Everything Wrong With Knives Out In Whodunnit Minutes
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 мар 2020
- Knives Out, Rian Johnson's follow up to The Last Jedi, was a universal home run with critics, and a hit with audiences alike. Because it's f*cking rad.
But we do what we do, so we did what we do, and here is what we did...
Thursday: Animated sins AND a brand new CinemaSins intro video-bumper!!
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book
#CinemaSins
#EverythingWrongWith
#KnivesOut 
Кино
"I'm removing 5 sins, mainly because I've been an unruly asshole to this fantastic film."
*removes 4 sins*
YAS.. I'm surprised very little notice that😂
Yes I noticed too
I watched that video multiple times and I didn´t notice it until you guys pointed it out
Oh shit, shame on me for not spotting that, that's a SIN.
He removed a sin in the beginning of the videos. Dumb fuvks
honestly casting chris evans was a good move, because his character is clearly the asshole/bad guy from the beginning. but everyone wants chris evans to be the good guy, so they overlook how he is obviously the bad guy.
Fax
I know.... like I LOVED his whole attitude.... probably just because it was Chris🤪🤪🤪
I think the same, he's asshole, but he's asshole by design, but he's still asshole, but isn't he the captain america?
He did a great job playing as the "villain"
i just wanted to punch him in the face since the first second he showed up, i mean how can someone be that repellent? i think this is my first chris evans movie though so i hope he isn't like this normally
I love how each of Harlan's children differently remembers how the cake was given to him, each making themselves the center of attention
Loved that detail too
I never noticed that but I love it because it furthers the idea of the flaws in each story
Same
All there stories are irrelevant at the end of the day.. none of the characters that had interviews benefited the plot.. did you catch on to that one
Yeah why was it that Fran and Jacob weren’t interviewed? Was it simply just cause they actually had relevance to the plot? (Jacob had an insignificant but he did contribute with what he overheard)
I love how they first showed Daniel Craig in this movie sitting in the dark doing James Bond things and then gave him the least James Bond accent ever.
His accent was really jarring for me!!
@@pamelalansbury94 ever been to Savannah?
@Nazar 26 Dude I'm from the south. That accent was jarring because it's not Craig, but between this and Logan Lucky, I've never heard a Brit actor do a better southern accent.
@@JesseLeeHumphry I really liked the accent because it was absurd
and it felt on purpose absurd
@Nazar 26 Oh it does throw you off, because you expect a certain accent with him in that suit, for sure.
I get the feeling that Cinema Sins liked this movie...
HAHAHHA he was really trying hard to find the sins here
Christian NoName IS THAT YOUR FUCKING TAKE!!!?
Considering how in the description they stated the film is rad, I think you're right.
Duh
Hey, it was a good movie!
Fran's amazing master plan:
1. Send Ransom a ransom letter
2. Meet him in an abandoned building (unarmed)
3. Tell him that you know what he did
4. Ransom will then give himself over instantly without fighting back
5. Success
6. Profit.
She smoked too much of the Colorado wacky weed to think it out.
Like Quasimodo not letting go of the tunic in the hunchback of Notre dame
it's because she's a huge fan of hallmark detective movies, and that's how those things usually work out.
She was armed, she had a finger gun duh
She was obviously an idiot. It's hinted a lot of times in the movie. She did not want to expose him, period. What she did makes sense for her character.
It really makes a funny joke though.😂
Seriously though, that last shot where she lifts the cup with "My house, My rules, My coffee" written on it is so good.
NO BUT THE WAY ITS COVERED AND IT JUST SAYS “MY HOUSE” WHILE THE FAMILY LOOKS WAS SO GENIUS
also because it was probably tea...
That was really great
Apparently that wasn’t even planned until the day it happened, but it was such a good shot they had to leave it in
@@drewschieman1741 of course yeah, you do an insert on an object and "it wasn't even planned". At least we can see Roundhead Johnson still takes his audience for idiots
Doctor: “ I’m sorry but Fran is dead”
Marta: “Doctor that’s great news”
Hangs up 😂
They joke about that in the commentary
It's wordplay. Because of her accent, it can be taken as "Doctor, that's grave news."
This might be the most praise he's ever given a movie
I think the dark knight was more
Get out was more
Nah go watch Fury Road, he flat out says it was one of the best movies that year
how about:
- Pulp Fiction
- Se7en
- Lego Movie
- Both Deadpool movies
This movies was masterfully written and executed, (the same as The Brothers Blume) and yet Ryan Johnson still gets blamed for The Last Jedi.
When Marta leaves the party at the beginning of the film, you can hear in the background her car struggle to start. So when it doesn't start later it isn't such a coincidence!
Jack Veal I kinda thought Ransom messed with it, cause he left before her and then gave her a ride
Jack Veal I always thought it was the battery from being left on for so long the night prior. It’s definitely a piece that has many possible reasons but they don’t tell you on purpose
I wish they left the subtlest of clues to implicate Ransom - like even if Ransom just asks "Whose car is that one?"
I do think ransom did something, because of all the lights that flashed
I mean, it'd be easy for Ransom to figure out which car is Marta's since she'd be the only one there without a luxury car, and for him to tamper with it before she gets in
"I WILL NOT EAT ONE IOTA OF SHIT!" May be the best line from any movie ever.
That should have been 10 sins off lmao
that entire 'eat shit' scene is hilarious even more considering he knew noone was getting anything in the will.
@@aaryanramesh7761 fun fact: they were supposed to say “fuck you” but they had to change it or else this movie would’ve been rated R 😂
Yesss thank you. What an underrated line!
Michael Shannon running over to tell Rhian to make sure they got a shot of Jaeden Martell yelling that Marta was "a dirty anchor baby" because he knew it would horrify people shows he's selfless as an actor.
In this age of "everything is a sequel, remake, or reboot," it was nice seeing a well-made, entertaining, original movie with original and interesting characters.
I wouldn’t call it completely original. Borrows heavily from Agatha Christie. Still a great movie though.
@@JamesIsAway It borrrows heavily from mystery movies in general. Like the final vomit scene is a nod to the many "we pretend a victim has survived to trick the culprit into confessing only to then reveal the victim did die and we actually had no evidence" cliche's we've seen countless times
@@leonpaelinck that was my first time seeing that cliche. I am not old enough to care for black-and-white movies
@@JamesIsAway but aside from Kenneth Branagh trying to adapt the Poirot Stories when's the last time Christie's work straight adapted or given Homage properly on film n the US (i think even in the UK the go-to is a 3 part Mini-series which is short even for them)
@@JamesIsAway ...or old enough to have watched any movies apparently if that is the first time you've seen that cliche
Chris Evans most difficult acting scene in his career : PRETENDING HE DOESNT LIKE DOGS
Fellow Crazy Dog Man Tom Hardy is pretty much the English equivalent. He had to pretend that he didn't know what to do with the puppy he accidentally acquires in _The Drop_ , and it is his best performance to date.
Aiight Chris Stuckmann
If I remember correctly I think there was a problem with the dogs liking Chris Evans too much, he had to hide treats in his jacket to make them bark at him
@@caitlinrix294 I agree!
My favorite part of him with the pup "The Drop" in was in the pet shop when he just held the puppy up in front of the wall of dog toys and moved him back and forth like he was going to choose one himself.
dragonball slayer326 Oh yeah, he totally is
This movie has the closest we’ll get to an actual evil captain America lol.
Donut hole.
with a smaller hole in it, in fact...it wasn't even a donut hole...it was a smaller DONUT
we might get the multiverse soon in MCU so who knows
@@alexmerriweather3143 And that donut isn't even a hole.
Actually "evil captain America" is in snowpiercer, he ate a baby!
Stevil
12:40 I mean, her first response was to look for the antidote, and after not finding it she immediately thinks to call for help, she even returns for a last attempt at stopping Harlan when she sees he's already done it. I think if Harlan wasn't such a fan of the theatrics she would've totally saved him.
Also I'm pretty sure she was doing CPR to Fran after the overdose thing
after seeing this a few more times I wonder if Harlan was suicidal the whole time. look at it, he tells Marta that it would take too long for an ambulance, he doesn't say anything about taking a car, he doesn't want her to call 911. he gets her out of the house for this incredible elaborate plan. so she's not there to see what he is about to do.
I think it's heavily implied that Ransom did do something to Marta's car since he leaves first after the will is read and every single warning light is on in her car
It's called poverty
CinemaSins: “I’m removing 5 sins”
Also CinemaSins: *removes 4 sins*
Welcome to cinemasins,where even mercy isn’t without sin!
Ding!
That's another sin for CinemaSins.
Adds a sin because he has to remove sins
"Comment sins a Cinemasins mistake" cliche. *Ding*
The hospital calls Marta to tell her about Fran, because, as Marta stated in the waiting room scene, she left her info with the hospital. It's a small thing, but it was bugging me :)
I think he's sinning it as a plot convenience because they call her right when they get to the housekeeper in the investigation.
Even if Marta did that, HIPPA Law dictates that they notify Frans next of kin, not the woman who brought her in. If Marta had been a nurse at that hospital or connected with Frans case in some way other than just being the person who called the ambulance, it would have made more sense.
@@makkorra12 I just presumed that she was Fran's next of kin. It's not like we thought she had any family around. Also, there are some ways around the whole NOK thing - if someone was dying, had no known NOK, no family, and her friend/colleague brought her in and she died, it's unlikely that the hospital are going to refuse to release that information, as they're going to need more details from her and ... well Fran can't answer them now
@@DrRR20231 she has a cousin that works in the coroner's office!
@@xletragedyx nobody says they did not call her family or whoever first and later call the nurse
I don’t think that I’ve had as much fun with a movie as I did with this one. I remembered the line about Ransom not knowing the difference between a stage prop and a real knife as he pulled the knife from the chair and it was so cool when I put the pieces together as I watched. Great work Rian Johnson - you did great with this film.
It’s okay CinemaSins, we loved this movie too
I didn’t
@@kingsman5121 That’s okay, opinions are valid :)
@@notactuallyacat. that’s a lot nicer reaction than I thought it was going to get thanks
@@kingsman5121 yeah in the beginning I w as skeptical.of the movie,but then when is started on myteryr aspect and the action i started to enjoy it
this is the most wholesome comment reply section i’ve seen in a while
i literally whispered ”RoLL cReDiTs” when he said ”knives out” this is the effect this channel has on me
I also do this when I watch movies where they say the title
i did the same thing! 😂
Yes and pitch meetings super easy Berely inconvenience
Lol when I saw it I was liking ''I already know cinemasins is gonna say roll credits''
I too said that along with ruining the movie by spoilers after watching cinema wins and saying slight details that made my family mad
When Blanc said "Knives out", I could picture Jeremy sinning it with "Roll credits" in my head. At least I came close.
I now hear Jeremy's voice everytime a character says the movie title,
and I like it
Hahaha! I heard Jeremy's voice when Blanc says: that was the stupidest car chase ever! 😂
@@katika17 oh yeah! That too!
Blew my mind!
I was like *"damn you CinemaSins! haunting me while I try to enjoy movies!"*
He's somehow becoming part of the Hollywood Cinematic Universe, or pop culture aha like Honest Trailers
Lmao same I said it under my breath in the theater.
He has a name??!
She wasn't fine after the partial truths, immediately after she left, she vomited. It wasn't completely without consequence
No she threw up because the last question he asked was “was he acting normal the last time you seen him”.
@@antcarrjr Well, that's possibly, but she might have thought about lying.
Like he said, it won't be consistent. She's able to control it for a while when the plot needs it.
Marta lies to blanc when she says WHAT I CANT HEAR YOU HUH and she doesn’t puke
Oh shit good point
The Fire Turkeys would be excellent at Cinemasins
Unless... she couldn’t hear what he was saying cause she was hearing the sound of herself yelling “I can’t hear you” over him telling her not to move 🤔
Lmaoo more likely a goof though 😂
Nice try but just watched that clip and she didn't say that she only said "what? What? Did you call me?" and walked straight
@@arandomguy9518 Yes but when she clearly heard him she pretended to be clueless which still falls under deception which should trigger her puking reaction.
"There is no reason to keep Marta around during the investigation," HE HAS SEEN BLOOD ON HER SHOE! He knows she is involved but knows she wouldnt hurt him on purpose and there is more to the story
This is absolutely right! So glad someone said it so I didn't have to comment. Well done, sir!
Also her regurgitation thing
jap,also why Chris evans didnt know that all this knives where fake ? I mean he grow up in that house and when he was a kid he never try to touch that giant cool Statue with all that weapons?
@@HomerXXX They can't all be fake, several of the blades are far too large to slide into the handles.
@@HomerXXX the throne is a mixture of real and fake. Harlan hinted that Ransom wouldn't know the the difference between a real knife and a fake knife
I just love the line where he has to admit that life makes no sense anymore, because a character is not an asshole for holding an "Apple"
EmperorJuliusCaesar you realize they are being paid by apple? And it’s simple copyright law that they can’t use them without permission... so what’s your quarrel? This happens in every country. Do you not like copyright?
Jeremy can remain sane as long as he just sticks to bad guys "eating" an apple instead of "holding" one. Not too many people will eat an iPhone, even villains.
I keep thinking this scene with the iPhone (besides obvious advertising) draws attention to the fact that, while the character SEEMS worried about Marta, she's still a rich spoiled kid or something. There's something of a bubble in the fact she studies social sciences (or something like that) and has a leftist world view and still 1. believes her family is entitled to the will by right and 2. holds an iPhone. But I may be forcing it.
@EmperorJuliusCaesar Yea that's the most fun thing about the Americans, they always shout out about their freedom, but, they are really really not, they can't do anything without getting sued by someone.
@@carlsiouxfalls unless crazy
I noticed that kept saying she was from different countries all through the movie and chuckled at how they didn’t throw it in your face. I definitely appreciated being trusted to catch it instead of being lead down a path step for step.
The second sin is actually the cruzifix in her car, which you can see in later shots. It's actually amazing that it's there.
Wow! Good catch!!! 🔎✝️🚙👍
Nice
I can’t be the only one who spotted this, but 71 sins - 5 sins = 66 sins so I’m gonna have to sin you for incorrectly sinning.
Yep, I was about to mention it.
*DING*
Thats where that one additional sin comes from to make it 67
He knew you were going to sin him for it. Therefore already made it 67. Just for you
@@joshevans3421 kore ga requiem da
“FISTING. HE DIED BY FISTING” when I say I started cackling-
C K me too😂
Hahaha me third and I can't stop. I'm seriously crying like a fucking idiot and I'm glad my neighbors aren't home lol.
C K I fucking lost it!!
When he said next it got me
😂😂😂😂😂
When will you say it?
I've watched this movie 4 times now. Each time I've rewatched this movie I've picked up on new Easter Eggs, foreshadowing, etc. If you pay attention to details the movie can be quite revealing. Which I really love!
For example, Richard actually exposes himself cheating on his wife by throwing the baseball out the window when looking for the hidden letter that Harlan wrote. Next, later on, as Blanc and Marta are combing the mansion for clues he throws the baseball for the dogs in the yard but instead, they return the broken lattice, leaving the baseball out in the yard. Finally, near the end of the movie we see Linda returning the recovered baseball to her late father's study. There she finds the letter open and thus revealing Richard being a cheater. Full circle. Like a donut hole within a donut...
Also, when Ransom is first revealed to us the dogs are barking at him and jumping on him like crazy. The same testimony we are told that when the dogs were heard barking late at night from when he came back to mess with the medicine bag.
Additionally, after Marta speaks to Blanc alone at night on the patio (during the cool cigar lighting) scene, she goes home and walks in on her mom watching the old TV show Murder, She Wrote.
Finally, you can also see the painting of Harlan change from having a stoic/concerned look (when Marta is looking at it before her interview with Blanc), and then when the mystery is solved at the end of the movie we can see Harlan smirking/smiling.
These are just some of my favorite ones that I noticed! Others include the foreshadowing of the stage prop knife from Harlan and then Ransom stabbing Marta with a "stage prop" knife and the family getting Marta's nationality wrong every time they mention where she is from.
I believe this movie was wonderfully written and shot. I can't wait for the second one to come out!
Cinema Sins: this is such a great shot, I'm removing 5 sins
Sin Counter: *goes from 71 to 67 sins*
Me: visible confusion
Speaks to the mental capacity of this content and its creators.
@@flamaurus lmfao huh? he makes rly good and entertaining videos? if u disagree thats totally fine but there is completly no need to hate in comment replies? how weird lol
67 is my favorite number, so I actually liked it.
A good explanation as to why the supposed smart villain hires the best detective ever would be ego. They could get away with the crime with a mediocre or even a decent detective but they want to prove they are as smart as they think they are. Even if its just in their own head.
Criminal psychology puts smart money on seeking validation, where the perpetrator inserts themselves into crime scenes, to not only get away with their crimes, but also to prove they're smarter by the detectives admitting defeat, and even that only started happening after fingerprinting became widespread, roughly 4 decades after its invention. It's a sad fact that in reality many investigations went sideways because people didn't want to use technology, were refused funds to access them, or be as egregious to exclude obvious suspects, because they were friends or card partners. It's also an equal opportunity offense, since women, who actually did commit crimes were let off the hook.
The two women who inspired the musical Chicago claimed to be innocent, yet were cold-hearted murderers and opportunists, who used an investigative journalist, a fellow woman, to bring them fame by claiming to be victim of circumstance, and granted, when Agatha Christie's first books came out, white slavery was believed to be real.
Ya, given it was adapted from agatha Christie novel, you are probably right. Most of Christie's murderers are charming fellows who over estimate their smartness.
it's not quite as egregious here as when someone in a poirot novel decides the most opportune time to kill their wife is on a cruise with the worlds greatest detective present. At least this guy couldn't simply have waited until there wasn't a detective sleeping two doors down from the scene of the crime.
Sin for trying to convince me Chris Evans could ever be a villain.
Edit: I say this as in, I try to solve mysteries in movies, but I foolishly refused to believe Chris Evans could be the villain, and I'm bitter
Well, they succeeded. He played the role so well
sin for seeing an actor that well portrayed a character with a good moral compass and not accepting that he is able to play other roles because of that
It's weird, he has a lot of similar acting styles to Steve Rogers when he plays Ransom, and yet they're completely different characters
Wilo Polis It’s the actor, that’s his style. His acting wasn’t the different in Gifted either, and that was another totally different character. I like the style, but that’s just him
Before he was cast as Captain America, Chris Evans WAS a villain actor. He was a typecast douche bro asshole. See: Not Another Teen Movie, Scott Pilgram vs the World. Evans admitted he was surprised he got the Cap America role as it was the complete opposite of his normal roles, and his role in Knives Out was much more closer to his roots.
I love how ballsy this movie was. Like it was framed as a whodunnit but at the very beginning they show how Harlan died so it becomes a movie about how Martha is gonna save her ass and them at the very end it has the classic whodunnit ending. It's a great movie all together
“FISTING! HE DIED BY FISTING! I SOLVED THE CASE! NEEEEEXT!”
Funi
remove sin for Harlem stating that if someone switch the covers on the vials, it could kill someone by accident, in the flashback scene with Marta. Revealed the whole plot in 3 sentences of dialogue, and you wouldn't notice it
Harlan also mentions that because of Ransom's upbringing he would not know the difference between a real and stage knife.
The sheer cleverness and genius of this movie strikes me every time
Plus, I think the scene that follows is Marta leaving and Nana seeing her, asking if Ransom had returned.
Well... I did so there’s probably thousands of other people too...
The best part is you do notice it, and the film slowly convinces you that that is not the answer, and once you are fully invested in just having Martha confess to what happened, they hit you with this switcheroo.
wait no remember in the ,movie he says " don't call me Hugh only the help calls me Hugh" which was foreshadowing, and she called him by the name he does not like
After watching another video on this movie it was pointed out that the dogs only ever bark at ransom, they don’t bark at anyone else. So the dogs barking at night gave it away.
I really like the fact that even if he nitpicks on slight things, he can recognize an amazing performance and he acknowledges it in his videos. Minus one sin!☺️
Also i died laughing my ass off at Craig’s accent only because of i picture him from a British Secret agent to an American sleuth.
Ransom's descriptions of him are funny af, with all the KFC jokes
This film has convinced me Chris Evans and Daniel Craig are Oscar nom worthy actors.
Plot twist: he only removed 4! A fist is actually 4 fingers and a thumb! Therefore, this reinforces the idea that he sucks at math!!!
Now because of Daniel Craig's performance in Knives Out i *CAN'T* want to see him as James Bond. *ALL I WANT* {now} is to see Daniel Craig doing other voices/accents to see how far the range of his talent goes with what we see in *THIS* Movie. Daniel Craig should have been given an Oscar for best actor OR best supporting actor. 👨🏫🎭 😓🗣🤺👨👩👧👦💌👣
Daniel Craig is great in everything he's in (but Bond). If you haven't scene Logan Lucky, it's a great film.
I was convinced with Bond and Captain America
You should check out Gifted and Defiance
just wanna say, as a home nurse who gives IVs it wouldn’t be unusual to have a drop of his blood on her shoe. sometimes you miss with a needle or hit a clot or something that causes excess blood. i’ve bled all over multiple nurses over the years during both shots, blood draws, and IV placements. even the best nurse can get blood on them because veins are weird
He had a port though. Lucky ass
Protect&Serve Gaming no he didn’t? she gave it to him in his arm, i can’t remember the exact specifics since i saw the movie a while ago but at most it would have been a picc line. a port is the one on the chest, and she would have opened his shirt to access it and even then a port isn’t typically given for routine meds like this, a picc would be the most likely
edit: i just checked through this video to see again and yeah you can tell he has a picc because the tube is fed through his sleeve and you can see her wipe off the end of it to sterilize it before connecting the meds. and either way, blood could still get on her shoes with a port or a picc
@@lightworthy they did roll back his shirt sleeve. She never stuck him. There was already a line in place and she administered the drugs by screwing them into the line. No blood from that Chica.
@@lightworthy I've never seen blood come through either. I've only seen nurses push meds and flush with saline. What are you doing that blood is shooting out or dripping out? Only time I had blood fly at me was because a lady yanked her arm while the vacutainer was active. During my syringe draws I never had spray.
Protect&Serve Gaming i know, which is why i said a picc line, which is more likely what it was supposed to be, and you can get blood from it. my dad had one for a while and there can be blood sometimes. when i wrote the original comment i didn’t remember the movie that perfectly which is why in my comment to you i clarified saying he likely had a picc. i never said anything about blood spraying, just that one tiny drop of blood when working with something directly going into veins isn’t unusual at all
"And I'm not sure how many opportunities I'll have to find sins in this so GOTCHA!" When cinema sins likes a movie you know it's good.
About the "Hugh" sin at 15:10. I suppose the twist is that Ransom's elitist and obnoxious attitude of making "the help" call him Hugh helped led to his arrest. I think it's like when they confuse her nationality, another dig at the whole "clash between classes" the film sells.
Also, 67 sins has to be the least amount of sins in the phase of much longer CS videos. The movie is that good.
The Doctor must have thought, "What the hell?" When Marta replied it was great news Fran died
omg that's actually so funny to think about
she'd probably hung up and was faking the rest of the call
THANK YOU!!!! I constantly have problems with movies that he doesn't point out and I'm so glad to see that he picked up on that 😂
At the end of the movie I was thinking that when she puked I was like “ so she said it was great news someone died?? ” its would be so weird for the doctors
Maybe she muted herself
Captain America’s life after he went through the time machine.
Sheehan Fan Films I know it’s a joke but I’m just wondering that once he went through the time travel machine doesn’t it mean that he will work with peggie since peggie fights a whole bunch of people in agent carter so basically it’s agent carter /w captain America edition
Haterno1likeu Gay uh, pretty sure
Exactly
Lol
clonesavegir.link/7dFOegqViMg
"Canine Christ" has to be the funniest description.
Also "FISTING! HE DIED BY FISTING!"
One of the few jokes that worked
08:07 is a mistake.
It isn’t a cliche because it isn’t about luck.
If you look carefully Ransom lives the room early. However he doesn’t depart immediately. He waits.
What is implied, and the only ration explanation, is that Ransom messed up Martha’s car. So that he could talk to her.
seems like a stretch to me. how did he sabotage the car without anybody noticing?
@@leonpaelinck My guess is given as self absorbed as all the family members were, probably no one cared enough to look outside at that point since they were dealing with the shock of being cut out of the will.
why is no one talking about toni collette's RANGE? from hereditary to this movie man
Probably one of the most underrated actresses. Love her! She can pull out any role wonderfully.
Have you not seen United States of Tara??
YES thank you! My favourite Australian actress by far!!
And 6th sense 👌
@@Ann-sv3dz am watching that on Hulu!
The trick widow is mentioned to be something Harlan had written into one of his books. One of the officers mentions it when they find it. I believe Harlan added different aspects of his books into his house.
"That's my ancestral home! Shut up, your father bought it from a foreign investor in 1987!"
Akos Barati I love that line! I don’t think it means he never added it in after he bought it though. If I was a rich mystery novel writer I would want to remodel my house to be like my books
@@naomilopez7949 Or it could have been the other way around. If you've seen Winchester, you might be familiar with the fact that in the age of spiritualism (a two-part event, one strong attraction to the occult in the 19th century in America after the Civil War and in the 1920s in Europe) people were taught to construct contraptions to confuse evil spirits or to provide a getaway.
Then again, since this one opened only from the outside, it's most likely one previous owner had it to welcome guests they didn't want others to see.
It could be opposite that he got the idea from his house. Like how he got idea of new way when marta told him about morphine overdose.
This movies looks boring to me - not sure if I would even consider watching it
I think the reason why Marta couldn’t react the way a nurse should’ve reacted when she realized she gave Harlon too much morphine was because she was in shock. She loved Harlon. It could’ve froze her. There’s a reason why doctors shouldn’t perform emergency surgery on their own loved ones. You may not make the right calls with so many emotions running through your head. Obviously it was necessary to drive the plot but I think many nurses could react in a similar fashion in that situation.
Can we just appreciate the spectacular cinematography in this film?
"God, this last shot is probably my favorite thing ever. I'm removing 5 sins, mainly because I've been an unruly asshole to this fantastic film."
*proceeds to remove only 4 sins*
You’re not counting the sin he would have added.
@@adanmartinezpiano But when they say "i'm removing a sin for X," the counter doesn't stay at the same number, it goes down by one. The movie should have 66 sins
“God this film is great! I’ll remove 5 sins”
Plot twist: he only removed 4! A fist is actually 4 fingers and a thumb! Therefore, this reinforces the idea that he sucks at math!!!
A thumb is a finger
Laquinton Wagner no
Its still a digit
“You want A scholarship, bro?”
@@dillpicklescentedsock5909 all fingers aren't thumbs, all thumbs are fingers. all jacuzzi's are hot tubs, not all hot tubs are jacuzzi's
You can tell Daniel Craig is struggling to do a American accent
Thank you! I was worried I was the only one thinking "What the hell is that accent Daniel Craig's attempting?" It was kind of like Morgan Freeman meets Forrest Gump.
@@Maerahn I feel like its a choice made because of the historically bad (excluding david suchet) french accents of the actors portraying Hercule Poirot for whom the character of Benoit Blanc is based. That's at least how I made myself come to terms with that accent.
Maerahn Aw hell, this was oscar worthy compared to his accent in Tomb Raider. Lol!
I don’t know maybe he’s just taken aback by how terrible the lines are
@@kingsman5121 It’s not that bad, it’s just more unique than most are used too
The part about Marta assuming there’d be a back entrance to the laundromat seemed legit. She’s proven herself to be a smart and resourceful person. However, as noted here, the whole plot about Fran arranging a secret meeting there seems wildly implausible.
CHRIS EVANS in a classic cream sweater being Chris Evans. That is All,
Did you see the matching one he had made for Dodger, his dog?
@@Noah-lo9vb oh goodness no I didn't... okay Google help a girl out, searching now :)
Noah he has a matching sweater for his dog? Awwwwwe
😇😇😇
That's the most important part of the movie. CE in sweaters.
Sorry, but I will defend that Windows XP wallpaper to the grave. It’s as much a nostalgic comfort as the XP startup sound.
Right, I never changed it, that generic background was like a part of the computer back then and went hand in hand with the startup sound. Nice phraze, "nostalgic comfort", that's how I feel too
that background will always make me think of elementary school
And what very old man would take the time to bother?
Also, is an 80+ year old really concerned about changing his desktop wallpaper? I doubt someone Harlan's age would even know how to change it.
One massive sin missed. The morphine overdose is meant to take 10mins to kill the victim, and Ransom meets Fran at 8am in which he gave her the overdose. Marta meets Fran 2 hours later so she should have been dead for at least an hour and a half and unable to move or speak.
that is of course if she was dosed (100 mg) the same amount as Harlan was.
@@vaanguintu2969 harlan was dosed 300 mg actually but i think to kill someone in 10 minutes 200 mg of morphine is enough
@@astridkjellberg why is it 300 again?
She's supposed to usually do 3 mg of morphine and 100 of the usual one but she does opposite
Wtf no od can take 5-10 seconds trust me after 15 years of heroin use I would know freaking clean for 7 years now
Add it to the list
9:36 Even though the report would show the overdose, there's no reason to believe Marta would have caused it. Since she left the medical kit in that room every night, Harlan could've used it himself... maybe even slitting his throat under the effect.
Yea narcs don’t make you violent they make u loopy happy high sleepy euphoric heroic energetic and calm
He should have written a suicide note and said he overdosed himself. Marta always left her bag there. Then again, if he had done that, Marta may have gotten in trouble for leaving drugs within his reach.
True but wouldn't this still call attention for her family? The whole point was Marta wanting to save her family from deportion.
Cinema Sins uploads their thoughts on Knives Out a day after Cinema Wins uploaded his.
Me: Perfectly Balanced as all things should be.
100% agree. Its pike they sre in kahoots
And in a few days there will be an everything wrong with cinema sins knives out.
A fellow man of culture I see
Except that there where two parts for CinamaWins Knives out... so not balanced
(Which makes perfect sense because it’s a good movie)
clonesavegir.link/up2PkmWWdsY
Fun fact about Knives Out:
Directors are not allowed to show movie villains with Apple products. Ransom is the only character who doesn’t have an iPhone
Almost, Marta doesn't have an iPhone either, but that is to separate her from the affluent Thrombeys
Christian Downing true, but she’s arguably responsible too so I guess the theory holds
Gotta source for that fact?
Koen Tynes it’s in an interview with Knives Out’s director, I’ll look for it now
Koen Tynes ruclips.net/video/69GjaVWeGQM/видео.html
The hospital had her down as the emergency info, that’s why they’d been willing to leave the hospital: They would call Marta if anything happened... undeserved sin. There were others undeserved ones too, but I didn’t feel like making a list right now...
As someone who was on morphine just days before seeing this, I know that I immediately felt the effects with a heaviness in my chest and slowly went to fall asleep.
the fact that you didn’t take off a sin for the camera work when marta is leaving after the will reading is a MAJOR sin *ding*
Hopefully the actress who plays Marta in this movie, Ana de Armas watches this CinemaSins because they are absolutely right she does deserve an Oscar Nomination.
Matt // And I just realized how much she reminds me of Janeane Garofalo, another underrated actress.
She was robbed
At first I also couldn't understand why Blanc wanted to keep Marta around for the investigation... but when he said that he'd understood she was involved from the second he'd seen her, I realized there would've been no other way to keep questioning her, since at first glance she looked completely innocent and he wouldn't have had any reason to keep calling her back
"That blood could have come from anywhere." Jeremy would be terrible at solving crimes.
The Birdman said that already.
Can I just say the vomit on Chris Evan’s face was fricking disgusting?!
I think that was the point of adding it in..
Yeah, I know, I know (cap reference)
But it was still just, bleeeeegh
I’m pretty sure they just threw a can of baby food in his face.
it was dripping into his mouth
Nobody stands there looking dramatic with vomit on their face
Chris Evans was absolutely fantastic in this, for me it was kinda of like a throwback to his Johnny Storm (Human Torch) character from Fantastic 4
YES
Disappointed that Cinemasins missed out on a “Benoit Balls” reference
The baseball thing actually bothered me too. I was expecting there to be a crash through the window, because why else would he through the baseball out to window, only for it to half-assesly fall into the grass
Can we just take a moment to appreciate Chris Evans in this movie? He was AMAZING!!!
@Knight Fall indeed. Great actors =/= great film.
@@primalknight just ignore the shithouse dialogue that’s fine don’t even fuckin worry about it
I never heard captain america swear so much in his life.
And james bond too
Yeah... proper good 20 mins
Nana wasn't in the final shot because it shows the divide between Marta and the Thrombeys. Nana never hated Marta. She was a sweet old lady.
Also unlike the rest of the family, Nana would’ve grown up poor or at least lower class. She would know the value of the money and life Harlan had gifted his family unlike the others who grew up with silver spoons shoved down their throats
I may be wrong but I think Marta said that she’s Fran’s emergency contact, so her having access to medical information actually makes perfect sense.
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say that he liked this movie.
5:36 I'm sure someones pointed this out already but there is a reason. As soon as Blanc meets Marta he looks directly down and then later in the scene he looks down again. This shows that he knows about the blood that is on her shoe, therefore keeping her around might be of a benefit.
How? By him making a leap in thought that the blood must be from the suicide and nothing else could’ve happened at all? Also, why wouldn’t he take her shoe as possible evidence if he believes the blood is the dead guy’s? There is no logical reason to keep her around, especially without knowing any motives that she may have.
@@paytonyoder1260 except it makes a perfect logical sense to keep her around
1. She was closest to the victim and knew almost everything about him..even the stuff that the family was trying to hide
2. She had no motive and therefore could be somewhat trusted
3. Her inability to lie automatically makes her the most valuable asset in such a confusing case
Ik the blood spot on her shoe can't really mean much but Blanc definitely had enough reasons to keep her around
@@arandomguy9518 that’s not proper protocol. You interrogate her and question her. You conduct the investigation without her, because her “inability to lie” isn’t something that could or should be trusted. She’s not an officer so all she’s doing is messing up the crime scene if not tampering with it directly like she did in the movie.
The police don’t walk around with witnesses helping an investigation. And she does have a motive, the will be changed to give her everything is definitely a possible motive for her and everybody else there to kill him.
@@paytonyoder1260 she WAS interrogated and questioned and the movie technically starts a week after Harlan's death by when the local authorities presumably had conducted their investigation without indulging her as much (not to mention that it was Blanc, a Private detective, who chose her as his confidant and not the cops).
And bruh did you even watch the movie cuz the will was read after almost an hour into the movie, after which Blanc himself said that everyone was suspecious including Marta
@@arandomguy9518 do you remember what your last message said? First you say she has no motive and that it makes sense for her to be helping out on the investigation. Now you say she has a motive and Blanc is suspicious of her. That’s exactly why she wouldn’t be helping out with the investigation directly.
Thank you for proving my point.
Can’t believe you didn’t take any sins off for the “eat s**t” scene! 😂
Bubbles093 I was waiting for that 😂😂😂😂
I will not eat one iota of shit!
Or when Grandnana laughed when Ransom was taken in.
For me that scene was too forced, and not very funny, probably the only part I didn’t care for. just a way for the directors to be like look it’s funny Captain America just said a bad word!
WarlordWoody22 nah it was perfect for ransoms characterisation. plus it helps people forget the “goody two shoes captain america” side that they would expect from chris.
Okay I'm a year late but:
I love how most of this just was intentional nitpicking/stretching little things or flat out jokes with only a few things (In comparison) being actual jabs at stuff. You can just hear how much he just wants to gush about it but this is CinemaSins, not CinemaWins so he has to sin something and even then he takes sins off repeatedly. I love it so much.
1:48 "Regurgative" is not a word. It's "regurgitative". Sin on the movie and sin on CinemaSins.
This is the kindest I have ever seen cinemasins be with a movie, and as someone who thoroughly enjoys this movie just as much as you apparently do, I wholeheartedly appreciate that
I appreciate it too. 😊 I believe I saw this the same month as Frozen 2, last November. I love Knives Out more than I do Frozen 2.
I just watched cinemawins do a 2-parted of this movie so what gives? lol
Sara Osorio So did I. Lol. Doesn't mean I can't love and respect both channels. 😜😍
@Carly Rosenbloom
The lack of a period at the end of your sentence makes me wonder if you meant to say something after it.
Sara Osorio Ayyy Cinemawins is great
Any movie: shows logo
CinemaSins: *tHaT'S a SiN*
its the sin equivalent of getting credit for writing your name at the top of a test.... everyone gets it.
SPUDIKIN For short logos though he usually still sins lmao so that’s like credit for no name
You dont look at the name on the top of a test for 40 seconds.
@@micab7660 It's called an "intro".
Is it bad that I now watch every film with a voice in the back of head saying 'This is going to to make a great Everything Wring With.......'
Been there, done that. ROTFL!! And when there’s NOT one, I feel kinda incomplete. 😂
I mean With rian “ I intentionally killed Star Wars” Johnson as the director it’s bound to be fun to bash
@@kingsman5121 Imo he did the best he could with what Abrams gave him to work with, but that's a matter of opinion. What gave you the impression that he intentionally ran Star Wars into the ground, though? He was getting paid a hell of a lot, and trying to sabotage it (for whatever reason) could've gotten him fired quickly. Honestly, anything that wasn't 100% on Disney's good side could've gotten him fired quickly. And running a franchise into the ground on purpose would've tanked his career.
@@haveagoodmourning he has said many times that he didn’t care very much about the universe that he was given. Granted I don’t think JJ cares very much either given that he only knows nostalgia, bigger/more stuff and lense flares.’You know what they both suck.
@@kingsman5121 Eh, I'm not too against Rian Johnson but I can agree to disagree on that, I do agree that JJ Abrams sucks though haha. And thank u for letting me know about him not particularly caring I actually had no clue about that lol :D
14:49 *Ding, 1 sin added to the review for not removing a sin for the awesome line "She said Hue did this, cause you made the help call you Hue, because you're an asshole." That line and the delivery made me howl with laughter.
Oof that scene about nobody knowing where Marta is from...agreed, brilliantly done!
Someone's Iron Throne DIY went sideways there.
ATTENTION BROTHER!!! I have two very very hot and big RUclipsr girlfriends who I show off (I smell like 100 de*d orangutans oh nooo)! Thank you for you attention, dear dude kid new
@@AxxLAfriku WTF is your problem
@@AxxLAfriku two more than you have in reality
15:35 the way she said it was "grey" news; the doctor could have interpreted it as "grave" while Ransom interpreted as "great"
i must say that so much of this movie works on the basis that harlan was a mystery writer. just that tiny aspect makes this film so much better than most others.
If she just called an ambulance then everything would've been fine. Instead the old man takes shit to eleven super quickly.
Doug Bleach yeah but shed lose her job
@@Phoenix-cg3hq he wouldn't have fired her. He gave her everything he had.
@@antifableach this movies is so over-rated just because it's a new idea and it looks good.
@@YumiSumire I thought it was good. I mean no movie is perfect, but they had me going. I seriously thought that it was the grandma for awhile lol
@@antifableach that's what I mean, everyone's acting like it's a perfect movie. The detective is really dumb and it's hard to watch.
Jeremy, I LITERALLY just finished watching Knives Out minutes ago, and you already uploaded this today......
*I SUSPECT FOUL PLAY*
I suspect Google Information Storge Medium.
SAME!!!
LOL
@@smokeseer8633 Lol nice
I just watched this movie for the 4th time and still found tiny gems in the script, performances, editing, set and staging.... such a rewarding work.
the drawback of films that break up mysteries like this is, the perpetrators of the murders are caught easily, because usually there are actors like Chris Evans who can't just be extras🤡
Worth noting however I can't think of a single actor, maybe Fran's actor excluded who doesn't steal the show in their own way throughout the film, it's the perfect smoke screen for him when everyone is equally great
But every actor is well known and the movie makes you think he's An important character for different reasons
The rest of the ensemble are notable in their own right...
the only two Thrombeys without Actor Name Recognition are Meg and Jacob...
"I am removing 5 sins" only removes 4 sins.
Lol good eyes dawg
Quick! Someone go get the Th3Birdman
Sin tax
You sinned the sin giver
That's a sin!
One sin you missed: in the beginning of the film it's established that you're dead 10 minutes after receiving 100 mg of morfine so how is Fran still alive 2 hours after her appointment with Ransom? Ransom basically injected her with an entire syringe
We don't know how much was in the syringe, but as she was still alive, it was most likely less than what would instantly kill (100 mg) but still enough to overdose
There are many factors. People's bodies can react differently. Fran may have had a a high tolerance
I just figured he didn't give the same dosage. He wouldn't know how much to give. She OD'ed, but it wasn't enough to be immediately fatal.
Here’s another one if Ransom never hired Detective Benoit he could’ve gotten away with it if he had just killed Fran afterwards at the laundromat.
yes but he also wanted his inheritance back, so he needed to not just get away with it but also frame Marta.
No....Blanc was right. At that moment, 3 of the interviewees had lied explicitly:
1) Marta about Richard’s affair
2) Richard about having an affair
3) Joni about the money wiring issue (well...her feeding off Harlan’s money)
Sooooo....that sin should be removed from the total
Yeah but he said "all three of them" when he had already interviewed more than 3 people.
Gabrielle Kelly, you are close. The three who lied to him where the three he pressed the piano key. (I think so. It's been a while since I've seen the movie.) Richard with is affair, Joni about money issues, and the last one about being Walt with the book publisher. Those are the one who lied. Granted there is more people he interview, but those are the ones who lied. Noticed it when I watch this movie for the second time in one day.
Sunny Hoopes: That makes so much sense thank you
@@gabriellekelly3141 You're welcome.
0:33 Marta had a cross hanging in her car I believe. You're seeing part of that shadow on her.
I thought it was a traffic light
Looked like a headphone hanging on the rearview mirror to me.
Mills That’s what I thought, too. Lol.
Its the little speakers used in old asian cars. Got them in my celica.
It’s a cross, you can see it clearly after the “car chase” (I can’t forget what the guy says but it was a v sad car chase lol)
15:15 That's because Marta gave the doctors her number to call to update her on Fran's status. She said that's what she did back in the Hospital waiting room. That's why she got the call.
One of my favourite 'Whodunnit' movies. Such an iconic performance from Daniel Craig.
When he throws the baseball out the window without breaking any glass, pay closer attention. He throws it toward a small alcove thing that curves outward and is covered in windows. You can see two windows in the right side, but the left side of it is hidden by the bookshelf, it’s obvious that there is at least one more window in this alcove. when the camera cuts to outside you can see these same two windows. The baseball doesn’t come out of either of these, proving that there was at least one more window that must’ve been open. Why would you acknowledge that there could’ve been a hidden window and then sin it anyway? Th3Birdman is making me jaded.
it’s how hard he threw it n how convenient it was to land in front of the detective dumbass
say wha well at 1:38 Jeremy specifically mentions how no windows were broken but ok.
Dylan O'Hara exactly a randomly convenient open window