Fallen Kingdom: The MacDonalds, Lords of the Isles | FULL DOCUMENTARY

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 янв 2025

Комментарии • 219

  • @blwkk2
    @blwkk2 Год назад +34

    I’m a descendant of McDonald’s on my father’s side and my mother was a Campbell. And the war never stopped.

    • @MichaelMacDaniel
      @MichaelMacDaniel 9 месяцев назад +5

      Same here 😆

    • @DeviantBris4nce
      @DeviantBris4nce 8 месяцев назад +5

      OMG, I'm a MacDonald and Campbell, hello cousin!

    • @winterwheels
      @winterwheels 6 месяцев назад

      Hahaha its probably unlikely your new "cousin" will get back to you as you have the word deviant in your name. Let me know how you get on lol

    • @AntonioJohnson-o5u
      @AntonioJohnson-o5u Месяц назад +1

      I am a descendant of a Mcdonald my mother Diana is a Mcdonald

    • @nascontraband
      @nascontraband 7 дней назад

      my ancestors are the macdonalds of dunnyveg we are spread out

  • @Coupal1
    @Coupal1 Год назад +14

    Somerled is my 21st great-grandfather though his son Ragnall and my 23rd great-grandfather through his son Dougal. Fascinating.

    • @Texas1836
      @Texas1836 10 месяцев назад +2

      Wow

    • @davidcarpenter5274
      @davidcarpenter5274 8 месяцев назад

      Yup, the traditions of Glastonbury . Go all the way through King Author , Boutica & the Tin-man . To the very family of Christ. Thanks .

    • @davidcarpenter5274
      @davidcarpenter5274 8 месяцев назад

      Somerled Being a common ancestor , to The Crown . (Stewart) .
      Somerled 20 million descendents , second only to Genghis Khan . Wow !!!

    • @davidcarpenter5274
      @davidcarpenter5274 8 месяцев назад

      That got my face leaking .
      Maybe lonely , but not alone .

    • @OldGreg3366
      @OldGreg3366 6 месяцев назад +2

      My great great grandfather also

  • @kumasenlac5504
    @kumasenlac5504 Год назад +16

    When the UK's Special Forces (The Royal Marines) needed a motto they adopted (and tweaked) Somerled's
    Per Mare, Per Terram.

  • @madhatter7785
    @madhatter7785 Год назад +36

    I just found out that Cheif MacDonald who was killed on February 13, 1692 was my 12th Great Grandfather. His Son John who escaped the Glencoe Massacre was my 11th Great Grandfather. It shows in my family history that my 10th Great Grandfather Daniel Donald McDonald born 1700 in Barra, Inverness-shire, Scotland migrated to Catawba River, Catawba, North Carolina, United States in 1720 and changed the family's name from MacDonald to McDaniel and then died in 1756.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +6

      Wow! That’s really interesting, thanks for sharing. Nice detective work! 🕵️‍♀️

    • @madhatter7785
      @madhatter7785 Год назад +4

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios thank you, I've been soaking up as much information as possible to learn more about my bloodline.

    • @bretwalda8543
      @bretwalda8543 Год назад +4

      Same, hes my 11th great grandfather, my great granny was a mcdonald

    • @Daniel_Watkins
      @Daniel_Watkins Год назад +5

      @madhatter7785 I’ve recently received some DNA results that suggest my ancestry is from McDonalds of Glencoe. I live in SC, I would love to connect!

    • @madhatter7785
      @madhatter7785 Год назад +1

      ​@@Daniel_Watkinsthat would be awesome. I would like to connect as well.

  • @garymacdonald7165
    @garymacdonald7165 Месяц назад +2

    Im a Northern Irish/Scot with parents with the surnames ONeill/Macdonald!
    Proud of the influential history of these 2 clans in those 2 countries!

  • @petertuckergoettler5720
    @petertuckergoettler5720 4 месяца назад +4

    I Never Step On Ground In Scotland, But I Feel I Know This Wonderful Ancient Place Of Mystery And Magick, merci.

  • @cynthiaskidmore7545
    @cynthiaskidmore7545 7 месяцев назад +6

    My 13th great grandfather was James MacDonnell, brother of Sorley Boy. We ended up in the American colonies. So much pain. Even my dad shared in the pain of being of this lineage. So much lost. Just heartbreaking. Pain doesn’t stop because your family is relocated. Again, absolutely heartbreaking. Never home. We can never go home

  • @azariahisrael5632
    @azariahisrael5632 Год назад +22

    Thanks for a great video. I can't believe this hasn't been viewed more. My 14th great grandmother is Flora Macdonald, daughter of John Macdonald/McDonell 8th of Glengarry, wife of Murdo MacLeod 8th of Gesto and Glenelg. So weird to hear all these names in your video and know they are my ancestors. I also decendant from Alasdar MacLeod. I have Macdonald ancestors of Sleat. I guess we all decend downward from Islay and Ragnhall. Somerled is my 27th great grandfather. I am very proud to be both a Macdonald and a MacLeod. The majority of Macdonald's are decendants of Robert the Bruce via his decendant Princess Margaret Stewart daughter of King Robert II. I am also a decendant of James IV and Edward IV via the Earls of Lumley who married into the Douglas-Hamilton/Stewart lines.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +2

      Absolutely fascinating stuff, you have a rich heritage indeed!! Many thanks for watching and glad you enjoyed it 😊

    • @mellissabrandon664
      @mellissabrandon664 Год назад +4

      I’m a descendant of this same family. We live in California now.

    • @corablunt-zy2be
      @corablunt-zy2be Год назад +3

      I'm from england from my Dads side family name is Irish and from my mum's side is Scottish my grandad is Scottish native from the macdonald clan and we have roots with somerled Norse Gaelic Lord of the island and I'm pagan

    • @tegan7885
      @tegan7885 Год назад +3

      MacDonald’s are related to everyone twice

    • @easymac24
      @easymac24 Год назад

      ​@@mellissabrandon664same!

  • @wingmanhoy3999
    @wingmanhoy3999 Месяц назад +1

    Very much enjoyed, being a Hoy, Haughey, Hoy Island Orkney, Scottish Irish, Gaelic Norse, Darini, Darine, proud to be United States Citizen, we have all come along way, have we not, thank you for this video, all the very best.

  • @mr.turnersneighborhood1741
    @mr.turnersneighborhood1741 2 года назад +10

    Great job and I really enjoyed this episode. As a kid, my father, William MacDonald, used to actually tell me some of these stories, especially ones about the Cambell's lol. It is just nice to know that because of channels like yours, untold and almost forgotten parts of history will still be able to be remembered, thanks guys.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  2 года назад +1

      Many thanks for the kind words and for watching. I found the research for this really enjoyable and entertaining - the stories are too good to be lost to history!

  • @marlinmacdonald3419
    @marlinmacdonald3419 Год назад +7

    Thanks for this video. Alberta Canada.

  • @kathybray2838
    @kathybray2838 28 дней назад +1

    Word from a family diary says that our Henderson Clan was already in Glen Coe,aka Glencoe, when the Glen was awarded to the Mac Donald Clan for their bravery and skill in the war. The clans joined in marriages and the Chieftain Eanruig (Henry or Hendrey ) and his sons and daughter, the Mac Eanruig (which became the Henderson Clan. ) fought with and supported the much larger clan. They were also there when the Campbell’s came to massacre, but claiming Hospitality which must be honored. It was a vicious trick. One of the sons was spoken of as having married a Norse Chieftain’s daughter from the Orkney’s before or about the time that the Sinclair’s were given control of the Orkney Isles. So the “son” was added to the Hendrey /Henry name. We wonder if that happened after the survivors left Glencoe or before. We believe it was after when everyone scattered to the North . Our Clan was much later to be located near the River Clyde and to the South and East of Edinburgh.

  • @ChristopherBowly
    @ChristopherBowly 5 месяцев назад +2

    A brilliant series of documentaries - very detailed, informative & interesting. Well researched & well narrated. Very many thanks.

  • @kathybray2838
    @kathybray2838 28 дней назад +1

    Thank you! You are a good storyteller! 😊

  • @stuartmacdonald9289
    @stuartmacdonald9289 Год назад +8

    The opinion of the Scottish government hasn't changed. 😂joking aside, I've just discovered your channel and am mightily impressed with your fair and balanced approach to your topic.
    You have a new subscriber.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +2

      That’s praise of the very highest order. Thanks so much for your support, it’s really appreciated. 👍

  • @joenolan4917
    @joenolan4917 7 месяцев назад +4

    Top notch story telling mate. You’d have been a valued bard back in the day

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  7 месяцев назад +1

      Damn, that’s quite the compliment! Thanks dude, glad you enjoyed the film.

  • @Serenity07-10
    @Serenity07-10 2 месяца назад +1

    Wonderful narration of this history.. thank you

  • @alastairjamesmainland2497
    @alastairjamesmainland2497 11 месяцев назад +1

    Grew up in Lochaber, so many swirling un joined dots of information, this sewed a great deal of that mystery together. Excellently told.

  • @amacd861
    @amacd861 Год назад +4

    Thanks for the video! Great content - Angus MacDonald

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад

      Glad you liked it!

    • @joyful_tanya
      @joyful_tanya Год назад

      Sir, can you tell me, for my genealogy research: What is the difference between "MacDonald" and "McDonald"? My husband's mother was "McDonald" from New York State. I can trace her grandparents through Nova Scotia but it stops there. James A. Mcdonald married to Mary (neé Close). James A. Born 1837 N. S. and died 1924 Monroe county New York.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад

      @tanyajoy There is no difference between Mac and Mc, the latter is simply an abbreviation. :)

  • @haraldtheyounger5504
    @haraldtheyounger5504 Год назад +7

    2 great books on Somhairlidh mhór mac Gillebride mhic Gilledomnán (Somerled) by R. Andrew McDonald: The Sea Kings, and The Kingdom of The Isles.

  • @RobertMcQuillan-my3du
    @RobertMcQuillan-my3du 7 месяцев назад +2

    I'm a subscriber and I'm learning allot from your channel and loving it so thank you my family history is Irish but love Scotland and have shared history.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  7 месяцев назад

      And many thanks for watching! Glad you’re finding it all useful! 🙂

  • @marianfrances4959
    @marianfrances4959 Год назад +4

    Ah...bitter-sweet history! 👍🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @Fires755
    @Fires755 Год назад +1

    Wow,my grandmother is Mac Donald,my mother side, my grandfather , William 1066this is my mom family, My father family is Rollo, Richardson, I did not know this about clan Mac Donald,its alot to take in, sad to me now, I have to learn more, thank you!!

  • @ScorRblx
    @ScorRblx 26 дней назад +1

    Great content -Calk MacDonald

  • @macalad8486
    @macalad8486 7 месяцев назад +3

    MacDonald here, from Sunderland, im guessing some of my ancestors settled here during the civil war when the Scots were fighting the royalists

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  6 месяцев назад

      Just a quick point on the semantics here as I know it's confusing. In Scotland, Royalists were mostly Scots (English-speaking Lowlanders: 'Albannaich' in Gaelic). The Gaels (Highlanders) were the traditional opponents of the Crown. This changed in the early modern era when the 'wrong' king - William of Orange - displaced James VII, whose supporters -Jacobites - included many Gaels; indeed, the Jacobite army at Killiecrankie was predominantly comprised of Highlanders.
      But yes, it's quite possible your ancestors were forcibly relocated from their Highland territory as part of the Highland Clearances.

  • @anthonygielty7242
    @anthonygielty7242 Год назад +2

    wonderful content

  • @Fell214
    @Fell214 2 года назад +2

    Very enjoyable. Thanks for the effort.

  • @SeestheDayphotography71
    @SeestheDayphotography71 9 месяцев назад +3

    I am a McDonald. My father’s DNA shows that we descended from Somerled. However, there are a lot of gaps that I would love to fill . My 5th great grandfather was Capt John McDonald born in 1742 . He fought in the Revolutionary war. Capt John Mc. Arrived ( with Cherokee Indians) at Abaco Bahamas after the war in 1783. He settled there in a place now known as Cherokee Sound. That information is confirmed with historical record. I suspect that Capt John’s father and grandfather were both named Alexander MacDonald . The only sure record I have is from an interview with John McDonald - Magistrate & School master of Cherokee Sound, who stated that his grandfather was a Loyalist soldier, and his great grandfather a ship builder in the river Clyde. I’d LOVE to know more about

    • @nickdeagle3271
      @nickdeagle3271 7 месяцев назад

      Really interesting. Would love to hear more of these folk’s stories.

  • @KingEdwardtheTurbulentNeill26
    @KingEdwardtheTurbulentNeill26 Год назад +1

    Will you be doing a video on the great clan the MacNeils of Barra

  • @austinm3377
    @austinm3377 Год назад

    Awesome video. Who sings the background music? Wouldn't happen to be Alistair McDonald?

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +1

      Thanks. It is indeed; all music is listed in the end credits :)

    • @austinm3377
      @austinm3377 Год назад

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios awesome! Thanks!

  • @erikhoff5010
    @erikhoff5010 9 месяцев назад

    I am from the Erwin's of Ireland and the Irwin's of Drum. Where did they fit in, if at all? Great video and information, thank you so much for your information. Skal from Oklahoma.

  • @NUHUHHHNIJGFHTRFF
    @NUHUHHHNIJGFHTRFF 9 месяцев назад +3

    Im a MacDonald my fam came from Nova Scotia to Connecticut

    • @JasonSulliman
      @JasonSulliman 2 месяца назад

      I have MacDonald familt in CT as well!

    • @NUHUHHHNIJGFHTRFF
      @NUHUHHHNIJGFHTRFF 2 месяца назад

      @@JasonSulliman Really what towns? My fam lived in Monroe Shelton and Oxford , Greenwich Im from Ansonia

    • @JasonSulliman
      @JasonSulliman 2 месяца назад

      @@NUHUHHHNIJGFHTRFF I lived in Vernon. My mother's family grew up in Windsor Locks/East Hartford. Her father was born in Amsterdam, NY and his father is from PEI (There was a large migration from Scotland to PEI in the Mid-1800's...happy to discuss more (just find my website and shoot me a line)

  • @mattgwayman
    @mattgwayman 10 месяцев назад +1

    Great Chanel man, up there with the Scottish History Tour guy. Whats that beautiful music at the beginning? This specific song name

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  10 месяцев назад +1

      Thanks man.
      It’s Andrew Prahlow’s title theme from the video game ‘Outer Wilds’.
      www.mobiusdigitalgames.com/outer-wilds.html

  • @1.1797
    @1.1797 4 месяца назад +1

    Per Mare, Per Terra!!

  • @martinanderson4832
    @martinanderson4832 6 месяцев назад

    excellent video just subscribed

  • @StacyHart-v9b
    @StacyHart-v9b Месяц назад

    WONDERFUL!

  • @StephenMcLeod-r2d2
    @StephenMcLeod-r2d2 10 месяцев назад

    Thank you. Terrific infotainment. I am a MacLeod. Is there an episode on the clan?

  • @alexandermurdock9643
    @alexandermurdock9643 5 месяцев назад +1

    Nice video. Live in Idaho USA. Originally from Tennessee

  • @TheEggmaniac
    @TheEggmaniac Месяц назад

    Interesting video. Though there were definitely Celts or people who spoke in a Celtic language and had Celtic culture, in Scotland ( 4.01 ) before the arrival the Gaels to the west coast, of what is today Scotland, in the fifth century. They were a Brittonic speaking people. A different branch of the Celtic languages. The Picts were Brittonic Celts, as were the Strathclyde Britons, of the independent kingdom of Alt Clud ( Strathclyde ). Which included most of the south west part of Scotland, from the river Clyde down into what is today Cumbria, In England. Alt Clud survived as a separate kingdom, speaking a Brittonic Celtic language, similar to Welsh, until the 12th century.

  • @ethancorey1959
    @ethancorey1959 Год назад +1

    What is the title of the alistair macdonald song that starts at part 4?

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад

      It’s great isn’t it? The music credits are at 38:45. It’s called ‘Smeòrach Chlann Dòmhnaill’; ‘The Songbird of Clan Donald’.
      The lyrics are wonderful if you can find a good translation (AI translation butchers it).
      The ‘holli-li-li-lili-ho’ refrain is purely phonetic and meant to simulate the bird’s call.
      “A songthrush of Clan Donald am I;
      A _mavis_ (colloquial: tuneful bird) on the floor at Phabuil…”

    • @ethancorey1959
      @ethancorey1959 Год назад

      Thank you for the prompt response.
      I believe Julie fowlis has a version of this as well, though I may be mistaken.
      Either way it is one of my favorite gaelic songs and I've never been able to find the title, so I thank you once again!

  • @VicariousAdventurer
    @VicariousAdventurer 8 месяцев назад

    Whiskey was a big incentive (and factor?) in invention of the barrel

  • @shirleythornburg
    @shirleythornburg Месяц назад

    How or where did clan MacQueen/ McQueen come in? My grandfather Alexander Mcqueen was born in Scotland before 1707 and was exiled to America... on ship Friendly but i can not find any information about him or his family prior to America. Thank you Shirley

  • @sheralynnicholson7639
    @sheralynnicholson7639 5 месяцев назад +1

    My 4x great grandfather Finley MacDonald helped settle Nova Scotia Canada.

  • @andymullins84
    @andymullins84 Год назад +1

    I'm not related to the Campbell's or the McDonald's but I'm related to several families from Kintyre and Galloway

  • @corablunt-zy2be
    @corablunt-zy2be Год назад +2

    I'm english from england and from my Dads side of the family name is Irish and from my mum's side my grandad is Scottish native from the macdonald clan and we have roots with somerled Norse Gaelic Lord of the island it's weird

  • @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964
    @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964 8 месяцев назад

    I am Macdonald on my moms side. My moms dad, his mother , was hewitt/hewittson, which is a sept of clan Macdonald

  • @christophersherman1198
    @christophersherman1198 Год назад +1

    Thank God for written records of the past, Thank God and our children for changing the Fate of the world's Future.
    ❤🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @aigslmnop
    @aigslmnop 6 месяцев назад

    lord of the isles title must've caused confusion with the wider island group or groups maybe 21:33

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  6 месяцев назад

      Indeed.

    • @aigslmnop6559
      @aigslmnop6559 6 месяцев назад

      ​​@@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios orkney was another mainland britain capital of old I've seen

  • @matthewreyes2401
    @matthewreyes2401 Год назад +1

    Interesting as this Mexican (me) has my ancestry with the Macdonald’s. My 11th great grandpa father was Hugh of Glenmore Macdonald

  • @fgaze72
    @fgaze72 7 месяцев назад

    the outer wilds theme tune was a surprise 😂

  • @darrenmcdonald5373
    @darrenmcdonald5373 10 месяцев назад

    Per Mare,Per Terras !

  • @eileenavci7105
    @eileenavci7105 8 месяцев назад

    My Grandfather was Alexandra Mac Donald of Ronald Moore .

  • @SAMinime_
    @SAMinime_ Год назад +4

    And now I know something about my ancestors

  • @particles1101
    @particles1101 3 месяца назад

    My great grandmother was a MacDonald. Her family came from County Claire in Ireland. It's fascinating to read up on the history. Norse Gaelic would explain where I got my grey eyes from at least.

  • @xtramail4909
    @xtramail4909 Год назад +1

    Really informative video!! However, my understanding is that the Picts united with the Kingdom of Dal Riada (the Scotti/Irish), not the Anglo Saxons, to form the Kingdom of Alba and modern day Scotland.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching and commenting!
      The Kingdom of Dalriada was an Irish Sea domain. There were Anglo-Saxons in the borders and lowlands, but in the West the Vikings had control of most of the old Dalriada by the 9th Century. As such, there would certainly be Celtic ‘refugees’ who would have moved eastwards to escape them… but as to the extent of this, and its bearing on the constitution of Alba, we have little evidence to go on.

    • @xtramail4909
      @xtramail4909 Год назад +1

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios at the height of Dal Riada, the Kingdom included Argyle and Antrim. Scotland was already inhabited by Celts prior to the Gaels arriving on their shores. The Gaels that formed Dal Riada met the Pictish Brythonic Celts. Kenneth MacAlpine was the first King of Scotland, in the 9th century, and this is what led to the Kingdom of Alba being created. Kenneth brought the Pictish Celts and the Gaelic Celts together under a single Royal line. While there was likely some displacement when the Vikings arrived, they ended up having significant cultural exchange which is evident in the Norse language and art adopted into Celtic languages and culture. These interactions also resulted in intermarriage between the Viking settlers and the Celtic population. As for the border areas, they are significantly more Celtic descent than Anglo Saxon descent, as Celtic peoples had been living there for thousands of years prior to the expansion of Anglo Saxons. The Anglo Saxons didn’t “replace” the Celts in the border areas and lowlands (not saying that’s what you said, but people often confuse the presence of Anglo Saxons in the Southern regions of Scotland as being the only people that inhabited those regions which is false). Anglo Saxon culture was adopted albeit not fully.
      British education covers up a lot of Scotlands predominately Celtic past. If you think I’m wrong please enlighten me. Great video though.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +1

      @xtramail4909 Not at all, that’s a fair comment and you make very good points. In an enormously condensed history feature such as this I realise I’m, by definition, making sweeping statements that some will disagree with or identify as poorly communicated.
      Your feedback is to extremely important as I continually strive for accuracy and to correct poor phrasing or factual error. I may reupload this in the future with a more nuanced description of the instance you mention.
      Once again, thanks for watching and commenting, much appreciated.

    • @xtramail4909
      @xtramail4909 Год назад +2

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios it’s an extremely complex, long history that is a challenge to cover. Keep up the great work! ☺️

    • @brucecollins641
      @brucecollins641 10 месяцев назад

      @xtramail4909...the dalriada may have been real(from scotland to ireland) tho.....the scotti coming from ireland is a myth. it's gallic in scotland most likely coming from the frankish regions of europe.

  • @michaeharvey1175
    @michaeharvey1175 8 месяцев назад +2

    My x6 grandfather was Ewan Macdonald grandson of William Macdonald of Aird and valley, Ewan was sent to tasmania as a convict more so a political prisoner with his sentence was also added he was never to return to GB...pretty handy for the women like men in power today 😂

  • @lloydertel1
    @lloydertel1 Год назад

    i don't know how to trace MY MacDonald lineage. I know my Grandfather was George MacDonald and was born in the homeland. I don't know where he was born. BUT he did speak with some strange words. he would never use the word street always routes. My mother was born somewhere( I have 2 birth certificates) one from Edinburgh and 1 from Toronto. where she grew up

  • @hsitynews7194
    @hsitynews7194 5 месяцев назад +2

    I’m from New Zealand 🇳🇿 I’m Maori half Tongan my great grandmother was a MacDonald so that makes me Maori Tongan Scottish 💯❤️

  • @browneli
    @browneli Год назад +1

    Donald MacAngus MacDonald, 8th Chief Laird of Clan MacDonald of Glengarry is my 14th Grandfather on my grandmother Eula Hutson Brown's side of the family.

  • @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964
    @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964 8 месяцев назад

    Not many people liked the Campbells. Pretty much everyone was at war with them. I know the Macgregor of Glenstrae and Campbell of Argyll were deadly enemies.

  • @Handlebar-MustDash
    @Handlebar-MustDash 6 месяцев назад

    I have oft pondered, do MacDonalds eat Campbells Soup?

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  6 месяцев назад

      They made their own a thousand years prior. Besides, even in the depths of starvation, they probably wouldn't have considered it edible.

    • @edwardbisset2624
      @edwardbisset2624 3 месяца назад

      I believe there is a-bar .in glencoe with a sign dogs welcome but no Campbells

    • @edwardbisset2624
      @edwardbisset2624 3 месяца назад

      I am 25th grandson of James the second we had land and a big house in Aberdeenshire A. descendant Walter bisset was accused of the murder of the earl of atholl after a tournament and our family were banished to Ireland and lost our lands to the lovat family we ended up with castles and land in ulster I believe these were gifted to the Bisset’s by William of orange I have no idea why but we seemed to change religions and I believe we had some involvement in the campbells attack on the McDonald’s of glencoe from Inveraray to my great regret

  • @corablunt-zy2be
    @corablunt-zy2be Год назад +3

    And I'm learning about paganism

  • @johngeddes4161
    @johngeddes4161 Год назад +1

    spouting read from others is seldom right.

  • @elisehoffman3653
    @elisehoffman3653 Год назад +2

    Disappointed that the full story of how the Lord of the Isles title came to Donald was not mentioned in this episode. The Mac Ruari's held the Lordship of the Isles through Somerled. Donald obtained this title through marrying Amy Mac Ruairi, who was the last MacRuari heir. But he wanted more power, and so divorced her after 3 children because he wanted an alliance with Robert II--he married his daughter, Margaret. But he got to keep his ex-wife's holdings! In other words, Donald was a CAD, and he and his successor's rapacity (instead of thoughtful leadership) led to political decisions that destroyed their own dynasty and eventually control of the Isles. The ensuing loss of stability in the Western Isles and how it affected the families involved over the next few hundred years cannot be under underestimated.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching! Given the scope of the subject it wasn’t possible to go into such detail but your comments are noted and I’ll endeavour to cover this in further MacDonald - connected episodes (Sgorr Dhonuill, Mull etc). :)

    • @hughmac13
      @hughmac13 Год назад +1

      Begone, Campbell.
      There is no joy without Clan Donald; there is no strength without them; the best clan in the world: every good man was one of them.
      The noblest clan ever born, who personified prowess and awesomeness; a people to whom tyrants made submission; they had great wisdom and piety.
      A brave, kind, mighty clan, the hottest clan in the face of battle, the most gentle clan among women and most valorous in war.
      Etc., etc.

    • @IMacdonnell
      @IMacdonnell Год назад

      You dont know what you're talking about! Clann Ruaidhrí never held the Lordship - once - ever! They tried - failed! And Donald son of Raghnall son of Somerled never married Ami! That was John son of Donald son of Angus Og. So why believe anything you say? Yes, Donald did take Magaret as his second wife which was pretty dam common those days.

    • @coldonemcdonald9036
      @coldonemcdonald9036 7 месяцев назад

      @@hughmac13 Thank you! That Blood still exist it made sure to get far to and warn it’s descendants tell the story. I didn’t get to hear it until I was 24 my grandfather told me it and I have researched as much as I can find. This is the greatest information I have found this far for Glencoe. I really like this Page.
      Time puts people different places.
      That blood is humbled and ready to stand for the people of the US and everyone who has good in they’re heart elsewhere. I hope to see Glencoe one day and return the blood that left over 332 years ago.

  • @lynnemurphy114
    @lynnemurphy114 5 месяцев назад

    💚

  • @jaycee2392
    @jaycee2392 Год назад

    My plinkit is noree mcdonal o~ Tookie..var gal.(norse) we still own it! Tha seas an landy Isle is mine!! A tell thee dat!!😊

  • @HalifaxPeacock
    @HalifaxPeacock 8 месяцев назад

    VIKING
    VI=6
    SIX KINGS

  • @andrewheaney6858
    @andrewheaney6858 9 месяцев назад

    “ Warring Picts and Anglo Saxons united in defence “ ? 1500 hundred years ago the Anglo Saxons had been settling Northumbria from what’s now Edinburgh down the East coast for a mere 50 years, they were no where near the Western Isles ? and “when Scotland was inhabited by Picts and Anglo Saxon tribes” there were two wave of invasion? the Anglo Saxon were the invaders and what about the native Brythonic Briton’s who inhabited the west coast of Scotland from Dumbarton castle all the way down to Wales at the time, no mention? The historical inaccuracy’s in the first 5 minutes set a tone of fiction to come !

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  9 месяцев назад

      Coming in hot there chief. What you call historical inaccuracies are legitimate academic theories for which there is evidence both for and against.
      Hence the “Lively academic debate”, this is a contested subject. We are all contributing to the debate.

    • @andrewheaney6858
      @andrewheaney6858 9 месяцев назад

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Takes a stretch of the imagination to think of the Anglo Saxons coming up to the western isles to join forces with the Picts to fight the Vikings thus forming Scotland no matter what academic theories you follow, just saying !🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  9 месяцев назад

      Nowhere in the film is it suggested that Anglo-Saxons were in the western isles or even the west coast.
      Thanks for watching though!

    • @andrewheaney6858
      @andrewheaney6858 9 месяцев назад

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Go back and listen to to your opening narrative it’s as clear as day, from you reply though it’s sounds unintentional , thank you too for going to the trouble of making the video it’s very good, history matters and has brought us to where we are today, Slainte Pal

  • @serviustullus7204
    @serviustullus7204 Год назад

    It was likely a territory of Gaels since 200 bce.

  • @richardvanderpoll6885
    @richardvanderpoll6885 9 месяцев назад

    I hope you do not regard that as a great achievement.....

  • @oldmacdreadapexriddims1460
    @oldmacdreadapexriddims1460 Год назад +12

    To this day I never trust a Campbell

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios  Год назад +3

      Given the last one to carry the name who held a prominent position in government (New Labour spin doctor Alasdair), we don’t blame you.

    • @haraldtheyounger5504
      @haraldtheyounger5504 Год назад +1

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Yep, even back then the Campbell's were doing the dirty work on behalf of those in London. There's a great video done by Scotland History Tours on RUclips about the massacre... ruclips.net/video/-FZktUwCgk8/видео.html

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Год назад +1

      When the Great Liar needed a mouthpiece his hireling was a Campbell.

    • @jordanmcdonald437
      @jordanmcdonald437 Год назад +1

      Me neither

    • @hilariousname6826
      @hilariousname6826 Год назад

      Ah! Spite is so wonderfully satisfying, isn't it?

  • @Duececoupe
    @Duececoupe Год назад

    Old Norse (Swede) sitting in Glasgow taking notes, to retake the islands....🪓⚔️😉

    • @Sofia.K.CheerYT
      @Sofia.K.CheerYT 9 месяцев назад

      IKEA got there first mate... those cinnamon buns (fika) 😍 ahhh