Fauci testifies to Congress | A Fair Appraisal of his Conduct
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Vinay Prasad, MD MPH; Physician & Professor
Hematologist/ Oncologist
Professor of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Medicine
Author of 500+ Peer Reviewed papers, 2 Books, 2 Podcasts, 100+ op-eds.
If you want to contact me, do it here: www.vinayakkpra...
Instagram: / vprasadmdmph
Google Scholar: scholar.google...
Substack: vinayprasadmdm...
Podcast: podcasts.apple...
Personal Website: www.vinayakkprasad.com
Laboratory Website: www.vkprasadlab.com
Podcast Website: www.plenarysessionpodcast.com
Academic Publications: www.vinayakkpra...
Follow me on:
Twitter @vprasadmdmph
I lost my (very senior position) 25 year career as a registered nurse thanks to moronic medical bureaucrats and the government. Cannot stand any of them. So glad I’m out of healthcare- it’s a total embarrassment and hopefully one day the appropriate people will be prosecuted.
Weak people make hard times.
Total weakness shown by senior healthcare going along with lies.
Money….
SCOTUS must $w!ng for upholding the mandate to inject health care workers with Graphine HYDROXIDE.
Annie fellow RN here, I bet that you’d never thought that you would see the day when RN’s and other medical personnel would be accused of “not following the science.” It’s a disgusting way to end a career!
@@poodledaddles1091 Absolutely. ‘Misconduct’ for using critical thinking skills that had been cultivated over many years. What a complete farce. It doesn’t even seem real.
@@poodledaddles1091What’s sad is that many who stayed and took the jab probably convinced themselves they were right, even though they could feel how wrong the whole thing was. I think that, when going along with a bully’s demands, people have one of two choices. They can go along with the bully and convince themselves that it was their choice or the right choice later or they can admit they acted out of cowardice. It’s very likely that most people rationalize and convince themselves they were right all along. Cowardice creates delusional people.
Why isn’t he charged with lying to Congress????
because congress is a charade...
Was he "Under Oath" at the time...? I think NOT.
As I understand it - Unless LEGALLY UNDER OATH, Lying To Congress is NOT a Crime : (
Who is responsible for that? AG... A political figure. Both JB and DT were entangled. Learn to meditate.
@@jarichards99utube He lied to Rand Paul under oath snowflake.
@@jarichards99utubeHe lied to Rand Paul under oath snowflake.
They never studied the vac in babies or children but they know the dosage. That was a red flag!
Everything since March 2020 was a red flag. I knew the whole thing was a scam from day one.
@@jackieb6621 it’s true! They say no otc meds etc but somehow jabs are fine. lol no way
I lean to the right. Vinay leans to the left. I trust Vinay's analysis on this over anyone I can think of.
The only way we can get accountability is with bipartisan pressure. Far left here. I want answers.
The word you’re looking for is “sociopath”.
He is all of the "Paths"!
My problem is the establishment literally shutting people down from speaking. People should have been allowed to discuss lab leak possibilities.
100% agree. There needs to be accountability
He is the prefect example of why science should not be political… it should be based on truth and actually scientific exploration
Dude had 3 or 4 pics of hinself all over his office, nobody else😂
Fauci has all the audacity of someone who knows where his safety lies.
You have to admire the confidence of someone so small.
He sold his soul decades ago.
with the dod and cia
Fauci's REAL JOB, is a Payed SHILL for the Big-Pharma $$$-Agendas.. Sad but true : (
Thank you for your assessment on weasly his answers were.
Very grateful for your hard work, research, and presentation of data. Your mind and heart can be fully contented and peaceful in having gone beyond your calling and your duty.
HE TOLD US TO WEAR TWO MASKS
He’s abhorrent 😡
And a face shield!
& goggles 😂
His voice was recorded, his words were annotated. Instill he defies logic, with continued disregard for the truth no words for that kind of pathological evil.
MSM gives another Grandpa a pass….
Love your analyses! 🍻💪
I agree with every point. You say it much more eloquently than i could. Thank you
"There is no question that there will be a challenge to the coming administration in the arena of infectious diseases. The thing we're extraordinarily confident about is that we're going to see this in the next few years."
Dr. Anthony Fauci 2017
Such a voice of reason, I so appreciate you. Thank you!
Thank you for your thoughts.
Imagine if the approach had been ”We are not sure yet, but are recommending 6 foot distancing while we study the issue.” Versus the “do what we say or we will destroy your life” approach that they took.
Thanks doctor! Very grateful for you, you made sense then. And thankfully, I followed your advice.
Again thank you Doctor
I had heard of CV before the 19 variant came along, so when 19 started to make the news cycle, I initially and in retrospect, naively thought the medical community reaction would be similar to H1N1. We exercised extra precautions to protect the most vunerable and we came up with an EUA monovalent vaccine for the H1N1 strain to be used with the regular trivalent flu shot that had already been released. There was concern of course, but it was business as usual as we waited for it to transition from pandemic to endemic. The influenza shot to this day still covers H1N1, but no one is running scared from it. It just became a fact of life. I assumed the new CV 19 variant would also run its course and then fade into the background in a similar style. Boy was I ever wrong.
And? What consequences besides a grade of F or stern finger wagging in a hearing are proposed if no other reason than to discourage the next narcissist from doing the same? Narcissists are transparent to the light of criticism.
Teflon Fauci. I respect you, Dr. Prasad, for your honest appraisal of Fauci and your willingness to see beyond the rhetoric. My husband and I both have science degrees and were left scratching our heads at what Fauci said during the pandemic. Many things were in direct contradiction what we knew and no credible research presented. His name is a four-letter word in my household.
A couple of months ago I attended a live music performance. At one point during between-songs chitchat, the performer made a scathing remark about "Fauci-19." I cheered. (No vax, no boosters, delta and omicron survivor here.)
The age stratified all cause mortality rates comparing the unvaccinated to cohorts for those vaccinated with a single dose, followed by each booster, will answer the question of just how safe and effective the mRNA vaccines truly are. I suspect if the answer to this question were positive for the vaccinated cohorts, public health and the captured corporate media would have been shouting it from the rooftops nonstop for years.
It was always about power, and forcing people to bend to their ATHOURITAH". Alas, children and elderly people were the greatest casualties. The rest of us had to navigate workplace restrictions, family and friend disconnections, gaslighting from every angle and the myriad of ridiculous theater. I am having a hard time getting back behind the NIH and CDC and other government orgs .. but VP has my utmost faith and admiration. ❤❤❤
Very good information, always. Just to define terms: exited the workforce = unjustly fired
Good politician = liar/bad doctor 😅
Thanks
Vinay could probably talk some people into joining a pickup basketball game with that new haircut. Thanks for the vids!
NET HARM !!! Absolutely. Check out the data now. One word ACCOUNTABILITY.
RFK JR!!! 2024!!! For hope!!!❤Let's make it happen!🦅🇺🇸🦅
🔥
yes, but when will there be consequences for Fauci????
awesome coverage! so disappointing thst very little will probably be done from an accountability perspective
It takes a true expert to be wrong on everything, and to continue lying about most of it with zero consequences.
It is surprising that Vinay still thinks these vaccines have saved lives, and the source I heard him quoting were original Moderna trials. It would be more cautions to say we do not know for now. And let’s run a study how many people are now worse of due to these vaccines- physically and mentally.
Fauci is a textbook narcissist. Thanks for bringing that up.
"Why didn't he use the budget to generate the data"...
I think we know the reason. He did not view it as a good investment (i.e., it did not generate a political revenue).
Ydes. 100% for anyone who can think.
he played us like a damn fiddle ! !
No ,he chose to be the face of the pandemic to cover his traces.
0:30
*Fact check:* it was actually 10 ft, polls say.
My niece was afraid to take off her cloth mask even outside around people She would cry if you asked her to take it off, because she was told in preschool that she would be punished if she took it off. The harms....
It should be explained to her the adults were wrong and believed politicians fear mongering.
Parental failure.
That is sick.
Absolutely disgusting the poor babies 😪
That’s a bit abstract for a preschooler.
When Fauci pressed that the vaccine “saved lives”, I wish the next comeback question would have been “ did the vaccine take any lives?”
Where is the proof of injections saved lives?😢
Fauci's REAL JOB, is a Payed SHILL for the Big-Pharma $$$-Agendas.. Sad but true : (
I would ask about the quality of the "evidence" that it did save lives. AFAIK, such calculations usually beg the question by assuming efficacy first. It goes something like this:
1) Efficacy is 90% (assumption, based on early clinical trials).
2) There were 1000 C deaths in an observation, among people who received "the treatment".
3) Since the efficacy is 90%, then for every treated person that dies, 9 more people would have died among the treated, if they weren't treated.
4) Therefore, 9000 lives were saved!
If that 90% efficacy is from the 2020 trials, then the figure is completely invalid by the third (Delta) variant, the first one that surged *after* the general population was allowed their "treatment". The 90% is only valid for the first variant, and only in the population in the trial! If the trial used people never exposed previously, then even for that same variant, the efficacy could not be claimed for people already exposed to that first variant (like most of the population of NYC).
@@Silver0426 In mathematical sleight-of-hand tricks.
The trends in cumulative C fatality, of course, say otherwise, a tale of natural immunization alone.
Vinay Prasad should answer that too
Remember, to get 100% of the answers wrong, you pretty much have to know 100% of the right answers. In my opinion, he had malicious intent.
It's that simple
Absolutely
Yes it is illegal to intentionally go around FOIA requests. The extent to which some of our leaders have bent over backward to hide the truth is beyond sinister.
What really stands out to me is dr f actually stating they needed to make life hard for people who stuck to their "ideological bullshit" and refused the shot.
Put that in the same box with Schwarzanazi's "Screw your freedoms!"
he said that?! .... !!
@@elloohno1349 alot of celebs, news people, officials and politicians were all pushing that message.
Hard to separate the fact from the fiction when they are all actors.
@@cerberus50caldawg ja very true ! but they don't always admit to it in such certain terms
Well his ideaolgy was bull shit and we were smart enough to see thru it
People who signed the Great Barrington Declaration should ALL receive an Honor in Science!
They should be running the NIAID, CDC, and FDA.
Science AND ETHICS!!🏆
At the very least, give them Nobel peace prize for the hell they went through
@@whm_w8833 For the good they did they should be commended as heros.
They spoke up and made a stand and spoke the truth.
What do they get for it?
Completely ignored if not chastised, ridiculed and called liars.
They all get a lot less then Fouldheese always gets all to himself on all the networks all the time.
Regular man of the hour right there.🤡
I signed The Great Barrington Declaration. I worked the frontline as a nurse with up to 32 C0vid positive very ill patients and never got C0vid. Then was mandated the jabs and now vacc1ne injured
The way the democrats praised him at the hearing was honestly scary. This should not be a political issue.
True Democrats are legitimately scary people.
The democrats are fascists and Fauci is a spiritual leader to them
This was made a political issue at the inception of the pandemic by both sides, let’s be clear on that.
@@THExBLAZEx88 what’s clear is that Fauci is the grand priest of democrats. And what’s clear is that when orange man bad started operation war speed. Democrats said they wouldn’t take a trump vaccine and then once
Brandon became president they pushed it. So democrats are the biggest gaslighters when it comes to Covid.
@@THExBLAZEx88Two sides of the same demonic coin. The Uniparty did this to us ☹️
Being a narcissist means never having to say you're sorry.
An incompetent narcissist. The incompetence is key here.
Yep...! 🙂👍 -70SomethingGuy
Yep. He definitely suffers from a god complex.
it only means you don't say sorry because you're too stupid to know what you have to be sorry about.
@@wstavis3135Fauci is not incompetent, he’s just evil.
He's lied to Congress previously by denying gain of function research. No accountability. No consequences.
Yes, never any consequences....🤔
And he still has a job at NIH.His wife works there as well.
They're all on the same team. They want you to be mad and hating the "other side," that helps keep them in power.
Democrats
He answers to higher powers.
The ones in the backrooms no one sees.
No democrat had a single critique of Tony yesterday. How does that make any sense ?
It makes perfect sense following cult logic: absolutely no dissent allowed.
Because most of them profited from his decisions
The more that it is revealed that Fauci made decisions by pulling out of his ash and loved the media attention, then it shows more light on the politicians that themselves forced mandates. Also, had the big man himself that held Covid press conferences saying it was going to be a deadly winter for the unvaccinated.
They care more about party than country. In short, they’re traitors. The whole 6 feet recommendation was implemented to help them steal the election. We have traitors amongst us walking free. Which way western man?
As soon as he started talking back to Trump he became a folk hero to anyone with TDS. That's all there is to it.
The email scheme is illegal, not just “technically” illegal.
Why does everyone keeping using the "technically illegal" term? Does it have something to do with Trump's conviction?
@@madscientist2621it’s been the contention of liberals that the Hunter Biden conviction is only a technical violation. The issue behind Trump’s conviction is the NY prosecutor moved to have the law changed and the statute of limitations ignored so he could bring what used to be at most a misdemeanor of the lower order up into the felony range. It’s NEVER been done before and no other person has ever been so much as investigated for it in criminal conduct. Yes it’s been pursued as a regulatory violation which is only a fine and even then it’s been a minor fine. People don’t look into anything anymore they just listen to CNN or whatever and get emotional. This is why everyone is quoting the “technical” thing.
He left a paper trail and lied against it
For science! JK. Obviously can´t keep hiding behind research and do absolutely horrible things.
This 100%
He believed he was above the law. The real tragedy? It's looking like another GRID/AIDS scandal for the profit focused beureaucrat.
If his name was Anthony Trump, we'd know what color his underwear is.
He gets cover from the Democrats and the media. He can basically get away with murder.
Thank you. Your podcast allows me to stay loosely informed without having to suffer the brain damage of trying to follow the madness directly. I appreciate your candor and your willingness to call BS when appropriate.
Vinay YOU should be the person in that hearing questioning Fauci. Have they ever asked you to testify before Congress?
Absolutely. He brought up most of the issues that would back Fauci into a corner he couldn’t smooth talk his way out of.
They didn't run studies because there was no money to made doing studies but there was big money in mRNA vaccines, Remsdesivir, and Paxlovid.
even if Remdesivir was known to kill people from its use in Africa ebola?
D-,F??? You're too generous. He committed Crimes Against Humanity
And all the other jabs they have planned.
I worked in healthcare, and refused the jabs. I submitted for religious exemption when the mandate happened, and was denied for no reason.
No lawyer would take my case. I will NEVER work in healthcare again.
It’s not really healthcare, it’s sick care. Unfortunately poor outcomes for the most part but nevertheless very expensive
That’s really sad. We need more people like you back in healthcare. Thanks for taking a stand.
SCOTUS must $w!ng for upholding the mandate to inject health care workers with Graphine HYDROXIDE.
I have retired from the health care field as well. This was all starting just before the virus was unleashed, it began with the "war on opiates". MD's were pressured and threatened if they did not cut back on prescribing opiates that they would lose their license to prescribe. So many caved in, including oncologists telling their terminal patients to cut down. I was disgusted and ready to leave the field, then came covid. No way I would want to go back now.
I am so sorry you went through this… I believe that they will try and cover this up till the end of the Earth so employers like yours will not be held responsible. Every employer that mandated the job and fired employees should be sued. I have a friend in the healthcare industry who suffered greatly. She was the only one in an office of about 50 people who declined the shot. She was treated and continues to be treated poorly because of her choice. These people will ignore the science because they went along with the lies. People think that the Holocaust and all that led up to it could never happen again. Covid showed me that we are human and fear drives us. The fear of being on the outside of the masses. I’m sure your choice was extremely difficult and financially devastating. There are millions of us that know you made the intelligent choice. Be well.❤
Why would he admit the possibility of a lab leak when the responsibility will fall upon him for the lab leak because HE FUNDED THE LAB
Because that is what an honest, God-Fearing person would do maybe...
@@atatterson6992 Yeh well.. God fearing or not.. when he leaves this mortal coil he might think maybe he shoulda tried harder at being a good boy.
He has had a good long life but it is running pretty close to the end and his time is surely coming whatever he thinks about it.
I have faith God will see fit to judge him appropriately for his works.
That's good enough for me.
@@cerberus50caldawg my point
It may be hard for him to admit to himself that the gain of function research he was at least partially responsible for could have brought about the pandemic.
@@michaelmorton4104Well that is just giving him to much credit as a decent person, please research involvement with the AIDS epidemic, he wanted vaccines for that, too, not people working on a cure, this is all done as experiments, on purpose, and the so - called leak may have been, too
Rochelle should not be forgiven either.
I want someone to square up the claim that unvaxed are responsible for 200,000 +extra deaths
All BS. Also, BS was the asymptomatic spreading caused by Spring Breakers. All lies. I remember seeing how they said one girl in Florida gave over 70 people COVID because she was an asymptomatic spreader which all turned out to be made-up BS.
High school Biology squares it up very nicely. Fear + divisive political narratives caused this, not science.
Yes ! What a crazy claim!
OR that the vx "saved lives"... HOW do they even back up that statement?! There is no way to know if the population at large would have come through it better without it, but there are indications that we prob would have!
Sounds like that number “ just appeared”! Lol
When are the colleges going to apologize to the students?
How is he not behind bars? He is a criminal. Glenn from Australia
You're watching computer animation 😂
Narcissists will always shift the blame to someone else, preferably to the victims of their abuse. They will never take responsibility or even apologise.
This wasn’t the first time he was responsible for sending a lot of people to an early grave. Just ask anyone in the gay community in the 1980s about the things he has done. A pattern exists with this guy.
yes, that was the dry run!
Friends of Mr DEPOPULATION gates himself!
He’s nefarious and bad man
EXACTLY!!
So true!
His defense "We just made it up. Then hid it from everyone." Says the person who said that to question him was to question science.
And we are called science deniers. To not use real science methods is to deny science.
He had millions of incentives to not run a study!
🎯🎯🎯
Lots of studies have been run since then. They take time. You don't just do a study overnight. Not defending the guy just saying studies take time. Donald Trump could have ordered him the CDC to do studies before implementing all the policies they did.
@@heazillaYES! Exactly why this should NOT have been forced on any one. It’s still mystery juice… and turns out it harmed more people than it helped. Ventilators also killed more than helped. It was a clown show at best. We tried to warn you! Your response was to act like nazis. We won’t forget. It was an IQ test and you people can not be trusted.
@@heazilla he was not the president. Ugh, why do I bother.
@@tulipsontheorgan Yeah, the president runs the executive. The CDC is under the executive which is why Trump threatened to fire Fauci. What exactly are you trying to explain to me other than your own ignorance?
Watching those people apologize to a person being grilled for potentially knowingly killing my dad was so appalling I do not have words.
I’m so sorry for your loss. 🙏🏻
@@mindbodyspirit22even more appalling. Thousands more in the same place
I’m still stuck at 98% survival rate
Still wonder what it really was considering the deaths attributable to policy measures taken from lockdowns & medical therapeutics to end of life protocol & DNR orders with financial incentives to write deaths off as covid.
How many were truly attributable to their original product funded by the NIH?
99.5% in most cases except people over 80 with comorbidities and people who are immune suppressed.
My husband was a technology worker for a community healthcare organization who lost his job over the vaxx mandates. He eventually was hired by a government contractor, ironically, who didn't require he be vaxxed for COVID. We were harmed financially, but couldn't get represented by an attorney to go after our state and the former employer. We were fortunate to have a family member that helped us out financially for several months, and he did get unemployment benefits. I know not everyone did.
The house and Senate was not required to take it either.
As I recall, Fauci called the lab-origin theory "molecularly impossible," whatever that means. Nobody pushed back.
Senator Rand Paul did then and continues to call him on the carpet
The use of the term "molecularly impossible" is a deflection from what he knew about genetic engineering. The ferin cleavage site observation suggests genetic engineering and he knew this.
It was impossible because the molecules would then be racists.
@@fredwhinery8016😂
Tons of people pushed back, and they were ridiculed and called racists.
I give him an A+ as a criminal against humanity.
Thank you for this. Given what we learned during the pandemic we need to restudy every aspect of our healthcare system. From the how we birth our children and every aspect of health care until end of life care. We can't trust any aspect of our current system.
If only the world had you as America's doctor and not Faucci, imagine where we could heading with healthcare. Keep up the great work you do VP, and thank you for your service!
The press likes Fauci? Or the press can’t say anything negative regarding big pharma?
Ding ding ding ding!
It's both. The media loved him and so did their pharma sponsors. The only reason to not run any trials around masking, other possible therapeutics, etc. is because he already knew the answer and it's not the one he wanted.
And who controls the media? And does Fauci represent them and their agenda? Do they protect him with their power and $? It seems naive to think he’s operating only with his own agenda.
@kcventures720 even if they didnt sell a single additional bottle of pills, it has been worth it to them to control the media
The press is funded by big pharma
They wore cloth masks in the nursing homes and Assisted Living facilities. Worthless.
Worthless then and worthless now! Read the box for the procedural mask! This retired RN did not believe this mass hysteria from the beginning. All public health procedures and scientific inquiry not used!!! No longer trusting of my profession. New healthcare paradigms will occur going forward. Covid opened eyes to many issues
They broke things and are continuing to break things that aren't easy to fix or maybe even fixable!
He was everywhere on TV because it was the world's largest CYA operation.
@@doggietreats67 Wait, did Trump authorize gain of function research and send money to the Wuhan lab to research corona viruses and make them more virulent to humans before he was ever president? No that was Fauci. Nice try.
@@doggietreats67 by this logic, it's the fault of the police for every crime, not the criminals who do the crime. Trump didn't authorize gain of function research, Fauci did.
Dr. Prasad, You are a champion in my opinion. You've risked getting removed, time and time, again from this platform on RUclips. I respect you no end!!
Fauci: I am the science.
Meanwhile he broke science
ARROGANT
🤬 he could care less!
Actually, Fauci's REAL JOB, is a Payed SHILL for the Big-Pharma $$$-Agendas.. Sad but true : (
I just got back from the bank - everyone still standing more than 6 feet apart. Five years ago, this would have been considered a mental illness.
It’s considered mental illness today… by sane people💯
Holy crap. Some people will never give it up. And you can't educate them out of this ridiculous behavior.
Zombies.
I'd actually be happy if strangers would continue to keep 6ft away from me but has nothing to do with the virus
AND 5 years ago wearing a mask into a bank might get you shot
Vinay, your brilliant, highly informed voice helped me thru the 3 years of Covid madness. I am so grateful and Inhope you will be fully vindicated for yr honest voice. Take care 🌟
Unexpected Tuesday morning 'Vinayspeak' .. most excellent.
Nobody says it more eloquent than you!
Yes! Dr Prasad needs a $5B research budget.
This has obviously been happening forever but now everything is having the lid blown off- that's the only difference.
I was so glad to see your critique. He snaps back so aggressively at Congressmen that for the layperson
it's impossible to read who's responsible. You totally resolved in my mind who is a significant culprit
in the gross over reach that was the Covid response.
Is there anyone around that still believes this congress Fauxi thing is something other than political pantomime?
We are still in the minority, I’m afraid..
The next time you are threatened with loosing you livelihood because you won't inoculated with an tested unstudied vaccine..it's just political theater...right??
The world is a stage not just this.
So important that we continue to investigate this until we get to the bottom. Scientists were playing God with US taxpayer funding and millions died.
Worse, they government (Fauci) silenced scientists that disagreed or had other hypotheses.
You'd mark him D- or F on his performance?!!! If he was my student there'd be no grade at all. He'd be immediately expelled, walked off the school property, and handed over to the police with allegations of fraud, mass murder, conspiring to commit a crime, protecting those involved with the crime, and I'm sure a lot lot more.
Love hearing from Vinay!
I have watched Vinay from the beginning of the pandemic to now and appreciate his commitment to truth, even though he has been dragged reluctantly from where he obviously hoped it would lead. His take on the subjects he is an expert in is invaluable if you hope to land anywhere near an objective, reality based opinion.
A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.
His a mass murder and will never be hold accountable
The quick sigh right at the beginning at this video says about everything…
The problem with the mandate for me was I started to suspect bullshit was occurring once they mandated. If a medicine is good you need not force it on anyone they will run over each other to get it!
A good product will sell itself.
There was no need to coerce, bribe, manipulate, deceive, threaten, or otherwise incentivize people to take a supposed “life-saving” vaccine.
The harder they pushed, the easier it became for me to say NO. I will not be threatened/pressured into doing something to my body, just to appease the misinformed masses & a corrupt govt.
Except that the rhetoric was so powerful that people believed the shot was good for them that they DID run like lemmings for it. Mandates should never be allowed; however, many companies and universities STILL are using mandates! Kids that are in the lowest % for real harm are STILL unable to attend some universities without the mandated protocol.
No.. it was not fauchi that had great conection to media. It was who ever payed him on the side.
Excellent commentary Doc. Thanks so much.