Everything Wrong with The Silence of the Lambs With A Side of Fava Beans
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 фев 2020
- The Silence of the Lambs is an all-time classic! Anthony Hopkins gives one of the best performances in film history! But yeah, it's got some sins, like all movies. So we counted them.
Next week: Disney sins and British sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book
#CinemaSins
#EverythingWrongWith
#SilenceOfTheLambs 
Кино
There are never actually any lambs in the movie *ding*
*blows mind*
They're still screaming...
Like that matters to this channel
Fact!
Actually there is a lamb drawn in charcoal in one of Lectors drawings . So technically there is a lamb in it
Finally a movie without “45 seconds of logos” and he sins the damn lion 😐
😂😂
😂😂😂😇😂😃😂😫🙄😂🤩😛🤪😛😟🤠👍😂😂👆
So?
It's a sin itself to sin any cat, big or small, for any reason.
He did the same thing with first blood🤬
The scene where he says chianti was making fun of her accent, and it was improvised so Jodie Foster's reaction to it was completely real with shock and slight hurt.
Good to know!!
Really? They weren't even together when they filmed these scenes..
@@ottomattix86 some scenes they did do together with him behind the glass. She said it in interviews
Nope; she has now said many many times that they were never even in the same room together filming these scenes; they were both just looking at a camera; that she had not even met Hopkins yet....
For people who said there's no lambs in the movie. It refers to the conversation she has with lecter where she said she grew up near slaughterhouse and she felt bad for the lambs that were crying out and then silence when they were killed. She said she always wanted to do something to save them. Now she is. The lambs in the title are the innocent victims that are silenced when murdered. So yes there are lambs in the movie.
Nice i like this
Ehh, that's a real stretch. A _real_ stretch. If that's true, they were clearly desperately reaching for some, _any,_ symbolism they could find.
Yes the lambs come from there but I think here Clarice is actually trying to find a redemption of some sort. She "wakes up in the dark to the screaming of the lambs" and feels guilty because she couldn't save them, she's compelled to save people so that she can "make up" that time when she couldn't save the innocents. When working on a case she hears the lambs (the innocent victims) screaming and when she manages to save them they stop (so now they're silent) because they're no more in danger, and will finally let her sleep peacefully.
Maybe it's the Mandela effect, but I thought they showed a flashback of her has a child carrying a lamb and running away with it.
@@reedr7142doesn’t show it but she describes it. She says she tries to save at least ONE lamb. She grabbed it and tried to run with it but it was too heavy
Fun fact from my dad who was at the FBI academy: You DO have to walk past all that shit to get to the offices.
Interesting, thanks for clearing that up. I've heard several people having a lot of online debates about the exact layout of the FBI campus grounds. Basically, someone said the scene is "impossible" because a highway or something physically blocks you from reaching the trees! Then the forum went into a meltdown and I couldn't keep up. I didn't bother to ask for someone to state whether or not there really is a small forest right next to the campus...
Thank ya
@@largol33t1 I went there for training in 1998. There is forest all over the place, but the obstacle course she was running is like 3 miles from the main academy. There are some other problems with what she does, but I really like this guy's videos.
@Frank Pitts, I did none of that, because I probably can’t cause I’m not American
True
can we just praise the fuck out of Anthony Hopkins...the man seems a gentleman in real life, is an amazing actor and brilliant piano player
dancingmonkey08 you must of seen his waltz he wrote played by Andre Rieu?
Just watched Two Popes, he was great in that too. A decent movie btw.
No 😅
for any fans of Anthony Hopkins I would suggest watching the HBO series "Westworld", where he is brilliant as Dr Robert Ford
I ❤love🧡 him in Legends of the Fall too!
Part of Lecter's character is that he is, in his own perverse fashion, a true gentleman. He's a murderer and a cannibal, yes, but he also has a fixation on things like respect, decorum, and politeness. That's part of what makes his character interesting, is that disconnect between utterly horrific crimes while also being a man of culture and civility. He's certainly capable of terrible things, but there are other actions and behaviors that he finds unconscionable and unforgivable, as in the case of Multiple Miggs. He knows what he's doing and he has never intended on doing it any other way.
This is why, although it seems many believe it is Mandela Effect, he wouldn't say 'Hello Clarice' on his first meeting with Starling.
This would be over-familiar and rude, which is not his character.
i never seen him on my long jump vids, he aint a man of culture lol
@@lazer2365 he breaks his politeness often so its not that much out of character
Fun fact about Jame Gumb's house: "During location scouting for the house in which the serial killer Jame Gumb was living, Ted Levine (Jame Gumb) was amazed to discover that the house being considered was not only in the town where he grew up, but was literally next door to the house of his high school girlfriend.
"
Thanks for posting. Very interesting!
Every damn scene with Anthony Hopkins in it should immediately have sins removed.
So the Movie pretty much wouldn’t have any sins.
Braxton Bling Very true, but he was actually only onscreen for 16 minutes
@@duelsedge309 nor should it. I mean come on it's near perfect
true story; if hopkins didn’t get success out of this role, he was going to give up american film and go back to stage acting in the UK
True. Sir Anthony is great
I saw this movie in the theater. The scene where Buffalo Bill opens the door and you see it's Clarice standing there, every single person in the theater said OH SHIT out loud, simultaneously. Moments like this are why I still like seeing movies in a movie theater.
cant fuck with that
but why? that movie is so boring
The movie didn’t tell Clarice that Hannibal had something in common with Buffalo Bill because, as later explained in the movie, if she had an agenda going in Hannibal would see right through it, Roy with her and then go cold, which makes sense because when she goes to interview him with the questionare he calls her out for so obviously transitioning to asking him to fill it out. He saw right through her and if she had a different goal he would have seen that too, therefore ruining her chance of getting anywhere.
Correct.
Barney wasn't being condescending, she looked nervous, he was being supportive and encouraging
I've never seen so many sins removed.... Good
This movie is a masterpiece.
He dared to sin Silence of the Lambs, unsining it a reasonably amount is a requirement for that.
I didn't like this movie. I prefer James Bond.
Exactly what makes it such a masterpiece? Idk that much about film.
movies such as seven, pulp fiction, mission impossible: rouge nation, the lego movie, and both Deadpool movies got more sins removed
Douglas Murphy and what are you?
Fact: This is the only horror / thriller movie that ever won Best Picture
And one of only 3 movies ever to win all top 5 (best picture, director, actor, actress and screenplay).
@@fearless1024 woah are you kidding me??? That's amazing
Wasn’t Beauty And The Beast the runner-up for Best Picture the same year this movie won it? Can’t fully remember if that’s so without Googling it on Bing first.
not any more. parasite just won best picture
Gone With The Wind? If you are black, Gone With The Wind is a horror movie.
Your sin about just using a common hose to threaten her can be explained by Buffalo Bill not wanting to damage her skin before it's ready to be removed. At least that was always my assumption. Plus the rhyme he says helps him get across that he's crazy so be mindful while also seeing her as an object.
"The judge was called Judge Detox. I'm sure the prosecutor was Alexander Rehab." lmao
The emphasis of "Chi- ANNE- ti" was ironic, I think. He said it like a hillbilly, as a dig to Starling.
Kira Carver that is actually the correct pronunciation... its italian
Cinemasins is incorrect
The book specify that he actually did.
Source needed
The book doesnt mention Chianti at all. In the book he drank "a big Amarone" with the poor chap's liver and fava beans.
I'm sure it was intentional. In the book, Lecter pokes fun at her family background several times.
"It puts the lotion on the skin or you get the hose again" should be a sin off for one of the best villain lines of all time
FFFFfffffFFFFFfffffFFFFFfffff
One of the best villain lines of all time and you didn't even quote it right. 100 sins for you
It wasn't til I read your comment that this line could have a totally other meaning in a, um, different movie genre
YUP!
I just realized they referenced this line in fkn Sam and cat
Can we appreciate how The Silence of The Lambs is leagues above many modern horror movies?
Horror is more than just spamming jumpscares left and right like you're padding the runtime.
There's a nice helping of genuine art that elevate the movie into a natural classic on top of becoming an iconic one at that.
11:01 "It rubs the lotion on it's skin or it gets the hose again." Iconic Line. Needs a Sin Off.
The only thing wrong with this movie is that I couldn't trust anyone when they ask "If I could help them load up a sofa in their van" lol
Honestly, it should... That was Ted Bundy's tactic 😱
You spelled THEIR wrong
lol. That is like someone asking you "does this rag smell like chloroform to you?"
\/(^_^)\/
@@FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_ hmm lemme take a sniff.... Oh wait.... Ah you got me!
That's a good thing. Your survival instincts have just leveled up.
The running at the start shows her dedication and isolation. She’s giving it all for the bureau, alone.
The running at the start is an allusion to Atalanta. The nymph that the boys couldnt beat in a foot race to win her hand. That and as women a good portion of our lives is being pursued. Sometimes in courtship, sometimes in competition, and sometimes with our very lives and bodily integrity at stake. We're all just running from boys.
It's also a visual reminder that she's focused and tenacious, like a dog with a bone. She keeps going even when her colleagues believe the job is done. Like Jeanette's comment above, I'd also wondered if it was partly to point out how vulnerable women can be, no matter how intelligent or capable. Seeing her from behind like that, you feel like she's being watched or followed, hunted even.
yeah another bs sin from Bullshi...errr..CinemaSins
Claire Pettie that’s a horrifying but great point.
Ryan Graham ah tbf I still think is a great channel. The stuff they come up with has to be based on nonsense a good amount of the time.
My middle name is Clarice, My parents got it from this movie.
Well that's creepy xD
Well...HELLO CLARICE!!!
Better than being name Debbie after that movie!!
cool!
Please don't become an FBI agent
You forgot to add "Looks like meat's back on the menu, boys!".
Imagine a money-grabbing remake in 2020:
"It rubs the *Aveeno Daily Nourishing Lotion with Broad Spectrum SPF* on its skin or else it gets the hose again"
or else it gets my pocket hose as seen on T.V. again....
Taylor Craig Newbold The killer is called “The bill for buffalo wings at Boston Pizza”
@@daerdevvyl4314 Rooooolllllll Credits!
They wouldn't do it because of the transgender aspect I think
Probably a hose pipe ban these days.
Fun fact: most older handcuffs, especially those used from the early 80's through the mid 90's were REMARKABLY easy to pick with anything from a pen clip to a paper clip with almost no noticeable effort involved. You just slide it in the gap where the teeth meet the cuff, apply less pressure than it takes to click a pen, and they immediately slide apart. Sounds too easy to be true, but it absolutely was. Even from a sitting position with your hands behind your back, if you knew how to pick them, you could easily be out in seconds using only the movement of your thumb and forefinger : )
vaevictusdeus tell that to Houdini!
Sigh {gta music please}
😎
But the way Lecter was cuffed, if the cuffs were double locked he would have never been able to pick them. Not to mention what they used were actually leg irons and not handcuffs. Chain is far too long for handcuffs. Also, and this comes from 16 years experience in corrections, there is no way that the officers would need to open the cell to give Lecter his meal let alone serve him something that he would need a knife to eat with.
vaevictusdeus And you know that because...
vaevictusdeus fun fact if your wrists are slit up they can’t put handcuffs on you in all 50 states .
@@kkandsims4612 True, You use humane restraints. Wide leather cuffs with fluff inside. Like BDSM cuffs. It holds the wounds closed. You only only open them in an ER. Seen it once. A long time ago.
0:36 No the training sequence shows she is a rookie and it's important to the plot because Hannibal Lector hates veteran FBI Agents refusing to talk to them, so establishing she is a Rookie is important to the plot. Also the scene foreshadows the film's climax where she will have to employ every method she learnt in this opening sequence to catch Buffalo Bill when she chases him into the darkened basement.
The training sequence is brilliant.
Also the camera following her through the woods is meant to emphasize her vulnerability, as is the fact that she is sitting when she talks to Lecter who is standing.
And even Dr. Chilton picks up on the FBI sending male agents, remarking how long it had been since he had seen a woman. He noted the female nurse Lechter mauled and we can assume that was likely the last female nurse allowed near Lechter
Lectors first speech when he meets Clarice legit makes me shake. It’s edited and shot so well it does what it means to do to set lector up to be sociopathic
Hopkins said he worked hard at not blinking when the camara was on him, giving the character a real creepazoid effect -
Give that man an Oscar! (oh, wait... )
“F*ck you dude I sinned Pete’s dragon once”
Got me good
I was wondering if anybody else noticed that. He hated that movie more than F&F
*#lolz*
Funny how you mentioned the chap who looks at the camera at the beginning, when Jonathan Demme's shooting style is to have the characters address the camera
this is also why Barney doesnt say anything till the camera pans to him.
You tell how good the movie is with this guy based off sins removed.
@@CCD2938 oh f*ck off man. i get CS has rabid fans that will defend them for even the most asinine things but seriously grow some balls and think for yourself man. jonomagic85 is right. that's literally the shooting style prevalent throughout the entire movie. sin reductions be damned
@@ryangraham2459 not really.... That guy did it unintentionally because he was unprofessional.
@@ryangraham2459 Oh..."it's an artistic choice" means it's above critism (or sins) now? Good to know I guess.
something I notice the last time I watched this movie was that Clarice has blue eyes but in the flash backs, as a child, she has brown eyes. It sort of surprised me that they didn't use a child actor that even vaguely resembled Jodie Foster. Light hair, small features and blue eyes...that's all they needed.
They do this in a lot of movies and it always irritates me 😑 there are tons of actors with the correct eye color and it kind of takes me out of the movie for a bit
In Barney's defense, he actually was being genuinely helpful and friendly. In the next book you see how he is treated as if he's an idiot by the big bad guy's doctor. He also isn't with Lecter when they transport him to Tenn, he knew Lecter well enough to anticipate his actions fairly well.
no, assuring someone theyll do fine when going to interview a psychopathic killer in the basement or a scary insane asylum, is sexist. according to the woke narrator.
@@faceripper77 Awww, did you get triggered, poor little boy?
@@amityislandchum ironic
@@faceripper77damn, you deleted your comment and then said Ironic?
the iconic line "I ate his liver with some fava beans and a nice chianti." is the most important part of what he was saying to her. Hannibal is usually on a strict regiment of MAOIs to keep him level...but that the specific list of food and drink would inhibit their function...he's telling Clarice he's off his meds and she should tread lightly with boring him.
It's never implied whether it's true of not. He's testing her knowledge and in this scene giving here all the info she needs to solve the crime. "Belvadear". In his painting. Belvadear Ohio. If she picks up on it. Etc. Its a clever game he's playing to size her up. We dont know if the census taker story is true or not. Imo.
I don't buy this. There is no evidence or suggestion that Lecter is on MAOIs. Plus, he ate the census taker's liver years earlier, long before he was caught and locked up. Lecter never had a therapist or anything, and he was always able to function easily in society. He would have had to prescribe those MAOIs for himself. And why would he do that? He's smart enough to know those medications would not do anything worthwhile for him, or for his sociopathy, mostly because he doesn't view himself as a sociopath in the first place. And MAOI's are not normally prescribed for homicidal maniacs anyway. Sometimes Lecter is described as a psychopath and sometimes a sociopath. But Starling makes the point that there is not actually a term for what is wrong with Lecter. Anyway, the mention of his consuming the census taker's liver, years earlier, couldn't logically indicate anything about being off his meds while he's talking to Starling years afterward. Doesn't make sense.
One odd factoid about his famous line in the movie: In the original novel, Lecter says he ate the guy's liver with fava beans and a "big Amarone". The movie changed a big Amarone to "a nice Chianti". I don't know why.
@@kcmichelson4528 red dragon and manhunter are better than this movie anyday, no disrespect to jodie fostered!
@@heartless604 Noooooo sir!
Ehhhhh that's too much of a stretch. She knows she should tread lightly anyway.
You should have taken sins off for the fact that Anthony Hopkins never blinks in this movie. It's a creepy little detail that just adds to this amazing film.
10:46
He took off 5 sins at the first HL scene alone.
I love how despite being locked behind glass in solitary confinement, Hannibal is still clean shaven and his hair is very neatly trimmed and cared for.
Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins are just SPECTACULAR in this movie!
He says "Chianti" wrong because he's making fun of her accent.
He pronounces it better than the narrator of this video ruclips.net/video/inHHbfC51UQ/видео.html
In the book it was a big amarone.
Typical Ameri-centrism thinking they pronounce it correctly.
Copperhead Ridge there was a BOOK?! 🤯
It seems to be Italian words that suffer most. Lasagne and Milan also get mispronounced by Americans.
I think the fact that they dident show the I’m having a freind over for dinner part was because they would know they would have to take like 50 sins off! It was a scene that did not disappoint
Didn't*
He said "I'm having an old friend for dinner" if memory serves me right which is even better because he will, quite literally, have him for dinner. ;) Agreed though, that's such an amazing scene to end the movie on.
Didn’t*
Lmao it's basically a dad joke
3:22 Lecter knows why he's called Buffalo Bill, he's asking Clarice to see her reaction. 4:55 In the book not only is Lecter in a different spot in relation to Miggs, but he can also smell the semen (he smells other things on her as well, her perfume, her wound after she comes back from the storage garage, etc...) . 6:03 In the book Lecter gives Clarice more information about a valentine gift for her so it's a little easier to understand her logic in finding the storage garage. 8:45 Read the book and you'll get much more of her female perspective 11:13 Bill uses a hose because he doesn't want to damage her, after all, he wants to wear her skin, so he can't use a lot of torture other than cold water. 17:10 It's not out of character, Bill thinks he wants to be a woman and Clarice is very beautiful. In the book he's admiring her as she stumbles through the dark, and he used to hunt women this way - he's also thinking it's a pity she's too small for him to take the skin off of. Read the book bruh, it's better than the movie and gives you answers to many of the sins you gave it.
The movie should be able to stand on its own without having to rely on a book, especially with as much of a master cast and crew as this one has. Also, the sins aren't that deep bruh
"Cinema sins"
THE BOOKS DON'T MATTER
you must be new here
Obviously a big part of this channel is comedy.
The obstacle course sin at the beginning may seem like a nitpick at first, but its not. In the book, it starts with her training alongside her friend, who tries ambushing her as the bad guy, but fails because Starling hears her pull the hammer back on her training revolver, which is how she survives her encounter with Buffalo Bill later.
Buffalo bill uses the hose because he doesn’t want to damage her skin
Keith Milton He does need or use the face, neck, hands or feet.
Plenty to torture without damaging his body suit.
15:02 in addition to recognizing the fabric pinned to the dress, and its resemblance to the skin cut from the victim, lecter also mentions "simplicity" when telling starling how to catch buffalo bill; simplicity is a pattern company.
Simplicity patterns? That's a stretch. Lecter of course has no way of knowing that Clarice can find a dressmaking dummy in Frederica Bimmel's house. He's quoting Marcus Aurelius.
“First principles, Clarice. Simplicity. Read Marcus Aurelius. Of each particular thing, ask what is it in itself? What is its nature? What does he do, this man you seek?”
Or, in the book:
“The Emperor counsels simplicity: First principles Of each particular thing, ask: What is it in itself, in its own constitution? What is its causal nature?"
.
@@joeymama4666 nah
@@bluegenes2273uhm, yeh
wait, starlings current accent is what happened when she tried to shed it? Holyshit she must have sounded like boomhauer before all that work.....😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I know, that was a really funny line! 😄
You missed a couple of big sins. The girl that plays Clarice when she is younger has brown eyes. In the scene where Buffalo Bill puts on his googles and hunts Clarice, you can see the shadow from his arm on her, so the audience can tell they are not really in the dark.
the line "i ate his liver with some fava beans and a nice Chianti" was more a joke that lector hasn't taken his meds because the anti psychotics he was on, the 3 things you cant have is liver, beans and wine
I’m going to have to research this before repeating it to friends, but if true, this is a great “did you know” party fact!
Isn't that a restriction for certain antidepressants, though? And antipsychotics are basically the opposite of antidepressants.
Otis Browndog Gaming please tell us if true!!!
Not true. There's a class of anti depressants called MAOIs which arent used regularly anymore. They have food restrictions including liver and beans. No antipsychotics have the same rule.
He's not depressed so I doubt he would have been taking MAOIs.
Wow. Someone watched one of the 500 RUclips videos reviewing the movie that mention this overstated fact... good for you..
I feel like you missed a sin when he said butterfly, and she said "yes a moth".
Moths are considered Butterflies.
They are in the same family
I just finished the book and that's pretty much how that goes. Lecter asks if it was a butterfly and she responds saying it was a moth. It was actually a Deaths-Head Moth pupa jammed in a dead girl's throat.
I actually think "the hose" is a perfectly understandable punishment given his goals. He can't really do anything that could damage her skin, since thats the whole point of him abducting her. So instead he comes up with a punishment that will make her miserable without physically harming her, like a minor water boarding.
A lot of Lecter's weird clues and "help" were him playing with Clarisse, and thru her, her boss, Crawford. In the novel, Lecter already had a pretty good idea who the killer was ("Bill" already killed the patient whose head Lecter left in the limo) and how to find him, but he had no intention of giving up any real information because his only fun now is toying with people.
"cumvenient"
Don't think I don't see you, editor
glad i wasnt the only one to notice
Ah shit, I didn't see these comments and posted one of my own about that :D
He did it on purpose
@@keenb3041 we know
12:04 also: the camera positioning/editing to show Clarice between bars powerfully reflects not only her captivity to this memory, but Lecter's control over their dynamic.
The later sequence, where the shot/reverse shot gradually closes in on Lecter and Starling as they talk, slowly losing all the details of the cell and even the glass, visually demonstrating the vanishing barriers between them is just >chef kiss< Frankly, I'm surprised that the film didn't also get the Best Cinematography Oscar as well as the big 5 it _did_ get.
Man Anthony Hopkins absolutely crushed this role, chilling
Buffalo Bill's house was up for sale a few years ago, a reasonable price for such a beautiful house, and in relatively good commuting distance to work for my wife and I. Couldn't talk her into it. :( Would have had the best Halloweens there.
No, he keeps that picture of the nurse in his pocket for his very dark nurse fetish.
*DING*
Probably a nurse main
Nah he’d remove a sin for that 😂
I hate to be the "In the book..." guy but, in the book, Buffalo Bill enjoys playing games in the dark of his basement with his victims before he kills them.
Don't hate it!
Also in the book, the Sin about a census taker testing him made more sense, because the line in the book was quantify, not test.
Exactly haha. I didn't wanna be that guy either but I just now finished the book tonight and that whole basement finale plays out almost exactly like the book does. Bill is even bummed he can't play around with her for longer.
Good to know. All these years I've been a fan of the movie and I never knew that. 👍
@AtheistOnTheEdge:
CinemaSins admitted that they read the books in their "Everything Wrong With CS" vid, so pls don't hate ever being the "In the book.." guy. If ppl spent more time reading books & less time on reddit, we wouldn't have this ridiculous urban legend that "The Chianti line was a veiled joke that Lector was on MAOIs.", or the Mandela Effect of "Hello Clarice." The books started 4 decades ago with "Red Dragon", and have never included that phrase or that MAOI 'joke'. Harris never even watched the movies.✌
3:10 I mean, here you're making it more difficult that it is! Probably those stairs are closed by a wall we don't see or some other unavoidable barrier, which explains perfectly both why there aren't any gates and why clarice had to enter from the other side. And honestly, it doesn't seem a bad idea to me to leave only one access to these cells full or murderous psychopaths!
Anthony Hopkins chews up scenery like Hannibal Lecter chews up his victims
He never actually says "hello, Clarice" in the movie.
Should have given a sin for the Mandela effect
When they talk at the end?
GVDub11 doesn’t say it at all in the movie
He does at the end when she's on the phone with him.
Wasn't that line from the second movie, though?
He says it in the second movie
5:42 "He swallowed his tongue" - Not a thing!
Actually yes it is. It's a suicide tactic that involves biting off one's own tongue. Due to none of the major blood vessels in the head (Or tongue) having valves that prevent back flow of blood (the reason why blood can rush to your head when doing a head stand, and why your tongue and throat swell shut in anaphalaxys), If bitten off a person can bleed to death within a couple minutes. On a side note, this same design flaw is also why tongue peircings can kill you as an infection can go straight to the brain within hours. And now you know, and nowing is half the battle. GO JOE!
But biting off ones own tongue is not nearly the same as what is implied when they say you can swallow your own tongue. At least it's not what I picture when I hear that phrase.
Biting your tounge off and bleeding to death.
Swallowing your on tounge and choking on it.
2 completely different scenarios. And no, you can not swallow your tounge. But you can bite it off. Also you can survive it being cut off if medical aid is rendered immediately.
Go joe!
A Rush of Blood to the Head
@@justinhedrick2906
Nope, sorry, but it's not possible. Sometimes people use that expression to mean other things, but unless one bites off parts of his own tongue and swallows thosr pieces, it is not possible to swallow your own tongue. Tongues are attached to the bottom of the mouth by a lingual frenulum. It doesn't allow enough movement for teeth to reach it. Google it and you'll see.
To be fair, Barney never came off as condescending in the book or film to me; if anything he was surprisingly kind and professional considering the type of patients he dealt with. They mainly made a point of it in the book, but still, Barney always seemed like a really nice and respectful dude.
The fact you referenced "Iocane Powder" IS a cinema WIN!!!!
*Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins have serious chemistry in this film, I feel it everytime I watch it*
Anthony Hopkins did an interview where he disdains all the talk about chemistry everyone was bestowing. Most of the scenes with Hannibal and Clarice were either Jodi Foster or Anthony Hopkins acting to the camera alone. Think about how those intense close up shots had to be filmed.
Foster admitted in an interview that they didn't get along very well. I think she said something about being scared of his portrayal
@@brycetharp4057 they got along but they barely interacted and due to his great acting, she was very intimidated by him.
The Shining gets a 5 sin removal at the start, The Silence of the Lambs gets nothing, I see you Jeremy.
At least they were silent.
The shining was a groundbreaking film that is still unique to this day.
Silence of the lambs was groundbreaking but been outclassed by many movies. One of those being prisoners.
...Um, he removed five sins for the bit where Lecter reads Clarice like a book. Do you, in fact, see Jeremy? Because I don’t think you saw this video.
@@stormcloudsabound it aint that serious AJ.
@@Talxicity Everything is serious in the *RUclips Comment Section™*
11:21 - "They TOTALLY copied Steve Buscemi's character from Con Air." That should be the other way around since Con Air was released in 1997 - six years after Silence of the Lambs.
Quite right. Con Air's Garland Greene was basically a pisstake of Lecter.
Gumb answering the door could be something as simple as he doesn't want people to get suspicious about whether the old lady has actually died in there if someone doesn't answer the door. Better to open up and just say "no, she doesn't live here anymore".
And him not killing Clarice immediately may seem stupid, but it isn't out of character at all. In the book he loves to taunts and terrorize his victims by letting them fumble around in the dark in the basement, while he stalks them and has the ability to see.
It's also stated that Gumb thinks Clarice is too thin for him to be able to use her skin, but he finds her hair lovely, so he wants to shoot her at such an angle that it won't damage the scalp and the hair
Ok, at this point I’m watching movies for free
Shhhhh, they will hear us.
As a film major student, especially from the screenwriting department, it hurts to watch a movie like this. You just know from the bottom of your heart......
You will never make a movie this good, not this life, not the next one.
Sure you can! And I'm sure many of the best writers have been plagued with self-doubt. It can take months and years of work and perseverance. Why not give it a shot! Good luck!
@@danielwagman9794 Thank you for your incredible kind words. What I meant is that everyone has their limitation even with hardest work and best luck. If I completely outdid myself, I would say I can write a story that's on the level of Rain Man, or The King's Speech, but not this movie, it's just so monumental and profound and unique that it's impossible to recreate, even for the best of writers out there.
"Toughened your nipples, didn't it?"
My favorite smart ass comment in a movie so far.
In the book he said " thirsty work"
17:40 There was a fly on Hannibal head like Pence in that debate 😂😂😂
A couple of things I just realized
-At the first encounter with Clarice, Lecter says about his drawings of Florence that it is the "view from the Belvedere". The same town where the killer lives
-Buffalo Bill goes by James Gump or John Grant. When introducing himself to Clarice he says he is Jack Gordon. Always the same initials
4:09
Anthony Hopkins portrayed Hannibal Lecter phenomenally. A classic film.
Just Some Guy without a Mustache are you omnipresent?
@@thoukers9277 I swear, the dude is there everywhere I go
Yeah, but then he shat the bed by trying to do it two more times when he was WELL past the age for it.
Why are you everywhere everytime I'm watching any videos in any different channels?
I teach sociology to college students and your commentary about gender dynamics is literally why I show this film in my class (and also be it’s one of the best films ever made)... well done cinemasins!
There was nothing wrong with this movie! it was epic! Every scene, even the opening of her running in the woods, actually builds up the tension and eeriness of the movie.
The “test” could mean like “you’re testing me “ when you’re getting angry with someone etc
In the book it was Quantify
ashoja 5082 I read the book a very long time ago and I more than likely didn’t pay attention as I was 17. I should give it a reread
@@funnycreep Do it.
8:40
Praising the movie for its portrayal of a woman doing a job dominated by men from her POV...but also failing to realize that this was the point of everyone looking into the camera when addressing Clarice.
4:26 The census taker was "testing him," as in testing his patience.. Not assessing his knowledge on a subject.
It has always bugged me how no one acknowledges how much "drag" buffalo Bill looks like Jon Bon Jovi.
The obstacle course is supposed to represent how she has to struggle in her field, being a woman, hence the scene. It's a metaphor.
Yes and it pays off in the film's climax where she will have to employ every technique in the book to apprehend Buffalo Bill on her own.
Also the scene establishes she is a rookie which is the reason she is sent to try and crack Hannibal, since he is only willing to talk to a rookie that he feels he can manipulate.
Even with lower entrance standards women still struggle.
It's also a visual representation of her struggle to climb to the top. When she pulls herself up with the rope it's similar to a shot we see later on of Catherine stuck in the well, so essentially the film is saying Clarice is the one who's gonna help Catherine escape the well.
Jodie Foster is one of the few actors who lives up to their hype.
Facts
Jodie Foster's knuckles.
Thank you!! Stellar actress since Taxi Driver
Joaquin
I didn't even know she was an actor. I thought she was an actress.
The captions saying "how cumvenient" was awesome.
Anthony Hopkins is one of very few celebrities I'd mourn. He's a national treasure.
Cinemasins has officially gone mad with power
Top comment.
have you ever tried going mad without power? Its boring. No-one listens to you
@@dancingmonkey08 Try going slightly mad with a slight amount of power. At least you get a feel for whether you want to go totally mad or not.
@@nighttrain1236 good advice my friend!
@@dancingmonkey08 Austin Powers?
Did anyone else notice the main female character sounded almost identical to Elastigirl from the Incredibles?
I never noticed that before, but now I can't unhear it!
I can't tell if you're being serious or if you're joking. Never mind. Different actress. Lol
@@shaunarovinski4081 nono I'm legit being serious. Every time she talked I was like ,"why does she sound so much like Elastigirl??"
Because the west Virginia accent?
DAMMIT!
Kudos for excellent acting to Buffalo Bill morphing into the inspector on Monk! He genuinely seems enraged when the girl in the well captures his dog.
You missed the fact that when they get to the house in Calumet City, Illinois there are mountains in the background. Cal City is a southern suburb of Chicago on the Indiana border there're no mountains anywhere near there.
I absolutely love these movies and the books are incredible but THANK YOU for pointing out the stairs at the end of the corridor! I’ve been shouting about those stairs for years! 😂
My dear. Its called old construction. I went to a Catholic school built in the 1850's and there were blind corridors and dead ends like that. The usually explanation was-servants' entrance, knocked down wall, or bricked up or unbricked maids room.
@@SanFranDentist94301 Very true. I have been in many re-purposed antique buildings and I have seen architectural oddities like this. However, I agree with Elderly Emo. Those stairs in the background have always bugged me. The one excuse I have always given for their placement in the movie was foreshadowing that Hannibal would eventually escape.
@@BarkingCur I always assumed it just led to a next / second floor, potentially of more prisoners, but is a dead end up there. like the only access to that part of the building IS those stairs
Jeanette Green that makes so much sense now! Literally bugged me for years 😂 thanks for your explanation!
@@EggsDeinony same here, I also assumed those stairs only lead to more prisoners, nothing more, nothing less.
That "Contact" joke at 5:12 had me grinning from ear to ear :D Very clever. And a great movie
Damn! Scrolling through the comments thinking I was the only one who spotted it! 👏🏻
@@jamessadventures1380 Nope, you're not alone; I caught it too and it made me snort-laugh so loud I almost woke up my roommates.
Love your outros with other movie lines dubbed in. Keep up the good work!
This really should be the shortest CinemaSins video of all time.
The pen. That's the big one. And the fact that there's a shadow on Clarice's back when Buffalo Bill is hunting her, even though it's supposed to be dark.
Unfortunately, the screenplay altered the way that Lecter obtained the doctor’s pen. Annoying.
@@DoctorQuackenbush
How did he do it, before the change?
@@Kremit_the_Forg It’s been years since I read the book, but, if I recall correctly, the doctor left the pen in Lector’s cell and Lector made a key from the brass ink cartridge. (That dates the story, eh?)
Jame Gumb had an infrared light on, so he could see with his night vision goggles. You still get shadows if something blocks the light source.
@@Kremit_the_Forg It is explained in the book.
"Oh and senator, one more thing. LOVE YOUR SUIT!"
Bold of you to sin the night vision scene- one of the most suspenseful scenes in film ever
Lmao 3:42 "She must've sounded like Boomhauer before all that work!"
CinemaSins: "Everybody calls this movie 'Silence of the Lambs.'"
Me: Actually, I call this movie "Lamb Chops", because that's what Hannibal orders right before he breaks out.
I call it Lamb Chop's Play Along only very, very dark version
@@homelesshannah50 "Come join the kids and play along, we've got a lot of good stuff for you!" never sounded so ominous as right now.
I'd be interested in a documentary about movies news articles.
Even better would be highlighting Easter eggs where movie crews wrote genuinely funny stuff
Would that include the Star Trek okudagrams, because those are ripe full of weird text
7:10 and I would like to thank this movie for having that song chronically lodged in my brain. It is so painful. I would not wish it in my worst enemy
14:50 I always thought it was crappy of Clarice to leave the murdered girl's photos (which were purposefully hidden) out in plain sight for her parents to find. Way to rub salt in the wound.
I always thought that too. It doesn't seem like something Clarice would do.
"I ate his liver with some fava beans and a nice Chianti." - Hannibal Lecter would have been on Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) the three things you're not allowed to eat while taking them are : Liver, beans and wine. - Doesn't this remove some sins ...
I highly doubt he would've been on them when he ate the census taker since it's implied to be before his arrest. Though I really really love your connection. Signed, an MAOI taker.
It's supposed to imply that Lecter cannot be trusted, since he would know that, also he is testing Clarice
I'd die. No liver, beans or wine. Damn
How tf does one eat wine🙄
@MsUn PC
No he was NOT saying that. It makes no sense.
This must be a record for the least sins/minute as well as the all-time high of sin removals.
I think he removed more sins in the video for Get Out
Technically, I believe Troll 2 had the least amount of sins 😂😂😂
I love your reviews brother. You are f+&king entertaining af
Buffulo Bill: you dont know what pain is
Cinemasins: 15:16
Me: 🤣😂