutaakimoto8096
    @shoutaakimoto8096 Год назад +1

    As a Floridan, even I can tell you this is dumb. And when I went to school, we didn't have manga in our school libraries nor did a very few select teachers like that some of us brought manga and anime. It was super weird. They got more lax when I got to high school but middle school, yeah they were very very restrictive with any of us bringing this stuff to school. Hell all you have to do is take out your CD walkman to rearrange your backpack and it's not on, the teacher confiscates it and holds it hostage for a whole ass year. When I say that manga was more interesting and engaging to read in middle and high school for me compared to the crap that was in the actual library, it kept me from being bored. And yes, I said CD walkman. I am that old. lmao.

  • @arnouxgaming3720
    @arnouxgaming3720 Год назад +5

    Twilight, Divergent, Harry Potter, Eragon, etc all have dark, murderous and/or sexual undertones in them at one point or another. Are we just going to ban all of them too?

    • @SuperCasualPleb
      @SuperCasualPleb Год назад +1

      All of these books were banned In schools at one point.
      in my school at least

  • @doctorwyvern9992
    @doctorwyvern9992 Год назад +1

    Actually, this reminds me more of the comic book controversy back in the 50s. A man named Frederick Wertham published a book called “Seduction of the Innocent”, claiming comic books were contributing to the delinquency and sexual perversion of minors. You should google this for more details, but it just goes to show that attacks on popular media outlets have been going on for a very long time.

  • @anthonyldaniel1
    @anthonyldaniel1 Год назад +35

    You can tell the people haven't read it cause you can obviously tell the teacher they are trying to assassinate is a God damn alien

    • @ansalem12
      @ansalem12 Год назад +1

      And practically invincible anyway. They were given an almost literally impossible task. They may as well have been told to assassinate Superman for all the difference that would make.

    • @SHADOMEGA7569
      @SHADOMEGA7569 7 месяцев назад

      With nerf gear at that

  • @sarazarah
    @sarazarah Год назад

    Nice explosions in the sky vinyl! They are one of my all time favs

  • @joshguide6389
    @joshguide6389 Год назад +8

    idk if you ask me, they've got a worse book in all those libraries, way more violent and sexually explicit... the bible. they should take a look at that one first

    • @traplover6357
      @traplover6357 Год назад +3

      Just goes to show that people don't read books and cherrypick based on bias.

  • @Murimz
    @Murimz 10 месяцев назад

    YP WTF THIS IS MY COUNTY I AM CLOSE TO THAT SCHOOL BRO PLS DONT HAPPEN TO ME.

  • @Sora_Metca
    @Sora_Metca Год назад +3

    this shit actually made me watch assassination classroom and it was so hecking good XD. one of the best anime i ever watched

  • @ananthakrishnanvj5090
    @ananthakrishnanvj5090 Год назад +2

    "Let's not solve the main problem, instead put the blame on something else because why not"
    When will this shit end ?

  • @jasonjasso666
    @jasonjasso666 Год назад +3

    Wait till they learn best boy wears a dress.

  • @zaticzonicz1474
    @zaticzonicz1474 Год назад

    Im more surprised that theres manga in school libraries??? In my school in Malaysia, theres never a single manga in sight

  • @Wilted.lycoris
    @Wilted.lycoris Год назад +3

    I live in Florida, and I don’t understand these book bans. Most children have access to much worse content on the internet for free. Sure,maybe a third grader shouldn’t be reading Lolita, but shielding them from all dark subject matter as they grow up will do nothing but hurt them. In my area,there was a push to get the Diary of Ann Frank from schools because it “glorified ww2.” It was insane how people genuinely thought that.

    • @jame254
      @jame254 Год назад +1

      tried to do in Indiana too growing up

    • @testchimp
      @testchimp Год назад

      bad parenting is leading to children having access to terrible thing in the internet.

  • @techyougo
    @techyougo 11 месяцев назад

    I think some Florida schools ended up banning it. Also some schools in Wisconsin and North Carolina

  • @tmkwb109
    @tmkwb109 Год назад +4

    “Blame the kid, not the manga” I agree lol.
    There are more intense mangas in Japan but almost no school shooting out there. てかフロリダの学校、図書室にマンガあるのいいなぁ。平成生まれだけど小中高図書室にマンガなかったよ。

  • @gondorianslayer4250
    @gondorianslayer4250 Год назад +2

    they sure hate people enjoying stuff.

  • @kab6754
    @kab6754 Год назад +46

    Wow I can't believe Florida Karen squad is trying to ban a manga series that's definitely not online.
    That's s lie. I can DEFINITELY see a Florida Karen squad doing this

    • @lssjgaming1599
      @lssjgaming1599 Год назад +8

      Florida Karen squad is an accurate description of not only Floridian parents but their government as well

    • @boxcarwilly
      @boxcarwilly Год назад +3

      These Karen squads are in every state, attending school board meetings and trying to ban all kind of books. It sucks.

  • @pisaupisaupisang
    @pisaupisaupisang Год назад +2

    Pov: you see this news and somehow you want o rewatch and reread assassination classroom.

  • @drauc
    @drauc Год назад +4

    I swear we really are regressing as a society on a lot of these issues.

  • @MrHidePatten
    @MrHidePatten Год назад +1

    As the propellerheads once sang: “feels like a little bit of history repeating”
    We’re doomed. I’m without hope.