Some of the oboe trills are virtually impossible to execute (eg trills up and down an octave - can't really be done). I wonder about some of the bassoon and horn writing too.
As a horn player, I must confess it's very hard because of the large range, yet it's really relevant when we hear it. Great job (maybe juste few things scattered in the sheet need to be rearranged for basson or oboe) !
I would gladly send you the music through email and such, and I have written almost every movement. Saturn is near completion, and I am half-way on Mars. Thanks! Email me at npd929@gmail.com
Horns have a 4 octave range for those who work at it. But in reality, very little is written in bass clef for horns, even though they can reach it easily. Titanic Fantasy was for 12 horns and they used the 4 octave range.
Good job overall, but there are some issues that need to be resolved before this can be playable.
Some of the oboe trills are virtually impossible to execute (eg trills up and down an octave - can't really be done). I wonder about some of the bassoon and horn writing too.
Yeah I tried to play this on oboe and it didn’t go too well…
i realized this along with the c sharp tremolos on clarinet, i will think about fixing it
I tried all of this on oboe, it's amazing but yea those trills are smth else
@@Yello96486 my fix is try the e to e trill as a b to e instead
@@lopunnova ah that'll work, amazing as always
As a horn player, I must confess it's very hard because of the large range, yet it's really relevant when we hear it. Great job (maybe juste few things scattered in the sheet need to be rearranged for basson or oboe) !
please do not be afraid to use bass clef for some of the lower horn stuff. Ledger lines are very difficult to read.
This is amazing
thank you!
Agreed, from an oboist
@@Yello96486 same bestie just made my first reed today
@@phantom8856 omg the memories of my first reed
i would switch to piccolo for a lot of these sections, the flute part gets way too high to comfortably play at any other volume than ff
How do I get a hold of the sheet music for this, and, are there other movements that have been transcribed as well?
I would gladly send you the music through email and such, and I have written almost every movement. Saturn is near completion, and I am half-way on Mars. Thanks! Email me at npd929@gmail.com
plz do saturn next! that one is my favorite music
Awesome arrangement but the high a to C sharp tremolo on bassoon would be a pain
Oh, but the 32nd notes in the key of B Major are doable? lol
2:42 wait, horns can play that low?? Especially those rhythms and that tempo?
It is within horn range, and double tounging could be used, or a really fast single tongue.
@@lopunnova oh cool, I didn't know they could play that low
Horns have a 4 octave range for those who work at it. But in reality, very little is written in bass clef for horns, even though they can reach it easily. Titanic Fantasy was for 12 horns and they used the 4 octave range.
No way a flute can play altissimo c in piano unless you’re like an insane pro