Red cross still hasn't visited the Ukrainian pows to check on them. The red cross see the Russian pows. I'm not surprised they haven't seen the Israeli hostages. It's so awful. Shame on them. ❤️🇺🇦❤️🇮🇱❤️
Yes, it’s so obvious that all the international organisations are participating in the worlds problems. Wherever they appear you can be sure that the problem will exist forever 🇺🇦🤍🇮🇱
The Russians have committed so many war crimes in Ukraine, we have lost count. The Red Cross is no longer effective. You can't count on them except for interference.
@@paulinetipper1351 I stopped donating them. Belarus Red Cross abducted 1000's of Ukraine children from occupied area of Ukraine, many who ended up in Russia!
Red cross a waste of space. In the past a wonderful organisation. Now, all they want to talk about is feelings. Hostages in captivity, in goodness what conditions. Do your job.
There is nothing to discuss. The International Red Cross MUST do their duty and insist on access to the hostages . If Hamas resists, then the whole International community must come down on them like a ton of bricks. Period.😡 A bad example has already been set and this will have HUGE consequences in future wars.
This lady is a good talker. She explains what the mission of ICRC is. She does not explain how comes they still did not have access to the hostages. And that was the only question she needs to answer here.
2 MONTHS!! The hostage's are in grave danger!! Each day matter's!! Why won't other muslim countries take the Gazains so they are safe from the bombing/fighting?? Why isn't pressure put on other countries to take them instead of blaming Israel for their demise?
ICRC is responsible for aid to civilians - yet IDF confiscated 50 drones with grenade attachments in a shipment, and the legitimate aid goods goes directly to Hamas. great work ICRC. you managed to fail 200%
I'm from Kenya and I don't understand why ICRC is applying double standards for failing to directedly approach Hamas as one if the actors in the conflict. ICRC negotiated the release of prisoners of wars between Srilanka Army and Liberation of Tamil Tigers Ealam.What have changed that they cant negotiate the release for Israel Hostages and dead bodies of soldiers from both sides of the conflict.Icrc should come clean on this situation unless they're pro hamas. They are supposed to take medicine, communication between hostages and.msgs between families without allowing hamas to see and to share confidential information on hostages with families.But they are changing goal posts on Israel. I agree with ICRC that they are independent and that's why they are trusted by both sides of the conflict.ICRC can talk to IDF and HAMAS without raising eye brows bcoz of neutrality and independence. So sad . I worked with ICRC 2006-2009 and I was part of the team in Srilanka.
The rep here expressly says they *are* directly in discussion with Hamas leadership. She specifically says the ICRC head has met with Hamas leaders face to face, and that in those conversations they're asking to be allowed to see and care for the Israeli hostages. The other guy is basically asking ~how about instead of working behind closed doors to pressure for access while also continuing to aid the civilians you are able to reach in Gaza you publicly refuse to treat any Gazans harmed by Israel's attacks until Hamas releases hostages?~ It's bizarre and shameful to see him accuse the Red Cross of having more soft power than, y'know, Netanyahu & the IDF.
She said: "We have no weapons ...". That is not true. You can loudly condemn Hamas for NOT creating the conditions that the Red Cross needs! But FIRST of all you have to condemn the taking of civilians hostage in the first place!
ICRC have the mandate to liaise with all military actors on the ground and that's why they have maintained independence and they can talk to any party in the conflict. Why not talk to Hamas and inform the world on Hamas responses.
What a cop out "I didn't see our trucks with the red roofs" OMG I don't want to hear you bad month the IDF for not bring in supplies!! Your in there & like you stated "You have a relationship with them as you have been in Gaza for DECADES" she is to young, no experience at all. Shamefully Red cross!!!!!!!
Somebody passed marketing with flying colours at Uni! Keep talking sister, but it doesn't change the truth which is y'all getting nowhere fast with Hamas!
She claims they have not been given access or the right conditions to access the hostages. Who is responsible for that? Who took the hostages in the first place? Who is still holding them hostage and restricting access? This is unbelievable. It's disappointing to see so many organisations and countries turn a blind eye to this terrorist group. I am so sorry for what the Israelis are going through. Sending strength and prayers to the IDF and Israelis.
She talks a good talk but their actions show the truth. They can put demands on Hamas to have access to the hostages. Interesting also they have had a presence in Gaza for years. Shows how the Palestinians have been oppressed by Hamas for so for years.
This lady said that ICRC doesn't have weapon recognizing that the only way to get to Hamas is using weapons😅 so shameful for a "neutral" organization whose employees in gaza are Hamas members
That accent belongs to a late 20s mid 30s woke career driven leftie Australian who has no life experience except a human rights university course. Sixty-seven days after 7 October this is the best ICRC can do and not front Hamas to demand to have access to all the hostages immediately.
People need to relax and let these people do their jobs. What people seem to forget is they are on this 24/7 now. And we don't see what goes on behind closed doors. There are literally thousands of people involved in it! Thank God for the Red Cross. They do some wonderful work.
...meanwhile in Israel, Arabs - Muslim, Druze and Christians go to the same universities to earn degrees, masters and doctorates in the same universities as other Israelis, Jews who are religious Jews, Christian Jews, agnostics, conservative, progressives. There are Arab judges, doctors, nurses working along side Jews, Arabs and Jews going to the same nightclubs in Tel-Aviv and Arabs and Jews selling their goods in the same markets in Netanya. Anyone can serve in the IDF and a month ago I was listening to a Bedouin in the IAF Intelligence who made it clear that Hamas is like ISIS. He had lost relatives in southern Syria to ISIS.
Actions speak louder than words
Excuse, excuse, excuse. Shame on her, they deserve all the public condemnation they get
just so you know, the red crescent/cross is trying very hard and doing everything they can, to do nothing.
I completely agree with you! her words say they are trying so hard, NOT.
💯% absolutely nothing
Never have so many words been spoken for such little result.
The ICRC and Red Cross have failed miserably. We now know who’s side they are on and it is not good 💔💔
If only the Red Cross didn’t care about their own lives 😡 those selfish b*stards!
Red cross still hasn't visited the Ukrainian pows to check on them. The red cross see the Russian pows. I'm not surprised they haven't seen the Israeli hostages. It's so awful. Shame on them.
❤️🇺🇦❤️🇮🇱❤️
Yes, it’s so obvious that all the international organisations are participating in the worlds problems. Wherever they appear you can be sure that the problem will exist forever 🇺🇦🤍🇮🇱
The Russians have committed so many war crimes in Ukraine, we have lost count. The Red Cross is no longer effective. You can't count on them except for interference.
Yes. Shame on them. I do not trust the ICRC further than I can throw them. Read about their behaviour during WWII.
Give them no more money, they are fraudulent.
@@paulinetipper1351 I stopped donating them. Belarus Red Cross abducted 1000's of Ukraine children from occupied area of Ukraine, many who ended up in Russia!
Red cross a waste of space. In the past a wonderful organisation. Now, all they want to talk about is feelings. Hostages in captivity, in goodness what conditions. Do your job.
The ICRC are very good talkers but hardly one sees or feels the positive results ( if any ) of their supposed hard work where needed
Red cross is red with the blood of Jews.
CUT OFF ALL CONTRIBUTiONS .
Horrible insincere creature, Red Cross only works with muslim Red Crescent, never with Magen David Adom!
If only the Red Cross didn’t care about their own lives 😡 those selfish b*stards!
Red cross is not doing anything.
There is nothing to discuss. The International Red Cross MUST do their duty and insist on access to the hostages . If Hamas resists, then the whole International community must come down on them like a ton of bricks. Period.😡 A bad example has already been set and this will have HUGE consequences in future wars.
These people are hypocrites, you dont stand with anybody, why are you calling for cease fire
It looks like you have stood on one side shame on the Red Cross.
Red Cross are in support of hamas, so I don't think they are interested on visiting the hostages, or they fear hamas coz hamas will not agree
I don't believe her. All criticism is towards Israel.
This lady is a good talker. She explains what the mission of ICRC is. She does not explain how comes they still did not have access to the hostages. And that was the only question she needs to answer here.
Hi, When you say access to the hostages. Do you mean now? Or the one's still with Hamas?
The hostages that Hamas keep now.
2 MONTHS!! The hostage's are in grave danger!! Each day matter's!! Why won't other muslim countries take the Gazains so they are safe from the bombing/fighting?? Why isn't pressure put on other countries to take them instead of blaming Israel for their demise?
They are trained to lie with a straight face, good questions!
After over 2 months. Too little too late.
Sue the RED CROSS.
ICRC is responsible for aid to civilians - yet IDF confiscated 50 drones with grenade attachments in a shipment, and the legitimate aid goods goes directly to Hamas. great work ICRC. you managed to fail 200%
It's not a choice, it's a mandatory requirement that icrc move into Gaza to care for those (wounded) hostages
I'm from Kenya and I don't understand why ICRC is applying double standards for failing to directedly approach Hamas as one if the actors in the conflict.
ICRC negotiated the release of prisoners of wars between Srilanka Army and Liberation of Tamil Tigers Ealam.What have changed that they cant negotiate the release for Israel Hostages and dead bodies of soldiers from both sides of the conflict.Icrc should come clean on this situation unless they're pro hamas.
They are supposed to take medicine, communication between hostages and.msgs between families without allowing hamas to see and to share confidential information on hostages with families.But they are changing goal posts on Israel.
I agree with ICRC that they are independent and that's why they are trusted by both sides of the conflict.ICRC can talk to IDF and HAMAS without raising eye brows bcoz of neutrality and independence.
So sad .
I worked with ICRC 2006-2009 and I was part of the team in Srilanka.
Agree. They need to solve this before its too late.
The rep here expressly says they *are* directly in discussion with Hamas leadership. She specifically says the ICRC head has met with Hamas leaders face to face,
and that in those conversations they're asking to be allowed to see and care for the Israeli hostages.
The other guy is basically asking
~how about instead of working behind closed doors to pressure for access while also continuing to aid the civilians you are able to reach in Gaza
you publicly refuse to treat any Gazans harmed by Israel's attacks until Hamas releases hostages?~
It's bizarre and shameful to see him accuse the Red Cross of having more soft power than, y'know, Netanyahu & the IDF.
She said: "We have no weapons ...".
That is not true. You can loudly condemn Hamas for NOT creating the conditions that the Red Cross needs!
But FIRST of all you have to condemn the taking of civilians hostage in the first place!
Red Cross must put pressure to care for the hostages, humanitarian care for them!!
She sounds so unreliable, no talking to the people, doing "whatever" nobody knows, under the shield: "We don't tell what we do", this is crazy!!!!
The only objective they have is to save civilians. Politics and war is for other people.
Agree crazy
I will never ever donate a single penny to these big organizations after the 7th oct atrocities
ICRC have the mandate to liaise with all military actors on the ground and that's why they have maintained independence and they can talk to any party in the conflict.
Why not talk to Hamas and inform the world on Hamas responses.
"Unfortunately held hostage"? What did she just say? International Committee indeed...
They are unfortunately being held hostage. Is it fortunate?
There is no excuse or moral equivalence to what Hamas did on october 7th
What a" PR". Basically she is telling we have done everything we could. What are you demanding for? I can't help
and to the lady giving this set of excuses..............talk is cheap, your actions speak louder
shame on red cross
What a cop out "I didn't see our trucks with the red roofs" OMG I don't want to hear you bad month the IDF for not bring in supplies!! Your in there & like you stated "You have a relationship with them as you have been in Gaza for DECADES" she is to young, no experience at all. Shamefully Red cross!!!!!!!
ICRC is a biased paper tiger?
Very dissapointed by the red cross 😢
Focusing on Gaza civilians, not on the hostages from Israel!!
Empty words. No actions.
I’ve donated in the past, still receiving their commercials witch go directly into🗑️
Somebody passed marketing with flying colours at Uni! Keep talking sister, but it doesn't change the truth which is y'all getting nowhere fast with Hamas!
Don't believe a word she's saying on behalf of the Rust cross
Nothing to discuss, much to act.
yes, at least something could have been sent to the hostages (medicines, pads, wet wipes...)
She claims they have not been given access or the right conditions to access the hostages. Who is responsible for that? Who took the hostages in the first place? Who is still holding them hostage and restricting access? This is unbelievable. It's disappointing to see so many organisations and countries turn a blind eye to this terrorist group. I am so sorry for what the Israelis are going through. Sending strength and prayers to the IDF and Israelis.
Just talk, no actions.
She talks a good talk but their actions show the truth. They can put demands on Hamas to have access to the hostages. Interesting also they have had a presence in Gaza for years. Shows how the Palestinians have been oppressed by Hamas for so for years.
I just googled ICRC comments on IDF/Israel Palestine and there are very political condemnations of them but dont see same on IRM.
We need to know where our money is going here
Red Cross go meet with the hostages
She should be selling used cars .
Too much politics.
I think you mean too little politics. They stay away from politics, and focus on saving lives only.
I call BS on the ICRC 😡
The ICRC lady is laying it on pretty thick. Surely nobody accused ICRC of slacking off...
She is the equivalent to a used car salesman
I will never give 1 dollar to the #redcross
Sorry icrc....your spokesperson manicured eyebrows etc speak volumes re your priorities....
Hoe corrupt kan je zijn, Rode Kruis ⁉️‼️
Liar
Question Does anyone know when that camera showed Hamas taken those trucks? Was it lately or in the past?
❤️🇮🇱💪🙏🇺🇸
Jesus is Lord And He will help Israel
Is it even safe for Red Cross to go into tunnels with Hamas
ICRC - "is impartial", "doesn't condemn".
Given Hamas' actions against civilians, the ICRC must have a moral void to make such statements.
This lady said that ICRC doesn't have weapon recognizing that the only way to get to Hamas is using weapons😅 so shameful for a "neutral" organization whose employees in gaza are Hamas members
After they discuss & discuss, there are no hostages to save.
Does she look like Hamas???
They want Red Cross workers to be killed by Hamas just to TRY to see the hostages 🤣🤣. Do they care about anyone but themselves ever???
That accent belongs to a late 20s mid 30s woke career driven leftie Australian who has no life experience except a human rights university course. Sixty-seven days after 7 October this is the best ICRC can do and not front Hamas to demand to have access to all the hostages immediately.
Very well said sir
"Neutral", yeah, right!!!
PROOF OF LIFE!!!!!!!
#1 for ICRC! Damn
AL Jazeera didn't see this video? Lol
We know that! They had it in food for oil.
Wtf are there no idf soldiers guiding these trucks into gaza,wtf,I thought this was sorted,omg
Hamas fighters guarding transport of civilian aid on video tells me all I need to know.
You need a list of every name-age-medical condition/needs.
❤🇮🇱
People need to relax and let these people do their jobs. What people seem to forget is they are on this 24/7 now. And we don't see what goes on behind closed doors. There are literally thousands of people involved in it! Thank God for the Red Cross. They do some wonderful work.
For the past 2 months the ICRC haven’t done anything for Israeli hostages except be a taxi service
Very weak journalists unable to challenge her. Foolishly listen to her as a kid.
Were is yad vacham
There inhuman
Blah blah blah red cross
I know it’s probably irrelevant but she has a undiplomatic face and voice 😂😂
I can't see past the red lippie, darls. Neutral, yeah ok 😂
She has that Soviet Union nurse look
@@kareemi7080 ahahahaha she certainly does!
Red cross are disgrace
At last.sjzme on you
Why should ICRC do that?
What was the reason to invade Gaza?
It’s not antisemitic to reject Israel as a Sectarian Apartheid Theocracy, without a Constitution
You lack knowledge of truth
I agree. It's stupid, but not directly antisemitic.
Lying about Jews is most definately anti-semetism.
...meanwhile in Israel, Arabs - Muslim, Druze and Christians go to the same universities to earn degrees, masters and doctorates in the same universities as other Israelis, Jews who are religious Jews, Christian Jews, agnostics, conservative, progressives. There are Arab judges, doctors, nurses working along side Jews, Arabs and Jews going to the same nightclubs in Tel-Aviv and Arabs and Jews selling their goods in the same markets in Netanya.
Anyone can serve in the IDF and a month ago I was listening to a Bedouin in the IAF Intelligence who made it clear that Hamas is like ISIS. He had lost relatives in southern Syria to ISIS.
@@1969cmp Yeah I feel that Israel is really failing in it's apartheid plan.
ICRC.what a waste of time...useless
Red cross are woke organisation.
Horrible insincere creature, Red Cross only works with muslim Red Crescent, never with Magen David Adom!