Linux and Freecad , running on a 14-year-old I3 computer While it may not be Formula 1 or aerospace level , its ok for a daily driver , brackets, space gears, assembly etc ... and as the name suggest ,,,its "free" however its nice if you put back into the community
CatiaV5 was the worst CAD system I ever had to use, the UI made absolutely NO sense at all. The order of sub menues, the layout of them and the sometimes wierd sequences of clicking on things that you normally don't need using other functions, in order to get simple things done, made CatiaV5 so bad and user unfriendly, they had to write several 500 page books about it... let that sink in I hope you put in serious time in the UI layout and design in V6
@@jordanmclaughlin3312 I personally recommend Fusion 360 from Autodesk, it is self-explanatory and modular, so you only book what you need. The collaboration functions are also verry esay to use and verry helpful.
Interesting, but I have to say my BS alarm starts going off when somebody talks about eliminating the need for physical prototyping. One of the industries highlighted - automotive - still uses clay models for finalizing the body of a car. And even very expensive industries like aerospace still test aircraft before going into production (hence the continued existence of test pilots).
Hi, it's certainly true that many industries still require physical prototypes for the final stages of the design process but virtual testing tools such as SIMULIA play an important part in those industries by reducing the amount of prototype iterations required. We'll be releasing a similar "What is SIMULIA?" video shortly where we can go more in depth into this topic. Also, if you're interested, this short video on our website also highlights some of the ways the aerospace industry test fluid dynamics with SIMULIA - www.solidsolutions.co.uk/solidworks-videos/evaluating-aircraft-aerodynamic-performance-with-simulia.aspx
@@TriMechGroup you're right, through simulation there's a lot of improvement in manufacture processes, and if you use a high quality software like COMSOL instead of SIMULIA you can expect realistic results instead of child's play results like in SIMULIA.
I am currently studying mechanical engineering and run solidworks on an intel MacBook Pro 16" via bootcamp. Seeing the performance of the new M1 MacBook Pros I'd really love to have solidworks running on MacOs natively
not gonna to happen since the price of the software is worth several PC workstations... why bother port and maintain cross platform software (also macOS is very niche in CAD...)
SolidWorks is more widely applicable but it depends on the industry you plan on going into after school. As discussed in the video, CATIA is often the software of choice in aerospace and automotive. SolidWorks is a good base to learn though for all 3D modeling so I’ll agree with the other commentor.
Dassault bought Solidworks in order to use the Solidworks platform for Catia V5. They’re similar but Catia has more functionality and modules. Learn Solidworks first. Then Catia won’t feel like a foreign language should you choose to pursue it.
I don't know why CATIA V5 is still around, it's ridiculously dated, it still dose surfacing well, but it take ten times the effort, it's just missing all the quality of life improvements of the last 10 years.
Its amazing ow the windowing system and user interface design motief is still in the Vista era. It just looks outdated and slow. You really dont want software that looks like its going to crash. it doenst matter if it does or not, it needs to look like its not going to crash. the nicer and more modern the interface the more sales of the system.
Alias is a good vertical tool for CAID (computer aided industrial design). Catia is a complex software suite including many different surface modules which can go well beyond that (but you need to know which one to choose for a given task).
@@pr00009 yeah unparalelled user unfriendly and restrictive... Siemens and even Autodesk Fusion do better jobs in making surface modeling easy and straight forward to use.
Catia is the flagship product of one of the most absolutely terrible companies in the 3d design world. There are no resources to learn it. They want you to pay an insane amount of money to get into it.. yes, it’s good software. but other software is quickly approaching the same level. Once Boeing drops Catia this arrogance will change. Even in the ad video that dude is threatening you that if you don’t get it, you won’t be able to work with other companies. doesn’t talk about how great the software is just that won’t work because they’ve cornered the market so pay their damn bill.
Yo simplemente no logro hacer clic con NX. Tiene todo incluido, pero sus funciones más básicas se sienten simplemente limitadas, incluso comparándola con SolidWorks por ejemplo. El modelado de superficies es terrible
Linux and Freecad , running on a 14-year-old I3 computer While it may not be Formula 1 or aerospace level , its ok for a daily driver , brackets, space gears, assembly etc ... and as the name suggest ,,,its "free" however its nice if you put back into the community
CatiaV5 was the worst CAD system I ever had to use, the UI made absolutely NO sense at all. The order of sub menues, the layout of them and the sometimes wierd sequences of clicking on things that you normally don't need using other functions, in order to get simple things done, made CatiaV5 so bad and user unfriendly, they had to write several 500 page books about it... let that sink in
I hope you put in serious time in the UI layout and design in V6
100% Yes
100 percent YES... CATIA V5 ever used most ugly UI
true
@@jordanmclaughlin3312 I personally recommend Fusion 360 from Autodesk, it is self-explanatory and modular, so you only book what you need. The collaboration functions are also verry esay to use and verry helpful.
@@dunichtich100 been using fusion for almost 2 years and it's great on many points, my only complain is how laggy the program is
Interesting, but I have to say my BS alarm starts going off when somebody talks about eliminating the need for physical prototyping. One of the industries highlighted - automotive - still uses clay models for finalizing the body of a car. And even very expensive industries like aerospace still test aircraft before going into production (hence the continued existence of test pilots).
Hi, it's certainly true that many industries still require physical prototypes for the final stages of the design process but virtual testing tools such as SIMULIA play an important part in those industries by reducing the amount of prototype iterations required. We'll be releasing a similar "What is SIMULIA?" video shortly where we can go more in depth into this topic. Also, if you're interested, this short video on our website also highlights some of the ways the aerospace industry test fluid dynamics with SIMULIA - www.solidsolutions.co.uk/solidworks-videos/evaluating-aircraft-aerodynamic-performance-with-simulia.aspx
@@TriMechGroup you're right, through simulation there's a lot of improvement in manufacture processes, and if you use a high quality software like COMSOL instead of SIMULIA you can expect realistic results instead of child's play results like in SIMULIA.
@@TriMechGroup next video
What is delmia ?
What is simulia ?
I am currently studying mechanical engineering and run solidworks on an intel MacBook Pro 16" via bootcamp. Seeing the performance of the new M1 MacBook Pros I'd really love to have solidworks running on MacOs natively
not gonna to happen since the price of the software is worth several PC workstations... why bother port and maintain cross platform software (also macOS is very niche in CAD...)
The interface is very tiring to use.
as an industrial engineering student, should I learn CATIA or SolidWorks first?
My vote goes to SolidWorks, but I'm biased since it is what I use.
@@Kroasis thanks
SolidWorks is more widely applicable but it depends on the industry you plan on going into after school. As discussed in the video, CATIA is often the software of choice in aerospace and automotive. SolidWorks is a good base to learn though for all 3D modeling so I’ll agree with the other commentor.
Dassault bought Solidworks in order to use the Solidworks platform for Catia V5. They’re similar but Catia has more functionality and modules. Learn Solidworks first. Then Catia won’t feel like a foreign language should you choose to pursue it.
Don not use SolidWorks first . Because it make CATIA ridiculous for you Use the funny CATIA product before
I don't know why CATIA V5 is still around, it's ridiculously dated, it still dose surfacing well, but it take ten times the effort, it's just missing all the quality of life improvements of the last 10 years.
the ui. lmao
@@gokiburi-chan4255 yes it's pure garbage
Thanks for the presentation!
Who is owner of the files created ?
Awesome video! I now understand much more!
How to enroll
Can you provide a full tutorial?
Its amazing ow the windowing system and user interface design motief is still in the Vista era. It just looks outdated and slow. You really dont want software that looks like its going to crash. it doenst matter if it does or not, it needs to look like its not going to crash. the nicer and more modern the interface the more sales of the system.
Hey there! Have you checked out 3DEXPERIENCE CATIA? That's a swanky, fresh interface to design in! Have a look here: enterprise.trimech.com/catia/
Anyone else with Team SolidWorks?
yeahhh this feels like a dumbed down version of solidworks
@@MichaelJacobi687 It kind of is. I completely agree with the comment above this, the guy roasting v5.
Agreed, however, SW does not do relations like CATIA does
Team Fusion 360!
Yes here
The surface modeling functionality is in competition with, Autodesk Alias?
Alias is a good vertical tool for CAID (computer aided industrial design). Catia is a complex software suite including many different surface modules which can go well beyond that (but you need to know which one to choose for a given task).
oh yeah. totally. surface modelling of catia is unparalleled
@@pr00009 yeah unparalelled user unfriendly and restrictive... Siemens and even Autodesk Fusion do better jobs in making surface modeling easy and straight forward to use.
Rhino is the most popular program for making complex, organic surfaces.
Solidworks is best
Does it work in Linux?
Fusion 360, and keycreator..
Yea, it may work on the screen but anything complex MUST do prototype testing. Or shit be falling out of the sky.
3D expierience is very bad, CATIA V5 is more reliable and way better in every aspect just because it's offline.
@Smithy18 who cares? That's a separate program
By far...Catia is our GOD.
Not perfectly has developed by French university..
c'tia...c'tia... c'tia
CA TI A ffs
AAAAAAAAAAAA like in ALABAMA
CA-TI-A
I am sure he also say C'D... Computer 'sisted Design
What a weird thing to whine about.
Ever heard of regional accents?
@@Cbricklyne sure, I've also heard of nucular accents.
Catia is the flagship product of one of the most absolutely terrible companies in the 3d design world. There are no resources to learn it. They want you to pay an insane amount of money to get into it.. yes, it’s good software. but other software is quickly approaching the same level. Once Boeing drops Catia this arrogance will change. Even in the ad video that dude is threatening you that if you don’t get it, you won’t be able to work with other companies. doesn’t talk about how great the software is just that won’t work because they’ve cornered the market so pay their damn bill.
siemens nx es mejor
Yo simplemente no logro hacer clic con NX. Tiene todo incluido, pero sus funciones más básicas se sienten simplemente limitadas, incluso comparándola con SolidWorks por ejemplo. El modelado de superficies es terrible
Sin embargo quiero darle otra oportunidad. Dónde se puede aprender bien NX sobretodo modelado avanzado de superficies
What a wasted show. This is more like bragging than a tutorial of how it's used. I cut my teeth on CATIA in the 80's & I see it's still breathing...