Видео

Can we see the whole score next time?

Thank you so much! This piece is done really well! It really feels like the original version by tchaikovsky! Thank you so much again!

This is quite good. I think with musical elements like the runs it's important to consider more strongly the intended effect than it is the notes themselves. For instance, a lot of these runs are written for the celesta, intended to give a starry, ethereal effect. Now consider the clarinet - what can a clarinet do to produce an ethereal effect within the confines of the instrument? The chord is already spelled out in the rest of the ensemble. Use the fifth instrument to provide the sparkle in a way unique to it. I think that's the approach you should take in these instances. It will be less literally translated, but it may be more effective and playable.

No way a flute can play altissimo c in piano unless you’re like an insane pro

The oboe goes into a very uncomfortable high range at some parts, same with flute. I'd recommend taking both down an octave in parts like 4:00 because of this. I get wanting it to be dramatic but it sounds strained on the real instruments.

I’m doing this for strings and dear god the piccolo register makes so many problems! (Also about what others said about the tempo, I believe that all it says is vivace which just means lively technically. Most performances actually play it outside of that vivace range like 144) But nice job!

How did you do this with 4/5 parts!? I did this for strings and I had anywhere from 5-10 parts at a time. Wonderful work here!

soprano part seems a LITTLe difficult

baba o'riley (alternate take)

please do not be afraid to use bass clef for some of the lower horn stuff. Ledger lines are very difficult to read.

what the butt this is so good 7 likes insane. Can I buy this somewhere?

As a horn player, I must confess it's very hard because of the large range, yet it's really relevant when we hear it. Great job (maybe juste few things scattered in the sheet need to be rearranged for basson or oboe) !

These arrangements are really quite good.

Outstanding arrangement! 👏👏

Flute and Piccolo changes impossible for one player

How do I get a hold of the sheet music for this, and, are there other movements that have been transcribed as well?

Pity the bassoon part is often obscured.

2:42 wait, horns can play that low?? Especially those rhythms and that tempo?

Good job overall, but there are some issues that need to be resolved before this can be playable.

plz do saturn next! that one is my favorite music

Awesome arrangement but the high a to C sharp tremolo on bassoon would be a pain

i would switch to piccolo for a lot of these sections, the flute part gets way too high to comfortably play at any other volume than ff

Some of the oboe trills are virtually impossible to execute (eg trills up and down an octave - can't really be done). I wonder about some of the bassoon and horn writing too.

This is amazing

the flute shouldn’t be in the fourth octave C as often in wind quintets, i’d switch to piccolo

the flute taking the melody at 2:45 is weird, it should be an octave lower so maybe the clarinet or french horn?

Hi @Iopunnova! What instrument do you play, out of interest?

i will pay someone a million bucks if they can do that horn run in 3:25 perfectly

in some parts you forget to change notes relevant to the key change, for instance the flute at the main melody, the notes in the key is E but it’s should be Eb

Im excited to hear/read the rest of the planets :)

beautiful! this is my favorite of the planets :)

Sounds good, buts it's too fast

a little too quick to be realistic