People hate her prolly cause she's stealing some of the spotlight for the others most of the time. I mean I cant blame cube. She's like a powerhouse like Hyuna. I hope what happened to 4minute,theyre not going to do it to g-idle :(
@@riellerivera3176 it wont, 4minute and g idle are in very different situations, especially when Cube arent trying to promote 1 individual more than the other. All of them pretty much have the same treatment, considering what they can bring to the table.
@@dusseln2063 she just doesnt sing here. im really sad. this song is her opportunity to sing since she got a lot of lines compare to previous song. she did sing the "lalala" part in other music show tho,,
@@dusseln2063 tbh just because she didn’t sing live doesn’t mean she hasn’t improved. she has improved, because she has sung it live in other music shows.
Don’t worry!! Shuhua sang live perfectly here!! Look!! ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html And here: ruclips.net/video/RSa6WoKk0GI/видео.html And more places, but these are just two examples! Our Shuhua, who improved so much!
The has to be the best MR removed I have ever heard/seen! Unlike the others where u can hear the backing vocals and people say it‘s their live singing. I know they can sing but still. The live voices have been filtered out so good here.
How long ago did gidle debuted that is more than enough time to improve, she’s an IDOL not a Model she should’ve learn instead of being just a pretty face
@@Jg8jewetwwhcastelw3 She literally came back to Korea earlier than all the other foreign members to do extra training, she posted several videos of that training. She has upped her game a LOT, just because she didn't sing in ONE stage doesn't mean anything.
Miyeon, Soyeon y Yuqi les salió perfecto. Shuhua en esta presentación no cantó nada, en demás presentaciones si lo hizo, se puede oír en los fancam fácilmente, solo lo digo para que no quede como mentirosa.
Miyeon and Soyeon as always stable. There is a reason why Miyeon is really their main vocal. Shuhua has ZERO improvement. It is such a shame because her fans are always shouting for Soyeon to give her lines and yet she still lipsynchs. She has lines now and still can't sing live. They were in hiatus for more than a year and she is the only member with no work, I thought she would improve already.
Everyone! Please stop hating on Shuhua! In here, she said her mic was broken, which is why you can slightly hear her but very quietly! But!! Don’t worry!! Shuhua sang live perfectly here!! Look!! ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html And here: ruclips.net/video/RSa6WoKk0GI/видео.html And more places, but these are just two examples! Our Shuhua, who improved so much! Edit: I did not say Shuhua is perfect, or that she does not need to improve anymore. I just said she has made big improvement now, but of course there is still room for more improvement! I was just showing places where Shuhua sings live! Don’t be like other commenters and make things up about what I said!
We are happy that she has improved, but you have to face the fact Shuhua still needs to work on her singing a lot more, especially since she will be getting more lines from now on. It's the 4th year since her debut, so people will be more critical.
@@NhuNguyen-sy1bn You are making things up. Where did I say she should stop improving? Of course she still needs to improve, and that is okay! But I was just saying she has improved a lot already. But there is always room for more improvement, indeed. However, I wrote this comment because people were upset she did not sing live, I was just trying to tell people she did sing live in other places! Also, I think her microphone was broken!
No ones hating on her though? She does sing live in some stages and doesn't in others but that's OK. She's improved a bunch and she probably just isn't fully confident to showcase her voice all the time. She's a LOT more confident in this comeback though so once again, she's definitely improved it's just not 100% there for her yet
@@murasakino101 1) When I commented this, there were a lot of people hating on her, so perhaps the comments got deleted. And 2) It was also so that people who came to this video who maybe were going to hate would read my comment and maybe understand a little more that she’s not talentless. Edit: Like there were lots of comments saying she’s talentless, etc. And in other videos, there were too… So I thought if they came here, then they would maybe shut up once they see this comment.
@@sunshinesunoo1770 What do you mean? She was really bad. No sense of pitch and she sang the half of her lines. She really can't sing and she is an idol for 4 years. I can't understand why CYBE debuted her
We all know that Akali and Ahri are the most stable at idle, let's appreciate their hard work💃 then Minnie and Yuqi, yes they are stable but their voices sometimes shake, let's also appreciate miqi❤️ and for shuhua , i know we all have high expectations, and instead of questioning the reason why she missed some parts, we better support shuhua so that shuhua works harder and can be stable like the other members, fighting🙌
Ok, so now Shuhua has lines, but she continues lip syncing. It's obvious that she can't sing. I think that the best for Shuhua was to have 10sec like before and her lines were given to another member who can sing.
her mic has a problem here, you can hear she a bit, and sometimes idols lipsync in choreo parts that are dificult ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
Gıdle artık çaylak grup değil ve buna rağmen shuha hala çaylak gibi. Amatör sesini kullanmıyor. Önceden dil engeli diye bahane ediyorlardı ama kaç yıldır Kore’de yaşıyor. Bunun arkasına da sığınamaz. Kore’deki birçok idol sadece görsel olduğu için idol zaten. Ama en azından diğer gruptakiler emek veriyor ses eğitimlerine. Shuha da bir gelişme göremiyorum
![[#2024KGMA] (여자)아이들((G)I-DLE) - Wife + 클락션(Klaxon) | #여자아이들 #GIDLE | ENA 241116 방송](/img/1.gif)
Soyeon is stable everytime. Like that girl works so hard and is good at everything and yet people are still hating on her.
she's too good some people are afraid of her, like they're scared that she's way better than their bias xD
People hate her prolly cause she's stealing some of the spotlight for the others most of the time. I mean I cant blame cube. She's like a powerhouse like Hyuna. I hope what happened to 4minute,theyre not going to do it to g-idle :(
@@riellerivera3176 it wont, 4minute and g idle are in very different situations, especially when Cube arent trying to promote 1 individual more than the other. All of them pretty much have the same treatment, considering what they can bring to the table.
Facts she's just too good for them
people are just jealous
I can't believe Miyeon has less than 15 seconds even when she is the most stable even in her rap part, along with soyeon
Can we appreciate soyeon again for her excellent live vocal!
Miyeon is so stable actually in her second part without breath 😎
shuhua really needs to learn to be confident with her voice. i hope she sings her part next time
i really thought she improved...
@@dusseln2063 she just doesnt sing here. im really sad. this song is her opportunity to sing since she got a lot of lines compare to previous song. she did sing the "lalala" part in other music show tho,,
She does sing her part in the newest stage!
@@dusseln2063 tbh just because she didn’t sing live doesn’t mean she hasn’t improved.
she has improved, because she has sung it live in other music shows.
Don’t worry!! Shuhua sang live perfectly here!! Look!!
ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
And here:
ruclips.net/video/RSa6WoKk0GI/видео.html
And more places, but these are just two examples!
Our Shuhua, who improved so much!
Soyeon stable like always
Yuqi and miyeon do really good too!
I was raising my mobile volume at start but suddenly soyeon part came and i got startled damn she have loud and nice vocals even with hard choreo
Soyeon, Yuqi and Miyeon are sooooo good
The has to be the best MR removed I have ever heard/seen! Unlike the others where u can hear the backing vocals and people say it‘s their live singing. I know they can sing but still. The live voices have been filtered out so good here.
They complain about the line distribution saying Soyeon always takes too much but... I mean there is a reason
Miyeon deserves more than Minnie though. I mean Soyeon and Miyeon were picked for K/DA for a reason
@@somebody1170 yeah i agree, but minnie is a songwriter so that's why i think she gets more lines. she has more control over her lines
Bro compared to their performances when they first debuted they've improved so much soyeon and miyeons voices are so stable I was honestly shocked
Soyeon is literally top tier wow 😮 ❤
I feel bad for Shuhua. I hope she'll be more stable soon. She'll get more lines from now on and she needs to really step up her game 🥺
She has! She has sung live in almost all other music show!
She has improved, but I agree that she needs to steps up her game with singing. You can tell that she is nervous when it comes to singing 😢.
@@NhuNguyen-sy1bn She has!! Look at (G)I-DLE on BTOB radio show, they sang Tomboy and she sounded a lot more comfortable! I was very proud!
How long ago did gidle debuted that is more than enough time to improve, she’s an IDOL not a Model she should’ve learn instead of being just a pretty face
@@Jg8jewetwwhcastelw3 She literally came back to Korea earlier than all the other foreign members to do extra training, she posted several videos of that training. She has upped her game a LOT, just because she didn't sing in ONE stage doesn't mean anything.
When yuqi says tomboy with that voice i lose my mind
I thought Shuhua would've at least sing a bit for the "Lalalala" part...
She did in Music bank live performance
@@tusjinn9274 Yeh she finally did. Good to see she's getting more confident!
Soyeon all rounder 🔥🔥
Soyeon the queen as expected but miyeon proved she is a perfect vocalist
Yuqi Soyeon and Miyeon they are stable
Oh my god Miyeon!
It's so clean Let's just appreciate their live vocals
Miyeon bebeğim mükemelsin
Shuhua ya tienes líneas , cantalas!!
No entiendo por qué nunca canta.....
Her microphone broke so that’s you couldn’t here her but there is many other performances where you can here her sing
She can't even do the low notes in a normal way lmao, what do you wanting for?
Soyeon ❤❤❤❤
Jeon soyeon is a queen
ソヨンミヨンすごすぎる
Miyeon, Soyeon y Yuqi les salió perfecto.
Shuhua en esta presentación no cantó nada, en demás presentaciones si lo hizo, se puede oír en los fancam fácilmente, solo lo digo para que no quede como mentirosa.
ソヨンは完璧！口パクダンスをするアイドルを崇めてる人には申し訳ないが、私は歌って踊れることが本物のアイドルだと思っている。ミヨンの歌声もいつも安定していて素晴らしいと思う。
Miyeon and Soyeon as always stable. There is a reason why Miyeon is really their main vocal. Shuhua has ZERO improvement. It is such a shame because her fans are always shouting for Soyeon to give her lines and yet she still lipsynchs. She has lines now and still can't sing live. They were in hiatus for more than a year and she is the only member with no work, I thought she would improve already.
god not you again. why are you on every gidle mr removed spouting the same shite? literally nobody asked. you don’t like it? simply don’t listen.
@@elli2590 LMAO I am fan of Gidle but I will not lie and will say the truth that Shuhua is tone deaf and lipsynchs. I am not a blind stan like you🤮
@@mocneeuq Shuhua live singer, you are just a hater.
A very stable main vocal who has less than 15 seconds in the song :/
soyeon best
Everyone! Please stop hating on Shuhua!
In here, she said her mic was broken, which is why you can slightly hear her but very quietly!
But!! Don’t worry!! Shuhua sang live perfectly here!! Look!!
ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
And here:
ruclips.net/video/RSa6WoKk0GI/видео.html
And more places, but these are just two examples!
Our Shuhua, who improved so much!
Edit: I did not say Shuhua is perfect, or that she does not need to improve anymore. I just said she has made big improvement now, but of course there is still room for more improvement!
I was just showing places where Shuhua sings live!
Don’t be like other commenters and make things up about what I said!
We are happy that she has improved, but you have to face the fact Shuhua still needs to work on her singing a lot more, especially since she will be getting more lines from now on. It's the 4th year since her debut, so people will be more critical.
@@NhuNguyen-sy1bn You are making things up. Where did I say she should stop improving?
Of course she still needs to improve, and that is okay! But I was just saying she has improved a lot already. But there is always room for more improvement, indeed.
However, I wrote this comment because people were upset she did not sing live, I was just trying to tell people she did sing live in other places!
Also, I think her microphone was broken!
No ones hating on her though? She does sing live in some stages and doesn't in others but that's OK. She's improved a bunch and she probably just isn't fully confident to showcase her voice all the time. She's a LOT more confident in this comeback though so once again, she's definitely improved it's just not 100% there for her yet
@@murasakino101 1) When I commented this, there were a lot of people hating on her, so perhaps the comments got deleted.
And 2) It was also so that people who came to this video who maybe were going to hate would read my comment and maybe understand a little more that she’s not talentless.
Edit:
Like there were lots of comments saying she’s talentless, etc.
And in other videos, there were too…
So I thought if they came here, then they would maybe shut up once they see this comment.
I see shuhua sing with leather jacket outfit perfomance
1:41 Did she bite?
,,Yeah I‘m _Crack_ Tomboy“
im pretty sure shuhua was singing, i think she was just having mic problems sadly
面姐和小娟好穩啊💪🏻
Shuhua…….😅😅😅😅😅
she actually sing her part at mcountdown today, i guess her mic has problem here.
@@sunshinesunoo1770 She actually can't sing
@@marvel3734 she can! just take a look at recent mr removed
@@sunshinesunoo1770 What do you mean? She was really bad. No sense of pitch and she sang the half of her lines. She really can't sing and she is an idol for 4 years. I can't understand why CYBE debuted her
I really fail my words to shuhua…She has debuted for 4 years…
They ate omlll
Shuhua really said “………💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻……..”
We all know that Akali and Ahri are the most stable at idle, let's appreciate their hard work💃
then Minnie and Yuqi, yes they are stable but their voices sometimes shake, let's also appreciate miqi❤️
and for shuhua , i know we all have high expectations, and instead of questioning the reason why she missed some parts, we better support shuhua so that shuhua works harder and can be stable like the other members, fighting🙌
Ok, so now Shuhua has lines, but she continues lip syncing. It's obvious that she can't sing. I think that the best for Shuhua was to have 10sec like before and her lines were given to another member who can sing.
she actually sing her part at mcountdown today, i guess her mic has problem here.
+shuhua barely lipsync, im telling u
See here! Shuhua live vocals! ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
And type in (G)I-DLE BTOB RADIO Tomboy!
@@sunshinesunoo1770 She barely sings in reality. In her best days she sings the half of her lines and she is out of tone. She is really bad vocalist.
@@marvel3734 nooo, since latata she has never lip sync on stage. she only skips SOME part. being not stable ≠ lip sync
her mic has a problem here, you can hear she a bit, and sometimes idols lipsync in choreo parts that are dificult ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
You need to do Soyeon's diss!!
The best mr removed, the other channels are not as cleas as yours
im tired of shuhua not singing pls
she actually sing her part at mcountdown today, i guess her mic has problem here.
@@sunshinesunoo1770 good for her. she barely sang here tho, even her lalala part.
@@沈开颜 she sang live in almost all over music show, and on btob live radio, really well!
shuhua actually sings live a lot, but it is just quiet.
I love how you can hear the girls kind of saying the f*cking part lmao
Soyeon woo
Shuhua is privileged
Minnie and Shuhua💀😭
Shuhua just doesn't sing...
Wait for their encore
She has sing some but she sing too soft
She sang but just too soft, listen carefully
Just not the lalala part
am I stupid or did Yuqi not sing the first part either?
@@viviyang8531 she didn't sing that part
А мне нравится)))
shuhua??
she actually sing her part at mcountdown today, i guess her mic has problem here.
@@sunshinesunoo1770 i am so tired of that excuse
@@princelime5676 lol then why can she sing in other mr removed videos, except for this one? 💀
@@sunshinesunoo1770 i have literally watched every single one of their mr removed out there... be fucking fr💀
mic nya shuhua rusak atw gimana?? 😅😅
See here! ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
And type in (G)I-DLE BTOB RADIO Tomboy!
Live singing, Shuhua.
kek nya rusak dah
shuhua is a 🤥🤥
she actually sing her part at mcountdown today, i guess her mic has problem here.
See here! Shuhua live vocals! ruclips.net/video/GFr7N_lr8l8/видео.html
And type in (G)I-DLE BTOB RADIO Tomboy!
Shuhua being on mute
So this why cube doesn’t give shuhua lines, she doesn’t even sing 😂
...
SOYEONG KAJJA ⛔😼😼
is this really live?
Gıdle artık çaylak grup değil ve buna rağmen shuha hala çaylak gibi. Amatör sesini kullanmıyor. Önceden dil engeli diye bahane ediyorlardı ama kaç yıldır Kore’de yaşıyor. Bunun arkasına da sığınamaz. Kore’deki birçok idol sadece görsel olduğu için idol zaten. Ama en azından diğer gruptakiler emek veriyor ses eğitimlerine. Shuha da bir gelişme göremiyorum
슈화는 가수를 왜 하냐?
카즈하 MR제거 보고오셈