JP, can we get a take on this overall situation we have with how narratives are always changing. If Alabama gets in with 3 losses they say some 2 loss weaker teams will get skipped over. Bama had the better wins and tougher schedule. Ok 👍. So how in the heck do they have Ashton Jeanty as a Heisman candidate playing a Mountain West schedule and Dylan Sampson is nowhere near it playing in the SEC? He’s not even on the Doak Walker list. Do they devalue the toughness of playing in the SEC with elite stats or what?
GA vs Tenn in the first round of the playoff is perfectly stupid. Thank you CFP for giving us a game no one wants to see again. There should be no first round conference rematches and no head to heads.
Alabama at 13 after receiving a 3rd loss (2nd to a non ranked opponent) is ridiculous, especially after Georgia dropped from 3 to 12 after their 2nd loss….that was to a ranked team….
It would not matter if they had 5 loses. Everyone knows how to beat BAMA now, so they are just taking up a spot:) Another Participation Trophy for BAMA:)
LSU was in the same exact spot last year, FSU was 9-3 at the 13th spot in 2022, 4 teams were 9-3 and ranked in the 9, 10, 11, 12 spots in 2018, Stanford was 9-3 ranked 12 in 2017, 3 teams were 9-3 and ranked 11, 12, and 13 in 2016 and ole miss was 9-3 and ranked 13 in 2015. This is normal, relax
The majority of college football want SOS tied to the winning percentage of your opponents. Because if it was tied to the quality of the teams you face, it'll lean heavily in favor of the SEC & B1G. And the majority don't want us to have another benefit to take advantage of.
They say late season performance matters. They say SOS matters. They say eye test matters. They say quality wins matters. They say all this til it’s time to bounce Bama from the rankings
Im thankful for Academy for making the show free Josh, but i just want to say this is the only RUclips show ive watched over the years I would enthusiastically pay to watch 3 times a week. Have a great Thanksgiving Josh and producer Jesse
Tennessee would have to lose also. If they win they are #8 and would move up with a Texas and Georgia loss and earn a bid in the SEC conference championship.
@@user-tz2zz5ij1sthat’s not how that works, GT is not in the SEC so Georgia has already clinched a championship spot; winner of TAMU-TU gets in the championship as well
Josh, I love the show and have watched every episode since the 2020 *offseason*. Auto-bids, while broken, have been responsible for adding such high stakes to so many games late into November this season. I mean, without the auto-bids, are you going to Arizona state vs BYU in November? Think about how auto-bids have brought playoff life and hope to teams like SMU, Iowa State, A&M, Arizona State, and more up to the very last regular season game of the year! While there are things to correct with the 12-team playoff EXPERIMENT, you can’t deny that it has ADDED luster to the regular season instead of DIMINISHED it. Regardless, keep up the good work and commentary
It's more about the auto bids/conference champions having first round byes, that is the problem. I don't mind the auto bids but put them ranked where they should be in the bracket. Currently Ohio Stank, Georgia, Oregon and Texas should have first round byes, but instead some ACC team and B12 team will most likely get 2 of the byes.
For real. Every problem he has I hear and I think "that's so sick" auto bids will make college football even and balanced because everyone is going to get a chance to win a championship not just two conferences
If the committee wants this dance to last they need to put their actual 4 best teams in 4 different corners of the bracket. We don’t need another tcu incident in a 12 team field deep into the playoffs
Happy to know you are still alive and ticking. I came here many times last night and this morning (Wednesday) and just now got the show this afternoon. ???
Hey JP ! Love the show and I watch weekly. What would take the YT production to the next level would be a list of timestamped topics in the description! That way, it'd be easier to reference when talking with friends, making bets, etc. Thanks!
Shocker… Josh has ND on upset alert for 4th game in a row. ND has beaten the past 3 opponents (whom Josh put Nd on upset alert against) by a combined 136-31… give me ND 35, USC 21
@@jonnyw2323 if you consider 14 points to be close, I guess? The spread is 7.5, and it would be the 4th “closest” game ND has played this year, so I don’t consider that close, but I guess it’s subjective.
Norte dame is and has been so overrated for years and continually choke. I get he’s picked that the past few weeks but every year they eventually do so it’s not crazy for him to say bc it will happen at some point. They’ll win 1 playoff game max.
New Windsor Marylaad Buckeye here. I love your show, Josh. Even when I don't agree with you. I love your presentation. Always informative and entertaining.
Joshua Joshua Joshua, this many late games have never been so important ever. The excitement is off the chain. The 12 team playoff is rocket fuel for college football. 🔥💥
And yet you don't see how you're being baited. You're given a taste of what could be to only capitulate when they change the format in their favor. They're making it so enticing that you'll do whatever it takes to keep it going or frustrate you to want to take the ball and go do your own thing. History will decide who's right.
@jimmyjam5453 that may be true for you and the G5. But the top of college football has changed. The entire year used to have playoff ramifications, and now they can lose 2 or 3 games. Those 2 or 3 games used to determine if your season is over. Now you'll be bitching about how Bama or Georgia still has a shot if they have 3 losses.
I predict that Auburn and Alabama BOTH lose the Iron Bowl. The time-space continimuninuum will split off and losses appear for both teams. And Notre Dame ends the year UNDEFEATED after getting blown out in the first round. Top those picks.
Not much point in ND scheduling and winning at A&M if people like Josh ignore it. Kyle Field is a tough place to win, especially when A&M had Moss. If Nd had lost that game, we would hear about it constantly. But ND won, so it is simply ignored.
If you have to hang your hat on one game, then you're no different from a G5 team. You'll need to come up with a different argument. That's not mentioning your biggest flaw. Nobody has an easier path to the playoffs than ND. Nobody! Personally, I believe that's by design. I believe it was designed that way to get ND used to the playoffs, so when they change the format... ND will be forced to join a conference (B1G) to continue the access. (That's 100% my conspiracy theory, and time will tell)
@@tremoore9831we can't get a 1st round bye, the 1st round of the playoffs is our conference championship game. It's completely opposite of your point. The committee is treating ND if we are a top team like a conference loser and ND isn't going to give up it's independence with a deal like that. ND has also scheduled Texas and Alabama in their future schedules. We scheduled a&m for a home and home. We play Clemson occasionally and USC every year. We scheduled Georgia home and home a few years back and lost at Georgia by a few points it's not like we don't schedule big time teams. ND is not going to be forced into a conference anytime soon with a playoff format, it's the opposite.
@tremoore9831 everyone in the top 5 is hanging their hat on one game lol... Texas is getting credit for who they lost to...penn st is getting credit for who they lost to... Indiana is getting credit for who they lost to and it should be who you beat..the only team that can hang there hat on more than one game is Georgia but they lost 2 games to team's that lost 3 games
You are so right and it is so wrong, when you said the runner up in SEC Championship would be left out of the playoff. Imagine if Georgia loses to Texas. Oh and by the way, Texas lost to Georgia earlier this year. That would be a travesty if someone like Bama gets in without playing an extra game, like Georgia may have to do. Total joke.
Dawg if Georgia lost to Texas in the SEC championship game they probably wouldn't even drop from 7. A&M is the only SEC "runner-up" that could be left out
I never get a shout-out for where I am listening from cause I live in Sweden and have to watch the replay in the morning when I wake up. The sad situation of an American in Sweden....... The time difference, I got to stay up till 1 in the morning some days to watch my Ducks. 😂 If it is a night game at Autzen I just wake up super early. 😂 But I have been known to pull an all nighter. 😅
I normally could care less or think about USC(Trogans) being a lifelong Georgia fan but crazy stat of year is they have led every game in the 4th guarter and have lost FIVE times. Wow!!
@CC-xh2qc Get it together Riley. Need USC to win this weekend. There's no reason Notre Dame or Penn State for that matter should be ranked higher than Georgia.
Big fan of the show, Josh. As a Texas alum who grew up in an A&M family, can confirm that the hate between these two fan bases runs deep. Can’t wait to raise hell at the Thanksgiving table this year.
Texas fans typically respect our most intense rival....OU. Sooners have a long winning history and something to begrudgingly respect. A$M on the other hand has never won anything of significance and act like they have. No ONE respects them especially Texas, which views them as equivalent to a weird cultist family member. Aggy is a damn embarrassment to the great state of Texas and its the University of Texas' job to always remind Aggy their role in society.
Good read on the Oregon Washington game. I knew the Wisconsin game would be tough. Oregon badly needed the break, is now at home, and absolutely hates the Huskies. 38-10 Ducks.
I knew gas is going to pick USC. He's been picking against Notre Dame all year. He's dying to see Notre Dame get beat. And he'll say it's not true but he doesn't like Notre Dame never has He's admitted that. I appreciate that he has admitted that. But I knew. Go Irish🍀🍀🍀
Ole Miss and Alabama both _should_ drop lower than that in a power/odds-making rating, because... Now that _everything_ in the college football world rises and sets on the playoff and nothing but the playoff, and it is suddenly known those teams will not make the playoff, many/most of their players (and probably coaches too) will be operating on low-effort cruise control for their final regular season game and bowl game. Their give-a-damn's busted. That's what the playoff era gets us.
Love the vibe on the show. I watch and like it. Agree with a lot of takes. But curious if Josh has actually watched Notre Dame play the last 4-5 weeks that he's had them on upset alert? Honest question.
Wow!!! KU is rated again. Never thought I’d see it again after the 1-5 start. And yes, I noticed that you tried warning Prime and the buffaloes about a potential upset. Odd fact because you mentioned USC leading every game in the 4th quarter. KU has led in all but one 4th quarter, and lost the lead to TCU with 2 minutes to go in the third. 6 Ls. Very proud of them not caving and coming back to the brink of bowl eligibility. Big big game for them against your number 25 Baylor for bowling on Saturday.
I thought the Big 12 champ gets an auto bid? Is it only the top 4 ranked conference champs? I.e if the G5 top ranked team is ranked above the Big 12 champ, then the Big 12 champ could be left out?
Is there a way to adjust your power ratings based on the failures of talent profile. I always feel like your model is just FanDuel light. And you often disagree with the model because it overrates teams based on preseason talent profile which should not be a factor in week 10
I don’t think the sec should not have to play each other in the first round of the playoffs because they have already played each other in the regular season.
Need Chuggy on the back shelf. Maybe do something from each trip, like a mini helmet, program, something subtle but clear. logistics might be too annoying or tough for that. Or do something that showcases where you are going. A Josh Pate for Commissioner sign would be nice too
To give the top seed a bye and then a neutral site game versus a home first round game against a lesser opponent is ridiculous. What did the top seed actually win?
Been watching A&M for 40 years and earned my degree there. Like all good rivalries there’s an underlying friendship, too. Check out the heart Texas showed in the game after the bonfire collapse and try not to shed a tear. Don’t worry: the game is still the game and we will be down for quite the gigging. BTHOtu! 👍
Let someone stand on the sideline with you and watch a game as a prize. For many of us that’s the ultimate prize getting to hang with you Josh and watch the game
On the Format…How in the world are they not reseeding after the first round like the NFL. I know the bracket isn’t set but theoretically if Arizona St. upsets OSU, how can you “reward” Oregon with a bye and then Georgia instead of letting them play the lowest rank team after the first round.
Partnering with QuikTrip is a great decision. They were created in my hometown “Tulsa” and they’re now the best gas station that exist. Plus it’s an actually one of the few gas station jobs that actually have a future and growth to them.
No DAWG in this point. ESPN said they see the committee picking teams not on just loses but how they are playing. If that’s true at all and South Carolina wins. They could/should go in over Bama if Bama doesn’t blow the roof off against Auburn. Can’t wait to watch DAWGS this Friday in Athens!
From where I sit Florida might be playing better than anyone not named Georgia in that conference. Just my opinion. But I'm not sure they will put much stock in a hot team. But S Carolina has the advantage of playing the 12th ranked team. And like mentioned, it would be hard to justify jumping ahead of Ole Miss or Bama based on head to head.... Unless of course they both lose.
@@feddyvonwigglestein3481 not sure what you mean? UGA fans and others say and spell dog=DAWG. It has been that way my whole life and I’m not far from Athens born and raised so I would know how we spell and say it lol. I guess if you need clarity I would say it’s a fan pride thing but also anytime you hear anyone on college game day or in the media talk about the DAWGS listen how they say it and you will know when they say dog or DAWG 🤣
@@lawrencematthes8948 Florida found a stride and honestly if Lagway didn’t go down during the cocktail party I am not convinced my inconsistent GA would have pulled that out. Unfortunately with head to head SC won’t get a shot unless like you said others lose. Would be interesting to see what the committee does if South Carolina blows the game up and the others lose or win unconvincingly. At the end of the day with any loss it’s a gamble this season. I will say the South Carolina team playing now is the one I’ve seen beat UGA and is among top teams in the country.
I agree 💯 on the USC game. Ohio St game too. Bama and Auburn is tuff. Did Auburn shoot their was last week or will lightning strike twice? This will be DeBore s biggest test as far as gauging his coaching acumen. He's fortunate it a home game this year.
Thank you so much for talking about how stupid the auto bids are. Ive been saying this since they announced the format last year. The 12 best teams should be in. Yes conference champs should be considered and winning your conference should give you a push towards going to the playoff, but it shouldn't automatically give you a ticket to the playoff
The problem with that is the cfp doesn’t need to be a conference tournament. Because it can be argued that the top 12 sec teams are better than Boise st or Indiana.
Bama was -13.5 against Oklahoma. It's why we play the games. With their rankings right now, Arizona State is still behind Bama and Ole Miss and would miss the playoff with no top 5 conference champion auto-bid. Determining the best teams should give plenty of weight to a conference champion. It helps eliminate the big conference bias and benefit of the doubt we see given to incredibly flawed teams like an Alabama.
Can’t even watch this show anymore. Was my favorite show. Now just gives me a headache. Also, 20 of my friends. Why do keep moving the camera????? What’s the point! Just keep it straight on Josh!
I have a playoff question. You hit on this, which is the only reason I am commenting. What would the point spread between Ga vs. Penn St? Ohio state? Notre Dame? Oregon? If it is to get the best teams to the top, does common sense EVER play in the consideration?
Gamecock living in Raleigh, NC. I hate the Tar Heels. Still, I have always respected (and almost liked) Mack Brown. The administration begged Brown to come out of retirement to put the program back on solid footing. He did that. The recruiting prowess of Brown is legendary, due in large part to his ability to connect with people.
I think it's great teams like boise state etc are rewarded with an autobid. Especially with jeanty in the heisman race. If they got rid of the autobids 3 loss sec and big 10 teams would be in every year. F that, id rather see a potential underdog in an upset as a fan.
I think your Floyd of Rosedale replica should be on the back shelf, no matter what else you get. Whomever sent you that should get ANOTHER Chalice, too.
But they do have wins over teams that were ranked when they played. Those teams fell out of the rankings after losing to Texas, and a&m is in the perfect position for that to happen to them too.
Rivalry weekend I got Texas winning a very close game at A&M 28-27, Quinn with a last second td I got the upset , I got Auburn upsetting Bama 27-24, I got osu beating Michigan in a closer game then what ppl will think. 34-24. I got sc beating Clemson 24-20
How do you have Ohio state over Oregon in the JP poll when Oregon beat them? Interesting take… I do 100% agree with the 5 seed issue. Realistically of things fall the way the bracket shows now, whoever loses the B1G championship game will absolutely have the easier path which would incentivize a team to punt on their most important game of the season (at that point anyways). I’ve always had the belief that the 12 team playoff should take the top 12 teams and create the bracket based on that. Unfortunately I don’t ever see that happening because then the conference championship games would be meaningless outside of bragging rights
I like Automatic Qualifiers. I think the problem is giving an AQ anything more than mere access. I treat it like the NCAA Basketball tourney, where the conf champs punch a ticket to the bracket, but are seeded where they are seeded. So like Boise for instance would be in, but are seeded based on ranking. Instead of being the 4 seed they would be at the 11. The other thing I would change is don't lock the bracket, There is no reason that the highest ranked/seeded team doesn't have to play the lowest seeded remaining team left on the bracket and the 2nd highest vs the 2nd lowest and so on.
Josh the reason why you haven't seen the Texas high gear from last year is very simple...they lost a dozen NFL level players. This team is heavily dependent on the portal for offensive skill players and they still haven't completely gelled. Maybe it happens this week?!? 🤘
Don’t understand why the playoff couldn’t just stay four teams with four conference champions on autobids. Simple, clear, and completely objective. Don’t like it cause your conference is too hard? Move to another one since apparently it’s so easy nowadays.
Keep the show free - SUBSCRIBE to the channel! - JP
JP, can we get a take on this overall situation we have with how narratives are always changing. If Alabama gets in with 3 losses they say some 2 loss weaker teams will get skipped over. Bama had the better wins and tougher schedule. Ok 👍. So how in the heck do they have Ashton Jeanty as a Heisman candidate playing a Mountain West schedule and Dylan Sampson is nowhere near it playing in the SEC? He’s not even on the Doak Walker list. Do they devalue the toughness of playing in the SEC with elite stats or what?
😂😅
This year feels like 2007 light but the off field drama cranked up 1000%.
Watch out for the Irish!
Josh Pate after dark goes hard.. immunity.
Does hit picks be hitting
Yup, some feelings got hurt. Good for Josh to let it out😊
Well played 🍻🤝😂
Nah take them Charges 😂😂😂
Just say pause after a comment like that or no Diddy 🤣
I agree with auto bids for champs. But they shouldn’t be seeded to top 4 automatically. It should be auto into the playoffs then seeded accordingly
That’s probably fair enough
2026 on should probably be back to 6x6 for the long haul
Agreed
@@insertcolorherehawk3761lol this will not happen. sec and big ten will bail before they get their lot limited to just 6 teams total
GA vs Tenn in the first round of the playoff is perfectly stupid. Thank you CFP for giving us a game no one wants to see again. There should be no first round conference rematches and no head to heads.
Tennessee is dogshit, nobody wants to see them in the playoffs at all. Praying Vandy knocks them out once and for all
Alabama at 13 after receiving a 3rd loss (2nd to a non ranked opponent) is ridiculous, especially after Georgia dropped from 3 to 12 after their 2nd loss….that was to a ranked team….
It would not matter if they had 5 loses. Everyone knows how to beat BAMA now, so they are just taking up a spot:) Another Participation Trophy for BAMA:)
LSU was in the same exact spot last year, FSU was 9-3 at the 13th spot in 2022, 4 teams were 9-3 and ranked in the 9, 10, 11, 12 spots in 2018, Stanford was 9-3 ranked 12 in 2017, 3 teams were 9-3 and ranked 11, 12, and 13 in 2016 and ole miss was 9-3 and ranked 13 in 2015. This is normal, relax
@@batmandeltaforcejust say you hate Baja’s former greatness
Whomst below them should be at 12 instead?
Ppl dont think before typing @@MeanSaltine14
Auto bids are not the problem. The problem is the auto first round bye week for the auto bids.
I think autobids is reeeeeetarded. However, you are correct. Giving them a first round bye is double dumbassery
Every week I check in to compare Josh's comments to NDs performance
Haha same. It’s been funny. He has been hating all year
He wants them to lose so his favorite team, Alabama, has a chance
Lmfao he’s gonna look so dumb when USC can’t score
I think SOS and the streak of SC should be noticed more
The majority of college football want SOS tied to the winning percentage of your opponents. Because if it was tied to the quality of the teams you face, it'll lean heavily in favor of the SEC & B1G. And the majority don't want us to have another benefit to take advantage of.
They say late season performance matters. They say SOS matters. They say eye test matters. They say quality wins matters. They say all this til it’s time to bounce Bama from the rankings
Im thankful for Academy for making the show free Josh, but i just want to say this is the only RUclips show ive watched over the years I would enthusiastically pay to watch 3 times a week. Have a great Thanksgiving Josh and producer Jesse
My favorite coach interview during the spring was with Coach Brown. He's an amazing person and a College Football treasure.
Nightmare Scenario - Georgia loses this week to Ga. Tech. A&M wins at home. SEC Championship is set with two teams not in the Top 12.
"On second thought, we actually love this playoff format!"
-SEC fans and execs if this happens
Tennessee would have to lose also. If they win they are #8 and would move up with a Texas and Georgia loss and earn a bid in the SEC conference championship.
@@user-tz2zz5ij1sthat’s not how that works, GT is not in the SEC so Georgia has already clinched a championship spot; winner of TAMU-TU gets in the championship as well
Well well well
Georgia won in 8ot
Josh, I love the show and have watched every episode since the 2020 *offseason*. Auto-bids, while broken, have been responsible for adding such high stakes to so many games late into November this season. I mean, without the auto-bids, are you going to Arizona state vs BYU in November? Think about how auto-bids have brought playoff life and hope to teams like SMU, Iowa State, A&M, Arizona State, and more up to the very last regular season game of the year! While there are things to correct with the 12-team playoff EXPERIMENT, you can’t deny that it has ADDED luster to the regular season instead of DIMINISHED it. Regardless, keep up the good work and commentary
Yeah it has added luster to some games for some teams that have no business being in the position to be in the playoffs in the first place
It's more about the auto bids/conference champions having first round byes, that is the problem. I don't mind the auto bids but put them ranked where they should be in the bracket. Currently Ohio Stank, Georgia, Oregon and Texas should have first round byes, but instead some ACC team and B12 team will most likely get 2 of the byes.
That’s true but it’s supposed to get the 12 best teams, right? But I see your point. As long as bama doesn’t get in I’m ok!
For real. Every problem he has I hear and I think "that's so sick" auto bids will make college football even and balanced because everyone is going to get a chance to win a championship not just two conferences
I can see autobids, but I think they should reseed the teams after the 12 are selected.
If the committee wants this dance to last they need to put their actual 4 best teams in 4 different corners of the bracket. We don’t need another tcu incident in a 12 team field deep into the playoffs
Automatic bids is dumbassery. All it will give us is terrible football
From one Georgian to another... HAPPY THANKSGIVING, @Josh! 🦃🍽️🏈🥧
Happy Thanksgiving from Gwinnett County!
Dekalb here... Happy Thanksgiving!
Happy to know you are still alive and ticking. I came here many times last night and this morning (Wednesday) and just now got the show this afternoon. ???
Josh please talk about Dylan Sampson not being in the final 3 RB award rankings. Ridiculous
Absolutely ridiculous. Shameful.
Not really. Jeanty and Johnson are obvious. Hampton is about to put up back to back years of 1500 rushing yards
Jeanty hasn't played the type of competition Sampson has by a country mile@@captainspartan04
Hey JP ! Love the show and I watch weekly. What would take the YT production to the next level would be a list of timestamped topics in the description! That way, it'd be easier to reference when talking with friends, making bets, etc. Thanks!
lol return to to LAAAAAATTTE kick
If anyone thinks Ohio state vs Michigan is a guaranteed win for OSU doesn’t know football rivalry games are immune to the script
Keep up the great work been watching you for years. Watching now from the Mississippi river on a towboat.
Where at on the Mississippi?
@jeremiahbird930 up by st gen going to heading to the hole
Anywhere near Tennessee?
@@pleaseclap5210 no but I do run up to Chattanooga sometimes
Shocker… Josh has ND on upset alert for 4th game in a row. ND has beaten the past 3 opponents (whom Josh put Nd on upset alert against) by a combined 136-31… give me ND 35, USC 21
Just cuz he puts em on upset alert doesn’t mean he thinks they’ll be upset. And they got smacked by niu so why wouldn’t he. Notre dame = trash
Soo you agree it’ll be close lol?
@@jonnyw2323 if you consider 14 points to be close, I guess? The spread is 7.5, and it would be the 4th “closest” game ND has played this year, so I don’t consider that close, but I guess it’s subjective.
@@jonnyw2323Two tuds isn’t close. It implies that at least an eighth of the game, if not closer to a quarter, was dominated by the winner.
Norte dame is and has been so overrated for years and continually choke. I get he’s picked that the past few weeks but every year they eventually do so it’s not crazy for him to say bc it will happen at some point. They’ll win 1 playoff game max.
New Windsor Marylaad Buckeye here. I love your show, Josh. Even when I don't agree with you. I love your presentation.
Always informative and entertaining.
Watching from Wichita Falls Texas....really appreciate you and your team Josh!!😁🤘🤘
Im moving there in a couple days. I was surprised it got on the shout out list lol
For a compromise, just keep the auto bids but don’t have any impact on seeding. Just like the NCAA basketball tournament
All of the talking heads are praying Notre Dame losses because they don’t own their television rights
Joshua Joshua Joshua, this many late games have never been so important ever. The excitement is off the chain. The 12 team playoff is rocket fuel for college football. 🔥💥
With garbage conferences
And yet you don't see how you're being baited. You're given a taste of what could be to only capitulate when they change the format in their favor. They're making it so enticing that you'll do whatever it takes to keep it going or frustrate you to want to take the ball and go do your own thing.
History will decide who's right.
@@tremoore9831 not at all ....Josh said the regular season would lose it's luster but the opposite has happened. That's it.
@@colepriceguitar1153 what are you talking about, the SEC?
@jimmyjam5453 that may be true for you and the G5. But the top of college football has changed. The entire year used to have playoff ramifications, and now they can lose 2 or 3 games. Those 2 or 3 games used to determine if your season is over. Now you'll be bitching about how Bama or Georgia still has a shot if they have 3 losses.
Thanks for waiting for the Zips and Rockets to wrap before starting the show.
Gross. Like torturing yourself?
I predict that Auburn and Alabama BOTH lose the Iron Bowl.
The time-space continimuninuum will split off and losses appear for both teams. And Notre Dame ends the year UNDEFEATED after getting blown out in the first round. Top those picks.
Not much point in ND scheduling and winning at A&M if people like Josh ignore it. Kyle Field is a tough place to win, especially when A&M had Moss. If Nd had lost that game, we would hear about it constantly. But ND won, so it is simply ignored.
At this point I think memaw indoctrinated josh into hating ND
If you have to hang your hat on one game, then you're no different from a G5 team. You'll need to come up with a different argument. That's not mentioning your biggest flaw.
Nobody has an easier path to the playoffs than ND. Nobody! Personally, I believe that's by design. I believe it was designed that way to get ND used to the playoffs, so when they change the format... ND will be forced to join a conference (B1G) to continue the access. (That's 100% my conspiracy theory, and time will tell)
Also don’t lose to a MAC team at home
@@tremoore9831we can't get a 1st round bye, the 1st round of the playoffs is our conference championship game. It's completely opposite of your point. The committee is treating ND if we are a top team like a conference loser and ND isn't going to give up it's independence with a deal like that. ND has also scheduled Texas and Alabama in their future schedules. We scheduled a&m for a home and home. We play Clemson occasionally and USC every year. We scheduled Georgia home and home a few years back and lost at Georgia by a few points it's not like we don't schedule big time teams. ND is not going to be forced into a conference anytime soon with a playoff format, it's the opposite.
@tremoore9831 everyone in the top 5 is hanging their hat on one game lol... Texas is getting credit for who they lost to...penn st is getting credit for who they lost to... Indiana is getting credit for who they lost to and it should be who you beat..the only team that can hang there hat on more than one game is Georgia but they lost 2 games to team's that lost 3 games
You are so right and it is so wrong, when you said the runner up in SEC Championship would be left out of the playoff. Imagine if Georgia loses to Texas. Oh and by the way, Texas lost to Georgia earlier this year. That would be a travesty if someone like Bama gets in without playing an extra game, like Georgia may have to do. Total joke.
😂💔😂
Dawg if Georgia lost to Texas in the SEC championship game they probably wouldn't even drop from 7.
A&M is the only SEC "runner-up" that could be left out
I think he was saying more if A&M got in, they could be left out. Texas Vs Georgia, both teams would be in.
UGA would be in over any other SEC team including Tennessee
A&M probably would deserve to miss the playoff though
I never get a shout-out for where I am listening from cause I live in Sweden and have to watch the replay in the morning when I wake up. The sad situation of an American in Sweden....... The time difference, I got to stay up till 1 in the morning some days to watch my Ducks. 😂 If it is a night game at Autzen I just wake up super early. 😂 But I have been known to pull an all nighter. 😅
I normally could care less or think about USC(Trogans) being a lifelong Georgia fan but crazy stat of year is they have led every game in the 4th guarter and have lost FIVE times. Wow!!
That's because Riley is a great coordinator who can build a lead but a terrible head coach and can't close a game.
@CC-xh2qc Get it together Riley. Need USC to win this weekend. There's no reason Notre Dame or Penn State for that matter should be ranked higher than Georgia.
what's with the deck chair format. we need the news desk back
Big fan of the show, Josh. As a Texas alum who grew up in an A&M family, can confirm that the hate between these two fan bases runs deep. Can’t wait to raise hell at the Thanksgiving table this year.
Texas fans typically respect our most intense rival....OU. Sooners have a long winning history and something to begrudgingly respect.
A$M on the other hand has never won anything of significance and act like they have. No ONE respects them especially Texas, which views them as equivalent to a weird cultist family member.
Aggy is a damn embarrassment to the great state of Texas and its the University of Texas' job to always remind Aggy their role in society.
Good read on the Oregon Washington game. I knew the Wisconsin game would be tough. Oregon badly needed the break, is now at home, and absolutely hates the Huskies. 38-10 Ducks.
Great Show!
My hometown, Ocilla, GA, with a shout-out! Josh even pernounced it correctly. Good job, sir!
We’re watching in Canberra, Australia Josh
Do you guys watch American College Football? I’m legit curious, no disrespect at all.
That’s how you know Late Kick really is late tonight
Great information, great show.👍
I knew gas is going to pick USC. He's been picking against Notre Dame all year. He's dying to see Notre Dame get beat. And he'll say it's not true but he doesn't like Notre Dame never has He's admitted that. I appreciate that he has admitted that. But I knew. Go Irish🍀🍀🍀
Ole Miss and Alabama both _should_ drop lower than that in a power/odds-making rating, because... Now that _everything_ in the college football world rises and sets on the playoff and nothing but the playoff, and it is suddenly known those teams will not make the playoff, many/most of their players (and probably coaches too) will be operating on low-effort cruise control for their final regular season game and bowl game. Their give-a-damn's busted. That's what the playoff era gets us.
No they shouldn’t because the JP poll favors star rating of players way too much
Love the vibe on the show. I watch and like it. Agree with a lot of takes. But curious if Josh has actually watched Notre Dame play the last 4-5 weeks that he's had them on upset alert? Honest question.
Since we're redoing 2007 it's only appropriate that we get another UGA - Hawaii type of bowl game
Wow!!!
KU is rated again. Never thought I’d see it again after the 1-5 start.
And yes, I noticed that you tried warning Prime and the buffaloes about a potential upset.
Odd fact because you mentioned USC leading every game in the 4th quarter. KU has led in all but one 4th quarter, and lost the lead to TCU with 2 minutes to go in the third. 6 Ls. Very proud of them not caving and coming back to the brink of bowl eligibility.
Big big game for them against your number 25 Baylor for bowling on Saturday.
Why cant the bracket be set up using the point spreads? Put the teams together that has a close spread. Please answer if you can.
I thought the Big 12 champ gets an auto bid? Is it only the top 4 ranked conference champs? I.e if the G5 top ranked team is ranked above the Big 12 champ, then the Big 12 champ could be left out?
Is there a way to adjust your power ratings based on the failures of talent profile. I always feel like your model is just FanDuel light. And you often disagree with the model because it overrates teams based on preseason talent profile which should not be a factor in week 10
I don’t think the sec should not have to play each other in the first round of the playoffs because they have already played each other in the regular season.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 then they should stop losing so many games this year.
@@jimmyjam5453 when you play in the toughest conference in the America you are bound to lose games
Need Chuggy on the back shelf. Maybe do something from each trip, like a mini helmet, program, something subtle but clear. logistics might be too annoying or tough for that.
Or do something that showcases where you are going.
A Josh Pate for Commissioner sign would be nice too
To give the top seed a bye and then a neutral site game versus a home first round game against a lesser opponent is ridiculous. What did the top seed actually win?
If we can’t agree on how to rank the teams how do we solve that? maybe use something objective like maybe conference championships, just an idea
Can someone please explain why Penn State is ranked so high? They’ve had the same season as Indiana
1:07:30 anyone know who he's referring to that didn't cite matt zenitz?
I too am from southwest Ga and have always had a soft spot in my heart for Iowa State. Always loved to start a dynasty with them in NCAA
My Power Ratings #4:
Rating. Team and Mascot (Difference in my power ratings since last week)
1. Ohio State Buckeyes (- -)
2. Oregon Ducks (+1)
3. Georgia Bulldogs (+1)
4. Texas Longhorns (+1)
5. Notre Dame Fighting Irish (+1)
6. Penn State Nittany Lions (+2)
7. Miami (FL) Hurricanes (+5)
8. Ole Miss Rebels (-6)
9. Tennessee Volunteers (- -)
10. Alabama Crimson Tide (-3)
11. Indiana Hoosiers (-1)
12. South Carolina Gamecocks (+3)
13. SMU Mustangs (-2)
14. Clemson Tigers (-1)
15. Arizona State Sun Devils (+6)
16. Kansas State Wildcats (+3)
17. Tulane Green Wave (+6)
18. Florida Gators (NEW)
19. Boise State Broncos (-1)
20. Texas A&M Aggies (-6)
21. Iowa State Cyclones (RETURN)
22. Colorado Buffaloes (-6)
23. Louisville Cardinals (RETURN)
24. UNLV Rebels (NEW)
25. Kansas Jayhawks (NEW)
Been watching A&M for 40 years and earned my degree there. Like all good rivalries there’s an underlying friendship, too. Check out the heart Texas showed in the game after the bonfire collapse and try not to shed a tear. Don’t worry: the game is still the game and we will be down for quite the gigging. BTHOtu! 👍
As an Alabama fan for much of the last 50 years, this is the first year that I have ever been unsure whether Alabama will beat Auburn.
Let someone stand on the sideline with you and watch a game as a prize. For many of us that’s the ultimate prize getting to hang with you Josh and watch the game
A desk or table of some kind is needed my friend… feel like I’m watching a college football interrogation hostage video lol
Josh, you might have to have a collection of every teams helmets and rotate them every show or you’ll be accused of being biased lol
P5 Pate, show some love to G5 now and again
On the Format…How in the world are they not reseeding after the first round like the NFL.
I know the bracket isn’t set but theoretically if Arizona St. upsets OSU, how can you “reward” Oregon with a bye and then Georgia instead of letting them play the lowest rank team after the first round.
Partnering with QuikTrip is a great decision. They were created in my hometown “Tulsa” and they’re now the best gas station that exist. Plus it’s an actually one of the few gas station jobs that actually have a future and growth to them.
Mack Brown 🤘🧡🤘
When Josh said Georgia “clinched the East” it got me
No DAWG in this point. ESPN said they see the committee picking teams not on just loses but how they are playing. If that’s true at all and South Carolina wins. They could/should go in over Bama if Bama doesn’t blow the roof off against Auburn. Can’t wait to watch DAWGS this Friday in Athens!
From where I sit Florida might be playing better than anyone not named Georgia in that conference. Just my opinion. But I'm not sure they will put much stock in a hot team. But S Carolina has the advantage of playing the 12th ranked team. And like mentioned, it would be hard to justify jumping ahead of Ole Miss or Bama based on head to head.... Unless of course they both lose.
I got Vanderbilt with +10.5 and on the money line
Why are UGAY fans so obnoxious? Nobody refers to your team the way you do
@@feddyvonwigglestein3481 not sure what you mean? UGA fans and others say and spell dog=DAWG. It has been that way my whole life and I’m not far from Athens born and raised so I would know how we spell and say it lol. I guess if you need clarity I would say it’s a fan pride thing but also anytime you hear anyone on college game day or in the media talk about the DAWGS listen how they say it and you will know when they say dog or DAWG 🤣
@@lawrencematthes8948 Florida found a stride and honestly if Lagway didn’t go down during the cocktail party I am not convinced my inconsistent GA would have pulled that out. Unfortunately with head to head SC won’t get a shot unless like you said others lose. Would be interesting to see what the committee does if South Carolina blows the game up and the others lose or win unconvincingly. At the end of the day with any loss it’s a gamble this season. I will say the South Carolina team playing now is the one I’ve seen beat UGA and is among top teams in the country.
I agree 💯 on the USC game. Ohio St game too. Bama and Auburn is tuff. Did Auburn shoot their was last week or will lightning strike twice? This will be DeBore s biggest test as far as gauging his coaching acumen. He's fortunate it a home game this year.
Thank you so much for talking about how stupid the auto bids are. Ive been saying this since they announced the format last year. The 12 best teams should be in. Yes conference champs should be considered and winning your conference should give you a push towards going to the playoff, but it shouldn't automatically give you a ticket to the playoff
The problem with that is the cfp doesn’t need to be a conference tournament. Because it can be argued that the top 12 sec teams are better than Boise st or Indiana.
Bama was -13.5 against Oklahoma. It's why we play the games. With their rankings right now, Arizona State is still behind Bama and Ole Miss and would miss the playoff with no top 5 conference champion auto-bid. Determining the best teams should give plenty of weight to a conference champion. It helps eliminate the big conference bias and benefit of the doubt we see given to incredibly flawed teams like an Alabama.
@@footballfreek975I can assure you IU is a top 12 SEC team. I’m not even an IU defender
@@bucks33331 well the one time Indiana played a decent team they got their brains blown out
@@bucks33331 Yeah no doubt. Indiana is a solid squad and is certainly a playoff team this year.... Boise St - not so much.
Can’t even watch this show anymore. Was my favorite show. Now just gives me a headache. Also, 20 of my friends. Why do keep moving the camera????? What’s the point! Just keep it straight on Josh!
I’m just not convinced Josh has watched a Notre Dame game lately. This running game and defense looks a lot like Michigan a year ago.
I have a playoff question. You hit on this, which is the only reason I am commenting. What would the point spread between Ga vs. Penn St? Ohio state? Notre Dame? Oregon? If it is to get the best teams to the top, does common sense EVER play in the consideration?
He actually did post this a while back, I think a few weeks ago Georgia would've been favored -1.5 @PSU 👍🏼
Thanks Pate!! Go Irish!!!
Best college football takes in the country. Tells it how it is
I've always liked Mack Brown..
A true gentleman, and hell of a coach !
Clemson loses, Miami loses, Clemson wins ACC giving USC a regular season win over the ACC Champion.
Best College Show on the interwebs...
The NIL and transfer portal rules are making college football insane!! Wild stuff
Gamecock living in Raleigh, NC. I hate the Tar Heels. Still, I have always respected (and almost liked) Mack Brown. The administration begged Brown to come out of retirement to put the program back on solid footing. He did that. The recruiting prowess of Brown is legendary, due in large part to his ability to connect with people.
I think it's great teams like boise state etc are rewarded with an autobid. Especially with jeanty in the heisman race. If they got rid of the autobids 3 loss sec and big 10 teams would be in every year. F that, id rather see a potential underdog in an upset as a fan.
I think your Floyd of Rosedale replica should be on the back shelf, no matter what else you get. Whomever sent you that should get ANOTHER Chalice, too.
It’s the College Foot Show - terrible placement of that sign behind Josh’s head for the bulk of the show. Please fix this.
Agreed
Josh, Texas has not a single win over a ranked team this year.... let that sink in..
Yet their SOS is stronger than all the BIG teams in the mix. Head shaker 😂
But they do have wins over teams that were ranked when they played. Those teams fell out of the rankings after losing to Texas, and a&m is in the perfect position for that to happen to them too.
53:58 best immunity call thus far, Josh! Lmao
I love this show 10x after today
Imo. Find your top twelve teams and let the top draft their opponents. Adds drama an extra motivational/psychological dynamic.
Texas’ underrated defense and bc defense travels is and will be the key to the game as well. It’s a top 3 defense
Who didn’t site the guy who broke the Mack brown firing?
Rivalry weekend
I got Texas winning a very close game at A&M 28-27, Quinn with a last second td
I got the upset , I got Auburn upsetting Bama 27-24,
I got osu beating Michigan in a closer game then what ppl will think. 34-24.
I got sc beating Clemson 24-20
How do you have Ohio state over Oregon in the JP poll when Oregon beat them? Interesting take… I do 100% agree with the 5 seed issue. Realistically of things fall the way the bracket shows now, whoever loses the B1G championship game will absolutely have the easier path which would incentivize a team to punt on their most important game of the season (at that point anyways). I’ve always had the belief that the 12 team playoff should take the top 12 teams and create the bracket based on that. Unfortunately I don’t ever see that happening because then the conference championship games would be meaningless outside of bragging rights
Top 4 teams would be funny. People would flip if B1G got 3 byes in the playoff.
Lol ..and Texas is basically a Big 12 team so the traditional SEC would be home watching TV.
Because they only have to play each other once and then get cupcakes the rest of the way.
Is the JP poll just a service’s betting line on a neutral field? Do you have any subjectivity in your ratings or analysis that goes into this?
Is the model a spreadsheet or is it sentient?
Need the red dodge and Dorothy from the original twister in the studio somewhere.
I like Automatic Qualifiers. I think the problem is giving an AQ anything more than mere access. I treat it like the NCAA Basketball tourney, where the conf champs punch a ticket to the bracket, but are seeded where they are seeded. So like Boise for instance would be in, but are seeded based on ranking. Instead of being the 4 seed they would be at the 11. The other thing I would change is don't lock the bracket, There is no reason that the highest ranked/seeded team doesn't have to play the lowest seeded remaining team left on the bracket and the 2nd highest vs the 2nd lowest and so on.
FYI, audio needs to be bumped up higher. much too low compared to the opening music/track
34:16 that aged well
Josh the reason why you haven't seen the Texas high gear from last year is very simple...they lost a dozen NFL level players.
This team is heavily dependent on the portal for offensive skill players and they still haven't completely gelled. Maybe it happens this week?!? 🤘
Don’t understand why the playoff couldn’t just stay four teams with four conference champions on autobids. Simple, clear, and completely objective. Don’t like it cause your conference is too hard? Move to another one since apparently it’s so easy nowadays.
Did Publix start sponsoring the show???? You showed their water. 😬
Josh preaching the gospel…….again!!!