1:19 - quick-fire quiz 7:13 - YQ shift in thinking (abstract) 9:20 - The shift of positions from Madinah to Yale 12:01 - Did his early positions once held after graduating from madinah change after coming to the US i.e. abrogate what he has studied before 18:53 - Is the change YQ experienced got to do with the starting point of strict aqeedah studies (goes to speak about the development of aqeedah) 22:04 - Do we need to rehash the study of aqeedah 26:57 - Advice to students of knowledge, on what to study and developing themselves 30:39 - What he would of have changed in his journey from the experiences and phases he's had 33:10 - How does he bridge the gap between looking at aqeedah/hadeeth centric and ethics based fiqh, fatwa, research 35:30 - Inspirations that are alive and people he goes to for advice 41:55 - People may think that YQ has a western centric form of islam but in fact the people he admires and takes advice from are from the east 47:10 - Where is the balance between living/experiencing islam in the west and basing our fatawa on that versus someone whos looking outside and who isnt subject to those living/experiences 51:02 - Are the muslims in the US under intense political pressure and the consequences 59:45 - What he does to keep himself in check/humble and how to deal with fame 1:12:10 - What hes going to be talking on his upcoming conference 1:13:40 - What does Islamic Seminary of America do
Dr yassir qadhi with all due respect to him is only showing one side of the argument. He doesn’t seem to warn his followers on the seamier side of learning Islam at Yale from non Muslims. They surely don’t look at things from the lens of iman, while they might be brilliant objectively. Here’s the danger of loosing your eman to shubuhaat.
afshan fatima true. Here in sweden. Even i can more about fiqh and legal issues than these m Swedish professors. They have everything in front of them. But still, they are not being able to gain knowledge
Although initially parts of this podcast make sense (like referring to your local ulema who understand the context better), I think the part at 44:03 sums up where this view of dawa in the West is heading and a big part of the problem seems to come from RESIDING among the disbelievers, which our beloved Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) warned us against. It was narrated from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) that he said: “I disavow every Muslim who resides among the mushrikeen.” Narrated by Abu Dawood (2645) and at-Tirmidhi (1604). Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Irwa’ al-Ghaleel (5/29-30) What is worrying is when referring to local ulema who understand the context better, in practice, turns into compromising, appeasing and taking weak opinions over stronger opinions to avoid giving 'hard core fatwa[s]...[that] nobody listen[s] to [and that are apparently] turn[ing] people away from Islam'. Consequently, it seems like, inevitably, residing among the disbelievers is, more and more, 'changing' us so much that we can't even 'recognise' ourselves anymore. Let's hope that our beloved Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) still recognises us as part of his ummah and worth interceding for, on the Day of Judgement. (See full quote from the podcast below). Also the brothers mentioned a few times the importance of keeping ourselves in check, which we should also accept from those who have a different minhaj. It does feel sad to see Muslims disagreeing so vehemently with each other but in one way it is a good thing and that is that these differences do help us to keep ourselves in check as our differing views help us to keep ourselves balanced. It's almost like a liberal versus conservative understanding of issues but the Truth could sometimes lie one one side, sometimes on the other side and sometimes near the middle. It reminds me of the different personalities of Abu Bakar (ra) and Umar (ra) during Abu Bakar's Caliphate, and how the softness of the former was balanced by the toughness of the latter, something that was unnecessary with our beloved prophet Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) as he had the most balanced personality. At 44:03 Yasir Qadhi says, “I met Shaykh Abdul Aziz Al-Fawzaan., a very, very dynamic shaykh and aalim and he had lived in America for 5 years...this is the first year after I graduated from Madinah, I met him in London actually, and I said Shaykh, coming back to America now, I'm seeing so many of the fatwas in fiqh that I held as being completely haqq, now I understand you cannot apply that any more and I'm changing so much because I see the context of my people and he said, ...how true is this Oh Yasir, I spent 5 years in America and...every year I kept on changing my fatwas until I couldn't even recognise myself from 5 years ago, like seeing the impact, you come you give a hard core fatwa and you see not only does nobody listen to it, it turns people away from Islam and then you realise there's another opinion that actually makes sense etc, etc. You learn from experience what you don't learn from books...He then sees all of these fataawa and he understands this is not going to apply in my society...and then we understand that this cannot be imported [inaudible].”
Rasul salAllahu'alayhi wasallam said, “Faith retreats to Madeenah like a snake returns to its hole.” [al-Bukhaari (1876) and Muslim (147)] In this hadeeth, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, “Faith retreats to Madeenah like a snake returns to its hole.” The word “retreats to” means to return and settle in Madeenah, just as a snake, when it goes out from its hole, returns to it. Here the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was saying that this religion will retreat to Madeenah after all other countries become corrupt, just as a snake comes out of its hole and wanders about the land, then it goes back to its hole. This hadeeth also indicates that just as Islam spread from Madeenah, it will return to it. Islam with its strength and authority spread from Madeenah, although its roots stemmed from Makkah. Makkah was the place where the first Revelation came down, but the Muslims did not have a state and power, and engage in jihad (battle), until after they migrated to Madeenah. Hence Islam with its power and authority, spread from Madeenah and will retreat to it at the end of time.
The best generation of Muslims were the Sahaba and those are the ones with the best knowledge and understanding of Islam. Islam is not like physics which progresses with time. For the best understanding, we go to the Quran and Sunnah and earlier generations.
Very nice and enjoyable talk. The questions were friendly but also probing and the answers were honest and fascinating. Dr. Yasir Qadhi is very knowledgeable about Islam and is also very easy to listen to. I think his views have moved from the mainstream over the years so I don't agree with everything he says. But even more importantly, why do 1.8 billion Muslims base everything in their lives on the teachings of one 7th century Arabian man (Muhammad)? Wouldn't it be better to adopt secular humanism instead, a system of belief which is based on human and animal rights and on maximizing happiness in the world? We wouldn't have to defend things like: chopping hands for theft, sex slavery of married and unmarried women (Nisa 4:24, Muslim 3432), and marrying and having intercourse with pre-pubescent girls (Talaq 65:4). I really liked the format and the talk. Thank you for having Dr. Qadhi on
Well first and foremost most Muslim nations have legal age of 18 and some 21. Now comes the question of punishment. For robbery the thing has to have a certain value than you need to find a way to calculate that value and compare it 1400 years ago. Which is why I'm also against it as you can't compare the value. Now as far as murder is concerned. Tell me are you ok feeding a guy who murdered your mother or someone close to you. Now slaves. You do realize they only captured slaves back than those who fought them in war. And you can't have sex without consent with your own wife let alone slaves.
Much love from an American convert who live in Cairo, Egypt. I will watch the entire show once I arrive back home. I'm in Tahrir Square. I enjoy watching & hearing Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's lectures. May Allah swt guide & protect all of you & us AmeeeeeeeeN
A man came to Umar bin Al Khattab (May Allah be pleased with him) and he had a big belly, Umar asked him, ‘What is this?’ The man replied, “It is a blessing from Allah!”Umar said, ‘No, its a punishment from Allah!.
Alot of very stupid and deviant points he brought, firstly the Aqidah is not something that has developed rather we have statements from the Sahaba and the generations after them and the generations after them talking about the correct Aqidah and calling to it. So it is something that has been preserved since the time of the prophet (Peace and blessings be upon him). After greek phisolophy came into the muslim world than other beliefs such as asharis and mutazilah beliefs came forth. So salafism is the pure theology that the companions of our prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) Secondly, Ibn taymiyyah refuted the ideas and the innovations that were spreading around the muslim world he did not embrace them and change his belief according to them, so lets say ibn taymiyyah would be alive than we believe he would refute the ideas of secularism and democracy and not embrace them such as we sadly see you doing.
@E .S Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa baarakatahu my brother in Islam, may Allah bless you! Following the way of the sahaba and the first three generations is what the Messenger of Allah alayhi salaam advised us to follow in the famous hadith and Allah mentions in the Quran to follow the way of the believers referring to the companions of the Prophet. All muslims should follow the Salaf and our greatest salaf is the Prophet alayhi salam. The problem is some of our salafi brothers have turned other muslims away from the correct path due to harshness, a lack of good akhlaaq, patience and gentleness and not knowing when to put things in there correct places. This is not the way of the Salaf!! Following the salaf just means to follow the best of the early muslims beginning with the Messenger. May Allah guide us all to what is pleasing to Him. Ameen Baarak Allahu feekum ikhwaan
@@Diamondraw4Real he meant, I would not want to be on Saudi's bad books, thus be able to get a visa for umrah, and also, that they are not very nice because some of their people go into their embassies and come out in pieces... Umrah and Jamal khashoggi
Only a kharijite and a devilish inspired man like Yasir Qadhi would utter such a statement; kharijite (khawaarij) because he incite and instigate rebellion against a muslim ruler, devilish inspired because he whispers syubuhaat over to the ignorants of things he knows nothing about inspiring them to think that the ruler instruct the murder of Khassogi. Has Yasir Qadhi elevated himself to be the one who knows of everything that is ghaib? p.s. even his Yale professors believe in the principle of " a man is innocence until proven guilty? wallahu a'lam.
@@rumahkubena fear Allah brother. Yasir Qadhi has a right over you for 3 reasons 1. He is a muslim 2. He has more knowledge thab you 3. He is (likely) older than you So show him respect, even if you disagree with him, speak with respect. His joke was very subttle, and reference a crime that the whole world knows Saudi government is involved in, so making a joke vs killing someone and cutting them up is nothing!
Atheism, secularism, feminism, human rights and capitalism are all easily refutable as it clearly goes against Islam and considering that the majority of the world's ills have thrived in this framework is evidence of its inherent shortcomings from being manmade. The reasons why they are a prevalent fitnah for the youth is because of the state enforced indoctrination veiled as education + constant consumption of media which brainwashes these beliefs into society from birth and the lack of Muslims taking responsibility in teaching their children Islam and protecting them from these evil ideologies. Not to mention the incapability for Muslims to promote theocracy (which would provide a fertile environment on a societal level for Muslims to practice their faith) as all other forms of government and governance are in contradiction to the Qur'an and Sunnah by definition as they resort to other idealogys to govern with.
@FAT cat uh human rights dont exist. If the so called west love it so much why do they not do anything about it in palestine? Why do they support wars by killing innocents then say they are the leaders of human rights? Same with the bullshit capitlist systwm. The west and most governments are under the thumb of the Private bankers. If you dig deep you will find the truth. Dont expect it to come to you because you are heavily indoctrinated.
You should study my brother. With all due respect you have shown the level of your knowledge with this comment. To include human rights and all these other categories and say that they clearly go against Islam. Take it easy bro, study Islam, study in a secular university as well, and be humble because there is much to learn
@@raheemhanifa9636 I guess he ment human rights by the way western do it n beleive in it! In Islam we dont need human right movement bcs all of what we learn from islam is human rights, women rights, childen ,animal and all living brings. Soif we practice islam n have good akhlaq we already done all these concepts! But the western ideologies r not merely the name it has more meaning n decieving information. Like they practice human rights when it works for their benefit, but become unhuman n kill ppl when they want! They shout for femenism to take women haya n let them do whatever they want with their body n tell them its their right! .. as Muslim we follow quran n sunnah not western ideologies bcs it goes hand in hand with their twisted desires n belief. I hope u got my humble point of view.🙄
@@raheemhanifa9636 he's saying what people call human rights like undressing apostasy etc. There's no indication of any kind of arrogance. In fact so much arrogance cones about when a person has studied even a little and they find it suitable to tell ant random person they need to "study more"- which while it may be true for everyone that we should learn our deen, is highly condescending, especially not knowing this random brothers educational background.
I was wondering if the first world problems of the Muslim minorities residing in Europe and America should really be of much practical interest to the larger Muslim Ummah that happens to populate third and second world countries? The western Muslims (be they scholars or laymen) generally didn't migrate to West for dawah purposes or the upliftment of the Ummah anyway. They mostly went there to enjoy the high life which comes with it's own pros and cons. Their scholarship is dealing with them the way they can, it's their problems. Dr. Yasir Qadhi keeps referring to "some 'alim in Timbaktu" and "had Ibn Taimiyyah been alive today he would be writing Londoniyya rather than Tadmuriyya" etc. Then why should majority of the Ummah that happens to live in "Timbaktu" even bother themselves with him? How can 21st century America/Europe be anywhere close 11th century Syria, Arabia, Persia and North Africa combined where Ibn Taimiyyah was addressing various doubts of the Ummah? "With all due respect" this whole podcast is reeking with elitist arrogance and somewhat demeaning the majority of Ummah that happens to be inhabiting "Timbaktu"! With all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of a desi reverse racism. Furthermore "my jaw just dropped" at the point where he draws comparison between the state of western Muslims and the Makkan phase. Then after a few minutes he discusses how American Muslims must look forward to engagement in American politics. I am nothing compared to Yasir Qadhi when it comes to the knowledge of seerah. But with all due respect, the self sacrificing and all consuming nature of the Makkan phase d'awah is being compared to the luxury of American dream here.
But the issues of the first world are in fact issues within our countries within the east, with the internet and media the narratives these shayateen put forward are gaining more and more traction within our lands, look at the rise of femnism and liberalism within our so called "educated" classes, within our nations. If we can address these issues in the west then we can deal with them within our own countries inshallah.
Akhi @ my point is simple, Yasir Qadhi keeps referring to "some 'alim in Timbaktu" and "had Ibn Taimiyyah been alive today he would be writing Londoniyya rather than Tadmuriyya" etc. Then why should majority of the Ummah that happens to live in "Timbaktu" even bother themselves with him? How can 21st century America/Europe be anywhere close 11th century Syria, Arabia, Persia and North Africa combined where Ibn Taimiyyah was addressing various doubts of the Ummah? "With all due respect" this whole podcast is reeking with elitist arrogance and somewhat demeaning the majority of Ummah that happens to be inhabiting "Timbaktu"! With all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of a desi reverse racism. Furthermore "my jaw just dropped" at the point where he draws comparison between the state of western Muslims and the Makkan phase. Then after a few minutes he discusses how American Muslims must look forward to engagement in American politics. I am nothing compared to Yasir Qadhi when it comes to the knowledge of seerah. But with all due respect, the self sacrificing and all consuming nature of the Makkan phase d'awah is being compared to the luxury of American dream.
Yassir Qadhi went to study with Freemasons. Why would any Muslim study with the likes of Tony Blair!? He probably had inferiority complex and now sold out his soul the Dunya by apostatising from the Deen.
I liked the podcast, but yes, like Linda Sarsour compared the struggles of Muslims today to slavery of blacks in America, sounds familiar, and so maybe he is kinda parroting that, idk. This is entertainment, not just teaching his experience. Like they said at the beginning, would he be facetious or serious, and they said "a little bit of everything". Peace.
Yousuf bin Mohammad "with all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of desi reverse racism" what do you mean by this? Allah bless you, Ameen. always easy to distinguish the sincere hearts.
As a former philosophy major who went from atheism to Salafiyah, I have never been impressed by Yasir Qadhi. That is the truth. I think only intellectual lightweights see him as being anything other than a man who could not justify his faith and lost most of it in a western university. Nothing unique or profound about that. He got a PHD from Yale in Islamic Studies lol. I am more impressed with SHAYKH TAHIR WYATT. A PHD from the UNIVERSITY OF MADINA and taught in the Prophet's Masjid. That, is impressive.
His words can be EASILY misunderstood if you don’t know the context behind what he is saying, who he is referring to, or even what. Ofc listening to this without any context will make it seem like he is bringing a “bidah”. Now what’s strange is that a lot of the grievances against Sh. Yasir posted by the likes of brother sajid were because he is advocating for looking beyond madhabs *and realizing that scholars, even giants of the past are fallible* . Yet even mufti muneer, the guy sajid defended says the SAME thing....
can you tell me what he means by 'strands' though? bc it seems that is the misunderstanding somehow. Like Saajid actually says that YQ thinks that it doesn't matter what Aqeedah you have, if your a Deobandi, salafi, or whatever else, like Qadiriya, which I didn't think was what Dr Qadhi meant at all when he spoke about different 'strands'.
Jane Dughatir Could you point out the time stamp so I can see what he is referring to? Because “strands” in islam could be aqeedah based, or fiqh/school of thought based.
@@symbiotezilla12345 asalaamu alaikum... i think that was @18:45 or so... it was about aqeedah pretty sure... or how to study aqeedah. Then he talks about Ibn Taiymiya's contribution or experiences. Have a good Ramadhan btw.
SubhanAllah, Shaikh Yasir Qadhi is one of my all time favourite Shaikhs since many years and Alhamdulillah I’ve learnt so much from his lectures which has opened my mind and heart into understanding Islam better especially in these Fitna times when certain sects who are causing division amongst the Ummah. I have benefitted so much from his lectures and I pray from the bottom of my heart that may his Da’wah and teachings be a Sadaqah e Jaariyah for him and a means for him in entering Jannat ul Firdaus, Allahumma Ameen! His words are of gold and I just wish he wasn’t interrupted with jokes.; he’s a scholar with great understanding.
We benefited from Dr Yasir Qadhi a lot but, we disagree som of his newly theological explanations. For instance, the comparison of physics and Islam (newton and Islamic scholars) is totally unsuitable. Human is a weak by nature whatsoever level and status he /she has reached. (كل بنى آدم خطاء ، وخير الخطائين التوابون) My Allah protect us and our ulamas from the Fitan.
Masha Allah I agree with you as well Dr YQ is a very knowledgeable individual but he seems to be experiencing doubts therefore he needs to be vigilant about his Eeman..He also needs to seek sincere guidance from Allah since Allah is the only one who guides the hearts..W'll make du'a for him may Allah guide us all to the straight path Allahuma Aameen❤
The example he gave makes perfect sense, but I think most people misunderstood it. It brilliantly describes who as one grows up and keeps learning about things, the way they understand that same subject will deepen and widen and develop. The student who began studying classical physics and later learned quantum physics will understand this.
YALEsir Qadhi is what this man ends up after many years of studying. I have listened to All of his seera class, All of his story of sahaba, the mother of the believers and much of his lectures and I would always wonder why is this guy keeps saying "let us Humanize the Sahaba, let us Humanize the Prophet" now I understand why. Because once he brings them down to his level and put doubt in the mind of the mass and lose the respect, it will be easy for him to say they are men and we are men, they make mistakes like we make mistakes so we don't have to follow or do exactly the same way as they did. If he has the audacity to say we can any kind of aqidah and still be ok, I have more rights to say the truth is one and follow it (the way of the salaf as sualih) and warn against to everything that's newly invented in the deen because if the truth was many there are no need to send the prophets and Messengers. Oh Allah do not misguide us after after you have guided. And guide those are misguided so that they don't misguide others
Salaam dear brothers & sisters Stick to the salaf of this Ummah the blessed 3 generations which the prophet pbuh praised. And anyone who clings on their path without bringing their own* opinions involved. Be careful of connecting yourselves to the khalaf (the ones who are alive now) for they are alive and can be lead astray by worldly gains or any other whim/desire!. How many a people Allah had blessed with knowledge and they let shaytan get the better of them. And they chased dunya rather than akhira. Wallahi its enough for the sincere Muslim to follow the path of the ones I mentioned. And no doubt the sincere slave of Allah who frees himself/herself from arrogance and high self thought. Allah shall guide and bestow fiqh (understanding of his deen). May Allah keep us firm upon his deen and make us from those who tread the middle path and not the 2 extremes. Wasalaam.
Very thought provoking however it is always best to stick within the ijam’ah off non boxed off mentality Ulema. Imam Ash-Shatibi r.a. who said: “Evil and misguided scholars are those who are dangerous to mankind. They are a disease to mankind, and they are those who do not act on their knowledge.” In his book Al-Fawa’id, Ibnul Qayyim r.a. gave a parable. He said: “Evil and misguided scholars are like people sitting on the gates of Paradise (Jannah) and calling people to come on in. With their tongues they are saying come on in, come on in, but their actions are saying do not come in. The more they talk to people and tell people to come in, the more their actions say do not listen to us, because if we were indeed truthful then we would have been the first to apply it…”
And Quraan understanding...memorizing is not enough when you face the level of doubts and debates that dr. yasir qadhi faces. Anybody can memorize the quraan...but what impact are such people having on the non muslims in their land? Dawah wise?
@@sugetsumillenium2112 no never Salafiyyah is not a sect, it is the true path. If you believe n follow quran and sunnah according to salaf (sahabas and followers) then you r on the right path. if u do what they used to not do then ur misguided. Yasir Qadhi's views have changed n he likes to cooperate with other sects.
asSalamualaikum my Brother, I feel like the harsh Salafi Dawah of the 90s and 2000s proved to be a superficial interpretation of a very rich islamic heritage, that is why there is a movement away from the more formalistic salafi approach towards something which speaks more to the heart. allah knows best
@@muhammada3749 salafiyah is not a sect?! The fact that you gave it a label separating it from other sects makes it a sect you moron. Typical idiot ignorant salafi comment LOL
@@TareqKhan0 To be a scholar you need more than the knowledge of Quran & Sunnah. You also need the ilm of makan & zaman. Our pious predecessors understood this, just look at the Imams of our madhahib. And here you guys are completely dismissing the importance of learning the knowledge of makan & zaman.
@@Muhammad-Al-Hafidz Did the prophet Muhammad sallallah alay wa salaam ever say you need more than just knowledge of the Quran and the sunnah to be a scholar and if so which hadiths proceeded you in your statement also which verses of the Quran say this please enlighten me?
Wow, Salman Al Awda the Ibn Taymiyya of our time? Who is he compared to Ibn Taymiyya!? Subhan Allah. Salman Awda, Sardar Hawaii are Ekhwaani Muslimoon. Hense Yasir Qadi is their student.
The problem lies in the fact his a student of knowledge himself so now his sitting with professors who are persuading him, the professors he learnt from maybe could meet these professors then more even playing field. His constantly Changing his views. But he does have a good grasp of the western Problems and it’s not the debate of the atharis and Ashreees as so many falling away from the deen
Ikhwanism, watering down the religion, belittling the scholars, doubting major concepts, how much more misguided can become in a sitting with these types of individuals. Ajeeb!
His is a victim of studying the creed of Ahlul Bidah and never clung to the Olama of Sunnah of today’s time to guide him while studying. This is why he never had a good relationship with the Olama there in Medina. Rather some of them like Sheikh Khalid Raddadi warned the students to stay away from him when he was a undergrad student
His comments about refusal to take selfies and breaking ppls khatir(roughly translates to heart/emotions) reminds me of when the prophet (pbuh) accepted some milk he didn’t want that was offered to him by an old lady. Even tho he didn’t want it, he didn’t want to break her khatir. I think it’s a unease you must tolerate when you become a “known” scholar.
@ subahanalah. Prophet and His companion didn't graduate or have PhD but manage to teach the ummah to the way of Islam. Thats isn't fair criticism toward who dissagree to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi
So sad for you Dr. Yasir! May Allah guide you and bring you back to the truth Dr. Yasir. May Allah make us steadfast and firm on the truth till we die.
I LOVE AND LIKE SHEIKH YASIR Qadhi's mind set I have the same though of course not all of it I am saying about the disunity of Ummah..... Why should we separate and make a group while all of them are Believing in One God And Last Messenger.... Yes there may be different in way of understanding in laws but throw all of away keep them separately but I am saying is pleased let's reunite again......
The true aqeedah of the first three generations of Islam is not something which was developed, rather when the likes of those astray groups such as the Jahmiyyah and Mu'tazilah began spreading their falsehood the scholars spoke out and expressed the correct Aqeedah. Ibn Taymiyyah and his student Ibn-ul-Qayyim did not bring anything new with regards to Aqeedah; they only reinforced the Aqeedah of the first three generations of Islam and refuted the astray groups of their times.
Many people stand with him still just off the mere fact that he's criticized Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab who Sufis, modernists, and Shia dispise. But people have ignored a lot of the other things that Yasir has said recently just because he critiqued the one man who they hate the most. Yasir Qadhi has literally admitted publicly that he had a faith crisis at Yale yet people still go through his lectutures and pick 1 thing that they like out of a 30 minute speech and promote that 1 thing as if there aren't 5 other issues in the same speech. I've even seen an agnostic/atheist praise Yasir Qadhi just because he said one thing that they liked. People seek validation from everything BUT the Kitab and sunnah.
It's wrong to not give Scholars of the muslim world their due and to say that we have sufficient scholars in the west if thats what is being suggested if not forgive me.Particulularly when you have benefitted from that knowledge.Especially so if that also means its acceptable to learn Islam from non muslims.Think about where that will take us.
Yasir Qadhi potrays islam in such a complicated way so much so that only Yale graduates can understand. But lo and behold! among the first who answered the call were bedoins... So who needs Yasir Qadhi to teach us islam?
Jabalnur Jabalthur only circumstantial illustrations predominated the discussion. Madina remains exceptionally outstanding as a source of undiluted Islamic guidance. But when one has been shot by philosophical ideas then he thinks otherwise. Islam permits 100 % plagiarism so, we have to ignore this kind of confused ideas and copy 100 % from good Islamic teachings. May Allah guide him and us all toward the right path. May Allah make us firm on the path of undiluted Islam teachings. Ameen
Yasir Qadhi has started crossing the red line. He has publicly said that he has left the aqeedah of the salaf and that is what moving on meant as he phrased it. If you are saying that aqeedah is no more important in this our generation because we are now dealing with atheism, LGBTQ, etc. because of these we should stop teaching people aqeedah which is the foundation of everthing u do in Islam. If your aqeedah is wrong any other things u do in Islam will not be accepted. Yasir Qadhi new ideology is just to be a muslim in this world in whatever way anyone wants whether or not it will be acceptable by Allah that does not matter. What really matters is to be able to westernized Islam in such ways it will be accepted to the world power for us to be able to be Americans muslims, British muslims etc.. Yasir Qadhi priority is for muslims to be acceptable by the world powers but their aqeedah being accepted by Allah or not in the hereafter is no more important in this our generation that muslims existence is being threatened in western world. This is a dangerous Ideology Yasir Qadhi.
It just feels wrong to listen to him. I just can't take him as a teacher. His words only place doubts in the heart of people about Islam. He calls every subject - a human development -, an attempt to understand God's wisdom. Then this is similar to perennialism. Why is he so sure of his Western-backed knowledge of Islam and not of how Muslim scholars have taught. All the time he blasts our ulamas as be completely retrograde and in the end, he says "I respect them ", that's not how true respect works... I feel, he should talk to Daniel Haqiqatjou to get his ideas correct. Some of what he says is correct and i don't say that he is a deviant or anything.
Putting reason before revelation on matters of belief opens the door to doubts and many more versions about ghayb, much more than the versions of bible out there and none of which would be correct. Physics deals with things that could be observed/measured and thus can developed. The unseen matters are not and hence the comparison between Newtonian and Einsteinian physics is not adequate.
@@quantummovement8879 yeah. He said it's a minor issue comparatively, the key word being comparatively. In any case its a fiqhi issue, not an aqeeda one.
@@quantummovement8879 This is your opinion. For how long we gonna keep arguing over what Mr.A and Mr. B sunnah?. Sunnah is big. What's black to you is white to other vis vis. Mawlid is least matter of argument in this day and age. Whoever wants to celebrate mawlid can go ahead as long as they stick to shariah guidelines.
My favourite podcast but the presenters need to know which guests to let talk ie yq and which guests to have more input with. Just let him talk you guys interrupted maybe a little too much, BarakAllahu feekum though you guys are smashing it!
Yeah, it was a bit weird when yq was speaking about some really serious topic, sometimes even speaking about the Qur'an, and then they just respond with a joke 😕
Why so many dislikes? All these people yapping about Yale forget that Yasir Qadhi also studied in Madinah. Also very good series on the Seerah. Instead of going to Hyde Park and listen to fools like Shamsi you would learn more watching Yasir Qadhis Seerah . Young over zealous people who think that you can only be a scholar if you are a Shaykh Salih Al Fawzan sitting in Saudi-Arabia. 242 dislikes from Dawah man types.
@RealDeal441 Tell me, where does he undermine the importance of Aqeedah, Aqeedah is important I don't think anyone disagrees with that. He also doesn't mock them, he is criticizing people without naming them. If you recall this Khariji called Dawah Man made an entire video slandering Yasir Qadhi so before you accuse Yasir Qadhi of mocking I would direct your attention to self taught wikipedia Sheikhs like Dawah Man. Who think that after 2 years of studying they can refute scholars. Foolishness. Dawah Man didnt even do a goob job in refuting because he misquoted and misunderstood Yasir Qadhi a lot.
I wanted to ask a question -I am a 17 year old girl btw so excuse me if I don't understand some things- But first and foremost, I think Dr. Sheikh Yasir Qadhi is intellectual scholar very beneficial to Muslims Especially those in academia and the youth. Personally living in the US can be difficult at times with Islamophobia and people being ignorant of your religion. I feel like having scholars here in the US is a great blessing. Since you have people who understand you, and explain matters very clearly and carefully. And it really has helped me learn more about my deen Allhamduliah 😁💙 I feel like constant arguing and not having respect for another puts our Ummah down. If we all helped each other in times of distress and were there for each other's backs, no nations wouldn't mess with us. And you wouldn't see such horrendous and heartbreaking wars and genocides going on in Muslim countries. Were is the action. People can say a LOT but do very little--this goes to everyone including me. So why are people fighting/slandering the participants, I mean is this the way to come. Everyone makes mistakes, this makes us human. However, is this what Islam teaches us to call nasty names to people of knowledge. I am just puzzled by the nature of people. May Allah swt. Grant us knowledge, WISDOM, and understanding. This is so disgusting what is going on in this comments. Tomorrow this is going to be presented in front of us. What will be the excuse for calling them such derogatory names. I am so disgusted, disappointed, horrified at the nature of our Muslim community. This is NOT what our beautiful deen teaches us. The Prophet-peace and blessings be upon him- was a man full of wisdom, is this how he corrected and informed others? Also to point people are trying to get closer to their deen, put when they see this it just puts them down. This is pretty long, so forgive for that brother. But I am so unhappy what the toxicity in this comment sphere. May God grant our scholars righteousness and grant them the highest in Jannah. Also may Allah make you successful in this world and in the next. AMEEN 🤲🏼
Does YQ really believe he has a place to promote his own ideology over the salaf who came before him? I used to look up to this guy but he is going the route Suhaib Webb is going. I won't be surprised if tomorrow he was getting triggered over gender pronouns.
That assumption is very extreme by the way. Suhaib won't dare criticize any state official and policy all of whom.yq has explicitly stated and defended
So many people are misunderstanding this interview. I think you guys need to do a followup interview in which all the misunderstandings are cleared up.
But is it not the case that part of saving the youth is to teach them the correct belief (aqeedah) first? 2nd point. The salaf were very quick to refute the people of kalam which includes the Ash'aariah. And the Ashari's of that time were better than those of today. And the early Ashari creed is different to the current Ashari creed where as the Athari creed has not changed
@Bouba Sane, do you know who is a kafir? Can you tell? Do you know how you will end? Fellow brother in Islam, let me give you the advice of great imam Abu Hanifa, he said it was better to deem 1000 Kumar as muslims than to attribute our to single muslim. It is important to hold our thoughts because ان السمع والبصر والفواد كل اولاءك كان عنه مسؤولا
@@alhassangangu4357 You're missing the entire point he's referring to when Yasir Qadhi went to Yale and by his own admission said he had a faith crisis. He's not making takfir of anyone since Yale is indeed a non Muslim school.
Also, to be technical takir does exist in Islam since the angels Harut and Marut made takfir of the magicians in Babylon. Takfir on individuals requires shurut (conditions) such as a person who is jahil, is forced to do kufr, has a moment of insanity, is not of mature age, did an act of kufr without intending, etc. The Muslim judges and scholars within a Muslim state judge people by these conditions because takfir has a hukm that is attached to it. Yes there are those who go to the extreme in takfir and confuse kufr akbar with kufr asghar, and kufr 'amali with kufr itiqadi, but takfir does exist and the brother you are responding to never made takfir on anyone to begin with. Also, Abu Hanifa's own student Abu Yusuf became a qadi (chief judge), one of their functions is to declare takfir, tabdi', etc on people when necessary so we can't pick and choose examples. Ahlus Sunnah are between the Khawarij who declare kufr without meeting the conditions and between the murji'ah who say that no one can be judged by action and statement.
Enjoyed this because of the guest Dr Yasir Qadhi A bit of constructive criticism in my opinion it was a bit too light hearted - too many jokes May Allah SWT accept your efforts
This Hadīth refutes Yasir Qadhi: Ibrāheem Ibn Abdur Rahmān Al ‘Udhri reports that the Messenger ﷺ said: _"This knowledge is carried in every generation by the trustworthy ones, they repel from it the distortions of those who go beyond bounds, the fabrications of those who fabricate, and the false interpretations of the ignorant"_ *يَحْمِلُ هذا العلمَ من كلِّ خلَفٍ عُدُولُهُ ، ينفونَ عنه تحريفَ الغالينَ ، وانتحالَ المُبْطِلينَ ، وتأويلَ الجاهِلينَ* [الألباني، تخريج مشكاة المصابيح ٢٣٩ • مرسل، لكن روي موصولا من طريق جماعة من الصحابة، وصحح بعض طرقه الحافظ العلائي]
Fantastic podcast. Guys you 2 are fun but joke just a little too much. We would have benefitted from a few more solid advises but hey thanks for sharing this moment with us. Chapeau Dr YaYasir😊 you are so full of knowledge fire so many ideas MashaAllah may the Almighty protect your heart from any form of celebrity-thrill. Ameen
Timeless principles don't change, their proofs hasn't changed. Today's reality is not significantly different from the past. Others' experiences and from their communities is knowledge for us.
@@ankhmorpok1497 I stand by what I said. We can deal with modernity, what is there not to be able to deal with? When I said today's reality isn't significantly different from the past I wasn't referring to advancing technologically and across other aspects of the human domain not ignoring that we too have declined with becoming spoilt human beings, distracted by living dramas, deluded etc. I was talking more about basic living structures, objectives, religion etc. That still stands, we're just living those realities in this modern age. Anyway the gist of my comment was that time is not the issue because God created it and therefore His religion works for anytime because it is not bound by it. Perhaps you're not acquainted with history, have you heard of islamic Spain where muslim civilisation were thriving whilst Europe was living in the dark ages? And then down the line due to internal conflicts and political issues, Islam lost that by God's plan and will becoming a shell of its former self. It hasn't got anything to do with modernity or you probably thought I was of the thinking that technology is haram? Hahaha. We're discussing something completely different here. My comment was a specific one on Islamic principles not changing and their proofs still preserved with our Prophetic tradition. That is a fact. If someone wants to change it for themselves or misinform others then they will be refuted for their deviation and they will bear the sin. That's all there is to it. Don't confuse human products with what God sent as invincible. The former changes the latter does not.
Slmz, Very interesting talk. How would someone be able to sign up or subscribe for that online course??? From what i gather... Newton and Einstein were basically onto the same thing but the knowledge and understanding of those around them IS the major difference. Imagine if I You and were to teach the exact same lesson to two different groups of people. You have a bunch of modern people and im teaching cave men... Whos gonna be more successful???
Yasir Qadi is on a mission to convince people that Salafi Dawah has many stands. Where did he get this from? Just like Muslims in general are devided, but Islam is clear. Likewise the saved victorious group those who strictly follow Rasool sallallahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah radhi Allahu anhum is clear. This group unites it's followers with Aqeedah, Manhaj, evidence and principles in all issues. This group has various names to identify it. Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama'ah. AhlusSunnah, Sunni, Salafi Dawah, Salafiyyah, Ahlul Hadeeth, Ahlul Athar, Firqatun Najiya, Taifatul Mansoora. They are distinct from the Ahlul Bidah.
@Witness Truth hadeeth of Mu‘aawiyah ibn Abi Sufyaan (may Allah be pleased with him), who said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) stood up amongst us and said: “Those who came before you of the people of the Book split into seventy-two sects, and this ummah will split into seventy-three sects, seventy-two of which will be in the Fire and one in Paradise. That is the jamaa’ah (the main body of Muslims).”
@Witness Truth brother, the Prophet Muhammad, sallAllahu alayhi wasalam, spoke about only ONE group that would go to Jannah among the Muslims. What did Yasir Qadho say in this podcast? The EXACT opposite. So choose who you follow, and remember your death and the Day of Judgement.
@Witness Truth Shaykh Ibn Taymiyyah  said: "This Hadeeth is authentic and is well-known in the books of Sunnah and in the Masaanid (plural of Musnad), such as the Sunnah of Abu Daawood, At-Tirmithi, An-Nasaa’i, and others. The wording of the Hadeeth is as follows: 'The Jews were split up into seventy-one sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one; the Christians were split up into seventy-two sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one; and my nation will split up into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one.' Another narration reads: "They asked: 'O prophet of Allah, who will be the saved sect?' He  replied: 'Those who will remain on the path which I and my companions are on today.'" Yet, another narration reads: "They are the Jamaa’ah (the main body of Muslims); the Hand of Allah is with the Jamaa’ah." It is for this reason that the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, described the saved sect as the Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa’ah, who are the overwhelming multitude and the great majority of the Muslims. The other sects are followers of aberrant views, schism, innovations and deviant desires. [….] The sign with which these sects are known is contradicting the Quran, the Sunnah, and the consensus of the scholars. Whoever acts according to the Book of Allah, the Sunnah, and the consensus (of the scholars), then he is from Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa’ah.'" [End of quote]
1:19 - quick-fire quiz
7:13 - YQ shift in thinking (abstract)
9:20 - The shift of positions from Madinah to Yale
12:01 - Did his early positions once held after graduating from madinah change after coming to the US i.e. abrogate what he has studied before
18:53 - Is the change YQ experienced got to do with the starting point of strict aqeedah studies (goes to speak about the development of aqeedah)
22:04 - Do we need to rehash the study of aqeedah
26:57 - Advice to students of knowledge, on what to study and developing themselves
30:39 - What he would of have changed in his journey from the experiences and phases he's had
33:10 - How does he bridge the gap between looking at aqeedah/hadeeth centric and ethics based fiqh, fatwa, research
35:30 - Inspirations that are alive and people he goes to for advice
41:55 - People may think that YQ has a western centric form of islam but in fact the people he admires and takes advice from are from the east
47:10 - Where is the balance between living/experiencing islam in the west and basing our fatawa on that versus someone whos looking outside and who isnt subject to those living/experiences
51:02 - Are the muslims in the US under intense political pressure and the consequences
59:45 - What he does to keep himself in check/humble and how to deal with fame
1:12:10 - What hes going to be talking on his upcoming conference
1:13:40 - What does Islamic Seminary of America do
@35:50 Salman Al Awdah
@37:20 Safar Al Hawali
Dr yassir qadhi with all due respect to him is only showing one side of the argument. He doesn’t seem to warn his followers on the seamier side of learning Islam at Yale from non Muslims. They surely don’t look at things from the lens of iman, while they might be brilliant objectively. Here’s the danger of loosing your eman to shubuhaat.
afshan fatima true. Here in sweden. Even i can more about fiqh and legal issues than these m Swedish professors. They have everything in front of them. But still, they are not being able to gain knowledge
@afshan fatima Sh. Yasir did talk about the danger in other talk: ruclips.net/video/LhtCEUw5MKQ/видео.html
@Abbas aboud it's also based on false premises and assumptions, so the conclusions will be incorrect too.
He has already lost alot of iman
@@safwanshahriar9579 you are not in the position to say that to anybody....... its unseen
Although initially parts of this podcast make sense (like referring to your local ulema who understand the context better), I think the part at 44:03 sums up where this view of dawa in the West is heading and a big part of the problem seems to come from RESIDING among the disbelievers, which our beloved Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) warned us against.
It was narrated from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) that he said: “I disavow every Muslim who resides among the mushrikeen.” Narrated by Abu Dawood (2645) and at-Tirmidhi (1604). Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Irwa’ al-Ghaleel (5/29-30)
What is worrying is when referring to local ulema who understand the context better, in practice, turns into compromising, appeasing and taking weak opinions over stronger opinions to avoid giving 'hard core fatwa[s]...[that] nobody listen[s] to [and that are apparently] turn[ing] people away from Islam'. Consequently, it seems like, inevitably, residing among the disbelievers is, more and more, 'changing' us so much that we can't even 'recognise' ourselves anymore. Let's hope that our beloved Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) still recognises us as part of his ummah and worth interceding for, on the Day of Judgement. (See full quote from the podcast below).
Also the brothers mentioned a few times the importance of keeping ourselves in check, which we should also accept from those who have a different minhaj. It does feel sad to see Muslims disagreeing so vehemently with each other but in one way it is a good thing and that is that these differences do help us to keep ourselves in check as our differing views help us to keep ourselves balanced. It's almost like a liberal versus conservative understanding of issues but the Truth could sometimes lie one one side, sometimes on the other side and sometimes near the middle. It reminds me of the different personalities of Abu Bakar (ra) and Umar (ra) during Abu Bakar's Caliphate, and how the softness of the former was balanced by the toughness of the latter, something that was unnecessary with our beloved prophet Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) as he had the most balanced personality.
At 44:03 Yasir Qadhi says, “I met Shaykh Abdul Aziz Al-Fawzaan., a very, very dynamic shaykh and aalim and he had lived in America for 5 years...this is the first year after I graduated from Madinah, I met him in London actually, and I said Shaykh, coming back to America now, I'm seeing so many of the fatwas in fiqh that I held as being completely haqq, now I understand you cannot apply that any more and I'm changing so much because I see the context of my people and he said, ...how true is this Oh Yasir, I spent 5 years in America and...every year I kept on changing my fatwas until I couldn't even recognise myself from 5 years ago, like seeing the impact, you come you give a hard core fatwa and you see not only does nobody listen to it, it turns people away from Islam and then you realise there's another opinion that actually makes sense etc, etc. You learn from experience what you don't learn from books...He then sees all of these fataawa and he understands this is not going to apply in my society...and then we understand that this cannot be imported [inaudible].”
Rasul salAllahu'alayhi wasallam said, “Faith retreats to Madeenah like a snake returns to its hole.” [al-Bukhaari (1876) and Muslim (147)]
In this hadeeth, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, “Faith retreats to Madeenah like a snake returns to its hole.” The word “retreats to” means to return and settle in Madeenah, just as a snake, when it goes out from its hole, returns to it. Here the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was saying that this religion will retreat to Madeenah after all other countries become corrupt, just as a snake comes out of its hole and wanders about the land, then it goes back to its hole.
This hadeeth also indicates that just as Islam spread from Madeenah, it will return to it. Islam with its strength and authority spread from Madeenah, although its roots stemmed from Makkah. Makkah was the place where the first Revelation came down, but the Muslims did not have a state and power, and engage in jihad (battle), until after they migrated to Madeenah. Hence Islam with its power and authority, spread from Madeenah and will retreat to it at the end of time.
The best generation of Muslims were the Sahaba and those are the ones with the best knowledge and understanding of Islam. Islam is not like physics which progresses with time. For the best understanding, we go to the Quran and Sunnah and earlier generations.
Very nice and enjoyable talk. The questions were friendly but also probing and the answers were honest and fascinating. Dr. Yasir Qadhi is very knowledgeable about Islam and is also very easy to listen to. I think his views have moved from the mainstream over the years so I don't agree with everything he says. But even more importantly, why do 1.8 billion Muslims base everything in their lives on the teachings of one 7th century Arabian man (Muhammad)? Wouldn't it be better to adopt secular humanism instead, a system of belief which is based on human and animal rights and on maximizing happiness in the world? We wouldn't have to defend things like: chopping hands for theft, sex slavery of married and unmarried women (Nisa 4:24, Muslim 3432), and marrying and having intercourse with pre-pubescent girls (Talaq 65:4). I really liked the format and the talk. Thank you for having Dr. Qadhi on
Well first and foremost most Muslim nations have legal age of 18 and some 21. Now comes the question of punishment. For robbery the thing has to have a certain value than you need to find a way to calculate that value and compare it 1400 years ago. Which is why I'm also against it as you can't compare the value.
Now as far as murder is concerned. Tell me are you ok feeding a guy who murdered your mother or someone close to you. Now slaves. You do realize they only captured slaves back than those who fought them in war. And you can't have sex without consent with your own wife let alone slaves.
Much love from an American convert who live in Cairo, Egypt.
I will watch the entire show once I arrive back home. I'm in Tahrir Square.
I enjoy watching & hearing Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's lectures.
May Allah swt guide & protect all of you & us
AmeeeeeeeeN
He is one of the sheikhs that i trust to listen.
Please don't watch brother. This man will lead us astray. Don't follow him, follow the people who are upon Tawheed and Sunnah.
@@abumuawiyyah1175 - who are those people?
@@Procrastinators - 😊😁🤪 nice one
@@munaali5612 Wallahi trust me, he's one of the last people you'd want to trust and take knowledge from...
A man came to Umar bin Al Khattab (May Allah be pleased with him) and he had a big belly, Umar asked him, ‘What is this?’ The man replied, “It is a blessing from Allah!”Umar said, ‘No, its a punishment from Allah!.
Before pointing a finger at someone point 3 at yourself.
@@ImranAli-tm3rq I just quoted a narration. Didn't point a finger at anyone.
@@أبومريموليدأنصاري Dishonesty is a major sin..
@@ImranAli-tm3rq Hypocrisy is worse.
@@أبومريموليدأنصاري Sure is.
Alot of very stupid and deviant points he brought, firstly the Aqidah is not something that has developed rather we have statements from the Sahaba and the generations after them and the generations after them talking about the correct Aqidah and calling to it. So it is something that has been preserved since the time of the prophet (Peace and blessings be upon him). After greek phisolophy came into the muslim world than other beliefs such as asharis and mutazilah beliefs came forth. So salafism is the pure theology that the companions of our prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) Secondly, Ibn taymiyyah refuted the ideas and the innovations that were spreading around the muslim world he did not embrace them and change his belief according to them, so lets say ibn taymiyyah would be alive than we believe he would refute the ideas of secularism and democracy and not embrace them such as we sadly see you doing.
@E .S there are ahadith to follow the salaf......
@E .S Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa baarakatahu my brother in Islam, may Allah bless you! Following the way of the sahaba and the first three generations is what the Messenger of Allah alayhi salaam advised us to follow in the famous hadith and Allah mentions in the Quran to follow the way of the believers referring to the companions of the Prophet. All muslims should follow the Salaf and our greatest salaf is the Prophet alayhi salam. The problem is some of our salafi brothers have turned other muslims away from the correct path due to harshness, a lack of good akhlaaq, patience and gentleness and not knowing when to put things in there correct places. This is not the way of the Salaf!! Following the salaf just means to follow the best of the early muslims beginning with the Messenger. May Allah guide us all to what is pleasing to Him. Ameen
Baarak Allahu feekum ikhwaan
Lärdas Översättningar piss off 🖕🏽
@@Alex21441 - following the Salafis of today means you .just stay quiet on rulers and be a total bootlicker.
@@MrRK0121 yasir qadhi is a Zindeeq but there are no authentic ahadeeth that say to "follow the salaf". I challenge you to bring one.
Sauid or Qatar?
Yasir: i would like to get a visa for umra and also be able to walk out of the embassy
😂😂😂
ha ha, the guys let that slide...
Whats funny?
@@Diamondraw4Real he meant, I would not want to be on Saudi's bad books, thus be able to get a visa for umrah, and also, that they are not very nice because some of their people go into their embassies and come out in pieces...
Umrah and Jamal khashoggi
Only a kharijite and a devilish inspired man like Yasir Qadhi would utter such a statement;
kharijite (khawaarij) because he incite and instigate rebellion against a muslim ruler, devilish inspired because he whispers syubuhaat over to the ignorants of things he knows nothing about inspiring them to think that the ruler instruct the murder of Khassogi. Has Yasir Qadhi elevated himself to be the one who knows of everything that is ghaib?
p.s. even his Yale professors believe in the principle of " a man is innocence until proven guilty?
wallahu a'lam.
@@rumahkubena fear Allah brother.
Yasir Qadhi has a right over you for 3 reasons
1. He is a muslim
2. He has more knowledge thab you
3. He is (likely) older than you
So show him respect, even if you disagree with him, speak with respect.
His joke was very subttle, and reference a crime that the whole world knows Saudi government is involved in, so making a joke vs killing someone and cutting them up is nothing!
I was glued to this from start to end. Thank you!
Atheism, secularism, feminism, human rights and capitalism are all easily refutable as it clearly goes against Islam and considering that the majority of the world's ills have thrived in this framework is evidence of its inherent shortcomings from being manmade. The reasons why they are a prevalent fitnah for the youth is because of the state enforced indoctrination veiled as education + constant consumption of media which brainwashes these beliefs into society from birth and the lack of Muslims taking responsibility in teaching their children Islam and protecting them from these evil ideologies. Not to mention the incapability for Muslims to promote theocracy (which would provide a fertile environment on a societal level for Muslims to practice their faith) as all other forms of government and governance are in contradiction to the Qur'an and Sunnah by definition as they resort to other idealogys to govern with.
Chicken brain cant hold much info though.
@FAT cat uh human rights dont exist. If the so called west love it so much why do they not do anything about it in palestine? Why do they support wars by killing innocents then say they are the leaders of human rights? Same with the bullshit capitlist systwm. The west and most governments are under the thumb of the Private bankers. If you dig deep you will find the truth. Dont expect it to come to you because you are heavily indoctrinated.
You should study my brother. With all due respect you have shown the level of your knowledge with this comment. To include human rights and all these other categories and say that they clearly go against Islam. Take it easy bro, study Islam, study in a secular university as well, and be humble because there is much to learn
@@raheemhanifa9636 I guess he ment human rights by the way western do it n beleive in it! In Islam we dont need human right movement bcs all of what we learn from islam is human rights, women rights, childen ,animal and all living brings. Soif we practice islam n have good akhlaq we already done all these concepts! But the western ideologies r not merely the name it has more meaning n decieving information. Like they practice human rights when it works for their benefit, but become unhuman n kill ppl when they want! They shout for femenism to take women haya n let them do whatever they want with their body n tell them its their right! .. as Muslim we follow quran n sunnah not western ideologies bcs it goes hand in hand with their twisted desires n belief. I hope u got my humble point of view.🙄
@@raheemhanifa9636 he's saying what people call human rights like undressing apostasy etc. There's no indication of any kind of arrogance. In fact so much arrogance cones about when a person has studied even a little and they find it suitable to tell ant random person they need to "study more"- which while it may be true for everyone that we should learn our deen, is highly condescending, especially not knowing this random brothers educational background.
Yasir Qadhi: we can't import fatwa from Muslims countries to the west.
Disbelievers: we are concerned about LGBT rights in Makkah and Medina.
Wait why not?Isn't Islam for all of mankind? Regardless the country?
@@zf1670 I'm wondering the same thing
😂😂😂
@@zf1670 Tawheed is universal, fiqh ie jurisprudence can vary from place to place.
There are gay Muslims getting married in America
I was wondering if the first world problems of the Muslim minorities residing in Europe and America should really be of much practical interest to the larger Muslim Ummah that happens to populate third and second world countries? The western Muslims (be they scholars or laymen) generally didn't migrate to West for dawah purposes or the upliftment of the Ummah anyway. They mostly went there to enjoy the high life which comes with it's own pros and cons. Their scholarship is dealing with them the way they can, it's their problems.
Dr. Yasir Qadhi keeps referring to "some 'alim in Timbaktu" and "had Ibn Taimiyyah been alive today he would be writing Londoniyya rather than Tadmuriyya" etc. Then why should majority of the Ummah that happens to live in "Timbaktu" even bother themselves with him? How can 21st century America/Europe be anywhere close 11th century Syria, Arabia, Persia and North Africa combined where Ibn Taimiyyah was addressing various doubts of the Ummah? "With all due respect" this whole podcast is reeking with elitist arrogance and somewhat demeaning the majority of Ummah that happens to be inhabiting "Timbaktu"! With all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of a desi reverse racism.
Furthermore "my jaw just dropped" at the point where he draws comparison between the state of western Muslims and the Makkan phase. Then after a few minutes he discusses how American Muslims must look forward to engagement in American politics. I am nothing compared to Yasir Qadhi when it comes to the knowledge of seerah. But with all due respect, the self sacrificing and all consuming nature of the Makkan phase d'awah is being compared to the luxury of American dream here.
But the issues of the first world are in fact issues within our countries within the east, with the internet and media the narratives these shayateen put forward are gaining more and more traction within our lands, look at the rise of femnism and liberalism within our so called "educated" classes, within our nations.
If we can address these issues in the west then we can deal with them within our own countries inshallah.
Akhi @ my point is simple, Yasir Qadhi keeps referring to "some 'alim in Timbaktu" and "had Ibn Taimiyyah been alive today he would be writing Londoniyya rather than Tadmuriyya" etc. Then why should majority of the Ummah that happens to live in "Timbaktu" even bother themselves with him? How can 21st century America/Europe be anywhere close 11th century Syria, Arabia, Persia and North Africa combined where Ibn Taimiyyah was addressing various doubts of the Ummah? "With all due respect" this whole podcast is reeking with elitist arrogance and somewhat demeaning the majority of Ummah that happens to be inhabiting "Timbaktu"! With all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of a desi reverse racism.
Furthermore "my jaw just dropped" at the point where he draws comparison between the state of western Muslims and the Makkan phase. Then after a few minutes he discusses how American Muslims must look forward to engagement in American politics. I am nothing compared to Yasir Qadhi when it comes to the knowledge of seerah. But with all due respect, the self sacrificing and all consuming nature of the Makkan phase d'awah is being compared to the luxury of American dream.
Yassir Qadhi went to study with Freemasons. Why would any Muslim study with the likes of Tony Blair!? He probably had inferiority complex and now sold out his soul the Dunya by apostatising from the Deen.
I liked the podcast, but yes, like Linda Sarsour compared the struggles of Muslims today to slavery of blacks in America, sounds familiar, and so maybe he is kinda parroting that, idk. This is entertainment, not just teaching his experience. Like they said at the beginning, would he be facetious or serious, and they said "a little bit of everything". Peace.
Yousuf bin Mohammad "with all due respect this elitism is on the verge of some sort of desi reverse racism" what do you mean by this?
Allah bless you, Ameen. always easy to distinguish the sincere hearts.
As a former philosophy major who went from atheism to Salafiyah, I have never been impressed by Yasir Qadhi. That is the truth. I think only intellectual lightweights see him as being anything other than a man who could not justify his faith and lost most of it in a western university. Nothing unique or profound about that. He got a PHD from Yale in Islamic Studies lol. I am more impressed with SHAYKH TAHIR WYATT. A PHD from the UNIVERSITY OF MADINA and taught in the Prophet's Masjid. That, is impressive.
His words can be EASILY misunderstood if you don’t know the context behind what he is saying, who he is referring to, or even what. Ofc listening to this without any context will make it seem like he is bringing a “bidah”.
Now what’s strange is that a lot of the grievances against Sh. Yasir posted by the likes of brother sajid were because he is advocating for looking beyond madhabs *and realizing that scholars, even giants of the past are fallible* . Yet even mufti muneer, the guy sajid defended says the SAME thing....
@Students of Knowledge طلاب العلم
Methodology of the 'salad' ??? 😂
can you tell me what he means by 'strands' though? bc it seems that is the misunderstanding somehow. Like Saajid actually says that YQ thinks that it doesn't matter what Aqeedah you have, if your a Deobandi, salafi, or whatever else, like Qadiriya, which I didn't think was what Dr Qadhi meant at all when he spoke about different 'strands'.
Jane Dughatir Could you point out the time stamp so I can see what he is referring to? Because “strands” in islam could be aqeedah based, or fiqh/school of thought based.
@Students of Knowledge طلاب العلم
Blame autocorrect ! 😁
@@symbiotezilla12345 asalaamu alaikum... i think that was @18:45 or so... it was about aqeedah pretty sure... or how to study aqeedah. Then he talks about Ibn Taiymiya's contribution or experiences. Have a good Ramadhan btw.
I did not understand the "windows" comment in the beginning. Can someone please explain?
they are just talking about Microsoft Windows Operating System and Apple MacOS operating system.
SubhanAllah, Shaikh Yasir Qadhi is one of my all time favourite Shaikhs since many years and Alhamdulillah I’ve learnt so much from his lectures which has opened my mind and heart into understanding Islam better especially in these Fitna times when certain sects who are causing division amongst the Ummah. I have benefitted so much from his lectures and I pray from the bottom of my heart that may his Da’wah and teachings be a Sadaqah e Jaariyah for him and a means for him in entering Jannat ul Firdaus, Allahumma Ameen! His words are of gold and I just wish he wasn’t interrupted with jokes.; he’s a scholar with great understanding.
We benefited from Dr Yasir Qadhi a lot but, we disagree som of his newly theological explanations. For instance, the comparison of physics and Islam (newton and Islamic scholars) is totally unsuitable. Human is a weak by nature whatsoever level and status he /she has reached.
(كل بنى آدم خطاء ، وخير الخطائين التوابون)
My Allah protect us and our ulamas from the Fitan.
Masha Allah
I agree with you as well
Dr YQ is a very knowledgeable individual but he seems to be experiencing doubts therefore he needs to be vigilant about his Eeman..He also needs to seek sincere guidance from Allah since Allah is the only one who guides the hearts..W'll make du'a for him may Allah guide us all to the straight path Allahuma Aameen❤
YQ said it himself that theres knowledge thay would do more harm than good may Allah help him
The example he gave makes perfect sense, but I think most people misunderstood it. It brilliantly describes who as one grows up and keeps learning about things, the way they understand that same subject will deepen and widen and develop. The student who began studying classical physics and later learned quantum physics will understand this.
YALEsir Qadhi is what this man ends up after many years of studying. I have listened to All of his seera class, All of his story of sahaba, the mother of the believers and much of his lectures and I would always wonder why is this guy keeps saying "let us Humanize the Sahaba, let us Humanize the Prophet" now I understand why. Because once he brings them down to his level and put doubt in the mind of the mass and lose the respect, it will be easy for him to say they are men and we are men, they make mistakes like we make mistakes so we don't have to follow or do exactly the same way as they did. If he has the audacity to say we can any kind of aqidah and still be ok, I have more rights to say the truth is one and follow it (the way of the salaf as sualih) and warn against to everything that's newly invented in the deen because if the truth was many there are no need to send the prophets and Messengers. Oh Allah do not misguide us after after you have guided. And guide those are misguided so that they don't misguide others
@de you will keep losing if don't stop listening this so called I know it all clown
@de before I forget, you worried about losing some points, well if you keep listening this man you will lose your Deen too if any left i
@@muhammedmuhammed2645 Yeah man you are right after I listened to Yasir crap about Yajuj Majud 2 days earlier.
@de Dont mock him.. go n see Yasir stupid claims about Yajuj Majuj. you will himself disregard this stupid Yasir once n for all
I am here from saajid Lipham videos.
Saajid Lipham deleted my comments when i tried to correct him. He misunderstands so much of what Yasir Qadhi was explaining.
Saajid keeps misconstruing what Yasir Qadhi says, and when anyone tries to explain that to him, he deletes their comment from his channel.
@@checkmate5338 He made an apology video+ a brief explanation.
I was yesterday as well.
Jane Dughatir I couldn't actually get what brother Saajid was trying to say.
Salaam dear brothers & sisters
Stick to the salaf of this Ummah the blessed 3 generations which the prophet pbuh praised. And anyone who clings on their path without bringing their own* opinions involved.
Be careful of connecting yourselves to the khalaf (the ones who are alive now) for they are alive and can be lead astray by worldly gains or any other whim/desire!.
How many a people Allah had blessed with knowledge and they let shaytan get the better of them. And they chased dunya rather than akhira.
Wallahi its enough for the sincere Muslim to follow the path of the ones I mentioned. And no doubt the sincere slave of Allah who frees himself/herself from arrogance and high self thought. Allah shall guide and bestow fiqh (understanding of his deen).
May Allah keep us firm upon his deen and make us from those who tread the middle path and not the 2 extremes.
Wasalaam.
جزاك الله يا اخى
بارك الله فيك
@@Jklmao2308 Same for you bro, may the turner of the hearts keep our hearts firm.
@@ayubmohamed369 Same for you bro, may the turner of the hearts keep our hearts firm.
Yusuf Suleiman
Then why are you following fools like Abdul Wahhab, Bin Baz & Ibn Taymmiyyah... you bunch of hypocrites
Very thought provoking however it is always best to stick within the ijam’ah off non boxed off mentality Ulema.
Imam Ash-Shatibi r.a. who said:
“Evil and misguided scholars are those who are dangerous to mankind. They are a disease to mankind, and they are those who do not act on their knowledge.”
In his book Al-Fawa’id, Ibnul Qayyim r.a. gave a parable. He said:
“Evil and misguided scholars are like people sitting on the gates of Paradise (Jannah) and calling people to come on in. With their tongues they are saying come on in, come on in, but their actions are saying do not come in. The more they talk to people and tell people to come in, the more their actions say do not listen to us, because if we were indeed truthful then we would have been the first to apply it…”
Very honest disclosures by shaykh Yassir, May Allah safeguard his Quran memorization in order to remain well balanced.
And Quraan understanding...memorizing is not enough when you face the level of doubts and debates that dr. yasir qadhi faces. Anybody can memorize the quraan...but what impact are such people having on the non muslims in their land? Dawah wise?
May Allah guide Yasir Qadhi back to how he used to believe 15 years ago.
Ameen
You prefer him to be sectarian? Wow
@@sugetsumillenium2112 no never Salafiyyah is not a sect, it is the true path. If you believe n follow quran and sunnah according to salaf (sahabas and followers) then you r on the right path. if u do what they used to not do then ur misguided. Yasir Qadhi's views have changed n he likes to cooperate with other sects.
asSalamualaikum my Brother, I feel like the harsh Salafi Dawah of the 90s and 2000s proved to be a superficial interpretation of a very rich islamic heritage, that is why there is a movement away from the more formalistic salafi approach towards something which speaks more to the heart. allah knows best
@@muhammada3749 salafiyah is not a sect?! The fact that you gave it a label separating it from other sects makes it a sect you moron. Typical idiot ignorant salafi comment LOL
If Allah loves someone, He gives them a deep understanding/knowledge of the Deen
Deep understanding from non Muslim teachers of Yale?
@@TareqKhan0 To be a scholar you need more than the knowledge of Quran & Sunnah. You also need the ilm of makan & zaman. Our pious predecessors understood this, just look at the Imams of our madhahib. And here you guys are completely dismissing the importance of learning the knowledge of makan & zaman.
Indeed..May Allah bless sh yasir Qhadi for choosing to grow in deen despite the overwhelming misunderstanding of him
@@TareqKhan0 lol 'without' taking it in the context of this video, I due admit the statement is hilarious.
@@Muhammad-Al-Hafidz Did the prophet Muhammad sallallah alay wa salaam ever say you need more than just knowledge of the Quran and the sunnah to be a scholar and if so which hadiths proceeded you in your statement also which verses of the Quran say this please enlighten me?
28:29 YQ says: When it comes to theological madh-hab choose one whether its athari, ashari, maturidi (laa howla wa laa quwwata illa billaah)
Couldn't agree more with the Sheikh. He's spot on what the umma needs to focus on.
Excellent interview. Don't agree with everything the Shaykh says, but he's definitely an asset to the Ummah.
what don't you agree with may I ask??
BEWARE of what this guy says in regards to aqeedah. Beware of people who use their opinion in general regarding Islam May Allah SWT guide us all
Unscripted topics shared by Sheikh YQadhi is refreshing.
Mashallah, I enjoy Yasir Qadi in conversation rather than preaching. Very intellectual.
And very misguided. His extensive knowledge won't save him.
what an excellent video. thank u for this. May God bless you.
Na bro. Aqeedah breathes life into the heart. When you know the Lord you worship
MashaAllah Very informative. Love the jokes as well.
Yeah great ice breakers.
Great episode mashAllah. May Allah reward you all.
You mean absolutely awful. May Allah guide us all
Asalamcaleykum ur Dutch revert brother
yusuf Anderson , My dear brother *PLEASE* watch my *Playlists*
Wa aleykum essalaam wa rahmatu'Allahi wa barakaatuhu, brother.
yusuf Anderson Wa alaykom asalam bro. MashaAllah. Much love from New York
Walaikumsalam wahragmataalahi wahbarakatahu
wa alekom salam broeder
Excellent talk. We need scholars who can bring our people out of these sectarian view that's rotting the Ummah. Time to move on.
These "sectarian views" are from the sunnah. From the hadeeth of the 73 sects. And you're denying it.
Wow, Salman Al Awda the Ibn Taymiyya of our time? Who is he compared to Ibn Taymiyya!? Subhan Allah. Salman Awda, Sardar Hawaii are Ekhwaani Muslimoon. Hense Yasir Qadi is their student.
Yeah, that was a heavy statement, but nothing compared to saying he wants to delete stuff from kaahfu shubuhaat.
Do you mean "Kashaf ash-Shubuhaat" by Sh AbdulWahab? If so, so what? Is that the Qur'an or something?
Abdus Samad yes, I did mean kashfu shubuhaat. Thanks for the correction.
MUHAMMAD HIJAS why are you directing that comment to me? Where did I call everyone or even anyone ikhwaani?
MUHAMMAD HIJAS even if I was, why didn’t you direct your comment towards him rather than starting on me?
Great Talk. Saw a little bit of Sheikh's personal side. May Allah bless you all
First time I’ve come across this channel, I thought the hosts were great. Brilliant podcast.
Allah guides whomsoever He wills and sends astray whomsoever He wills.
The problem lies in the fact his a student of knowledge himself so now his sitting with professors who are persuading him, the professors he learnt from maybe could meet these professors then more even playing field. His constantly Changing his views. But he does have a good grasp of the western Problems and it’s not the debate of the atharis and Ashreees as so many falling away from the deen
Ikhwanism, watering down the religion, belittling the scholars, doubting major concepts, how much more misguided can become in a sitting with these types of individuals. Ajeeb!
His is a victim of studying the creed of Ahlul Bidah and never clung to the Olama of Sunnah of today’s time to guide him while studying. This is why he never had a good relationship with the Olama there in Medina. Rather some of them like Sheikh Khalid Raddadi warned the students to stay away from him when he was a undergrad student
who is ahlul bidah???
Truth!
Overall, we should be tolerant and (a little bit more) open minded against sectarianism.
Because YQ said it, it's the truth.
"I saw it in a museum." oh boy these guys should all do standup. 3 min to 5 min...next level comedy. I love the British digs...YQ for life.
Good podcast but too much joking and laughing
His comments about refusal to take selfies and breaking ppls khatir(roughly translates to heart/emotions) reminds me of when the prophet (pbuh) accepted some milk he didn’t want that was offered to him by an old lady. Even tho he didn’t want it, he didn’t want to break her khatir. I think it’s a unease you must tolerate when you become a “known” scholar.
Good interview! I wish Dr. Yasir Qadhi all the best.
39:41
This is what happens when you take knowledge of Deen from Tony Blair n likes May Allah guides us all.
@ subahanalah. Prophet and His companion didn't graduate or have PhD but manage to teach the ummah to the way of Islam. Thats isn't fair criticism toward who dissagree to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi
The blind followers don’t care as long as he has phD. Even when he says things which may take one from fold of Islam, his got PhD and you don’t.
Clear Baatil!
and warned against too much eating too. I need to control my eating too. So please don't give importance to food too much. Moderation.
So sad for you Dr. Yasir!
May Allah guide you and bring you back to the truth Dr. Yasir.
May Allah make us steadfast and firm on the truth till we die.
I LOVE AND LIKE SHEIKH YASIR Qadhi's mind set I have the same though of course not all of it I am saying about the disunity of Ummah..... Why should we separate and make a group while all of them are Believing in One God And Last Messenger.... Yes there may be different in way of understanding in laws but throw all of away keep them separately but I am saying is pleased let's reunite again......
The true aqeedah of the first three generations of Islam is not something which was developed, rather when the likes of those astray groups such as the Jahmiyyah and Mu'tazilah began spreading their falsehood the scholars spoke out and expressed the correct Aqeedah. Ibn Taymiyyah and his student Ibn-ul-Qayyim did not bring anything new with regards to Aqeedah; they only reinforced the Aqeedah of the first three generations of Islam and refuted the astray groups of their times.
How many stand with sheikh yasir after watching his latest video on yajooj and Majooj. Like who don’t and comment who do
His own mind doesnt stand with him
I do . Best lecture ever Mash allah
Many people stand with him still just off the mere fact that he's criticized Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab who Sufis, modernists, and Shia dispise. But people have ignored a lot of the other things that Yasir has said recently just because he critiqued the one man who they hate the most.
Yasir Qadhi has literally admitted publicly that he had a faith crisis at Yale yet people still go through his lectutures and pick 1 thing that they like out of a 30 minute speech and promote that 1 thing as if there aren't 5 other issues in the same speech.
I've even seen an agnostic/atheist praise Yasir Qadhi just because he said one thing that they liked. People seek validation from everything BUT the Kitab and sunnah.
It's wrong to not give Scholars of the muslim world their due and to say that we have sufficient scholars in the west if thats what is being suggested if not forgive me.Particulularly when you have benefitted from that knowledge.Especially so if that also means its acceptable to learn Islam from non muslims.Think about where that will take us.
I think Sheikh Yasir Qadhi should speak about sectarianism in Islam more! Its needed for the students of knowledge
Yasir Qadhi potrays islam in such a complicated way so much so that only Yale graduates can understand. But lo and behold! among the first who answered the call were bedoins...
So who needs Yasir Qadhi to teach us islam?
If you are studying at primary level why would you attend a Master's level class?
You good comment.. and that’s the point ...this religion is simple and with Islam brought by a simple man who were followed by simple people
Jabalnur Jabalthur
only circumstantial illustrations predominated the discussion. Madina remains exceptionally outstanding as a source of undiluted Islamic guidance. But when one has been shot by philosophical ideas then he thinks otherwise. Islam permits 100 % plagiarism so, we have to ignore this kind of confused ideas and copy 100 % from good Islamic teachings.
May Allah guide him and us all toward the right path. May Allah make us firm on the path of undiluted Islam teachings.
Ameen
Yasir Qadhi has started crossing the red line. He has publicly said that he has left the aqeedah of the salaf and that is what moving on meant as he phrased it. If you are saying that aqeedah is no more important in this our generation because we are now dealing with atheism, LGBTQ, etc. because of these we should stop teaching people aqeedah which is the foundation of everthing u do in Islam. If your aqeedah is wrong any other things u do in Islam will not be accepted. Yasir Qadhi new ideology is just to be a muslim in this world in whatever way anyone wants whether or not it will be acceptable by Allah that does not matter. What really matters is to be able to westernized Islam in such ways it will be accepted to the world power for us to be able to be Americans muslims, British muslims etc.. Yasir Qadhi priority is for muslims to be acceptable by the world powers but their aqeedah being accepted by Allah or not in the hereafter is no more important in this our generation that muslims existence is being threatened in western world. This is a dangerous Ideology Yasir Qadhi.
It just feels wrong to listen to him. I just can't take him as a teacher. His words only place doubts in the heart of people about Islam. He calls every subject - a human development -, an attempt to understand God's wisdom. Then this is similar to perennialism. Why is he so sure of his Western-backed knowledge of Islam and not of how Muslim scholars have taught. All the time he blasts our ulamas as be completely retrograde and in the end, he says "I respect them ", that's not how true respect works... I feel, he should talk to Daniel Haqiqatjou to get his ideas correct.
Some of what he says is correct and i don't say that he is a deviant or anything.
Do you know where Sheikh Yasir Qadhi was educated?
Br. Daneil has a nice degree FROM Harvard but has he every studied in Medina?
Well said bro!! I wonder how he will be in the future by going down his new creed !!?? And Allah knows best !!
Putting reason before revelation on matters of belief opens the door to doubts and many more versions about ghayb, much more than the versions of bible out there and none of which would be correct. Physics deals with things that could be observed/measured and thus can developed. The unseen matters are not and hence the comparison between Newtonian and Einsteinian physics is not adequate.
Thank you Yasir Qadhi for exposing Islam.You helped me understand evolution.
what do you mean.
The opening questions reflect the round shape of the interviewers. Time to hit the treadmill.
Disappointing to see Islam21c do this. At the very least you could've grilled him more instead of being so enamoured.
@@quantummovement8879 who said it's a sunnah. The max that is attributed is mustahab or mubhha.
@@quantummovement8879 yeah. He said it's a minor issue comparatively, the key word being comparatively.
In any case its a fiqhi issue, not an aqeeda one.
@E .S check your sources and also mention chief of fitnah Iran.
Quantum Movement Israel gives Palestine aid by your logic israel is fine too
@@quantummovement8879 This is your opinion. For how long we gonna keep arguing over what Mr.A and Mr. B sunnah?. Sunnah is big. What's black to you is white to other vis vis. Mawlid is least matter of argument in this day and age. Whoever wants to celebrate mawlid can go ahead as long as they stick to shariah guidelines.
"I was gonna bring my copy of Kashaf ash-Shubuhaat for you to sign but..." LOL! I only listen to these podcast for Salman's jokes
MashaAllah quality episode
11:37 dude is checking his watch lol
116 dislikes from the people of Timbuktu, their city took a real beating here.
Fruck outtahere what is it with you and your likes always using Timbuktu in a derogatory way
@@jayoils123 LOL. When? You know I've got love for the well of Buktu
is it timbuktu in Mli west Africa ?
My favourite podcast but the presenters need to know which guests to let talk ie yq and which guests to have more input with. Just let him talk you guys interrupted maybe a little too much, BarakAllahu feekum though you guys are smashing it!
Yeah, it was a bit weird when yq was speaking about some really serious topic, sometimes even speaking about the Qur'an, and then they just respond with a joke 😕
43:20 anyone know the mosque, mufti and masters graduate Shaykh Yasir was referring to
I'm not 100% sure but I think it's Green Lane Masjid in Birmingham since they always bring scholars from overseas.
Why so many dislikes? All these people yapping about Yale forget that Yasir Qadhi also studied in Madinah. Also very good series on the Seerah. Instead of going to Hyde Park and listen to fools like Shamsi you would learn more watching Yasir Qadhis Seerah . Young over zealous people who think that you can only be a scholar if you are a Shaykh Salih Al Fawzan sitting in Saudi-Arabia. 242 dislikes from Dawah man types.
@RealDeal441 Tell me, where does he undermine the importance of Aqeedah, Aqeedah is important I don't think anyone disagrees with that. He also doesn't mock them, he is criticizing people without naming them. If you recall this Khariji called Dawah Man made an entire video slandering Yasir Qadhi so before you accuse Yasir Qadhi of mocking I would direct your attention to self taught wikipedia Sheikhs like Dawah Man. Who think that after 2 years of studying they can refute scholars. Foolishness. Dawah Man didnt even do a goob job in refuting because he misquoted and misunderstood Yasir Qadhi a lot.
@@sheriefelsayad5578 Many of them are coming from another young salafi channel, who misunderstands so much of what Yasir Qadhi says.
I wanted to ask a question
-I am a 17 year old girl btw so excuse me if I don't understand some things-
But first and foremost, I think Dr. Sheikh Yasir Qadhi is intellectual scholar very beneficial to Muslims
Especially those in academia and the youth. Personally living in the US can be difficult at times with Islamophobia and people being ignorant of your religion. I feel like having scholars here in the US is a great blessing. Since you have people who understand you, and explain matters very clearly and carefully. And it really has helped me learn more about my deen Allhamduliah 😁💙
I feel like constant arguing and not having respect for another puts our Ummah down. If we all helped each other in times of distress and were there for each other's backs, no nations wouldn't mess with us. And you wouldn't see such horrendous and heartbreaking wars and genocides going on in Muslim countries. Were is the action. People can say a LOT but do very little--this goes to everyone including me.
So why are people fighting/slandering the participants, I mean is this the way to come. Everyone makes mistakes, this makes us human. However, is this what Islam teaches us to call nasty names to people of knowledge. I am just puzzled by the nature of people. May Allah swt. Grant us knowledge, WISDOM, and understanding. This is so disgusting what is going on in this comments. Tomorrow this is going to be presented in front of us. What will be the excuse for calling them such derogatory names. I am so disgusted, disappointed, horrified at the nature of our Muslim community. This is NOT what our beautiful deen teaches us. The Prophet-peace and blessings be upon him- was a man full of wisdom, is this how he corrected and informed others? Also to point people are trying to get closer to their deen, put when they see this it just puts them down. This is pretty long, so forgive for that brother. But I am so unhappy what the toxicity in this comment sphere. May God grant our scholars righteousness and grant them the highest in Jannah. Also may Allah make you successful in this world and in the next. AMEEN 🤲🏼
May Allah give you hidayath,
Wa Alaikum mus Salaam
I like the end message. Live Islam well. That's it. I am guilty as charged.
Does YQ really believe he has a place to promote his own ideology over the salaf who came before him? I used to look up to this guy but he is going the route Suhaib Webb is going. I won't be surprised if tomorrow he was getting triggered over gender pronouns.
That assumption is very extreme by the way. Suhaib won't dare criticize any state official and policy all of whom.yq has explicitly stated and defended
God reward you with the best!
So many people are misunderstanding this interview. I think you guys need to do a followup interview in which all the misunderstandings are cleared up.
But is it not the case that part of saving the youth is to teach them the correct belief (aqeedah) first?
2nd point. The salaf were very quick to refute the people of kalam which includes the Ash'aariah. And the Ashari's of that time were better than those of today. And the early Ashari creed is different to the current Ashari creed where as the Athari creed has not changed
Couldnt agree more with syech Yasir.. 👍
You did not only study with the Kufar, you ended up promoting their ideas of us.
@Bouba Sane, do you know who is a kafir? Can you tell? Do you know how you will end? Fellow brother in Islam, let me give you the advice of great imam Abu Hanifa, he said it was better to deem 1000 Kumar as muslims than to attribute our to single muslim. It is important to hold our thoughts because ان السمع والبصر والفواد كل اولاءك كان عنه مسؤولا
@@alhassangangu4357 You're missing the entire point he's referring to when Yasir Qadhi went to Yale and by his own admission said he had a faith crisis. He's not making takfir of anyone since Yale is indeed a non Muslim school.
Also, to be technical takir does exist in Islam since the angels Harut and Marut made takfir of the magicians in Babylon. Takfir on individuals requires shurut (conditions) such as a person who is jahil, is forced to do kufr, has a moment of insanity, is not of mature age, did an act of kufr without intending, etc. The Muslim judges and scholars within a Muslim state judge people by these conditions because takfir has a hukm that is attached to it.
Yes there are those who go to the extreme in takfir and confuse kufr akbar with kufr asghar, and kufr 'amali with kufr itiqadi, but takfir does exist and the brother you are responding to never made takfir on anyone to begin with.
Also, Abu Hanifa's own student Abu Yusuf became a qadi (chief judge), one of their functions is to declare takfir, tabdi', etc on people when necessary so we can't pick and choose examples.
Ahlus Sunnah are between the Khawarij who declare kufr without meeting the conditions and between the murji'ah who say that no one can be judged by action and statement.
Excellent talk Dr Yasir qhadi..😍😍
May Allah grant Sheikh Salman Al Odah freedom, the Sheikh Ul Islam of our times! We need him back🙏🏽
Enjoyed this because of the guest Dr Yasir Qadhi
A bit of constructive criticism in my opinion it was a bit too light hearted - too many jokes
May Allah SWT accept your efforts
He probably meant 40 %of leicester is indian who are hindu sikh and Muslim
MashaAllah superb job Love you all specially nice talk from Yasir Qadhi my fav sheikh
Our Shiekh's need to also care for thier physique as much they care for ilm.
Their accent is not easy to understand. They eat so many words. 😂😁😂😁
This Hadīth refutes Yasir Qadhi:
Ibrāheem Ibn Abdur Rahmān Al ‘Udhri reports that the Messenger ﷺ said:
_"This knowledge is carried in every generation by the trustworthy ones, they repel from it the distortions of those who go beyond bounds, the fabrications of those who fabricate, and the false interpretations of the ignorant"_
*يَحْمِلُ هذا العلمَ من كلِّ خلَفٍ عُدُولُهُ ، ينفونَ عنه تحريفَ الغالينَ ، وانتحالَ المُبْطِلينَ ، وتأويلَ الجاهِلينَ*
[الألباني، تخريج مشكاة المصابيح ٢٣٩ • مرسل، لكن روي موصولا من طريق جماعة من الصحابة، وصحح بعض طرقه الحافظ العلائي]
How does it refute him?
Fantastic podcast. Guys you 2 are fun but joke just a little too much. We would have benefitted from a few more solid advises but hey thanks for sharing this moment with us. Chapeau Dr YaYasir😊 you are so full of knowledge fire so many ideas MashaAllah may the Almighty protect your heart from any form of celebrity-thrill. Ameen
Bc the interviewer was there he kinda saved YQ from a bigger blunder #IMO
@@Diamondraw4Realwdym ??
Exactly what I was thinking... Too much interruptions with jokes and too often
Timeless principles don't change, their proofs hasn't changed. Today's reality is not significantly different from the past. Others' experiences and from their communities is knowledge for us.
@@ankhmorpok1497 I stand by what I said. We can deal with modernity, what is there not to be able to deal with? When I said today's reality isn't significantly different from the past I wasn't referring to advancing technologically and across other aspects of the human domain not ignoring that we too have declined with becoming spoilt human beings, distracted by living dramas, deluded etc. I was talking more about basic living structures, objectives, religion etc. That still stands, we're just living those realities in this modern age. Anyway the gist of my comment was that time is not the issue because God created it and therefore His religion works for anytime because it is not bound by it. Perhaps you're not acquainted with history, have you heard of islamic Spain where muslim civilisation were thriving whilst Europe was living in the dark ages? And then down the line due to internal conflicts and political issues, Islam lost that by God's plan and will becoming a shell of its former self. It hasn't got anything to do with modernity or you probably thought I was of the thinking that technology is haram? Hahaha. We're discussing something completely different here.
My comment was a specific one on Islamic principles not changing and their proofs still preserved with our Prophetic tradition. That is a fact. If someone wants to change it for themselves or misinform others then they will be refuted for their deviation and they will bear the sin. That's all there is to it. Don't confuse human products with what God sent as invincible. The former changes the latter does not.
Slmz, Very interesting talk. How would someone be able to sign up or subscribe for that online course???
From what i gather... Newton and Einstein were basically onto the same thing but the knowledge and understanding of those around them IS the major difference. Imagine if I You and were to teach the exact same lesson to two different groups of people. You have a bunch of modern people and im teaching cave men... Whos gonna be more successful???
Really poor questions by the brothers I must say. It would have been more interesting if they asked thought provoking questions and more grilling.
Came for the fish and chips 😂😂😂😂
So eye opening mashaAllah
may Allah reward all your efforts ya Shaikh ❤
May Allah guide you
Mohammed Mesaed Dont forget yourself for asking quidance, because we all need that ☝️
It is like a competition "Who can ask faster questions". Annoying accent + Lightening Speed = I could not withstand 3 minutes...
Yasir Qadi is on a mission to convince people that Salafi Dawah has many stands. Where did he get this from? Just like Muslims in general are devided, but Islam is clear. Likewise the saved victorious group those who strictly follow Rasool sallallahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah radhi Allahu anhum is clear. This group unites it's followers with Aqeedah, Manhaj, evidence and principles in all issues. This group has various names to identify it. Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama'ah. AhlusSunnah, Sunni, Salafi Dawah, Salafiyyah, Ahlul Hadeeth, Ahlul Athar, Firqatun Najiya, Taifatul Mansoora. They are distinct from the Ahlul Bidah.
🤦♂️🤦🏿♂️
@Witness Truth hadeeth of Mu‘aawiyah ibn Abi Sufyaan (may Allah be pleased with him), who said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) stood up amongst us and said: “Those who came before you of the people of the Book split into seventy-two sects, and this ummah will split into seventy-three sects, seventy-two of which will be in the Fire and one in Paradise. That is the jamaa’ah (the main body of Muslims).”
@Witness Truth brother, the Prophet Muhammad, sallAllahu alayhi wasalam, spoke about only ONE group that would go to Jannah among the Muslims. What did Yasir Qadho say in this podcast? The EXACT opposite. So choose who you follow, and remember your death and the Day of Judgement.
@Witness Truth there are also other versions and narators of IT. I have not come across anyone saying the concept of the 73 sects Being weak.
@Witness Truth Shaykh Ibn Taymiyyah  said:
"This Hadeeth is authentic and is well-known in the books of Sunnah and in the Masaanid (plural of Musnad), such as the Sunnah of Abu Daawood, At-Tirmithi, An-Nasaa’i, and others. The wording of the Hadeeth is as follows:
'The Jews were split up into seventy-one sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one; the Christians were split up into seventy-two sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one; and my nation will split up into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in Hellfire except one.'
Another narration reads: "They asked: 'O prophet of Allah, who will be the saved sect?' He  replied: 'Those who will remain on the path which I and my companions are on today.'"
Yet, another narration reads: "They are the Jamaa’ah (the main body of Muslims); the Hand of Allah is with the Jamaa’ah."
It is for this reason that the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, described the saved sect as the Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa’ah, who are the overwhelming multitude and the great majority of the Muslims. The other sects are followers of aberrant views, schism, innovations and deviant desires. [….] The sign with which these sects are known is contradicting the Quran, the Sunnah, and the consensus of the scholars. Whoever acts according to the Book of Allah, the Sunnah, and the consensus (of the scholars), then he is from Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa’ah.'" [End of quote]